1997A&AS..121...95C


Query : 1997A&AS..121...95C

1997A&AS..121...95C - Astron. Astrophys., Suppl. Ser., 121, 95-112 (1997/January-0)

Abundances for globular cluster giants. I. Homogeneous metallicities for 24 clusters.

CARRETTA E. and GRATTON R.G.

Abstract (from CDS):

We have obtained high resolution, high signal-to-noise ratio CCD echelle spectra of 10 bright red giants in 3 globular clusters (47 Tuc, NGC 6752 and NGC 6397) roughly spanning the whole range of metallicities of the galactic globular cluster system. The analysis of this newly acquired material reveals no significant evidence of star-to-star variation of the [Fe/H] ratio in these three clusters. Moreover, a large set of high quality literature data (equivalent widths from high dispersion CCD spectra) was re-analyzed in an homogeneous and self-consistent way to integrate our observations and derive new metal abundances for more than 160 bright red giants in 24 globular clusters (i.e. about 16% of the known population of galactic globulars). This set was then used to define a new metallicity scale for globular clusters which is the result of high quality, direct spectroscopic data, of new and updated model atmospheres from the grid of Kurucz (1992, priv. comm.), and of a careful fine abundance analysis; this last, in turn, is based on a common set of both atomic and atmospheric parameters for all the stars examined. Given the very high degree of internal homogeneity, our new scale supersedes the offsets and discrepancies existing in previous attempts to obtain a metallicity scale. The internal uncertainty in [Fe/H] is very small: 0.06dex (24 clusters) on average, and can be interpreted also as the mean precision of the cluster ranking. Compared to our system, metallicities on the widely used Zinn and West's scale are about 0.10dex higher for [Fe/H]>-1, 0.23dex lower for -1<[Fe/H]←1.9 and 0.11dex too high for [Fe/H]←1.9. The non-linearity of the Zinn and West's scale is significant even at 3σ level. A quadratic transformation is given to correct older values to the new scale in the range of our calibrating clusters (-2.24≤[Fe/H]ZW≤-0.51). A minor disagreement is found at low metallicities between the metallicity scale based on field and cluster RR Lyrae variables (via a new calibration of the {DELTA}S index) and our new cluster metallicities. It could be tentatively ascribed to non-linearity in the [Fe/H]-{DELTA}S relationship. The impact of new metallicities on major astrophysical problems is exemplified through a simple exercise on the Oosterhoff effect in the classical pair M 3 and M 15.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): stars: abundances - stars: population II - globular clusters: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+AS/121/95): table9>

CDS comments: Table 9: some * not identified

Simbad objects: 127

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 127
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 1407 * 00 23 23.0 -72 04 24   14.85 13.78     ~ 12 0
2 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5422 * 00 23 23.0 -72 04 24   13.87 12.47     ~ 19 0
3 Cl* NGC 104 HH 9414 * 00 23 23.0 -72 04 24   13.45 11.87     ~ 19 0
4 NGC 104 GlC 00 24 05.359 -72 04 53.20     4.09     ~ 4158 0
5 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 8406 s?r 00 25 00.9103997016 -72 20 38.070660408   13.765 12.396 12.10   ~ 17 0
6 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 8416 * 00 26 58.2828614352 -72 18 16.871090004   14.58 13.43     ~ 10 0
7 NGC 288 GlC 00 52 45.24 -26 34 57.4   10 8.13     ~ 1130 0
8 2MASS J01024512-7052105 RG* 01 02 45.1287312000 -70 52 10.590947112   14.601 13.441     ~ 27 0
9 NGC 362 GlC 01 03 14.26 -70 50 55.6     6.58     ~ 1167 0
10 M 79 GlC 05 24 10.59 -24 31 27.3     8.16     ~ 883 0
11 NGC 2298 GlC 06 48 59.41 -36 00 19.1     8.89     ~ 547 0
12 2MASS J10172684-4625446 RG* 10 17 26.8437706732 -46 25 44.585314677   14.20 12.843     ~ 20 0
13 NGC 3201 GlC 10 17 36.82 -46 24 44.9           ~ 1001 0
14 NGC 3201 3522 RG* 10 17 44.8973148144 -46 24 06.403830336   14.07 12.73     ~ 19 0
15 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 1260 RG* 12 39 24.6556097478 -26 43 33.129429097   14.013 12.69   11.276 ~ 26 0
16 M 68 GlC 12 39 27.98 -26 44 38.6     7.96     ~ 1069 0
17 Cl* NGC 4590 ALC 53 RG* 12 39 30.8380890720 -26 47 52.674381456   14.166 12.76   11.551 ~ 23 0
18 Cl* NGC 4590 ALC 97 RG* 12 39 34.2907733784 -26 43 23.371720968   14.112 12.87   11.508 ~ 26 0
19 NGC 4833 GlC 12 59 33.92 -70 52 35.4           ~ 467 0
20 NGC 5272 238 RR* 13 41 51.5277150024 +28 23 22.494877008   14.09 12.22     ~ 62 0
21 M 3 GlC 13 42 11.62 +28 22 38.2     6.39     ~ 2593 0
22 NGC 5897 GlC 15 17 24.40 -21 00 36.4   10.16 8.52     ~ 424 0
23 NGC 5904 280 RG* 15 18 18.6760872648 +02 04 32.897627544   13.9600 12.4200   10.9538 ~ 63 0
24 NGC 5904 311 RG* 15 18 22.8375836304 +02 03 09.821837052   14.122 12.781 12.625 11.4812 ~ 44 0
25 NGC 5904 321 RG* 15 18 23.4537912264 +01 59 57.281951724   14.1800 12.8500   11.5629 ~ 32 0
26 2MASS J15182435+0201574 AB* 15 18 24.3532513368 +02 01 57.458156340   14.0684 12.8800   11.6833 ~ 36 0
27 NGC 5904 351 RG* 15 18 24.9948300024 +02 03 09.925833024   13.8300 12.2500   10.6567 ~ 31 0
28 NGC 5904 372 RG* 15 18 25.9108701912 +02 05 07.674028548   14.1000 12.6100   11.1373 ~ 34 0
29 2MASS J15182938+0208275 RG* 15 18 29.3839381752 +02 08 27.637458180   13.9700 12.3400   10.8537 ~ 22 0
30 NGC 5904 556 RG* 15 18 32.2284330168 +02 01 34.133171052   14.1100 12.6320   11.2242 ~ 39 0
31 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7     5.95     ~ 2095 0
32 NGC 5904 653 RG* 15 18 35.3133819792 +02 07 40.104335604   14.5100 13.3600   12.1848 ~ 39 0
33 2MASS J15184052+0207337 RG* 15 18 40.5233923296 +02 07 33.780842256   14.4700 13.3300   12.1487 ~ 22 0
34 NGC 5904 814 RG* 15 18 41.3224246872 +02 05 01.508208936   14.7000 13.6300   12.4198 ~ 36 0
35 NGC 5904 821 RG* 15 18 41.6460601368 +02 03 53.408347164   13.9400 12.4000   10.9177 ~ 41 0
36 2MASS J15184298+0207314 RG* 15 18 42.9880459704 +02 07 31.470224916   13.9500 12.4400   10.9986 ~ 28 0
37 NGC 5904 870 AB* 15 18 45.4061535624 +02 04 30.356708340   13.9511 12.6700   11.3695 ~ 64 0
38 NGC 5904 872 RG* 15 18 45.5149016664 +02 07 20.244223884   14.355 13.104 12.923 11.8441 ~ 25 0
39 2MASS J15184766+0203127 RG* 15 18 47.6701748976 +02 03 12.773139300   14.2100 12.8500   11.5910 ~ 22 0
40 NGC 6121 209 RG* 16 23 24.3734062920 -26 32 28.498772292 15.04 13.866 12.437   10.755 ~ 34 0
41 NGC 6121 154 RG* 16 23 26.9462895216 -26 31 31.372012704 15.06 13.898 12.485   10.788 ~ 37 0
42 NGC 6121 6 RG* 16 23 29.5109139504 -26 29 11.711659776 14.88 13.678 12.246   10.565 ~ 35 0
43 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1978 0
44 NGC 6144 GlC 16 27 13.86 -26 01 24.6           ~ 268 0
45 NGC 6205 70 RG* 16 41 23.5306872480 +36 30 17.265922560   13.71 12.12     ~ 93 0
46 NGC 6205 72 RG* 16 41 24.0799988472 +36 25 30.784251324   13.54 12.32     ~ 73 0
47 NGC 6205 77 RG* 16 41 24.6362215608 +36 25 45.116782032   13.97 12.77     ~ 49 0
48 NGC 6205 96 RG* 16 41 27.0864680880 +36 28 00.359401188   13.79 12.52     ~ 71 0
49 NGC 6205 158 RG* 16 41 30.5281002456 +36 29 43.440409140   13.89 12.70     ~ 46 0
50 NGC 6205 194 RG* 16 41 31.9970786088 +36 28 29.999965224   13.54 12.03     ~ 58 0
51 NGC 6205 199 RG* 16 41 32.5304694216 +36 24 42.571380852   12.65 11.93 11.90   ~ 65 0
52 NGC 6205 240 RG* 16 41 33.9173386656 +36 30 05.682748896   13.71 12.34     ~ 45 0
53 NGC 6205 252 RG* 16 41 34.3412115240 +36 30 13.276471320   13.098 11.771 12.393 11.36 ~ 34 0
54 NGC 6205 244 RG* 16 41 34.3634099664 +36 25 04.761614316   13.91 12.67 12.305   ~ 41 0
55 NGC 6205 261 RG* 16 41 34.7595031656 +36 27 59.516329536   13.50 12.17   10.79 ~ 44 0
56 NGC 6205 262 RG* 16 41 34.8156068016 +36 27 19.620308880   13.64 12.25     ~ 32 0
57 2MASS J16413629+3625104 RG* 16 41 36.2863923696 +36 25 10.303652496   13.81 12.58     ~ 33 0
58 NGC 6205 324 RG* 16 41 36.6351298080 +36 26 35.468102904   13.65 12.00     ~ 47 0
59 NGC 6205 414 RG* 16 41 38.6880896352 +36 25 37.905071700   13.61 12.14     ~ 65 0
60 M 13 GlC 16 41 41.634 +36 27 40.75     5.8     ~ 2291 0
61 NGC 6205 598 RG* 16 41 41.9443189176 +36 26 51.715259736   13.64 12.00     ~ 57 0
62 2MASS J16414255+3626563 RG* 16 41 42.5493186408 +36 26 56.173428780   13.42 11.94     ~ 38 0
63 NGC 6205 745 RG* 16 41 44.8522130952 +36 30 51.375592656   13.821 12.525 12.242   ~ 37 0
64 2MASS J16414703+3625576 RG* 16 41 47.0167556736 +36 25 57.511404084   13.48 12.03     ~ 40 0
65 NGC 6205 853 RG* 16 41 47.4290997048 +36 28 28.339241700   13.68 12.20     ~ 38 0
66 2MASS J16414970+3627489 RG* 16 41 49.6881218256 +36 27 48.777763752   13.47 12.04     ~ 28 0
67 NGC 6205 954 RG* 16 41 50.2992880776 +36 24 15.542524512   13.63 12.09     ~ 68 0
68 NGC 6205 973 RG* 16 41 50.9158586208 +36 28 54.352362612   13.65 11.91     ~ 73 0
69 NGC 6254 2024 RG* 16 57 00.3818138256 -04 06 01.348538724   13.5087 11.8755   10.1272 ~ 31 0
70 NGC 6254 3005 RG* 16 57 04.6471804392 -04 06 34.039735344   14.1712 12.7862 12.579 11.2526 ~ 22 0
71 NGC 6254 2050 RG* 16 57 06.7596386424 -04 03 10.518371712   13.8689 12.4176   10.8265 ~ 24 0
72 NGC 6254 3016 RG* 16 57 07.3397857992 -04 07 26.171023332   13.7979 12.2359   10.5567 ~ 27 0
73 M 10 GlC 16 57 09.05 -04 06 01.1     4.98     ~ 857 0
74 NGC 6254 3021 RG* 16 57 09.5277849336 -04 07 22.245629196   13.7386 12.0091   10.1823 ~ 31 0
75 NGC 6254 1002 RG* 16 57 10.7671267368 -04 04 43.911145200   13.6502 11.8535   9.9777 ~ 30 0
76 NGC 6254 1060 RG* 16 57 11.1851926248 -04 03 19.078672464   14.3372 13.0455 12.879 11.5769 ~ 24 0
77 2MASS J16571278-0403156 AB* 16 57 12.7885811880 -04 03 15.690877092   14.2506 13.0446   11.6224 ~ 25 0
78 NGC 6341 7018 RG* 17 16 37.4894075472 +43 06 15.600437640   13.47 12.18     ~ 77 0
79 NGC 6341 5045 RG* 17 16 49.8559809624 +43 10 41.184279768   13.87 12.83     ~ 39 0
80 NGC 6341 7122 AB* 17 16 57.3796096896 +43 07 23.741615280   13.438 12.327 12.234   ~ 34 0
81 M 92 GlC 17 17 07.39 +43 08 09.4     6.52     ~ 2240 0
82 NGC 6341 3082 RG* 17 17 08.0703754176 +43 10 44.890516704   14.119 13.220 13.156   ~ 38 0
83 NGC 6341 2053 RG* 17 17 13.0708130760 +43 09 48.270277188   13.53 12.35     ~ 33 0
84 NGC 6341 3065 RG* 17 17 14.1278300304 +43 10 46.201331604   13.68 12.49     ~ 52 0
85 NGC 6341 11019 RG* 17 17 18.7509075720 +43 04 50.891873916   13.815 12.821 12.702   ~ 29 0
86 NGC 6341 3013 Ro* 17 17 21.7194706080 +43 12 53.395475724   13.36 12.03     ~ 67 0
87 NGC 6341 12008 RG* 17 17 31.7161838520 +43 05 41.460088704   13.82 12.76     ~ 62 0
88 NGC 6352 GlC 17 25 29.11 -48 25 19.8           ~ 425 0
89 NGC 6362 32 * 17 31 47.5669999056 -67 02 14.186580216 16.676 14.644 13.296     ~ 7 0
90 NGC 6362 25 Pe* 17 31 52.5785906616 -67 01 57.909499500   14.79 13.33     ~ 8 0
91 NGC 6362 GlC 17 31 54.99 -67 02 54.0           ~ 637 0
92 NGC 6397 428 RG* 17 40 15.2617950648 -53 40 15.042604836 10.14 12.56 11.48 11.247   ~ 40 0
93 CPD-53 8708 RG* 17 40 20.1710551800 -53 42 01.828844568 10.87 11.38 10.03     ~ 27 0
94 NGC 6397 43 * 17 40 34.77 -53 35 20.0   11.96 10.94     ~ 28 0
95 NGC 6397 603 * 17 40 38.40 -53 45 24.8     10.631     ~ 29 0
96 CPD-53 8716 RG* 17 40 41.9976245291 -53 50 00.765473803   11.4 10.34     ~ 38 0
97 NGC 6397 GlC 17 40 42.09 -53 40 27.6     5.17     ~ 2103 0
98 NGC 6397 211 * 17 41 25.41 -53 37 37.9   11.40 10.10     ~ 43 0
99 NGC 6656 3052 * 18 36 10.1880699192 -23 54 22.149836316   13.2488 11.5217   9.6761 ~ 38 0
100 NGC 6656 3012 Pe* 18 36 14.2688646888 -23 54 31.402104804   13.236 11.540   9.723 ~ 26 0
101 M 22 GlC 18 36 23.94 -23 54 17.1           ~ 1459 0
102 NGC 6656 1092 * 18 36 33.2884633608 -23 52 32.858872716   13.141 11.561   9.828 ~ 28 0
103 Cl* NGC 6752 CL 1089 Pe* 19 10 11.1520724592 -59 55 00.680718396   12.67 11.05     ~ 13 0
104 Cl* NGC 6752 CS 3 * 19 10 38.3083769568 -60 04 14.036835684   12.75 11.49     ~ 29 0
105 NGC 6752 61 * 19 10 40.4523248616 -59 57 39.655507068   12.80 11.65     ~ 7 0
106 NGC 6752 GlC 19 10 52.11 -59 59 04.4           ~ 2121 0
107 NGC 6752 45 * 19 10 53.2459770888 -59 57 15.307148160   12.78 11.54     ~ 16 0
108 Cl* NGC 6752 CL 1066 * 19 11 00.1 -59 52 33   12.75 11.53     ~ 12 0
109 Cl* NGC 6752 GA 31 LP? 19 11 11.2981038888 -59 59 55.426567308   12.52 10.833     M 36 0
110 NGC 6752 29 RG* 19 11 14.3927402376 -60 00 32.223800196   13.006 11.867     ~ 36 0
111 Cl* NGC 6752 CL 1015 RG* 19 11 18.8129918784 -60 06 45.871175520   13.018 11.924 11.667   ~ 22 0
112 Cl* NGC 6838 AH A9 RG* 19 53 37.4728877088 +18 44 59.689600692   14.51 12.94     ~ 67 0
113 Cl* NGC 6838 AH S RG* 19 53 39.8690554440 +18 43 52.997623356   14.45 12.94     ~ 58 0
114 2MASS J19534477+1846349 AB* 19 53 44.7709947960 +18 46 34.989387348   13.99 12.42     ~ 31 0
115 M 71 GlC 19 53 46.49 +18 46 45.1           ~ 1190 0
116 2MASS J19534750+1846169 AB* 19 53 47.5108324968 +18 46 17.016728880   14.51 13.02     ~ 53 0
117 Cl* NGC 6838 ZDA 18 RG* 19 53 53.2569747960 +18 46 47.152843176   13.89 12.20     ~ 68 0
118 NGC 7078 144 RG* 21 29 49.7866647864 +12 11 05.792758584   14.40 13.06     ~ 68 0
119 M 15 GlC 21 29 58.33 +12 10 01.2           ~ 3274 0
120 2MASS J21300090+1208571 RG* 21 30 00.9013777728 +12 08 57.080615748   14.319 12.874     ~ 43 0
121 Cl* NGC 7099 AL 157 Pe* 21 40 11.8393848024 -23 12 34.847755740   13.99 12.94 12.771   ~ 14 0
122 M 30 GlC 21 40 22.12 -23 10 47.5     7.10     ~ 1121 0
123 NGC 7099 4 Pe* 21 40 26.6227358160 -23 14 35.462807124   13.98 12.83 12.593   ~ 17 0
124 NGC 3201 1501 * ~ ~   14.12 12.85     ~ 11 0
125 Cl* NGC 4590 ALC 260 * ~ ~           ~ 3 0
126 Cl* NGC 6752 GA 36 * ~ ~   12.75 11.59     ~ 6 0
127 Cl* NGC 6752 GA 284 * ~ ~           ~ 5 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 1997A&AS..121...95C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu