2003AJ....125.2018S

Query : 2003AJ....125.2018S

2003AJ....125.2018S - Astron. J., 125, 2018-2028 (2003/April-0)

A comparison of copper abundances in globular cluster and halo giant stars.

SIMMERER J., SNEDEN C., IVANS I.I., KRAFT R.P., SHETRONE M.D. and SMITH V.V.

Abstract (from CDS):

We derive [Cu/Fe] for 117 giant stars in 10 globular clusters (M3, M4, M5, M10, M13, M15, M71, NGC 7006, NCG 288, and NGC 362) and find that globular cluster Cu abundances appear to follow [Cu/Fe] trends found in the field. This result is interesting in light of recent work, which indicates that the globular cluster ω Centauri shows no trend in [Cu/Fe] with [Fe/H] over the abundance range -2.0<[Fe/H]←0.8. Of particular interest are the two clusters M4 and M5. While at a similar metallicity ([Fe/H]~-1.2), they differ greatly in some elemental abundances: M4 is largely overabundant in Si, Ba, and La compared with M5. We find that it is also overabundant in Cu with respect to M5, although this overabundance is in accord with [Cu/Fe] ratios found in the field.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): Galaxy: Abundances - Galaxy: Halo - Galaxy: Globular Clusters: General - Stars: Abundances - Stars: Population II

CDS comments: Table 1 : * in M 4 are Cl* NGC 6121 LEE, * in NGC 288 are a mixture of Cl* NGC 288 OCH and Cl* NGC 288 ALC (* 388 probably a misprint for Cl* NGC 288 OCH 338), in M 3 : AA = Cl* NGC 5272 S AA, II-46 = Cl* NGC 5272 S I-II-46, III-28 = Cl* NGC 5272 S I-III-28, stars L-NNN in M 13 are NGC 6205 NNN

Simbad objects: 126

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 126
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA 		ICRS (J2000)
DEC 		Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026 		#notes
1 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 260 RG* 00 52 41.1278269776 -26 33 27.013493592   15.213 11.380     ~ 32 0
2 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 307 RG* 00 52 45.2061879936 -26 34 58.209081096   15.013 13.864     ~ 17 0
3 NGC 288 GlC 00 52 45.24 -26 34 57.4   10 8.13     ~ 1130 0
4 2MASS J00524624-2637260 RG* 00 52 46.2599330400 -26 37 25.927623624   14.400 12.609     ~ 32 0
5 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 297 RG* 00 52 46.2686827392 -26 35 49.330804308   14.774 13.509     ~ 19 0
6 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 287 * 00 52 46.7443001067 -26 35 13.583451278   14.82 13.57     ~ 9 0
7 Cl* NGC 288 OCH 351 RG* 00 52 52.5149634720 -26 36 04.033208556   14.729 13.477     ~ 13 0
8 Cl* NGC 288 OCH 338 RG* 00 52 52.8034445808 -26 34 38.726621256   14.76 13.63     ~ 16 0
9 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 194 RG* 00 52 52.8804416016 -26 35 20.088540240   14.42 13.06     ~ 28 0
10 Cl* NGC 288 ALC 78 RG* 00 53 01.13 -26 36 07.1   14.36 12.88     ~ 21 0
11 NGC 362 4084 RG* 01 02 37.6352653416 -70 50 37.066360920   14.335 12.950     ~ 30 0
12 NGC 362 4100 RG* 01 02 43.3142150544 -70 48 48.050544096   14.360 12.772     ~ 30 0
13 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1159 RG* 01 02 53.1634752912 -70 50 30.884368848   14.331 12.68     ~ 19 0
14 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 148 * 01 02 58.2200721888 -70 55 51.196903284           ~ 12 1
15 2MASS J01025851-7049444 LP* 01 02 58.5131996808 -70 49 44.447162844   14.206 13.02   11.54 ~ 20 1
16 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 215 RG* 01 03 07.7825635128 -70 49 46.495031340     12.94   11.55 ~ 17 0
17 NGC 362 GlC 01 03 14.26 -70 50 55.6     6.58     ~ 1167 0
18 NGC 362 3063 RG* 01 03 21.7274048904 -70 48 40.417634808   14.290 12.716     ~ 30 0
19 NGC 362 3039 RG* 01 03 33.0080720232 -70 49 37.352379540   14.14 12.77   11.25 ~ 31 0
20 NGC 362 3044 RG* 01 03 34.9196877312 -70 48 07.968919104   14.261 12.804     ~ 30 0
21 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1356 RG* 01 03 35.6740148064 -70 50 56.203271556   14.816 13.715     ~ 17 0
22 2MASS J01033571-7050521 LP* 01 03 35.7120138456 -70 50 52.239186924     12.63 12.200 11.00 ~ 23 0
23 NGC 362 2020 RG* 01 03 38.4065826000 -70 52 04.822764096   14.202 12.769     ~ 26 0
24 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3677 0
25 2MASS J13414576+2824597 AB* 13 41 45.7668971856 +28 24 59.665303044   14.18 12.81     ~ 70 0
26 NGC 5272 238 RR* 13 41 51.5277150024 +28 23 22.494877008   14.09 12.22     ~ 62 0
27 NGC 5272 297 * 13 41 58.366 +28 15 52.58   14.31 12.89     ~ 41 0
28 M 3 GlC 13 42 11.62 +28 22 38.2     6.39     ~ 2593 0
29 NGC 5272 837 RG* 13 42 12.0532321224 +28 26 26.474013996   14.27 12.67     ~ 50 0
30 NGC 5272 1000 RG* 13 42 14.2886095920 +28 25 31.561359384   14.41 13.01     ~ 32 0
31 NGC 5272 1127 RG* 13 42 16.7922839088 +28 23 47.840303112   14.16 12.93     G8Ib 33 0
32 Cl* NGC 5272 SAW V236 RG* 13 42 41.4990637608 +28 19 08.050336392   14.303 12.661 12.398   ~ 64 0
33 NGC 5904 228 RG* 15 18 10.4247821304 +02 03 32.157608940   14.1414 12.9088   11.5593 ~ 24 1
34 2MASS J15182014+0203321 AB* 15 18 20.1492159744 +02 03 32.238671472   14.3739 13.2800   12.1502 ~ 26 0
35 NGC 5904 293 RG* 15 18 20.7268892784 +02 06 41.472317880   14.8800 13.8662   12.7346 ~ 37 0
36 2MASS J15182382+0201069 AB* 15 18 23.8200752040 +02 01 06.954718332   14.4860 13.5200   12.4670 ~ 9 0
37 Cl* NGC 5904 ARP 3052 RG* 15 18 24.2872684824 +02 01 09.101751384   15.0100 14.0600   12.9592 ~ 26 0
38 NGC 5904 382 RG* 15 18 26.3623910712 +02 02 38.558387832   14.9100 13.9300   12.8078 ~ 22 0
39 NGC 5904 469 RG* 15 18 29.3624119968 +02 07 50.039630148   14.8200 13.7679   12.6370 ~ 27 0
40 2MASS J15182938+0208275 RG* 15 18 29.3839381752 +02 08 27.637458180   13.9700 12.3400   10.8537 ~ 22 0
41 NGC 5904 501 RG* 15 18 30.4935229440 +02 07 00.547230432   14.4800 13.2900   12.0993 ~ 29 0
42 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7     5.95     ~ 2095 0
43 NGC 5904 612 RG* 15 18 34.0127761416 +02 07 15.869136540   14.8600 13.7900   12.6586 ~ 28 0
44 NGC 5904 631 RG* 15 18 34.8134587200 +02 02 22.702221132   15.0800 14.0700   12.9465 ~ 24 0
45 2MASS J15183505+0201068 RG* 15 18 35.0468206368 +02 01 06.901668264   14.0400 12.6000   11.2380 ~ 36 0
46 Cl* NGC 5904 G 2 Cl* 15 18 36 +02 04.0           ~ 2 0
47 2MASS J15183638+0208507 AB* 15 18 36.3835950672 +02 08 50.833200120   14.5470 13.5800   12.5859 ~ 25 0
48 2MASS J15183689+0202057 AB* 15 18 36.8856378144 +02 02 05.736285636   14.4833 13.4800   12.3755 ~ 11 0
49 NGC 5904 731 RG* 15 18 37.8171133944 +02 07 02.488561032   14.8500 13.8200   12.6774 ~ 28 0
50 NGC 5904 774 RG* 15 18 39.5468841048 +02 07 23.833088472   14.3900 13.2200   12.0244 ~ 27 0
51 2MASS J15183978+0201101 AB* 15 18 39.7776892704 +02 01 10.230139200   14.5298 13.5700   12.5178 ~ 11 0
52 2MASS J15184052+0207337 RG* 15 18 40.5233923296 +02 07 33.780842256   14.4700 13.3300   12.1487 ~ 22 0
53 Cl* NGC 5904 ARP 1014 RG* 15 18 40.6183528944 +02 06 24.224594544   14.2700 13.0000 12.806 11.7152 ~ 32 0
54 NGC 5904 806 RG* 15 18 41.0379347568 +02 02 24.340356096   14.9700 13.9528   12.8520 ~ 28 0
55 NGC 5904 811 RG* 15 18 41.2055908008 +02 01 51.226608036   14.085 12.924 12.948 11.7741 ~ 19 0
56 NGC 5904 818 AB* 15 18 41.3966214120 +02 06 00.549493956   13.8090 12.6200   11.1332 ~ 26 0
57 NGC 5904 821 RG* 15 18 41.6460601368 +02 03 53.408347164   13.9400 12.4000   10.9177 ~ 41 0
58 NGC 5904 865 RG* 15 18 44.9526006144 +02 02 03.568247448   13.8900 12.2000   10.6289 ~ 42 0
59 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2208 RG* 16 22 50.1081114384 -26 28 24.729900816 15.09 13.75 12.33   10.52 ~ 19 0
60 NGC 6121 314 RG* 16 23 04.3810595256 -26 23 43.069565040 14.75 13.303 11.817   10.100 ~ 41 0
61 2MASS J16231442-2636055 RG* 16 23 14.4181955592 -26 36 05.547999564 14.64 12.73 10.88 9.80 9.04 ~ 46 0
62 2MASS J16231672-2634279 AB* 16 23 16.7266384920 -26 34 28.144667604   13.170 11.732   10.093 ~ 30 0
63 NGC 6121 316 RG* 16 23 18.6900091416 -26 23 43.311594840   13.174 11.493   9.608 ~ 27 0
64 CD-26 11312 RG* 16 23 23.8093956576 -26 34 29.821786140 14.75 12.63 10.76   8.51 ~ 38 0
65 NGC 6121 45 RG* 16 23 29.1248946984 -26 30 29.805818400 14.92 13.354 11.781   9.988 ~ 48 0
66 2MASS J16232988-2631490 AB* 16 23 29.8820971752 -26 31 49.183529844 14.38 13.360 11.990   10.361 ~ 23 0
67 CD-26 11313 AB* 16 23 30.8920148160 -26 27 04.098919788   12.598 10.808   8.880 K2 40 0
68 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1978 0
69 2MASS J16233741-2638238 AB* 16 23 37.4194753800 -26 38 23.993321388 14.27 13.492 12.251   10.721 ~ 28 0
70 NGC 6121 259 RG* 16 23 38.4683784336 -26 33 19.295581140 15.13 12.818 10.833   8.608 ~ 42 0
71 NGC 6121 261 RG* 16 23 39.2711924040 -26 33 06.121074240   12.718 10.776   8.620 ~ 47 0
72 NGC 6121 27 RG* 16 23 39.9822671376 -26 28 49.036544760 14.74 13.304 11.743   9.938 ~ 50 0
73 2MASS J16234405-2630061 RG* 16 23 44.0648699088 -26 30 06.152203764 14.67 13.262 11.771   10.079 ~ 32 0
74 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 4511 RG* 16 23 49.8048740256 -26 33 58.872520404 14.83 13.177 11.568   9.748 ~ 30 0
75 2MASS J16235772-2622557 AB* 16 23 57.7217800608 -26 22 55.845721452 14.14 13.43 12.21   10.69 ~ 23 0
76 2MASS J16235872-2639489 AB* 16 23 58.7174848752 -26 39 49.008718332   13.045 11.625   9.934 ~ 26 0
77 2MASS J16235946-2627572 AB* 16 23 59.4618765552 -26 27 57.227309676   12.851 11.284   9.512 ~ 33 0
78 2MASS J16240301-2624034 AB* 16 24 03.0209319576 -26 24 03.464563248   12.571 10.859   8.967 ~ 45 0
79 2MASS J16240858-2624552 AB* 16 24 08.5890044928 -26 24 55.234147608   13.099 11.845   10.307 ~ 28 0
80 NGC 6205 70 RG* 16 41 23.5306872480 +36 30 17.265922560   13.71 12.12     ~ 93 0
81 2MASS J16413082+3630130 AB* 16 41 30.8206687560 +36 30 12.984390252   14.52 13.62     ~ 42 0
82 NGC 6205 194 RG* 16 41 31.9970786088 +36 28 29.999965224   13.54 12.03     ~ 58 0
83 NGC 6205 337 RG* 16 41 36.8265865632 +36 29 28.802595660   14.89 13.80     ~ 29 0
84 NGC 6205 348 RG* 16 41 37.0626791592 +36 30 37.786828176   15.05 14.11     ~ 27 0
85 NGC 6205 469 RG* 16 41 39.4397271192 +36 32 02.915596608   15.46 14.61     ~ 28 0
86 M 13 GlC 16 41 41.634 +36 27 40.75     5.8     ~ 2291 0
87 NGC 6205 598 RG* 16 41 41.9443189176 +36 26 51.715259736   13.64 12.00     ~ 57 0
88 2MASS J16414255+3626563 RG* 16 41 42.5493186408 +36 26 56.173428780   13.42 11.94     ~ 38 0
89 NGC 6205 726 RG* 16 41 44.7755349216 +36 23 27.274350408   14.66 13.58     ~ 32 0
90 NGC 6205 766 RG* 16 41 45.2787311568 +36 31 06.799082448   14.53 13.54     ~ 40 0
91 2MASS J16414703+3625576 RG* 16 41 47.0167556736 +36 25 57.511404084   13.48 12.03     ~ 40 0
92 NGC 6205 954 RG* 16 41 50.2992880776 +36 24 15.542524512   13.63 12.09     ~ 68 0
93 NGC 6205 955 RG* 16 41 50.3678850672 +36 23 41.605888344   14.82 13.79     ~ 28 0
94 NGC 6205 973 RG* 16 41 50.9158586208 +36 28 54.352362612   13.65 11.91     ~ 73 0
95 2MASS J16415160+3629363 AB* 16 41 51.5917356264 +36 29 36.207830796   14.44 13.69     ~ 25 0
96 NGC 6205 1062 RG* 16 41 58.6173751632 +36 27 46.400687964   15.37 14.52     ~ 28 0
97 NGC 6254 2024 RG* 16 57 00.3818138256 -04 06 01.348538724   13.5087 11.8755   10.1272 ~ 31 0
98 NGC 6254 3005 RG* 16 57 04.6471804392 -04 06 34.039735344   14.1712 12.7862 12.579 11.2526 ~ 22 0
99 NGC 6254 3016 RG* 16 57 07.3397857992 -04 07 26.171023332   13.7979 12.2359   10.5567 ~ 27 0
100 Cl* NGC 6254 BARN 3 RG* 16 57 07.7896295472 -04 06 06.023039580   13.85 12.447   10.858 ~ 15 0
101 2MASS J16570827-0405151 AB* 16 57 08.2770227256 -04 05 15.182266812   15.36 14.11     ~ 10 0
102 Cl* NGC 6254 RS 6 * 16 57 08.86 -04 05 40.5   15.34 13.76     ~ 8 0
103 M 10 GlC 16 57 09.05 -04 06 01.1     4.98     ~ 857 0
104 Cl* NGC 6254 RS 7 RG* 16 57 10.1906006112 -04 06 09.997254216   15.31 13.78     ~ 13 0
105 NGC 6254 1060 RG* 16 57 11.1851926248 -04 03 19.078672464   14.3372 13.0455 12.879 11.5769 ~ 24 0
106 2MASS J16571278-0403156 AB* 16 57 12.7885811880 -04 03 15.690877092   14.2506 13.0446   11.6224 ~ 25 0
107 Cl* NGC 6838 AH A9 RG* 19 53 37.4728877088 +18 44 59.689600692   14.51 12.94     ~ 67 0
108 NGC 6838 1077 RG* 19 53 37.5742734744 +18 47 28.603448124   14.447 12.762     ~ 63 0
109 Cl* NGC 6838 AH S RG* 19 53 39.8690554440 +18 43 52.997623356   14.45 12.94     ~ 58 0
110 M 71 GlC 19 53 46.49 +18 46 45.1           ~ 1190 0
111 NGC 6838 1053 RG* 19 53 50.6409291720 +18 49 07.531926240   14.58 12.97   11.527 ~ 67 0
112 Cl* NGC 6838 ZDA 18 RG* 19 53 53.2569747960 +18 46 47.152843176   13.89 12.20     ~ 68 0
113 NGC 7006 GlC 21 01 29.465 +16 11 16.49     10.46     ~ 562 0
114 NGC 7078 386 RG* 21 29 55.6204516368 +12 10 45.523873704   14.162 12.776     ~ 34 0
115 NGC 7078 462 RG* 21 29 56.6627934840 +12 09 46.341312228   14.45 12.90     ~ 40 0
116 2MASS J21295678+1210269 AB* 21 29 56.7771862968 +12 10 26.945682140   13.99 12.68     ~ 33 0
117 NGC 7078 490 * 21 29 57.03 +12 09 37.4   14.12 12.86     ~ 17 0
118 M 15 GlC 21 29 58.33 +12 10 01.2           ~ 3274 0
119 NGC 7078 583 RG* 21 29 58.5643129152 +12 09 21.382732260   14.26 12.83     ~ 34 0
120 Cl* NGC 7078 GEB 1141 RG* 21 29 59.32 +12 09 11.2   14.31 12.64   11.26 ~ 17 0
121 NGC 7078 702 RG* 21 30 00.3378196872 +12 10 50.879895708   13.83 12.68   11.52 ~ 31 0
122 NGC 7078 853 RG* 21 30 02.7380076312 +12 10 43.803937992   14.27 12.88     ~ 33 0
123 Cl* NGC 6254 MB B * ~ ~   15.09 13.50     ~ 4 0
124 Cl* NGC 7006 SW I-1 * ~ ~   17.39 15.69     ~ 4 0
125 Cl* NGC 7006 SW II-103 * ~ ~   17.64 16.23     ~ 8 0
126 Cl* NGC 7006 SW II-46 * ~ ~   17.76 16.38     ~ 8 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2003AJ....125.2018S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu