2004AJ....127.1513S


Query : 2004AJ....127.1513S

2004AJ....127.1513S - Astron. J., 127, 1513-1530 (2004/March-0)

The integrated spectrum of M67 and the spectroscopic age of M32.

SCHIAVON R.P., CALDWELL N. and ROSE J.A.

Abstract (from CDS):

We construct an integrated spectrum of the intermediate-age, solar-metallicity Galactic cluster M67, from individual spectroscopic observations of bona fide cluster members. The spectrum so obtained is used as a template to test our stellar population synthesis models, in an age and metallicity regime where such models remain largely untested. As a result, we demonstrate that our models predict a spectroscopic age of 3.5±0.5 Gyr for M67, which is the same age we obtain from fitting isochrones to the color-magnitude diagram of the cluster. Full consistency is reached when using either Hβ, Hγ, or Hδ as the age indicator. We also check if the models, when applied to the cluster integrated spectrum, predict elemental abundances in agreement with the known detailed abundance pattern of the cluster. The models also pass the latter test, by predicting the abundances of iron, magnesium, carbon, and nitrogen in agreement with detailed abundance analyses of cluster stars to within 0.1 dex. Encouraged by the high degree of consistency of our models, we apply them to the study of the integrated spectrum of the central 3" of the compact elliptical galaxy M32. The resulting luminosity-weighted age of the galaxy ranges between 2 and 3.5 Gyr, depending on the age indicator adopted. According to our models, the center of M32 seems to have a supersolar iron abundance, ranging between [Fe/H]~+0.1 and +0.3, depending on the spectral index adopted. The light element magnesium seems to be underabundant in the center of M32 relative to iron by about ∼0.1-0.2 dex, whereas the data are consistent with nearly solar carbon and nitrogen abundances relative to iron. We find that single-age, single-metallicity stellar population models with solar-scaled abundance patterns cannot fit all the Balmer and metal lines in the integrated spectrum of M32. In particular, there is a systematic trend in the sense that bluer absorption lines indicate a younger age and a higher metallicity. This slight inconsistency can be due either to (unaccounted for) abundance ratio effects on blue iron and Balmer line indices or to a spread of the ages of the stellar populations in M32. Current stellar population models cannot break this degeneracy at the level of accuracy required to address this problem.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): Galaxies: Clusters: General - Galaxies: Individual: Messier Number: M32 - Galaxies: Stellar Content - Galaxy: Open Clusters and Associations: Individual: Messier Number: M67 - Stars: Evolution

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/AJ/127/1513): table1.dat table2.dat table3.dat table6.dat>

Simbad objects: 111

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 111
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 M 32 GiG 00 42 41.82480 +40 51 54.6120 9.51 9.03 8.08     ~ 2236 2
2 HD 37216 PM* 05 39 52.3476047976 +52 53 50.951967360   8.60 7.83     G5V 81 0
3 * psi04 Aur PM* 06 43 04.9720763016 +44 31 28.018081668 8.33 6.50 5.02     K5III 108 0
4 HD 49178 PM* 06 48 53.8179652461 +37 30 18.436463504   8.76 8.07     G0 58 0
5 * ups Gem PM* 07 35 55.3500141720 +26 53 44.680194960 7.54 5.60 4.06 2.82 1.91 M0III 212 0
6 HD 61606 BY* 07 39 59.3286138624 -03 35 51.027583488 8.89 8.136 7.169 6.626 6.15 K3V 216 0
7 * g Gem SB* 07 46 07.4484186384 +18 30 35.993172960 8.09 6.33 4.87 3.72 2.89 K4III 183 0
8 HD 69582 SB* 08 17 29.6055783480 -03 06 27.227814300   8.28 7.56     G5/6V 30 0
9 HD 69830 PM* 08 18 23.9469682407 -12 37 55.817187530   6.74 5.95     G8:V 587 1
10 * 31 Lyn LP* 08 22 50.1094369374 +43 11 17.270175202 7.71 5.80 4.25 3.05 2.17 K4+III 169 0
11 BD+12 1920 HB* 08 50 18.2738243760 +11 55 21.204725232   10.994 9.909   8.890 ~ 48 0
12 BD+12 1921 RB? 08 50 21.0990835800 +12 21 11.689176636   11.83 10.464     ~ 24 0
13 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 598 V* 08 50 34.3879932817 +11 39 56.721924944 13.288 13.23 12.594   11.926 G0IV 47 0
14 NGC 2682 4 RG* 08 50 36.1346743896 +11 43 18.093424152 14.180 13.72 12.689   11.746 G8IV 47 0
15 NGC 2682 6 BS? 08 50 40.7921866032 +11 47 46.232730384 13.334 13.355 12.839   12.165 F7V 40 0
16 NGC 2682 8 * 08 50 41.5623791328 +11 44 30.091519644 13.329 13.12 12.331   11.502 G4V 17 0
17 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 745 SB* 08 50 46.0916139312 +11 43 08.297523444 13.686 13.71 13.077   12.435 F9V 36 0
18 NGC 2682 16 BS? 08 50 47.6624732228 +11 44 51.454924690 13.159 13.18 12.671   12.073 F7IV 41 0
19 NGC 2682 20 Pe* 08 50 49.9469249705 +11 49 12.771453264 14.186 13.78 12.889   11.998 G8V 79 0
20 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 720 Ro* 08 50 50.7337330704 +11 35 02.761962756   13.53 13.019   12.248 ~ 12 0
21 NGC 2682 23 ** 08 50 51.711816 +11 48 10.30320 13.360 13.22 12.67 12.53 12.244 F7V 17 0
22 NGC 2682 22 SB* 08 50 51.8285331648 +11 56 55.904875440 13.367 13.271 12.743   12.143 ~ 50 0
23 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 733 * 08 50 53.0766182688 +11 40 02.269492824 14.303 14.26 13.633 13.568 13.033 G0V 22 0
24 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 738 * 08 50 53.4164917896 +11 40 43.489745436 14.386 14.34 13.700   12.989 F9V 9 0
25 NGC 2682 28 SB* 08 50 54.3947168904 +11 56 29.078294820 13.385 13.32 12.761     F8IV 52 0
26 NGC 2682 30 * 08 50 55.6925064870 +11 52 14.690654736   12.64 11.954   11.369 F9IV 55 0
27 NGC 2682 37 RB? 08 50 58.1579169528 +11 52 22.369391242 14.489 13.8 12.806   11.881 K0IV 81 0
28 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 816 SB* 08 50 59.2373800527 +11 56 36.865859655 13.845 13.80 13.213   12.545 ~ 39 0
29 NGC 2682 45 SB* 08 50 59.7602748192 +11 39 22.274439588 14.983 14.07 12.895   11.746 K4V 22 0
30 NGC 2682 46 Pe* 08 51 00.1768051728 +11 54 32.104231704 13.991 13.541 12.764   11.889 G5IV 59 0
31 NGC 2682 49 Em* 08 51 00.8241144264 +11 39 37.623726720 13.645 12.56 12.596 12.58 11.843 G8V 24 0
32 NGC 2682 48 RB? 08 51 01.0583959920 +11 50 10.912564680 13.781 13.47 12.699   11.895 G2IV 51 0
33 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1077 SB* 08 51 07.2254409816 +11 53 01.951858464 13.382 13.24 12.595   11.752 F4 53 0
34 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 939 SB* 08 51 07.4210086776 +11 36 53.551735020 13.951 13.96 13.439   12.727 F8V 27 0
35 NGC 2682 70 * 08 51 07.8118960464 +11 48 09.326114712   11.96 11.522   11.036 F4IV 23 0
36 NGC 2682 81 BS* 08 51 11.7789373696 +11 45 22.123673277   9.96 10.024     B8V 114 0
37 NGC 2682 84 HB* 08 51 12.6931158192 +11 52 42.446745336   11.629 10.393 10.234 9.500 K1III 152 0
38 NGC 2682 88 SB* 08 51 13.6081464936 +11 50 38.121179748 13.152 12.97 12.180 11.931 11.545 G1IV 27 0
39 NGC 2682 90 BS* 08 51 14.3529693120 +11 45 00.540874080   11.43 10.819   10.544 ~ 51 0
40 NGC 2682 95 SB* 08 51 15.4464408600 +11 47 31.475192784 13.211 13.17 12.680 12.355 12.044 F2 46 0
41 NGC 2682 98 SB* 08 51 15.7591211352 +11 52 58.817131032 13.507 13.4 12.817   12.146 F9IV 33 0
42 Cl* NGC 2682 ES I-49 SB* 08 51 16.2831897720 +11 44 32.938447020 14.166 14.12 13.419   12.784 F5V 41 0
43 NGC 2682 104 RG* 08 51 17.0400668664 +11 50 46.501856052   12.114 11.001 10.863 10.12 K0III/IV 97 0
44 NGC 2682 110 SB* 08 51 17.5965222768 +11 39 36.061327872 14.185 14.13 13.590   12.841 G1V 26 0
45 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 986 SB* 08 51 17.9917758696 +11 45 54.232467732 13.363 13.28 12.733   12.04 ~ 84 0
46 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 999 RS* 08 51 18.6870620808 +11 47 02.715891216 13.632 13.38 12.569 12.143 11.69 ~ 97 0
47 NGC 2682 124 BS* 08 51 19.9070240880 +11 47 00.441178944 12.576 12.59 12.117 11.848 11.564 F5IV 90 0
48 NGC 2682 128 * 08 51 20.3300020320 +11 45 52.481465496 13.782 13.72 13.244   12.445 ~ 75 0
49 NGC 2682 130 BS* 08 51 20.5734927984 +11 46 16.412199564 13.346 13.34 12.950   12.30 G: 69 0
50 NGC 2682 134 V* 08 51 21.2238774840 +11 45 52.751052612 12.903 12.83 12.315 11.904 11.553 F5 78 0
51 NGC 2682 136 SB* 08 51 21.7535381400 +11 52 37.872333372   11.92 11.235   10.595 F8V 84 0
52 NGC 2682 140 Ro* 08 51 22.0511842656 +11 46 41.010219552 13.811 13.797 13.189 12.834 12.496 ~ 87 0
53 NGC 2682 141 HB* 08 51 22.8036640800 +11 48 01.779545736   11.570 10.346 10.180 9.40 K0IIIb 167 0
54 Cl* NGC 2682 ES IV-6 SB* 08 51 22.9620482520 +11 49 13.163000016 13.700 13.72 13.275 12.978 12.667 F7V 44 0
55 NGC 2682 OpC 08 51 23.5 +11 48 54           ~ 2528 0
56 NGC 2682 143 SB* 08 51 23.7746734704 +11 49 49.338989364   12.39 11.420   10.61 G4III 105 0
57 NGC 2682 144 SB* 08 51 23.8037727648 +11 47 16.083236724 13.914 13.62 12.835   11.981 G4IV 31 0
58 Cl* NGC 2682 ES I-245 mul 08 51 24.102720 +11 47 10.00428 14.294 12.93 12.22 13.00 12.781 ~ 13 0
59 NGC 2682 149 SB* 08 51 25.3734964224 +11 47 34.270786320 13.204 13.12 12.535 12.191 11.839 F9IV 44 0
60 NGC 2682 148 * 08 51 25.5222059040 +11 52 38.833392252   13.88 13.284   12.564 F9IV 29 0
61 NGC 2682 151 RG* 08 51 26.1833544456 +11 53 51.981683748   11.58 10.391     K1III 124 0
62 NGC 2682 156 BS* 08 51 27.0120114864 +11 51 52.582244112   11.1 10.940   10.862 A2V 81 0
63 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1036 EB* 08 51 28.1469477144 +11 49 27.495860592 13.262 13.27 12.809   12.184 F3 84 0
64 NGC 2682 163 Ro* 08 51 28.8031691832 +11 51 59.977626372   13.36 12.658   11.916 G1IV 47 0
65 NGC 2682 164 RG* 08 51 28.9910274072 +11 50 33.127331784   11.675 10.441 10.250 9.46 K1III 162 0
66 NGC 2682 166 Pe* 08 51 29.3544247680 +11 45 27.647071884 14.413 13.85 12.910   11.962 K0IV 83 0
67 NGC 2682 165 SB* 08 51 29.4079592280 +11 54 13.962790188   13.47 12.845   12.177 F9V 38 0
68 NGC 2682 173 RG* 08 51 30.4540403064 +11 48 58.324606164 13.834 13.12 11.731 11.594 11.08 ~ 53 0
69 NGC 2682 181 * 08 51 32.4021057960 +11 48 01.224703332 13.931 13.60 12.830 12.360 11.895 F5IV 34 0
70 NGC 2682 182 * 08 51 32.4464411376 +11 47 52.374354324 13.335 13.27 12.738 12.294 11.920 G0V 40 0
71 NGC 2682 185 BS* 08 51 32.5946133024 +11 48 52.103681712   11.46 11.48   10.80 A0V 75 0
72 NGC 2682 189 BS? 08 51 34.2794185200 +11 49 43.866397236 13.415 13.44 12.862   12.244 F8IV 46 0
73 NGC 2682 192 Pe* 08 51 35.4048721128 +11 57 56.554444188 13.879 13.583 12.817     G2IV 59 0
74 NGC 2682 193 RG* 08 51 35.7789056016 +11 53 34.748492712 13.904 13.22 12.267   11.228 K0III 121 0
75 NGC 2682 195 SB* 08 51 36.0102891818 +11 46 33.602537041 13.539 13.4 12.682 12.328 11.915 G0 64 0
76 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1318 SB* 08 51 36.3849438528 +11 56 50.841388680 14.610 14.62 14.070     ~ 27 0
77 NGC 2682 206 * 08 51 37.9564222728 +11 58 49.258353396 14.654 13.91 12.925 12.59   ~ 24 0
78 NGC 2682 218 RG* 08 51 42.3411424776 +11 50 07.677862008   12.71 11.48     K1III 84 0
79 NGC 2682 217 RG* 08 51 42.3635843520 +11 51 23.075134668   12.80 11.23     K1III 101 0
80 NGC 2682 219 SB* 08 51 42.4520308920 +11 49 51.965419080 13.158 13.11 12.606   11.817 F7V 35 0
81 NGC 2682 221 * 08 51 42.6777213456 +11 46 36.599534004 12.908 12.95 12.460   11.646 F8 27 0
82 NGC 2682 224 RG* 08 51 43.5490441608 +11 44 26.477313396   11.894 10.686 10.460 9.660 K1III 116 0
83 NGC 2682 223 RG* 08 51 43.8874792752 +11 56 42.528745068   11.658 10.476   9.500 K1III 114 0
84 NGC 2682 226 Pe* 08 51 44.0075287632 +11 46 24.535277112 13.749 13.549 12.790   11.928 G0 83 0
85 NGC 2682 227 RB? 08 51 44.7392991552 +11 46 46.046943048 14.402 13.898 13.000   11.994 K0IV 78 0
86 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1190 SB* 08 51 46.0808032872 +11 36 18.330058404   12.02 11.155     ~ 16 0
87 NGC 2682 235 * 08 51 46.4157683952 +11 46 26.717955492 13.989 13.95 13.463   12.694 F8V 38 0
88 NGC 2682 236 SB* 08 51 48.3253485888 +11 51 11.957150304 13.271 13.17 12.557   11.741 G1IV 46 0
89 NGC 2682 237 * 08 51 48.8385365448 +11 56 51.245718540 14.453 13.82 12.982     K0IV 49 0
90 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1192 * 08 51 50.6116599120 +11 36 33.852927492 13.788 13.86 13.520   12.801 ~ 8 0
91 Cl* NGC 2682 MMJ 6228 * 08 51 52.57 +12 04 23.1   13.310 12.688     ~ 2 0
92 NGC 2682 261 * 08 51 56.0039584272 +11 51 26.532969048   10.91 10.589   10.317 A3 28 0
93 NGC 2682 262 RB? 08 51 56.1167034360 +11 50 14.841071664 14.595 13.9 12.976   11.906 K0IV 53 0
94 NGC 2682 265 * 08 51 58.5184211016 +11 46 52.979678472 13.110 13.05 12.517   11.707 F9V 23 0
95 NGC 2682 266 RG* 08 51 59.5227693496 +11 55 04.835590251   11.65 10.463   9.490 K1III 113 0
96 NGC 2682 267 Em* 08 51 59.6372211192 +11 52 57.679412484 13.454 13.37 12.878   12.115 ~ 37 0
97 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1446 * 08 52 09.6150409488 +11 46 46.239444660 14.701 14.66 14.169   13.318 ~ 26 0
98 BD+12 1930 BS* 08 52 10.7435074328 +11 44 05.867673842   10.81 10.700     A1V 71 0
99 Cl* NGC 2682 ES II-152 RG* 08 52 10.9715389335 +11 31 49.232248887   12.051 10.911   9.790 G5 84 0
100 NGC 2682 281 V* 08 52 11.3482966608 +11 45 37.976349384 14.016 13.734 12.951   12.019 G5IV 52 0
101 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1440 BS* 08 52 13.4288665992 +11 46 01.293315564 13.907 13.97 13.546   12.843 ~ 23 0
102 Cl* NGC 2682 SAND 1586 SB* 08 52 16.6514311536 +11 42 29.998092744 14.008 14.06 13.598     ~ 28 0
103 NGC 2682 286 HB* 08 52 18.5744408733 +11 44 26.374152806   11.541 10.382   9.430 K0III 101 0
104 * 56 Leo LP? 10 56 01.4682688998 +06 11 07.341317877 8.45 7.24 5.78 3.53 1.44 M5.5III: 179 0
105 * lam Crt SB* 11 23 21.8814666155 -18 46 48.128136896   5.51 5.09     F5III 120 0
106 HD 106156 PM* 12 12 57.5317999258 +10 02 15.776359716   8.71   7.4   G8V 105 0
107 HD 126511 PM* 14 24 48.9417591696 +41 16 30.390340080       7.9   G5 60 0
108 V* KU Lib BY* 14 40 31.1063299272 -16 12 33.452598312 8.247 7.977 7.240 6.837 6.47 G8Vk: 112 0
109 HD 136834 PM* 15 22 42.5465323962 +01 25 07.052636328   9.30   8.738   K3IV-V 148 0
110 HD 158614 SB* 17 30 23.79699 -01 03 46.4882 6.34     5.52   G9-IV-VHdel1 307 0
111 * 70 Oph SB* 18 05 27.28518 +02 30 00.3558 5.40 4.89 4.03 3.38 2.92 K0-V 679 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2004AJ....127.1513S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu