2004MNRAS.347..367C


Query : 2004MNRAS.347..367C

2004MNRAS.347..367C - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 347, 367-379 (2004/January-2)

The effects of age on red giant metallicities derived from the near-infrared CaII triplet.

COLE A.A., SMECKER-HANE T.A., TOLSTOY E., BOSLER T.L. and GALLAGHER J.S.

Abstract (from CDS):

We have obtained spectra with a resolution of ∼2.5 Å in the region of ~7500-9500Å for 116 red giants in five galactic globular clusters and six old open clusters (five with published metallicities and one previously unmeasured). The signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio lies within the range 20 ≤ S/N ≤ 85. We measure the equivalent widths of the infrared CaII triplet absorption lines in each star and compare them with cluster metallicities taken from the literature. With globular cluster abundances on the Carretta & Gratton scale, and open cluster abundances taken from the compilation of Friel and collaborators, we find a linear relation between [Fe/H] and CaII line strength spanning the range -2 ≲[Fe/H]≲-0.2 and 2.5 ≲ (age/Gyr) ≲ 13. The reference abundance scales appear to be consistent with each other at the ∼0.1 dex level. Alternate choices for metallicity scales can introduce curvature into the relation between the [Fe/H] and CaII equivalent width. No evidence for an age effect on the metallicity calibration is observed. Using this calibration, we find the metallicity of the massive, old, open cluster Trumpler 5 to be [Fe/H]-0.56±0.11. This is the first spectroscopic abundance measurement for Trumpler 5, and is lower by ~0.3 dex than estimates based on the cluster colour-magnitude diagram. Considering the 10 clusters of known metallicity shifted to a common distance and reddening, we find that the additional error introduced by the variation of horizontal branch/red clump magnitude with metallicity and age is of the order of ±0.05 dex, which can be neglected in comparison with the intrinsic scatter in the method. The results are discussed in the context of abundance determinations for red giants in Local Group galaxies.

Abstract Copyright: 2004 RAS

Journal keyword(s): techniques: spectroscopic - stars: abundances - stars: late-type - open clusters and associations: individual: Trumpler 5

Simbad objects: 113

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 113
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5422 * 00 23 23.0 -72 04 24   13.87 12.47     ~ 19 0
2 Cl* NGC 104 HH 3027 * 00 23 23.0 -72 04 24   13.67 12.18     ~ 18 0
3 Cl* NGC 104 HH 3205 * 00 23 23 -72 04.4   13.69 12.21     ~ 11 0
4 Cl* NGC 104 HH 9413 * 00 23 23.0 -72 04 24   14.64 13.56     ~ 14 0
5 NGC 104 GlC 00 24 05.359 -72 04 53.20     4.09     ~ 4158 0
6 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5528 * 00 25 53.0208907130 -71 52 30.740553276   15.40 14.78     ~ 5 0
7 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5419 * 00 26 03.1703411256 -71 50 46.478360760   14.92 14.05     ~ 8 0
8 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5418 * 00 26 05.4446301336 -71 49 20.684380296   16.20 15.33     ~ 5 0
9 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5530 * 00 26 23.2185978240 -71 57 54.170656524   14.20 13.14     ~ 5 0
10 Cl* NGC 104 LEE 5310 * 00 26 45.4673354064 -71 47 23.674059564   14.05 13.41     ~ 6 0
11 M 31 AGN 00 42 44.330 +41 16 07.50 4.86 4.36 3.44     ~ 13622 1
12 NGC 1851 GlC 05 14 06.76 -40 02 47.6           ~ 1529 0
13 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 19090 0
14 NGC 1904 153 RG* 05 24 09.1300227312 -24 34 16.114505592   14.8 13.44   11.556 ~ 42 0
15 NGC 1904 160 RG* 05 24 09.3928763208 -24 33 30.124697904   14.56 13.02     ~ 43 0
16 NGC 1904 15 LP* 05 24 09.5748185688 -24 29 51.399093696   14.662 13.307   11.898 ~ 17 0
17 M 79 GlC 05 24 10.59 -24 31 27.3     8.16     ~ 883 0
18 NGC 1904 241 LP* 05 24 18.0461265024 -24 30 14.850930852   14.808 13.635   12.373 ~ 18 0
19 Cl Berkeley 20 OpC 05 32 36.8 +00 11 06           ~ 129 0
20 Cl* Berkeley 20 MPJF 22 * 05 32 36.8762941512 +00 11 49.517888712   17.970 16.915     ~ 9 0
21 Cl* Berkeley 20 FMP 10770 * 05 32 37.9493386560 +00 11 09.624148980     15.12     ~ 20 0
22 Cl* Berkeley 20 SBR 1240 * 05 32 38.9519765184 +00 11 20.368920480     15.154     ~ 25 0
23 NGC 2141 5009 * 06 02 49 +10 31.4   15.90 14.62     ~ 3 0
24 NGC 2141 4009 RG* 06 02 50.7852271656 +10 30 28.104400296     13.27     ~ 24 0
25 NGC 2141 OpC 06 02 56.5 +10 26 57           ~ 159 0
26 NGC 2141 1321 * 06 02 58.2717613905 +10 26 38.962864438   15.23 14.00     ~ 9 0
27 NGC 2141 5013 RG* 06 03 00.0247696344 +10 32 23.492692212   15.21 13.96     ~ 18 0
28 NGC 2141 3240 RG* 06 03 01.5540518304 +10 28 34.732120512   15.13 13.33     ~ 23 0
29 NGC 2141 4025 RG* 06 03 07.5542553768 +10 26 49.217579052   15.34 14.06     ~ 18 0
30 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-2579 * 06 36 23.93 +09 28 17.2   17.153 15.588     ~ 2 0
31 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-1305 * 06 36 24.54 +09 25 46.7   16.280 14.242     ~ 2 0
32 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-2324 * 06 36 24.83 +09 27 46.6   16.647 15.034     ~ 2 0
33 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-1401 * 06 36 28.0986549960 +09 25 56.265010320   16.665 15.289     ~ 13 0
34 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-2565 * 06 36 28.48 +09 28 13.4   17.345 15.792     ~ 2 0
35 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-3354 RG* 06 36 29.3064593266 +09 29 45.221265094   16.237 14.466 13.899   ~ 17 0
36 Cl Trumpler 5 OpC 06 36 31.8 +09 28 03           ~ 146 0
37 V* V493 Mon C* 06 36 32.6761497240 +09 25 39.300580236   15.80   11.31   C 27 1
38 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-1935 * 06 36 33.1114015512 +09 27 00.850167396   14.865 12.815 12.199   ~ 8 0
39 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-3763 * 06 36 34.11 +09 30 34.6   16.195 14.536     ~ 2 0
40 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-1834 * 06 36 35.56 +09 26 48.0   17.710 16.239     ~ 2 0
41 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-2280 * 06 36 35.99 +09 27 35.2   16.743 15.161     ~ 2 0
42 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-3066 * 06 36 36.4651159248 +09 29 08.114649756   15.460 13.744 13.795   ~ 6 0
43 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-488 * 06 36 40.41 +09 23 45.1   18.300 16.510     ~ 2 0
44 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-833 RG* 06 36 42.0680553768 +09 24 34.141319532   16.713 14.909 14.258   ~ 15 0
45 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-1214 * 06 36 42.29 +09 25 25.7   15.741 13.911     ~ 2 0
46 Cl* Trumpler 5 K 3-1026 * 06 36 42.9630897720 +09 25 02.268696720   16.407 14.712 14.118   ~ 6 0
47 NGC 2298 GlC 06 48 59.41 -36 00 19.1     8.89     ~ 547 0
48 Cl Melotte 66 4151 RG* 07 26 12.0671119656 -47 43 24.765309264   14.249 12.668 12.277 11.00 ~ 30 0
49 Cl* Melotte 66 KJF 2155 RB? 07 26 13.5073697928 -47 37 24.660205320     14.5   13.29 ~ 7 0
50 Cl Melotte 66 4265 * 07 26 13.5097732152 -47 43 53.152242564   15.353 14.019 13.789 12.74 ~ 8 0
51 Cl Melotte 66 3101 RB? 07 26 17.4540367944 -47 40 44.313712464     15.2   13.95 ~ 6 0
52 Cl Melotte 66 OpC 07 26 19.2 -47 41 14   8.73       ~ 213 0
53 Cl Melotte 66 2107 * 07 26 19.8971855928 -47 40 15.854429964   15.627 14.462 14.413 13.52 ~ 17 0
54 UCAC4 212-013246 RB? 07 26 22.0542148848 -47 39 28.018549836   14.681 13.170 12.807 11.53 ~ 16 0
55 GEN# +5.20662261 RB? 07 26 23.0286559992 -47 37 42.182803884   14.85 13.6   12.33 ~ 8 0
56 Cl* Melotte 66 KJF 1419 RB? 07 26 26.6608492344 -47 37 55.807878000   15.470 14.48   13.29 ~ 16 0
57 UCAC4 212-013296 RB? 07 26 30.5355580248 -47 41 43.883907072   15.277 14.012 13.853 12.77 ~ 12 0
58 Cl Melotte 66 3235 * 07 26 34.5891912456 -47 42 47.162670264   15.780 14.626 14.428 13.39 ~ 17 0
59 Cl Melotte 66 2233 * 07 26 35.2234826352 -47 38 24.984623076     15.44   14.29 ~ 7 0
60 UCAC4 212-013332 RB? 07 26 37.6776555192 -47 39 07.623195588   15.379 14.272 13.925 12.84 ~ 8 0
61 Cl Melotte 66 3229 * 07 26 39.2744796816 -47 44 05.750801340   15.168 13.956 13.690 12.65 ~ 8 0
62 Cl* Berkeley 39 KR 9 HB* 07 46 39.2703886536 -04 37 54.285867480   15.444 14.199   12.996 ~ 19 0
63 Cl* Berkeley 39 KR 17 * 07 46 42.0442112424 -04 41 05.987519304   15.958 14.740   13.504 ~ 12 0
64 Cl* Berkeley 39 KR 5 * 07 46 47.6010941496 -04 39 56.256954948   15.286 13.995   12.500 ~ 25 0
65 Cl Berkeley 39 OpC 07 46 48.1 -04 39 59           ~ 209 1
66 Cl* Berkeley 39 FMP 21815 * 07 46 49.1145617736 -04 41 55.686738768   16.698 15.518   14.185 ~ 17 0
67 Cl* Berkeley 39 FMP 21925 * 07 46 51.1422109680 -04 40 29.232107973   16.076 14.783   13.491 ~ 10 0
68 Cl* Berkeley 39 KR 16 * 07 46 52.49 -04 41 14.6   15.649 14.426   13.187 ~ 8 0
69 Cl* Berkeley 39 KUBVI 1139 HB* 07 46 54.1492528272 -04 38 58.224033096   15.489 14.359   13.113 ~ 24 0
70 NGC 2682 104 RG* 08 51 17.0400668664 +11 50 46.501856052   12.114 11.001 10.863 10.12 K0III/IV 97 0
71 NGC 2682 105 RG* 08 51 17.0998188072 +11 48 16.173832932   11.554 10.316 9.942 9.07 K2III 167 0
72 NGC 2682 108 RG* 08 51 17.4855757728 +11 45 22.707921744   11.064 9.603 9.370 8.36 ~ 161 1
73 NGC 2682 135 RG* 08 51 21.5640702312 +11 46 06.216394188   12.53 11.394   10.39 K1III 122 0
74 NGC 2682 141 HB* 08 51 22.8036640800 +11 48 01.779545736   11.570 10.346 10.180 9.40 K0IIIb 167 0
75 NGC 2682 OpC 08 51 23.5 +11 48 54           ~ 2528 0
76 NGC 2682 164 RG* 08 51 28.9910274072 +11 50 33.127331784   11.675 10.441 10.250 9.46 K1III 162 0
77 BD+12 1926 RG* 08 51 29.9058258360 +11 47 16.870629444   11.004 9.555 9.360 8.36 K3III 155 0
78 Cl* NGC 4590 ALC 69 * 12 39 15.9158967504 -26 46 11.222131152   15.368 14.728   13.859 ~ 8 0
79 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR I-2 RG* 12 39 17.6391100444 -26 44 43.681161442 16.069 15.971 15.148 14.638 14.127 ~ 10 1
80 Cl* NGC 4590 ALC 66 RG* 12 39 18.2334625752 -26 46 40.418097600 15.676 15.537 14.666 14.135 13.606 ~ 21 0
81 Cl* NGC 4590 ALC 60 RG* 12 39 21.5405299032 -26 48 17.363253096 16.061 15.972 15.153 14.647 14.137 ~ 13 0
82 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 1260 RG* 12 39 24.6556097478 -26 43 33.129429097   14.013 12.69   11.276 ~ 26 0
83 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 1119 RG* 12 39 27.0710087040 -26 47 51.184492224   14.664 13.659   12.445 ~ 13 0
84 M 68 GlC 12 39 27.98 -26 44 38.6     7.96     ~ 1069 0
85 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 1258 RG* 12 39 30.0786276864 -26 42 46.615100076   15.246 14.356   13.268 ~ 17 0
86 Cl* NGC 4590 ALC 97 RG* 12 39 34.2907733784 -26 43 23.371720968   14.112 12.87   11.508 ~ 26 0
87 Cl* NGC 4590 HAR 1239 RG* 12 39 37.6268792376 -26 45 15.557633604   15.211 14.277   13.195 ~ 19 0
88 NGC 6253 OpC 16 59 06.4 -52 42 39     10.2     ~ 209 0
89 NGC 6528 GlC 18 04 49.61 -30 03 20.8   12.12 10.65     ~ 561 0
90 NGC 6553 GlC 18 09 15.68 -25 54 27.9   9.08       ~ 644 0
91 NGC 6791 OpC 19 20 52.8 +37 46 40   10.52 9.5     ~ 1120 0
92 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 195 * ~ ~     15.82     ~ 3 0
93 Cl* NGC 2298 AL 22 * ~ ~     15.30   14.10 ~ 3 0
94 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 179 * ~ ~     16.45     ~ 3 0
95 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 160 * ~ ~     15.51   14.51 ~ 3 0
96 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 123 * ~ ~     16.21   15.58 ~ 3 0
97 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 65 * ~ ~     15.75   14.75 ~ 3 0
98 Cl* Berkeley 39 KR 2 * ~ ~   14.56 13.09     ~ 4 0
99 Cl* NGC 2298 AL 25 * ~ ~     15.69   14.60 ~ 3 0
100 NGC 2141 3234 * ~ ~   16.04 14.95     ~ 3 0
101 Cl* Berkeley 20 MPJF 29 * ~ ~     17.140     ~ 3 0
102 Cl* Berkeley 20 MPJF 12 * ~ ~     16.209     ~ 3 0
103 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 231 * ~ ~     15.93   14.93 ~ 3 0
104 Cl* Berkeley 39 KR 13 * ~ ~     14.35     ~ 3 0
105 Cl* Berkeley 39 KR 3 * ~ ~   14.90 13.55     ~ 11 0
106 Cl* NGC 2298 AL 6 * ~ ~     13.82   12.38 ~ 3 0
107 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 275 * ~ ~   16.47 15.10   12.82 ~ 3 0
108 Cl* NGC 1851 STET 209 * ~ ~   15.67 14.39   12.82 ~ 4 0
109 Cl* NGC 2298 AL 12 * ~ ~     14.23   12.88 ~ 3 0
110 NGC 1904 6 * ~ ~   16.20 15.27     ~ 8 0
111 NGC 2141 3252 * ~ ~   15.84 14.47     ~ 3 0
112 NGC 2141 1405 * ~ ~   16.29 14.71     ~ 3 0
113 Cl* NGC 2298 AL 15 * ~ ~     14.86   13.53 ~ 3 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2004MNRAS.347..367C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu