2006MNRAS.371.1648F


Query : 2006MNRAS.371.1648F

2006MNRAS.371.1648F - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 371, 1648-1658 (2006/October-1)

New age estimates of M31 globular clusters from multicolour photometry.

FAN Z., MA J., DE GRIJS R., YANG Y. and ZHOU X.

Abstract (from CDS):

The large majority of extragalactic star cluster studies performed to date essentially use multicolour photometry, combined with theoretical stellar synthesis models, to derive ages, masses, extinction estimates and metallicities. M31 offers a unique laboratory for studies of globular cluster (GC) systems. In this paper, we obtain new age estimates for 91 M31 GCs, based on improved photometric data, updated theoretical stellar synthesis models and sophisticated new fitting methods. In particular, we used photometric measurements from the Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS), which, in combination with optical photometry, can partially break the well-known age-metallicity degeneracy operating at ages in excess of a few Gyr. We show robustly that previous age determinations based on photometric data were affected significantly by this age-metallicity degeneracy. Except for one cluster, the ages of our other sample GCs are all older than 1 Gyr. Their age distribution shows populations of young- and intermediate-age GCs, peaking at ∼3 and 8 Gyr, respectively, as well as the `usual' complement of well-known old GCs, i.e. GCs of similar age as the majority of the Galactic GCs. Our results also show that although there is significant scatter in metallicity at any age, there is a notable lack of young metal-poor and old metal-rich GCs, which might be indicative of an underlying age-metallicity relationship among the M31 GC population.

Abstract Copyright: 2006 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2006 RAS

Journal keyword(s): globular clusters: general - galaxies: individual: M31 - galaxies: star clusters

Simbad objects: 99

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 99
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 Bol 9 GlC 00 40 30.6999535344 +41 36 55.732742820 17.540 17.630 16.920 16.420 15.870 ~ 51 0
2 Bol 15 GlC 00 40 45.0276446400 +40 59 56.109063876 20.344 19.411 18.130 17.265 16.381 ~ 37 0
3 Bol 17 GlC 00 40 48.7201449960 +41 12 07.176983544 17.547 17.048 15.968 15.246 14.510 ~ 47 0
4 Bol 23 GlC 00 41 01.151 +41 13 45.41 16.040 15.400 14.17 13.560 12.570 ~ 98 0
5 Bol 25 GlC 00 41 12.5499576864 +41 00 28.115847468 17.959 17.702 16.799 16.205 15.680 ~ 39 0
6 Bol 27 GlC 00 41 14.5288661472 +40 55 50.974329576 16.669 16.486 15.642 15.104 14.55 ~ 67 0
7 Bol 29 GlC 00 41 17.8243331280 +41 00 22.868949204 18.297 17.725 16.713 16.069 15.380 ~ 54 0
8 Bol 30 GlC 00 41 18.7279643712 +40 57 15.630595344 19.743 18.754 17.436 16.574 15.729 ~ 43 0
9 Bol 31 GlC 00 41 20.9232034944 +40 59 04.170773400 19.565 18.934 17.800 17.094 16.408 ~ 38 0
10 Bol 34 GlC 00 41 28.1192391768 +40 53 49.683810084 16.772 16.372 15.442 14.873 14.220 ~ 65 0
11 Bol 36 GlC 00 41 32.8188760032 +41 26 05.199934740 18.320 18.250 17.310 16.790 16.130 ~ 33 0
12 Bol 37 GlC 00 41 34.9868411928 +41 14 55.086295416 19.891 18.749 16.849 15.428 14.190 ~ 65 0
13 Bol 38 GlC 00 41 35.9544840120 +41 19 14.819589084 17.683 17.425 16.498 15.879 15.240 ~ 42 0
14 Bol 39 GlC 00 41 37.8790732536 +41 20 50.036035488 17.824 17.186 15.982 15.177 14.420 ~ 43 0
15 Bol 40 GlC 00 41 38.8429994184 +40 40 54.332136804 17.568 17.748 17.339 17.042 16.625 ~ 44 1
16 Bol 41 * 00 41 40.81 +41 14 45.5 19.552 19.240 18.542 18.088 17.553 ~ 29 0
17 Bol 42 GlC 00 41 41.6786368368 +41 07 26.269463460 18.617 17.665 16.197 15.242 14.400 ~ 44 0
18 Bol 44 GlC 00 41 42.9114940512 +41 20 06.192452688 18.474 17.912 16.815 16.102 15.369 ~ 31 0
19 Bol 51 GlC 00 41 46.6798156320 +41 25 19.140355632 17.851 17.289 16.184 15.464 14.650 ~ 44 0
20 Bol 54 GlC 00 41 47.6764482576 +41 00 55.290167640 19.907 19.243 18.228 17.598 16.902 ~ 28 0
21 Bol 56 GlC 00 41 51.1652469480 +40 57 40.092561864 19.006 18.291 17.283 16.639 15.938 ~ 38 0
22 Bol 57 GlC 00 41 52.8196632480 +40 52 05.111837508 18.460 18.388 17.662 17.186 16.735 ~ 35 0
23 Bol 59 GlC 00 41 54.1021167648 +41 11 00.760923312 18.958 18.392 17.249 16.516 15.789 ~ 29 0
24 Bol 61 GlC 00 42 00.1325402352 +41 29 35.739624372 18.490 17.870 16.721 15.959 15.120 ~ 46 0
25 Bol 63 GlC 00 42 00.8663431920 +41 29 09.534752664 17.416 16.806 15.650 14.885 14.080 ~ 46 0
26 Bol 64 GlC 00 42 01.9218618048 +41 11 07.504677204 17.217 17.054 16.259 15.752 15.197 ~ 41 0
27 Bol 68 GlC 00 42 03.2023791960 +40 58 50.141249688 18.291 17.497 16.318 15.562 14.794 ~ 51 0
28 Bol 73 GlC 00 42 07.3229975400 +40 59 21.190499700 17.403 16.917 15.979 15.423 14.819 ~ 46 0
29 Bol 76 GlC 00 42 10.2368913456 +41 05 22.018914924 17.883 17.641 16.760 16.249 15.685 ~ 46 0
30 Bol 82 GlC 00 42 15.8394998856 +41 01 14.308375260 18.082 16.972 15.465 14.497 13.630 ~ 80 0
31 Bol 86 GlC 00 42 18.6515838696 +41 14 01.999584816 15.985 15.899 15.131 14.661 13.920 ~ 78 0
32 Bol 88 GlC 00 42 21.0614832024 +41 32 14.153991756 16.763 16.414 15.340 14.609 13.950 ~ 55 0
33 Bol 93 GlC 00 42 23.1500137488 +41 21 43.583576076 18.034 17.699 16.736 16.122 15.660 ~ 43 0
34 Bol 94 GlC 00 42 25.0389347352 +40 57 17.621278884 17.045 16.490 15.531 14.950 14.290 ~ 59 0
35 Bol 96 GlC 00 42 26.080 +41 19 14.79 18.796 17.863 16.635 15.857 15.188 ~ 67 0
36 Bol 98 GlC 00 42 27.38 +40 59 36.0 17.532 17.139 16.236 15.692 15.110 ~ 45 0
37 Bol 97 GlC 00 42 27.4633120896 +41 25 32.167755084 18.317 17.841 16.816 16.162 15.480 ~ 37 0
38 Bol 103 GlC 00 42 29.7326748504 +41 17 57.540046020 16.76 16.161 15.166 14.548 13.95 ~ 55 0
39 Bol 102 * 00 42 29.80 +41 34 18.5 17.131 17.242 16.601 16.236 15.630 ~ 25 0
40 Bol 105 GlC 00 42 30.7600675272 +41 30 27.336946860 18.421 18.079 17.168 16.580 16.059 ~ 32 0
41 Bol 106 GlC 00 42 31.0374692880 +41 12 18.277656552 17.556 17.086 16.137 15.539 14.770 ~ 43 0
42 Bol 107 GlC 00 42 31.2490262592 +41 19 38.842862160 17.00 16.725 15.764 15.171 14.681 ~ 76 0
43 Bol 110 GlC 00 42 33.1042029024 +41 03 28.347878700 16.430 16.036 15.163 14.619 14.000 ~ 71 0
44 Bol 116 GlC 00 42 35.0 +41 32 51 19.006 18.183 16.830 15.910 14.930 ~ 49 0
45 Bol 125 GlC 00 42 42.2652267624 +41 05 31.024974804 17.327 17.190 16.444 15.970 15.476 ~ 36 0
46 M 31 AGN 00 42 44.330 +41 16 07.50 4.86 4.36 3.44     ~ 13622 1
47 Bol 127 GlC 00 42 44.52 +41 14 41.5 15.80 15.200 14.42 13.800 13.29 ~ 63 0
48 Bol 130 GlC 00 42 48.8555834400 +41 29 52.628904384 18.408 17.979 16.918 16.211 15.641 ~ 34 0
49 Bol 131 GlC 00 42 50.7993174648 +41 17 07.346354136 16.62 16.220 15.342 14.800 14.38 ~ 54 0
50 Bol 134 GlC 00 42 51.6426613536 +41 14 03.617692692 17.73 17.582 16.699 16.161 15.736 ~ 52 0
51 Bol 135 GlC 00 42 51.9745899672 +41 31 08.204480040 17.117 16.866 15.953 15.358 14.820 ~ 72 0
52 Bol 137 GlC 00 42 53.9946126480 +41 32 14.305919712 19.367 18.873 17.709 16.915 16.233 ~ 27 0
53 Bol 143 GlC 00 42 59.6426520720 +41 19 19.253372304 17.800 17.075 16.087 15.486 14.94 ~ 84 0
54 Bol 148 GlC 00 43 03.8563107048 +41 18 04.761860328 16.80 16.623 15.799 15.284 14.869 ~ 84 0
55 Bol 149 GlC 00 43 05.4677240736 +41 34 27.255793836 18.199 17.812 16.862 16.171 15.500 ~ 34 0
56 Bol 151 GlC 00 43 09.54 +41 21 32.1 16.74 16.056 14.77 14.130 13.40 ~ 54 0
57 Bol 152 GlC 00 43 10.0062074904 +41 18 16.021066068 17.443 17.003 16.093 15.528 15.015 ~ 48 0
58 Bol 153 GlC 00 43 10.6182973728 +41 14 51.289897920 17.726 17.117 16.148 15.553 14.98 ~ 73 0
59 Bol 154 GlC 00 43 12.4500104280 +41 16 04.887403896 18.296 17.715 16.758 16.201 15.739 ~ 53 0
60 Bol 158 GlC 00 43 14.3953843272 +41 07 21.141017796 15.900 15.560 14.65 14.150 13.550 ~ 119 1
61 Bol 161 GlC 00 43 15.4138672416 +41 11 24.926083692 17.363 17.133 16.291 15.807 15.415 ~ 58 0
62 Bol 163 GlC 00 43 17.6311962552 +41 27 44.994405276 16.77 16.030 15.00 14.430 13.87 ~ 80 0
63 Bol 164 GlC 00 43 18.1275231888 +41 12 29.195615340 19.451 18.826 17.821 17.214 16.658 ~ 38 0
64 Bol 165 GlC 00 43 18.2207068848 +41 10 54.647724792 17.252 17.214 16.483 16.037 15.62 ~ 46 0
65 Bol 167 GlC 00 43 21.1209933072 +41 14 08.187468720 18.87 18.325 17.346 16.731 16.206 ~ 40 0
66 Bol 171 GlC 00 43 25.6003962624 +41 15 37.095704604 16.795 16.192 15.217 14.635 14.07 ~ 75 0
67 Bol 174 GlC 00 43 30.2984835048 +41 38 56.239256508 16.653 16.280 15.363 14.709 14.057 ~ 45 0
68 Bol 178 GlC 00 43 30.78 +41 21 16.5 15.91 15.820 14.97 14.530 14.12 ~ 49 0
69 Bol 179 GlC 00 43 31.1069226792 +41 18 14.612214636 16.449 16.162 15.316 14.800 14.43 ~ 55 0
70 Bol 180 GlC 00 43 31.7272406160 +41 07 46.303455108 17.299 16.946 16.041 15.483 14.820 ~ 42 0
71 Bol 182 GlC 00 43 36.6643147368 +41 08 12.099171372 16.608 16.266 15.314 14.820 14.27 ~ 71 0
72 Bol 183 GlC 00 43 36.9301798680 +41 02 02.291200548 17.424 16.900 15.941 15.352 14.650 ~ 44 0
73 Bol 185 GlC 00 43 37.2819255864 +41 14 43.514072700 16.910 16.475 15.543 14.982 14.47 ~ 75 0
74 Bol 184 GlC 00 43 37.5017611680 +41 36 34.565895648 19.062 18.174 17.185 16.502 15.793 ~ 36 0
75 Bol 190 GlC 00 43 43.3786658424 +41 34 05.993199876 17.887 17.614 16.801 16.218 15.88 ~ 43 0
76 Bol 193 GlC 00 43 45.4998657576 +41 36 57.605146668 16.746 16.097 15.193 14.565 14.18 ~ 89 0
77 Bol 197 GlC 00 43 49.7041052976 +41 30 10.086786972 19.203 18.565 17.598 16.919 16.61 ~ 32 0
78 Bol 201 GlC 00 43 52.830 +41 09 57.90 17.127 16.904 16.066 15.552 15.115 B 47 0
79 Bol 203 GlC 00 43 55.82 +41 32 35.0 17.955 17.645 16.825 16.280 15.735 ~ 41 0
80 Bol 204 GlC 00 43 56.4208141968 +41 22 02.887837428 17.011 16.574 15.652 15.170 14.62 ~ 55 0
81 Bol 205 GlC 00 43 58.147 +41 24 38.66 16.478 16.224 15.375 14.848 14.44 ~ 53 0
82 Bol 206 GlC 00 43 58.62 +41 30 18.1 15.885 15.650 14.913 14.384 14.08 ~ 54 0
83 Bol 209 GlC 00 44 02.6215469544 +41 25 26.714765460 17.531 17.314 16.552 16.063 15.508 ~ 44 0
84 Bol 211 GlC 00 44 02.9211728616 +41 20 04.737395328 17.482 17.370 16.626 16.154 15.761 ~ 43 0
85 Bol 213 GlC 00 44 03.5120929536 +41 30 38.647890144 18.088 17.666 16.785 16.205 15.575 ~ 55 0
86 Bol 214 GlC 00 44 03.9428129016 +41 26 18.643941960 18.365 18.268 17.560 17.049 16.483 ~ 42 0
87 Bol 217 GlC 00 44 10.6005243408 +41 23 51.101862936 17.653 17.275 16.420 15.833 15.218 ~ 48 0
88 Bol 218 GlC 00 44 14.3248282920 +41 19 19.371822456 15.875 15.559 14.682 14.230 13.74 ~ 74 0
89 Bol 220 GlC 00 44 19.4549832912 +41 30 34.664513446 17.315 17.178 16.472 15.963 15.458 ~ 48 0
90 Bol 221 GlC 00 44 23.0616908616 +41 33 06.327826308 17.901 17.562 16.716 16.130 15.531 ~ 47 0
91 Bol 222 GlC 00 44 25.3441465992 +41 14 11.911954848 18.683 18.385 17.686 17.235 16.749 ~ 44 1
92 Bol 224 GlC 00 44 27.09 +41 28 49.8 16.132 16.034 15.340 14.842 14.339 ~ 54 0
93 Bol 225 GlC 00 44 29.5618369896 +41 21 35.714596284 15.50 15.000 14.220 13.679 13.02 ~ 136 0
94 Bol 228 GlC 00 44 33.2019731640 +41 41 27.776317056 18.043 17.576 16.669 16.036 15.396 ~ 44 0
95 Bol 235 GlC 00 44 57.9226531440 +41 29 23.790790644 17.337 17.050 16.238 15.658 15.019 ~ 49 0
96 HD 19445 Pe* 03 08 25.5883873084 +26 19 51.400965175 8.29 8.52 8.06 7.60 7.27 G2VFe-3 801 0
97 HD 84937 Pe* 09 48 56.0992891997 +13 44 39.326709913 8.49 8.68 8.32 7.97 7.70 F8Vm-5 831 0
98 BD+26 2606 SB* 14 49 02.3593347728 +25 42 09.192358874 9.92 10.16 9.73 9.27 8.95 A5 383 0
99 BD+17 4708 SB* 22 11 31.3756832854 +18 05 34.177983548 9.73 9.91 9.46 9.03 8.70 sdF8 580 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2006MNRAS.371.1648F and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu