2007ApJ...665.1067M


Query : 2007ApJ...665.1067M

2007ApJ...665.1067M - Astrophys. J., 665, 1067-1073 (2007/August-3)

The dynamical distinction between elliptical and lenticular galaxies in distant clusters: further evidence for the recent origin of S0 galaxies.

MORAN S.M., LOH B.L., ELLIS R.S., TREU T., BUNDY K. and MacARTHUR L.A.

Abstract (from CDS):

We examine resolved spectroscopic data obtained with the Keck II telescope for 44 spheroidal galaxies in the fields of two rich clusters, Cl 0024+16 (z=0.40) and MS 0451-03 (z=0.54) and contrast this with similar data for 23 galaxies within the redshift interval 0.3<z<0.65 in the GOODS northern field. For each galaxy we examine the case for systemic rotation, derive central stellar velocity dispersions σ and photometric ellipticities ε. Using morphological classifications obtained via Hubble Space Telescope imaging as the basis, we explore the utility of our kinematic quantities in distinguishing between pressure-supported ellipticals and rotationally supported lenticulars (S0s). We demonstrate the reliability of using the v/(1-ε) versus σ and v/σ versus ε distributions as discriminators, finding that the two criteria correctly identify 63%±3% and 80%±2% of S0s at z∼0.5, respectively, along with 76+8–3% and 79%±2% of ellipticals. We test these diagnostics using equivalent local data in the Coma Cluster, and find that the diagnostics are similarly accurate at z=0. Our measured accuracies are comparable to the accuracy of visual classification of morphologies, but avoid the band-shifting and surface brightness effects that hinder visual classification at high redshifts. As an example application of our kinematic discriminators, we then examine the morphology-density relation for elliptical and S0 galaxies separately at z∼0.5. We confirm, from kinematic data alone, the recent growth of rotationally supported spheroidals. We discuss the feasibility of extending the method to a more comprehensive study of cluster and field galaxies to z≃1, in order to verify in detail the recent density-dependent growth of S0 galaxies.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): Galaxies: Clusters: General - Galaxies: Elliptical and Lenticular, cD - Galaxies: Evolution - Galaxies: Spiral - Galaxies: Stellar Content

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/665/1067): table1.dat>

Nomenclature: Table 1: [MLE2007] CNN (Nos C1-C44), [MLE2007] FNN (Nos F1-F23).

Simbad objects: 71

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 71
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 [MET2005] 06.499540+17.336300 GiC 00 25 59.890 +17 20 10.68         19.937 ~ 4 0
2 [MET2005] 06.514290+17.317301 GiC 00 26 03.430 +17 19 02.28         18.848 ~ 6 0
3 [MET2005] 06.536870+17.165199 GiC 00 26 08.849 +17 09 54.72         19.418 ~ 5 0
4 [MET2005] 06.589540+17.236601 GiC 00 26 21.490 +17 14 11.76         19.592 ~ 6 0
5 [MET2005] p13i135c4 GiC 00 26 22.8923 +17 12 31.456         18.609 ~ 7 0
6 [TEK2003] 36-3-61 GiC 00 26 27.1113 +17 12 26.073         18.929 ~ 10 0
7 [MET2005] 06.629040+17.285900 GiC 00 26 30.970 +17 17 09.24         20.603 ~ 5 0
8 [TEK2003] 36-2-2 GiC 00 26 31.3952 +17 10 55.616         18.015 ~ 12 0
9 [APS2019] 186 GiC 00 26 31.411 +17 10 27.12         20.906 ~ 8 0
10 [MET2005] p24i1c3 GiC 00 26 31.5244 +17 06 03.847         18.875 ~ 6 0
11 [MET2005] 06.631500+17.286900 GiC 00 26 31.560 +17 17 12.84         19.848 ~ 6 0
12 [MET2005] 06.640250+17.158600 GiC 00 26 33.660 +17 09 30.96         19.616 ~ 11 0
13 [TEK2003] 0-3-96 GiC 00 26 34.3440 +17 10 22.144         18.774 ~ 14 0
14 [MET2005] 06.645750+17.172600 GiC 00 26 34.980 +17 10 21.36         19.571 ~ 12 0
15 ZwCl 0024+1652 ClG 00 26 35.6 +17 09 32     18.35     ~ 648 1
16 [TEK2003] 0-3-79 GiC 00 26 36.0089 +17 09 45.854         17.750 ~ 14 0
17 [MET2005] 06.660040+17.166300 AGN 00 26 38.39 +17 09 59.1         20.152 ~ 14 0
18 [TEK2003] 37-4-16 GiC 00 26 43.7433997896 +17 08 17.802865788         18.020 ~ 7 0
19 [MET2005] 06.726580+17.140800 GiC 00 26 54.379 +17 08 26.88         19.007 ~ 8 0
20 [MET2005] 06.741920+17.266001 GiC 00 26 58.061 +17 15 57.60         20.691 ~ 4 0
21 [MET2005] 06.782330+17.180401 GiC 00 27 07.759 +17 10 49.44         18.662 ~ 6 0
22 [MET2007] 73.439285-3.137721 GiC 04 53 45.428 -03 08 15.80         18.4 ~ 2 0
23 [MLE2007] C27 GiC 04 53 46.185 -02 54 00.65         20.1 ~ 2 0
24 [MET2007] 73.496521-2.947559 GiC 04 53 59.165 -02 56 51.21         19.5 ~ 3 0
25 [MET2007] 73.501228-2.982943 GiC 04 54 00.295 -02 58 58.59         20.4 ~ 4 0
26 [MET2007] 73.512947-2.932297 GiC 04 54 03.107 -02 55 56.27         19.3 ~ 3 0
27 CNOC MS 0451 101564 GiC 04 54 04.89 -03 00 01.3         19.5 ~ 6 0
28 [MLE2007] C21 GiC 04 54 04.949 -03 05 45.50           ~ 3 0
29 CNOC MS 0451 101306 GiC 04 54 05.71 -03 00 40.4         20.1 ~ 6 0
30 [MET2007] 73.530853-3.091667 GiC 04 54 07.405 -03 05 30.00         20.6 ~ 3 0
31 [MLE2007] C44 GiC 04 54 08.494 -03 00 33.66         20.7 ~ 3 0
32 [MLE2007] C34 GiC 04 54 09.72 -03 00 15.1         20.4 ~ 4 0
33 [MET2007] 73.541359-3.024954 GiC 04 54 09.926 -03 01 29.83         21.2 ~ 3 0
34 CNOC MS 0451 101234 BiC 04 54 10.84 -03 00 51.6         18.1 ~ 12 1
35 CNOC MS 0451 100920 GiC 04 54 10.86 -03 01 36.2         19.8 ~ 5 0
36 ClG 0451-03 ClG 04 54 10.9 -03 01 07     20.0     ~ 368 0
37 CNOC MS 0451 101087 GiC 04 54 12.47 -03 01 07.7         19.6 ~ 7 0
38 [MET2007] 73.555710-3.012476 GiC 04 54 13.370 -03 00 44.91         20.5 ~ 4 0
39 CNOC MS 0451 101748 GiC 04 54 14.13 -02 59 29.4         19.0 ~ 5 0
40 [MET2007] 73.559753-3.025665 GiC 04 54 14.341 -03 01 32.39         20.4 ~ 3 0
41 [MET2007] 73.566437-3.101368 GiC 04 54 15.945 -03 06 04.92         19.7 ~ 3 0
42 [MET2007] 73.579903-2.990404 GiC 04 54 19.177 -02 59 25.45         20.6 ~ 4 0
43 [MET2007] 73.600822-3.060730 GiC 04 54 24.197 -03 03 38.63         19.5 ~ 4 0
44 [MET2007] 73.601791-3.064176 GiC 04 54 24.430 -03 03 51.03         20.2 ~ 4 0
45 [MLE2007] C42 GiC 04 54 39.549 -03 05 03.63         19.7 ~ 3 0
46 [MET2007] 73.690666-3.034112 GiC 04 54 45.760 -03 02 02.80         19.1 ~ 3 0
47 SDSS J123603.25+621111.1 rG 12 36 03.26 +62 11 10.9 23.10 22.3841 21.664 20.72 20.3027 ~ 46 0
48 SHARDS 20003377 G 12 36 15.300 +62 12 21.72 25.19 23.4184 22.288 21.4 20.8840 ~ 19 0
49 CXOHDFN J123617.6+621344 rG 12 36 17.684 +62 13 44.29 25.36 24.3376 22.782 20.93 20.9918 ~ 32 0
50 CXOHDFN J123622.7+621259 AGN 12 36 22.79 +62 12 59.7 23.86 23.3263 21.997 20.38 20.5519 ~ 29 0
51 GOODS J123634.22+621433.3 G 12 36 34.2168 +62 14 33.256 25.32 20.7630 22.630 20.29 20.6513 ~ 18 0
52 CXOHDFN J123635.3+621110 AGN 12 36 35.270 +62 11 09.89 25.82 23.8362 22.393 20.80 20.9412 ~ 31 0
53 GOODS J123638.00+621729.5 G 12 36 37.991 +62 17 29.01 25.65 24.3408 22.082 21.74 20.9400 ~ 17 0
54 GOODS J123641.47+621403.1 G 12 36 41.492 +62 14 02.52 25.63 24.2785 23.010 20.85 21.0325 ~ 18 0
55 Cowie 4 rG 12 36 48.09 +62 13 08.9 25.83 23.5640 22.416 20.43 20.6113 ~ 68 0
56 COLDz -cont-GN-5 rG 12 36 52.888 +62 14 43.97 24.30 21.9002 20.016 18.93 19.1887 ~ 62 0
57 NAME GOODS-N Field reg 12 36 55.0 +62 14 15           ~ 1364 1
58 Cowie 18 G 12 37 00.582 +62 12 34.78 25.59 24.4852 23.232 21.43 21.5068 ~ 43 0
59 GOODS J123702.93+621423.9 G 12 37 02.930 +62 14 23.57 23.24 22.8831 22.578 20.27 20.5819 ~ 22 0
60 GOODS J123713.99+622036.9 G 12 37 14.022 +62 20 36.42 24.47 22.8385 21.784 20.7 20.0808 ~ 16 0
61 GOODS J123721.51+621334.9 G 12 37 21.511 +62 13 34.32 25.53 22.9472 21.857 19.64 19.8766 ~ 16 0
62 GOODS J123726.17+621403.5 G 12 37 26.1666 +62 14 03.462 27.76 24.3012 22.641   20.9090 ~ 13 0
63 GOODS J123726.22+621347.4 G 12 37 26.235 +62 13 46.80 25.38 23.1112 22.210 20.9 20.1207 ~ 19 0
64 FIGS GN2 1314 G 12 37 26.569 +62 17 13.64 26.7 24.7527 23.143 21.94 21.2632 ~ 16 0
65 CXOHDFN J123729.9+621300 G 12 37 29.912 +62 13 00.55 24.13 22.7181   21.0 20.0811 ~ 18 0
66 TKRS 13665 Sy2 12 37 44.205 +62 13 58.44 24.83 20.8596 22.00 21.7 21.1485 ~ 21 0
67 GOODS J123752.57+621449.4 G 12 37 52.602 +62 14 49.03 24.78 23.4742   20.9 20.1245 ~ 14 0
68 GOODS J123753.29+621454.2 G 12 37 53.324 +62 14 53.81 24.91 23.3483 21.03 20.9 20.0380 ~ 15 0
69 GOODS J123754.56+621527.2 G 12 37 54.588 +62 15 26.78 25.00 23.8961 21.704 21.41 20.8667 ~ 12 0
70 GOODS J123757.29+621547.7 G 12 37 57.297 +62 15 47.69 23.72 22.2915 20.15 20.7 19.7569 ~ 16 0
71 ACO 1656 ClG 12 59 44.40 +27 54 44.9           ~ 5141 2

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2007ApJ...665.1067M and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu