2009ApJ...693..355W


Query : 2009ApJ...693..355W

2009ApJ...693..355W - Astrophys. J., 693, 355-369 (2009/March-1)

Probing the lower mass limit for supernova progenitors and the high-mass end of the initial-final mass relation from white dwarfs in the open cluster M35 (NGC 2168).

WILLIAMS K.A., BOLTE M. and KOESTER D.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present a photometric and spectroscopic study of the white dwarf (WD) population of the populous, intermediate-age open cluster M35 (NGC 2168); this study expands upon our previous study of the WDs in this cluster. We spectroscopically confirm 14 WDs in the field of the cluster: 12 DAs, 1 hot DQ, and 1 DB star. For each DA, we determine the WD mass and cooling age, from which we derive each star's progenitor mass. These data are then added to the empirical initial-final mass relation (IFMR), where the M35 WDs contribute significantly to the high-mass end of the relation. The resulting points are consistent with previously published linear fits to the IFMR, modulo moderate systematics introduced by the uncertainty in the star cluster age. Based on this cluster alone, the observational lower limit on the maximum mass of WD progenitors is found to be ∼5.1 M☉- 5.2 M☉ at the 95% confidence level; including data from other young open clusters raises this limit to as high as 7.1 M☉, depending on the cluster membership of three massive WDs and the core composition of the most massive WDs. We find that the apparent distance modulus and extinction derived solely from the cluster WDs ((m - M)V= 10.45±0.08 and E(B-V) = 0.185±0.010, respectively) is fully consistent with that derived from main-sequence fitting techniques. Four M35 WDs may be massive enough to have oxygen-neon cores; the assumed core composition does not significantly affect the empirical IFMR. Finally, the two non-DA WDs in M35 are photometrically consistent with cluster membership; further analysis is required to determine their memberships.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): open clusters and associations: individual: M35 - stars: evolution - white dwarfs

Nomenclature: Table 2: LAWDS NGC 2168 NN (Nos 29-53) added.

Simbad objects: 71

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 71
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 PG 0136+251 WD* 01 38 52.9776840264 +25 23 22.640581464   15.83       DA1.2 91 0
2 LB 3567 WD* 02 40 37.7370723888 +42 52 29.550897444   19.747 19.628     DA 8 0
3 LB 3570 WD* 02 41 09.0720030312 +42 43 51.011107428   20.241 20.088     DA 8 0
4 Cl* NGC 1039 LAWDS S1 WD* 02 41 17.0865615912 +42 25 46.514259912   18.921 18.965     DA 7 0
5 LAWDS NGC 1039 26 WD* 02 42 00.2187216826 +42 59 48.745538788   20.36 20.355     DB 5 0
6 NGC 1039 OpC 02 42 09.1 +42 44 02           ~ 467 0
7 Cl Melotte 22 OpC 03 46 38.0 +24 10 41           ~ 3679 0
8 GD 50 WD* 03 48 50.1859724280 -00 58 32.290187664 12.596 13.787 14.063 14.210 14.388 DA1.2 272 1
9 EGGR 25 WD* 03 52 11.3301458285 +24 55 48.797718780 15.42 16.32 16.52     DA1.5 93 0
10 LP 474-252 PM* 04 20 12.1432227120 +13 10 26.296372272   17.91   16.06   ~ 13 0
11 Cl Melotte 25 OpC 04 30 27.4 +16 46 43           ~ 3309 0
12 EGGR 316 WD* 04 40 23.8781083870 +13 58 45.880560826   14.97 14.94 13.25   DB4 89 0
13 M 37 OpC 05 52 18.6 +32 32 36           ~ 436 0
14 LAWDS NGC 2168 53 CV* 06 07 33.8 +24 07 55           ~ 5 0
15 LAWDS NGC 2168 52 WD? 06 07 47.3898166080 +24 35 22.697276640     20.653     ~ 2 0
16 LAWDS NGC 2168 51 WD? 06 07 47.39 +24 34 15.3     21.877     ~ 1 0
17 LAWDS NGC 2168 50 WD? 06 07 47.77 +24 28 52.0     21.465     ~ 1 0
18 LAWDS NGC 2168 49 WD? 06 07 52.9487787024 +24 25 23.226774780     20.191     ~ 2 0
19 LAWDS NGC 2168 30 WD* 06 07 56.62296 +24 13 26.8320     21.175     DA 6 0
20 LAWDS NGC 2168 48 WD? 06 07 58.70 +24 28 40.1     21.590     ~ 1 0
21 LAWDS NGC 2168 47 WD? 06 08 00.37 +24 18 02.1     21.540     ~ 1 0
22 LAWDS NGC 2168 46 WD? 06 08 00.63 +24 07 40.2     20.998     ~ 1 0
23 LAWDS NGC 2168 29 WD* 06 08 02.1958591944 +24 25 23.915073468     20.719     DA 6 0
24 LAWDS NGC 2168 45 WD* 06 08 03.7586125104 +24 27 38.103857712     18.403     DA 7 0
25 LAWDS NGC 2168 44 WD? 06 08 03.8388582600 +24 27 36.996777720     19.718     ~ 1 0
26 LAWDS NGC 2168 28 WD* 06 08 13.509 +24 20 32.38   21.65 21.63     DQ 6 0
27 LAWDS NGC 2168 43 WD? 06 08 20.96 +24 08 51.4     22.440     ~ 1 0
28 LAWDS NGC 2168 42 WD? 06 08 24.11 +24 22 34.7     22.338     ~ 1 0
29 LAWDS NGC 2168 22 WD* 06 08 24.6576832440 +24 33 47.190406680     19.657     DA(H?) 10 0
30 LAWDS NGC 2168 41 WD? 06 08 34.9821705816 +24 32 46.796697060     18.886     ~ 3 0
31 LAWDS NGC 2168 18 WD? 06 08 35.44 +24 34 19.5     22.566     ~ 1 0
32 Cl* NGC 2168 RA 1 WD* 06 08 38.792 +24 15 06.61   20.64 20.989     DA 13 0
33 LAWDS NGC 2168 2 WD* 06 08 42.315 +24 10 17.61   22.38 21.569     DA 12 0
34 LAWDS NGC 2168 40 WD? 06 08 54.53 +24 35 58.5     22.244     ~ 1 0
35 LAWDS NGC 2168 37 WD? 06 08 59.02 +24 08 40.8     21.049     ~ 1 0
36 LAWDS NGC 2168 39 WD? 06 09 01.46 +24 26 50.3     22.648     ~ 1 0
37 LAWDS NGC 2168 36 WD? 06 09 04.59 +24 06 45.7     21.276     ~ 1 0
38 LAWDS NGC 2168 3 WD? 06 09 04.7847993888 +24 21 39.100161204     20.581     ~ 1 0
39 Cl* NGC 2168 RA 2 WD* 06 09 05.81 +24 12 11.3     21.216     DB 3 0
40 LAWDS NGC 2168 27 WD* 06 09 06.256 +24 19 25.25   22.04 21.398     DA 12 0
41 NGC 2168 OpC 06 09 07.5 +24 20 15           ~ 604 0
42 LAWDS NGC 2168 38 WD? 06 09 08.26 +24 36 24.2     22.158     ~ 1 0
43 Cl* NGC 2168 RA 3 WD* 06 09 11.5412764416 +24 27 20.709332676   20.1 20.065     DO 16 0
44 LAWDS NGC 2168 15 WD* 06 09 11.7448605408 +24 02 41.586083232   19.9 20.785 18.9   DA 11 0
45 LAWDS NGC 2168 35 WD? 06 09 12.92 +24 22 17.4     21.809     ~ 1 0
46 LAWDS NGC 2168 14 WD* 06 09 15.10008 +24 33 15.0696     21.701     DA 6 0
47 Cl* NGC 2168 RA 4 WD* 06 09 23.4729139560 +24 27 21.788696088   20.2 19.863     DO 16 0
48 LAWDS NGC 2168 34 WD? 06 09 25.26 +24 14 05.2     21.026     ~ 1 0
49 LAWDS NGC 2168 13 WD? 06 09 29.71 +24 15 58.6     21.542     ~ 1 0
50 LAWDS NGC 2168 12 WD* 06 09 31.19928 +24 19 05.9304     21.303     DA 6 0
51 LAWDS NGC 2168 33 WD? 06 09 33.02 +24 15 23.5     22.259     ~ 1 0
52 LAWDS NGC 2168 32 WD? 06 09 37.35 +24 31 52.5     22.000     ~ 1 0
53 LAWDS NGC 2168 11 WD* 06 09 42.787 +24 11 05.10     21.198     DA 8 0
54 LAWDS NGC 2168 10 WD? 06 09 43.6281193488 +24 19 15.562755876     20.238     ~ 2 0
55 LAWDS NGC 2168 31 WD? 06 10 08.4654629832 +24 22 32.112490584     20.231     ~ 1 0
56 * alf CMa SB* 06 45 08.91728 -16 42 58.0171 -1.51 -1.46 -1.46 -1.46 -1.43 A0mA1Va 1610 0
57 * alf CMa B WD* 06 45 09.3041925037 -16 43 00.724740067   8.41 8.44     DA1.9 563 1
58 M 41 OpC 06 46 03.1 -20 43 07   4.89 4.5     ~ 308 0
59 NGC 2516 OpC 07 58 00.5 -60 46 36           ~ 793 0
60 NGC 2632 OpC 08 39 58.4 +19 36 33           ~ 1733 0
61 EGGR 61 WD* 08 40 28.0935005160 +19 43 34.488958224   17.6 17.66 17.7   DA 72 0
62 Cl* NGC 2632 DPN 3 WD* 08 40 31.4689640280 +21 40 42.732950412   18.0 18.0     DA 39 0
63 NGC 3532 OpC 11 05 33.9 -58 42 13           ~ 414 0
64 LAWDS NGC 6633 4 WD* 18 27 10.4365098576 +06 26 15.997852824   18.98 18.82     DA 13 0
65 NGC 6633 OpC 18 27 30.2 +06 38 21           ~ 423 0
66 LAWDS NGC 6633 7 WD* 18 27 49.9118513904 +06 20 52.020302208   19.5 19.27     DA 10 0
67 LAWDS NGC 6633 16 WD* 18 28 04.6921473313 +06 45 06.687568620   20.22 20.08     DB 7 0
68 NGC 6791 OpC 19 20 52.8 +37 46 40   10.52 9.5     ~ 1120 0
69 NGC 6819 OpC 19 41 18.3 +40 11 19   8.21 7.3     ~ 719 0
70 LAWDS NGC 7063 1 WD* 21 24 10.2344482896 +36 26 02.295124224   20.27 20.03     DA 7 0
71 NGC 7789 OpC 23 57 19.4 +56 43 28   7.68 6.7     ~ 575 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2009ApJ...693..355W and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu