2009ApJ...696.1355L

We present high-resolution High Resolution Echelle Spectrometer (HIRES)/Keck spectra of HD 209458, and a Monte Carlo variation on the basic method used by other workers, to look for the excess in-transit absorption in the NaD doublet at 5893 Å due to the extrasolar planet. The HIRES data, binned by bandpass, allow a direct comparison with previous results. We find >3σ results in most test bandpasses around the NaD doublet, including relative absorption of (-108.8±25.7)x10^–5 in the "narrow" bandpass used by other workers. This is ~4.7 times larger than the "narrow" results reported by Charbonneau et al. for HD 209458b. However, >2σ absorption is detected in some weak Fe I and Ni I lines that were tested for comparison, raising concern about the uncertainties introduced by continuum-fitting and terrestrial atmosphere subtraction.