2010A&A...514A..87C


Query : 2010A&A...514A..87C

2010A&A...514A..87C - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 514A87-87 (2010/5-1)

A serendipitous survey for variability amongst the massive stellar population of Westerlund 1.

CLARK J.S., RITCHIE B.W. and NEGUERUELA I.

Abstract (from CDS):

Massive stars are known to demonstrate significant spectroscopic and photometric variability over a wide range of timescales. However the physical mechanisms driving this behaviour remain poorly understood. Westerlund 1 presents an ideal laboratory for studying these processes in a rich, coeval population of post-main sequence stars and we present a pathfinding study aimed at characterising their variability. To do this we utilised the large body of spectroscopic and photometric data that has accumulated for Wd1 during the past decade of intensive studies, supplemented with the sparser historical observations extending back to the early 1960s. Despite the heterogeneous nature of this dataset, we were able to identify both spectroscopic and photometric variability amongst every class of evolved massive star present within Wd 1. Spectroscopic variability attributable to both wind asphericity and photospheric pulsations was present amongst both the hot and cool hypergiants and the former, also with the Wolf Rayets. Given the limitations imposed by the data, we were unable to determine the physical origin of the wind structure inferred for the OB supergiants, noting that it was present in both single pulsating and binary stars. In contrast we suspect that the inhomogineities in the winds of the Wolf Rayets are driven by binary interactions and, conversely, by pulsations in at least one of the cool hypergiants. Photospheric pulsations were found for stars ranging from spectral types as early as O9 I through to the mid F Ia+ yellow hypergiants - with a possible dependence on the luminosity class amongst the hot supergiants. The spectroscopically variable red supergiants (M2-5 Ia) are also potential pulsators but require further observations to confirm this hypothesis. Given these findings it was therefore rather surprising that, with the exception of W243, no evidence of the characteristic excursions of both luminous blue variables and yellow hypergiants was found. Nevertheless, future determination of the amplitude and periodicity of these pulsations as a function of temperature, luminosity and evolutionary state holds out the tantalising possibility of constraining the nature of the physical mechanisms driving the instabilities that constrain and define stellar evolution in the upper reaches of the HR diagram. Relating to this, the lack of secular evolution amongst the cool hypergiants and the presence of both high-luminosity yellow hypergiants and red supergiants within Wd1 potentially place strong constraints on post-main sequence evolutionary pathways, with the latter result apparently contradicting current theoretical predictions for >25M☉ stars at solar metallicites.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): stars: evolution - stars: variables: general - supergiants

Simbad objects: 79

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 79
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 * bet Cas dS* 00 09 10.68518 +59 08 59.2120 2.73 2.61 2.27 1.97 1.77 F2III 551 0
2 HD 5980 WR* 00 59 26.5838833944 -72 09 53.927337312   11.13 11.31   11.029 WN4+O7I: 419 1
3 [HS53] A s*y 01 32 32.8025598888 +30 30 25.003726668 20.1 19.9 19.1 18.6 17.7 F8Ia 55 0
4 * 61 And s*b 02 19 04.4525174952 +57 08 07.795069656 6.63 7.00 6.5678   6.6876 B3Ia 212 0
5 V* S Per s*r 02 22 51.7113133056 +58 35 11.422774248 13.22 10.55 7.90     M4.5-7Iae 388 0
6 NAME Magellanic Clouds GrG 03 00 -71.0           ~ 7988 0
7 WOH G 64 Mi* 04 55 10.5236094912 -68 20 30.019011036       15.69 12.795 M7.5(I)e 110 0
8 * eps Ori s*b 05 36 12.81335 -01 12 06.9089 0.48 1.51 1.69 1.76 1.93 B0Ia 921 0
9 HD 269858 s*b 05 36 43.6936418088 -69 29 47.451149232   10.24 10.15 9.95 9.05 LBV 296 2
10 * 9 Gem s*b 06 16 58.7058631680 +23 44 27.284070336 6.31 6.70 6.25 5.78 5.38 B3Iab 253 0
11 HD 50896 WR* 06 54 13.0439608392 -23 55 42.023319852 5.74 6.63 6.91 7.74   WN4b 794 0
12 V* VY CMa s*r 07 22 58.3261352189 -25 46 03.194390594 12.01 10.068 8.691 7.938   M5Iae 1169 0
13 * J Pup s*b 07 53 18.1574768969 -48 06 10.566474468 3.11 4.10 4.24 4.26 4.38 B0.5Ib 249 0
14 HD 92207 sg* 10 37 27.0681291600 -58 44 00.016141092 5.71 5.95 5.45     A0Ia 158 0
15 * eta Car s*b 10 45 03.545808 -59 41 03.95124 6.37 7.03 6.48 6.123 4.41 LBV 2543 0
16 V* AG Car WR* 10 56 11.5781414448 -60 27 12.810673260 7.00 7.57 6.96 7.73   WN11h 649 0
17 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 55 s*b 16 46 58.4205093840 -45 51 31.294157724   21.6 18.030 15.283 12.758 B0Ia 19 0
18 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 2 s*b 16 46 59.7175806088 -45 50 51.190946043   20.4 16.978 14.287 11.771 B2Ia 20 0
19 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 21 s*b 16 47 01.1124528826 -45 51 13.583454380   22.5 18.41 15.619 12.861 B0.5Ia 13 0
20 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 57 s*b 16 47 01.3600091808 -45 51 45.804003408   20.7 16.877 13.83 11.13 B4Ia 22 0
21 Cl* Westerlund 1 BKS H s*y 16 47 01.4269856784 -45 50 37.248841536   18.781 14.47 11.80 9.15 F3Ia+ 31 0
22 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 78 s*b 16 47 01.5500127120 -45 49 57.922981500   21.0 17.413 14.621 12.04 B1Ia 14 0
23 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 24 s*b 16 47 02.1561069816 -45 51 12.581922276   23.0 18.71 15.96 13.24 O9Iab 22 0
24 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 12 s*y 16 47 02.2214295629 -45 50 58.987616665   22.0 17.575 13.611 10.42 A5Ia+ 27 0
25 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 11 s*b 16 47 02.2390158456 -45 50 47.186514564   21.2 17.508 14.599 11.898 B2Ia 19 0
26 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 61a s*b 16 47 02.2999985640 -45 51 41.772039336   21.2 17.506 14.633 12.01 B0.5Ia 18 0
27 Cl Westerlund 1 OpC 16 47 02.4 -45 51 07           ~ 655 1
28 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 61b s*b 16 47 02.5662082776 -45 51 41.864431536   22.7 18.59 16.00 13.31 O9.5Iab 20 0
29 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 23a s*b 16 47 02.5776330614 -45 51 08.902293204   22.1 18.316 14.986 12.081 B2Ia+B:I? 20 0
30 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 41 s*b 16 47 02.7105467198 -45 50 56.972033345   21.3 17.87 15.39 12.78 O9Iab 18 0
31 WR 77f WR* 16 47 02.9772955944 -45 50 19.713734556   21.552 17.792 15.035 12.508 WNL/BIa+ 38 0
32 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 6a s*b 16 47 03.0477797919 -45 50 23.748131606   22.2 18.41 15.80 13.16 B0.5Iab 21 0
33 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 237 s*r 16 47 03.1097130192 -45 52 18.960733164   22.8 19.008 13.634 9.19 M3I 32 0
34 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 42 s*b 16 47 03.2521856424 -45 50 52.195013052         10.764 B9Ia+ 21 0
35 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 10 s*b 16 47 03.3405625992 -45 50 34.603317456   22.720 18.516 15.257   O9.5/B0.5Iae 20 0
36 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 43a s*b 16 47 03.5568442836 -45 50 57.728053296   22.8 18.05 15.22 12.26 B0Ia 14 0
37 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 7 s*b 16 47 03.6281794392 -45 50 14.365482036   20.0 15.972 12.73 9.99 B5Ia+ 31 0
38 Cl* Westerlund 1 BKS F s*y 16 47 03.6850109472 -45 50 43.536110712     15.05     F5Ia+ 23 0
39 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 30 ** 16 47 04.1126936513 -45 50 39.164057275   22.4 18.45 15.80 13.20 O4-5Ia+ 25 0
40 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 33 s*b 16 47 04.1256274968 -45 50 48.488202564   20.090 15.61 12.803 10.04 B5Ia+ 26 0
41 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 60 s*b 16 47 04.1335644720 -45 51 52.259535324   22.8 18.50 16.041 13.384 B0Iab 20 0
42 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 9 WR* 16 47 04.1419806984 -45 50 31.311670632   21.8 17.47 14.47 11.74 sgB[e] 56 0
43 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 35 s*b 16 47 04.2023052264 -45 50 53.727473868   22.7 18.59 16.00 13.31 O9Iab 16 0
44 WR 77k WR* 16 47 04.2072122904 -45 51 07.177760892   22.6 18.86 15.61 12.52 WN7 29 0
45 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 29 s*b 16 47 04.4118843432 -45 50 39.933732768   22.6 18.66 16.02 13.38 O9.5/B0.5Ia 14 0
46 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 238 s*b 16 47 04.4263582176 -45 52 27.788277972   21.4 17.820 14.98 12.45 B1Iab 18 0
47 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 28 s*b 16 47 04.6646286552 -45 50 38.503394520   20.9 17.146 14.303 11.64 B2Ia 17 0
48 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 20 s*r 16 47 04.6967287296 -45 51 23.953706496       15.660   M6I 28 0
49 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 8 s*y 16 47 04.7959778348 -45 50 25.013789709   19.9 15.913 12.64 9.89 F8Ia+ 23 0
50 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 19 s*b 16 47 04.8672458112 -45 50 59.295902136   22.6 18.784 15.366 12.452 B1Ia 19 0
51 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 8b s*b 16 47 04.95 -45 50 26.7           B1.5Ia 10 0
52 Cl* Westerlund 1 CN F WR* 16 47 05.2114579896 -45 52 24.985725096   21.7 17.86 15.39 12.90 WC9d 33 0
53 2MASS J16470540-4550367 s*r 16 47 05.4076906176 -45 50 36.617071668   22.1 16.79 12.63 9.19 M2-5Ia 40 0
54 Cl* Westerlund 1 CN E WR* 16 47 06.0667110144 -45 52 08.266249200     18.379 15.675 12.940 WC9 25 0
55 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 265 s*y 16 47 06.2785465416 -45 49 23.774098692   22.0 17.739 13.62 10.54 F1-5Ia+ 27 0
56 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 13 WR* 16 47 06.4540771320 -45 50 26.072579796   21.1 17.19 14.63 12.06 WNL/BIa+ 40 0
57 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 16 sg* 16 47 06.6158603112 -45 50 42.186706944   20.5 16.248 12.82 9.90 A5Ia+ 29 0
58 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 15 * 16 47 06.6306037464 -45 50 29.723762580   22.8 18.96 16.38 13.75 O9Ib 29 0
59 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 74 s*b 16 47 07.0783996992 -45 50 13.086504168       15.835 13.312 O9.5Iab 17 0
60 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 243 s*b 16 47 07.5040736160 -45 52 29.123491188   19.873 15.730     LBV 67 0
61 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 71 s*b 16 47 08.4584673360 -45 50 49.338181284   21.5 17.531 14.158 11.16 B2.5Ia 24 0
62 2MASS J16470892-4549585 s*r 16 47 08.9198319768 -45 49 58.452357324     16.70     M4Ia 29 0
63 Cl* Westerlund 1 W 70 s*b 16 47 09.3836656992 -45 50 49.668960804   21.2 16.88 14.10 11.352 B3Ia 19 0
64 * zet01 Sco s*b 16 53 59.7271314888 -42 21 43.307334468 4.80 5.31 4.79 4.32 3.86 B1.5Ia+ 390 0
65 HD 160529 s*b 17 41 59.0261939376 -33 30 13.704456780 8.17 7.87 6.66 5.50 4.51 B8-A9Ia+ 203 1
66 NAME Galactic Center reg 17 45 39.60213 -29 00 22.0000           ~ 16269 0
67 GCIRS 34W WR* 17 45 39.73 -29 00 26.6           Ofpe/WN9 63 0
68 GCIRS 16NW WR* 17 45 40.0451 -29 00 26.847           Ofpe/WN9 144 0
69 GCIRS 16SW WR* 17 45 40.1245 -29 00 29.018           Ofpe/WN9 167 0
70 NAME Quintuplet Cluster OpC 17 46 13.9 -28 49 48           ~ 561 0
71 [FMM95] 3 s*b 17 46 15.240 -28 50 03.58           LBV 151 1
72 [GMC99] D6 s*b 17 46 17.982 -28 49 03.46           LBV 66 0
73 V* VX Sgr s*r 18 08 04.0442790744 -22 13 26.600899044 11.72 9.41 6.52 3.90 2.11 M8.5Ia 622 0
74 HD 179821 pA* 19 13 58.6082398776 +00 07 31.935181836 10.81 9.694 8.19     G4_0-Ia 247 0
75 IRC +10420 pA* 19 26 48.0979492536 +11 21 16.758531216   13.98 11.66     F8Ia+e 492 0
76 Schulte 12 s*b 20 32 40.9572199728 +41 14 29.279036940 16.1 14.45 11.702     B3-4Ia+ 453 0
77 HD 199478 s*b 20 55 49.8039729168 +47 25 03.564093468 5.79 6.12 5.64 5.16 4.78 B7Ia 231 0
78 V* V509 Cas LP* 23 00 05.1012218544 +56 56 43.350876312 8.01 6.68 5.13 3.96 3.11 G4_0 339 0
79 * rho Cas LP* 23 54 23.0325302520 +57 29 57.774737400 7.00 5.85 4.59 3.63 2.89 G2_0 401 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2010A&A...514A..87C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu