2010ApJ...715..310R


Query : 2010ApJ...715..310R

2010ApJ...715..310R - Astrophys. J., 715, 310-322 (2010/May-3)

The early stages of star formation in infrared dark clouds: characterizing the core dust properties.

RATHBORNE J.M., JACKSON J.M., CHAMBERS E.T., STOJIMIROVIC I., SIMON R., SHIPMAN R. and FRIESWIJK W.

Abstract (from CDS):

Identified as extinction features against the bright Galactic mid-infrared background, infrared dark clouds (IRDCs) are thought to harbor the very earliest stages of star and cluster formation. In order to better characterize the properties of their embedded cores, we have obtained new 24 µm, 60-100 µm, and submillimeter continuum data toward a sample of 38 IRDCs. The 24 µm Spitzer images reveal that while the IRDCs remain dark, many of the cores are associated with bright 24 µm emission sources, which suggests that they contain one or more embedded protostars. Combining the 24 µm, 60-100 µm, and submillimeter continuum data, we have constructed broadband spectral energy distributions (SEDs) for 157 of the cores within these IRDCs and, using simple graybody fits to the SEDs, have estimated their dust temperatures, emissivities, opacities, bolometric luminosities, masses, and densities. Based on their Spitzer/Infrared Array Camera 3-8 µm colors and the presence of 24 µm point-source emission, we have separated cores that harbor active, high-mass star formation from cores that are quiescent. The active "protostellar" cores typically have warmer dust temperatures and higher bolometric luminosities than the more quiescent, perhaps "pre-protostellar," cores. Because the mass distributions of the populations are similar, however, we speculate that the active and quiescent cores may represent different evolutionary stages of the same underlying population of cores. Although we cannot rule out low-mass star formation in the quiescent cores, the most massive of them are excellent candidates for the "high-mass starless core" phase, the very earliest in the formation of a high-mass star.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): dust, extinction - infrared: stars - stars: formation - submillimeter: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/715/310): table2.dat table3.dat table4.dat>

Simbad objects: 194

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 194
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.05+00.07 MM4 mm 18 17 32.0 -15 46 35           ~ 4 0
2 [VVH2014] IRDC G015.05-2 cor 18 17 40.0 -15 48 55           ~ 5 0
3 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.05+00.07 MM5 mm 18 17 40.2 -15 49 47           ~ 4 0
4 MSXDC G015.05+00.07 DNe 18 17 41.8 -15 49 39           ~ 4 0
5 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.05+00.07 MM3 mm 18 17 42.4 -15 47 03           ~ 4 0
6 [TBH2012] 574 cor 18 17 50.0242 -15 53 41.725           ~ 20 0
7 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.31-00.16 MM3 mm 18 18 45.3 -15 41 58           ~ 10 0
8 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.31-00.16 MM4 mm 18 18 48.0 -15 44 22           ~ 4 0
9 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.31-00.16 MM5 mm 18 18 49.1 -15 42 47           ~ 4 0
10 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.31-00.16 MM2 mm 18 18 50.4 -15 43 19           ~ 5 0
11 [RJS2006] MSXDC G015.31-00.16 MM1 mm 18 18 56.4 -15 45 00           ~ 4 0
12 AGAL G019.286+00.082 Y*O 18 25 52.11528 -12 04 49.8900           ~ 30 0
13 BGPSv2 G018.702-00.228 smm 18 25 52.6 -12 44 37           ~ 8 0
14 [CUS2014] G018.7344-0.2261 cor 18 25 56 -12 42.8           ~ 34 0
15 [RJS2006] MSXDC G019.27+00.07 MM1 MoC 18 25 58.29 -12 04 13.5           ~ 17 0
16 [RJS2006] MSXDC G018.82-00.28 MM4 MoC 18 26 15.14 -12 41 43.4           ~ 12 0
17 [RJS2006] MSXDC G018.82-00.28 MM6 MoC 18 26 19.04 -12 41 14.8           ~ 11 0
18 [RJS2006] MSXDC G018.82-00.28 MM5 MoC 18 26 21.78 -12 41 10.2           ~ 10 0
19 BGPS G018.834-00.299 cor 18 26 23.4 -12 39 37           ~ 16 0
20 AGAL G022.376+00.447 Y*O 18 30 24 -09 10.6           ~ 47 0
21 [RJS2006] MSXDC G022.35+00.41 MM2 mm 18 30 24.2 -09 12 44           ~ 5 0
22 [RJS2006] MSXDC G022.35+00.41 MM3 mm 18 30 38.1 -09 12 44           ~ 6 0
23 [RJS2006] MSXDC G022.73+00.11 MM1 mm 18 32 13.0 -09 00 50           ~ 5 0
24 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM5 mm 18 34 09.5 -08 18 00           ~ 6 0
25 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM3 mm 18 34 10.0 -08 18 28           ~ 7 0
26 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM1 mm 18 34 11.6 -08 19 06           ~ 14 0
27 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM6 mm 18 34 18.2 -08 18 52           ~ 6 0
28 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM2 mm 18 34 21.1 -08 18 07           ~ 13 0
29 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM7 mm 18 34 21.1 -08 17 11           ~ 8 0
30 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM9 mm 18 34 22.5 -08 16 04           ~ 4 0
31 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM4 mm 18 34 23.0 -08 18 21           ~ 7 0
32 [RJS2006] MSXDC G023.60+00.00 MM8 mm 18 34 24.9 -08 17 14           ~ 3 0
33 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.08+00.04 MM2 mm 18 34 51.1 -07 45 32           ~ 9 0
34 BGPSv2 G024.185+00.121 smm 18 34 57.0 -07 43 26           ~ 8 0
35 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.08+00.04 MM3 mm 18 35 02.2 -07 45 25           ~ 7 0
36 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.08+00.04 MM4 mm 18 35 02.6 -07 45 56           ~ 7 0
37 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM11 mm 18 35 05.1 -07 35 58           ~ 6 0
38 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.08+00.04 MM5 mm 18 35 07.4 -07 45 46           ~ 4 0
39 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM6 mm 18 35 07.7 -07 34 33           ~ 7 0
40 IRAS 18324-0737 mm 18 35 08.1 -07 35 04           ~ 23 0
41 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM7 mm 18 35 09.8 -07 39 48           ~ 5 0
42 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM4 mm 18 35 19.4 -07 37 17           ~ 11 0
43 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM8 mm 18 35 23.4 -07 37 21           ~ 6 0
44 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM9 mm 18 35 26.5 -07 36 56           ~ 6 0
45 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM3 mm 18 35 27.9 -07 36 18           ~ 6 0
46 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM10 mm 18 35 27.9 -07 35 32           ~ 5 0
47 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM5 mm 18 35 33.8 -07 36 42           ~ 7 0
48 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.33+00.11 MM2 mm 18 35 34.5 -07 37 28           ~ 9 0
49 AGAL G024.629+00.172 Y*O 18 35 35.6 -07 18 12           ~ 40 0
50 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.60+00.08 MM4 mm 18 35 39.3 -07 18 51           ~ 4 0
51 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.60+00.08 MM1 mm 18 35 40.2 -07 18 37           ~ 15 0
52 [RJS2006] MSXDC G024.60+00.08 MM3 mm 18 35 41.1 -07 18 30           ~ 6 0
53 MSXDC G025.04-00.20 DNe 18 37 26.6 -07 09 14           ~ 8 0
54 [RJS2006] MSXDC G025.04-00.20 MM3 mm 18 38 10.2 -07 02 44           ~ 6 0
55 [RJS2006] MSXDC G025.04-00.20 MM1 mm 18 38 10.2 -07 02 34           ~ 10 0
56 [RJS2006] MSXDC G025.04-00.20 MM5 mm 18 38 12.0 -07 02 44           ~ 4 0
57 [RJS2006] MSXDC G025.04-00.20 MM4 mm 18 38 13.7 -07 03 12           ~ 7 0
58 [RJS2006] MSXDC G025.04-00.20 MM2 mm 18 38 17.7 -07 02 51           ~ 7 0
59 [RJS2006] MSXDC G027.75+00.16 MM3 mm 18 41 16.8 -04 31 55           ~ 4 0
60 AGAL G027.741+00.172 cor 18 41 19.9 -04 32 20           ~ 17 0
61 [RJS2006] MSXDC G027.75+00.16 MM5 mm 18 41 23.6 -04 30 42           ~ 4 0
62 BGPS G027.797+00.152 smm 18 41 30.4 -04 30 00           ~ 10 0
63 AGAL G027.746+00.116 Y*O 18 41 33.0 -04 33 44           ~ 17 0
64 AGAL G028.089+00.071 smm 18 42 20.3 -04 16 42           ~ 12 0
65 AGAL G028.324+00.161 cor 18 42 26.8 -04 01 30           ~ 23 0
66 AGAL G028.341+00.142 cor 18 42 32.4 -04 01 16           ~ 20 0
67 IRAS 18399-0405 Y*O 18 42 37.12488 -04 02 02.2020           ~ 33 0
68 AGAL G028.364+00.121 cor 18 42 40.01 -04 00 34.4           ~ 31 0
69 AGAL G028.418+00.141 Y*O 18 42 41.8 -03 57 08           ~ 16 0
70 AGAL G028.354+00.102 Y*O 18 42 44.02 -04 01 54.5           ~ 29 0
71 AGAL G028.324+00.067 Y*O 18 42 46.7 -04 04 08           ~ 59 0
72 AGAL G028.354+00.072 MoC 18 42 49.34 -04 02 27.3           ~ 37 0
73 AGAL G028.244+00.012 smm 18 42 49.7 -04 09 54           ~ 27 0
74 AGAL G028.344+00.061 cor 18 42 50.45 -04 03 17.7           ~ 93 0
75 AGAL G028.398+00.081 cor 18 42 51.86 -03 59 43.3           ~ 60 0
76 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.37+00.07 MM14 MoC 18 42 52.59 -04 02 44.3           ~ 20 0
77 AGAL G028.361+00.054 cor 18 42 54.37 -04 02 31.7           ~ 36 1
78 AGAL G028.291+00.007 cor 18 42 56.3 -04 07 31           ~ 26 0
79 AGAL G028.581+00.146 cor 18 42 58.2 -03 48 20           ~ 20 0
80 AGAL G028.388+00.037 MoC 18 42 59.99 -04 01 33.1           ~ 29 0
81 AGAL G028.321-00.009 smm 18 43 03.1 -04 06 24           ~ 25 0
82 AGAL G028.687+00.177 cor 18 43 03.1 -03 41 41           ~ 21 0
83 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.67+00.13 MM7 MoC 18 43 06.71 -03 45 09.9           ~ 9 0
84 AGAL G028.658+00.144 Y*? 18 43 07.05096 -03 44 06.7380           ~ 26 0
85 SDC G28.660+0.142 DNe 18 43 07.75 -03 44 08.4           ~ 7 0
86 [BT2009] C14 mm 18 43 09.9 -04 06 52           ~ 9 0
87 JCMTLSP J184310.2-034518 MoC 18 43 10.12 -03 45 15.8           ~ 12 0
88 [BT2009] E6 mm 18 43 12.2 -03 45 39           ~ 6 0
89 AGAL G028.416-00.007 Y*O 18 43 12.9 -04 01 16           ~ 15 0
90 AGAL G028.717+00.146 smm 18 43 13.2 -03 41 03           ~ 10 0
91 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.23-00.19 MM2 mm 18 43 29.0 -04 12 16           ~ 4 0
92 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.23-00.19 MM3 mm 18 43 30.0 -04 12 33           ~ 6 0
93 AGAL G028.273-00.167 MoC 18 43 30.7 -04 13 12           ~ 39 0
94 AGAL G027.974-00.421 cor 18 43 52.8 -04 36 13           ~ 24 0
95 JCMTLSP J184355.3-043616 mm 18 43 54.9 -04 36 08           ~ 6 0
96 AGAL G028.011-00.426 MoC 18 43 58.4077 -04 34 25.837           ~ 19 0
97 [RJS2006] MSXDC G027.94-00.47 MM2 mm 18 44 03.1 -04 37 25           ~ 3 0
98 AGAL G027.968-00.474 cor 18 44 03.6 -04 38 00           ~ 19 0
99 AGAL G028.048-00.456 cor 18 44 08.5 -04 33 22           ~ 19 1
100 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.28-00.34 MM4 mm 18 44 11.4 -04 17 22           ~ 4 0
101 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.10-00.45 MM1 mm 18 44 12.9 -04 29 45           ~ 4 0
102 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.28-00.34 MM3 mm 18 44 13.4 -04 18 05           ~ 5 0
103 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.10-00.45 MM2 mm 18 44 14.3 -04 29 48           ~ 4 0
104 AGAL G028.288-00.362 cor 18 44 15.0 -04 17 54           ~ 26 0
105 AGAL G028.541-00.237 Y*O 18 44 15.38 -04 00 50.7           ~ 25 0
106 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.53-00.25 MM2 MoC 18 44 16.43 -03 59 22.3           ~ 15 0
107 AGAL G028.526-00.251 Y*O 18 44 17.05 -04 02 01.5           ~ 33 0
108 MSXDC G028.53-00.25 DNe 18 44 17.1 -03 59 37           ~ 24 0
109 AGAL G028.564-00.236 cor 18 44 17.69 -03 59 26.5           ~ 53 0
110 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.53-00.25 MM4 MoC 18 44 17.78 -04 00 12.4           ~ 14 0
111 [BT2009] D10 mm 18 44 17.8 -04 00 05           ~ 9 0
112 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.53-00.25 MM10 MoC 18 44 18.29 -03 59 06.2           ~ 10 0
113 JCMTLSP J184419.4-035806 MoC 18 44 18.74 -03 58 13.7           ~ 14 0
114 [RJS2006] MSXDC G028.53-00.25 MM8 MoC 18 44 22.51 -04 01 53.5           ~ 10 0
115 AGAL G028.539-00.269 MoC 18 44 23.79 -04 02 11.5           ~ 17 0
116 AGAL G028.301-00.382 MoC 18 44 25.2113 -04 17 38.596           ~ 21 0
117 AGAL G030.106-00.067 cor 18 46 31.7 -02 32 41           ~ 16 0
118 [RJS2006] MSXDC G030.14-00.06 MM1 mm 18 46 35.7 -02 31 03           ~ 4 0
119 AGAL G030.583-00.211 cor 18 47 54.700 -02 11 10.72           ~ 19 0
120 AGAL G030.529-00.259 cor 18 47 58.7 -02 15 20           ~ 17 0
121 [RJS2006] MSXDC G030.57-00.23 MM6 mm 18 47 59.4 -02 13 13           ~ 3 0
122 BGPS G030.596-00.229 mm 18 47 59.9 -02 11 01           ~ 10 0
123 AGAL G030.651-00.204 Y*O 18 48 00.0 -02 07 20           ~ 21 0
124 AGAL G030.578-00.252 smm 18 48 01.8 -02 12 35           ~ 18 0
125 AGAL G031.024-00.112 cor 18 48 20.7 -01 44 48           ~ 18 0
126 AGAL G030.971-00.141 cor 18 48 22.0 -01 48 29           ~ 43 1
127 [RJS2006] MSXDC G030.97-00.14 MM2 mm 18 48 22.0 -01 47 42           ~ 5 0
128 AGAL G031.946+00.076 cor 18 49 21.9 -00 50 35           ~ 23 0
129 AGAL G031.982+00.064 cor 18 49 28.4 -00 48 54           ~ 18 0
130 JCMTSE J184929.3-004808 smm 18 49 29.1 -00 48 12           ~ 9 0
131 [RJS2006] MSXDC G031.97+00.07 MM9 mm 18 49 31.6 -00 46 30           ~ 7 0
132 AGAL G032.019+00.064 Y*O 18 49 32.3 -00 47 02           ~ 16 0
133 JCMTLSP J184933.3-004734 cor 18 49 33.0 -00 47 33           ~ 9 0
134 JCMTLSP J184934.6-004643 cor 18 49 35.0 -00 46 44           ~ 9 0
135 JCMTLSP J184936.4-004617 cor 18 49 36.0 -00 46 16           ~ 8 0
136 AGAL G032.044+00.059 cor 18 49 36.6 -00 45 49           ~ 48 0
137 AGAL G033.633-00.022 smm 18 52 47.8 +00 36 47           ~ 21 0
138 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM6 mm 18 52 48.7 +00 35 58           ~ 4 0
139 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM2 mm 18 52 49.9 +00 37 57           ~ 5 0
140 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM3 mm 18 52 50.8 +00 36 43           ~ 5 0
141 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM10 mm 18 52 52.7 +00 38 35           ~ 4 0
142 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM8 mm 18 52 53.9 +00 41 16           ~ 6 0
143 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM11 mm 18 52 56.2 +00 41 48           ~ 6 0
144 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM4 mm 18 52 56.4 +00 43 08           ~ 8 0
145 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM9 mm 18 52 58.1 +00 41 20           ~ 5 0
146 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM7 mm 18 52 58.1 +00 44 08           ~ 4 0
147 [RJS2006] MSXDC G033.69-00.01 MM1 mm 18 52 58.8 +00 42 37           ~ 6 0
148 [RJS2006] MSXDC G034.43+00.24 MM8 mm 18 53 16.4 +01 26 20           ~ 35 0
149 AGAL G034.411+00.234 Y*O 18 53 18.0319 +01 25 25.500           ~ 108 0
150 [RJS2006] MSXDC G034.43+00.24 MM7 mm 18 53 18.3 +01 27 13           ~ 37 0
151 [ZYL2017] G34-6 MoC 18 53 18.42 +01 27 33.9           ~ 22 0
152 [ZYL2017] G34-9 MoC 18 53 18.51 +01 28 30.5           ~ 31 0
153 AGAL G034.401+00.226 cor 18 53 18.6 +01 24 40           ~ 74 1
154 [BT2009] F6 mm 18 53 19.0 +01 24 08           ~ 31 0
155 [RJS2006] MSXDC G034.43+00.24 MM5 mm 18 53 19.8 +01 23 30           ~ 17 0
156 AGAL G034.459+00.247 Y*O 18 53 20.4 +01 28 23           ~ 71 0
157 [BT2009] H9 mm 18 56 41.2 +02 09 52           ~ 6 0
158 [BT2009] G1 mm 18 56 44.7 +01 20 42           ~ 9 0
159 IRAS 18542+0114 cor 18 56 48.27432 +01 18 47.1132           ~ 37 0
160 [BT2009] G3 mm 18 56 48.9 +01 23 34           ~ 10 0
161 [BT2009] G2 mm 18 56 50.3 +01 23 16           ~ 33 0
162 [BT2009] H7 mm 18 56 59.2 +02 04 53           ~ 9 0
163 [RJS2006] MSXDC G035.59-00.24 MM1 mm 18 57 02.3 +02 17 04           ~ 4 0
164 AGAL G035.452-00.296 Y*O 18 57 05.178 +02 06 30.26           ~ 26 0
165 [ZYL2017] G35-8 MoC 18 57 06.88 +02 08 44.8           ~ 14 0
166 [ZYL2017] G35-4 MoC 18 57 06.92 +02 08 20.9           ~ 15 0
167 [RJS2006] MSXDC G035.59-00.24 MM2 mm 18 57 07.4 +02 16 14           ~ 6 0
168 [ZYL2017] G35-7 MoC 18 57 08.17 +02 10 51.8           ~ 22 0
169 [ZYL2017] G35-6 MoC 18 57 08.27 +02 08 57.7           ~ 16 0
170 [ZYL2017] G35-5 MoC 18 57 08.83 +02 08 24.3           ~ 15 0
171 [ZYL2017] G35-9 MoC 18 57 11.37 +02 07 27.1           ~ 10 0
172 [RJS2006] MSXDC G035.59-00.24 MM3 mm 18 57 11.6 +02 16 08           ~ 5 0
173 [RJS2006] MSXDC G036.67-00.11 MM2 mm 18 58 35.6 +03 15 06           ~ 4 0
174 MSXDC G036.67-00.11 a mm 18 58 39.6 +03 16 16           ~ 4 0
175 [RJS2006] MSXDC G038.95-00.47 MM4 mm 19 04 00.6 +05 09 06           ~ 8 0
176 JCMTSE J190403.4+050756 smm 19 04 03.4 +05 07 56           ~ 16 0
177 AGAL G038.957-00.466 Y*O 19 04 07.4 +05 08 48           ~ 24 0
178 [RJS2006] MSXDC G038.95-00.47 MM3 mm 19 04 07.4 +05 09 44           ~ 10 0
179 [RJS2006] MSXDC G048.65-00.29 MM2 mm 19 21 47.6 +13 49 22           ~ 5 0
180 [RJS2006] MSXDC G048.65-00.29 MM1 mm 19 21 49.7 +13 49 30           ~ 5 0
181 [BT2009] J2 mm 19 29 00.6 +17 55 11           ~ 5 0
182 AGAL G053.141+00.069 cor 19 29 17.50 +17 56 24.0           ~ 33 1
183 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.11+00.05 MM2 mm 19 29 20.2 +17 57 06           ~ 12 0
184 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.11+00.05 MM4 mm 19 29 20.4 +17 55 04           ~ 8 0
185 [BT2009] J3 mm 19 29 26.3 +17 54 53           ~ 6 0
186 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.25+00.04 MM6 mm 19 29 31.5 +17 59 50           ~ 7 0
187 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.25+00.04 MM2 mm 19 29 33.0 +18 01 00           ~ 8 0
188 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.25+00.04 MM4 mm 19 29 34.5 +18 01 39           ~ 8 0
189 AGAL G053.259+00.039 Y*O 19 29 39.0 +18 01 42           ~ 16 0
190 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.25+00.04 MM5 mm 19 29 39.4 +17 58 40           ~ 4 0
191 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.31+00.00 MM2 mm 19 29 42.1 +18 03 57           ~ 5 0
192 HIGALBM G053.2270-00.0023 smm 19 29 44.0 +17 58 47           ~ 5 0
193 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.31+00.00 MM3 mm 19 29 49.7 +18 04 39           ~ 4 0
194 [RJS2006] MSXDC G053.31+00.00 MM1 mm 19 29 50.0 +18 05 07           ~ 4 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2010ApJ...715..310R and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu