2010ApJ...724..714H


Query : 2010ApJ...724..714H

2010ApJ...724..714H - Astrophys. J., 724, 714-729 (2010/November-3)

M/LB and color evolution for a deep sample of M* cluster galaxies at z ∼ 1: the formation epoch and the tilt of the fundamental plane.

HOLDEN B.P., VAN DER WEL A., KELSON D.D., FRANX M. and ILLINGWORTH G.D.

Abstract (from CDS):

We have measured velocity dispersions (σ) for a sample of 36 galaxies with J < 21.2 or Mr< -20.6 mag in MS 1054-03, a massive cluster of galaxies at z = 0.83. Our data are of uniformly high quality down to our selection limit, our 16 hr exposures typically yielding errors of only δ(σ) ∼ 10% for L* and fainter galaxies. By combining our measurements with data from the literature, we have 53 cluster galaxies with measured dispersions, and HST/ACS-derived sizes, colors and surface brightness. This sample is complete for the typical L {sstarf} galaxy at z ∼ 1, unlike most previous z ∼ 1 cluster samples which are complete only for the massive cluster members (>1011 M☉). We find no evidence for a change in the tilt of the fundamental plane (FP). Nor do we find evidence for evolution in the slope of the color-σ relation and M/LB-σ relations; measuring evolution at a fixed σ should minimize the impact of structural evolution found in other work. The M/LB at fixed σ evolves by Δlog10M/LB = -0.50±0.03 between z = 0.83 and z = 0.02 or dlog10M/LB= -0.60 ± 0.04 dz, and we find Δ(U - V)z= -0.24±0.02 mag at fixed σ in the rest frame, matching the expected evolution in M/LB within 2.25 standard deviations. The implied formation redshift from both the color and M/LB evolution is z{sstarf}= 2.0±0.2±0.3(sys), during the epoch in which the cosmic star formation activity peaked, with the systematic uncertainty showing the dependence of z{sstarf} on the assumptions we make about the stellar populations. The lack of evolution in either the tilt of the FP or in the M/L-σ and color-σ relations imply that the formation epoch depends weakly on mass, ranging from z{sstarf}= 2.3+1.3–0.3 at σ = 300 km/s to z{sstarf}= 1.7+0.3–0.2 at σ = 160 km/s and implies that the initial mass function similarly varies slowly with galaxy mass.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: clusters: general - galaxies: clusters: individual: EMSS 1054.4-0321 - galaxies: elliptical and lenticular, cD - galaxies: evolution - galaxies: fundamental parameters - galaxies: photometry

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/724/714): tablea1.dat tablea2.dat>

Status at CDS : All or part of tables of objects will not be ingested in SIMBAD.

Simbad objects: 106

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 106
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 ClG J0152-1358 ClG 01 52 41.3 -13 58 13           ~ 262 3
2 [BVF2002] 6301 G 10 56 55.2 -03 37 12           ~ 4 0
3 [BVF2002] 6036 GiP 10 56 55.7 -03 38 06           ~ 5 1
4 [BVF2002] 5666 G 10 56 56.0 -03 39 01           ~ 5 0
5 [BVF2002] 5840 GiP 10 56 56.4 -03 37 14           ~ 4 1
6 [BVF2002] 5450 G 10 56 56.8 -03 37 41           ~ 5 0
7 [BVF2002] 5577 GiP 10 56 57.0 -03 36 49           ~ 5 0
8 [BVF2002] 5347 GiP 10 56 57.6 -03 36 41           ~ 6 1
9 [BVF2002] 5298 GiP 10 56 58.4 -03 37 18           ~ 5 0
10 [BVF2002] 5280 GiP 10 56 58.5 -03 37 16           ~ 5 0
11 [BVF2002] 4926 G 10 56 59.6 -03 37 41           ~ 5 0
12 [BVF2002] C1 GiC 10 56 59.66 -03 37 27.8           ~ 12 0
13 [DVG98] 1 BiC 10 56 59.976 -03 37 35.85       19.86   ~ 18 0
14 ClG 1054-03 ClG 10 57 00.2 -03 37 27     22     ~ 458 0
15 [BVF2002] 4345 G 10 57 01.3 -03 37 51           ~ 5 0
16 [BVF2002] 3910 G 10 57 02.0 -03 37 49           ~ 5 0
17 [BVF2002] 3768 G 10 57 02.5 -03 37 38           ~ 5 0
18 [BVF2002] C3 rG 10 57 02.60 -03 37 05.0           ~ 11 0
19 [BVF2002] 3058 G 10 57 03.4 -03 37 47           ~ 5 0
20 [BVF2002] C12 rG 10 57 04.05 -03 35 58.5           ~ 10 0
21 [BVF2002] 2409 G 10 57 05.5 -03 38 01           ~ 5 0
22 [BVF2002] 1649 G 10 57 08.1 -03 37 54           ~ 5 0
23 [BVF2002] 1192 G 10 57 09.0 -03 38 36           ~ 2 0
24 Z 160-37 GiG 12 57 09.4184229096 +27 27 59.137216200   15.0       ~ 84 0
25 NGC 4839 BiC 12 57 24.3563164776 +27 29 52.203087132 13.56 13.02 12.06     ~ 482 3
26 NGC 4841 LIN 12 57 31.978 +28 28 36.86   13.5       ~ 154 0
27 NGC 4840 LIN 12 57 32.8380921120 +27 36 37.243946592   14.8       ~ 115 0
28 NGC 4841B LIN 12 57 33.8858810016 +28 28 56.223469956   13.5       ~ 90 0
29 Z 160-49 GiG 12 57 48.6632127528 +28 10 49.480506876   15.5       ~ 78 0
30 2MASX J12575392+2829594 GiC 12 57 53.9421825408 +28 29 59.362304424   15       ~ 46 0
31 NGC 4850 AGN 12 58 21.8338490568 +27 58 04.024808724 15.43 15.3 14.03     ~ 101 0
32 Z 160-65 GiG 12 58 30.2081987472 +28 00 53.079578820 15.30 15.0 13.88     ~ 96 0
33 NGC 4854 GiG 12 58 47.4113103480 +27 40 29.084942676 15.66 15.2 13.83 13.48   ~ 104 0
34 2MASX J12585077+2805019 GiC 12 58 50.7702779928 +28 05 02.470669440 16.69 16.778 15.34 15.269 14.601 ~ 54 0
35 IC 3947 AG? 12 58 52.1045260536 +27 47 06.266103540 16.00 15.866 14.61 14.341 13.633 ~ 93 0
36 2MASX J12585523+2757529 GiC 12 58 55.2555720768 +27 57 52.976652984 16.78 16.505 15.39 15.01 14.264 ~ 82 0
37 2MASX J12590006+2758029 GiC 12 59 00.0748454616 +27 58 02.956799568 17.27 17.216 15.80 15.55 15.032 ~ 73 0
38 NGC 4860 GiG 12 59 03.9057463440 +28 07 25.326557148 14.84 14.7 13.24     ~ 157 0
39 IC 3955 GiC 12 59 06.0295581048 +27 59 48.152325300 15.78 15.591 14.31 14.011 13.323 ~ 98 0
40 IC 3957 GiC 12 59 07.5004634112 +27 46 04.045220580 16.15 15.862 14.72 14.332 13.683 ~ 113 0
41 IC 3960 AGN 12 59 07.9458606024 +27 51 17.892495432 15.96 15.5 14.47 14.233 13.516 ~ 103 1
42 IC 3959 GiG 12 59 08.2121809416 +27 47 02.945321736 15.56 15.2 14.03 13.771 13.064 ~ 143 0
43 NGC 4864 GiG 12 59 13.129 +27 58 36.91 15.338 14.8 13.872 13.321 12.594 ~ 136 0
44 IC 3963 GiC 12 59 13.5007965936 +27 46 28.624729584 16.11 15.837 14.72 14.33 13.71 ~ 91 0
45 NGC 4867 GiG 12 59 15.2505719952 +27 58 14.616353712 15.60 15.5 14.14 13.969 13.213 ~ 129 0
46 NGC 4865 EmG 12 59 19.8737739096 +28 05 03.488821044 15.06 14.6 13.692 13.131 12.443 ~ 115 0
47 2MASX J12592016+2753098 GiC 12 59 20.1719431200 +27 53 09.554536464 16.59 16.657 15.38 15.07 14.591 ~ 89 0
48 2MASX J12592265+2753488 GiC 12 59 22.6199737728 +27 53 48.734841408 16.66 16.504 15.33 14.972 14.39 ~ 67 0
49 NGC 4869 EmG 12 59 23.3588349024 +27 54 41.731884360 15.03 14.9 13.52 13.292 12.536 ~ 286 0
50 2MASX J12592491+2744198 LSB 12 59 24.9342998952 +27 44 19.850059932 16.65 16.403 15.23 14.872 14.213 ~ 69 0
51 2MASX J12592529+2758048 GiC 12 59 25.3302921888 +27 58 04.567089792 16.97 17.055 15.59 15.541 14.863 ~ 67 0
52 IC 3968 EmG 12 59 25.4893671192 +27 58 23.553468660 16.70 16.795 15.32 15.271 14.593 ~ 63 0
53 LEDA 44594 EmG 12 59 26.5981818744 +27 59 54.533097708 17.532 17.181 15.87 15.52 15.052 ~ 76 0
54 LEDA 44602 AG? 12 59 28.7291561256 +28 02 25.896174396 17.389 16.995 16.033 15.471 14.803 ~ 54 0
55 IC 3976 G 12 59 29.4017977320 +27 51 00.507145788 15.93 15.5 14.42 14.212 13.495 ~ 111 0
56 NGC 4871 LIN 12 59 29.9631023208 +27 57 23.169658968 15.59 15.1 14.07 13.801 13.113 ~ 121 0
57 2MASX J12593064+2747288 GiC 12 59 30.6487772544 +27 47 29.144981328 17.10 17.083 15.84 15.6 14.942 ~ 65 0
58 IC 3973 AG? 12 59 30.8230953864 +27 53 03.142254372 15.50 15.2 14.03 13.802 13.114 ~ 112 0
59 LEDA 44616 EmG 12 59 31.4454616392 +28 02 47.777266752 16.664 15.931 15.014 14.412 13.647 ~ 67 0
60 NGC 4873 EmG 12 59 32.7956813376 +27 59 01.023698256 15.53 15.4 14.36 14.24 13.224 ~ 125 0
61 NGC 4872 AGN 12 59 34.1212116072 +27 56 48.678716616 15.58 14.7 14.10 14.092 13.423 ~ 141 0
62 NGC 4874 LIN 12 59 35.7093764280 +27 57 33.293892204 13.01 13.7 12.71 12.27 11.386 ~ 814 3
63 NGC 4875 GiC 12 59 37.9093929384 +27 54 26.400242232 16.03 15.92 14.57 14.322 13.605 ~ 99 0
64 LEDA 44644 G 12 59 39.6590757624 +27 57 14.115321252 16.97 16.99 15.59 15.41 14.99 ~ 75 0
65 Z 160-233 G 12 59 42.3031814928 +27 55 29.073263772 17.64 16.553 15.42 15.051 14.373 ~ 99 0
66 LEDA 44656 G 12 59 43.7289109656 +27 59 40.858551456 16.53 16.384 15.15 14.832 14.154 ~ 96 0
67 NGC 4876 LIN 12 59 44.4043327032 +27 54 44.883805032 15.61 15.1 14.18 13.992 13.333 ~ 154 0
68 ACO 1656 ClG 12 59 44.40 +27 54 44.9           ~ 5141 2
69 Z 160-235 GiC 12 59 46.1220417624 +27 51 26.046219456 16.37 16.258 15.00 14.701 13.994 ~ 66 0
70 IC 3998 G 12 59 46.7810952336 +27 58 25.887811872 16.07 15.909 14.61 14.341 13.605 ~ 97 0
71 Z 160-79 EmG 12 59 47.1522973224 +27 42 37.061804484   15.1       ~ 74 0
72 2MASX J12595511+2807422 GiC 12 59 55.0983190896 +28 07 42.060679572 16.70 15 15.33     ~ 86 0
73 NGC 4883 GiG 12 59 56.0172515304 +28 02 04.976091780 15.76 15.2 14.27 13.872 13.165 ~ 110 0
74 NGC 4881 LIN 12 59 57.7481819280 +28 14 48.009858036 15.03 14.7 13.56     ~ 190 0
75 NGC 4886 EmG 13 00 04.4494334064 +27 59 15.306472032 15.595 15.1 14.294 13.712 13.092 ~ 134 0
76 LEDA 44704 AG? 13 00 06.2918094240 +27 46 32.785530024 16.51 16.154 15.09 14.631 13.973 ~ 69 0
77 IC 4011 G 13 00 06.3940488048 +28 00 14.849196120 16.37 16.207 15.05 14.661 14.002 ~ 120 0
78 IC 4012 G 13 00 07.9959855216 +28 04 42.812545800 16.09 15.948 14.64 14.362 13.655 ~ 124 0
79 NGC 4889 EmG 13 00 08.097 +27 58 37.29 12.93 13.0 11.30 11.652 10.906 ~ 742 1
80 NGC 4895A EmG 13 00 09.1231203816 +28 10 13.436530176 16.33 15.6 14.94     ~ 98 0
81 LEDA 44723 G 13 00 12.8704082496 +28 04 31.779305976 16.53 16.272 15.17 14.742 14.122 ~ 81 0
82 IC 4021 LIN 13 00 14.7492904032 +28 02 28.679693064 16.12 15.974 14.75 14.451 13.783 ~ 125 0
83 NGC 4894 AG? 13 00 16.5193713624 +27 58 03.082120068 16.28 16.106 15.04 14.71 14.051 ~ 77 0
84 NGC 4898A GiC 13 00 17.6793071808 +27 57 18.945906156 15.252 15.0 13.862 13.32 12.574 ~ 59 0
85 NGC 4895 LIN 13 00 17.9283615768 +28 12 08.593323732 14.57 14.3 13.09     ~ 110 0
86 NGC 4898B GiC 13 00 18.0983806416 +27 57 23.732971884 15.7 15.284 14.333 13.771 13.093 ~ 47 0
87 IC 4026 EmG 13 00 22.1409893328 +28 02 49.238219148 15.99 15.5 14.63 14.202 13.553 ~ 104 0
88 2MASX J13002689+2730556 GiC 13 00 26.8586825136 +27 30 56.170117944   15       ~ 52 0
89 IC 4030 G 13 00 27.9700441440 +27 57 21.580940088 16.65 16.50 15.27 14.91 14.49 ~ 77 0
90 Z 160-251 GiC 13 00 35.5780988616 +28 08 46.059465768   15.7       ~ 58 0
91 LEDA 44792 G 13 00 38.7668539488 +28 00 52.318973772 16.058 15.75 14.844 14.291 13.69 ~ 68 0
92 NGC 4906 G 13 00 39.7603737720 +27 55 26.243500044 15.50 15.2 14.08 13.822 13.144 ~ 136 0
93 IC 4041 EmG 13 00 40.8541511496 +27 59 47.807863512 16.19 15.88 14.77 14.343 13.733 ~ 107 0
94 IC 4042 AGN 13 00 42.7595583480 +27 58 16.579136856 15.44 15.272 14.01 13.713 13.025 ~ 105 0
95 LEDA 44809 EmG 13 00 42.8383665048 +27 57 47.226609072 16.34 16.013 14.96 14.501 13.813 ~ 80 0
96 LEDA 44815 AG? 13 00 44.6404235112 +28 06 02.280300408 16.90 15 15.59   14.89 ~ 66 0
97 IC 4045 AGN 13 00 48.6521997192 +28 05 26.675160468 15.25 15.1 13.77 13.573 12.895 ~ 153 0
98 NGC 4908 LIN 13 00 51.5428778808 +28 02 34.346182596 15.05 14.9 13.58 13.273 12.566 ~ 125 0
99 IC 4051 EmG 13 00 54.4630403184 +28 00 27.502143300 15.04 14.8 13.50 13.003 12.305 ~ 218 0
100 Z 160-261 EmG 13 00 59.2582319952 +27 53 59.450406900 15.99 15.6 14.61     ~ 65 0
101 Z 160-92 EmG 13 01 09.2357211984 +27 49 05.993484708 16.48 15.7 15.22     ~ 73 0
102 2MASX J13012280+2811456 GiC 13 01 22.7807820912 +28 11 45.754464732   15       ~ 51 0
103 NGC 4923 EmG 13 01 31.7992415376 +27 50 51.100173564   14.7       ~ 114 0
104 NGC 4926 LIN 13 01 53.7302453520 +27 37 28.027389360   14.1       ~ 159 0
105 ZwCl 1358+6245 ClG 13 59 54.3 +62 30 36     18.5     ~ 370 0
106 ACO 2218 ClG 16 35 54.0 +66 13 00           ~ 827 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2010ApJ...724..714H and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu