2011A&A...535A..31V


Query : 2011A&A...535A..31V

2011A&A...535A..31V - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 535A31-31 (2011/11-1)

Bimodality of light and s-elements in M4 (NGC 6121). A hint for the massive main-sequence star pollution scenario.

VILLANOVA S. and GEISLER D.

Abstract (from CDS):

All globular clusters (GCs) studied in detail host two or more populations of stars (the multiple population phenomenon). Theoretical models suggest that the second population is formed from gas polluted by processed material produced by massive stars of the first generation. However the nature of the polluters is matter of strong debate. Several candidates have been proposed: massive main-sequence stars (fast rotating or binaries), intermediate-mass AGB stars, or SNeII. We studied red giant branch (RGB) stars in the GC M4 (NGC 6121) to measure their chemical signature. Our goal is to measure abundances for many key elements (from Li to Eu) in order to derive constraints on the polluters responsible for the multiple populations. We observed 23 RGB stars below the RGB-bump using the GIRAFFE spectroscopic facility installed on VLT2. Spectra cover a wide range and allowed us to measure light (Li, C, 12C/13C, N, O, Na, Mg, Al), α (Si, Ca, Ti), iron-peak (Cr, Fe, Ni), light-s (Y), heavy-s (Ba), and r (Eu) elements. We supplemented this study by analyzing an additional subsample of the UVES spectra in order to gather further clues about light s-elements of different atomic number (Y and Zr). We confirm the presence of a bimodal population. Stars can be easily separated according to their N content. The two groups have different C, 12C/13C, N, O, Na content, but share the same Li, C+N+O, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, Cr, Fe, Ni, Zr, Ba and Eu abundance. Quite surprisingly the two groups differ also in their Y abundance. This result is strongly supported also by the analysis of the UVES spectra. The absence of a spread in α-elements, Eu and Ba makes SNeII and AGB stars unlikely as polluters. On the other hand, massive main-sequence stars can explain the bimodality of Y through the weak s-process. This statement is confirmed independently also by literature data on Rb and Pb. The lack of a Mg/Al spread and the extension of the [O/Na] distribution suggest that the mass of the polluters is between 20 and 30M☉. This implies a formation time scale for the cluster of 10/30Myr. This result is valid for M4. Other clusters such as NGC 1851, M 22, or ω Cen have different chemical signatures and may require other kinds of polluters.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): stars: abundances - globular clusters: individual: M4

Nomenclature: Table 1: Cl* NGC 6121 MVP NNNNN N=23 among (Nos 907-67553) added.

Simbad objects: 53

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 53
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NGC 1851 GlC 05 14 06.76 -40 02 47.6           ~ 1529 0
2 NGC 2808 GlC 09 12 03.10 -64 51 48.6           ~ 1540 0
3 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3677 0
4 * alf Boo RG* 14 15 39.67207 +19 10 56.6730 2.46 1.18 -0.05 -1.03 -1.68 K1.5IIIFe-0.5 2417 1
5 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 33584 RG* 16 23 09.9291214416 -26 28 33.625764660 16.14 15.60 14.50   13.026 ~ 10 0
6 NGC 6121 474 RG* 16 23 13.9484472072 -26 33 24.539562864 14.89 13.556 12.055   10.286 ~ 33 0
7 2MASS J16231442-2636055 RG* 16 23 14.4181955592 -26 36 05.547999564 14.64 12.73 10.88 9.80 9.04 ~ 46 0
8 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2422 RG* 16 23 14.5990497360 -26 30 46.990708560 15.05 13.901 12.482   10.813 ~ 22 0
9 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 28590 RG* 16 23 15.4533630528 -26 38 47.245425036 16.13 15.60 14.52     ~ 8 0
10 NGC 6121 471 RG* 16 23 16.5623721744 -26 32 09.733929072 14.79 13.236 11.661   9.896 ~ 37 0
11 NGC 6121 424 RG* 16 23 16.9017005856 -26 29 47.955475500 15.28 14.389 13.100   11.559 ~ 22 0
12 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 270 RG* 16 23 21.4120564944 -26 28 33.576492540 16.17 15.54 14.42     ~ 14 0
13 NGC 6121 240 RG* 16 23 23.0552864928 -26 33 32.339018160 15.28 14.413 13.112   11.546 ~ 16 0
14 NGC 6121 241 RG* 16 23 23.5445994696 -26 33 41.335025544 15.18 14.40 13.109   11.463 ~ 17 0
15 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 402 * 16 23 23.7417046968 -26 33 21.939136380 16.23 15.669 14.524   13.057 ~ 6 0
16 CD-26 11312 RG* 16 23 23.8093956576 -26 34 29.821786140 14.75 12.63 10.76   8.51 ~ 38 0
17 NGC 6121 243 RG* 16 23 25.3052755200 -26 33 29.260116612 15.17 14.157 12.815   11.201 ~ 15 0
18 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2624 * 16 23 27.08280 -26 31 23.7144 16.07 15.58 14.46     ~ 4 0
19 NGC 6121 244 RG* 16 23 27.0867816384 -26 33 29.744986932 15.32 14.630 13.361   11.786 ~ 19 0
20 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 394 * 16 23 27.7207010880 -26 33 41.870512044 16.33 15.736 14.547     ~ 5 0
21 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 406 RG* 16 23 27.7486630920 -26 32 32.030326464 16.26 15.711 14.526   13.02 ~ 6 0
22 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 391 RG* 16 23 28.2763588296 -26 34 27.946022304 16.40 15.839 14.668   13.17 ~ 11 0
23 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 1618 * 16 23 30.8339644176 -26 33 28.090371780 16.28 15.778 14.611     ~ 5 0
24 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 43020 * 16 23 30.94248 -26 33 44.2368 16.48 15.99 14.87     ~ 3 0
25 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 1621 RG* 16 23 33.3816269160 -26 33 14.945612796 15.65 14.864 13.612   12.079 ~ 19 0
26 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 535 * 16 23 33.5069430744 -26 30 35.056000440 16.26 15.793 14.642     ~ 5 0
27 NGC 6121 254 RG* 16 23 34.1256590760 -26 33 03.928892112 15.48 14.75 13.470   11.847 ~ 14 0
28 2MASS J16233418-2632485 RG* 16 23 34.1844165672 -26 32 48.545869452 15.52 14.832 13.595   12.063 ~ 10 0
29 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1978 0
30 2MASS J16233712-2633500 RG* 16 23 37.1349921744 -26 33 50.091976332 15.43 14.76 13.489   11.856 ~ 10 0
31 NGC 6121 545 RG* 16 23 38.2590071376 -26 35 55.199209632 15.69 14.94 13.668   12.055 ~ 18 0
32 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 163 RG* 16 23 40.0065763152 -26 39 03.171895452 16.89 14.668 13.443   11.916 ~ 14 0
33 NGC 6121 600 RG* 16 23 40.9203645192 -26 37 23.519488260 15.11 14.234 12.934   11.362 ~ 23 0
34 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 45200 * 16 23 41.41848 -26 32 31.0488 16.36 15.78 14.65     ~ 3 0
35 2MASS J16234260-2633174 RG* 16 23 42.6021374304 -26 33 17.495740584 15.53 14.961 13.793   12.23 ~ 9 0
36 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 4627 * 16 23 43.99680 -26 32 01.8240 15.98 15.47 14.38     ~ 4 0
37 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 198 * 16 23 44.4192593088 -26 35 37.238171172 16.33 15.772 14.660     ~ 5 0
38 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 152 RG* 16 23 44.5909091712 -26 38 03.474565440 16.13 15.692 14.538     ~ 10 0
39 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 50032 * 16 23 45.3730161048 -26 30 16.378218792 16.13 15.59 14.50     ~ 7 0
40 Cl* NGC 6121 SAW V56 RG* 16 23 45.9300539040 -26 33 38.946380148 15.02 14.24 12.93 12.13 11.35 ~ 22 0
41 Cl* NGC 6121 SAW V57 RG* 16 23 46.9279043904 -26 33 43.899680520 15.22 14.256 12.980   11.341 ~ 23 0
42 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 8460 RG* 16 23 47.3275948128 -26 22 30.069873120 16.14 15.47 14.37   12.92 ~ 13 0
43 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 39100 * 16 23 48.7039718232 -26 36 25.857338868 16.04 15.54 14.40     ~ 5 0
44 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 27448 RG* 16 23 48.7977828528 -26 35 09.179191752   13.219 11.691   9.909 ~ 18 0
45 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 484 * 16 23 48.9671273592 -26 30 59.085264312 15.92 15.398 14.271     ~ 6 0
46 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 4510 * 16 23 49.0758164304 -26 34 00.540644412 16.22 15.652 14.548     ~ 5 0
47 2MASS J16235358-2634151 RG* 16 23 53.5834359408 -26 34 15.161300760 14.93 13.892 12.534   10.908 ~ 29 0
48 2MASS J16235384-2633525 RG* 16 23 53.8477290288 -26 33 52.539302124 15.13 14.193 12.892   11.327 ~ 19 0
49 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 36820 * 16 23 55.71000 -26 39 00.7000 16.33 15.81 14.69     ~ 1 0
50 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 96 RG* 16 24 00.6064769544 -26 28 20.750658276 15.77 15.266 14.173   12.76 ~ 13 0
51 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 907 * 16 24 08.98000 -26 22 40.5000 15.81 15.31 14.21     ~ 1 0
52 NGC 6397 GlC 17 40 42.09 -53 40 27.6     5.17     ~ 2103 0
53 M 22 GlC 18 36 23.94 -23 54 17.1           ~ 1459 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2011A&A...535A..31V and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu