2011MNRAS.418.1089C

Query : 2011MNRAS.418.1089C

2011MNRAS.418.1089C - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 418, 1089-1101 (2011/December-1)

X-ray calibration of Sunyaev–Zel'dovich scaling relations with the ACCEPT catalogue of galaxy clusters observed by Chandra.

COMIS B., DE PETRIS M., CONTE A., LAMAGNA L. and DE GREGORI S.

Abstract (from CDS):

We explore the scaling relation between the flux of the Sunyaev–Zel'dovich (SZ) effect and the total mass of galaxy clusters using already reduced Chandra X-ray data present in the ACCEPT (Archive of Chandra Cluster Entropy Profile Tables) catalogue. The analysis is conducted over a sample of 226 objects, examining the relatively small scale corresponding to a cluster overdensity equal to 2500 times the critical density of the background universe, at which the total masses have been calculated exploiting the hydrostatic equilibrium hypothesis. Core entropy (K₀) is strongly correlated with the central cooling time, and is therefore used to identify cooling-core (CC) objects in our sample. Our results confirm the self-similarity of the scaling relation between the integrated Comptonization parameter (Y) and the cluster mass, for both CC and NCC (non-cooling-core) clusters. The consistency of our calibration with recent ones has been checked, with further support for Y as a good mass proxy. We also investigate the robustness of the constant gas fraction assumption, for fixed overdensity, and of the Y_x = M_gasT_x proxy considering CC and NCC clusters, again sorted on K₀ from our sample. We extend our study to implement a K₀-proxy, obtained by combining SZ and X-ray observables, which is proposed to provide a CC indicator for higher redshift objects. Finally, we suggest that an SZ-only CC indicator could benefit from the employment of deprojected Comptonization radial profiles.

Abstract Copyright: 2011 The Authors Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society2011 RAS

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: clusters: intracluster medium - large-scale structure of Universe - X-rays: galaxies: clusters

CDS comments: ESO 3060170 = ACO S 540, ESO 5520200 = NAME ESO 552-20 GROUP

Simbad objects: 228

Full paper

View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 228

N	Identifier	Otype	ICRS (J2000) RA	ICRS (J2000) DEC	Mag U	Mag B	Mag V	Mag R	Mag I	Sp type	#ref 1850 - 2026	#notes
1	ACO 2717	ClG	00 03 12.9	-35 56 13						~	146	0
2	ClG J0011-2850	ClG	00 11 21.623	-28 51 14.44						~	7	0
3	ACT-CL J0011.7-1523	ClG	00 11 42.9	-15 23 22						~	39	0
4	ACO 13	ClG	00 13 38.5	-19 30 19						~	107	1
5	ACO 2744	ClG	00 14 20.03	-30 23 17.8						~	1077	0
6	ClG 0016+16	ClG	00 18 33.3	+16 26 36						~	517	0
7	ACT-CL J0035.4-2015	ClG	00 35 26.5	-20 15 46						~	52	0
8	ACO 68	ClG	00 37 06.2	+09 09 33						~	195	0
9	ACO 85	ClG	00 41 36.21	-09 19 30.4						~	974	0
10	ACO 2813	ClG	00 43 22.8	-20 37 21						~	111	0
11	3C 28	rG	00 55 50.583	+26 24 36.68		18.63	19.57	16.26		~	213	1
12	ACO 119	ClG	00 56 08.57	-01 12 00.8						~	577	2
13	ACO 133	ClG	01 02 41.5	-21 52 53						~	391	1
14	ACO 141	ClG	01 05 37.183	-24 40 49.95						~	87	0
15	ACO 160	ClG	01 12 59.98	+15 30 05.3						~	181	0
16	Z 385-64	BLL	01 18 53.6237165304	-01 00 07.248153600		15.0				~	81	1
17	ZwCl 0120+3300	ClG	01 23 36.9	+33 15 03						~	80	0
18	NGC 507	rG	01 23 39.950	+33 15 22.22		13.0				~	459	1
19	ACO 209	ClG	01 31 52.9	-13 36 53						~	326	0
20	ACO 222	ClG	01 37 31.1	-12 59 30						~	153	1
21	ACO 223	ClG	01 37 55.9	-12 49 11						~	135	1
22	ACO 267	ClG	01 52 43.016	+00 59 58.90						~	241	0
23	ACO 262	ClG	01 52 50.4	+36 08 46						~	727	1
24	ACT-CL J0159.8-0849	ClG	01 59 49.4	-08 50 00						~	98	0
25	ACT-CL J0220.9-3828	ClG	02 20 56.8	-38 29 02						~	29	0
26	ACT-CL J0232.2-4421	ClG	02 32 18.69	-44 20 41.5						~	130	0
27	ACO 368	ClG	02 37 24.65	-26 30 01.8						~	33	0
28	ACO 370	ClG	02 39 50.5	-01 35 08						~	825	0
29	ClG J0242-2132	ClG	02 42 35.9	-21 32 26						~	55	0
30	ACO 383	ClG	02 48 03.3915	-03 31 45.228						~	389	0
31	2A 0251+413	ClG	02 54 26.6	+41 33 25						~	328	1
32	ACT-CL J0257.1-2325	ClG	02 57 09.151	-23 26 05.83						~	80	0
33	ACO 402	ClG	02 57 41.33	-22 09 14.4						~	62	0
34	ACO 399	ClG	02 57 56.4	+13 00 59						~	420	0
35	ACO 401	ClG	02 58 50.3	+13 34 07						~	592	0
36	ACO 3084	ClG	03 04 03.950	-36 56 27.16						~	35	0
37	ACO 3088	ClG	03 07 02.12	-28 39 57.3						~	78	0
38	MCS J0308.9+2645	ClG	03 08 55.9	+26 45 38						~	48	0
39	ACO 3112	ClG	03 17 52.9	-44 15 06						~	329	1
40	ACO 3120	ClG	03 21 53	-51 19.3						~	25	0
41	RX J0329.6-0211	ClG	03 29 41.6	-02 11 47						~	155	0
42	ACT-CL J0331.1-2100	ClG	03 31 06.0	-21 00 34						~	36	0
43	ZwCl 0335+0956	ClG	03 38 35.3	+09 57 54						~	402	1
44	ACO 3158	ClG	03 43 07.5	-53 38 09						~	327	0
45	ACO S 405	ClG	03 51 32.8	-82 13 15						~	50	0
46	ACO 478	ClG	04 13 24.8	+10 27 52						~	522	0
47	ACT-CL J0417.5-1154	ClG	04 17 34.6	-11 54 32						~	116	0
48	BAX 064.9080+02.4099	GrG	04 19 38.2	+02 25 12						~	44	1
49	ClG 0422-09	ClG	04 25 51.02	-08 33 38.5						~	97	0
50	ClG J0429-0253	ClG	04 29 36.0	-02 53 09						~	131	0
51	ACO 3266	ClG	04 31 26.4	-61 25 17						~	447	0
52	ACO 496	ClG	04 33 40.8	-13 14 34						~	728	2
53	ACT-CL J0438.9+0716	ClG	04 39 00.7	+07 15 45						~	62	0
54	BAX 069.7593+05.3453	ClG	04 39 02.2	+05 20 43						~	82	0
55	ClG 0440+02	ClG	04 43 09.7	+02 10 19			17.03			~	129	0
56	ACO 521	ClG	04 54 08.6	-10 14 39						~	279	0
57	ACO 520	ClG	04 54 10.1	+02 55 38						~	465	0
58	ClG 0451-03	ClG	04 54 10.9	-03 01 07			20.0			~	368	0
59	CAN 28	ClG	04 54 52.318	-18 06 56.52						~	32	0
60	ACO 539	ClG	05 16 35.1	+06 27 14						~	255	2
61	ACT-CL J0520.7-1328	ClG	05 20 42.0	-13 28 49						~	39	0
62	ACT-CL J0528.8-3927	ClG	05 28 56.2	-39 27 49						~	78	0
63	ACO S 540	ClG	05 40 06.2	-40 50 29						~	60	0
64	ACT-CL J0546.9-3904	ClG	05 47 01.5	-39 04 28						~	37	0
65	ACO 3364	ClG	05 47 38.1	-31 52 15						~	86	0
66	ACO S 592	ClG	06 38 49.40	-53 58 40.8						~	75	0
67	ClG J0647+7015	ClG	06 47 50.0	+70 14 55						~	177	0
68	ACO 562	ClG	06 51 56	+69 16.4						~	44	0
69	ClG 0657-56	ClG	06 58 26.9	-55 58 21						~	1077	1
70	ClG J0717+3745	ClG	07 17 36.50	+37 45 23.0						~	511	0
71	B3 0714+378	Rad	07 17 36.6	+37 45 01						~	170	2
72	ACO 586	ClG	07 32 20.3	+31 37 58						~	196	0
73	Z 262-19	BiC	07 40 58.2309667896	+55 25 37.870473828		14.2				~	52	1
74	ZwCl 0735+7421	ClG	07 41 40.3	+74 14 58			17.70			~	273	0
75	ClG J0744+3927	ClG	07 44 52.5	+39 27 30						~	189	0
76	PKS 0745-19	rG	07 47 31.3247085936	-19 17 40.013334276		19.60				~	422	1
77	ClG 0745-1910	ClG	07 47 32.4	-19 18 23						~	378	0
78	ACO 611	ClG	08 00 58.7	+36 02 49						~	275	0
79	ACO 644	ClG	08 17 26.1	-07 31 13						~	241	0
80	BAX 124.9136+63.6101	ClG	08 19 26.0	+63 37 26						~	21	0
81	ACO 665	ClG	08 30 45.2	+65 52 55						~	457	0
82	4C 55.16	Bla	08 34 54.90398776	+55 34 21.0703409		20.75	19.45	17.180		~	297	2
83	ZwCl 0839+2937	ClG	08 42 55.9	+29 27 26			17.0			~	93	0
84	ACO 697	ClG	08 42 57.6	+36 21 45						~	277	0
85	ZwCl 0847+3617	ClG	08 50 12.0	+36 03 36						~	75	0
86	ACO 744	ClG	09 07 20.0	+16 39 25						~	81	0
87	ClG 0906.5+1110	ClG	09 09 12.7	+10 58 32						~	108	0
88	ACO 773	ClG	09 17 51.3	+51 43 20						~	308	0
89	MCG-02-24-007	LIN	09 18 05.66848602	-12 05 43.8060823		14.38	14.8			~	1077	1
90	ClG J0947+7623	ClG	09 46 59.916	+76 23 43.99						~	165	0
91	NVSS J094712+762312	Rad	09 47 12.37	+76 23 09.3						~	151	1
92	ZwCl 0949+5207	ClG	09 52 49.1	+51 53 05						~	141	0
93	ACO 907	ClG	09 58 21.84	-11 03 47.5						~	137	0
94	HCG 42	CGG	10 00 13.1	-19 38 24						~	100	0
95	BAX 150.1046+44.1539	ClG	10 00 17.91	+44 08 35.8						~	40	0
96	ZwCl 1006+1201	ClG	10 08 47.1	+11 47 55			18.0			~	75	0
97	ClG 1008-12	ClG	10 10 34.1	-12 39 48			18.0			~	155	0
98	ACO 963	ClG	10 17 03.4	+39 02 56						~	414	0
99	BAX 155.5304+38.5153	ClG	10 22 18.24	+38 32 39.6						~	63	0
100	ZwCl 1021+0426	ClG	10 23 39.0	+04 11 14		15.6	17.95			~	297	0
101	ACO 3444	ClG	10 23 53.1540	-27 15 07.840						~	97	0
102	ACO 1068	ClG	10 40 47.1	+39 57 19						~	232	0
103	ACO 1201	ClG	11 12 54.4	+13 26 08						~	131	1
104	ACO 1204	ClG	11 13 32.2	+17 35 40						~	101	0
105	ClG J1115+5319	ClG	11 15 14.8	+53 19 54						~	56	0
106	MCS J1115.8+0129	ClG	11 15 52.1	+01 29 53						~	142	0
107	ACO 1240	ClG	11 23 37.7	+43 03 28						~	113	0
108	ACO 1275	ClG	11 29 45.44	+36 37 49.4						~	50	0
109	ACO 1300	ClG	11 32 00.7	-19 53 34						~	168	0
110	ACO 1361	ClG	11 43 45.85	+46 20 51.8						~	96	0
111	MCS J1149.5+2223	ClG	11 49 35.8	+22 23 55						~	546	0
112	ACO 1413	ClG	11 55 12.87	+23 23 46.9						~	456	0
113	ACO 1423	ClG	11 57 17.3206	+33 36 39.364						~	181	0
114	ClG J1159+5531	ClG	11 59 53.02	+55 32 22.8			15.64			~	100	1
115	ACO 1446	ClG	12 01 54.77	+58 01 40.7						~	104	1
116	NAME NGC 4073 Group	GrG	12 04 44.08	+01 48 40.9			13.53			~	292	0
117	MCS J1206.2-0847	ClG	12 06 12.2	-08 48 02						~	286	0
118	ZwCl 1215+0400	ClG	12 17 43.62	+03 38 51.5						~	169	0
119	ClG J1226+3332	ClG	12 26 57.7	+33 32 50						~	228	0
120	M 49	Sy2	12 29 46.8	+08 00 01		13.21	12.17			~	2174	2
121	M 87	AGN	12 30 49.42338414	+12 23 28.0436859	10.16	9.59	8.63		7.49	~	7815	3
122	ACO 1569	ClG	12 36 19.49	+16 32 46.8						~	83	0
123	ACO 1576	ClG	12 36 59.5	+63 11 18						~	116	0
124	NGC 4636	LIN	12 42 49.8333280080	+02 41 15.951929028		12.62	11.84			~	1156	1
125	ACO 3526	ClG	12 48 49.2	-41 18 17						~	1154	2
126	HCG 62	CGG	12 53 05.6	-09 12 21						~	313	0
127	BAX 193.6700-29.2254	ClG	12 54 40.6	-29 13 44						~	76	0
128	ACO 1644	ClG	12 57 11.6	-17 24 34						~	391	1
129	ACO 1650	ClG	12 58 42.0	-01 45 45						~	325	0
130	ACO 1651	ClG	12 59 27.3	-04 10 49						~	307	0
131	ACO 1664	ClG	13 03 42.4	-24 14 44						~	136	0
132	ClG J1311-0311	ClG	13 11 01.7	-03 10 38						~	120	0
133	ACO 1689	ClG	13 11 29.5	-01 20 28						~	1178	0
134	NGC 5044	BiC	13 15 23.9607836592	-16 23 07.547751744		11.9		10.74		~	531	0
135	NGC 5096B	rG	13 20 14.7283808160	+33 08 36.294146268		15.0				~	112	2
136	ACO 1736	ClG	13 26 52.1	-27 06 33						~	268	2
137	BAX 202.4458-31.6081	ClG	13 29 47.0	-31 36 29						~	80	1
138	ACO 1758	ClG	13 32 32.1	+50 30 37						~	266	2
139	ACO 1763	ClG	13 35 20.1	+41 00 04						~	335	0
140	ClG J1347-1145	ClG	13 47 30.5	-11 45 07						~	577	0
141	ACO 3571	ClG	13 47 32.4	-32 50 12						~	308	2
142	ACO 1795	ClG	13 48 47.4	+26 34 55						~	1330	0
143	ZwCl 1358+6245	ClG	13 59 54.3	+62 30 36			18.5			~	370	0
144	ACO 1835	ClG	14 01 02.07	+02 52 43.2						~	727	1
145	ACO 3581	ClG	14 07 29.8	-27 01 04						~	197	3
146	3C 295	Sy1	14 11 20.6	+52 12 09		22.34	20.80	18.54		~	1021	4
147	ClG J1423+2404	ClG	14 23 47.7	+24 04 40						~	231	0
148	ACO 1914	ClG	14 25 57.4	+37 49 54						~	338	0
149	ACO 1942	ClG	14 38 21.8673	+03 40 13.247						~	122	0
150	BAX 220.1796+03.4530	ClG	14 40 34.37	+03 29 49.7			14.31			~	131	0
151	ACO 1995	ClG	14 52 55.0	+58 02 59						~	140	0
152	ACO 1991	ClG	14 54 41.53	+18 38 08.4						~	349	1
153	ZwCl 1455+2232	ClG	14 57 15.2	+22 20 30			18.62	20.04		~	309	0
154	ClG J1504-0248	ClG	15 04 07.4	-02 48 15						~	186	0
155	NGC 5846	rG	15 06 29.253	+01 36 20.29		11.9		9.74		~	891	2
156	ACO 2034	ClG	15 10 03.9	+33 30 57						~	248	1
157	ACO 2029	ClG	15 10 54.2	+05 44 23						~	1020	0
158	ACO 2052	ClG	15 16 41.64	+07 01 45.5						~	756	1
159	ACT-CL J1521.8+0742	ClG	15 21 48.8	+07 43 41			15.13			~	326	0
160	ACO 2065	ClG	15 22 22.7	+27 44 20						~	398	0
161	ACO 2063	ClG	15 23 01.8	+08 38 22						~	414	2
162	ACO 2069	ClG	15 24 02.92	+29 53 20.3						~	165	0
163	LEDA 1900245	Bla	15 32 53.780	+30 20 59.41		19.1		15.7	17.819	~	155	1
164	2MAXI J1546-834	ClG	15 39 37.0	-83 35 03						~	33	0
165	ACO 2107	ClG	15 39 39.04	+21 46 57.8						~	270	0
166	ACO 2111	ClG	15 39 40.9	+34 25 04						~	188	0
167	ACO 2104	ClG	15 40 06.8	-03 17 39						~	113	0
168	ACO 2125	ClG	15 41 14.1	+66 15 57						~	124	1
169	ACO 2122	ClG	15 44 55.93	+36 06 05.2						~	243	0
170	ACO 2142	ClG	15 58 26.5	+27 13 52						~	825	0
171	ACO 2147	ClG	16 02 11.96	+15 55 11.5						~	416	0
172	ACO 2151	ClG	16 05 15.0	+17 44 55						~	594	3
173	ACO 2163	ClG	16 15 46.1	-06 08 50						~	586	0
174	ClG J1621+3810	ClG	16 21 25.5	+38 09 43						~	83	0
175	ACO 2187	ClG	16 24 13.9	+41 14 37						~	47	0
176	ACO 2199	ClG	16 28 34.5	+39 32 26						~	1206	1
177	ACO 2204	ClG	16 32 47.7	+05 34 18						~	457	0
178	ACO 2218	ClG	16 35 54.0	+66 13 00						~	827	1
179	ACO 2219	ClG	16 40 22.1	+46 42 20						~	381	0
180	MCG+01-43-006	SyG	16 51 07.9886687784	+04 59 35.547131472			18.25			~	502	1
181	ACO 2244	ClG	17 02 40.33	+34 02 58.7						~	301	0
182	ACO 2256	ClG	17 03 37.5	+78 37 23						~	928	1
183	BAX 258.1082-23.3759	ClG	17 12 26.3	-23 21 38						~	303	0
184	ACO 2259	ClG	17 20 09.2	+27 40 09						~	131	0
185	ClG J1720+2638	ClG	17 20 09.6	+26 37 35						~	284	0
186	ClG J1720+3536	ClG	17 20 16.8	+35 36 27						~	150	1
187	ACO 2261	ClG	17 22 26.9	+32 07 58						~	370	0
188	ACO 2294	ClG	17 24 10.1	+85 53 09						~	69	0
189	ZwCl 1728+4353	ClG	17 33 00.0	+43 45 00						~	41	0
190	ZwCl 1742+3306	ClG	17 44 16.2753	+32 59 55.115						~	93	0
191	3C 388.0	SyG	18 44 02.3840387736	+45 33 29.628672300		16.91	15.56			~	338	1
192	BAX 283.0392+57.1972	ClG	18 52 08.35	+57 11 42.7						~	24	0
193	ClG J1931-2635	ClG	19 31 49.6	-26 34 33						~	181	0
194	MCG+07-41-003	Bla	19 59 28.35656837	+40 44 02.0972325		16.22	15.10			~	2537	2
195	ACO 3667	ClG	20 12 33.68	-56 50 26.3						~	676	1
196	ACT-CL J2049.9-3217	ClG	20 49 56.2	-32 16 52						~	22	0
197	ClG J2129+0005	ClG	21 29 40.5	+00 05 47						~	308	0
198	ClG 2137-2353	ClG	21 40 12.8	-23 39 27			18.5			~	390	0
199	ACO 2384	ClG	21 52 20.9	-19 32 53						~	117	0
200	ACO 2390	ClG	21 53 37.4	+17 41 46						~	732	2
201	ACO 3822	ClG	21 54 06.2	-57 50 49						~	98	0
202	ACO 2409	ClG	22 00 52.7	+20 58 27						~	101	0
203	ACO 3827	ClG	22 01 49.1	-59 57 15						~	178	0
204	ACO 2420	ClG	22 10 22.5	-12 11 13						~	126	0
205	ACT-CL J2211.7-0349	ClG	22 11 44.8	-03 49 33						~	96	0
206	ACT-CL J2214.9-1359	ClG	22 14 57.3	-14 00 12						~	100	0
207	NAME 2PIGG J2227.0-3041	GrG	22 27 54.560	-30 34 34.84						~	6	0
208	BAX 337.1433+20.6131	ClG	22 28 32.6	+20 37 08						~	132	0
209	ClG J2229-2756	ClG	22 29 45.36	-27 55 36.5						~	50	0
210	ACO 2462	ClG	22 39 17.3	-17 22 23						~	96	0
211	MCS J2245.0+2637	ClG	22 45 04.5	+26 38 07						~	40	0
212	ACO S 1063	ClG	22 48 45.4	-44 31 42						~	395	0
213	ACO 3921	ClG	22 49 59.0	-64 25 48						~	165	1
214	ACO S 1077	ClG	22 58 52.34	-34 46 54.6						~	198	0
215	ACO 2537	ClG	23 08 22.3	-02 11 29						~	152	0
216	ACO 2554	ClG	23 12 18.7	-21 30 54						~	100	1
217	ACO 2556	ClG	23 13 03.3	-21 37 40						~	83	0
218	ACO S 1101	ClG	23 13 58.5	-42 43 39						~	272	1
219	Z 532-11	BiC	23 18 38.2641503880	+42 57 28.797497604		15.3				~	41	1
220	ACO 2589	ClG	23 24 00.5	+16 49 29						~	327	1
221	ACO 2597	ClG	23 25 19.70	-12 07 27.7						~	572	0
222	ACT-CL J2327.4-0204	ClG	23 27 27.60	-02 04 37.4						~	44	0
223	ACO 2626	ClG	23 36 31.0	+21 09 36						~	265	0
224	ACO 2631	ClG	23 37 40.7	+00 16 35						~	183	0
225	ACO 2657	ClG	23 44 51.0	+09 08 40						~	280	3
226	ACO 4038	ClG	23 47 31.1	-28 12 10						~	349	3
227	ACO 2667	ClG	23 51 39.37	-26 05 02.7						~	190	0
228	ACO 4059	ClG	23 57 02.2	-34 45 58						~	400	1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2011MNRAS.418.1089C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu