2012A&A...537A.132B


Query : 2012A&A...537A.132B

2012A&A...537A.132B - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 537A132-132 (2012/1-1)

A comparison between star formation rate diagnostics and rate of core collapse supernovae within 11 mpc.

BOTTICELLA M.T., SMARTT S.J., KENNICUTT R.C.Jr, CAPPELLARO E., SERENO M. and LEE J.C.

Abstract (from CDS):

The core collapse supernova rate provides a strong lower limit for the star formation rate (SFR). Progress in using it as a cosmic SFR tracer requires some confidence that it is consistent with more conventional SFR diagnostics in the nearby Universe. This paper compares standard SFR measurements based on Hα, far ultraviolet (FUV) and total infrared (TIR) galaxy luminosities with the observed core collapse supernova rate in the same galaxy sample. The comparison can be viewed from two perspectives. Firstly, by adopting an estimate of the minimum stellar mass to produce a core collapse supernova one can determine a SFR from supernova numbers. Secondly, the radiative SFR can be assumed to be robust and then the supernova statistics provide a constrain on the minimum stellar mass for core collapse supernova progenitors. The novel aspect of this study is that Hα, FUV and TIR luminosities are now available for a complete galaxy sample within the local 11Mpc volume and the number of discovered supernovae in this sample within the last 13 years is high enough to perform a meaningful statistical comparison. We exploit the multi-wavelength dataset from 11 HUGS, a volume-limited survey designed to provide a census of SFR in the Local Volume. There are 14 supernovae discovered in this sample of galaxies within the last 13 years. Although one could argue that this may not be complete, it is certainly a robust lower limit. Assuming a lower limit for core collapse of 8M☉ (as proposed by direct detections of SN progenitor stars and white dwarf progenitors), the core-collapse supernova rate matches the SFR from the FUV luminosity. However, the SFR based on Hα luminosity is lower than these two estimates by a factor of nearly 2. If we assume that the FUV or Hα based luminosities are a true reflection of the SFR, we find that the minimum mass for core collapse supernova progenitors is 8±1M☉ and 6±1M☉, respectively. The estimate of the minimum mass for core collapse supernova progenitors obtained exploiting FUV data is in good agreement with that from the direct detection of supernova progenitors. The concordant results by these independent methods point toward a constraint of 8±1 M☉ on the lower mass limit for progenitor stars of core collapse supernovae.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): stars: massive - supernovae: general - galaxies: star formation

Simbad objects: 119

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 119
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 V* S And No* 00 42 43.12368 +41 16 03.2124           ~ 190 2
2 M 31 AGN 00 42 44.330 +41 16 07.50 4.86 4.36 3.44     ~ 13622 1
3 SN 1940E SN* 00 47 31 -25 17.6   14.3       SNI 19 1
4 NGC 253 SyG 00 47 33.134 -25 17 19.68   8.03   6.94 8.1 ~ 3588 2
5 AT 2008jd ev 00 54 34.16 -37 38 28.6           ~ 134 1
6 NGC 300 GiG 00 54 53.4465638304 -37 41 03.168402396 8.83 8.69 8.13 7.46   ~ 1614 2
7 NAME NGC 300 2010da s*b 00 55 04.86 -37 41 43.7           LBV 189 0
8 SN 2002ap SN* 01 36 23.85 +15 45 13.2   13.11 14.54     SNIc-BL 587 1
9 M 74 G 01 36 41.7451236624 +15 47 01.107512304 10.52 10.00 9.46 9.16   ~ 1934 1
10 SN 2003gd SN* 01 36 42.65 +15 44 19.9     13.2     SNIIP 267 2
11 SN 1986J SN* 02 22 31.33 +42 19 56.4   18.4 18.4     SNII 331 1
12 NGC 891 H2G 02 22 32.907 +42 20 53.95 11.08 10.81 9.93 7.86   ~ 1741 2
13 NGC 1003 GiG 02 39 16.893 +40 52 20.25   12.1   10.83   ~ 198 0
14 SN 1937D SN* 02 39 21.0 +40 52 20   12.9       SNIa 56 1
15 SN 2007gr SN* 02 43 27.98 +37 20 44.7       12.77   SNIc 265 1
16 NGC 1058 Sy2 02 43 30.0264850248 +37 20 28.782851784   12.29 11.75 10.85   ~ 483 0
17 SN 1961V SN* 02 43 36.42 +37 20 43.6   12.7 12.5     SNIIpec? 212 2
18 SN 1969L SN* 02 43 45 +37 18.7   13.2 13.2     SNIIP 121 1
19 SN 1963L SN* 02 47 53.54 +37 31 52.7   15.0 15.0     SNI 10 1
20 Z 524-20 GiP 02 47 55.4194406880 +37 32 18.528735876   14.3   12.8   ~ 131 0
21 SN 1978K SN* 03 17 38.620 -66 33 03.40   13.0       SNII 214 1
22 SN 1962M SN* 03 18 12.26 -66 31 38.5   11.7 9.50     SNIIP 36 1
23 NGC 1313 AG? 03 18 16.046 -66 29 53.74   10.06 10.0 9.40 10.4 ~ 723 2
24 IC 342 AGN 03 46 48.514 +68 05 45.98   10.5       ~ 1579 1
25 ESO 302-14 GiG 03 51 40.90 -38 27 08.0   14.84   14.54 14.8 ~ 60 0
26 SN 2008jb SN* 03 51 44.66 -38 27 00.1           SNII 16 1
27 NGC 1808 Sy2 05 07 42.343 -37 30 46.98 11.05 10.80 9.94 9.36 10.2 ~ 756 3
28 SN 1993af SN* 05 08 00.71 -37 29 18.0     17     SNIa 19 1
29 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 19090 0
30 SN 1987A SN* 05 35 27.98840 -69 16 11.1134           SNIIpec 5203 2
31 NGC 2168 OpC 06 09 07.5 +24 20 15           ~ 604 0
32 NGC 2403 AGN 07 36 51.3381434280 +65 36 09.650825640 9.31 8.84 8.38 8.19   ~ 1887 1
33 SN 1954J SN* 07 36 56.20 +65 37 52.3   16.3 16.50     SNIIpec? 95 2
34 TS V37 s*b 07 37 01.83 +65 34 29.3     19     LBV 67 1
35 2MASS J07371703+6535579 HXB 07 37 17.0432126424 +65 35 57.826001220           SNIIP 317 1
36 SN 1993J SN* 09 55 24.77476 +69 01 13.7026   10.8 12.0     SNIIb 1507 1
37 M 81 Sy2 09 55 33.1726556496 +69 03 55.062505368   7.89 6.94     ~ 4725 3
38 CXOU J095546.6+694037 HXB 09 55 46.6536476856 +69 40 37.899496056           SNIIP 51 1
39 SN 2008iz SN* 09 55 51.55 +69 40 45.8           SNII: 63 1
40 M 82 AGN 09 55 52.430 +69 40 46.93 9.61 9.30 8.41     ~ 6156 6
41 M 96 GiP 10 46 45.744 +11 49 11.78 10.42 10.15 9.25 8.99   ~ 862 1
42 SN 1998bu SN* 10 46 46.01 +11 50 07.5   12.11       SNIa 328 1
43 NGC 3432 AG? 10 52 31.132 +36 37 07.60   11.81 11.67 11.29   ~ 321 1
44 SN 2000ch SN* 10 52 41.40 +36 40 09.5     17.4     SNIIn? 104 2
45 SN 1996cb SN* 11 03 41.98 +28 54 13.7   14.22       SNIIb 119 1
46 NGC 3510 LSB 11 03 43.356 +28 53 13.58   13.6       ~ 199 0
47 SN 1973R SN* 11 20 11.5 +12 59 55   15.3 11.8     SNIIP 80 1
48 SN 1989B SN* 11 20 13.93 +13 00 18.9   12.25       SNIa 372 1
49 AT 1997bs ev 11 20 14.25 +12 58 19.6     17.13     SNIIn? 128 1
50 M 66 AGN 11 20 15.0 +12 59 29 9.85 9.65 8.92     ~ 1509 4
51 SN 2009hd SN* 11 20 16.99 +12 58 46.3           SNII 70 1
52 SN 1984R SN* 11 26 07.34 +43 35 05.8   16.0 13     ~ 9 1
53 NGC 3675 GiG 11 26 08.5641089832 +43 35 09.587062464   11.04   9.57   ~ 300 1
54 NGC 4096 GiG 12 06 01.161 +47 28 42.09   11.61   10.86   ~ 271 0
55 SN 1960H SN* 12 06 07.52 +47 30 38.1   14.5 14.5     SNIapec 22 1
56 NGC 4228 SBG 12 15 39.174 +36 19 36.80 10.63 10.30 9.93 9.74   ~ 1017 1
57 SN 1954A SN* 12 15 45 +36 16.2   9.3       SNIb 104 1
58 NGC 4242 GiG 12 17 30.1835103480 +45 37 09.508940220   11.37 10.83     ~ 285 1
59 SN 2002bu SN* 12 17 37.18 +45 38 47.4     15.5     SNIIn? 58 2
60 M 106 Sy2 12 18 57.620 +47 18 13.39   9.14 8.41 8.11   ~ 2512 4
61 SN 1981K SN* 12 18 59.42 +47 19 31.0   16.0 16.0     SNII 51 1
62 NGC 4490 GiG 12 30 34.5 +41 38 26 10.03 10.22 9.79     ~ 616 3
63 SN 1982F SN* 12 30 38 +41 38.0   16.2       SNIIP 43 1
64 SN 2008ax SN* 12 30 40.80 +41 38 16.1   23.6 23.5 14.1 22.6 SNIIb 295 1
65 NGC 4618 GiP 12 41 32.8976471760 +41 09 03.185175528 11.03 11.22 10.78     ~ 344 2
66 SN 1985F SN* 12 41 33.01 +41 09 05.9   12.1       SNIb 139 1
67 NAME NGC4656-OT SN* 12 43 45.84 +32 06 15.0           ~ 4 0
68 NGC 4656 GiP 12 43 57.6889089768 +32 10 13.345914504   10.96 10.52     ~ 385 3
69 SN 2005af SN* 13 04 44.06 -49 33 59.8     12.8     SNIIP 76 1
70 NGC 4945 Sy2 13 05 27.279 -49 28 04.44   9.31 14.40 7.55   ~ 1582 2
71 IC 4182 BiC 13 05 48.7478324064 +37 36 12.965157684   11.86   11.40   ~ 344 1
72 SN 1937C SN* 13 05 53.2 +37 36 07   8.80 8.77     SNIa 203 1
73 M 63 LIN 13 15 49.2741893928 +42 01 45.728076108   9.34 8.59 8.35   ~ 1292 2
74 SN 1971I SN* 13 15 49.6 +41 59 15   11.60       SNIa 75 1
75 NAME Centaurus A BLL 13 25 27.61521044 -43 01 08.8050291   8.18 6.84 6.66   ~ 4774 3
76 SN 1986G SN* 13 25 36.46 -43 01 53.6   12.45 11.44     SNIapec 422 1
77 M 51 Sy2 13 29 52.698 +47 11 42.93   9.26 8.36 8.40   ~ 4565 4
78 SN 2005cs SN* 13 29 53.37 +47 10 28.2   14.5       SNIIP 450 1
79 SN 1994I SN* 13 29 54.072 +47 11 30.50     12.9     SNIc 645 1
80 SN 1945A SN* 13 29 57 +47 16.3   14.0 14.0     SNI 25 1
81 NGC 5195 GiG 13 29 59.590 +47 15 58.06 10.76 10.45 9.55 9.31   ~ 816 3
82 SN 1945B SN* 13 36 51 -30 10.3   13.9       ~ 31 1
83 SN 1983N SN* 13 36 51.23 -29 54 01.7   11.7       SNIb 278 1
84 SN 1950B SN* 13 36 52.88 -29 51 55.7   14.5 14.5     ~ 58 1
85 SN 1968L SN* 13 37 00.42 -29 51 59.8   12.0 12.0     SNIIP 83 1
86 M 83 SBG 13 37 00.91920 -29 51 56.7400 8.85 8.11 7.52 7.21   ~ 2778 2
87 SN 1957D SN* 13 37 03.57 -29 49 40.7   15.0 15.0     ~ 121 1
88 SN 1923A SN* 13 37 09.2 -29 51 04   12.4 14.0     SNIIP: 80 1
89 SN 1972E SN* 13 39 52.7 -31 40 09   8.49 8.30     SNIa 309 1
90 SN 1895B SN* 13 39 55.9 -31 38 31   8.26       SNIa 24 3
91 NGC 5253 rG 13 39 55.990 -31 38 24.11 11.48 10.94 10.49 10.33 13.47 ~ 1421 4
92 SN 1909A SN* 14 02 03.17 +54 28 05.9   13.5 13.50     SNIIP: 59 1
93 SN 1970G SN* 14 03 00.83 +54 14 32.8   11.8 11.50     SNIIL 221 1
94 M 101 GiP 14 03 12.583 +54 20 55.50   8.46 7.86 7.76   ~ 3138 2
95 SN 1951H SN* 14 03 55.30 +54 21 41.0     17.5     SNII: 39 1
96 NAME Circinus Galaxy Sy2 14 13 09.906 -65 20 20.47   10.89 9.84 10.6 10.0 ~ 1331 1
97 SN 1996cr SN* 14 13 10.01139 -65 20 44.5654     19.5     SNIIn: 90 1
98 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7     5.95     ~ 2095 0
99 NGC 6633 OpC 18 27 30.2 +06 38 21           ~ 423 0
100 NAME Local Void vid 18 38 +18.0           ~ 234 0
101 NGC 6744 GiG 19 09 46.1335950504 -63 51 26.897079024   9.28 8.25 8.08 9.6 ~ 303 0
102 SN 2005at SN* 19 09 53.57 -63 49 22.8     14.3     SNIc 35 1
103 SN 1939C SN* 20 34 24.0678381888 +60 09 29.851268436   13.7 13.8     SNI: 41 1
104 SN 2002hh SN* 20 34 44.29 +60 07 19.0     17.18     SNIIP 158 1
105 SN 2008S ev 20 34 45.33 +60 05 58.4   19.89 18.79 17.93   SNIIn? 253 1
106 SN 1917A SN* 20 34 46.9 +60 07 29   13.6       SNII 52 1
107 SN 1969P SN* 20 34 51.3 +60 06 14   14.2       ~ 33 1
108 NGC 6946 H2G 20 34 52.332 +60 09 13.24   10.5       ~ 2661 2
109 SN 1968D SN* 20 34 58.40 +60 09 34.4   13.5 13.5     SNII 74 1
110 NGC 6949 AGN 20 35 06.9170240784 +64 48 10.045666548   15.0       ~ 65 0
111 SN 1948B SN* 20 35 21.5 +60 10 16   14.0 14.0     SNIIP 77 1
112 SN 2004et SN* 20 35 25.33 +60 07 17.7   12.88       SNIIP 547 1
113 SN 1980K SN* 20 35 30.07 +60 06 23.7   11.6       SNIIL 482 1
114 NGC 7063 OpC 21 24 30.2 +36 29 45   7.32 7.0     ~ 99 0
115 NGC 7713 EmG 23 36 15.154 -37 56 22.18   11.63   11.09 11.6 ~ 151 1
116 SN 1982L SN* 23 36 29 -37 55.9     16.0     SNII: 13 1
117 NGC 7793 GiG 23 57 49.7540045856 -32 35 27.701550744 10.26 9.74 9.28 9.06 9.7 ~ 1188 2
118 SN 2008bk SN* 23 57 50.42 -32 33 21.5           SNIIP 167 2
119 NAME Local Group GrG ~ ~           ~ 9325 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2012A&A...537A.132B and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu