2012ApJ...753..172S


Query : 2012ApJ...753..172S

2012ApJ...753..172S - Astrophys. J., 753, 172 (2012/July-2)

The nature of dust in compact galactic planetary nebulae from Spitzer spectra.

STANGHELLINI L., GARCIA-HERNANDEZ D.A., GARCIA-LARIO P., DAVIES J.E., SHAW R.A., VILLAVER E., MANCHADO A. and PEREA-CALDERON J.V.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present the Spitzer/Infrared Spectrograph (IRS) spectra of 157 compact Galactic planetary nebulae (PNe). These young PNe provide insight on the effects of dust in early post-asymptotic giant branch evolution, before much of the dust is altered or destroyed by the hardening stellar radiation field. Most of the selected targets have PN-type IRS spectra, while a few turned out to be misclassified stars. We inspected the group properties of the PN spectra and classified them based on the different dust classes (featureless or F, carbon-rich dust or CRD, oxygen-rich dust or ORD, mixed-chemistry dust or MCD) and subclasses (aromatic and aliphatic, and crystalline and amorphous). All PNe are characterized by dust continuum and more than 80% of the sample shows solid-state features above the continuum, in contrast with the Magellanic Cloud sample where only ∼40% of the entire sample displays solid-state features; this is an indication of the strong link between dust properties and metallicity. The Galactic PNe that show solid-state features are almost equally divided among the CRD, ORD, and MCD. We analyzed dust properties together with other PN properties and found that (1) there is an enhancement of MCD PNe toward the Galactic center, in agreement with studies of Galactic bulge PNe; (2) CRD PNe could be seen as defining an evolutionary sequence, contrary to the ORD and MCD PNe, which are scattered in all evolutionary diagrams; (3) carbon-rich and oxygen-rich grains retain different equilibrium temperatures, as expected from models; and (4) ORD PNe are highly asymmetric, i.e., bipolar or bipolar core, and CRD PNe highly symmetric, i.e., round or elliptical; point symmetry is statistically more common in MCD than in other dust class PNe. By comparing the sample of this paper to that of Magellanic Cloud PNe, we find that the latter sample does not include MCD PNe, and the other dust classes are differently populated, with continuity of the fraction of F, CRD, ORD, and MCD populations from high to low metallicity environments. We also find similar sequences for CRD PNe in the Galactic disk and the Magellanic Clouds, except that the Magellanic Cloud PNe seem to attain higher dust temperatures at similar evolutionary stages, in agreement with the observational findings of smaller dust grains (i.e., lower radiation efficiency) in low metallicity interstellar environments.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): planetary nebulae: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/753/172): table1.dat table3.dat table4.dat>

Simbad objects: 161

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 161
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NAME Magellanic Clouds GrG 03 00 -71.0           ~ 7988 0
2 PN MaC 2-1 PN 05 03 41.8528461912 -06 10 03.027145764     14.4     ~ 46 0
3 PN M 1-5 PN 05 46 50.0119955400 +24 22 02.848049436           ~ 123 1
4 PN M 1-12 PN 07 19 21.4685188440 -21 43 55.402228344     14.08     WC10-11 125 0
5 WRAY 16-8 PN 07 47 20.0414144496 -51 15 03.432601872   11.9 12.80     Of(H) 119 0
6 PN PB 2 PN 08 20 40.1874636648 -46 22 58.508819832     13.60     wels? 62 0
7 WRAY 15-344 PN 09 13 52.85 -55 28 17.2     13.70     ~ 58 0
8 PN My 47 PN 09 19 27.50 -59 12 00.3   12.7 12.40     ~ 70 0
9 WRAY 16-56 Sy* 09 41 13.9986771624 -49 22 47.206454520     16.686   13.542 C-rich 81 1
10 WRAY 16-66 PN 10 07 23.6183570256 -63 54 30.063363120     13.80     ~ 56 0
11 PN Pe 1-1 PN 10 38 27.5856481368 -56 47 07.226821644   15.855 14.178 15.394   [WC4/5] 108 1
12 PN Pe 2-7 PN 10 41 19.59 -56 09 16.2     15.20     ~ 34 0
13 WRAY 16-86 PN 11 17 43.1561941272 -70 49 32.165781780   12.3 14.00     ~ 46 0
14 WRAY 16-88 PN 11 24 01.04424 -52 51 19.3860         16.245 ~ 58 0
15 WRAY 16-94 PN 11 31 45.4605161808 -65 58 14.143658844     14.30     ~ 67 0
16 WRAY 16-100 PN 11 48 38.0955840000 -65 08 36.445176132   14.595 13.036 14.833   ~ 93 1
17 WRAY 16-107 PN 12 09 10.2069705456 -58 42 37.284368328     15.20     ~ 39 0
18 WRAY 16-117 PN 12 30 30.4344727152 -64 52 05.689186752   14.55 15.00     [WC4] 130 0
19 PN MyCn 18 PN 13 39 35.0596178496 -67 22 51.750497136   13.30 12.54 13.19 12.61 ~ 293 1
20 WRAY 16-133 PN 13 42 36.1638733080 -61 22 28.912461456     15.86     ~ 61 0
21 PN MaC 1-2 PN 13 54 27.067 -64 59 36.14           ~ 30 1
22 WRAY 16-141 Sy* 13 54 55.6938014256 -58 27 16.518257496     15.00     K?e 65 1
23 WRAY 16-162 PN 15 05 16.80 -55 11 10.5     14.50     ~ 119 0
24 WRAY 16-178 PN 15 23 36.35 -53 51 28.1     15.00     ~ 63 0
25 WRAY 16-182 PN 15 25 32.6550631928 -52 50 37.942546489     15.20     ~ 55 0
26 WRAY 15-1341 PN 15 41 58.83 -56 36 25.6     14.50     ~ 77 0
27 WRAY 16-194 PN 15 58 08.1032974200 -55 41 50.351235504     15.60     ~ 91 0
28 PN StWr 4-10 PN 16 02 13.0530888744 -41 33 36.067165524   13.9 15.00     [WC2/3] 61 0
29 PN H 1-1 Em* 16 13 28.1768868744 -34 35 39.387943572   10.72 9.61     ~ 60 0
30 WRAY 16-208 Sy* 16 14 01.1094201648 -56 59 28.043753388     16.00     M8/9e 93 1
31 Hen 2-149 PN 16 14 24.266 -54 47 38.82           ~ 54 0
32 WRAY 15-1440 PN 16 15 42.2912711376 -59 54 01.013284224     13.08     B0 88 0
33 WRAY 16-217 PN 16 22 14.3332450878 -53 40 54.122927915     15.50     ~ 67 0
34 WRAY 16-218 PN 16 23 30.6466211640 -58 19 22.800710784   13.7 13.90     ~ 76 0
35 Hen 2-178 PN 16 42 33.4932941808 -38 54 40.139817336   15.48 13.95 14.23   ~ 47 0
36 ESO 332-1 PN 16 46 45.1437388968 -38 36 58.034908296   12.5       Be 37 0
37 ESO 332-2 PN 16 49 32.85 -39 21 09.1           ~ 33 0
38 ESO 332-4 PN 16 51 33.575 -40 02 56.01           ~ 28 0
39 PN H 1-4 PN 16 53 37.0764407952 -31 40 33.135570228   13.6 13.1     ~ 42 0
40 HD 151895 PN 16 54 35.1297096456 -64 14 28.564429056   12.03 11.72     O(H)4-8III-V 108 0
41 WRAY 15-1585 PN 16 59 36.1292977968 -51 42 08.621516808     14.30     ~ 95 0
42 CD-53 7049 PN 17 03 02.8784604504 -53 55 53.966024508   11.84 11.48     B/Ae 70 1
43 PN Sa 1-5 PN 17 11 27.3945863181 -47 25 02.050977873     15.60     ~ 33 0
44 PN M 2-10 PN 17 14 07.0266004296 -31 19 42.983628132     15.00     ~ 85 0
45 PN H 1-8 PN 17 14 42.93 -33 24 47.4     13.6     ~ 62 0
46 PN Th 3-6 PN 17 19 20.2424693280 -31 12 40.849468344           ~ 35 0
47 PN M 3-40 PN 17 22 28.2905114736 -27 08 42.369295200           ~ 71 0
48 PN Th 3-10 PN 17 24 40.90 -30 51 59.6           ~ 43 0
49 PN Th 3-12 PN 17 25 06.1265978981 -29 45 16.998857110         15.647 ~ 47 0
50 PN M 3-10 PN 17 27 20.19 -28 27 51.2     14.40     ~ 95 0
51 PN H 1-18 PN 17 29 42.76 -29 32 50.3           ~ 75 0
52 PN H 1-19 PN 17 30 02.57 -27 59 17.5     16.30     ~ 78 0
53 WRAY 16-278 PN 17 30 03.8807837544 -45 22 50.719871748     15.70     ~ 21 0
54 PN Al 2-E PN 17 30 14.4363597912 -27 30 20.385097740     17.50     ~ 42 0
55 PN Al 2-F PN 17 30 30.44 -28 35 54.9     17.50     ~ 29 0
56 PN Th 3-24 PN 17 30 51.354 -30 17 12.49           ~ 27 0
57 PN Th 3-55 PN 17 30 58.838 -31 01 05.73           ~ 38 0
58 PN H 2-13 PN 17 31 08.11 -30 10 28.3     16.60   18.501 ~ 45 0
59 PN H 1-22 PN 17 32 22.1496278448 -37 57 23.714516232     16.70     ~ 35 0
60 PN H 1-23 PN 17 32 46.92 -30 00 14.9     16.00     ~ 77 0
61 PN H 1-21 PN 17 32 47.8114390416 -40 58 28.653130920     15.20     ~ 31 0
62 WRAY 16-286 PN 17 33 00.67 -36 43 51.8     15.40     ~ 48 0
63 PN M 4-6 PN 17 35 13.99 -29 03 10.6           ~ 62 0
64 PN Th 3-32 Be* 17 35 15.4584141096 -28 07 02.573354532   18.8 17 15.1 15.13 Be 29 1
65 WRAY 16-290 PN 17 36 06.9416309496 -49 25 45.242375808   13.5 14.50     ~ 41 0
66 PN Bl B PN 17 36 59.836 -29 40 08.93           ~ 31 0
67 PN H 2-17 PN 17 40 07.4258459184 -24 25 42.592055448     16.00     ~ 83 0
68 PN H 2-18 PN 17 43 28.7517226002 -21 09 51.615242509         15.912 ~ 79 0
69 PN H 1-29 WV* 17 44 13.8729577601 -34 17 32.824856894     14.90 16.04 14.90 [WC4/6] 76 0
70 PN Sa 2-237 PN 17 44 42.282 -15 45 11.45   16.1 15.5     ~ 36 0
71 NAME Galactic Center reg 17 45 39.60213 -29 00 22.0000           ~ 16269 0
72 PN Th 4-1 PN 17 46 20.8184146392 -20 13 48.276182748           ~ 38 0
73 PN H 1-33 PN 17 47 49.4162559989 -34 08 05.126681277     15.30     ~ 66 1
74 PN H 1-34 PN 17 48 07.572 -22 46 47.33           ~ 45 0
75 PN Th 4-3 PN 17 48 37.390 -22 16 48.79           ~ 37 0
76 PN Th 4-6 PN 17 50 57.24 -18 46 48.4           ~ 36 0
77 PN H 2-27 PN 17 51 50.5693182432 -33 47 36.313494108           ~ 39 0
78 PN Bl 3-15 PN 17 52 35.87 -29 06 38.6           ~ 37 0
79 OGLE BLG-LPV-102396 LP* 17 53 36.4656690192 -31 25 25.842199368     19.215   13.967 ~ 25 0
80 PN Pe 2-10 PN 17 53 37.22 -21 58 41.8           ~ 29 0
81 PN Bl O PN 17 53 49.7366933616 -28 59 11.534113500       16.23   ~ 36 0
82 PN Cn 2-1 PN 17 54 33.010 -34 22 21.15     12.70 14.47 13.70 ~ 136 0
83 PN H 2-31 PN 17 56 02.350 -28 14 11.36           ~ 31 0
84 PN H 2-32 PN 17 56 24.3326114424 -29 38 06.740932164     15.60     ~ 41 0
85 WRAY 16-330 PN 17 56 33.7099931280 -43 03 19.135687320   13.4 13.60     ~ 51 0
86 PN Th 4-10 PN 17 57 06.599 -18 06 43.43           ~ 44 0
87 PN M 3-47 PN 17 57 43.367 -30 02 29.91           ~ 28 0
88 PN H 1-44 EB* 17 58 10.6463633856 -31 42 55.980086112     17.00   18.939 ~ 66 0
89 PN H 1-46 PN 17 59 02.5031407080 -32 21 43.494698556     14.30     ~ 83 0
90 PN KFL 4 PN 18 02 51.67 -27 40 59.6           ~ 29 0
91 PN M 3-50 PN 18 04 05.183 -34 28 37.39           ~ 41 0
92 PN M 1-37 PN 18 05 25.8092901000 -28 22 04.282489956     14.70     [WC11]? 135 0
93 PN H 1-53 PN 18 05 57.4366602508 -26 29 42.153615022           ~ 55 1
94 PN M 1-38 PN 18 06 05.74 -28 40 30.0     13.90     ~ 106 0
95 IRAS 18042-0855 PN 18 06 59.8024112599 -08 55 32.973045447   15.2 14.3   15.852 ~ 26 0
96 PN H 1-56 PN 18 07 53.8842030888 -29 44 34.338810768     15.00     O? 85 0
97 PN H 2-39 PN 18 08 05.759 -28 26 10.50           ~ 46 0
98 PN KFL 11 PN 18 10 12.244 -27 16 35.00           ~ 36 0
99 PN KFL 12 PN 18 10 30.807 -28 19 22.91           ~ 36 0
100 PN MaC 1-11 PN 18 14 50.89 -22 43 55.7           ~ 34 0
101 PN M 3-25 PN 18 15 16.97376 -10 10 09.3612           ~ 55 0
102 PN M 1-44 PN 18 16 17.3419504152 -27 04 30.536970384   12.5 12.5     Be 86 0
103 PN H 2-46 PN 18 18 37.4530403160 -31 54 45.330851160           ~ 35 1
104 PN M 2-39 PN 18 22 01.1620945464 -24 10 39.916889760     15.00     wels 82 0
105 PN M 2-42 PN 18 22 32.08 -24 09 27.7     13.90     ~ 84 0
106 PN M 1-45 PN 18 23 07.9832213304 -19 17 05.323374528           ~ 59 0
107 PN Sa 3-134 PN 18 29 19.82 -15 07 39.9           ~ 20 0
108 PN MA 13 PN 18 30 30.3940394160 -07 27 38.178410436           ~ 25 0
109 WRAY 16-413 PN 18 31 52.8340461600 -24 46 17.691242340     16.30     ~ 40 0
110 PN M 3-54 PN 18 33 03.745 -13 44 19.95           ~ 41 0
111 PN K 3-6 PN 18 33 17.4969402000 +00 11 46.782624084     16.5     ~ 40 0
112 PN M 4-10 PN 18 34 13.85 -13 12 24.7           ~ 41 0
113 PN V-V 3-5 PN 18 36 32.2456168272 -19 19 29.071857828   12.20 11.72     ~ 52 0
114 PN M 1-55 PN 18 36 33.8579678454 -21 49 02.698282618       14.02 13.20 ~ 52 0
115 PN V-V 3 PN 18 37 11.11 -19 02 21.9           ~ 47 0
116 PN K 3-11 PN 18 41 07.311 -08 55 58.97           ~ 45 0
117 PN K 3-13 PN 18 45 24.6682212456 +02 01 25.376350188           ~ 34 0
118 PN Pe 2-15 PN 18 45 27.542 -06 56 57.43           ~ 27 0
119 PN M 1-61 PN 18 45 55.12 -14 27 37.9           ~ 116 0
120 PN H 2-48 PN 18 46 35.1182447568 -23 26 48.261468804     13     OIII-V 94 0
121 PN K 3-14 PN 18 48 32.8112121864 +10 35 50.714952360   10       O8-9 42 0
122 PN M 1-62 PN 18 50 26.0470300152 -22 34 22.707895260           [WC] 54 0
123 PN G044.1+05.8 PN 18 50 46.8610793064 +12 37 29.843864796           ~ 21 0
124 PN K 3-15 PN 18 51 41.54 +09 54 52.6           ~ 36 0
125 PN K 4-8 PN 18 54 20.0197786200 -08 47 33.234394848           ~ 38 0
126 PN Hb 7 PN 18 55 37.8037363176 -32 15 48.553611372   12.58 11.65 13.61   O3 98 0
127 PN Sp 4-1 PN 19 00 26.5460404944 +38 21 07.280102016       15.26   O? 40 0
128 PN K 3-19 PN 19 01 36.575 -01 19 07.85           ~ 44 0
129 PN K 3-20 PN 19 02 10.1580699528 -01 48 45.405616140           ~ 38 0
130 PN K 4-16 PN 19 04 51.5055791208 +15 47 39.125257584           ~ 41 0
131 PN K 4-19 PN 19 13 22.6022844000 +03 25 00.209394048           B1I 27 0
132 PN M 1-69 PN 19 13 53.890 +03 37 41.78   15.26 13.70     WC 31 0
133 SS 438 PN 19 14 59.7259060224 +17 22 46.027654716   14.715 13.582 13.179   B9IV:e 49 0
134 PN K 3-29 PN 19 15 30.5684625864 +14 03 49.876616808           ~ 41 0
135 IC 4846 PN 19 16 28.2266496960 -09 02 36.677150592           ~ 221 0
136 PN K 3-31 PN 19 19 02.6456875992 +19 02 21.008706036           ~ 48 0
137 WRAY 16-423 PN 19 22 10.63 -31 30 38.7   13.0 14.20     ~ 51 0
138 PN K 3-33 PN 19 22 26.6674857936 +10 41 21.260931252           ~ 44 1
139 PN K 3-37 PN 19 33 46.75 +24 32 27.1           ~ 39 0
140 NGC 6807 PN 19 34 33.53 +05 41 02.5     12     ~ 144 0
141 PN K 3-39 PN 19 35 54.469 +24 54 48.20           ~ 40 0
142 PN K 3-40 PN 19 36 21.81 +23 39 47.7           ~ 35 0
143 PN M 1-71 PN 19 36 26.9207484077 +19 42 24.018831075           [WC] 92 1
144 Hen 2-440 PN 19 38 08.36 +25 15 41.1           ~ 44 1
145 PN K 3-41 PN 19 39 15.86 +16 20 46.7           ~ 37 0
146 PN K 3-43 PN 19 40 25.908 +18 49 14.20           ~ 25 0
147 NGC 6833 PN 19 49 46.5667474512 +48 57 40.113276876           ~ 181 0
148 PN K 3-49 PN 19 54 00.6166935384 +33 22 12.491081616           ~ 38 0
149 PN K 4-41 PN 19 56 34.027 +32 22 12.96           ~ 47 0
150 PN K 3-52 PN 20 03 11.44 +30 32 34.1           ~ 48 0
151 PN K 3-54 PN 20 04 58.6341865368 +25 26 37.272489324           ~ 49 0
152 PN K 3-56 PN 20 06 55.385 +44 14 18.65           ~ 37 0
153 PN KjPn 2 PN 20 15 22.19 +40 34 44.6   19.8 17.6     ~ 27 0
154 PN K 3-78 PN 20 45 22.6885835640 +50 22 39.860086116           ~ 36 0
155 PN K 3-62 PN 21 31 50.1857850312 +52 33 51.571785996           ~ 87 1
156 PN G097.6-02.4 PN 21 57 41.7846489624 +51 41 39.289876548           ~ 77 0
157 PN Bl 2-1 PN 22 20 16.62720 +58 14 16.5624           ~ 53 1
158 PN K 4-57 PN 22 48 34.3251773808 +58 29 08.268148248           ~ 30 0
159 PN K 3-87 PN 22 55 06.9347561376 +56 42 31.022604684           ~ 40 0
160 PN KjPn 8 PN 23 24 10.472 +60 57 30.75           ~ 123 0
161 NAME Galactic Bulge reg ~ ~           ~ 4794 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2012ApJ...753..172S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu