2012MNRAS.420.2884S


Query : 2012MNRAS.420.2884S

2012MNRAS.420.2884S - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 420, 2884-2898 (2012/March-2)

Dust discs around intermediate-mass and Sun-like stars in the 16 Myr old NGC 1960 open cluster.

SMITH R. and JEFFRIES R.D.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present an analysis of Spitzer IRAC (3.6–8 µm) and MIPS (24 µm) imaging of members of the 165+10 Myr old open cluster NGC 1960 (M36). Models of terrestrial planet formation indicate that rocky planets are likely to achieve their final masses at around 10–30 Myr, and thus this cluster is at an interesting epoch for planet formation. We find 21 B–F5 type stars and 14 F6–K9 type stars which have 24 µm excess emission, and thus determine that >30 per cent of B–F5 type stars and >23 per cent of F6–K9 type stars in this cluster have 24 µm excess emission. These excess frequencies are similar to those observed in other clusters of similar age. Three early-type stars have excesses at near-infrared wavelengths. Analysis of their spectral energy distributions confirms that these are true debris discs and not remnant primordial or transitional discs. None of the 61 Sun-like stars has confirmed near-infrared excess, and we can place a limit on the frequency of 8 µm excess emission around Sun-like stars of <7 per cent. All of the detected excesses are consistent with emission from debris discs and are not primordial.

Abstract Copyright: 2012 The Authors Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society2012 RAS

Journal keyword(s): circumstellar matter - open clusters and associations: individual: NGC 1960 - infrared: stars

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/MNRAS/420/2884): table1.dat table2.dat table3.dat table4.dat>

Nomenclature: Tables 2+4: [SJ2012] N-NNNN N=69.

Simbad objects: 156

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 156
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 Cl Blanco 1 OpC 00 03 04.1 -29 48 55           ~ 380 0
2 NGC 869 OpC 02 18 57.0 +57 08 02           ~ 504 0
3 NAME NGC 869/884 OpC 02 20.5 +57 08           ~ 72 0
4 NGC 884 OpC 02 22 15.7 +57 08 59           ~ 503 0
5 Cl Melotte 22 OpC 03 46 38.0 +24 10 41           ~ 3679 0
6 Cl Melotte 25 OpC 04 30 27.4 +16 46 43           ~ 3309 0
7 Ass Ori OB 1b As* 05 34.0 -01 30           ~ 281 0
8 ZTF J053432.25+335545.5 BY* 05 34 32.2494757098 +33 55 45.544894394           ~ 4 0
9 ZTF J053437.08+340307.1 BY* 05 34 37.0830140760 +34 03 07.152166872 17.655         ~ 5 0
10 NAME Orion Nebula Cluster OpC 05 35.0 -05 29           ~ 2514 0
11 * lam Ori ** 05 35 08.27761 +09 56 02.9611 2.45 3.48 3.66 3.72 3.89 O8IIIf+B0.5V 327 0
12 [BNM2013] 60.04 581 * 05 35 27.4388759112 +34 08 30.846102108 15.974         ~ 2 0
13 NGC 1960 231 Y*O 05 35 30.2328766080 +34 10 58.827984276   12.443 12.262     B8IV 9 0
14 [BNM2013] 60.01 504 * 05 35 40.7902314624 +33 57 31.079910996 16.479         ~ 3 0
15 NGC 1960 152 Y*O 05 35 42.2953445184 +34 10 54.658937856   11.28 11.26     ~ 12 0
16 NGC 1960 151 Y*O 05 35 44.1931352016 +34 10 28.623536724 16.201 15.338 14.741     ~ 9 0
17 NGC 1960 153 * 05 35 46.8023465088 +34 11 49.185162240   14.484 13.805     ~ 3 0
18 2MASS J05354817+3409152 * 05 35 48.1642072440 +34 09 15.271049484 19.616         ~ 6 0
19 NGC 1960 154 Y*O 05 35 49.1048518872 +34 11 56.048083368   12.614 12.448     ~ 8 0
20 [BNM2013] 60.04 485 * 05 35 49.1500693080 +34 06 15.045354252 17.375         ~ 5 0
21 [BNM2013] 60.04 697 * 05 35 51.2997436392 +34 09 33.337148436 21.253         ~ 5 0
22 NGC 1960 123 Y*O 05 35 51.6557186256 +34 10 32.451887316   11.64 11.53     B8V 13 0
23 NGC 1960 118 * 05 35 52.0836777192 +34 07 38.670224628   13.405 13.128     ~ 3 0
24 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 124 Y*O 05 35 52.1435016480 +34 06 47.961117288 16.548 15.666 14.963     ~ 9 0
25 NGC 1960 120 Y*O 05 35 52.3785292115 +34 08 57.507063661   13.876 13.481     ~ 11 0
26 [BNM2013] 60.04 464 * 05 35 53.1102728520 +34 06 46.478283696 20.693         ~ 2 0
27 [BNM2013] 60.03 773 * 05 35 53.5808733504 +34 16 03.456810264 20.297         ~ 5 0
28 2MASS J05355574+3358535 * 05 35 55.7443681656 +33 58 53.568819048 20.267         ~ 5 0
29 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 161 * 05 35 58.0450066896 +34 03 04.419780372 17.133 16.297 15.400     ~ 8 0
30 NGC 1960 83 Y*O 05 35 58.3948886568 +34 08 11.650139628 16.149   14.75     ~ 9 0
31 [BNM2013] 60.04 440 Y*O 05 35 58.6982904048 +34 13 47.730939780 19.379         ~ 6 0
32 2MASS J05355878+3409253 Em* 05 35 58.7820850411 +34 09 25.301686461           ~ 6 0
33 NGC 1960 87 Y*O 05 35 59.2713324456 +34 10 27.370198704   10.72 10.65     A2III 16 0
34 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 165 Y*O 05 35 59.3361234956 +34 05 35.311053013 17.049 16.221 15.446     ~ 10 0
35 NGC 1960 85 Y*? 05 36 01.9566449040 +34 09 17.625117672   11.458 11.290     ~ 9 0
36 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 125 Y*O 05 36 01.9789358616 +34 10 50.888753724 16.656 15.762 14.989     ~ 9 0
37 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 85 * 05 36 02.074 +34 14 12.44   14.133 13.594     ~ 2 0
38 BD+34 1098 Y*O 05 36 02.3878778016 +34 06 50.922605268   10.03 9.987     ~ 22 0
39 NGC 1960 79 Y*O 05 36 02.6600469120 +34 06 06.170243796   12.05 11.93     ~ 8 0
40 NGC 1960 89 Y*O 05 36 03.0745873716 +34 11 13.686424493   13.451 13.134     ~ 10 0
41 NGC 1960 86 * 05 36 03.2798617272 +34 10 07.823624808   10.71 10.65     ~ 9 0
42 NGC 1960 158 * 05 36 03.5836238328 +34 15 36.493561836   13.194 12.957     ~ 3 0
43 [BNM2013] 60.01 752 * 05 36 03.9267411552 +34 02 08.286623232           ~ 4 0
44 2MASS J05360580+3405514 Y*O 05 36 05.8051075800 +34 05 51.515553372 17.801         ~ 7 0
45 NGC 1960 92 * 05 36 05.9323860864 +34 12 03.225940452   11.01 10.96     ~ 8 0
46 IRAS 05327+3404 Y*O 05 36 05.9747181336 +34 06 11.867057640     18.62     K2IIIe 17 1
47 NGC 1960 45 * 05 36 06.7888600752 +34 06 46.047207960   13.583 13.207     ~ 8 0
48 NGC 1960 47 Em* 05 36 07.2042246624 +34 08 03.267208104   10.56 10.44     ~ 13 0
49 NGC 1960 50 * 05 36 07.7439103368 +34 09 25.055606736   11.81 11.61     ~ 10 0
50 BD+34 1099 * 05 36 07.8930998184 +34 08 50.344691964   9.43 9.36     B3 15 0
51 NGC 1960 53 Y*O 05 36 08.0267058744 +34 09 52.685908704   13.901 13.477     ~ 9 0
52 2MASS J05360820+3417504 Y*O 05 36 08.2085614656 +34 17 50.377991640 16.675         ~ 8 0
53 NGC 1960 54 Y*O 05 36 08.3584818192 +34 10 12.161152884   13.632 13.329     ~ 9 0
54 2MASS J05360849+3407377 * 05 36 08.4926912208 +34 07 37.781874912 18.422         ~ 6 0
55 2MASS J05360855+3404063 * 05 36 08.5483433712 +34 04 06.463663140 16.442         ~ 7 0
56 2MASS J05360891+3405161 * 05 36 08.9112498816 +34 05 16.206774180 20.007         ~ 6 0
57 2MASS J05360891+3357245 Y*O 05 36 08.9137703052 +33 57 24.604894081 16.275         ~ 10 0
58 BD+34 1101 * 05 36 09.7722048120 +34 11 35.938194864   10.41 10.37     ~ 17 0
59 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 122 Y*O 05 36 10.4298216552 +34 08 06.664457364 16.462 15.673 14.937     ~ 9 0
60 [SJ2012] 1-138 Y*O 05 36 10.6042759217 +33 52 48.096878655           ~ 6 0
61 NGC 1960 90 Y*O 05 36 10.8880569408 +34 11 21.644867112   13.695 13.338     ~ 9 0
62 NGC 1960 44 Y*O 05 36 11.5371829344 +34 07 06.435692832   11.47 11.38     B2V 18 0
63 NGC 1960 18 Y*O 05 36 12.5631742752 +34 08 58.559507772   10.86 10.78     B2III 17 0
64 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 142 * 05 36 12.8533846632 +34 09 53.234133984   16.001 15.167     ~ 4 0
65 2MASS J05361322+3406246 Y*O 05 36 13.2239917536 +34 06 24.517815228 19.258         ~ 8 0
66 NGC 1960 19 * 05 36 13.5497482560 +34 09 25.067693088   14.111 13.529     ~ 3 0
67 NGC 1960 94 * 05 36 13.6531373832 +34 12 43.086694500   13.902 13.342     ~ 3 0
68 2MASS J05361377+3407160 Y*O 05 36 13.7769820056 +34 07 16.053422160           ~ 7 0
69 2MASS J05361400+3411070 Y*O 05 36 14.0011479321 +34 11 07.042707453           ~ 6 0
70 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 162 Y*O 05 36 14.6737328280 +34 10 09.289727904 17.156 16.248 15.403     ~ 9 0
71 NGC 1960 13 * 05 36 15.2889670248 +34 07 12.435792456   10.93 10.80     ~ 12 0
72 NGC 1960 112 Y*O 05 36 15.6110383752 +34 03 25.177158324   12.51 12.30     ~ 9 0
73 2MASS J05361571+3403538 * 05 36 15.7157016888 +34 03 53.814853584 17.132         ~ 7 0
74 BD+34 1103 * 05 36 15.8001138168 +34 08 36.630196080 8.2 8.82 8.79     B2V 26 1
75 2MASS J05361601+3401045 Y*? 05 36 16.0089104211 +34 01 04.574330164 17.186         ~ 8 0
76 2MASS J05361697+3412434 * 05 36 16.9775078503 +34 12 43.483742252           ~ 5 0
77 NGC 1960 1 Y*O 05 36 17.8419693984 +34 09 14.695941924   14.514 13.971     ~ 9 0
78 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 168 * 05 36 17.9664136392 +34 05 38.598002592 17.432 16.429 15.478     ~ 7 0
79 NGC 1960 20 Y*O 05 36 18.5711724854 +34 10 46.028599588   12.591 12.300     ~ 10 0
80 NGC 1960 55 Y*? 05 36 19.4900488968 +34 12 14.766244308   11.72 11.62     ~ 11 0
81 M 36 OpC 05 36 19.8 +34 08 02   6.09 6.0     ~ 206 2
82 NGC 1960 41 Y*O 05 36 20.0269148544 +34 06 11.461575852   12.57 12.38     ~ 9 0
83 NGC 1960 40 Y*O 05 36 20.7528223344 +34 06 50.158643364   12.624 12.327     ~ 9 0
84 NGC 1960 57 Y*O 05 36 20.8926332208 +34 12 43.071118164   11.88 11.76     ~ 10 0
85 LS V +34 52 * 05 36 21.0569597424 +34 10 16.715126964 9.17 9.63 9.6     B2 25 1
86 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 157 Y*O 05 36 21.2037107616 +34 05 25.280899872 16.988         ~ 10 0
87 NGC 1960 12 Y*O 05 36 21.2457635784 +34 07 06.437448300   13.182 12.931     ~ 7 0
88 NGC 1960 22 Y*O 05 36 21.5338246056 +34 09 51.115803948   12.387 12.205     ~ 9 0
89 [BNM2013] 60.04 271 * 05 36 21.8124953016 +34 05 34.025792460 18.203         ~ 5 0
90 NGC 1960 11 Y*O 05 36 22.1388928320 +34 07 13.763547984   10.98 10.99     ~ 11 1
91 NGC 1960 39 Y*O 05 36 22.5288771528 +34 06 08.182771380   13.664 13.309     ~ 8 0
92 ZTF J053622.56+335517.8 BY* 05 36 22.5676261032 +33 55 17.858736660 17.698         ~ 9 0
93 ZTF J053622.96+340341.6 BY* 05 36 22.9624300968 +34 03 41.625908460 17.975         ~ 11 0
94 2MASS J05362301+3406163 Y*O 05 36 23.0150572992 +34 06 16.388805384 18.405         ~ 8 0
95 BD+34 1109 Y*O 05 36 23.0536418832 +34 10 32.671308756 8.29 8.97 8.96     B3 24 0
96 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 140 Y*O 05 36 23.6536548264 +34 11 02.861284128 16.785 15.877 15.163     ~ 9 0
97 BD+34 1108 Y*O 05 36 23.8384355160 +34 05 57.187916844   9.97 9.92     ~ 15 0
98 NGC 1960 73 Y*O 05 36 24.0253794009 +34 04 43.236414070 15.835   14.57     ~ 11 0
99 NGC 1960 5 Y*O 05 36 24.4405142352 +34 08 28.222679940   13.052 12.824     ~ 7 0
100 NGC 1960 25 Y*O 05 36 25.0176966960 +34 09 17.461869228 16.158 15.341 14.695     ~ 10 0
101 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 139 Y*O 05 36 25.1895597768 +34 13 03.974626344   15.897 15.159     ~ 8 0
102 NGC 1960 59 Y*O 05 36 25.6621525848 +34 11 31.117576812   13.407 13.106     ~ 9 0
103 [BNM2013] 60.01 252 * 05 36 26.2916361864 +33 57 57.220721568 16.093         ~ 2 0
104 NGC 1960 34 Y*O 05 36 26.4979678289 +34 07 18.286380594   14.581 13.953     ~ 10 0
105 NGC 1960 36 * 05 36 26.5815760512 +34 06 21.280502304   13.105 12.735     ~ 3 0
106 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 186 * 05 36 28.023 +34 14 37.12   16.59 15.631     ~ 2 0
107 BD+34 1110 Y*O 05 36 28.0300078392 +34 08 30.616662048 8.49 9.60 9.58     B2 33 0
108 NGC 1960 30 Y*O 05 36 28.0439492712 +34 07 49.051096860   11.09 11.23     ~ 11 0
109 [BNM2013] 60.04 648 * 05 36 28.2805400778 +34 08 10.028582831 21.605         ~ 8 0
110 NGC 1960 33 Y*O 05 36 28.3581037477 +34 07 21.492439873   11.99 11.87     ~ 8 0
111 2MASS J05362892+3413229 Y*O 05 36 28.9271640168 +34 13 23.049454152           ~ 7 0
112 2MASS J05362907+3402100 Y*O 05 36 29.0750538648 +34 02 10.006807308 19.578         ~ 8 0
113 NGC 1960 31 Y*O 05 36 29.1061014312 +34 07 42.065224500 15.520 14.659 14.116     ~ 10 0
114 2MASS J05362945+3412152 * 05 36 29.4511775976 +34 12 15.292088748 20.984         ~ 8 0
115 NGC 1960 28 Y*O 05 36 29.4610729560 +34 08 07.812026484   12.996 12.795     ~ 9 0
116 NGC 1960 69 Y*O 05 36 30.8168800632 +34 06 06.434586828   12.63 12.43     ~ 8 0
117 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 166 * 05 36 31.7747633400 +34 04 11.713026900 17.341 16.293 15.460     ~ 7 0
118 BD+34 1111 Y*O 05 36 31.9963632576 +34 10 47.269705620   9.10 9.09     B2V: 36 0
119 NGC 1960 64 Y*O 05 36 33.7800799392 +34 08 04.366027680   14.165 13.755     ~ 9 0
120 NGC 1960 67 Y*O 05 36 33.9389298888 +34 07 17.559726384   12.568 12.409     ~ 9 0
121 [BNM2013] 60.01 212 Y*O 05 36 33.9480780792 +33 52 57.300092544 20.036         ~ 6 0
122 NGC 1960 128 * 05 36 34.0900143216 +34 14 50.371061784     13.97     ~ 7 0
123 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 208 Y*O 05 36 34.5500454168 +34 04 18.047867304   16.683 15.870     ~ 7 0
124 NGC 1960 109 Y*O 05 36 34.7708350608 +34 03 55.472223420   10.78 10.70     B2I 15 0
125 NGC 1960 108 Y*O 05 36 36.4434534552 +34 04 17.131256544   12.38 12.212     ~ 9 0
126 NGC 1960 62 * 05 36 36.6448117344 +34 10 24.702939120   12.04 12.47     ~ 10 0
127 2MASS J05363683+3408253 * 05 36 36.8360239200 +34 08 25.415916144           ~ 7 0
128 2MASS J05363906+3417573 Y*O 05 36 39.0630734184 +34 17 57.315994908 18.800         ~ 7 0
129 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 170 Y*O 05 36 39.1580093904 +34 11 42.723151440 17.796 16.313 15.496     ~ 8 0
130 HD 245239 Y*? 05 36 39.2560665480 +34 03 49.810263876   9.00 8.94     B3 22 0
131 NGC 1960 66 Y*O 05 36 39.7418946960 +34 06 44.772079356   13.844 13.486     ~ 8 0
132 NGC 1960 65 Y*O 05 36 40.8667894897 +34 07 47.219029682   12.893 12.680     ~ 8 0
133 2MASS J05364107+3403099 Y*O 05 36 41.0756493192 +34 03 09.874997964 17.007         ~ 8 0
134 BD+34 1113 Be* 05 36 42.3020005224 +34 12 05.944874688 8.59 9.14 9.14     B2 51 0
135 2MASS J05364579+3405598 Y*O 05 36 45.7983098715 +34 05 59.727427266           ~ 8 0
136 Cl* NGC 1960 SAB 135 * 05 36 48.062 +34 12 09.38   15.917 15.110     ~ 2 0
137 [SJ2012] 4-615 * 05 36 49.2934826919 +34 08 16.839277385           ~ 5 0
138 2MASS J05365195+3404354 * 05 36 51.9462594408 +34 04 35.265502596 19.096         ~ 7 0
139 2MASS J05365290+3412133 * 05 36 52.8962815608 +34 12 13.293441900 16.703         ~ 7 0
140 2MASS J05365762+3406262 * 05 36 57.6186649509 +34 06 26.274145396 16.697         ~ 10 0
141 NGC 1960 169 Y*O 05 36 58.6875060888 +34 06 52.777930176 15.533   14.23     ~ 9 0
142 NGC 1960 212 * 05 37 04.8137503056 +34 03 43.190553492 16.222   15.24     ~ 6 0
143 2MASS J05371127+3413388 Y*O 05 37 11.2707153864 +34 13 38.875522188           ~ 8 0
144 * zet Lep * 05 46 57.3413646658 -14 49 19.020570470   3.637 3.525     A2IV-V(n) 308 0
145 NGC 2232 OpC 06 27 45.6 -04 44 26           ~ 212 0
146 NGC 2547 OpC 08 10 01.5 -49 12 08           ~ 445 0
147 IC 2391 OpC 08 41 17.5 -53 03 00           ~ 871 0
148 NAME Lower Centaurus Crux As* 12 19 -57.1           ~ 565 1
149 NAME beta Pic Moving Group MGr 14 30 -42.0           ~ 894 0
150 NAME Upper Centaurus Lupus MGr 15 24 -41.9           ~ 567 1
151 NAME Upper Sco Association As* 16 12 -23.4           ~ 1586 1
152 NAME Upper Sco-Cen As* 16 15 -24.2           ~ 1497 1
153 IC 4665 OpC 17 46 04.0 +05 36 54           ~ 407 0
154 HD 172555 PM* 18 45 26.9009806435 -64 52 16.534807985   4.967 4.767     A7V 321 0
155 * eta Tel PM* 19 22 51.2060774616 -54 25 26.145617376   5.035 5.020   4.99 A0V 228 0
156 Ass Ori OB 1a As* ~ ~           ~ 237 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2012MNRAS.420.2884S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu