2012MNRAS.424.1372A


Query : 2012MNRAS.424.1372A

2012MNRAS.424.1372A - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 424, 1372-1391 (2012/August-1)

Progenitor mass constraints for core-collapse supernovae from correlations with host galaxy star formation.

ANDERSON J.P., HABERGHAM S.M., JAMES P.A. and HAMUY M.

Abstract (from CDS):

Using Hα emission as a tracer of ongoing (<16 Myr old) and near-ultraviolet (UV) emission as a tracer of recent (16–100 Myr old) star formation, we present constraints on the properties of core-collapse (CC) supernova (SN) progenitors through the association of their explosion sites with star-forming regions. Amalgamating previous results with those gained from new data, we present statistics of a large sample of SNe; 163.5 Type II (58 IIP, 13 IIL, 13.5 IIb, 19 IIn and 12 `impostors', plus 48 with no sub-type classification) and 96.5 Type Ib/c (39.5 Ib and 52 Ic, plus five with no sub-type classification). Using pixel statistics we build distributions of associations of different SN types with host galaxy star formation. Our main findings and conclusions are as follows.

 {\listitem {\label 1} {\par}An increasing progenitor mass sequence is observed, implied from an increasing association of SNe to host galaxy H{alpha} emission. This commences with the Type Ia showing the weakest association, followed by the Type II, then the Ib, with the Type Ic showing the strongest correlation to star-forming regions. Thus, our progenitor mass sequence runs Ia--II--Ib--Ic.} {\listitem {\label 2} {\par}Overall, the Type Ibc SNe are found to occur nearer to bright H {\sc ii} regions than SNe of Type II. This implies that the former have shorter stellar lifetimes, thus arising from more massive progenitor stars.} {\listitem {\label 3} {\par}While Type IIP SNe do not closely follow the ongoing star formation, they accurately trace the recent formation. This implies that their progenitors arise from stars at the low end of the CC SN mass sequence, consistent with direct detections of progenitors in pre-explosion imaging.} {\listitem {\label 4} {\par}Similarly, the Type IIn SNe trace recent but not the ongoing star formation. This implies that, contrary to the general consensus, the majority of these SN do {\em not} arise from the most massive stars.} {\par}Results and suggestive constraints are also presented for the less numerous SNe of Types IIL and IIb, and SN `impostors'. Finally, we present an analysis of possible biases in the data, the results of which argue strongly against any selection effects that could explain the relative excess of Type Ibc SNe within bright H {\sc ii} regions. Thus, intrinsic progenitor differences in the sense of the mass sequence we propose remain the most plausible explanation of our findings. {\note {\par}Based on observations made with the Isaac Newton Telescope operated on the island of La Palma by the Isaac Newton Group in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos of the Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias, observations made with the Liverpool Telescope operated on the island of La Palma by Liverpool John Moores University in the Spanish Observatorio del Roque de los Muchachos of the Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias with financial support from the UK Science and Technology Facilities Council, and observations made with the 2.2-m MPG/ESO telescope at La Silla, proposal ID: 084.D-0195.}


Abstract Copyright: 2012 The Authors Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society2012 RAS

Journal keyword(s): supernovae: general - galaxies: statistics

Simbad objects: 283

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 283
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SN 2005gl SN* 00 49 50.02 +32 16 56.8       17.0   SNIIn 162 2
2 NGC 493 EmG 01 22 08.985 +00 56 43.21   13.0   13.0 12.8 ~ 131 0
3 SN 1971S SN* 01 22 12.1 +00 57 21   15.7       SNIIP 24 1
4 SN 2004ds SN* 02 03 56.51 -23 18 50.6     16.8     SNIIP: 7 1
5 NGC 808 AG? 02 03 56.581 -23 18 41.70   14.12   13.07   ~ 45 1
6 SN 2003id SN* 02 21 35.70 -05 31 51.0     16.7     SNIcpec 19 1
7 NGC 894 Sy2 02 21 36.470 -05 31 17.02 12.21 12.26 11.73     ~ 163 2
8 NGC 908 Sy1 02 23 04.569 -21 14 01.86   11.03 10.18 9.84 10.6 ~ 202 1
9 SN 1994ai SN* 02 23 06.17 -21 14 09.3     17     SNIc 23 1
10 SN 2009js SN* 02 25 48.28 +18 29 25.8           SNIIP 36 1
11 NGC 918 AGN 02 25 50.7899313312 +18 29 46.358860992   16.00 15.01     ~ 157 0
12 NGC 941 EmG 02 28 27.847 -01 09 05.61   12.8   13.0 12.9 ~ 158 0
13 SN 2005ad SN* 02 28 29.45 -01 08 20.0           SNIIP 29 1
14 SN 1984L SN* 02 35 30.54 -07 09 30.3   14.0       SNIb 197 1
15 NGC 991 LSB 02 35 32.6841762360 -07 09 15.862909536   12.36   12.7 12.6 ~ 166 1
16 SN 1990E SN* 02 39 29.1 -08 08 14     15.2     SNIIP 97 1
17 NGC 1035 EmG 02 39 29.136 -08 08 01.11   12.89   13.0 12.6 ~ 188 1
18 SN 2011aq SN* 02 42 48.14 +28 34 25.8           SNII 9 1
19 NGC 1056 Sy2 02 42 48.2914236192 +28 34 26.660028468   13.5       ~ 180 0
20 SN 2007gr SN* 02 43 27.98 +37 20 44.7       12.77   SNIc 265 1
21 NGC 1058 Sy2 02 43 30.0264850248 +37 20 28.782851784   12.29 11.75 10.85   ~ 483 0
22 SN 1961V SN* 02 43 36.42 +37 20 43.6   12.7 12.5     SNIIpec? 212 2
23 SN 1969L SN* 02 43 45 +37 18.7   13.2 13.2     SNIIP 121 1
24 SN 2007Y SN* 03 02 35.92 -22 53 50.1     17.5     SNIb 135 1
25 NGC 1187 Sy1 03 02 37.5895048560 -22 52 02.479512648   11.41   10.43 11.2 ~ 228 1
26 SN 1982R SN* 03 02 39.41 -22 51 01.0   14.8       SNIb: 34 1
27 SN 2001du SN* 03 33 29.11 -36 08 32.5     14.0     SNIIP 58 1
28 SN 1983V SN* 03 33 31.63 -36 08 55.0   14.67       SNIc 102 1
29 NGC 1365 Sy1 03 33 36.458 -36 08 26.37 10.48 10.08 9.63 8.79 9.7 ~ 1987 2
30 SN 2003lo SN* 03 37 05.12 -05 02 17.3     17.2     SNIIn 14 1
31 SN 1999go SN* 03 37 05.72 -05 02 19.0     15.5     SNII 13 1
32 NGC 1376 GiG 03 37 05.9375589144 -05 02 33.518943636   12.9   11.96 12.7 ~ 95 0
33 NGC 1343 AG? 03 37 49.7256129120 +72 34 16.612030092   14.1       ~ 77 1
34 SN 2008dv SN* 03 37 51.43 +72 34 21.8           SNIc 16 1
35 NGC 1398 GiG 03 38 52.130 -26 20 16.22   10.37   8.90 10.1 ~ 250 0
36 SN 1996N SN* 03 38 55.37 -26 20 04.0       16   SNIb 49 2
37 NGC 1433 Sy2 03 42 01.4847418992 -47 13 18.929092656   10.84 9.99 9.61 10.2 ~ 447 0
38 SN 1985P SN* 03 42 06.30 -47 12 35.6   13.5 13.5     SNIIP 38 1
39 Z 327-11 AG? 04 01 00.9912515928 +74 05 01.685568552   14.3       ~ 40 0
40 SN 2008im SN* 04 01 02.11 +74 05 49.1           SNIb 12 1
41 ESO 302-27 EmG 04 01 51.756 -41 56 30.53   15.13   14.57 15.2 ~ 32 0
42 SN 2005my SN* 04 01 53.13 -41 56 08.3     17.8     SNII 6 1
43 MCG-05-10-012 Sy1 04 07 45.561 -29 51 30.48   13.52 13.04 12.58 13.1 ~ 53 0
44 SN 2005dg SN* 04 07 46.25 -29 51 28.1     16.6     SNIc 9 1
45 NGC 1536 EmG 04 10 59.838 -56 28 49.64   13.29 13.15 12.19   ~ 88 0
46 SN 1997D SN* 04 11 01.00 -56 29 56.0       16.3   SNIIpec 184 1
47 NGC 1591 Sy1 04 29 30.5379132408 -26 42 47.240666424   13.77   12.62   ~ 65 0
48 SN 2008V SN* 04 29 31.30 -26 42 39.8     16.8     SNIIb 12 1
49 NGC 1614 Sy1 04 34 00.027 -08 34 44.57   14.66 13.99     ~ 697 1
50 SN 1996D SN* 04 34 00.30 -08 34 44.0     18.2     SNIc 30 1
51 SN 2009kr SN* 05 12 03.30 -15 41 52.2           SNII 93 1
52 NGC 1832 Sy2 05 12 03.3433348776 -15 41 16.021694220   12.2   11.07 11.8 ~ 245 1
53 M 42 HII 05 35 16.8 -05 23 15           ~ 4411 0
54 IC 438 Sy1 05 53 00.0793932408 -17 52 34.051147932   12.75   11.45 12.2 ~ 77 0
55 SN 1997B SN* 05 53 01.9 -17 51 55     16.5     SNIc 30 2
56 SN 2003H SN* 06 16 25.68 -21 22 23.8     17.8     SNIbpec 49 1
57 ESO 121-26 AG? 06 21 38.7213440688 -59 44 23.748469764   12.58   11.54 12.2 ~ 82 0
58 SN 2008M SN* 06 21 41.28 -59 43 45.4     15.5     SNIIP 39 1
59 NGC 2273B AG? 06 46 31.6119515088 +60 20 25.427246748   14.1       ~ 50 0
60 SN 2011fd SN* 06 46 39.85 +60 21 02.8           SNIIP 9 1
61 IC 454 AG? 06 51 06.3178825440 +12 55 19.047410220   14.5       ~ 56 0
62 SN 2000H SN* 06 51 07.67 +12 55 18.5   17.9       SNIIb 57 1
63 SN 2006bc SN* 07 21 16.50 -68 59 57.3   17.6 16.0     SNIIP 52 1
64 NGC 2397 Sy1 07 21 19.8926907744 -69 00 05.031850284   12.85   11.57   ~ 98 0
65 Z 330-36 GiG 07 22 34.7529993480 +71 35 56.174136504   13.0       ~ 68 0
66 SN 2002A SN* 07 22 36.14 +71 35 41.5     17.4     SNIIn 20 1
67 NGC 2276 AG? 07 27 14.485 +85 45 16.20   12.3       ~ 393 0
68 SN 2005dl SN* 07 27 31.75 +85 45 15.0     17.1     SNII 14 1
69 SN 1999ga SN* 07 36 16.70 -69 33 21.8       18   SNIIL 21 1
70 NGC 2442 LIN 07 36 23.7700545576 -69 31 50.997856332 11.47 11.15 10.42 9.71 10.4 ~ 243 1
71 NGC 2403 AGN 07 36 51.3381434280 +65 36 09.650825640 9.31 8.84 8.38 8.19   ~ 1887 1
72 SN 1954J SN* 07 36 56.20 +65 37 52.3   16.3 16.50     SNIIpec? 95 2
73 TS V37 s*b 07 37 01.83 +65 34 29.3     19     LBV 67 1
74 SN 2000fn SN* 08 06 57.79 +08 00 19.3     18.8     SNIb 19 1
75 NGC 2526 GiP 08 06 58.6222158888 +08 00 14.127856236   14.6       ~ 49 0
76 SN 1999gb SN* 08 10 13.70 +33 57 29.8     16.1     SNIIn 21 1
77 NGC 2532 AG? 08 10 15.1864372560 +33 57 23.768999208   12.90       ~ 169 0
78 Z 236-32 AG? 08 11 08.311 +46 27 56.33   14.3       ~ 43 0
79 SN 1984F SN* 08 11 10 +46 27.5     16.0     SNII: 9 1
80 SN 2002hc SN* 08 17 06.05 -27 27 27.0     17     SNIIL 8 1
81 NGC 2559 GiG 08 17 06.074 -27 27 20.95   11.71   10.10 10.7 ~ 78 1
82 SN 2007ay SN* 08 17 14.85 +01 12 06.9     17.1     SNIIb 19 1
83 Z 3-25 AG? 08 17 15.727 +01 12 22.96   15.3       ~ 28 0
84 SN 2008W SN* 08 36 19.22 -20 16 52.5     17.5     SNIIP 23 1
85 MCG-03-22-007 Sy2 08 36 19.8201984384 -20 17 06.752473224   15.8       ~ 29 0
86 NGC 2642 Sy1 08 40 44.3751778920 -04 07 18.044937444   12.6   11.79 12.3 ~ 82 0
87 SN 2002fj SN* 08 40 45.10 -04 07 38.5     15.8     SNIIn 18 1
88 SN 2003Z SN* 09 07 32.46 +60 29 17.5     16.7     SNIIP 83 1
89 NGC 2742 GiG 09 07 33.5746410432 +60 28 45.818789124   12.0       ~ 214 0
90 SN 1994ak SN* 09 14 01.47 +40 06 21.5     16.3     SNIIn 39 1
91 NGC 2782 Sy2 09 14 05.11967 +40 06 49.6800 12.29 12.30 11.63     ~ 494 3
92 SN 2006jc SN* 09 17 20.78 +41 54 32.7     13.8     SNIbn 380 1
93 IC 2481 G 09 27 28.8048814800 +03 55 46.561377252   14.5       ~ 64 1
94 SN 2003I SN* 09 27 29.48 +03 55 45.6     17.6     SNIb 21 1
95 NGC 2980 Sy2 09 43 11.9803098960 -09 36 44.548192296   13.6   12.34 13.2 ~ 52 0
96 SN 2006ba SN* 09 43 13.40 -09 36 53.0     18.4     SNIIb 21 1
97 NGC 2993 Sy1 09 45 48.325 -14 22 06.02 12.72 13.11 12.64 13.4 13.0 ~ 194 2
98 SN 2003ao SN* 09 45 48.46 -14 22 14.0     17.3     SNIIP 17 1
99 Z 35-58 AG? 09 47 45.381 +02 37 38.93   14.4       ~ 76 0
100 SN 1989C SN* 09 47 45.41 +02 37 36.1   15.0 14.5     SNIIP 30 1
101 NGC 3054 EmG 09 54 28.5871599144 -25 42 12.369525732   12.27   10.92 11.4 ~ 151 0
102 SN 2006T SN* 09 54 30.21 -25 42 29.3     17.2     SNIIb 67 1
103 SN 1993J SN* 09 55 24.77476 +69 01 13.7026   10.8 12.0     SNIIb 1507 1
104 SN 2008iz SN* 09 55 51.55 +69 40 45.8           SNII: 63 1
105 M 82 AGN 09 55 52.430 +69 40 46.93 9.61 9.30 8.41     ~ 6156 6
106 NGC 3074 AG? 09 59 41.2147116065 +35 23 34.127422846   14.8       ~ 70 0
107 SN 1965N SN* 09 59 41.71 +35 23 43.6   16.0       SNIIP 26 1
108 SN 1999gi SN* 10 18 16.66 +41 26 28.2   14.8       SNIIP 248 1
109 SN 1937F SN* 10 18 16.9 +41 25 27   13.7 13.9     SNIIP: 38 1
110 NGC 3180 GiG 10 18 16.985 +41 25 27.77   10.4       ~ 777 0
111 AT 2010dn ev 10 18 19.89 +41 26 28.8           ~ 25 1
112 SN 1999bw SN* 10 19 46.81 +45 31 35.0     17.8     SNIIn? 61 2
113 NGC 3198 EmG 10 19 54.990 +45 32 58.88 10.83 10.87 10.33     ~ 946 1
114 Z 9-18 GiG 10 23 56.4965068704 -03 10 55.465094280   13.4       ~ 57 0
115 SN 2005bf SN* 10 23 56.99 -03 11 29.3     18.0     SNIb 225 1
116 SN 2001db SN* 10 27 50.4 -43 54 21           SNII 16 1
117 NGC 3256 Sy2 10 27 51.284 -43 54 13.55   11.83 11.33 10.62 11.9 ~ 920 2
118 SN 1993N SN* 10 29 46.2 +13 01 13     17.5     SNIIn 31 1
119 Z 65-46 AG? 10 29 46.777 +13 01 05.35   14.9       ~ 59 0
120 SN 1994N SN* 10 29 46.8 +13 01 13       17.5   SNII 39 1
121 SN 1990H SN* 10 36 15.08 +37 19 27.2     16     SNIIP 32 1
122 NGC 3294 AG? 10 36 16.2564642096 +37 19 29.049225924   11.5       ~ 210 0
123 NGC 3318 Sy2 10 37 15.5052550728 -41 37 38.912719512   12.71 11.97 11.77 12.4 ~ 107 0
124 SN 2000cl SN* 10 37 16.07 -41 37 47.8     14.8     SNIIn 12 1
125 NGC 3313 Sy2 10 37 25.4644853016 -25 19 09.838240356   12.38   11.13 11.7 ~ 75 0
126 SN 2002jp SN* 10 37 26.50 -25 21 35.2     16.9     SNIc 16 1
127 NGC 3430 GiP 10 52 11.3923421616 +32 57 01.545623100   12.2       ~ 235 0
128 SN 2004ez SN* 10 52 15.11 +32 57 20.1       17.3   SNIIP 18 1
129 SN 2002J SN* 10 54 38.36 -21 03 53.6     16.8     SNIc 25 1
130 SN 2002hy SN* 10 54 39.18 -21 03 41.2     16.4     SNIbpec 24 1
131 NGC 3464 GiG 10 54 40.1376198816 -21 03 59.251207824   13.23   12.01 12.4 ~ 109 0
132 NGC 3504 LIN 11 03 11.19147 +27 58 20.7660   13.48 12.93     ~ 545 2
133 SN 2001ac SN* 11 03 15.37 +27 58 29.5     18.2     SNIIn? 35 2
134 SN 2001fv SN* 11 04 01.66 +28 01 55.7     16.4     SNIIP 24 1
135 NGC 3512 GiP 11 04 02.9540255952 +28 02 12.394037112   13.7 12.87     ~ 168 0
136 SN 1969B SN* 11 11 21 +55 40.2   14.3       SNIIP 31 1
137 M 108 AGN 11 11 30.967 +55 40 26.84   10.70       ~ 497 1
138 SN 1973R SN* 11 20 11.5 +12 59 55   15.3 11.8     SNIIP 80 1
139 AT 1997bs ev 11 20 14.25 +12 58 19.6     17.13     SNIIn? 128 1
140 M 66 AGN 11 20 15.0 +12 59 29 9.85 9.65 8.92     ~ 1509 4
141 SN 2009hd SN* 11 20 16.99 +12 58 46.3           SNII 70 1
142 SN 1965L SN* 11 20 58.2 +53 11 06   16.0       SNIIP 43 1
143 SN 1996bu SN* 11 20 59.18 +53 12 08.0     17.3     SNIIn 24 1
144 NGC 3631 AG? 11 21 02.8871865144 +53 10 10.415331660   11.0       ~ 385 1
145 NGC 3690 IG 11 28 31.0 +58 33 41   13.19 12.86     ~ 1015 4
146 SN 2010P SN* 11 28 31.38 +58 33 49.3           SNII: 33 1
147 SN 2005U SN* 11 28 33.22 +58 33 42.5           SNIIb 36 1
148 SN 2010O SN* 11 28 33.86 +58 33 51.6           SNIb 37 1
149 Z 185-80 AG? 11 32 02.3907222312 +36 41 52.797708996   14.0       ~ 80 0
150 SN 2006lv SN* 11 32 03.30 +36 42 03.6       17.0   SNIb 20 1
151 SN 1975T SN* 11 36 42 +54 17.2   16.5       SNIIP 20 1
152 NGC 3756 GiG 11 36 48.0255259872 +54 17 36.721532292   12.1       ~ 193 0
153 SN 1999bu SN* 11 39 42.50 +31 54 29.1     17.5     SNIc 20 1
154 SN 2005ay SN* 11 52 48.07 +44 06 18.4   15.3       SNIIP 74 1
155 SN 1964L SN* 11 52 49.09 +44 07 45.4   13.4 13.4     SNIc 71 1
156 NGC 3938 GiG 11 52 49.4335936248 +44 07 14.697085116 10.80 10.90 10.38     ~ 566 1
157 NGC 4030 EmG 12 00 23.6102390784 -01 06 00.197099136   11.42   10.3 10.4 ~ 361 1
158 SN 2007aa SN* 12 00 27.69 -01 04 51.6 16.9 16.4 5.8     SNIIP 78 1
159 SN 2004gt SN* 12 01 50.37 -18 52 12.7   19.42 14.9     SNIc 86 1
160 SN 1994W SN* 12 02 10.92 +62 08 32.7     13.3     SNIInP 194 1
161 NGC 4041 SyG 12 02 12.2376697152 +62 08 14.096124312   11.6       ~ 270 1
162 NGC 4051 Sy1 12 03 09.6101337312 +44 31 52.682601288   11.08 12.92 9.94   ~ 2270 1
163 SN 2010br SN* 12 03 10.95 +44 31 43.1           SNIb/c 25 1
164 SN 1999bg SN* 12 04 07.26 +62 30 00.1     15.5     SNIIP 34 1
165 IC 758 AG? 12 04 11.875 +62 30 19.29   14.4       ~ 64 0
166 SN 1991G SN* 12 05 28.85 +50 32 11.7   15.7       SNIIP 54 1
167 SN 2009dd SN* 12 05 34.10 +50 32 18.6           SNII 46 1
168 NGC 4088 AGN 12 05 34.2230093952 +50 32 21.064017876   11.2       ~ 428 1
169 NGC 4141 AG? 12 09 47.3108897640 +58 50 57.253147188   14.5       ~ 86 0
170 SN 2008X SN* 12 09 48.33 +58 51 01.6     17.6     SNIIP 29 1
171 NGC 4242 GiG 12 17 30.1835103480 +45 37 09.508940220   11.37 10.83     ~ 285 1
172 SN 2002bu SN* 12 17 37.18 +45 38 47.4     15.5     SNIIn? 58 2
173 SN 1972Q SN* 12 18 49.6 +14 24 59   15.8       SNIIP 47 1
174 M 99 H2G 12 18 49.625 +14 24 59.36 10.45 10.44 9.87     ~ 1004 2
175 SN 1986I SN* 12 18 52.03 +14 24 43.8   14.2 14.2     SNIIP 76 1
176 SN 1936A SN* 12 19 55.9 +05 21 08   14.9 14.9     SNIIP 34 1
177 NGC 4273 H2G 12 19 56.063 +05 20 36.12   12.3       ~ 274 0
178 M 61 Sy2 12 21 54.9282582888 +04 28 25.597367184 10.07 10.18 9.65     ~ 1084 1
179 SN 2006ov SN* 12 21 55.30 +04 29 16.7     14.9     SNIIP 88 1
180 SN 1999gn SN* 12 21 57.04 +04 27 45.7     16.0     SNIIP 40 1
181 SN 1985G SN* 12 28 40.4 +09 15 40   15.3       SNIIP 35 1
182 NGC 4451 GiG 12 28 40.558 +09 15 32.13   13.4       ~ 207 0
183 NGC 4490 GiG 12 30 34.5 +41 38 26 10.03 10.22 9.79     ~ 616 3
184 SN 1982F SN* 12 30 38 +41 38.0   16.2       SNIIP 43 1
185 NGC 4495 LIN 12 31 22.90653 +29 08 10.9320   14.19 13.46     ~ 100 1
186 SN 2011ca SN* 12 31 24.94 +29 07 50.6           SNIc 3 1
187 NGC 4527 AGN 12 34 08.49600 +02 39 13.7160   12.4       ~ 549 2
188 SN 2004gn SN* 12 34 12.10 +02 39 34.4     16.6     SNIc 31 1
189 SN 1990B SN* 12 36 33.86 +11 14 29.9     15.75     SNIc 131 1
190 NGC 4568 H2G 12 36 34.292 +11 14 19.07   12.11 11.19     ~ 394 2
191 SN 2004cc SN* 12 36 34.40 +11 14 32.8     17.5     SNIc 43 1
192 Z 14-81 EmG 12 38 03.322 -02 15 49.48   14.10   13.510   ~ 50 0
193 SN 2007rw SN* 12 38 03.64 -02 15 40.1     14.3     SNII 13 1
194 NGC 4603 GiG 12 40 55.2223531200 -40 58 35.061387924   12.42 11.30 10.96 11.5 ~ 125 0
195 SN 2008cn SN* 12 40 55.66 -40 58 12.1           SNII 41 1
196 Z 315-52 AG? 12 40 57.433 +63 31 11.30   14.8       ~ 60 0
197 SN 2006bv SN* 12 41 01.55 +63 31 11.6     17.8     SNIIn? 26 2
198 NGC 4615 EmG 12 41 37.3165133424 +26 04 22.103980284   13.8       ~ 135 0
199 SN 1987F SN* 12 41 37.46 +26 04 28.3   15.3       SNIIn 90 1
200 SN 2006my SN* 12 43 40.74 +16 23 14.1     15.3     SNIIP 64 1
201 NGC 4651 LIN 12 43 42.6376070448 +16 23 36.002649300   11.30 10.92 10.42 9.84 ~ 537 0
202 NGC 4650A Sy2 12 44 49.0352044176 -40 42 51.691570488   14.12 13.58 13.29 13.9 ~ 205 0
203 SN 1990I SN* 12 44 50.26 -40 43 36.5   16.7 16.7     SNIb 62 1
204 SN 1965H SN* 12 45 07 -00 28.1   14.6       SNIIP 28 1
205 NGC 4666 AGN 12 45 08.676 -00 27 42.88   11.7   11.5 10.7 ~ 421 1
206 NGC 4725 Sy2 12 50 26.5716367992 +25 30 02.733090588   13.45 12.44     ~ 727 2
207 MCG-02-33-020 LSB 12 50 29.414 -10 51 15.89   13.0   12.59 13.2 ~ 79 0
208 SN 2008aq SN* 12 50 30.36 -10 52 01.3     16.3     SNIIb 55 1
209 SN 1940B SN* 12 50 33 +25 32.2   13.1 12.8     SNIIP 39 1
210 NGC 4900 AGN 13 00 39.1193785512 +02 30 05.154593868   12.8       ~ 267 1
211 SN 1999br SN* 13 00 41.80 +02 29 45.8     17.5     SNIIPp 171 1
212 NGC 4965 EmG 13 07 09.3504711408 -28 13 41.789696088   12.76   11.96 12.7 ~ 79 1
213 SN 2000P SN* 13 07 10.53 -28 14 02.5     14.1     SNIIn 25 1
214 NGC 4981 GiG 13 08 48.7426150512 -06 46 38.957361240   12.1   10.91 11.7 ~ 176 1
215 SN 2007C SN* 13 08 49.30 -06 47 01.0 18.1 17.1 15.9     SNIb 67 1
216 SN 1997eg SN* 13 11 36.73 +22 55 29.4     15.6     SNIIn 78 1
217 NGC 5012 LIN 13 11 37.0550725200 +22 54 55.807560612   13.6       ~ 158 1
218 SN 1984I SN* 13 14 36 -42 40.1   16.60       SNIb 20 1
219 MCG-07-27-049 GiG 13 14 40.0827409824 -42 40 34.371770880   13.33   12.21 12.8 ~ 37 0
220 SN 2001R SN* 13 29 16.93 +17 02 41.2     18.5     SNIIP 13 1
221 NGC 5172 AG? 13 29 19.1664440208 +17 03 06.252023952   12.7       ~ 80 0
222 M 51 Sy2 13 29 52.698 +47 11 42.93   9.26 8.36 8.40   ~ 4565 4
223 SN 2005cs SN* 13 29 53.37 +47 10 28.2   14.5       SNIIP 450 1
224 SN 2011dh SN* 13 30 05.10555 +47 10 10.9227           SNIIb 445 1
225 SN 2001bb SN* 13 43 25.31 -29 48 13.1     16.5     SNIc 19 1
226 IC 4319 EmG 13 43 26.5817844936 -29 48 12.083860296   14.35   12.79 12.92 ~ 63 0
227 SN 2003gm SN* 13 52 51.72 -01 06 39.2     17.0     SNII? 33 2
228 NGC 5334 LSB 13 52 54.4632396696 -01 06 52.604999568   12.0   12.3 12.1 ~ 177 0
229 SN 1994Y SN* 13 55 36.90 +40 27 53.4   14.52       SNIIn 69 1
230 NGC 5390 LIN 13 55 39.9385716624 +40 27 42.380606592   12.81 11.93 10.04   ~ 373 1
231 SN 2008dw SN* 14 00 56.27 +41 00 29.0           SNII 8 1
232 Z 219-42 GiP 14 00 56.503 +41 00 19.17   15.4       ~ 33 0
233 IC 4367 GiG 14 05 36.5942202960 -39 12 12.101893272   13.00   11.84 12.2 ~ 40 0
234 SN 2005bq SN* 14 05 37.05 -39 12 04.4     18.3     SNIc 9 1
235 NGC 5468 GiP 14 06 34.8905851004 -05 27 10.718829772   12.1   11.58 12.2 ~ 160 0
236 SN 2002ed SN* 14 06 38.22 -05 27 28.0       16.5   SNIIP 13 1
237 SN 2004cm SN* 14 07 24.91 +55 06 10.0           SNIIP 14 1
238 NGC 5486 LSB 14 07 25.027 +55 06 10.52   14.0       ~ 106 1
239 NAME Circinus Galaxy Sy2 14 13 09.906 -65 20 20.47   10.89 9.84 10.6 10.0 ~ 1331 1
240 SN 1996cr SN* 14 13 10.01139 -65 20 44.5654     19.5     SNIIn: 90 1
241 SN 2001co SN* 14 19 11.80 +24 47 42.9     18.5     SNIb/cpec 38 1
242 NGC 5630 AG? 14 27 36.581 +41 15 28.14   13.6       ~ 125 0
243 SN 2006am SN* 14 27 37.24 +41 15 35.4     18.5     SNIIn 25 1
244 Z 19-44 GiG 14 29 34.5926526984 -00 01 05.660319828   13.8   14.0 14.0 ~ 105 0
245 SN 2002ao SN* 14 29 35.74 -00 00 55.8     14.3     SNIb/cpec 56 1
246 NGC 5612 GiG 14 34 01.274 -78 23 14.85   13.01 12.14 11.39   ~ 44 0
247 SN 2004ch SN* 14 34 06.27 -78 23 09.5     16     SNII 5 1
248 SN 1995N SN* 14 49 28.29 -10 10 14.0     17.5     SNIIn 172 1
249 MCG-02-38-017 GiP 14 49 32.7 -10 09 47   16.6   17.1   ~ 75 1
250 SN 1996ae SN* 14 53 59.81 +03 31 46.3     16.5     SNIIn 28 1
251 SN 2003dv SN* 14 58 04.92 +58 52 49.9     16.2     SNIIn 15 1
252 Z 296-20 AG? 14 58 09.755 +58 52 18.52   15.5       ~ 34 0
253 SN 2004dg SN* 14 59 58.96 +01 53 25.6     17.1     SNIIP 40 1
254 NGC 5806 Sy2 15 00 00.4088018736 +01 53 28.779594792   12.40 11.70 10.94 11.6 ~ 305 1
255 SN 1987B SN* 15 07 02.92 +01 30 12.4     14.5     SNIInL 50 1
256 NGC 5850 LIN 15 07 07.6828131840 +01 32 39.513281352   11.5   10.79 11.1 ~ 330 1
257 SN 1988H SN* 15 13 44 -14 15.3   15.5 16.2     SNIIP 27 1
258 NGC 5878 EmG 15 13 45.7287265656 -14 16 11.524994832   12.1   11.26 11.7 ~ 93 0
259 SN 2001X SN* 15 21 55.45 +05 03 42.1     17.0     SNIIP 48 1
260 NGC 5921 AG? 15 21 56.561 +05 04 13.94   12.7       ~ 286 0
261 Z 224-46 EmG 16 29 00.4117713408 +41 17 03.356731968   14.8       ~ 70 0
262 NGC 6221 Sy2 16 52 46.329 -59 13 00.99   10.90 13.45 9.68 10.4 ~ 328 0
263 SN 1990W SN* 16 52 47.17 -59 12 55.0   15.80 15.0     SNIb/c 35 1
264 NGC 6643 AG? 18 19 46.370 +74 34 06.23   11.80       ~ 320 1
265 SN 2008ij SN* 18 19 51.81 +74 33 54.9           SNII 27 1
266 SN 2008bo SN* 18 19 54.34 +74 34 20.9           SNIIb 65 1
267 SN 2002hh SN* 20 34 44.29 +60 07 19.0     17.18     SNIIP 158 1
268 SN 2008S ev 20 34 45.33 +60 05 58.4   19.89 18.79 17.93   SNIIn? 253 1
269 NGC 6946 H2G 20 34 52.332 +60 09 13.24   10.5       ~ 2661 2
270 SN 1948B SN* 20 35 21.5 +60 10 16   14.0 14.0     SNIIP 77 1
271 NGC 6951 Sy2 20 37 14.1228088488 +66 06 20.049916392   11.64 10.65     ~ 553 2
272 SN 1999el SN* 20 37 18.03 +66 06 11.9     14.9     SNIIn 74 1
273 SN 1995X SN* 22 40 51.30 +75 10 11.5     18     SNII 14 1
274 UGC 12160 AG? 22 40 54.4503219000 +75 09 52.577667360   15.5       ~ 46 0
275 MCG+12-21-001 AG? 22 45 38.0005073448 +73 09 43.818943896   15.5       ~ 25 0
276 SN 2006fp ev 22 45 41.13 +73 09 47.8           SNIIn? 18 1
277 SN 2009jf SN* 23 04 52.98 +12 19 59.5           SNIb 121 1
278 NGC 7479 Sy2 23 04 56.6432243448 +12 19 22.357387020 11.74 11.60 10.85 10.47 9.66 ~ 783 2
279 SN 2002gd SN* 23 14 37.01 +04 30 06.1     16.7     SNII 63 1
280 SN 2007fo SN* 23 36 13.98 +02 09 30.4     18.2     SNIb: 18 1
281 NGC 7714 AGN 23 36 14.1257730600 +02 09 18.197422668   14.91 14.36     ~ 788 1
282 MCG+03-01-002 AG? 23 55 46.025 +18 25 33.60   17       ~ 65 0
283 SN 2007od SN* 23 55 48.68 +18 24 54.8       14.4   SNIIP 147 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2012MNRAS.424.1372A and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu