2013MNRAS.428.3443M

Query : 2013MNRAS.428.3443M

2013MNRAS.428.3443M - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 428, 3443-3461 (2013/February-1)

Plasma diagnostics for planetary nebulae and HII regions using the NII and OII optical recombination lines.

McNABB I.A., FANG X., LIU X.-W., BASTIN R.J. and STOREY P.J.

Abstract (from CDS):

We carry out plasma diagnostic analyses for 123 planetary nebulae (PNe) and 42 Hii regions using the Nii and Oii optical recombination lines (ORLs). New effective recombination coefficients for the Nii and Oii optical recombination spectra are used. These data were calculated under the intermediate coupling scheme for a number of electron temperature (Te) and density (Ne) cases. We use a new method to determine the Te's and Ne's for the nebular sample, combining the ORLs with the most reliable measurements for each ion and the predicted intensities that are based on the new atomic data. Uncertainties of the derived Te and Ne are estimated for each object.

The diagnostic results from heavy element ORLs show reasonable agreement with previous calculations in the literature. We compare the electron temperatures derived from the Nii and Oii ORLs, Te(ORLs), and those from the collisionally excited lines (CELs), Te(CELs), as well as the hydrogen Balmer jump, Te(Hi BJ), especially for the PNe with large abundance discrepancies. Temperatures from the Hei recombination lines, Te(Hei), are also used for comparison if available. For all the objects included in our sample, Te(ORLs) are lower than Te(Hi BJ), which are in turn systematically lower than Te(CELs). PNe with Te(Hei) available show the relation Te(ORLs) ≤ Te(Hei) ≤ Te(Hi BJ) ≤ Te(CELs), which is consistent with predictions from the bi-abundance nebular model postulated by Liu et al.


Abstract Copyright: © 2012 The Authors Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Astronomical Society (2012)

Journal keyword(s): atomic data - Hii regions - planetary nebulae: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/MNRAS/428/3443): table1.dat table2.dat table3.dat table4.dat refs.dat>

CDS comments: NGC 2867-1 and -2, and PB 6-1 and 6-2 are not in Simbad.

Simbad objects: 139

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 139
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA 		ICRS (J2000)
DEC 		Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026 		#notes
1 NGC 40 PN 00 13 01.0170097248 +72 31 19.033338720   11.63 11.46     [WC8] 632 2
2 PN Hu 1-1 PN 00 28 15.435 +55 57 54.48           ~ 169 1
3 PN BoBn 1 PN 00 37 16.03 -13 42 58.6   16       ~ 135 1
4 M 31 AGN 00 42 44.330 +41 16 07.50 4.86 4.36 3.44     ~ 13622 1
5 BA 1-671 HII 00 46 34.52 +42 11 33.7           ~ 22 1
6 SNR B0057-72.2 SNR 00 59 27.40 -72 10 10.7   12.37 12.57     ~ 251 0
7 LHA 115-N 87 PN 01 21 10.6470507816 -73 14 34.846684584   15.94 15.553   16.758 ~ 47 0
8 NGC 595 HII 01 33 33.53 +30 41 29.8           ~ 213 0
9 M 33 GiG 01 33 50.8965749232 +30 39 36.630403128 6.17 6.27 5.72     ~ 6226 1
10 NGC 604 HII 01 34 32.1 +30 47 01           ~ 608 0
11 IC 1747 PN 01 57 35.6899203048 +63 19 18.447328776   15.8 15.4     [WC4] 269 2
12 IC 351 PN 03 47 32.9806443144 +35 02 48.639127308   13.11 12.27 14.35   Of(H) 264 0
13 IC 2003 PN 03 56 21.9884187048 +33 52 30.759977028   13.11 11.87 13.44   [WC3?] 261 0
14 NGC 1501 PN 04 06 59.3920909320 +60 55 14.278542024   15.17 13.0     [WO4] 314 1
15 NGC 1763 As* 04 56 51.5 -66 24 25     9.40     ~ 169 3
16 LEDA 16573 G 05 01 37.832 -04 15 28.48   13.44   12.76   ~ 74 1
17 NGC 1741 EmG 05 01 38.3 -04 15 25   13.7   13.02 13.6 ~ 273 0
18 SV* HV 5824 PN 05 25 26.0089259016 -68 55 53.818836492 15.497 15.946 14.902 15.59 16.714 ~ 53 0
19 IC 418 PN 05 27 28.2059533560 -12 41 50.282287764   9.405 9.010 10.118   O7fp 1059 2
20 NAME Ori Trapezium OpC 05 35 16.5 -05 23 14           ~ 1708 1
21 M 42 HII 05 35 16.8 -05 23 15           ~ 4411 0
22 SV* HV 5967 PN 05 36 20.7215081304 -67 18 07.658262756 15.56 16.225 14.948   16.558 [WN4.5:] 147 0
23 NAME 30 Dor Nebula SFR 05 38 36.0 -69 05 11           ~ 1276 2
24 NGC 2022 PN 05 42 06.1904253312 +09 05 10.585995576   14.9 14.2     [WC] 371 1
25 NGC 2363 AG? 07 28 29.59 +69 11 34.3   15.5       ~ 262 1
26 NGC 2366 H2G 07 28 52.4529 +69 12 38.859 12.25 11.86 11.39 11.33   ~ 801 0
27 CXOU J073645.6+653659 HII 07 36 45.6 +65 36 59           ~ 27 0
28 HK NGC 2403 270 Cl* 07 36 52.13 +65 36 48.5           ~ 24 0
29 [S75b] NGC 2403 2 HII 07 37 06.82 +65 36 38.7           ~ 41 0
30 NGC 2440 PN 07 41 55.34603 -18 12 30.4117   11.469 10.104     ~ 665 2
31 NGC 2467 OpC 07 52 18 -26 25.7           ~ 190 1
32 [J79] 3 PoC 08 46 53.254 +17 52 52.72           ~ 9 0
33 PN A66 30 PN 08 46 53.4639874872 +17 52 46.369394580   14.23 14.30 13.47   [WC5] 431 0
34 [J79] 1 PoC 08 46 53.793 +17 52 39.38           ~ 8 0
35 NGC 2867 PN 09 21 25.3832468160 -58 18 40.626683604   12.0 10.30     [WO2] 313 0
36 IC 2501 PN 09 38 47.1901701864 -60 05 30.807638520   11.7 10     O3-6 188 1
37 NGC 3132 PN 10 07 01.7656422504 -40 26 11.130553032   10.14 10.01     A2V 423 1
38 PN PB 6 PN 10 13 15.9622567176 -50 19 59.563979688   17.4 17.6     [WO1] 144 0
39 NGC 3242 PN 10 24 46.1335521792 -18 38 32.296857792   11.83 12.15     ~ 838 1
40 NGC 3576 HII 11 11 53.2 -61 18 26           ~ 245 2
41 NGC 3603 OpC 11 14 57.9 -61 14 32           ~ 1136 1
42 NGC 3918 PN 11 50 17.7709504944 -57 10 57.017302428   10.0 8.5     ~ 390 1
43 [CC2002] NGC 4395 70 HII 12 25 57.8 +33 31 39           ~ 4 0
44 IC 3568 PN 12 33 06.8549162136 +82 33 50.202643608   11.809 10.730 12.651   ~ 407 0
45 PB 8 WD* 12 51 38.0745954984 +49 00 53.722514628   18.5       DB 16 0
46 Mrk 59 rG 12 59 00.288 +34 50 42.45           ~ 319 2
47 NGC 4861 H2G 12 59 02.340 +34 51 33.98   12.90 12.32     ~ 389 2
48 IC 4191 PN 13 08 47.3071977936 -67 38 37.542860628   10.32 11.61     ~ 144 0
49 PN MyCn 18 PN 13 39 35.0596178496 -67 22 51.750497136   13.30 12.54 13.19 12.61 ~ 293 1
50 NGC 5253A H2G 13 39 55.9 -31 38 24           ~ 26 0
51 [DAZ2013] 129 Cl* 13 39 55.98 -31 38 31.9           ~ 23 0
52 NGC 5253B H2G 13 39 56.00 -31 38 25.8           ~ 18 0
53 NGC 5253C H2G 13 39 56.020 -31 38 27.89           ~ 33 0
54 NGC 5307 PN 13 51 03.2580878376 -51 12 20.835744984   11.5 10     O3.5V 184 1
55 NGC 5315 PN 13 53 56.9726795664 -66 30 50.859483264   14.58 14.40     [WO4] 323 1
56 NGC 5447 HII 14 02 28.0 +54 16 34           ~ 73 0
57 M 101 GiP 14 03 12.583 +54 20 55.50   8.46 7.86 7.76   ~ 3138 2
58 [H69] NGC 5457 40 PoG 14 03 31.300 +54 21 05.81           ~ 43 0
59 NGC 5461 HII 14 03 40.96 +54 19 02.4           ~ 195 0
60 NGC 5471 EmG 14 04 28.627 +54 23 52.84           ~ 250 1
61 IC 4406 PN 14 22 26.1440976888 -44 09 02.185112988   11.5 10.90     ~ 294 1
62 WRAY 16-165 PN 15 06 13.7137862736 -42 59 56.499680904   13.2 13.20     ~ 78 0
63 NGC 5882 PN 15 16 49.9562553264 -45 38 58.616280132   11.9 10.9     ~ 281 1
64 IC 4593 PN 16 11 44.5479462840 +12 04 17.031388584   10.91 10.84     O7fp 462 0
65 NGC 6153 PN 16 31 30.5708444544 -40 15 12.646208700   10.7 15.55     ~ 320 0
66 PN DdDm 1 PN 16 40 18.1517248296 +38 42 20.033859348   14.0 13.90     sd+G/K 153 0
67 NGC 6210 PN 16 44 29.5191019368 +23 47 59.421958296   12.3 11.7     Of/[WR] 597 0
68 PN M 2-4 PN 17 01 06.2230175160 -34 49 38.610796908     14.40     ~ 81 0
69 PN M 2-6 PN 17 04 18.32832 -30 53 28.8816       15.650   ~ 83 0
70 NGC 6302 PN 17 13 44.5 -37 06 11           O-rich 821 2
71 PN M 3-7 PN 17 24 34.4529856560 -29 24 19.796240052     14.60     [WC] 97 0
72 PN M 1-20 PN 17 28 57.6165015264 -19 15 54.033719256           ~ 136 0
73 NGC 6439 PN 17 48 19.820 -16 28 44.42     12.2     ~ 180 0
74 PN H 1-35 PN 17 49 13.9398459192 -34 22 52.812575256     12.90     wels? 118 0
75 PN M 1-29 PN 17 50 17.9658145641 -30 34 54.987881214     14.00     ~ 91 1
76 PN Vy 1-2 PN 17 54 22.98 +27 59 58.1           ~ 118 0
77 PN Cn 2-1 PN 17 54 33.010 -34 22 21.15     12.70 14.47 13.70 ~ 136 0
78 PN H 1-41 PN 17 57 19.1084978568 -34 09 48.784614372           [WC] 93 0
79 PN H 1-42 PN 17 57 25.1720091886 -33 35 43.132190632     12.80     ~ 81 0
80 NGC 6543 PN 17 58 33.4039587288 +66 37 58.750734000   11.09 11.28     [WC] 1197 2
81 PN M 2-23 PN 18 01 42.6413050824 -28 25 44.117293404     13.00     ~ 124 0
82 PN M 2-24 PN 18 02 02.8945854456 -34 27 47.275175592   15.62 14.60 15.29   ~ 100 0
83 PN M 3-21 PN 18 02 32.33 -36 39 11.3     12.20     ~ 109 1
84 M 20 OpC 18 02 42 -22 58.3           ~ 456 1
85 M 8 OpC 18 03 37 -24 23.2           ~ 644 1
86 PN M 2-27 PN 18 03 52.5718384152 -31 17 47.161796424     14.40     [WC4]: 110 0
87 PN H 1-50 PN 18 03 53.5082954976 -32 41 42.015068628   10 12.80     ~ 87 0
88 PN H 1-54 PN 18 07 07.2793260936 -29 13 05.972785284     13.90     ~ 108 0
89 PN M 1-42 PN 18 11 04.99 -28 58 59.1   13.1 14.00     ~ 221 0
90 NGC 6565 PN 18 11 52.4858232888 -28 10 42.421241244   12.5 12.2 12.12   PN 233 0
91 NGC 6572 PN 18 12 06.3181909152 +06 51 13.027935240   9.3 10.8     [WC] 761 0
92 PN M 2-31 PN 18 13 16.0521431976 -25 30 05.320920636   13.3 13.60     [WC4/6] 110 0
93 NGC 6567 PN 18 13 45.1636643352 -19 04 34.071637152     10.9     [WC5/6] 277 0
94 PN M 2-33 PN 18 15 06.5634327720 -30 15 33.265211580       14.61 14.03 O5f(H) 111 0
95 PN Cn 3-1 PN 18 17 34.1015035728 +10 09 03.304908396   12.93 12.49 12.35   07Ib(f) 224 0
96 PN M 2-36 PN 18 17 41.43 -29 08 19.9         17.012 ~ 140 0
97 IC 4699 PN 18 18 32.0450169624 -45 59 01.735217988   13.83 12.71 15.51 15.09 O3V((f)) 104 0
98 M 16 OpC 18 18 45.1 -13 47 31           ~ 1084 1
99 NGC 6618 OpC 18 20 47 -16 10.3           ~ 1700 0
100 PN M 2-39 PN 18 22 01.1620945464 -24 10 39.916889760     15.00     wels 82 0
101 PN M 2-42 PN 18 22 32.08 -24 09 27.7     13.90     ~ 84 0
102 NGC 6620 PN 18 22 54.182 -26 49 17.19   12.8 13.30 14.34 14.55 ~ 145 0
103 M 28 GlC 18 24 32.89 -24 52 11.4           ~ 821 0
104 PN M 3-27 PN 18 27 48.2638650624 +14 29 06.066648996           ~ 84 0
105 PN Vy 2-1 PN 18 27 59.6260402536 -26 06 48.065269284   12.8 13.20     [WC] 94 0
106 PN Cn 1-5 PN 18 29 11.6500996872 -31 29 59.135208396   15.5 15.2 13.34   [WC5/6] 163 0
107 PN Hf 2-2 PN 18 32 30.9015918072 -28 43 20.276106312     15.90     ~ 110 0
108 PN M 3-29 PN 18 39 25.8182649336 -30 40 37.222765752   13.0 14.10     ~ 83 0
109 PN M 3-32 PN 18 44 43.03 -25 21 34.8           ~ 79 0
110 PN M 1-61 PN 18 45 55.12 -14 27 37.9           ~ 116 0
111 PN M 3-33 PN 18 48 12.1403633760 -25 28 52.423742352     13.20     ~ 87 0
112 PN Hu 2-1 PN 18 49 47.5610183328 +20 50 39.396894756   12.369 11.126 12.30   ~ 286 0
113 M 57 PN 18 53 35.0967659112 +33 01 44.883287544   15.405 15.769 15.901 16.062 DA(O?) 868 2
114 PN Sp 4-1 PN 19 00 26.5460404944 +38 21 07.280102016       15.26   O? 40 0
115 NGC 6741 PN 19 02 37.10 -00 26 56.7     9.6     ~ 353 0
116 IC 4846 PN 19 16 28.2266496960 -09 02 36.677150592           ~ 221 0
117 PN A66 58 PN 19 18 20.476 +01 46 59.62           [WC4] 327 0
118 NGC 6790 PN 19 22 56.972976 +01 30 46.40112   12.247 10.504 12.684   wels 329 0
119 PN Vy 2-2 PN 19 24 22.2390166933 +09 53 56.259102426   14.02 12.65 13.38   O-rich 274 0
120 PN M 3-34 PN 19 27 01.8981450048 -06 35 04.739628516           ~ 70 1
121 NGC 6803 PN 19 31 16.4826019750 +10 03 21.620200381   13.034 11.616 13.242   ~ 254 0
122 NGC 6807 PN 19 34 33.53 +05 41 02.5     12     ~ 144 0
123 PN M 1-73 PN 19 41 09.2937490896 +14 56 58.980006096           O3.5If 85 1
124 PN M 1-74 PN 19 42 18.78 +15 09 08.3   12.8       ~ 127 0
125 NGC 6818 PN 19 43 57.770472 -14 09 13.36932     9.3     ~ 357 1
126 NGC 6826 PN 19 44 48.1500225888 +50 31 30.249034932   9.779 9.359 10.775   O3f(H) 736 0
127 NGC 6833 PN 19 49 46.5667474512 +48 57 40.113276876           ~ 181 0
128 NGC 6884 PN 20 10 23.6424784416 +46 27 39.631794408   11.9 10.9     ~ 322 1
129 NGC 6879 PN 20 10 26.6930056361 +16 55 21.272110541   13.661 12.540 14.075   O3f(He) 157 0
130 NGC 6891 PN 20 15 08.8435405584 +12 42 15.584146740   12.11 12.51     O3Ib(f*) 405 0
131 NGC 7009 PN 21 04 10.8155187648 -11 21 48.580157556   12.48 12.07     ~ 1020 1
132 NGC 7026 PN 21 06 18.5723414928 +47 51 06.774735780   15.33 15.1     [WC3] 427 1
133 NGC 7027 PN 21 07 01.571952 +42 14 10.47120   10.358 8.831 10.157   ~ 2541 1
134 PN Hu 1-2 PN 21 33 08.3106242400 +39 38 09.554428752     12.0     ~ 295 1
135 M 30 GlC 21 40 22.12 -23 10 47.5     7.10     ~ 1121 0
136 IC 5217 PN 22 23 55.7180137224 +50 58 00.464340252     15.5     [WC7] 314 0
137 PN Me 2-2 PN 22 31 43.6753782000 +47 48 03.836846628   9.3       ~ 160 0
138 NGC 7662 PN 23 25 53.8318792825 +42 32 05.835828380       11.427   ~ 940 1
139 NAME Galactic Bulge reg ~ ~           ~ 4794 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2013MNRAS.428.3443M and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu