2014ApJ...789..140L


Query : 2014ApJ...789..140L

2014ApJ...789..140L - Astrophys. J., 789, 140 (2014/July-2)

Constraining sub-parsec binary supermassive black holes in quasars with multi-epoch spectroscopy. II. The population with kinematically offset broad Balmer emission lines.

LIU X., SHEN Y., BIAN F., LOEB A. and TREMAINE S.

Abstract (from CDS):

A small fraction of quasars have long been known to show bulk velocity offsets (of a few hundred to thousands of km/s) in the broad Balmer lines with respect to the systemic redshift of the host galaxy. Models to explain these offsets usually invoke broad-line region gas kinematics/asymmetry around single black holes (BHs), orbital motion of massive (∼sub-parsec (sub-pc)) binary black holes (BBHs), or recoil BHs, but single-epoch spectra are unable to distinguish between these scenarios. The line-of-sight (LOS) radial velocity (RV) shifts from long-term spectroscopic monitoring can be used to test the BBH hypothesis. We have selected a sample of 399 quasars with kinematically offset broad Hβ lines from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) Seventh Data Release quasar catalog, and have conducted second-epoch optical spectroscopy for 50 of them. Combined with the existing SDSS spectra, the new observations enable us to constrain the LOS RV shifts of broad Hβ lines with a rest-frame baseline of a few years to nearly a decade. While previous work focused on objects with extreme velocity offset (>103 km/s), we explore the parameter space with smaller (a few hundred km/s) yet significant offsets (99.7% confidence). Using cross-correlation analysis, we detect significant (99% confidence) radial accelerations in the broad Hβ lines in 24 of the 50 objects, of ∼10-200 km/s/yr with a median measurement uncertainty of ∼10 km/s/yr, implying a high fraction of variability of the broad-line velocity on multi-year timescales. We suggest that 9 of the 24 detections are sub-pc BBH candidates, which show consistent velocity shifts independently measured from a second broad line (either Hα or Mg II) without significant changes in the broad-line profiles. Combining the results on the general quasar population studied in Paper I, we find a tentative anti-correlation between the velocity offset in the first-epoch spectrum and the average acceleration between two epochs, which could be explained by orbital phase modulation when the time separation between two epochs is a non-negligible fraction of the orbital period of the motion causing the line displacement. We discuss the implications of our results for the identification of sub-pc BBH candidates in offset-line quasars and for the constraints on their frequency and orbital parameters.

Abstract Copyright: ∼

Journal keyword(s): black hole physics - galaxies: active - galaxies: nuclei - line: profiles - quasars: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/789/140): table1.dat>

Simbad objects: 56

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 56
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 2MASX J00122399-1022269 Sy1 00 12 24.0235889448 -10 22 26.551199748   17.59 17.25     ~ 61 0
2 [VV2006] J001257.2+011527 QSO 00 12 57.2581500288 +01 15 27.392977836   18.90 18.77     ~ 33 0
3 LBQS 0019+0022A QSO 00 21 41.0149113120 +00 38 41.715667104   18.99 18.54     ~ 38 0
4 [VV2006] J004712.6-084330 QSO 00 47 12.5786277096 -08 43 30.837846828   18.75 18.64     ~ 22 0
5 6dFGS gJ011110.0-101632 Sy1 01 11 10.0407996504 -10 16 31.924953192   17.32 16.96     ~ 34 0
6 NVSS J014218+132747 Sy1 01 42 19.0093430760 +13 27 46.489180068   19.04 18.57     ~ 29 1
7 [VV2006] J020011.5-093126 QSO 02 00 11.5260312000 -09 31 26.196503088   18.41 18.27     ~ 48 0
8 2MASS J02211313+0101031 Sy1 02 21 13.1482941456 +01 01 02.909270136   17.9 18.32 18.3   ~ 30 0
9 Z 538-57 Sy1 02 23 11.41124925 +42 59 31.3853324   15.71 14.81     ~ 582 2
10 SDSS J032838.27-000341.6 Sy1 03 28 38.2850918568 -00 03 41.673192876   20.17 19.54     ~ 15 0
11 2MASS J07391535+4014458 Sy1 07 39 15.3530062488 +40 14 45.725568864   19.00 18.61     ~ 21 0
12 ICRF J074541.6+314256 Sy1 07 45 41.6715742128 +31 42 56.614217508   16.10 15.97     ~ 265 1
13 2MASS J08020278+1019431 QSO 08 02 02.7921167808 +10 19 43.131349488   19.54 18.74     ~ 14 0
14 SDSS J081032.73+565105.3 Sy1 08 10 32.7341564928 +56 51 05.247657432   19.86 19.36     ~ 20 0
15 2MASS J08293059+2728224 Sy1 08 29 30.6001971624 +27 28 22.680198192   18.70 18.49     ~ 33 0
16 2MASS J08471602+3732182 Sy1 08 47 16.0432340520 +37 32 18.032278992   18.62 18.51     ~ 74 0
17 LB 8798 QSO 08 52 37.0182735720 +20 04 10.970840136   18.29 18.27     ~ 31 0
18 PG 0851+202 BLL 08 54 48.8749846272 +20 06 30.639583620   15.649 15.146 15.446   ~ 2513 1
19 QSO J0918+3156 QSO 09 18 33.8205227544 +31 56 21.173631576   18.57 18.27     ~ 37 0
20 QSO J0918+2325 QSO 09 18 58.1572204896 +23 25 55.369388856   16.9 17.91 17.1   ~ 28 0
21 QSO J0919+1108 QSO 09 19 30.3165830760 +11 08 54.039290028   17.56 17.43     ~ 25 0
22 [VV2006] J091941.1+534550 QSO 09 19 41.1477796992 +53 45 51.102295344   19.12 19.03     ~ 25 0
23 SBSG 0924+606B Bla 09 28 37.9886806104 +60 25 21.018272772   17.53 17.20     ~ 88 1
24 QSO J0936+5331 QSO 09 36 53.8425623232 +53 31 26.793991092   17.52 17.22     ~ 42 0
25 SDSS J101000.54+074235.5 QSO 10 10 00.5412724248 +07 42 35.516675196   19.74 19.42     ~ 22 0
26 6C 101804+453853 Bla 10 21 06.0461738640 +45 23 31.819761204   18.44 18.38 17.6   ~ 58 1
27 6C 102810+311911 BLL 10 30 59.0936990784 +31 02 55.723145964   17.07 16.71 16.1   ~ 192 1
28 2MASS J10444877+0739281 Sy1 10 44 48.8138370552 +07 39 28.671004872   18.77 18.48     ~ 20 0
29 2MASS J11005099+1709341 QSO 11 00 50.9997617256 +17 09 34.247217564   19.13 18.89     ~ 18 0
30 2MASS J11123089+1813115 Sy1 11 12 30.8999026920 +18 13 11.470991412   18.96 18.43     ~ 24 0
31 2MASS J11200742+4235517 Sy1 11 20 07.4313427152 +42 35 51.389354292   17.91 17.69     ~ 36 1
32 2MASS J11364090+5738399 Sy1 11 36 40.8993335616 +57 38 39.961599432   18.08 17.74     ~ 28 0
33 QSO J1154+0134 QSO 11 54 49.4222764200 +01 34 43.581752256   18.34 18.12     ~ 30 1
34 NGC 4151 Sy1 12 10 32.5759813872 +39 24 21.063527532   12.18 11.48     ~ 3938 2
35 2MASS J12201843+0641196 Sy1 12 20 18.4414889616 +06 41 19.609635012   17.67 17.49     ~ 49 0
36 2MASS J12281188+5146232 QSO 12 28 11.8883750184 +51 46 22.768988304   19.78 19.15     ~ 26 0
37 ZW VIII 233 Sy1 13 05 34.4947107168 +18 19 32.869333236   17.35 17.00     ~ 29 0
38 2MASS J13071235+3406225 Sy1 13 07 12.3343988424 +34 06 22.566562668   18.35 17.86     ~ 25 0
39 LEDA 1398154 Sy1 13 45 48.5056508376 +11 44 43.518012468   17.71 17.43     ~ 36 0
40 2MASS J14130054+4016245 QSO 14 13 00.5371748592 +40 16 24.510315648   18.87 18.59     ~ 25 0
41 NGC 5548 Sy1 14 17 59.5400291832 +25 08 12.603122268   14.35 13.73     ~ 2895 0
42 6C 142125+510933 Bla 14 23 14.1852096840 +50 55 37.285758732   18.25 17.88 14.93   ~ 96 1
43 QSO B1628+3803 QSO 16 30 20.7806364000 +37 56 56.424675300   18.35 18.24     ~ 47 0
44 2MASS J16521947+2903193 Sy1 16 52 19.4786268912 +29 03 19.102600368   18.93 18.38     ~ 21 0
45 Z 252-40 Bla 17 19 14.4925971408 +48 58 49.423205136   15.86 14.81 9.44   ~ 335 1
46 3C 390.3 Bla 18 42 08.9904975672 +79 46 17.127835104   16.06 15.38     ~ 1381 1
47 2SLAQ J211234.88-005926.8 Sy1 21 12 34.8767738304 -00 59 26.858271192   18.86 18.44     ~ 33 0
48 [VV2006] J212937.0-072432 QSO 21 29 36.9729248016 -07 24 31.862140632   17.93 17.82     ~ 22 0
49 SDSS J213040.15-082159.9 Sy1 21 30 40.1550897792 -08 21 59.901352812   18.92 18.52     ~ 22 0
50 2MASS J22053771-0711147 Sy1 22 05 37.7185254768 -07 11 14.570660904   18.86 18.44     ~ 25 0
51 SDSS J224903.28-080841.7 QSO 22 49 03.2870480040 -08 08 41.703650088   19.71 19.54     ~ 23 0
52 SDSS J230248.88+134553.4 QSO 23 02 48.8786603952 +13 45 53.472928716   19.22 18.98     ~ 21 0
53 6dFGS gJ230323.5-100236 Sy1 23 03 23.4817468248 -10 02 35.365776324   18.97 18.36     ~ 26 0
54 LEDA 994116 Sy2 23 08 45.6001315368 -09 11 23.962016220   17.92 17.47 16.54   ~ 34 0
55 SDSS J232124.43+134930.1 QSO 23 21 24.4379532264 +13 49 30.065570940   19.02 18.75     ~ 25 0
56 [VV2006] J234852.5-091400 QSO 23 48 52.5034369536 -09 14 00.806152560   18.97 18.90     ~ 24 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2014ApJ...789..140L and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu