2015MNRAS.449.4038D


Query : 2015MNRAS.449.4038D

2015MNRAS.449.4038D - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 449, 4038-4047 (2015/June-1)

Lithium abundances in globular cluster giants: NGC 1904, NGC 2808, and NGC 362.

D'ORAZI V., GRATTON R.G., ANGELOU G.C., BRAGAGLIA A., CARRETTA E., LATTANZIO J.C., LUCATELLO S., MOMANY Y., SOLLIMA A. and BECCARI G.

Abstract (from CDS):

The presence of multiple populations in globular clusters has been well established thanks to high-resolution spectroscopy. It is widely accepted that distinct populations are a consequence of different stellar generations: intracluster pollution episodes are required to produce the peculiar chemistry observed in almost all clusters. Unfortunately, the progenitors responsible have left an ambiguous signature and their nature remains unresolved. To constrain the candidate polluters, we have measured lithium and aluminium abundances in more than 180 giants across three systems: NGC 1904, NGC 2808, and NGC 362. The present investigation along with our previous analysis of M12 and M5 affords us the largest data base of simultaneous determinations of Li and Al abundances. Our results indicate that Li production has occurred in each of the three clusters. In NGC 362, we detected an M12-like behaviour, with first- and second-generation stars sharing very similar Li abundances favouring a progenitor that is able to produce Li, such as asymptotic giant branches stars. Multiple progenitor types are possible in NGC 1904 and NGC 2808, as they possess both an intermediate population comparable in lithium to the first generation stars and also an extreme population, that is enriched in Al but depleted in Li. A simple dilution model fails in reproducing this complex pattern. Finally, the internal Li variation seems to suggest that the production efficiency of this element is a function of the cluster's mass and metallicity - low-mass or relatively metal-rich clusters are more adept at producing Li.

Abstract Copyright: © 2015 The Authors Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Astronomical Society (2015)

Journal keyword(s): stars: abundances - stars: Population II - globular clusters: individual: NGC 1904 - globular clusters: individual: NGC 2808 - globular clusters: individual: NGC 362

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/MNRAS/449/4038): table1.dat>

Nomenclature: Table 1: [DGA2015] NGC 1904 NNNNN N=48 among (Nos 622-12004), [DGA2015] NGC 2808 NNNNN N=69 among (Nos 7431-63132), [DGA2015] NGC 362 NNNNN N=68 among (Nos 1155-19167).

Simbad objects: 198

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 198
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NGC 288 GlC 00 52 45.24 -26 34 57.4   10 8.13     ~ 1130 0
2 2MASS J01021432-7059066 RG* 01 02 14.3089688304 -70 59 06.567765360   17.121 16.361     ~ 7 0
3 2MASS J01022786-7054122 RG* 01 02 27.8571186000 -70 54 12.188664324   16.526 15.736     ~ 11 0
4 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 58 RG* 01 02 30.4323808728 -70 55 07.017786336   16.240 15.426     ~ 16 0
5 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 63 * 01 02 32.5276923408 -70 50 17.992235364   16.970 16.241     ~ 7 0
6 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2130 * 01 02 32.5599007536 -70 50 38.174862048   16.660 15.876     ~ 9 0
7 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2209 * 01 02 42.4174011072 -70 51 28.338832116   16.665 15.901     ~ 6 0
8 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2217 * 01 02 46.5149621304 -70 52 35.049014940   16.862 16.118     ~ 7 0
9 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 100 Pe* 01 02 47.2367345496 -70 48 14.298947280   16.497 15.658     ~ 12 0
10 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1213 * 01 02 49.9629968160 -70 51 58.246881804   16.250 15.429     ~ 10 0
11 2MASS J01025134-7051315 * 01 02 51.3244863192 -70 51 31.509585324   16.976 16.229     ~ 6 0
12 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1201 * 01 02 52.739 -70 51 08.29   16.985 16.214     ~ 2 0
13 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1146 * 01 02 53.9177408232 -70 49 49.918675764   16.141 15.271     ~ 10 0
14 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 135 * 01 02 56.50 -70 49 40.3   16.800 15.980     ~ 5 0
15 2MASS J01025707-7051018 RG* 01 02 57.0716533800 -70 51 01.891934676   16.190 15.362     ~ 10 0
16 2MASS J01025723-7046199 RG* 01 02 57.2371065624 -70 46 19.943699304   16.782 15.987     ~ 12 0
17 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2110 * 01 02 57.4486424064 -70 48 34.059756744   17.034 16.243     ~ 6 0
18 2MASS J01025863-7049508 * 01 02 58.638 -70 49 50.81   17.070 16.287     ~ 4 0
19 2MASS J01025878-7052042 * 01 02 58.7959115592 -70 52 04.328683788   17.038 16.291     ~ 6 0
20 2MASS J01025903-7048579 RG* 01 02 59.0262346704 -70 48 57.931778808   16.658 15.818     ~ 11 0
21 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 108 * 01 03 00.8835196440 -70 55 17.473499508   16.261 15.451     ~ 11 0
22 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2221 RG* 01 03 00.9725733360 -70 53 17.640611160   16.182 15.381     ~ 15 0
23 2MASS J01030159-7049479 * 01 03 01.5850047600 -70 49 48.048430836   16.441 15.576     ~ 6 0
24 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2107 * 01 03 02.5919197584 -70 48 23.011519860   16.892 16.076     ~ 8 0
25 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 190 Pe* 01 03 03.6731849520 -70 56 21.385326768   16.577 15.726     ~ 9 0
26 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 218 Pe* 01 03 09.1435375824 -70 47 30.154279236   16.700 15.856     ~ 12 0
27 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 109 RG* 01 03 10.0430287680 -70 54 33.835316040   16.262 15.412     ~ 16 0
28 GES J01031273-7049395 * 01 03 12.7404435336 -70 49 39.460042992   16.226 15.381     ~ 5 0
29 NGC 362 GlC 01 03 14.26 -70 50 55.6     6.58     ~ 1167 0
30 2MASS J01031833-7052456 * 01 03 18.3165665736 -70 52 45.692052096   17.110 16.371     ~ 6 0
31 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1309 * 01 03 18.3641846832 -70 53 16.604050812   16.187 15.344     ~ 11 0
32 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 257 * 01 03 18.8368821312 -70 49 47.182737756   16.407 15.567     ~ 6 0
33 2MASS J01031999-7051497 * 01 03 20.0118173065 -70 51 49.683204376   17.023 16.249     ~ 6 0
34 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 274 * 01 03 21.2270847406 -70 52 38.213174476   16.570 15.768     ~ 10 0
35 2MASS J01032304-7045467 RG* 01 03 23.0394394008 -70 45 46.864384236   16.929 16.128     ~ 11 0
36 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 132 RG* 01 03 23.1261570168 -70 55 36.525085644   16.288 15.429     ~ 15 0
37 2MASS J01032415-7051369 * 01 03 24.160 -70 51 36.96   16.750 15.995     ~ 5 0
38 2MASS J01032640-7050109 * 01 03 26.4103670376 -70 50 11.036700060   16.647 15.858     ~ 6 0
39 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1322 * 01 03 26.545 -70 52 27.80   16.965 16.238     ~ 5 0
40 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 314 * 01 03 27.7139936928 -70 50 26.482057944   16.249 15.424     ~ 7 0
41 2MASS J01032799-7052510 * 01 03 27.9895110528 -70 52 51.056811480   16.802 16.025     ~ 8 0
42 2MASS J01032870-7049226 * 01 03 28.6894790904 -70 49 22.716773184   16.776 15.973     ~ 5 0
43 2MASS J01032877-7051032 * 01 03 28.7806394319 -70 51 03.375328859   16.945 16.219     ~ 5 0
44 NGC 362 2041 * 01 03 30.5525204088 -70 53 53.831342652   17.032 16.301     ~ 9 0
45 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 128 * 01 03 31.0346531472 -70 54 17.512542360   16.259 15.434     ~ 11 0
46 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2312 * 01 03 32.2091613408 -70 53 35.937813876   16.443 15.639     ~ 7 0
47 2MASS J01033224-7051051 * 01 03 32.2470537264 -70 51 05.249991816   16.614 15.822     ~ 4 0
48 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2416 * 01 03 34.059 -70 48 54.75   16.370 15.519     ~ 3 0
49 2MASS J01033754-7051522 * 01 03 37.5392032776 -70 51 52.380303480   16.817 16.015     ~ 5 0
50 2MASS J01033772-7051225 * 01 03 37.7195422488 -70 51 22.617672264   16.340 15.527     ~ 5 0
51 2MASS J01033862-7049449 * 01 03 38.625 -70 49 44.90   17.047 16.222     ~ 6 0
52 2MASS J01033916-7056231 RG* 01 03 39.1453572192 -70 56 23.231474232   17.122 16.345     ~ 7 0
53 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2323 * 01 03 40.1139074136 -70 52 14.890491516   16.298 15.497     ~ 5 0
54 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1404 * 01 03 42.0156723408 -70 50 45.514777596   17.088 16.349     ~ 7 0
55 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 135 RG* 01 03 43.0441241904 -70 54 52.210317780   16.230 15.398     ~ 16 0
56 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2327 * 01 03 46.5633357168 -70 52 02.178261300   16.887 16.134     ~ 5 0
57 2MASS J01034760-7055033 RG* 01 03 47.5901322384 -70 55 03.419470956   16.713 15.906     ~ 14 0
58 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2406 * 01 03 47.8983743304 -70 50 02.494883940   16.286 15.463     ~ 11 0
59 2MASS J01035172-7049082 RG* 01 03 51.7077160896 -70 49 08.379029316   16.200 15.310     ~ 8 0
60 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2404 RG* 01 03 54.4994866608 -70 50 22.922629692   16.261 15.436     ~ 17 0
61 2MASS J01035491-7052292 RG* 01 03 54.9096125664 -70 52 29.337213756   16.157 15.314     ~ 8 0
62 2MASS J01035605-7042262 RG* 01 03 56.0539913160 -70 42 26.321390244   16.331 15.425     ~ 10 0
63 2MASS J01040598-7048483 RG* 01 04 05.9854644600 -70 48 48.422763864   16.151 15.260     ~ 12 0
64 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 163 RG* 01 04 05.9986610352 -70 52 32.836324836   16.214 15.382     ~ 16 0
65 2MASS J01040681-7050557 * 01 04 06.8145860232 -70 50 55.677740856   16.849 16.110     ~ 6 0
66 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 443 RG* 01 04 11.4836124024 -70 43 39.781499736   16.330 15.461     ~ 15 0
67 2MASS J01041856-7052362 RG* 01 04 18.5549893656 -70 52 36.203272608   16.274 15.430     ~ 12 0
68 2MASS J01041867-7049395 RG* 01 04 18.6633308952 -70 49 39.574989840   16.749 15.905     ~ 8 0
69 2MASS J01042200-7054126 RG* 01 04 21.9937409448 -70 54 12.666741192   16.605 15.808     ~ 11 0
70 2MASS J01042945-7048428 RG* 01 04 29.4375615504 -70 48 42.852851928   16.992 16.200     ~ 8 0
71 2MASS J05234497-2434143 * 05 23 44.9758772616 -24 34 14.443830300   17.240 16.467     ~ 9 0
72 2MASS J05234968-2434235 * 05 23 49.6776036672 -24 34 23.596763376   17.565 16.806     ~ 9 0
73 2MASS J05235454-2432081 RG* 05 23 54.5438165184 -24 32 08.194475760   16.34 15.49 15.334 14.50 ~ 14 0
74 2MASS J05235893-2430021 RG* 05 23 58.9363704192 -24 30 02.186522028   16.922 15.984 15.871   ~ 12 0
75 2MASS J05235968-2433393 RG* 05 23 59.6830572696 -24 33 39.327611904   17.48 16.77   15.89 ~ 8 0
76 UCAC4 328-007634 RG* 05 24 02.1828031896 -24 31 17.356640124   15.65 14.69 14.517 13.60 ~ 18 0
77 2MASS J05240265-2431446 RG* 05 24 02.6593953552 -24 31 44.774169348   17.09 16.31   15.38 ~ 11 0
78 UCAC4 328-007640 Pe* 05 24 04.1202701784 -24 32 23.105681412   16.427 15.618 15.307   ~ 9 0
79 2MASS J05240494-2431266 RG* 05 24 04.9455829176 -24 31 26.741631540   16.06 15.17   14.14 ~ 9 0
80 2MASS J05240496-2430110 * 05 24 04.9696658314 -24 30 11.065170282   17.251 16.507     ~ 8 0
81 2MASS J05240503-2429444 RG* 05 24 05.0320902384 -24 29 44.512695996   16.460 15.571     ~ 11 0
82 2MASS J05240576-2432148 * 05 24 05.7677833176 -24 32 14.901064584   16.978 16.215     ~ 6 0
83 2MASS J05240661-2431125 RG* 05 24 06.6134494656 -24 31 12.622308024   15.41 14.38   13.26 ~ 17 0
84 2MASS J05240730-2433590 RG* 05 24 07.3055032440 -24 33 59.088957624   15.73 14.78   13.70 ~ 14 0
85 2MASS J05240737-2433383 RG* 05 24 07.3750007952 -24 33 38.419485192   17.43 16.69   15.80 ~ 8 0
86 2MASS J05240772-2430216 * 05 24 07.7298243840 -24 30 21.705536592   17.125 16.368     ~ 5 0
87 2MASS J05240954-2435015 * 05 24 09.5443848504 -24 35 01.595292936   17.471 16.718     ~ 8 0
88 2MASS J05240973-2428280 * 05 24 09.7350638688 -24 28 28.118377560   16.190 15.274     ~ 9 0
89 2MASS J05240988-2427489 Pe* 05 24 09.8860483464 -24 27 49.026320928   16.570 15.724     ~ 11 0
90 2MASS J05240999-2432244 RG* 05 24 09.9942131856 -24 32 24.506932200   15.525 14.558     ~ 11 0
91 M 79 GlC 05 24 10.59 -24 31 27.3     8.16     ~ 883 0
92 UCAC4 328-007742 RG* 05 24 10.7491775520 -24 35 44.468077704   15.855 15.047 14.680 13.867 ~ 19 0
93 2MASS J05241160-2436297 RG* 05 24 11.6152056192 -24 36 29.783611728   17.166 16.322     ~ 10 0
94 2MASS J05241172-2430038 RG* 05 24 11.7293334792 -24 30 03.906240300   15.341 14.257   13.061 ~ 14 0
95 2MASS J05241192-2432377 RG* 05 24 11.9297592768 -24 32 37.834546524   16.932 16.105     ~ 9 0
96 2MASS J05241202-2433374 RG* 05 24 12.0208530120 -24 33 37.569563244   17.353 16.555     ~ 7 0
97 2MASS J05241274-2430539 * 05 24 12.7495225728 -24 30 54.003058020   16.964 16.187     ~ 6 0
98 2MASS J05241284-2432576 RG* 05 24 12.8513890392 -24 32 57.748276356   17.374 16.602     ~ 10 0
99 2MASS J05241286-2432198 * 05 24 12.8631019464 -24 32 19.909457952   16.523 15.679     ~ 6 0
100 Cl* NGC 1904 SAW V1 RG* 05 24 13.0056794976 -24 34 44.078020284   15.971 15.012   13.944 ~ 17 0
101 2MASS J05241399-2432015 RG* 05 24 14.0010611688 -24 32 01.578917832   16.937 16.107     ~ 9 0
102 2MASS J05241411-2430405 RG* 05 24 14.1149134704 -24 30 40.625298900   15.38 14.34 13.991 13.20 ~ 8 0
103 2MASS J05241413-2429397 * 05 24 14.1484332336 -24 29 39.838615044   17.192 16.392     ~ 5 0
104 UCAC4 328-007849 RG* 05 24 15.8123243808 -24 29 52.643251536   15.832 15.113 14.738   ~ 14 0
105 [CBG2009] NGC 1904 440 RG* 05 24 17.1829812624 -24 31 24.828911616   16.885 16.083     ~ 7 0
106 2MASS J05241744-2431425 RG* 05 24 17.4536215872 -24 31 42.657053124   16.941 16.131     ~ 7 0
107 2MASS J05241771-2430285 * 05 24 17.7205760592 -24 30 28.677701484   17.465 16.767     ~ 5 0
108 2MASS J05241812-2429393 RG* 05 24 18.1302433848 -24 29 39.466753584   17.357 16.581     ~ 9 0
109 2MASS J05241873-2430146 Pe* 05 24 18.7458162480 -24 30 14.756311116   15.172 14.045     ~ 9 0
110 2MASS J05241942-2427339 RG* 05 24 19.4257013664 -24 27 34.071789456   16.315 15.438     ~ 11 0
111 2MASS J05241954-2433012 RG* 05 24 19.5485902848 -24 33 01.355804532   16.202 15.405 15.169   ~ 11 0
112 2MASS J05241990-2433366 * 05 24 19.9163668584 -24 33 36.723380796   16.973 16.223     ~ 8 0
113 2MASS J05241997-2431224 RG* 05 24 19.9760391024 -24 31 22.559059344   17.156 16.376     ~ 7 0
114 UCAC4 328-007881 Pe* 05 24 20.5864271928 -24 30 40.055960376   16.582 15.762 15.685   ~ 7 0
115 2MASS J05242075-2433266 RG* 05 24 20.7540084192 -24 33 26.733534444   15.936 14.987   13.909 ~ 17 0
116 2MASS J05242370-2430189 RG* 05 24 23.7153736152 -24 30 19.040433264   15.219 14.123     ~ 15 0
117 2MASS J05242512-2428560 RG* 05 24 25.1267733096 -24 28 56.132238360   17.218 16.447     ~ 11 0
118 UCAC4 328-007892 RG* 05 24 26.0585703192 -24 31 47.995073832   15.399 14.296 13.765 13.096 ~ 18 0
119 UCAC4 328-007899 Pe* 05 24 32.3844102456 -24 30 28.366723260   16.523 15.666 15.301   ~ 9 0
120 2MASS J09104826-6448061 * 09 10 48.2640839496 -64 48 06.209156520   17.967 16.978     ~ 5 0
121 2MASS J09104989-6452165 * 09 10 49.9037314656 -64 52 16.671241848   17.888 16.893     ~ 5 0
122 2MASS J09110592-6446565 * 09 11 05.9309697912 -64 46 56.549355780   17.727 16.742     ~ 6 0
123 2MASS J09111896-6451494 * 09 11 18.9797351712 -64 51 49.421761308   16.93 15.840     ~ 6 0
124 2MASS J09112065-6451382 * 09 11 20.6474321136 -64 51 38.292712668   17.866 16.856     ~ 5 0
125 2MASS J09112571-6453259 * 09 11 25.7035404792 -64 53 25.944797292   17.812 16.788     ~ 5 0
126 2MASS J09113787-6451485 * 09 11 37.8727442208 -64 51 48.564653868   17.637 16.599     ~ 5 0
127 GES J09113929-6452595 * 09 11 39.2976315785 -64 52 59.599162028   17.896 16.914     ~ 4 0
128 2MASS J09113948-6451285 * 09 11 39.4989114768 -64 51 28.638866808   18.027 16.987     ~ 6 0
129 2MASS J09113954-6452143 * 09 11 39.5422110936 -64 52 14.382496740   17.891 16.901     ~ 4 0
130 2MASS J09114207-6452127 * 09 11 42.0752905968 -64 52 12.793814652   17.589 16.522     ~ 5 0
131 2MASS J09114296-6447452 * 09 11 42.9793780824 -64 47 45.257209872   17.741 16.716     ~ 5 0
132 2MASS J09114660-6450097 * 09 11 46.6113234432 -64 50 09.834750816   17.776 16.821     ~ 5 0
133 2MASS J09114685-6454093 * 09 11 46.8614901936 -64 54 09.400703184   17.551 16.607     ~ 5 0
134 2MASS J09114940-6456348 * 09 11 49.4080768776 -64 56 34.898023464   17.733 16.716     ~ 5 0
135 2MASS J09114990-6450270 * 09 11 49.9234278744 -64 50 27.017804436   17.795 16.785     ~ 6 0
136 GES J09115027-6452249 * 09 11 50.2884151480 -64 52 25.010174894   17.872 16.913     ~ 4 0
137 2MASS J09115254-6452541 * 09 11 52.5386870283 -64 52 54.105652567   17.737 16.762     ~ 4 0
138 2MASS J09115253-6448233 * 09 11 52.5468664896 -64 48 23.284801512   17.808 16.763     ~ 6 0
139 2MASS J09115301-6450304 * 09 11 53.0252696136 -64 50 30.394565628   16.997 15.906     ~ 5 0
140 GES J09115332-6450477 * 09 11 53.3369613238 -64 50 47.803272702   17.510 16.566     ~ 4 0
141 2MASS J09115615-6456256 * 09 11 56.1500586936 -64 56 25.741804740   17.737 16.728     ~ 5 0
142 2MASS J09115671-6449557 * 09 11 56.7068043542 -64 49 55.883590597   17.713 16.738     ~ 5 0
143 2MASS J09115824-6448300 * 09 11 58.2352435320 -64 48 30.159912204   17.655 16.613     ~ 5 0
144 2MASS J09120087-6450373 * 09 12 00.8587584176 -64 50 37.554001224   17.721 16.747     ~ 5 0
145 2MASS J09120093-6503451 * 09 12 00.9321318240 -65 03 45.261834336   17.806 16.876     ~ 4 0
146 2MASS J09120106-6454285 * 09 12 01.0595747472 -64 54 28.611975420   17.574 16.568     ~ 5 0
147 GES J09120305-6453201 * 09 12 03.05 -64 53 20.1   17.553 16.556     ~ 4 0
148 NGC 2808 GlC 09 12 03.10 -64 51 48.6           ~ 1540 0
149 2MASS J09120496-6449256 * 09 12 04.9830869934 -64 49 25.643826013   17.983 17.001     ~ 5 0
150 2MASS J09120566-6456385 * 09 12 05.6572584912 -64 56 38.590964304   17.813 16.836     ~ 5 0
151 2MASS J09120614-6454034 * 09 12 06.1465660730 -64 54 03.866210862   17.936 16.975     ~ 5 0
152 2MASS J09120733-6453186 * 09 12 07.3226016023 -64 53 18.684419562   17.697 16.792     ~ 4 0
153 2MASS J09120907-6450508 * 09 12 09.0840675132 -64 50 50.880424963   17.661 16.675     ~ 4 0
154 2MASS J09120982-6450218 * 09 12 09.8689759736 -64 50 21.951266391   17.618 16.593     ~ 5 0
155 2MASS J09121026-6455143 * 09 12 10.2643799472 -64 55 14.375439840   17.641 16.704     ~ 4 0
156 2MASS J09121076-6448378 * 09 12 10.7733823488 -64 48 37.864636560   17.728 16.684     ~ 6 0
157 2MASS J09121181-6458293 * 09 12 11.8203288528 -64 58 29.448646392   17.612 16.633     ~ 5 0
158 2MASS J09121265-6455413 * 09 12 12.6510539856 -64 55 41.425186512   17.911 16.925     ~ 5 0
159 2MASS J09121359-6452240 * 09 12 13.6062839088 -64 52 24.003324972   17.943 17.010     ~ 4 0
160 GES J09121370-6452363 * 09 12 13.71 -64 52 36.4   17.662 16.668     ~ 5 0
161 2MASS J09121379-6446130 * 09 12 13.8030417939 -64 46 13.115504539   17.796 16.832     ~ 5 0
162 GES J09121563-6450417 * 09 12 15.6428425570 -64 50 41.735826623   17.897 16.942     ~ 4 0
163 2MASS J09121692-6453111 * 09 12 16.9358580648 -64 53 11.285283516   17.506 16.57     ~ 7 0
164 2MASS J09121738-6448592 * 09 12 17.3878008360 -64 48 59.353869960   17.634 16.589     ~ 5 0
165 2MASS J09121801-6455160 * 09 12 18.0262648272 -64 55 16.158311076   17.603 16.572     ~ 6 0
166 2MASS J09121868-6453555 * 09 12 18.6972636288 -64 53 55.545142344   17.778 16.864     ~ 5 0
167 GES J09121908-6451284 * 09 12 19.0878866671 -64 51 28.441080922   17.582 16.583     ~ 4 0
168 2MASS J09122009-6449561 * 09 12 20.1058756029 -64 49 56.173167303   17.776 16.799     ~ 5 0
169 2MASS J09122276-6448360 * 09 12 22.7660121057 -64 48 36.127656902   17.937 16.978     ~ 5 0
170 2MASS J09122306-6451373 * 09 12 23.0655657456 -64 51 37.458636840   17.596 16.614     ~ 4 0
171 2MASS J09122306-6452205 * 09 12 23.0878757781 -64 52 20.451500319   17.775 16.814     ~ 5 0
172 2MASS J09122316-6448189 * 09 12 23.1648012456 -64 48 19.001941956   17.616 16.555     ~ 5 0
173 2MASS J09122405-6447568 * 09 12 24.0675163152 -64 47 56.982570648   17.951 16.945     ~ 5 0
174 2MASS J09122461-6451473 * 09 12 24.6347230920 -64 51 47.521991196   17.922 16.942     ~ 5 0
175 2MASS J09122485-6455097 * 09 12 24.8551318416 -64 55 09.854490288   17.826 16.847     ~ 5 0
176 2MASS J09122592-6453315 * 09 12 25.9488472128 -64 53 31.568475948   17.893 16.977     ~ 5 0
177 2MASS J09122812-6456498 * 09 12 28.1168156640 -64 56 49.883283888   17.715 16.775     ~ 5 0
178 2MASS J09122908-6453263 * 09 12 29.1041820552 -64 53 26.385047556   17.680 16.698     ~ 5 0
179 2MASS J09122912-6450230 * 09 12 29.1442472904 -64 50 23.088589512   16.978 15.881     ~ 5 0
180 2MASS J09123529-6448403 * 09 12 35.3135541864 -64 48 40.451471100   17.726 16.674     ~ 5 0
181 2MASS J09123886-6450193 * 09 12 38.8827280968 -64 50 19.344167448   17.668 16.648     ~ 6 0
182 2MASS J09124000-6449081 * 09 12 40.0163626080 -64 49 08.200861788   17.627 16.585     ~ 5 0
183 2MASS J09124374-6451051 * 09 12 43.7564055192 -64 51 05.184764424   16.969 15.892     ~ 5 0
184 2MASS J09125194-6444119 * 09 12 51.9677891304 -64 44 11.955236496   17.973 16.965     ~ 5 0
185 2MASS J09125944-6445313 * 09 12 59.4565427280 -64 45 31.294551708   18.004 16.973     ~ 5 0
186 2MASS J09130064-6451361 * 09 13 00.6637508376 -64 51 36.140506272   17.590 16.556     ~ 6 0
187 2MASS J09130111-6455180 * 09 13 01.1232713280 -64 55 17.947962156   17.623 16.662     ~ 5 0
188 2MASS J09130326-6454445 * 09 13 03.2704866864 -64 54 44.486682732   17.551 16.571     ~ 5 0
189 2MASS J09130974-6450150 * 09 13 09.7601854704 -64 50 15.131843664   17.719 16.67     ~ 6 0
190 Cl Ruprecht 106 GlC 12 38 40.20 -51 09 01.0           ~ 413 0
191 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7     5.95     ~ 2095 0
192 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1978 0
193 M 12 GlC 16 47 14.18 -01 56 54.7     6.07     ~ 736 0
194 NGC 6397 GlC 17 40 42.09 -53 40 27.6     5.17     ~ 2103 0
195 M 54 GlC 18 55 03.33 -30 28 47.5           ~ 1164 0
196 NGC 6752 GlC 19 10 52.11 -59 59 04.4           ~ 2121 0
197 Cl Terzan 7 GlC 19 17 43.92 -34 39 27.8           ~ 460 0
198 Cl Pal 12 GlC 21 46 38.84 -21 15 09.4     11.89     ~ 548 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2015MNRAS.449.4038D and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu