2016A&A...589A.110A

Query : 2016A&A...589A.110A

2016A&A...589A.110A - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 589A110-110 (2016/5-1)

Type II supernovae as probes of environment metallicity: observations of host H II regions.

ANDERSON J.P., GUTIERREZ C.P., DESSART L., HAMUY M., GALBANY L., MORRELL N.I., STRITZINGER M.D., PHILLIPS M.M., FOLATELLI G., BOFFIN H.M.J., DE JAEGER T., KUNCARAYAKTI H. and PRIETO J.L.

Abstract (from CDS):

Context. Spectral modelling of typeII supernova atmospheres indicates a clear dependence of metal line strengths on progenitor metallicity. This dependence motivates further work to evaluate the accuracy with which these supernovae can be used as environment metallicity indicators.
Aims. To assess this accuracy we present a sample of typeII supernova host HII-region spectroscopy, from which environment oxygen abundances have been derived. These environment abundances are compared to the observed strength of metal lines in supernova spectra.
Methods. Combining our sample with measurements from the literature, we present oxygen abundances of 119 host HII regions by extracting emission line fluxes and using abundance diagnostics. These abundances are then compared to equivalent widths of FeII 5018Å at various time and colour epochs.
Results. Our distribution of inferred typeII supernova host HII-region abundances has a range of ∼0.6dex. We confirm the dearth of typeII supernovae exploding at metallicities lower than those found (on average) in the Large Magellanic Cloud. The equivalent width of FeII 5018Å at 50 days post-explosion shows a statistically significant correlation with host HII-region oxygen abundance. The strength of this correlation increases if one excludes abundance measurements derived far from supernova explosion sites. The correlation significance also increases if we only analyse a "gold" IIP sample, and if a colour epoch is used in place of time. In addition, no evidence is found of a correlation between progenitor metallicity and supernova light-curve or spectral properties - except for that stated above with respect to FeII 5018Å equivalent widths - suggesting progenitor metallicity is not a driving factor in producing the diversity that is observed in our sample.
Conclusions. This study provides observational evidence of the usefulness of typeII supernovae as metallicity indicators. We finish with a discussion of the methodology needed to use supernova spectra as independent metallicity diagnostics throughout the Universe.

Abstract Copyright: © ESO, 2016

Journal keyword(s): supernovae: general - HII regions - galaxies: abundances

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/589/A110): tablea1.dat tableb1.dat>

Errata: corrigendum vol.590, art. C2 (2016)

CDS comments: Title corrected from erratum (H II instead of He II).

Simbad objects: 217

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 217
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA 		ICRS (J2000)
DEC 		Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026 		#notes
1 Z 409-33 GiP 00 33 15.441 +07 54 18.45   15.7       ~ 35 0
2 SN 2003ip SN* 00 33 16.76 +07 54 19.5     16.5     SNII 16 1
3 SN 1990K SN* 00 34 13.98 -27 47 45.9     14     SNII 64 1
4 NGC 150 Sy1 00 34 15.4727570592 -27 48 12.824363736   12.04 11.13 10.92 11.7 ~ 208 0
5 SN 2008gr SN* 00 45 32.28 -26 34 20.2           SNIIP 19 1
6 IC 1579 EmG 00 45 32.463 -26 33 55.78   14.99   13.83   ~ 24 0
7 NAME SMC G 00 52 38.0 -72 48 01   2.79 2.2     ~ 12317 1
8 SN 1992am SN* 01 25 02.76 -04 39 00.9   18.5 18.5     SNIIP 59 1
9 MCG-01-04-039 GiC 01 25 04.3345577592 -04 38 59.130533760   15   14.43   ~ 27 0
10 IC 1704 GiG 01 27 09.5314788936 +14 46 34.605545232   14.2       ~ 57 0
11 SN 2007il SN* 01 27 09.75 +14 46 46.5     18.4     SNII 29 1
12 MCG-07-04-011 EmG 01 30 05.4318266256 -42 41 10.786443072   14.04   12.83   ~ 46 0
13 SN 2005me SN* 01 30 09.22 -42 41 07.0     17.5     SNII 22 1
14 SN 2002ig SN* 01 36 36.72 +00 55 25.6           SNII 12 1
15 SN 2003gd SN* 01 36 42.65 +15 44 19.9     13.2     SNIIP 267 2
16 SN 2003hd SN* 01 49 46.31 -21 54 37.8     17.4     SNII 26 1
17 SN 2004fc SN* 01 51 03.85 -09 42 06.9     15.5     SNIIP 36 1
18 NGC 701 GiG 01 51 03.8830973976 -09 42 09.227365200   12.8   11.59 12.6 ~ 185 0
19 SN 2009A SN* 01 52 44.34 -03 23 48.2           SNIIP 18 1
20 NGC 772 GiP 01 59 19.5557148984 +19 00 27.475677216 11.35 11.09 10.31 10.23 9.38 ~ 339 1
21 SN 2003iq SN* 01 59 19.96 +18 59 42.1     16.4     SNII 38 1
22 SN 2003hl SN* 01 59 21.28 +19 00 14.5     16.5     SNII 45 1
23 SN 2008il SN* 02 17 53.07 -34 47 53.4           SNII 16 1
24 MCG-06-06-001 EmG 02 17 54.9510142200 -34 48 11.513030040   14.44   13.63   ~ 32 0
25 SN 2002gw SN* 02 25 02.97 -24 47 50.6     17.3     SNII 37 1
26 SN 2008ho SN* 02 25 04.00 -24 48 02.4           SNIIP 22 1
27 NGC 922 EmG 02 25 04.400 -24 47 17.46   12.54 12.21 11.84   ~ 161 1
28 SN 2004er SN* 02 36 59.04 -05 21 19.7     17.0     SNII 40 1
29 SN 1990E SN* 02 39 29.1 -08 08 14     15.2     SNIIP 97 1
30 NGC 1035 EmG 02 39 29.136 -08 08 01.11   12.89   13.0 12.6 ~ 188 1
31 SN 2008gi SN* 02 44 00.33 +05 25 42.8           SNII 24 1
32 Z 415-4 GiP 02 44 00.3856362024 +05 25 47.366846076   14.9       ~ 27 0
33 SN 2003B SN* 02 46 13.78 -30 13 45.1     15.0     SNIIP 47 2
34 NGC 1097 LIN 02 46 19.059 -30 16 29.68 10.46 9.97 9.48 8.72 9.8 ~ 1448 3
35 NGC 1085 GiG 02 46 25.3115345424 +03 36 26.122717908   13.6       ~ 106 1
36 SN 2003hk SN* 02 46 25.69 +03 36 32.3     17.6     SNII 26 1
37 IC 1861 G 02 53 06.9903981984 +25 29 25.779896088   14.70       ~ 48 0
38 SN 1999eg SN* 02 53 08.39 +25 29 24.2     17.5     SNII 18 1
39 MCG-01-08-015 Sy1 02 54 54.0814356264 -06 22 23.511699768   14   12.78   ~ 38 0
40 SN 2008F SN* 02 54 55.11 -06 21 56.7     18.4     SNIIP 22 1
41 SN 2002hj SN* 02 58 09.34 +04 41 03.8     17.4     SNII 22 1
42 LEDA 3092113 G 02 58 09.503 +04 41 11.32           ~ 17 1
43 SN 2005gk SN* 03 08 16.05 -04 12 00.2     18.5     SNII 14 1
44 NGC 1448 EmG 03 44 31.915 -44 38 41.38   11.46   10.24 10.9 ~ 295 1
45 SN 2003hn SN* 03 44 36.1 -44 37 49     14.1     SNIIP 67 1
46 SN 2005dx SN* 04 04 28.85 -17 54 27.5     18.6     SNII 25 1
47 MCG-03-11-009 Sy1 04 04 29.6945497488 -17 54 16.107321888   15.34   14.10   ~ 36 0
48 SN 1986L SN* 04 17 29.4 -62 47 04     13.3     SNIIP 58 1
49 NGC 1559 GiG 04 17 35.7508602240 -62 47 01.251567384   11.19 10.45 10.11 10.4 ~ 325 1
50 SN 2003E SN* 04 39 10.88 -24 10 36.5     17.0     SNII 30 1
51 MCG-04-12-004 AG? 04 39 11.10 -24 10 47.4   15.93   14.69 15.2 ~ 52 0
52 SN 1999em SN* 04 41 27.04 -02 51 45.2   13.79 13.7     SNIIP 727 1
53 NGC 1637 Sy2 04 41 28.1926876152 -02 51 28.667815488   11.4   11.0 11.3 ~ 444 0
54 SN 2008ga SN* 04 45 24.00 +18 24 25.1           SNII 19 1
55 SN 2004fx SN* 05 11 11.67 -09 23 31.6     16.9     SNII 35 1
56 SN 2007Z SN* 05 15 42.68 +19 21 49.5     17.5     SNII 7 1
57 2MASX J05154347+1921467 GiG 05 15 43.4287044672 +19 21 46.701799128           ~ 27 0
58 ESO 553-36 G 05 19 49.968 -20 58 02.79   15.76   14.21   ~ 16 0
59 SN 2006qq SN* 05 19 50.30 -20 58 06.4     17.0     SNIIn 25 1
60 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 19090 0
61 SN 1992ba SN* 05 41 47.10 -64 18 00.7     14     SNIIP 54 1
62 NGC 2082 GiG 05 41 51.0901098120 -64 18 03.828857148   12.79   11.45 11.6 ~ 101 0
63 ESO 121-26 AG? 06 21 38.7213440688 -59 44 23.748469764   12.58   11.54 12.2 ~ 82 0
64 SN 2008M SN* 06 21 41.28 -59 43 45.4     15.5     SNIIP 39 1
65 NGC 2223 GiG 06 24 35.9228253792 -22 50 17.745492084   12.46   11.18 11.9 ~ 93 0
66 SN 1993K SN* 06 24 37.8 -22 49 50     14.5     SNII 27 1
67 SN 2006Y SN* 07 13 17.19 -51 41 18.8     17.7     SNII 45 1
68 SN 2006bc SN* 07 21 16.50 -68 59 57.3   17.6 16.0     SNIIP 52 1
69 NGC 2397 Sy1 07 21 19.8926907744 -69 00 05.031850284   12.85   11.57   ~ 98 0
70 SN 2006ai SN* 07 29 52.16 -84 02 20.5     16.2     SNII 41 1
71 ESO 5-9 G 07 29 55.3 -84 02 25   15.52   14.63   ~ 18 0
72 SN 1993A SN* 07 39 17.3 -62 03 14   18.5 18.5     SNII 23 1
73 SN 2007ay SN* 08 17 14.85 +01 12 06.9     17.1     SNIIb 19 1
74 Z 3-25 AG? 08 17 15.727 +01 12 22.96   15.3       ~ 28 0
75 SN 2002hx SN* 08 27 39.43 -14 47 15.7     18.3     SNII 23 1
76 LEDA 23727 Sy2 08 27 39.7356000432 -14 46 55.065666576   15.60   14.37   ~ 26 0
77 SN 2008W SN* 08 36 19.22 -20 16 52.5     17.5     SNIIP 23 1
78 MCG-03-22-007 Sy2 08 36 19.8201984384 -20 17 06.752473224   15.8       ~ 29 0
79 SN 2006qr SN* 08 38 01.15 -09 49 06.1     17.9     SNII 25 1
80 MCG-02-22-023 Sy2 08 38 01.3700052360 -09 49 10.593254100   15   13.57   ~ 44 0
81 NGC 2642 Sy1 08 40 44.3751778920 -04 07 18.044937444   12.6   11.79 12.3 ~ 82 0
82 SN 2008bh SN* 08 40 46.15 -04 07 09.3           SNII 25 1
83 SN 2007sq SN* 08 47 16.13 -20 01 27.6     17.9     SNIIP 20 1
84 MCG-03-23-005 EmG 08 47 16.981 -20 02 08.38   13.5   12.47 12.7 ~ 96 1
85 SN 2003T SN* 09 14 11.06 +16 44 48.0     18.1     SNII 38 1
86 Z 91-28 LIN 09 14 12.7550319600 +16 44 32.342651880   14.7       ~ 57 0
87 MCG-01-24-010 EmG 09 20 21.9574885200 -07 52 50.686562208   13.93   13.05 13.2 ~ 48 0
88 SN 2008if SN* 09 20 23.47 -07 52 33.1           SNII 28 1
89 NGC 2923 GiG 09 36 03.8300734104 +16 45 37.340325612   15.2       ~ 23 0
90 SN 2005K SN* 09 36 04.31 +16 45 46.8     17.8     SNII 21 1
91 NGC 2939 GiG 09 38 07.9018488384 +09 31 26.138516952   13.5       ~ 89 0
92 SN 2009ao SN* 09 38 08.54 +09 31 00.7           ~ 25 1
93 MCG-04-23-017 EmG 09 47 13.3847022000 -24 50 22.781218092   13.79   12.56 12.9 ~ 53 0
94 SN 2008H SN* 09 47 13.45 -24 50 25.8     17.4     SNIIP 13 1
95 SN 2008br SN* 09 55 07.67 -33 08 22.7           SNII 24 1
96 IC 2522 Sy2 09 55 08.9545569792 -33 08 13.621874136   12.60   11.93 12.3 ~ 81 1
97 SN 2008bp SN* 10 00 01.57 -31 33 21.8           SNIIP 27 1
98 SN 2004ej SN* 10 00 02.84 -31 33 25.5     16.1     SNII 27 1
99 NGC 3095 Sy1 10 00 05.8037684890 -31 33 09.714480192   12.45 11.58 12.2 11.7 ~ 99 1
100 SN 2005kh SN* 10 01 25.41 +15 46 49.4     18.7     SNII 16 1
101 NGC 3094 G 10 01 25.9394231904 +15 46 12.175678236   13.5       ~ 124 1
102 SN 2003bn SN* 10 02 35.51 -21 10 54.5     16.7     SNII 30 1
103 SN 1999ca SN* 10 05 22.95 -34 12 41.0       17   SNII 25 1
104 NGC 3120 EmG 10 05 23.0159887440 -34 13 11.894842236   13.53   12.40 12.8 ~ 70 0
105 MCG-02-26-039 AG? 10 11 08.40 -13 46 53.0   15.24   14.55 15.3 ~ 22 0
106 SN 2008gq SN* 10 11 08.85 -13 47 21.4           SNIIP 6 1
107 NGC 3279 GiG 10 34 42.792 +11 11 50.08   14.10       ~ 110 0
108 SN 2007av SN* 10 34 43.18 +11 11 39.1     15.5     SNIIP 31 1
109 SN 2005Z SN* 10 45 09.18 +22 04 38.3     16.7     SNII 25 1
110 NGC 3363 rG 10 45 09.4503151608 +22 04 42.518847756   14.7       ~ 51 0
111 SN 2007am SN* 10 46 33.62 +13 45 09.3     17.8     SNII 12 1
112 NGC 3367 Sy1 10 46 34.9528432440 +13 45 03.081157488 11.89 12.05 11.50     ~ 285 1
113 SN 2003dq SN* 11 04 45.44 +15 26 49.4     18.9     SNII 13 1
114 SN 2003ci SN* 11 10 23.83 +04 49 35.9     17.5     SNII 22 1
115 Z 39-34 BiC 11 10 24.5457680928 +04 49 48.169022628   14.0   13.60   ~ 65 2
116 NGC 3905 Sy2 11 49 04.9150829016 -09 43 47.835584652   13   12.55   ~ 66 0
117 NGC 4012 AG? 11 58 27.5195538024 +10 01 17.325339744   14.6       ~ 65 0
118 SN 2005J SN* 11 58 28.54 +10 01 09.2     16.5     SNII 31 1
119 NGC 4030 EmG 12 00 23.6102390784 -01 06 00.197099136   11.42   10.3 10.4 ~ 361 1
120 SN 2007aa SN* 12 00 27.69 -01 04 51.6 16.9 16.4 5.8     SNIIP 78 1
121 SN 2008N SN* 12 19 55.78 +05 20 21.3     17.8     SNII 13 1
122 NGC 4273 H2G 12 19 56.063 +05 20 36.12   12.3       ~ 274 0
123 M 61 Sy2 12 21 54.9282582888 +04 28 25.597367184 10.07 10.18 9.65     ~ 1084 1
124 SN 2008in SN* 12 22 01.77 +04 28 47.5           SNIIP 117 1
125 NGC 4411B Sy2 12 26 47.2270744440 +08 53 04.479254880   14.4       ~ 190 0
126 SN 1992ad SN* 12 26 49.59 +08 52 38.7     13.5     SNII 31 1
127 ESO 506-11 Sy2 12 28 27.3283193976 -24 38 12.854579388   15.26   13.79   ~ 31 0
128 SN 2005an SN* 12 28 27.35 -24 38 02.4     17.3     SNII: 27 1
129 NGC 4487 EmG 12 31 04.4731449720 -08 03 14.548820040   11.7   11.9 11.6 ~ 189 0
130 SN 2009N SN* 12 31 09.46 -08 02 56.3           SNIIP 111 1
131 SN 2003ej SN* 12 39 11.10 +00 43 30.4     16.5     SNII 20 1
132 Z 14-92 AG? 12 39 11.38280 +00 43 02.8696   15.322   14.298   ~ 50 0
133 SN 2003ef SN* 12 49 42.25 -11 05 29.5     16.3     SNII 32 1
134 NGC 4727 G 12 50 57.2355548616 -14 19 58.216816632   18.21   12.08   ~ 40 1
135 SN 2003eg SN* 12 50 58.33 -14 20 01.1     15.8     SNII 13 1
136 MCG-05-31-009 EmG 12 59 45.894 -29 36 00.98   14.45   13.30 13.9 ~ 81 0
137 SN 2009au SN* 12 59 46.00 -29 36 07.5           SNIIn 28 1
138 NGC 4900 AGN 13 00 39.1193785512 +02 30 05.154593868   12.8       ~ 267 1
139 SN 1999br SN* 13 00 41.80 +02 29 45.8     17.5     SNIIPp 171 1
140 Z 71-101 G 13 02 58.2737683104 +10 30 14.126523048   15.6       ~ 24 0
141 SN 2008bm SN* 13 02 58.75 +10 30 27.0           SNIIn 22 1
142 SN 2008aw SN* 13 04 14.11 -10 19 12.9     15.9     SNII 34 1
143 NGC 4939 Sy2 13 04 14.3280524928 -10 20 22.300454724   14.81 13.80 10.92   ~ 332 1
144 SN 2005af SN* 13 04 44.06 -49 33 59.8     12.8     SNIIP 76 1
145 NGC 4945 Sy2 13 05 27.279 -49 28 04.44   9.31 14.40 7.55   ~ 1582 2
146 SN 2003cn SN* 13 07 37.05 -00 56 49.9     18.1     SNII 24 1
147 IC 849 GiG 13 07 38.6954670000 -00 56 32.942948064   14.0       ~ 60 0
148 SN 1999cr SN* 13 20 18.34 -20 08 52.0     18.0     SNIIP 26 1
149 ESO 576-34 LSB 13 20 18.354 -20 08 52.69   16.02   15.22   ~ 23 0
150 SN 2007W SN* 13 21 48.50 -13 12 56.9     17.1     SNII 23 1
151 NGC 5105 Sy2 13 21 49.0850894088 -13 12 24.456364560   13.3   12.52 12.8 ~ 71 0
152 ESO 221-18 Sy2 13 56 45.0246491424 -48 29 50.115496488   14.60   13.90 14.3 ~ 19 0
153 SN 2009aj SN* 13 56 45.33 -48 29 36.2           ~ 20 1
154 SN 2003cx SN* 13 57 06.46 -17 02 22.6     19.1     SNII 17 1
155 NGC 5374 GiG 13 57 29.6301294792 +06 05 49.187588172   13.7       ~ 91 1
156 SN 2003bl SN* 13 57 30.65 +06 05 36.4     18.4     SNII 34 1
157 SN 2007it SN* 14 18 25.63 -43 22 53.8     13.5     SNII 62 1
158 NGC 5530 AG? 14 18 27.10 -43 23 14.8   11.78 11.00 10.84 11.4 ~ 110 0
159 MCG-06-32-008 AG? 14 30 11.9235442920 -36 57 51.591056508   13.32   12.08   ~ 51 0
160 SN 2007X SN* 14 30 14.50 -36 57 53.1     15.3     SNII 21 1
161 Z 77-73 AG? 15 19 25.129 +11 03 15.24   14.7       ~ 43 0
162 SN 2009bz SN* 15 19 26.04 +11 03 30.1           SNIIP 23 1
163 SN 2006bl SN* 15 39 50.62 +14 11 21.3     17.3     SNII 25 1
164 Z 78-43 G 15 39 50.6957563032 +14 11 14.639941464   14.9       ~ 34 0
165 SN 2006be SN* 15 45 39.00 +28 05 19.2     15.4     SNIIP 34 1
166 IC 4582 AG? 15 45 39.412 +28 05 19.37   14.9       ~ 81 0
167 SN 2008bu SN* 16 47 23.05 -20 08 48.2           SNII 27 1
168 ESO 586-2 EmG 16 47 24.44 -20 08 30.2   16.18   17.43 14.9 ~ 39 0
169 SN 2007ab SN* 16 51 29.13 -03 05 33.6     17.8     SNII 22 1
170 SN 2008ag SN* 18 39 52.38 -67 25 59.0     16.7     SNIIP 24 1
171 IC 4729 Sy2 18 39 56.4717963696 -67 25 32.588497524   13.59   11.84 13.0 ~ 55 0
172 IC 4882 Sy2 19 40 23.2869222648 -55 11 49.087601520   14.61   12.95   ~ 28 0
173 SN 2005dk SN* 19 40 23.71 -55 12 05.1     17.8     SNII 22 1
174 SN 1991al SN* 19 42 24.07 -55 06 23.5   16.0 16     SNIIP 30 1
175 NGC 6861 EmG 20 07 19.482 -48 22 12.94   12.01 11.10 10.43   ~ 211 0
176 SN 2005dn SN* 20 11 11.73 -48 16 35.5     15.0     SNII 18 1
177 Z 398-18 GiG 20 11 49.3340206512 +05 45 49.871701368   14.8       ~ 44 0
178 SN 2003fb SN* 20 11 50.33 +05 45 37.6     18.6     SNII 27 1
179 MCG-06-44-023 Sy1 20 15 25.4414132256 -37 30 43.113556980   14.03   13.11   ~ 32 0
180 SN 2004fb SN* 20 15 25.63 -37 30 34.6     18.3     SNII 15 1
181 IC 4998 G 20 22 10.5645612336 -38 18 30.052619568   14.02   12.90   ~ 22 0
182 SN 2008fq SN* 20 25 06.19 -24 48 27.6           SNII 47 1
183 NGC 6907 AG? 20 25 06.63 -24 48 33.0   11.91 11.30 10.47 11.3 ~ 189 2
184 ESO 340-38 EmG 20 30 38.818 -42 18 32.69   15.04   14.62   ~ 19 0
185 SN 1992af SN* 20 30 40.25 -42 18 35.2   17.5 17.5     SNIIP 32 1
186 SN 2003ib SN* 20 33 30.98 -24 37 15.0     17.6     SNII 15 1
187 NGC 6935 EmG 20 38 20.1988150992 -52 06 37.891816812   12.77 12.10 11.57   ~ 72 0
188 SN 2006ms SN* 20 38 20.52 -52 06 55.9     17.3     SNII 20 1
189 SN 2006it SN* 20 43 51.38 +12 30 30.9     17.6     SNIIP 22 1
190 NGC 6956 GiG 20 43 53.7237446736 +12 30 42.856404588   13.5       ~ 52 0
191 SN 2002fa SN* 20 52 21.78 +02 08 41.9     19.4     SNII 16 1
192 SN 2002ew SN* 20 54 30.50 -00 08 26.0     17.8     SNII 20 1
193 SN 2007hm SN* 20 57 55.47 -07 23 24.1       18.3   SNII 21 1
194 SN 2005gz SN* 21 05 20.69 -07 50 47.5     18.3     SNII: 13 1
195 MCG-01-53-022 Sy2 21 05 20.7285401472 -07 50 44.873522664   14.63   13.87   ~ 26 0
196 ESO 235-58 AG? 21 06 28.411 -48 07 15.79   15.19   14.06 13.9 ~ 53 0
197 SN 2003ho SN* 21 06 30.56 -48 07 29.9     18.6     SNII 19 1
198 SN 2004dy SN* 21 11 30.13 -02 02 13.3     19.4     SNII 22 1
199 IC 5090 Sy1 21 11 30.46873 -02 01 57.2950   14.5       ~ 52 1
200 MCG-05-52-049 EmG 22 13 31.355 -27 33 28.65   13.76   12.62   ~ 52 1
201 SN 2005dw SN* 22 13 31.83 -27 33 19.6     16.7     SNII 19 1
202 SN 1993S SN* 22 52 24.1 -40 18 43     17.5     SNII 22 1
203 NGC 7408 Sy2 22 55 56.8300856753 -63 41 40.813463246   13.35 15.41 12.32 13.0 ~ 49 0
204 SN 2009bu SN* 22 56 01.40 -63 41 39.6           SNIIP 18 1
205 NGC 7418 Sy1 22 56 36.1156121952 -37 01 47.845242192   11.66 11.39 10.66 11.3 ~ 172 2
206 SN 2007oc SN* 22 56 41.77 -36 46 22.3     13.6     SNIIP 26 1
207 NGC 7537 GiP 23 14 34.5173585112 +04 29 54.054910824   13.8       ~ 220 0
208 SN 2002gd SN* 23 14 37.01 +04 30 06.1     16.7     SNII 63 1
209 SN 2006iw SN* 23 21 19.48 +00 15 35.1   19.82 18.97 18.56 18.31 SNIIP 36 1
210 SN 2005dt SN* 23 23 38.32 -19 00 24.5     18.5     SNII 20 1
211 MCG-03-59-006 G 23 23 38.4171709512 -19 00 35.515344888   14.67   13.58   ~ 35 0
212 SN 2005es SN* 23 25 47.62 +08 02 17.3     18.4     SNII 22 1
213 Z 406-107 G 23 25 47.7977640024 +08 02 25.621762308   15.4       ~ 24 0
214 Z 407-32 AG? 23 38 36.7003344336 +05 26 01.135160016   15.3       ~ 29 0
215 SN 2005dz SN* 23 38 38.33 +05 26 17.3     18     SNII 33 1
216 NGC 7793 GiG 23 57 49.7540045856 -32 35 27.701550744 10.26 9.74 9.28 9.06 9.7 ~ 1188 2
217 SN 2008bk SN* 23 57 50.42 -32 33 21.5           SNIIP 167 2

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2016A&A...589A.110A and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu