2018ApJ...859...75M


Query : 2018ApJ...859...75M

2018ApJ...859...75M - Astrophys. J., 859, 75-75 (2018/May-3)

The chemical composition of NGC 5824, a globular cluster without iron spread but with an extreme Mg-Al anticorrelation.

MUCCIARELLI A., LAPENNA E., FERRARO F.R. and LANZONI B.

Abstract (from CDS):

NGC 5824 is a massive Galactic globular cluster suspected to have an intrinsic spread in its iron content, according to the strength of the calcium triplet lines. We present chemical abundances of 117 cluster giant stars using high-resolution spectra acquired with the multi-object spectrograph FLAMES. The metallicity distribution of 87 red giant branch stars is peaked at [Fe/H] = -2.11 ± 0.01 dex, while that derived from 30 asymptotic giant branch stars is peaked at [Fe/H] = -2.20 ± 0.01 dex. Both the distributions are compatible with a null spread, indicating that this cluster did not retain the ejecta of supernovae. The small iron abundance offset between the two groups of stars is similar to the abundances already observed among red and asymptotic giant branch stars in other clusters. The lack of intrinsic iron spread rules out the possibility that NGC 5824 is the remnant of a disrupted dwarf galaxy, as previously suggested. We also find evidence of the chemical anomalies usually observed in globular clusters, namely the Na-O and the Mg-Al anticorrelations. In particular, NGC 5824 exhibits a huge range of [Mg/Fe] abundance, observed in only a few metal-poor and/or massive clusters. We conclude that NGC 5824 is a normal globular cluster, without spread in [Fe/H] but with an unusually large spread in [Mg/Fe], possibly due to an efficient self-enrichment driven by massive asymptotic giant branch stars.

Abstract Copyright: © 2018. The American Astronomical Society. All rights reserved.

Journal keyword(s): globular clusters: individual: NGC 5824 - stars: abundances - techniques: spectroscopic

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/859/75): table1.dat table2.dat table3.dat table4.dat>

Nomenclature: Tables 1+3-4: [MLF2018] NNNNN N=117+6 among (Nos 8953-35432).

Simbad objects: 139

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 139
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NGC 2419 GlC 07 38 08.51 +38 52 54.9     10.05     ~ 998 0
2 NGC 2808 GlC 09 12 03.10 -64 51 48.6           ~ 1540 0
3 NGC 3201 GlC 10 17 36.82 -46 24 44.9           ~ 1001 0
4 Cl Ruprecht 106 GlC 12 38 40.20 -51 09 01.0           ~ 413 0
5 NGC 4833 GlC 12 59 33.92 -70 52 35.4           ~ 467 0
6 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3677 0
7 NGC 5286 GlC 13 46 26.81 -51 22 27.3           ~ 485 0
8 [DHS2014] 52009427 AB* 15 03 39.2325445872 -33 03 00.253296216 18.281   16.809   15.621 ~ 2 0
9 [DHS2014] 51000368 AB* 15 03 40.3193366496 -33 01 47.724464892 18.631   17.456   16.375 ~ 2 0
10 [DHS2014] 52009987 RG* 15 03 41.8424935056 -33 02 44.299322376 18.909   17.472   16.314 ~ 2 0
11 [DHS2014] 52006004 RG* 15 03 42.0152705472 -33 04 26.784318216 18.997   17.679   16.539 ~ 2 0
12 [DHS2014] 71001880 RG* 15 03 42.9230730768 -33 05 54.502375560 19.027   17.710   16.549 ~ 2 0
13 [DHS2014] 21001061 RG* 15 03 44.7389007408 -33 03 43.163265960 19.027   17.735   16.568 ~ 2 0
14 2MASS J15034579-3308353 AB* 15 03 45.7813049016 -33 08 35.360870028 18.685   17.509   16.366 ~ 2 0
15 [DHS2014] 52005710 RG* 15 03 45.8661647592 -33 04 34.350410784 18.540   16.958   15.731 ~ 3 0
16 [DHS2014] 32004229 RG* 15 03 46.8332339520 -33 05 43.175052420 18.257   16.523   15.241 ~ 3 0
17 [DHS2014] 52011176 RG* 15 03 47.59 -33 02 07.1 18.826   17.409   16.231 ~ 2 0
18 [DHS2014] 52009395 RG* 15 03 47.7340089192 -33 03 01.292541948 18.745   17.369   16.203 ~ 3 0
19 [DHS2014] 52005547 RG* 15 03 47.7352164288 -33 04 38.563184100 19.007   17.693   16.534 ~ 2 0
20 [MLF2018] 37173 RG* 15 03 47.8864051392 -33 07 23.222092728 18.183   15.900     ~ 1 0
21 [MLF2018] 36633 RG* 15 03 48.6768370392 -33 09 06.108762132 18.878   17.701     ~ 1 0
22 [DHS2014] 52010016 RG* 15 03 48.6856350576 -33 02 43.644239952 19.059   17.620   16.464 ~ 2 0
23 [MLF2018] 35600 RG* 15 03 50.0490444264 -32 57 25.839029268 18.910   17.890     ~ 1 0
24 [DHS2014] 52009516 RG* 15 03 50.2773501960 -33 02 57.845763060 18.895   17.512   16.335 ~ 2 0
25 [DHS2014] 71002877 RG* 15 03 50.3985870816 -33 05 20.683105656 18.259   15.808   14.359 ~ 4 0
26 [MLF2018] 35241 RG* 15 03 50.7500395680 -33 03 07.248029400 18.895   17.696     ~ 1 0
27 [DHS2014] 51000173 RG* 15 03 50.8246749936 -33 01 53.964056100 18.538   16.890   15.650 ~ 3 0
28 [DHS2014] 42011439 RG* 15 03 51.5317838472 -33 03 01.426897368 18.521   16.897   15.669 ~ 3 0
29 [DHS2014] 42008805 AB* 15 03 51.5350308408 -33 03 55.148777280 18.259   16.728   15.518 ~ 2 0
30 [DHS2014] 42006266 AB* 15 03 52.0112569656 -33 04 46.507014192 18.467   17.151   16.025 ~ 2 0
31 [DHS2014] 42008772 RG* 15 03 52.81 -33 03 56.4 18.576   17.079   15.892 ~ 2 0
32 [DHS2014] 42007205 RG* 15 03 52.8135841595 -33 04 27.890069132 18.913   17.673   16.553 ~ 2 0
33 [MLF2018] 33726 RG* 15 03 53.1740460792 -33 02 26.833367616 18.161   15.586     ~ 1 0
34 [DHS2014] 61000707 AB* 15 03 53.4446861640 -33 06 17.645575428 18.435   16.963   15.785 ~ 2 0
35 [MLF2018] 33418 RG* 15 03 53.5650175968 -33 02 43.684016640 18.790   17.550     ~ 1 0
36 [DHS2014] 42008343 AB* 15 03 53.6207806152 -33 04 04.733474628 18.209   16.494   15.232 ~ 3 0
37 [DHS2014] 41003361 RG* 15 03 53.9858324592 -32 59 53.084393520 18.588   17.060   15.856 ~ 3 0
38 [DHS2014] 61000182 RG* 15 03 54.3625536624 -33 06 58.536157752 18.586   16.975   15.726 ~ 3 0
39 [DHS2014] 42007539 RG* 15 03 54.4308844848 -33 04 18.976023120 18.133   15.945   14.553 ~ 3 0
40 [MLF2018] 32555 AB* 15 03 54.7364004096 -33 05 28.854883860 18.640   17.610     ~ 1 0
41 [DHS2014] 42008180 AB* 15 03 54.7602839904 -33 04 08.523555492 18.165   16.513   15.230 ~ 2 0
42 [DHS2014] 42010715 RG* 15 03 54.9121361928 -33 03 16.452208908 18.342   16.619   15.349 ~ 3 0
43 [DHS2014] 61000397 RG* 15 03 54.9464424360 -33 06 39.881814912 18.229   16.308   14.953 ~ 3 0
44 [DHS2014] 61002370 AB* 15 03 54.9747115344 -33 05 11.690552364 18.158   16.428   15.192 ~ 2 0
45 [MLF2018] 32308 RG* 15 03 55.1335900920 -32 59 23.415699804 18.818   17.650     ~ 1 0
46 [DHS2014] 42005961 AB* 15 03 55.4214862536 -33 04 52.900229028 18.615   17.152   15.999 ~ 2 0
47 [DHS2014] 21000354 AB* 15 03 55.6606677936 -33 04 19.670942316 18.130   16.007   14.708 ~ 2 0
48 [DHS2014] 42009955 RG* 15 03 55.9566671016 -33 03 35.610737544 18.176   15.917   14.533 ~ 4 0
49 [DHS2014] 61001622 RG* 15 03 56.0570787600 -33 05 34.324072800 18.892   17.478   16.309 ~ 2 0
50 [DHS2014] 61001052 RG* 15 03 56.12 -33 05 59.3 18.487   16.786   15.546 ~ 3 0
51 [DHS2014] 42009028 RG* 15 03 56.5241080944 -33 03 50.822132544 18.669   17.281   16.103 ~ 2 0
52 [DHS2014] 42006307 RG* 15 03 56.6671175280 -33 04 48.789926364 18.273   16.342   15.042 ~ 3 0
53 [DHS2014] 42007326 AB* 15 03 57.07 -33 04 25.6 18.150   16.905   15.721 ~ 2 0
54 [MLF2018] 30385 RG* 15 03 57.2926001448 -33 05 13.706778480 18.892   17.797     ~ 1 0
55 [DHS2014] 41002449 RG* 15 03 57.4418308464 -33 00 32.926043340 18.629   17.068   15.855 ~ 3 0
56 [DHS2014] 61001885 AB* 15 03 57.4872253464 -33 05 25.348770924 18.802   17.719   16.639 ~ 2 0
57 [MLF2018] 29987 RG* 15 03 57.5756855352 -33 03 46.711010268 18.965   17.873     ~ 1 0
58 [DHS2014] 71000126 RG* 15 03 57.8515983912 -33 07 14.910057660 18.806   17.444   16.256 ~ 2 0
59 [DHS2014] 42011588 RG* 15 03 58.1600223096 -33 03 01.740802392 18.203   16.419   15.123 ~ 3 0
60 [DHS2014] 42010600 RG* 15 03 58.1919166368 -33 03 19.134244656 18.788   17.422   16.261 ~ 2 0
61 [MLF2018] 28971 AB* 15 03 58.3730540424 -33 03 28.081823832 18.465   17.470     ~ 1 0
62 NGC 5824 GlC 15 03 58.612 -33 04 06.70   10.28 9.56     ~ 441 0
63 [DHS2014] 61000142 RG* 15 03 58.7357258832 -33 07 02.753284332 18.618   17.035   15.823 ~ 3 0
64 [DHS2014] 61002588 RG* 15 03 58.7630185128 -33 05 05.500477104 18.756   17.328   16.143 ~ 2 0
65 [DHS2014] 42006477 AB* 15 03 59.2317617616 -33 04 42.389338476 17.863   16.012   14.699 ~ 2 0
66 [DHS2014] 61007408 RG* 15 03 59.3895366120 -33 03 47.046054168 18.181   16.168   14.798 ~ 3 0
67 [DHS2014] 42011404 RG* 15 03 59.5309130640 -33 03 02.552376492 18.085   15.973   14.582 ~ 4 0
68 [MLF2018] 26942 RG* 15 03 59.9075121432 -33 04 37.438127724 18.882   17.678     ~ 1 0
69 [MLF2018] 26540 RG* 15 04 00.2115112440 -33 03 54.754346844 18.390   16.999     ~ 1 0
70 [DHS2014] 42010114 RG* 15 04 00.23 -33 03 28.4 18.388   16.756   15.510 ~ 2 0
71 [DHS2014] 21000267 RG* 15 04 00.6134883360 -33 04 24.149835120 18.035   15.606   14.130 ~ 4 0
72 [DHS2014] 61000663 AB* 15 04 00.6829328040 -33 06 19.932176592 18.805   17.603   16.512 ~ 2 0
73 [DHS2014] 42012172 RG* 15 04 00.7619253264 -33 02 45.176289324 18.499   16.958   15.743 ~ 3 0
74 [DHS2014] 22003374 RG* 15 04 00.9527315616 -33 05 17.142075312 18.786   17.399   16.233 ~ 2 0
75 [DHS2014] 42011097 RG* 15 04 01.0514761224 -33 03 08.504321040 18.375   16.651   15.384 ~ 3 0
76 [DHS2014] 61001836 RG* 15 04 01.5849409392 -33 05 26.780223804 18.569   16.883   15.658 ~ 3 0
77 [DHS2014] 42008555 AB* 15 04 01.6160870352 -33 04 00.391740816 18.365   16.977   15.769 ~ 3 0
78 [DHS2014] 42011285 RG* 15 04 01.7372578104 -33 03 04.674494736 18.758   17.415   16.232 ~ 2 0
79 [DHS2014] 61005163 RG* 15 04 02.0572405968 -33 04 20.134883532 18.324   15.908   14.523 ~ 4 0
80 [DHS2014] 42008747 AB* 15 04 02.0895842544 -33 03 56.625679152 18.190   16.795   15.620 ~ 2 0
81 [MLF2018] 23774 RG* 15 04 02.3926813752 -33 03 39.936231612 18.978   17.878     ~ 1 0
82 [DHS2014] 42005986 RG* 15 04 02.4441372840 -33 04 52.343777640 18.823   17.507   16.342 ~ 2 0
83 [DHS2014] 42012704 RG* 15 04 02.5260008304 -33 02 32.057255724 18.161   16.186   14.835 ~ 3 0
84 [DHS2014] 61001892 AB* 15 04 03.1325253432 -33 05 25.008121860 18.764   17.667   16.593 ~ 2 0
85 [DHS2014] 42012854 RG* 15 04 03.2555062920 -33 02 28.841081892 18.900   17.605   16.449 ~ 2 0
86 [DHS2014] 42009102 AB* 15 04 03.49 -33 03 49.2 18.177   16.691   15.470 ~ 2 0
87 [DHS2014] 41004485 RG* 15 04 03.6627678312 -32 58 57.287811252 18.964   17.648   16.511 ~ 2 0
88 [DHS2014] 41001607 RG* 15 04 03.9028838592 -33 01 05.722950144 18.337   16.149   14.789 ~ 3 0
89 [DHS2014] 42006214 AB* 15 04 03.9083268840 -33 04 47.617347828 18.720   17.689   16.626 ~ 2 0
90 [DHS2014] 42007331 RG* 15 04 04.87 -33 04 25.3 18.410   16.824   15.578 ~ 3 0
91 [DHS2014] 61001690 RG* 15 04 04.9366513608 -33 05 31.398314280 18.616   17.107   15.890 ~ 3 0
92 [DHS2014] 21000688 RG* 15 04 04.9984469208 -33 04 01.175725020 18.093   15.754   14.284 ~ 4 0
93 [DHS2014] 12001300 RG* 15 04 05.1064447368 -33 07 29.004099744 18.263   16.241   14.946 ~ 3 0
94 [DHS2014] 42006382 AB* 15 04 05.7200437224 -33 04 44.069588364 18.601   17.473   16.366 ~ 2 0
95 [DHS2014] 61000144 RG* 15 04 06.1722818208 -33 07 02.325357120 18.265   16.404   15.082 ~ 3 0
96 [DHS2014] 21002944 RG* 15 04 06.7382197584 -33 01 50.536860528 18.193   15.385   13.743 ~ 3 0
97 [DHS2014] 61002302 RG* 15 04 06.76 -33 05 13.2 19.049   17.754   16.594 ~ 2 0
98 [DHS2014] 41000940 RG* 15 04 06.8337515400 -33 01 30.101249856 18.250   16.466   15.176 ~ 3 0
99 [DHS2014] 42008494 AB* 15 04 07.0380103152 -33 04 01.571945088 18.730   17.736   16.676 ~ 2 0
100 [DHS2014] 61000826 RG* 15 04 07.5746317824 -33 06 10.505496960 18.265   16.271   14.961 ~ 3 0
101 [DHS2014] 61002172 RG* 15 04 07.9337181192 -33 05 16.166773248 18.899   17.400   16.237 ~ 2 0
102 [DHS2014] 41001009 RG* 15 04 08.2311980688 -33 01 27.719442336 19.012   17.762   16.637 ~ 2 0
103 [DHS2014] 42010713 RG* 15 04 09.5665790592 -33 03 16.666398684 18.831   17.491   16.309 ~ 2 0
104 [DHS2014] 42010124 RG* 15 04 10.4490989256 -33 03 30.798100872 18.024   15.876   14.454 ~ 3 0
105 [DHS2014] 41001656 AB* 15 04 12.3997888128 -33 01 06.175091784 18.355   17.112   15.987 ~ 2 0
106 [DHS2014] 61003283 RG* 15 04 12.6153613776 -33 04 49.995576480 18.243   16.279   14.931 ~ 3 0
107 [DHS2014] 41005005 RG* 15 04 13.3081240344 -32 58 26.604063156 18.925   17.536   16.383 ~ 2 0
108 [MLF2018] 14431 RG* 15 04 13.8017992944 -32 55 52.095798444 18.491   17.180     ~ 1 0
109 [MLF2018] 14395 AB* 15 04 13.8342482520 -33 00 09.559234872 18.579   17.558     ~ 1 0
110 [MLF2018] 14266 RG* 15 04 14.0653183320 -33 00 08.195784192 18.867   17.659     ~ 1 0
111 [MLF2018] 14064 AB* 15 04 14.4872659800 -32 57 12.699109296 18.682   17.802     ~ 1 0
112 [DHS2014] 62000027 RG* 15 04 14.6015682192 -33 10 14.007314712 18.363   16.434   15.124 ~ 3 0
113 [DHS2014] 11001198 RG* 15 04 14.7674676192 -33 02 34.960528896 18.136   16.352   15.009 ~ 3 0
114 [MLF2018] 13793 RG* 15 04 14.9931859296 -32 55 57.268497972 18.411   16.916     ~ 1 0
115 [DHS2014] 61000086 AB* 15 04 15.1072751032 -33 07 07.817548793 18.379   16.959   15.753 ~ 3 0
116 [DHS2014] 42008963 RG* 15 04 16.4511138672 -33 03 51.717593916 18.780   17.564   16.394 ~ 2 0
117 [DHS2014] 42011701 RG* 15 04 16.7957478552 -33 02 55.725597384 19.097   17.776   16.622 ~ 2 0
118 [DHS2014] 42013014 AB* 15 04 18.7131240432 -33 02 22.637079600 18.033   16.236   14.860 ~ 3 0
119 [MLF2018] 12035 AB* 15 04 18.8055853128 -33 03 59.787652860 18.586   17.645     ~ 1 0
120 [MLF2018] 11730 RG* 15 04 19.6356179520 -32 58 09.515881740 18.085   16.306     ~ 1 0
121 [DHS2014] 42007983 AB* 15 04 20.8509340680 -33 04 12.073235124 18.354   17.093   15.892 ~ 3 0
122 [MLF2018] 10967 RG* 15 04 21.7325806152 -32 55 41.111800428 18.218   15.972     ~ 1 0
123 [MLF2018] 10647 RG* 15 04 22.5804820104 -33 07 16.764961008 17.901   15.773     ~ 1 0
124 [DHS2014] 62000309 AB* 15 04 23.9506689576 -33 08 57.996365316 18.503   17.398   16.280 ~ 2 0
125 [MLF2018] 8953 RG* 15 04 27.9085220448 -33 11 51.436346784 18.464   17.032     ~ 1 0
126 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1978 0
127 M 13 GlC 16 41 41.634 +36 27 40.75     5.8     ~ 2291 0
128 M 19 GlC 17 02 37.69 -26 16 04.6   8.45 5.57     ~ 406 1
129 M 92 GlC 17 17 07.39 +43 08 09.4     6.52     ~ 2240 0
130 NGC 6362 GlC 17 31 54.99 -67 02 54.0           ~ 637 0
131 Cl Terzan 5 Cl* 17 48 05.00 -24 46 48.0           ~ 948 1
132 M 22 GlC 18 36 23.94 -23 54 17.1           ~ 1459 0
133 M 54 GlC 18 55 03.33 -30 28 47.5           ~ 1164 0
134 NAME SDG G 18 55 19.0 -30 32 43   4.5 3.6     ~ 2438 2
135 NGC 6752 GlC 19 10 52.11 -59 59 04.4           ~ 2121 0
136 M 15 GlC 21 29 58.33 +12 10 01.2           ~ 3274 0
137 M 2 GlC 21 33 27.02 -00 49 23.7     6.25     ~ 1114 1
138 NAME Local Group GrG ~ ~           ~ 9325 0
139 NAME Galactic Bulge reg ~ ~           ~ 4794 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2018ApJ...859...75M and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu