2018MNRAS.475.1288S


Query : 2018MNRAS.475.1288S

2018MNRAS.475.1288S - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 475, 1288-1305 (2018/March-3)

Identifying the subtle signatures of feedback from distant AGN using ALMA observations and the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulations.

SCHOLTZ J., ALEXANDER D.M., HARRISON C.M., ROSARIO D.J., McALPINE S., MULLANEY J.R., STANLEY F., SIMPSON J., THEUNS T., BOWER R.G., HICKOX R.C., SANTINI P. and SWINBANK A.M.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present sensitive 870 µm continuum measurements from our ALMA programmes of 114 X-ray selected active galactic nuclei (AGN) in the Chandra Deep Field-South and Cosmic Evolution Survey fields. We use these observations in combination with data from Spitzer and Herschel to construct a sample of 86 X-ray selected AGN, 63 with ALMA constraints at z = 1.5-3.2 with stellar mass >2 x 1010 M☉. We constructed broad-band spectral energy distributions in the infrared band (8-1000 µm) and constrain star-formation rates (SFRs) uncontaminated by the AGN. Using a hierarchical Bayesian method that takes into account the information from upper limits, we fit SFR and specific SFR (sSFR) distributions. We explore these distributions as a function of both X-ray luminosity and stellar mass. We compare our measurements to two versions of the Evolution and Assembly of GaLaxies and their Environments (EAGLE) hydrodynamical simulations: the reference model with AGN feedback and the model without AGN. We find good agreement between the observations and that predicted by the EAGLE reference model for the modes and widths of the sSFR distributions as a function of both X-ray luminosity and stellar mass; however, we found that the EAGLE model without AGN feedback predicts a significantly narrower width when compared to the data. Overall, from the combination of the observations with the model predictions, we conclude that (1) even with AGN feedback, we expect no strong relationship between the sSFR distribution parameters and instantaneous AGN luminosity and (2) a signature of AGN feedback is a broad distribution of sSFRs for all galaxies (not just those hosting an AGN) with stellar masses above ≃1010 M☉.

Abstract Copyright: © 2017 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Astronomical Society

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: active - galaxies: evolution - infrared: galaxies - X-rays: galaxies

Simbad objects: 150

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 150
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 CXOCDFS J033202.5-274601 Sy1 03 32 02.45 -27 46 00.5   24.291 24.5944 22.425 23.7324 ~ 48 0
2 CANDELS UDS F160W J033203.04-274450.1 Sy2 03 32 03.07 -27 44 50.1   26.9484   25.45 25.0739 ~ 46 0
3 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 28908 AGN 03 32 05.3468 -27 46 44.100   27.9053     25.816 ~ 45 0
4 [LBX2017] 145 AGN 03 32 06.14 -27 49 28.4   24.925 25.07 24.66 23.573 ~ 30 0
5 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 35061 AGN 03 32 06.706 -27 44 55.18   26.7747     25.8577 ~ 23 0
6 CXOCDFS J033207.2-275229 AGN 03 32 07.109 -27 52 29.11   26.19 26.27 25.45 24.97 ~ 22 0
7 [LBX2017] 170 AGN 03 32 07.99858 -27 46 57.2578   25.6308   24.931 25.0534 ~ 46 0
8 GOODS J033208.77-273956.3 AGN 03 32 08.76 -27 39 55.9       26.77   ~ 9 0
9 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 16498 AGN 03 32 09.83 -27 50 10.2   24.489   24.44 23.920 ~ 15 0
10 CXOCDFS J033209.9-275016 rG 03 32 09.860 -27 50 15.70   30.071 28.16   28.428 ~ 39 0
11 [LBX2017] 198 AGN 03 32 10.201 -27 51 55.96       26.37 25.281 ~ 12 0
12 ATCDFS J033210.80-274629.2 rG 03 32 10.797 -27 46 28.11   24.593 25.416 23.110 23.286 ~ 56 0
13 2XMM J033210.9-274415 Sy1 03 32 10.91 -27 44 15.1 23.35 22.500 22.882 22.50 22.3707 ~ 83 0
14 CXOCDFS J033211.0-274857 AGN 03 32 10.9586 -27 48 56.070   25.72 25.55 25.47 25.447 ~ 37 0
15 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 29954 AGN 03 32 11.78 -27 46 28.5   26.64   26.27 25.531 ~ 52 0
16 ACS-GC 90107802 AGN 03 32 12.54 -27 46 29.5   27.514 25.775 24.73 24.038 ~ 36 0
17 GOODS J033212.56-274938.2 AGN 03 32 12.5558 -27 49 38.197   26.3189   26.29 25.448 ~ 21 0
18 CXOCDFS J033213.0-275238 Sy2 03 32 12.96 -27 52 36.5       24.040 23.899 ~ 52 0
19 CXOCDFS J033213.5-274857 AGN 03 32 13.405 -27 48 56.01   27.219 27.07   26.338 ~ 28 0
20 ATCDFS9 J033213.90-275000.6 rG 03 32 13.898 -27 50 00.88   26.72 26.71 26.13 25.630 ~ 37 0
21 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 13174 AGN 03 32 14.8572 -27 51 03.761   26.13 25.75 25.19 24.925 ~ 30 0
22 ACS-GC 90043493 rG 03 32 14.98 -27 42 25.2   23.814 23.50 23.004 22.8916 ~ 56 0
23 ACS-GC 90042677 Sy2 03 32 15.182 -27 41 58.71   26.655   24.540 25.0556 ~ 40 0
24 GNS 6114 AGN 03 32 15.7591 -27 52 43.924   24.59 24.52 24.16 24.929 ~ 19 0
25 ZFOURGE CDFS 27587 AGN 03 32 15.777 -27 42 07.83   25.68 24.74     ~ 16 0
26 [ABB2003] CDFS 110 AGN 03 32 16.262 -27 55 24.05   28.23 27.75   25.88 ~ 13 0
27 [LBX2017] 305 AGN 03 32 17.107 -27 41 36.89   27.0936   26.51 26.3225 ~ 31 0
28 BLAST J033217-275054 AGN 03 32 17.86370 -27 50 59.2055   20.0276 19.3459 18.7423 18.4294 ~ 42 0
29 CANDELS UDS F160W J033218.24-275241.4 Sy1 03 32 18.2555 -27 52 41.418   24.5285 24.6214 24.102 24.2474 ~ 52 0
30 ACS-GC 90045885 Sy2 03 32 18.39 -27 50 55.3   24.8876 24.190 23.82 23.039 ~ 85 0
31 CXOCDFS J033218.9-275136 Sy2 03 32 18.8321 -27 51 35.476   25.15   24.51 25.128 ~ 83 0
32 ZFOURGE CDFS 7732 AGN 03 32 19.836 -27 51 59.44   28.20 27.67   25.82 ~ 22 0
33 [LBA2005] 356 AGN 03 32 19.950 -27 42 43.19   28.0511 26.18 25.4 27.1838 ~ 36 0
34 NAME BzK 8608 AGN 03 32 20.94854 -27 55 46.2839   25.52   24.93 25.047 ~ 22 0
35 [LBX2017] 384 AGN 03 32 21.39658 -27 55 49.2398   25.5307   24.301 24.5990 ~ 31 0
36 CXOCDFS J033222.2-274812 AGN 03 32 22.16 -27 48 11.6   27.9990 28.91   26.106 ~ 43 0
37 CXOCDFS J033222.6-274806 rG 03 32 22.514 -27 48 04.99   25.6748 27.82 25.07 25.4668 ~ 29 0
38 ACS-GC 90042090 rG 03 32 22.52 -27 46 04.2   25.2790   24.91 24.424 ~ 63 0
39 CANDELS UDS F160W J033222.57-274814.9 AGN 03 32 22.57 -27 48 15.1   27.3416     25.694 ~ 33 0
40 EIS-DEEP CDFS-1 Ks 1 218 AGN 03 32 23.127 -27 44 42.20   26.61   25.93 25.260 ~ 27 0
41 ACS-GC 90043834 AGN 03 32 23.434 -27 42 55.02   25.861 25.14 25.324 24.698 ~ 47 0
42 ACS-GC 90043098 AGN 03 32 24.17 -27 42 58.1   24.8200 24.39 24.319 24.157 ~ 53 0
43 [PBM2009] s124624 Sy1 03 32 25.21 -27 42 18.8   24.7725 23.75 23.21 22.6063 ~ 92 0
44 CANDELS UDS F160W J033225.68-274305.6 Sy2 03 32 25.74 -27 43 05.6   26.617 25.773 26.13 25.3679 ~ 76 0
45 CANDELS UDS F160W J033225.95-274514.3 AGN 03 32 25.9457 -27 45 14.347   27.8578   26.040 25.8074 ~ 37 0
46 CXOCDFS J033226.7-274013 AGN 03 32 26.69 -27 40 13.6   23.8628 23.80 23.826 23.4188 ~ 39 0
47 [LBX2017] 490 AGN 03 32 26.7783 -27 46 03.991   28.9513     27.239 ~ 48 0
48 NAME Chandra Deep Field-South reg 03 32 28.0 -27 48 30           ~ 2282 1
49 NAME GOODS Southern Field reg 03 32 28.0 -27 48 30           ~ 1623 1
50 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 37542 AGN 03 32 28.285 -27 44 03.45   24.631 24.49 23.050 22.925 ~ 34 0
51 CXOCDFS J033228.4-275305 AGN 03 32 28.467 -27 53 05.30   27.327     25.756 ~ 14 0
52 ACS-GC 90044741 AGN 03 32 29.478 -27 43 22.12   24.9899 24.73 24.94 24.0969 ~ 33 0
53 CXOCDFS J033229.9-275329 AGN 03 32 29.7841 -27 53 28.369   27.24   26.66 27.0326 ~ 34 0
54 [VV2006] J033229.9-275106 Sy2 03 32 29.8487 -27 51 05.879   27.5675 25.05 23.970 24.5370 ~ 101 0
55 ZFOURGE CDFS 5606 AGN 03 32 30.1398 -27 53 11.373   27.3762   26.27 25.8335 ~ 11 0
56 [LBX2017] 565 GiP 03 32 30.1426 -27 53 06.000   22.2225   21.390 21.2550 ~ 17 0
57 CXOCDFS J033231.9-275715 AGN 03 32 31.80 -27 57 14.0       25.05 25.3186 ~ 19 0
58 ACS-GC 90042502 AGN 03 32 32.073 -27 41 55.16   24.2542 23.91 23.967 23.4390 ~ 44 0
59 CXOCDFS J033232.2-274652 AGN 03 32 32.170 -27 46 51.49   28.3350 27.2830   26.411 ~ 50 0
60 CXOCDFS J033232.8-275152 AGN 03 32 32.731 -27 51 50.98   22.847 21.16 20.92 21.651 ~ 25 0
61 CXOCDFS J033233.2-275206 AGN 03 32 33.113 -27 52 05.47   28.63 28.82   28.550 ~ 32 0
62 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 31397 AGN 03 32 33.8458 -27 46 00.211   25.558 25.21 25.06 24.222 ~ 39 0
63 CXOCDFS J033234.1-274900 AGN 03 32 33.996 -27 48 59.58   27.679 27.06 26.060 26.594 ~ 35 0
64 EIS-DEEP CDFS-2 J 1 611 EmG 03 32 34.177 -27 45 54.14   21.8238   20.667 20.562 ~ 32 0
65 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 5001 AGN 03 32 35.2075 -27 53 18.019   27.5835     26.282 ~ 39 0
66 NAME BzK 4892 Sy2 03 32 35.73 -27 49 16.2   25.681 27.798 25.00 24.645 ~ 89 0
67 GEMS J033236.17-274258.4 EmG 03 32 36.172 -27 42 58.31 24.09 22.3641 22.145 21.808 21.5928 ~ 23 0
68 GMASS 2148 AGN 03 32 36.283 -27 42 49.41   25.899 26.24 25.81 24.4278 ~ 35 0
69 [HSN2014] 19937 AGN 03 32 37.26 -27 44 26.9   27.106     26.312 ~ 5 0
70 ASPECS LP.1mm.C08 AGN 03 32 38.029 -27 46 26.31 28.2222 28.4300 27.60 27.04 26.106 ~ 70 1
71 CXOCDFS J033238.4-275554 AGN 03 32 38.29 -27 55 52.7   27.6521   27.42 25.8797 ~ 32 0
72 CXOCDFS J033238.8-275122 AGN 03 32 38.7610 -27 51 21.621   27.7247   27.02 26.1466 ~ 45 0
73 [SWM2014] GOODS-S 42607 AGN 03 32 38.952 -27 42 43.69   26.5505   25.879 22.091 ~ 24 0
74 CXOCDFS J033239.1-274440 AGN 03 32 39.052 -27 44 39.32   27.8340     26.304 ~ 44 1
75 ASPECS LP.3mm.05 rG 03 32 39.737 -27 46 11.25 25.2508 25.0913 25.00 24.94 23.902 ~ 97 0
76 NAME HUDF-JD1 AGN 03 32 42.885 -27 48 09.51   31.2665 29.09   29.527 ~ 35 0
77 ACS-GC 90044579 rG 03 32 43.038 -27 48 45.09   26.3069 25.14 25.56 24.431 ~ 53 0
78 CANDELS UDS F160W J033244.60-274835.9 QSO 03 32 44.599 -27 48 35.88   25.6176   25.070 24.7295 ~ 54 0
79 CXOCDFS J033247.2-275335 QSO 03 32 47.0589 -27 53 33.531   30.967   25.98 26.2117 ~ 38 0
80 ACS-GC 90040140 AGN 03 32 47.73 -27 50 38.2   25.7528 25.87 26.18 24.112 ~ 38 0
81 CXOCDFS J033249.3-275505 AGN 03 32 49.14 -27 55 04.4   25.88 25.56 24.99 25.5765 ~ 40 0
82 [GZW2002] Main 267 AGN 03 32 54.899 -27 45 06.03   24.53 24.47 24.10 23.18 ~ 21 0
83 ZFOURGE CDFS 3628 AGN 03 32 58.68 -27 54 27.5   25.540   25.40 24.786 ~ 12 0
84 CXOCDFS J033259.4-274859 rG 03 32 59.314 -27 48 58.70   23.73 23.57 23.37 22.68 ~ 42 0
85 ACS-GC 20131022 AGN 09 58 52.97 +02 20 56.5   24.8035 24.0186   22.563 ~ 24 0
86 ACS-GC 20155137 AGN 09 59 25.13 +02 36 25.0   23.9211 23.5819   23.745 ~ 20 0
87 SDSS J095930.20+024124.8 QSO 09 59 30.204 +02 41 24.83   21.6099 21.2693   21.060 ~ 38 0
88 COSMOS2015 793328 QSO 09 59 31.793 +02 30 18.63           ~ 19 0
89 [VV2006] J095949.4+020140 QSO 09 59 49.4023471848 +02 01 40.976414868   19.84 19.67   19.00 ~ 77 0
90 COSMOS2015 746810 AGN 09 59 52.0 +02 25 57   27.29 26.63 25.71 25.36 ~ 14 0
91 ACS-GC 20273957 AGN 09 59 55.58 +02 18 54.0   25.376 25.582   24.692 ~ 21 0
92 [VV2006] J095958.6+021805 QSO 09 59 58.5352330248 +02 18 05.143568796   20.7067 20.349   20.12 ~ 39 0
93 ACS-GC 20257695 rG 10 00 00.61 +02 15 31.1   25.596 25.580   24.826 ~ 42 0
94 COSMOS2015 638527 AGN 10 00 02.53 +02 16 10.1           ~ 13 0
95 ACS-GC 20123811 AGN 10 00 02.57 +02 19 58.8 25.29 25.28 24.83 24.54 24.04 ~ 33 0
96 COSMOS2015 704289 AGN 10 00 02.68 +02 22 04.4           ~ 9 0
97 COSMOS 2004639 G 10 00 03.75 +02 26 31.8           ~ 8 0
98 ACS-GC 20123713 AGN 10 00 04.76 +02 20 56.9   25.056 25.195   24.232 ~ 19 0
99 COSMOS2015 695834 QSO 10 00 04.82 +02 21 13.1   22.3048 21.7142   21.568 ~ 17 0
100 COSMOS2015 748043 rG 10 00 06.542 +02 26 05.00           ~ 15 0
101 COSMOS2015 763569 AGN 10 00 07.896 +02 27 30.94           ~ 15 0
102 COSMOS2015 699272 AGN 10 00 08.83 +02 21 30.7 25.98 25.62 25.18 24.98 24.38 ~ 16 0
103 COSMOS2015 631272 AGN 10 00 08.846 +02 15 27.99           ~ 16 0
104 ACS-GC 20067563 rG 10 00 10.23 +02 03 47.8 23.709 23.71 23.41 23.39 22.74 ~ 28 0
105 ACS-GC 20094946 QSO 10 00 11.041 +02 12 04.05         22.37 ~ 33 0
106 COSMOS2015 705530 AGN 10 00 12.55 +02 22 09.6           ~ 21 0
107 COSMOS2015 553873 rG 10 00 13.241 +02 08 35.57           ~ 17 0
108 [VV2006] J100014.0+020054 QSO 10 00 14.1384525888 +02 00 54.483786360   19.9645 19.7155   19.77 ~ 73 0
109 COSMOS2015 739490 AGN 10 00 15.24 +02 25 18.5           ~ 12 0
110 ACS-GC 20120455 Sy1 10 00 15.49 +02 19 44.6   22.9146 22.0843   21.56 ~ 46 0
111 CANDELS COSMOS F160W J100015.51+021127.3 rG 10 00 15.516 +02 11 27.44           ~ 19 0
112 ACS-GC 20273084 AGN 10 00 17.908 +02 18 07.21 23.53 22.49 21.86   25.415 ~ 37 0
113 COSMOS2015 635245 AGN 10 00 18.24 +02 15 51.4   23.536 24.063 23.55   ~ 18 0
114 ACS-GC 20118705 Sy1 10 00 21.97 +02 23 56.7   22.9127 22.3273   21.98 ~ 40 0
115 ACS-GC 20272233 AGN 10 00 23.136 +02 17 34.94           ~ 22 0
116 ACS-GC 20092341 AGN 10 00 24.22 +02 10 04.2   23.9791 23.3239   22.694 ~ 19 0
117 [VV2006] J100024.5+020619 QSO 10 00 24.4802452008 +02 06 19.669651812   19.43 19.42   19.89 ~ 64 0
118 SDSS J100024.88+023956.6 QSO 10 00 24.885 +02 39 56.59   20.994 21.284   21.21 ~ 40 0
119 COSMOS2015 621569 AGN 10 00 25.121 +02 14 37.74           ~ 20 0
120 NAME COSMOS Field reg 10 00 28.60 +02 12 21.0           ~ 3639 0
121 ACS-GC 20271392 Sy2 10 00 28.70 +02 17 45.3 23.89 24.270 23.976   24.188 ~ 31 0
122 ACS-GC 20121134 AGN 10 00 31.93 +02 18 11.8   23.984 24.079   23.587 ~ 36 0
123 CANDELS COSMOS F160W J100036.52+021828.1 rG 10 00 36.52 +02 18 28.3   26.17 24.92 24.63 24.31 ~ 27 0
124 ACS-GC 20090331 AGN 10 00 43.202 +02 13 52.75   23.9125 23.8059   23.565 ~ 30 0
125 CANDELS COSMOS F160W J100044.77+022719.1 rG 10 00 44.77295 +02 27 19.1919           ~ 19 0
126 COSMOS2015 819374 AGN 10 00 46.03 +02 32 38.1           ~ 16 0
127 ACS-GC 20090383 AGN 10 00 46.23 +02 13 11.5 23.51 23.9403 23.0494   23.169 ~ 32 0
128 ACS-GC 20149465 rG 10 00 49.28 +02 30 10.5   24.0642 23.4208   23.425 ~ 24 0
129 ACS-GC 20118275 Sy1 10 00 50.580 +02 23 29.30   23.3968 22.4927   22.986 ~ 37 0
130 ACS-GC 20288368 AGN 10 00 51.40 +02 28 30.1 24.93 24.31 23.52 23.46 23.22 ~ 18 0
131 [VV2006] J100051.5+021215 QSO 10 00 51.5174198904 +02 12 15.332100804   21.2347 21.2034   20.99 ~ 38 0
132 [VV2006] J100051.9+015919 QSO 10 00 51.927 +01 59 19.28   21.997 21.536   21.416 ~ 32 0
133 COSMOS2015 644795 Sy2 10 00 52.553 +02 16 44.14           ~ 16 0
134 ACS-GC 20090171 rG 10 00 53.770 +02 16 14.88   24.569 24.658   23.687 ~ 29 0
135 ACS-GC 20119905 AGN 10 00 54.06 +02 21 04.4 25.31 24.614 24.40 24.42 24.09 ~ 23 0
136 ACS-GC 20145920 rG 10 00 54.514 +02 32 15.35   24.635 24.473   23.780 ~ 24 0
137 [VV2006] J100055.6+022150 QSO 10 00 55.6277266344 +02 21 50.380395192   20.8269 20.5506   20.58 ~ 30 0
138 ACS-GC 20117015 AGN 10 00 56.52 +02 21 42.3   24.6224 23.6422   22.837 ~ 23 0
139 ACS-GC 20115062 Sy2 10 00 59.47 +02 26 31.7   24.095 24.346   24.335 ~ 26 0
140 COSMOS2015 703280 AGN 10 01 05.03 +02 21 54.3 25.83 24.18 23.76 23.45 23.15 ~ 13 0
141 SDSS J100105.31+021348.3 QSO 10 01 05.3121211080 +02 13 48.296075376   20.9144 20.4948   20.605 ~ 43 0
142 COSMOS2015 736288 AGN 10 01 07.481 +02 24 57.24           ~ 13 0
143 COSMOS2015 722987 QSO 10 01 08.36 +02 23 42.2   21.647 21.893   21.57 ~ 29 0
144 2XMM J100108.5+020053 QSO 10 01 08.547 +02 00 52.43   21.3345 20.8779   20.95 ~ 36 0
145 [VV2006] J100114.3+022356 QSO 10 01 14.2959939888 +02 23 56.870929824 19.71 19.44 19.46   19.165 ~ 75 0
146 ACS-GC 20060233 rG 10 01 18.45 +02 05 39.5         24.301 ~ 19 0
147 ACS-GC 20088817 rG 10 01 22.49 +02 08 26.4   25.213 25.154   24.589 ~ 22 0
148 2XMM J100124.8+022031 QSO 10 01 24.8637470400 +02 20 31.785153756   21.2235 20.8361   20.589 ~ 34 0
149 [VV2006] J100129.7+020643 QSO 10 01 29.6700868944 +02 06 43.285011372   21.51 21.27   20.95 ~ 35 0
150 IC 1127 SyG 15 34 57.22396 +23 30 11.6084   14.76 13.88     ~ 3090 4

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2018MNRAS.475.1288S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu