2019ApJ...879...49C


Query : 2019ApJ...879...49C

2019ApJ...879...49C - Astrophys. J., 879, 49-49 (2019/July-1)

A temporary epoch of stalled spin-down for low-mass stars: insights from NGC 6811 with Gaia and Kepler.

CURTIS J.L., AGUEROS M.A., DOUGLAS S.T. and MEIBOM S.

Abstract (from CDS):

Stellar rotation was proposed as a potential age diagnostic that is precise, simple, and applicable to a broad range of low-mass stars (≤ 1 M☉). Unfortunately, rotation period (Prot) measurements of low-mass members of open clusters have undermined the idea that stars spin down with a common age dependence (i.e., Prot∝ \sqrtage): K dwarfs appear to spin down more slowly than F and G dwarfs. Agueros et al. interpreted data for the ≃1.4 Gyr-old cluster NGC 752 differently, proposing that after having converged onto a slow-rotating sequence in their first 600-700 Myr (by the age of Praesepe), K dwarf Prot stall on that sequence for an extended period of time. We use data from Gaia DR2 to identify likely single-star members of the ≃1 Gyr-old cluster NGC 6811 with Kepler light curves. We measure Prot for 171 members, more than doubling the sample relative to the existing catalog and extending the mass limit from ~0.8 to ≃0.6 M☉. We then apply a gyrochronology formula calibrated with Praesepe and the Sun to 27 single G dwarfs in NGC 6811 to derive a precise gyrochronological age for the cluster of 1.04 ± 0.07 Gyr. However, when our new low-mass rotators are included, NGC 6811's color-Prot sequence deviates away from the naive 1 Gyr projection down to Teff~4295 K (K5V, 0.7 M☉), where it clearly overlaps with Praesepe's. Combining these data with Prot for other clusters, we conclude that the assumption that mass and age are separable dependencies is invalid. Furthermore, the cluster data show definitively that stars experience a temporary epoch of reduced braking efficiency where Prot stall, and that the duration of this epoch lasts longer for lower-mass stars.

Abstract Copyright: © 2019. The American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): open clusters and associations: individual: (NGC 6811, Pleiades, Praesepe) - stars: evolution - stars: rotation - stars: solar-type

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/879/49): table1.dat>

Simbad objects: 183

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 183
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 Cl Blanco 1 OpC 00 03 04.1 -29 48 55           ~ 380 0
2 NGC 752 OpC 01 56 53.7 +37 45 06           ~ 712 0
3 NGC 1039 OpC 02 42 09.1 +42 44 02           ~ 467 0
4 Cl Melotte 22 OpC 03 46 38.0 +24 10 41           ~ 3679 0
5 Cl Melotte 25 OpC 04 30 27.4 +16 46 43           ~ 3309 0
6 NGC 2168 OpC 06 09 07.5 +24 20 15           ~ 604 0
7 NGC 2632 OpC 08 39 58.4 +19 36 33           ~ 1733 0
8 Cl Melotte 111 OpC 12 11 54.9 +25 16 36           ~ 520 0
9 NAME Ursa Major Cluster ClG 15 08.8 +67 07           ~ 424 1
10 NGC 6774 OpC 19 16 17.6 -16 20 45           ~ 258 0
11 2MASS J19333980+4612149 V* 19 33 39.8064393484 +46 12 14.825524324           F6Vs 12 0
12 KOI-243 * 19 34 40.8339604845 +46 17 44.331435792           G3V 25 0
13 2MASS J19345021+4607255 * 19 34 50.2207814020 +46 07 25.512896305           ~ 8 0
14 2MASS J19350692+4600234 * 19 35 06.9258872486 +46 00 23.446106705           ~ 24 0
15 2MASS J19350980+4602121 * 19 35 09.8084287608 +46 02 12.153432444           ~ 20 0
16 2MASS J19351085+4631352 Ro* 19 35 10.8561862128 +46 31 35.117087088           ~ 13 0
17 BOKS 15885 V* 19 35 12.3413223528 +46 41 35.501406072           ~ 9 0
18 2MASS J19351328+4603434 V* 19 35 13.2905706368 +46 03 43.467933198           ~ 13 0
19 2MASS J19351579+4642257 Er* 19 35 15.8002875138 +46 42 25.728197751           ~ 8 0
20 2MASS J19352254+4602532 * 19 35 22.5496425984 +46 02 53.312010828           ~ 19 0
21 2MASS J19352553+4624192 V* 19 35 25.5395801328 +46 24 19.180422288           ~ 4 0
22 2MASS J19352932+4645546 * 19 35 29.3344421204 +46 45 54.650192872           ~ 7 0
23 2MASS J19353693+4602007 * 19 35 36.9310418776 +46 02 00.733548627           ~ 4 0
24 2MASS J19354696+4606270 * 19 35 46.9644208536 +46 06 27.096288084           ~ 22 0
25 2MASS J19355015+4546575 * 19 35 50.1498676344 +45 46 57.540535068           ~ 17 0
26 Kepler-66 Ro* 19 35 55.5742859415 +46 41 15.957071005     15.3 15.29   G3 75 1
27 2MASS J19360860+4630432 * 19 36 08.6064996657 +46 30 43.153242487           ~ 21 0
28 UCAC4 683-072399 * 19 36 14.1474058464 +46 25 43.104514944   16.562 15.657 16.109   ~ 11 0
29 2MASS J19361439+4617321 * 19 36 14.3944070280 +46 17 31.962398460           ~ 11 0
30 2MASS J19361564+4618094 * 19 36 15.6490957643 +46 18 09.449017766           ~ 21 0
31 2MASS J19361704+4641251 * 19 36 17.0425855708 +46 41 25.044367968           ~ 7 0
32 2MASS J19362915+4607283 Ro* 19 36 29.1572806200 +46 07 28.290253188           ~ 12 0
33 2MASS J19362942+4607101 * 19 36 29.4241923480 +46 07 09.944490612           ~ 11 0
34 2MASS J19363023+4622150 * 19 36 30.2431141522 +46 22 15.001263861           ~ 17 0
35 UCAC4 683-072458 V* 19 36 32.8301080484 +46 24 28.903491571   14.529 13.952 13.902   ~ 13 0
36 2MASS J19363587+4525227 Ro* 19 36 35.8758421296 +45 25 22.772792712           ~ 14 0
37 Kepler-67 Ro* 19 36 36.8093759520 +46 09 59.166722448     16.4     ~ 52 1
38 2MASS J19363829+4635301 * 19 36 38.2825534800 +46 35 30.002518500           ~ 9 0
39 2MASS J19363846+4615254 Pu* 19 36 38.4655164744 +46 15 25.298900712           ~ 23 0
40 2MASS J19363872+4615106 Ro* 19 36 38.7185988480 +46 15 10.611795960           ~ 12 0
41 2MASS J19363933+4627018 V* 19 36 39.3336725264 +46 27 01.820215031           F5V 16 0
42 2MASS J19364036+4638329 * 19 36 40.3501458864 +46 38 32.727034500           ~ 5 0
43 2MASS J19364078+4618155 * 19 36 40.7807338694 +46 18 15.457011398           ~ 21 0
44 2MASS J19364087+4618513 * 19 36 40.8807661273 +46 18 51.090440055           ~ 4 0
45 2MASS J19364116+4623095 V* 19 36 41.1691801080 +46 23 09.505299841           F2V 14 0
46 UCAC4 682-069633 * 19 36 41.9195440872 +46 15 35.841517092       14.376   ~ 9 0
47 BOKS 24488 V* 19 36 43.4220950184 +46 14 41.808175512           ~ 8 0
48 2MASS J19364368+4609130 * 19 36 43.6769191191 +46 09 13.115109637           ~ 26 0
49 2MASS J19364491+4622270 * 19 36 44.9087200608 +46 22 26.914525320           ~ 19 0
50 2MASS J19364504+4644579 * 19 36 45.0495517200 +46 44 57.807108060           ~ 13 0
51 2MASS J19364532+4627157 * 19 36 45.3180831984 +46 27 15.725497212           ~ 23 0
52 2MASS J19364564+4613004 * 19 36 45.6511653840 +46 13 00.286018536           ~ 8 0
53 UCAC4 682-069650 * 19 36 47.4278518368 +46 15 42.965783208           ~ 10 0
54 2MASS J19364777+4632454 * 19 36 47.7676702656 +46 32 45.345247188           ~ 19 0
55 2MASS J19364824+4628364 * 19 36 48.2445195743 +46 28 36.361319223           G0IV-V 28 0
56 2MASS J19365012+4653022 * 19 36 50.1313638943 +46 53 02.285857593           ~ 4 0
57 UCAC4 682-069671 V* 19 36 51.1191166344 +46 13 02.001788004   14.570 14.034 13.903   ~ 12 0
58 2MASS J19365187+4621382 * 19 36 51.8722882056 +46 21 38.261550168           ~ 9 0
59 2MASS J19365264+4619356 Ro* 19 36 52.6417379880 +46 19 35.532765948           ~ 8 0
60 2MASS J19365264+4643249 * 19 36 52.6443385200 +46 43 24.846127644           ~ 24 0
61 2MASS J19365448+4605446 * 19 36 54.4895036232 +46 05 44.653711452           ~ 23 0
62 2MASS J19365467+4625036 V* 19 36 54.6774866506 +46 25 03.610365631           F2V 16 0
63 2MASS J19365476+4615265 * 19 36 54.7642785792 +46 15 26.409585564           ~ 9 0
64 2MASS J19365480+4635116 V* 19 36 54.7915351608 +46 35 11.484953988           ~ 12 0
65 2MASS J19365500+4631480 * 19 36 54.9987934104 +46 31 47.885386188           ~ 21 0
66 UCAC4 683-072544 * 19 36 55.4619057072 +46 30 30.705930252   15.230 14.588 14.572   ~ 11 0
67 2MASS J19365592+4616418 * 19 36 55.9261797792 +46 16 41.819288916           ~ 19 0
68 2MASS J19365606+4625416 * 19 36 56.0700168768 +46 25 41.710872072           ~ 9 0
69 2MASS J19365620+4625500 * 19 36 56.2182651381 +46 25 49.981576680           ~ 4 0
70 UCAC4 683-072567 V* 19 36 58.7214855600 +46 26 58.755328404   14.063 13.499 13.395   ~ 12 0
71 2MASS J19370019+4632277 * 19 37 00.1952001271 +46 32 27.667755084           ~ 23 0
72 2MASS J19370057+4623464 * 19 37 00.5794512168 +46 23 46.465451952           ~ 16 0
73 2MASS J19370220+4639506 * 19 37 02.2153550623 +46 39 50.628549769           ~ 5 0
74 2MASS J19370235+4624559 * 19 37 02.3545648104 +46 24 55.913393160           ~ 17 0
75 2MASS J19370296+4618467 * 19 37 02.9770271760 +46 18 46.745162244           ~ 21 0
76 2MASS J19370522+4635080 * 19 37 05.2255070010 +46 35 07.919208689           ~ 24 0
77 2MASS J19370678+4558188 * 19 37 06.7866791712 +45 58 18.764622876           ~ 20 0
78 2MASS J19370731+4648474 * 19 37 07.3162289610 +46 48 47.424997694           ~ 14 0
79 2MASS J19370786+4622123 * 19 37 07.8782396016 +46 22 12.321719940           ~ 13 0
80 2MASS J19370830+4600255 * 19 37 08.3069505000 +46 00 25.466339268           ~ 9 0
81 2MASS J19370887+4638152 * 19 37 08.8662299856 +46 38 15.168550092           ~ 18 0
82 UCAC4 683-072610 V* 19 37 09.4109795016 +46 27 55.198955376   14.602 14.059 13.899   ~ 11 0
83 UCAC4 682-069749 * 19 37 10.4146837632 +46 22 32.534564952       14.477   ~ 11 0
84 2MASS J19371041+4639193 * 19 37 10.4243757720 +46 39 19.333440468           ~ 17 0
85 2MASS J19371098+4617473 * 19 37 10.9952494906 +46 17 47.331946112           ~ 6 0
86 2MASS J19371128+4620491 * 19 37 11.2964232888 +46 20 49.147443492           ~ 22 0
87 2MASS J19371137+4612276 * 19 37 11.3812227394 +46 12 27.597817767           ~ 25 0
88 2MASS J19371187+4618080 V* 19 37 11.8825356072 +46 18 08.053571196           ~ 12 0
89 KOI-4142 * 19 37 14.1236958552 +46 24 47.011311612           ~ 15 0
90 2MASS J19371444+4622143 * 19 37 14.4502134648 +46 22 14.367098784           ~ 23 0
91 2MASS J19371593+4620159 * 19 37 15.9282070032 +46 20 16.048574952           ~ 5 0
92 UCAC4 682-069795 V* 19 37 17.8155468813 +46 19 06.837396731   14.389 13.839 13.712   ~ 14 0
93 2MASS J19371951+4617136 Ro* 19 37 19.5193791840 +46 17 13.538621868           ~ 11 0
94 2MASS J19372035+4622063 Ro* 19 37 20.3585695632 +46 22 06.333129840           ~ 14 0
95 2MASS J19372041+4603030 * 19 37 20.4196934568 +46 03 03.006050904           ~ 5 0
96 UCAC4 683-072652 * 19 37 20.9331288691 +46 26 36.959567310   14.922 14.381 14.206   ~ 13 0
97 2MASS J19372117+4628495 * 19 37 21.1664280528 +46 28 49.500694200           ~ 17 0
98 2MASS J19372149+4603362 * 19 37 21.5010497424 +46 03 36.237754440           ~ 21 0
99 NGC 6811 OpC 19 37 21.8 +46 22 43   7.47 6.8     ~ 435 0
100 2MASS J19372235+4643399 * 19 37 22.3547087013 +46 43 39.982674843           ~ 2 0
101 2MASS J19372275+4628099 V* 19 37 22.7538637920 +46 28 09.829210512           ~ 12 0
102 2MASS J19372367+4603581 * 19 37 23.6707323576 +46 03 58.088641932           ~ 22 0
103 KOI-7218 Ro* 19 37 24.1795936296 +46 18 42.360692436           ~ 16 0
104 2MASS J19372459+4643232 * 19 37 24.5835803076 +46 43 23.233189306           ~ 4 0
105 BOKS 28553 V* 19 37 24.7585471728 +46 05 07.172712204           ~ 9 0
106 2MASS J19372490+4622161 * 19 37 24.9019215168 +46 22 16.224212100           ~ 16 0
107 UCAC4 682-069832 dS* 19 37 25.0633986101 +46 23 44.827462259       13.814   ~ 9 0
108 BOKS 28712 V* 19 37 26.6274346752 +46 26 41.195517756           ~ 11 0
109 2MASS J19372774+4619359 * 19 37 27.7401842448 +46 19 35.913774288           ~ 19 0
110 2MASS J19373252+4624030 * 19 37 32.5187778312 +46 24 03.041903448           G0IV-V 24 0
111 2MASS J19373549+4638086 * 19 37 35.4946326120 +46 38 08.740356756           ~ 8 0
112 2MASS J19373575+4622525 * 19 37 35.7579525600 +46 22 52.550673600           ~ 12 0
113 2MASS J19373600+4621058 * 19 37 36.0105518562 +46 21 05.854073297           ~ 8 0
114 BOKS 29748 V* 19 37 37.4058915360 +46 31 33.984362460           ~ 15 0
115 2MASS J19373775+4615278 * 19 37 37.7769439875 +46 15 27.639651660           ~ 7 0
116 ZTF J193738.27+461913.9 BY* 19 37 38.2754528784 +46 19 13.976251536           ~ 22 0
117 2MASS J19373857+4629125 gD* 19 37 38.5729801473 +46 29 12.682361256           ~ 18 0
118 2MASS J19373961+4613037 Ro* 19 37 39.6281498376 +46 13 03.503463420           ~ 10 0
119 2MASS J19373981+4615309 * 19 37 39.8210404488 +46 15 30.804228360           G2IV-V 13 0
120 2MASS J19374177+4646135 * 19 37 41.7807998971 +46 46 13.323007370           ~ 6 0
121 UCAC4 681-071584 * 19 37 43.4605206768 +46 09 37.450223280   15.317 14.681 14.538   ~ 11 0
122 2MASS J19374386+4619128 * 19 37 43.8678811536 +46 19 12.931569732           ~ 18 0
123 2MASS J19374570+4612252 Ro* 19 37 45.7104467208 +46 12 25.205652108           ~ 13 0
124 2MASS J19374597+4627303 * 19 37 45.9770518968 +46 27 30.555498672           ~ 21 0
125 2MASS J19374599+4626380 * 19 37 45.9889979047 +46 26 38.079171159           ~ 4 0
126 2MASS J19374614+4618084 V* 19 37 46.1530729543 +46 18 08.443048535           F3V 14 0
127 UCAC4 682-069932 V* 19 37 46.6939730472 +46 23 05.856476064       14.087   ~ 10 0
128 UCAC4 682-069937 V* 19 37 47.1064345768 +46 23 22.880253084       13.918   ~ 11 0
129 2MASS J19374736+4618461 * 19 37 47.3693503464 +46 18 46.184288796           ~ 16 0
130 2MASS J19374747+4616243 V* 19 37 47.4804288973 +46 16 24.377732080           F5IV 15 0
131 2MASS J19374874+4626020 * 19 37 48.7463200584 +46 26 02.253617808           ~ 7 0
132 2MASS J19375005+4626049 Ro* 19 37 50.0571820728 +46 26 05.094256524           ~ 17 0
133 2MASS J19375067+4632062 * 19 37 50.6839756464 +46 32 06.282159072           ~ 17 0
134 2MASS J19375118+4628350 Ro* 19 37 51.1808874144 +46 28 35.259068244           ~ 9 0
135 UCAC4 679-071031 * 19 37 51.8071873995 +45 44 24.629774211   16.402 15.896 15.822   ~ 3 0
136 UCAC4 683-072787 V* 19 37 53.0202616632 +46 35 34.736753004   14.686 14.138 14.028   ~ 13 0
137 2MASS J19375990+4624446 V* 19 37 59.9109560125 +46 24 44.744129763           ~ 13 0
138 UCAC4 682-069986 * 19 38 01.8013170936 +46 19 33.941570376       14.273   ~ 11 0
139 2MASS J19380241+4622271 * 19 38 02.4171728592 +46 22 27.178223844           ~ 22 0
140 UCAC4 683-072814 V* 19 38 02.8431570020 +46 26 40.746936585   14.233 13.726 13.566   ~ 13 0
141 2MASS J19380842+4625416 Ro* 19 38 08.4211717440 +46 25 41.692368108           ~ 12 0
142 2MASS J19380873+4632381 * 19 38 08.7360639402 +46 32 38.082741953           ~ 20 0
143 2MASS J19380876+4622270 Ro* 19 38 08.7455536968 +46 22 27.073124976           ~ 10 0
144 2MASS J19380959+4621129 * 19 38 09.5319881352 +46 21 13.202947044           ~ 4 0
145 2MASS J19380997+4631254 * 19 38 09.9729618888 +46 31 25.311658080           ~ 6 0
146 2MASS J19381087+4616342 * 19 38 10.8674956392 +46 16 34.205590632           ~ 19 0
147 UCAC4 682-070025 V* 19 38 11.9507003616 +46 23 21.420584160   15.156 14.477 14.461   ~ 11 0
148 2MASS J19381246+4625287 V* 19 38 12.4668921182 +46 25 28.652696267           G2V 16 0
149 2MASS J19381294+4640590 * 19 38 12.9540309768 +46 40 58.515199392           ~ 3 0
150 2MASS J19381369+4643598 * 19 38 13.7059529256 +46 43 59.806786836           ~ 9 0
151 UCAC4 681-071704 V* 19 38 15.4336862424 +46 08 59.982705240   14.868 14.291 14.129   ~ 12 0
152 Gaia DR2 2128127265491233280 * 19 38 17.5459656537 +46 15 45.871294089           ~ 10 0
153 2MASS J19382633+4621064 Pu* 19 38 26.3385273360 +46 21 06.421173876           ~ 20 0
154 2MASS J19383089+4626500 Ro* 19 38 30.8872414800 +46 26 50.051666544           ~ 8 0
155 2MASS J19383497+4608042 * 19 38 34.9709658174 +46 08 04.422318695           ~ 6 0
156 BOKS 35694 V* 19 38 37.2736744080 +46 41 31.323987240           ~ 14 0
157 2MASS J19384101+4630142 V* 19 38 41.0098567334 +46 30 14.189772048           F5IV 14 0
158 2MASS J19384659+4645599 V* 19 38 46.5953809176 +46 45 59.942877763           F3V 14 0
159 ZTF J193847.56+461806.8 BY* 19 38 47.5738701552 +46 18 06.863218560           ~ 23 0
160 2MASS J19384808+4611180 V* 19 38 48.0768864024 +46 11 18.033179424           ~ 6 0
161 2MASS J19384960+4624130 * 19 38 49.6006283352 +46 24 13.083557184           ~ 17 0
162 2MASS J19385048+4621538 * 19 38 50.4732270115 +46 21 53.779225623           ~ 3 0
163 UCAC4 684-069411 * 19 38 50.8575013374 +46 36 47.417449243           ~ 8 0
164 2MASS J19385521+4637187 * 19 38 55.2206785056 +46 37 18.754348332           ~ 20 0
165 2MASS J19385633+4637292 * 19 38 56.3391181224 +46 37 29.269132896           ~ 9 0
166 2MASS J19385654+4631480 * 19 38 56.5389794016 +46 31 48.057211380           ~ 21 0
167 2MASS J19385801+4554117 Ro* 19 38 58.0096297632 +45 54 11.698805268           ~ 19 0
168 2MASS J19385818+4624134 * 19 38 58.1753299575 +46 24 13.427297558           ~ 2 0
169 2MASS J19385856+4621541 * 19 38 58.5636515855 +46 21 54.104500197           ~ 22 0
170 2MASS J19390104+4656515 * 19 39 01.0534453032 +46 56 51.600928668           ~ 17 0
171 2MASS J19390376+4622580 * 19 39 03.7654517535 +46 22 58.011397135           ~ 6 0
172 2MASS J19390480+4616554 * 19 39 04.8095634815 +46 16 55.384382160           ~ 4 0
173 UCAC4 682-070206 * 19 39 06.0104099112 +46 21 28.508057280       15.859   ~ 8 0
174 BOKS 38993 V* 19 39 09.1541090136 +46 36 42.815869668           ~ 16 0
175 2MASS J19391727+4619399 Er* 19 39 17.2767505734 +46 19 39.815638480           ~ 9 0
176 2MASS J19391806+4617525 Ro* 19 39 18.0627597000 +46 17 52.519594884           ~ 12 0
177 2MASS J19393111+4632375 * 19 39 31.1097544106 +46 32 37.547873186           ~ 23 0
178 2MASS J19393326+4611295 * 19 39 33.2593809360 +46 11 29.541300252           ~ 20 0
179 2MASS J19393675+4640096 * 19 39 36.7514210975 +46 40 09.679724714           ~ 7 0
180 2MASS J19394835+4612235 * 19 39 48.3545079726 +46 12 23.521795594           ~ 7 0
181 2MASS J19395054+4626592 * 19 39 50.5472602944 +46 26 59.160494436           ~ 22 0
182 2MASS J19400187+4621454 * 19 40 01.8762588504 +46 21 45.331730892           ~ 5 0
183 2MASS J19401800+4625548 V* 19 40 18.0044842868 +46 25 54.862820467           F2IV 13 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2019ApJ...879...49C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu