2020A&A...642A..58C


Query : 2020A&A...642A..58C

2020A&A...642A..58C - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 642A58-58 (2020/10-1)

Automatic catalog of RR Lyrae from ∼14 million VVV light curves: How far can we go with traditional machine-learning?

CABRAL J.B., RAMOS F., GUROVICH S. and GRANITTO P.M.

Abstract (from CDS):


Context. The creation of a 3D map of the bulge using RR Lyrae (RRL) is one of the main goals of the VISTA Variables in the Via Lactea Survey (VVV) and VVV(X) surveys. The overwhelming number of sources undergoing analysis undoubtedly requires the use of automatic procedures. In this context, previous studies have introduced the use of machine learning (ML) methods for the task of variable star classification.
Aims. Our goal is to develop and test an entirely automatic ML-based procedure for the identification of RRLs in the VVV Survey. This automatic procedure is meant to be used to generate reliable catalogs integrated over several tiles in the survey.
Methods. Following the reconstruction of light curves, we extracted a set of period- and intensity-based features, which were already defined in previous works. Also, for the first time, we put a new subset of useful color features to use. We discuss in considerable detail all the appropriate steps needed to define our fully automatic pipeline, namely: the selection of quality measurements; sampling procedures; classifier setup, and model selection.
Results. As a result, we were able to construct an ensemble classifier with an average recall of 0.48 and average precision of 0.86 over 15 tiles. We also made all our processed datasets available and we published a catalog of candidate RRLs.
Conclusions. Perhaps most interestingly, from a classification perspective based on photometric broad-band data, our results indicate that color is an informative feature type of the RRL objective class that should always be considered in automatic classification methods via ML. We also argue that recall and precision in both tables and curves are high-quality metrics with regard to this highly imbalanced problem. Furthermore, we show for our VVV data-set that to have good estimates, it is important to use the original distribution more abundantly than reduced samples with an artificial balance. Finally, we show that the use of ensemble classifiers helps resolve the crucial model selection step and that most errors in the identification of RRLs are related to low-quality observations of some sources or to the increased difficulty in resolving the RRL-C type given the data.

Abstract Copyright: © ESO 2020

Journal keyword(s): methods: data analysis - methods: statistical - surveys - catalogs - stars: variables: RR Lyrae - Galaxy: bulge

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/642/A58): tableg.dat>

Simbad objects: 243

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 243
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 VVV J172934.42-293248.5 RR* 17 29 34.4189197217 -29 32 48.604815689           ~ 5 0
2 VVV J173022.12-291526.9 RR? 17 30 22.1225659724 -29 15 26.893668397           ~ 2 0
3 VVV J173104.93-293408.7 RR* 17 31 04.9250018417 -29 34 08.735432695           ~ 5 0
4 VVV J173109.12-285519.9 RR? 17 31 09.1119840460 -28 55 19.980167753           ~ 2 0
5 VVV J173121.82-300816.1 RR* 17 31 21.82 -30 08 16.2           ~ 3 0
6 VVV J173121.98-291332.8 RR? 17 31 21.98 -29 13 32.8           ~ 1 0
7 VVV J173132.57-293253.4 RR* 17 31 32.57 -29 32 53.4           ~ 3 0
8 VVV J173138.32-293219.7 RR* 17 31 38.32 -29 32 19.8           ~ 3 0
9 VVV J173141.82-293139.8 RR* 17 31 41.82 -29 31 39.8           ~ 3 0
10 VVV J173148.03-295554.0 RR? 17 31 48.0310131817 -29 55 54.033181959           ~ 2 0
11 VVV J173148.40-291123.4 RR? 17 31 48.40 -29 11 23.4           ~ 1 0
12 VVV J173148.72-290052.4 RR? 17 31 48.72 -29 00 52.4           ~ 1 0
13 VVV J173152.91-300840.5 RR? 17 31 52.91 -30 08 40.5           ~ 1 0
14 VVV J173212.93-285453.9 RR* 17 32 12.93 -28 54 53.9           ~ 3 0
15 VVV J173230.95-285727.1 RR* 17 32 30.95 -28 57 27.1           ~ 2 0
16 VVV J173244.85-285440.1 RR* 17 32 44.85 -28 54 40.1           ~ 3 0
17 VVV J173316.61-285514.8 RR? 17 33 16.5963900836 -28 55 14.838976448           ~ 2 0
18 VVV J173331.56-293241.3 RR* 17 33 31.56 -29 32 41.4           ~ 3 0
19 VVV J173334.49-293202.7 RR* 17 33 34.4677270458 -29 32 02.732597127           ~ 5 0
20 VVV J173339.15-285501.0 RR* 17 33 39.15 -28 55 01.1           ~ 3 0
21 VVV J173346.21-290936.8 RR? 17 33 46.21 -29 09 36.8           ~ 1 0
22 VVV J173353.59-285439.9 RR? 17 33 53.59 -28 54 39.9           ~ 1 0
23 VVV J173432.50-291813.8 RR? 17 34 32.50 -29 18 13.8           ~ 1 0
24 VVV J173514.52-291508.9 RR* 17 35 14.4951884884 -29 15 08.976835436           ~ 5 0
25 NAME Galactic Center reg 17 45 39.60213 -29 00 22.0000           ~ 16269 0
26 VVV J174729.91-183118.1 RR? 17 47 29.9115554326 -18 31 18.122440175           ~ 2 0
27 VVV J174739.05-182535.8 RR* 17 47 39.0459700980 -18 25 35.886284477           ~ 4 0
28 VVV J174748.65-182609.1 EB* 17 47 48.6453057391 -18 26 09.219750805           ~ 3 0
29 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-53776 RR* 17 47 56.7356397928 -18 27 43.344264123         16.349 ~ 8 0
30 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-53800 RR* 17 48 03.9521819427 -18 16 02.142800569         16.596 ~ 7 0
31 ATO J267.0280-18.5156 RR* 17 48 06.7331144225 -18 30 56.298133294       16.323 15.584 ~ 9 0
32 VVV J174816.23-182243.9 RR? 17 48 16.2260704722 -18 22 44.040350856           ~ 2 0
33 VVV J174818.47-184240.3 EB* 17 48 18.4712539862 -18 42 40.312370630           ~ 3 0
34 VVV J174819.09-183741.8 RR? 17 48 19.09 -18 37 41.8           ~ 1 0
35 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-53845 RR* 17 48 22.2020355037 -18 26 31.059706423         16.210 ~ 8 0
36 VVV J174837.69-182243.3 EB* 17 48 37.6903541265 -18 22 43.404182194           ~ 3 0
37 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-53894 RR* 17 48 38.4437691551 -18 17 58.512335321         16.353 ~ 8 0
38 VVV J174851.35-183557.1 RR? 17 48 51.3495449005 -18 35 57.231465882           ~ 2 0
39 VVV J174858.70-184406.4 RR? 17 48 58.6978995226 -18 44 06.341429919           ~ 2 0
40 VVV J174858.77-182134.1 EB* 17 48 58.7800154824 -18 21 34.102637131           ~ 3 0
41 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-53959 RR* 17 49 01.7025522880 -18 09 09.893015997         15.043 ~ 8 0
42 VVV J174905.20-180158.6 RR? 17 49 05.2038070222 -18 01 58.725977384           ~ 2 0
43 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-53973 RR* 17 49 10.4261500420 -18 24 13.214256363         15.525 ~ 7 0
44 VVV J174914.37-183922.0 RR? 17 49 14.3660334318 -18 39 21.993276934           ~ 2 0
45 VVV J174923.39-180950.5 RR? 17 49 23.3822488108 -18 09 50.697087270           ~ 2 0
46 VVV J174924.53-180746.9 RR? 17 49 24.5252324751 -18 07 47.072712167           ~ 2 0
47 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54022 RR* 17 49 28.6215918977 -18 39 45.159144838         15.087 ~ 8 0
48 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54043 RR* 17 49 33.5951122113 -18 27 11.510763346         16.088 ~ 8 0
49 VVV J174936.98-180337.6 RR? 17 49 36.9783764664 -18 03 37.791201984           ~ 2 0
50 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54065 RR* 17 49 41.0724738432 -18 34 49.759619372         16.455 ~ 8 0
51 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54068 RR* 17 49 42.5092968168 -17 39 58.240293624         15.574 ~ 9 0
52 VVV J174943.68-183005.5 RR? 17 49 43.6753143934 -18 30 05.536251082           ~ 2 0
53 ATO J267.4519-18.1813 RR* 17 49 48.4731402663 -18 10 52.843531064         15.779 ~ 9 0
54 VVV J174951.30-182038.2 RR? 17 49 51.2967583159 -18 20 38.260380751           ~ 2 0
55 VVV J174957.06-185056.2 RR* 17 49 57.0593700334 -18 50 56.170950213           ~ 4 0
56 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54107 RR* 17 49 57.7312061597 -18 24 58.318826449         15.704 ~ 7 0
57 VVV J175001.34-181438.8 RR? 17 50 01.3367818625 -18 14 38.826481315           ~ 2 0
58 VVV J175005.18-180035.5 RR? 17 50 05.1705265047 -18 00 35.671702959           ~ 2 0
59 VVV J175006.12-181502.0 RR? 17 50 06.1144255649 -18 15 02.006854849           ~ 2 0
60 VVV J175007.04-184545.3 RR? 17 50 07.03 -18 45 45.3           ~ 1 0
61 VVV J175008.70-180601.2 RR? 17 50 08.70 -18 06 01.2           ~ 1 0
62 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54133 RR* 17 50 08.7149115235 -18 05 38.071601963         16.061 ~ 8 0
63 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54138 RR* 17 50 10.1333514706 -18 31 16.888640880         16.511 ~ 8 0
64 VVV J175010.71-185558.2 RR? 17 50 10.7044687222 -18 55 58.166489667           ~ 2 0
65 VVV J175011.98-184159.6 RR* 17 50 11.9787513968 -18 41 59.661484651           ~ 4 0
66 VVV J175012.91-184052.0 RR? 17 50 12.8991122059 -18 40 52.175219306           ~ 2 0
67 VVV J175013.79-183031.1 RR? 17 50 13.7768444329 -18 30 31.117695332           ~ 2 0
68 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54146 RR* 17 50 14.4386597216 -18 15 11.242913624         16.056 ~ 6 0
69 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54151 RR* 17 50 17.4827456450 -18 00 54.886522852         15.906 ~ 6 0
70 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54175 RR* 17 50 27.8759311555 -18 01 22.787014607         16.070 ~ 6 0
71 VVV J175029.05-182011.5 RR? 17 50 29.05 -18 20 11.5           ~ 1 0
72 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54190 RR* 17 50 31.4904114910 -18 20 11.683377496         16.289 ~ 6 0
73 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54195 RR* 17 50 33.08 -18 44 05.2         16.376 ~ 4 0
74 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54199 RR* 17 50 33.7098682505 -18 27 45.094939418         15.513 ~ 6 0
75 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54214 RR* 17 50 38.8393790643 -17 49 00.039528440         16.002 ~ 6 0
76 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54216 RR* 17 50 39.3127223861 -18 34 49.631938053         16.454 ~ 5 0
77 VVV J175042.93-181324.5 RR* 17 50 42.9298861231 -18 13 24.566306979           ~ 3 0
78 VVV J175044.68-183310.8 RR? 17 50 44.6708169484 -18 33 10.904171641           ~ 2 0
79 VVV J175051.64-190024.2 RR? 17 50 51.64 -19 00 24.2           ~ 1 0
80 VVV J175052.39-175426.6 RR? 17 50 52.3818894410 -17 54 26.841583847           ~ 2 0
81 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54259 RR* 17 50 55.3056275002 -18 38 12.439150660         16.320 ~ 6 0
82 VVV J175055.40-174744.1 EB* 17 50 55.3966726765 -17 47 44.118245734           ~ 3 0
83 VVV J175055.99-175233.4 RR? 17 50 55.9865136526 -17 52 33.503714133           ~ 2 0
84 VVV J175058.63-183908.0 RR? 17 50 58.6272654615 -18 39 07.989378971           ~ 2 0
85 ATO J267.7458-18.5763 EB* 17 50 58.9996528424 -18 34 34.734340501       15.305   ~ 3 0
86 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54297 RR* 17 51 06.1117694068 -18 24 33.276421977         16.460 ~ 7 0
87 VVV J175106.82-181234.8 RR? 17 51 06.82 -18 12 34.8           ~ 1 0
88 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54305 RR* 17 51 07.70 -18 59 07.1         15.761 ~ 4 0
89 VVV J175109.70-185006.0 RR* 17 51 09.7048404907 -18 50 05.986080630           ~ 2 0
90 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54311 RR* 17 51 10.0484754072 -18 16 45.539277132         15.923 ~ 8 0
91 VVV J175112.95-190345.5 RR? 17 51 12.95 -19 03 45.5           ~ 1 0
92 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54321 RR* 17 51 13.3949594221 -18 04 50.058489949         16.374 ~ 7 0
93 VVV J175113.82-183107.5 RR? 17 51 13.8128182238 -18 31 07.467094293           ~ 2 0
94 VVV J175115.23-183311.3 RR? 17 51 15.2321123938 -18 33 11.357824458           ~ 2 0
95 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54329 RR* 17 51 15.8244628723 -17 48 26.972938075         15.527 ~ 8 0
96 VVV J175116.73-181532.6 RR? 17 51 16.7225891248 -18 15 32.736317272           ~ 2 0
97 VVV J175120.85-173644.3 RR? 17 51 20.8398194058 -17 36 44.386235575           ~ 2 0
98 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54348 RR* 17 51 23.43 -18 58 40.3         15.358 ~ 5 0
99 VVV J175125.96-181823.4 RR* 17 51 25.9573320264 -18 18 23.444342167           ~ 3 0
100 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54370 RR* 17 51 29.8421675208 -17 53 05.174004660         16.271 ~ 8 0
101 VVV J175134.20-181323.8 RR* 17 51 34.1903246571 -18 13 23.943180011           ~ 5 0
102 VVV J175135.60-185156.8 RR? 17 51 35.5949324714 -18 51 56.844429534           ~ 2 0
103 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54399 RR* 17 51 37.3427556395 -18 21 30.691061736         15.751 ~ 8 0
104 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54412 RR* 17 51 40.7237281800 -17 53 00.898866312         16.107 ~ 8 0
105 VVV J175144.83-185532.0 RR? 17 51 44.83 -18 55 32.0           ~ 1 0
106 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54434 RR* 17 51 47.2409413605 -18 30 24.292130472         16.204 ~ 8 0
107 VVV J175147.56-181433.8 RR? 17 51 47.56 -18 14 33.8           ~ 1 0
108 VVV J175151.29-185422.0 RR? 17 51 51.2848075561 -18 54 22.122963841           ~ 2 0
109 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54449 RR* 17 51 51.5624250196 -18 02 35.940503635         16.123 ~ 6 0
110 VVV J175151.82-181311.0 RR? 17 51 51.82 -18 13 11.0           ~ 1 0
111 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54453 RR* 17 51 52.8799829162 -18 37 49.093346606         16.607 ~ 6 0
112 VVV J175153.50-175251.9 RR? 17 51 53.4887493239 -17 52 52.139703821           ~ 2 0
113 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54457 RR* 17 51 53.9733382162 -17 56 23.542105970         15.350 ~ 7 0
114 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54486 RR* 17 52 05.4286991351 -18 37 54.729220869         16.558 ~ 6 0
115 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54493 RR* 17 52 08.2316205649 -17 53 14.856633009         16.706 ~ 8 0
116 VVV J175210.36-181822.1 RR? 17 52 10.3464599475 -18 18 22.140682464           ~ 2 0
117 VVV J175213.79-180827.9 RR? 17 52 13.79 -18 08 27.9           ~ 1 0
118 VVV J175216.33-184401.9 RR? 17 52 16.3180296062 -18 44 02.027523990           ~ 2 0
119 VVV J175219.02-180707.9 RR? 17 52 19.02 -18 07 07.9           ~ 1 0
120 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54528 RR* 17 52 21.0135253928 -17 49 52.768203548         16.204 ~ 6 0
121 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54534 RR* 17 52 22.2738833208 -18 17 47.267764512         15.321 ~ 10 0
122 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54537 RR* 17 52 23.7659817947 -17 55 31.986368117         16.331 ~ 6 0
123 VVV J175225.27-180705.0 EB* 17 52 25.2598749698 -18 07 05.055757609           ~ 3 0
124 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54560 RR* 17 52 27.4884389793 -18 35 30.641077338         16.640 ~ 8 0
125 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54564 RR* 17 52 28.3237069204 -17 45 48.880888939         15.888 ~ 8 0
126 VVV J175232.88-174312.6 RR? 17 52 32.88 -17 43 12.6           ~ 1 0
127 VVV J175232.89-181925.8 RR? 17 52 32.8858728914 -18 19 25.772674633           ~ 2 0
128 VVV J175234.11-183947.4 RR? 17 52 34.1050115108 -18 39 47.517038206           ~ 2 0
129 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54580 RR* 17 52 34.2623847201 -17 48 23.740685229         15.966 ~ 6 0
130 ATO J268.1510-17.7651 EB* 17 52 36.2466505109 -17 45 54.457050052       14.568   ~ 4 0
131 ATO J268.1853-18.1678 RR* 17 52 44.4798828120 -18 10 04.221333156           ~ 7 0
132 VVV J175246.17-183139.2 RR? 17 52 46.1667902963 -18 31 39.227605706           ~ 2 0
133 VVV J175251.58-174457.5 RR? 17 52 51.5747767291 -17 44 57.576491599           ~ 2 0
134 VVV J175251.71-174540.4 RR? 17 52 51.7017938015 -17 45 40.538106020           ~ 2 0
135 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54633 RR* 17 52 52.4045725296 -18 30 41.119348356         16.545 ~ 9 0
136 VVV J175256.82-174505.0 RR? 17 52 56.8151996230 -17 45 05.184013107           ~ 2 0
137 VVV J175305.84-175213.9 RR? 17 53 05.8356188521 -17 52 14.036488497           ~ 2 0
138 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54698 RR* 17 53 11.3518595208 -17 52 31.595476706         16.486 ~ 8 0
139 VVV J175335.32-181114.5 RR? 17 53 35.3274257056 -18 11 14.579050946           ~ 2 0
140 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54779 RR* 17 53 39.1699264899 -17 59 38.318785925         16.070 ~ 7 0
141 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-54781 RR* 17 53 39.5394996269 -18 06 42.376372161         16.500 ~ 8 0
142 ATO J268.5180-17.9698 EB* 17 54 04.3378616901 -17 58 11.309290363       15.598   ~ 3 0
143 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-55793 RR* 17 59 59.3059457860 -40 20 59.608534566         15.174 ~ 5 0
144 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-55878 RR* 18 00 34.3530933536 -40 24 01.701232389         15.010 ~ 5 0
145 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-55882 RR* 18 00 38.1051900341 -40 22 17.173098884         15.180 ~ 6 0
146 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-55985 RR* 18 01 22.0377745371 -39 47 51.232807791         14.988 ~ 6 0
147 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-68441 RR* 18 01 23.0973810466 -35 19 18.616490247     16.624   15.781 ~ 5 0
148 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56006 RR* 18 01 26.4040773227 -40 19 20.599909354         14.754 ~ 6 0
149 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56036 RR* 18 01 36.6229159690 -39 50 20.684682230         15.131 ~ 6 0
150 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56063 RR* 18 01 46.8319759649 -40 10 17.713528188         15.251 ~ 5 0
151 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56101 RR* 18 02 01.4818389645 -39 52 09.411211631         14.928 ~ 6 0
152 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56132 RR* 18 02 12.4892113112 -39 47 34.666118928         14.380 ~ 6 0
153 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56238 RR* 18 03 01.3270858054 -40 20 52.228923471         14.857 ~ 6 0
154 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56248 RR* 18 03 05.1055196563 -40 28 03.838031271         15.443 ~ 5 0
155 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56308 RR* 18 03 30.6403487806 -40 46 05.254352694         14.403 ~ 6 0
156 NAME Baade Window reg 18 03.5 -30 01           ~ 643 3
157 VVV J180333.03-394105.2 RR? 18 03 33.0284900854 -39 41 05.250835692           ~ 2 0
158 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56419 RR* 18 04 15.2174778447 -39 45 22.604525818         15.616 ~ 5 0
159 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56431 RR* 18 04 18.7705424646 -39 49 38.337324172         15.441 ~ 6 0
160 V* NW CrA RR* 18 04 43.5126401904 -40 03 43.249268772         14.340 ~ 7 0
161 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56489 RR* 18 04 45.8068166232 -40 12 31.143062304         14.969 ~ 7 0
162 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56492 RR* 18 04 47.3044793726 -40 12 17.899994901         15.141 ~ 6 0
163 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56526 RR* 18 05 06.3944950944 -40 14 14.055308412         14.511 ~ 7 0
164 VVV J180531.65-400424.3 RR? 18 05 31.6362013365 -40 04 24.421790306           ~ 2 0
165 VVV J180606.03-393827.8 EB* 18 06 06.0182590141 -39 38 27.823948431           ~ 3 0
166 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-56655 RR* 18 06 14.1016285120 -35 12 39.440606396         15.250 ~ 6 0
167 VVV J180649.57-315928.9 RR* 18 06 49.5772115472 -31 59 28.770777672           ~ 4 0
168 VVV J180935.02-335151.8 RR* 18 09 35.0035338127 -33 51 51.805689309           ~ 4 0
169 VVV J180951.71-342819.1 RR? 18 09 51.71 -34 28 19.1           ~ 1 0
170 VVV J181017.83-335048.2 RR? 18 10 17.83 -33 50 48.2           ~ 1 0
171 VVV J181022.76-342819.9 RR? 18 10 22.76 -34 28 19.9           ~ 1 0
172 VVV J181058.84-335034.6 RR* 18 10 58.8405639328 -33 50 34.684438466           ~ 3 0
173 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57255 RR* 18 10 59.73 -34 56 17.3         15.454 ~ 4 0
174 VVV J181102.10-345941.2 RR? 18 11 02.0961659484 -34 59 41.120811754           ~ 2 0
175 VVV J181117.24-344747.3 RR? 18 11 17.24 -34 47 47.3           ~ 1 0
176 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57327 RR* 18 11 29.8599850596 -34 59 13.770618938         15.518 ~ 6 0
177 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57398 RR* 18 11 59.60 -34 35 00.0         14.588 ~ 4 0
178 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57459 RR* 18 12 27.5923643640 -34 40 30.977427072     18.679   15.361 ~ 7 0
179 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57478 RR* 18 12 33.1588585025 -34 57 04.863574270     18.416   15.217 ~ 6 0
180 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57494 RR* 18 12 41.9626157472 -35 05 13.647304032         15.002 ~ 5 0
181 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57508 RR* 18 12 46.6536934416 -34 35 49.229092068     20.357   15.715 ~ 7 0
182 VVV J181254.17-342725.3 RR* 18 12 54.1663054056 -34 27 25.157119428           ~ 4 0
183 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57525 RR* 18 12 54.4455962157 -34 14 58.943399490         15.743 ~ 6 0
184 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57540 RR* 18 13 01.4627698272 -34 28 37.888647384         15.181 ~ 7 0
185 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57580 RR* 18 13 20.8519722983 -34 26 28.687260597     19.084   15.711 ~ 6 0
186 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57583 RR* 18 13 23.1951743318 -34 31 15.259809764     19.106   15.120 ~ 5 0
187 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57610 RR* 18 13 38.5028765309 -34 19 11.063914099     18.152   15.150 ~ 6 0
188 VVV J181342.66-342803.1 RR? 18 13 42.66 -34 28 03.1           ~ 1 0
189 VVV J181347.03-350812.9 RR? 18 13 47.0470700431 -35 08 12.908991509           ~ 2 0
190 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57646 RR* 18 13 57.02 -34 34 14.1     19.478   15.367 ~ 4 0
191 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57697 RR* 18 14 17.4687021746 -34 25 07.902429684     17.778   15.265 ~ 6 0
192 V* V1152 Sgr RR* 18 14 36.1132647840 -34 37 18.592538700     20.096   15.306 ~ 6 0
193 VVV J181509.42-341210.4 RR? 18 15 09.4075220913 -34 12 10.348797253           ~ 2 0
194 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57815 RR* 18 15 14.6809903277 -34 17 58.169610495     19.030   15.198 ~ 6 0
195 VVV J181522.12-350716.6 EB* 18 15 22.1247783181 -35 07 16.623275651           ~ 3 0
196 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-57920 RR* 18 16 12.1075199863 -35 12 10.628333951         14.827 ~ 6 0
197 V* V2853 Sgr RR* 18 16 46.8474635332 -35 25 08.417167733         15.384 ~ 9 0
198 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-58165 RR* 18 17 48.87 -34 59 45.4     18.031   15.237 ~ 4 0
199 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-58200 RR* 18 17 59.92 -34 58 05.5     17.136   15.030 ~ 4 0
200 V* V2963 Sgr RR* 18 18 25.0177020024 -34 12 06.811394076         15.673 ~ 10 0
201 VVV J181826.64-344401.2 EB* 18 18 26.6404227419 -34 44 01.296686566           ~ 3 0
202 V* V2981 Sgr RR* 18 18 54.1277349792 -34 13 47.647352532         14.646 ~ 12 0
203 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-58507 RR* 18 19 35.3808093632 -34 48 01.170997784         15.027 ~ 5 0
204 VVV J181945.49-341939.4 RR? 18 19 45.4957089840 -34 19 39.492819516           ~ 2 0
205 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-58673 RR* 18 20 28.2775975064 -34 26 13.145779084         15.269 ~ 5 0
206 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-58726 RR* 18 20 50.3961618809 -35 05 06.073195776         15.411 ~ 6 0
207 VVV J182113.23-344729.2 RR? 18 21 13.2295503170 -34 47 29.245747682           ~ 2 0
208 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-58989 RR* 18 22 01.3098670416 -35 13 45.898690908         14.753 ~ 5 0
209 VVV J183725.74-243751.1 EB* 18 37 25.7462667426 -24 37 51.033968967           ~ 3 0
210 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-64174 RR* 18 37 50.4503450496 -24 18 44.824778100         15.530 ~ 10 0
211 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-64179 RR* 18 37 51.5468042797 -24 29 02.677960239         16.227 ~ 7 0
212 VVV J183827.60-243516.4 RR? 18 38 27.6136077717 -24 35 16.382664104           ~ 2 0
213 ATO J279.9188-24.4865 EB* 18 39 40.5197199516 -24 29 11.551336665   15.642 14.820 14.967   ~ 4 0
214 VVV J183959.38-244738.9 EB* 18 39 59.3840897479 -24 47 38.850177590           ~ 3 0
215 VVV J184000.98-244740.2 RR? 18 40 00.9747967219 -24 47 40.180711199           ~ 2 0
216 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-64844 RR* 18 40 22.7227762224 -23 56 48.173342280         15.771 ~ 9 0
217 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65011 RR* 18 40 56.3153621280 -24 48 19.661272452         15.310 ~ 8 0
218 ATO J280.2508-24.8615 RR* 18 41 00.2121914200 -24 51 41.345312265   16.138 15.342 15.468 14.454 ~ 8 0
219 VVV J184124.06-245403.1 RR? 18 41 24.0623713309 -24 54 03.016649728           ~ 2 0
220 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65139 RR* 18 41 24.5673796489 -24 29 48.999673144         15.884 ~ 6 0
221 ATO J280.3951-25.1089 RR* 18 41 34.8377338824 -25 06 32.209139619   16.625 15.843   15.294 ~ 6 0
222 VVV J184136.04-235324.2 RR? 18 41 36.0219259640 -23 53 24.289801010           ~ 2 0
223 VVV J184149.94-235645.8 RR? 18 41 49.9414539982 -23 56 45.811500365           ~ 2 0
224 VVV J184201.71-242900.8 RR? 18 42 01.71 -24 29 00.9           ~ 1 0
225 VVV J184236.63-241216.9 RR? 18 42 36.6254306737 -24 12 17.033964528           ~ 2 0
226 VVV J184238.41-244132.2 RR? 18 42 38.4123862688 -24 41 32.183803975           ~ 2 0
227 VVV J184302.38-242841.9 RR? 18 43 02.3783999278 -24 28 41.863616620           ~ 2 0
228 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65758 RR* 18 43 52.3137598848 -24 52 46.318563876         15.340 ~ 8 0
229 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65762 RR* 18 43 53.6307961369 -25 17 59.409684279         15.908 ~ 6 0
230 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65792 RR* 18 44 00.2747107392 -25 21 57.721415832         15.614 ~ 11 0
231 VVV J184402.60-243818.9 EB* 18 44 02.6024118447 -24 38 18.922545600           ~ 3 0
232 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65893 RR* 18 44 22.1276412864 -24 30 04.093884576         15.171 ~ 7 0
233 ATO J281.0925-24.1847 RR* 18 44 22.2213694488 -24 11 04.971088212           ~ 5 0
234 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65949 RR* 18 44 39.9469395888 -24 52 16.208321772         14.935 ~ 6 0
235 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-65956 RR* 18 44 41.6953098792 -24 11 20.283385344         15.533 ~ 8 0
236 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-66092 RR* 18 45 20.0714517696 -24 31 50.007902664         14.673 ~ 10 0
237 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-66145 RR* 18 45 36.6752305113 -24 16 12.605907159         15.216 ~ 6 0
238 VVV J184630.34-251453.7 RR? 18 46 30.3421184161 -25 14 53.666260031           ~ 2 0
239 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-66389 RR* 18 46 45.7977898258 -24 31 25.091314962         15.375 ~ 7 0
240 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-66461 RR* 18 47 08.0819579031 -24 25 40.933472683         14.694 ~ 8 0
241 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-66473 RR* 18 47 12.3514249066 -24 48 41.287728623         15.070 ~ 5 0
242 OGLE BLG-RRLYR-66479 RR* 18 47 14.6849897775 -24 50 37.049627144         15.578 ~ 6 0
243 NAME Galactic Bulge reg ~ ~           ~ 4794 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2020A&A...642A..58C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu