2020ApJ...889...32S

Query : 2020ApJ...889...32S

2020ApJ...889...32S - Astrophys. J., 889, 32-32 (2020/January-3)

No significant evolution of relations between black hole mass and galaxy total stellar mass up to z ∼ 2.5.

SUH H., CIVANO F., TRAKHTENBROT B., SHANKAR F., HASINGER G., SANDERS D.B. and ALLEVATO V.

Abstract (from CDS):

We investigate the cosmic evolution of the ratio between black hole (BH) mass (MBH) and host galaxy total stellar mass (Mstellar) out to z ∼ 2.5 for a sample of 100 X-ray-selected moderate-luminosity, broad-line active galactic nuclei (AGNs) in the Chandra-COSMOS Legacy Survey. By taking advantage of the deep multiwavelength photometry and spectroscopy in the COSMOS field, we measure in a uniform way the galaxy total stellar mass using an spectral energy distribution decomposition technique and the BH mass based on broad emission line measurements and single-epoch virial estimates. Our sample of AGN host galaxies has total stellar masses of 1010–12M☉, and BH masses of 107.0–9.5M☉. Combining our sample with the relatively bright AGN samples from the literature, we find no significant evolution of the MBH-Mstellar relation with the BH-to-host total stellar mass ratio of MBH/Mstellar ∼ 0.3% at all redshifts probed. We conclude that the average BH-to-host stellar mass ratio appears to be consistent with the local value within the uncertainties, suggesting a lack of evolution of the MBH-Mstellar relation up to z ∼ 2.5.

Abstract Copyright: © 2020. The American Astronomical Society. All rights reserved.

Journal keyword(s): AGN host galaxies - Active galaxies - Active galactic nuclei - X-ray active galactic nuclei - Galaxy evolution - Black holes

Simbad objects: 101

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 101
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA 		ICRS (J2000)
DEC 		Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026 		#notes
1 COSMOS2015 676685 G 09 57 38.0430761880 +02 19 31.653052320           ~ 8 0
2 COSMOS2015 671978 G 09 57 40.1284043832 +02 19 08.217431724   21.766 21.741     ~ 7 0
3 [VV2006] J095754.7+023832 QSO 09 57 54.7079257440 +02 38 32.777463408   19.558 19.583   19.242 ~ 60 0
4 [VV2006] J095759.5+020436 QSO 09 57 59.5060485192 +02 04 35.973055344 19.41 19.12 19.25   18.989 ~ 61 0
5 [VV2006] J095815.4+014922 QSO 09 58 15.5023015968 +01 49 22.997026416   20.533 20.805   20.34 ~ 65 0
6 ACS-GC 20074261 AGN 09 58 17.871 +02 05 06.26   22.543 22.632   22.11 ~ 24 0
7 [VV2006] J095820.7+020213 QSO 09 58 20.7865815864 +02 02 13.552709172   21.4354 21.2605   21.06 ~ 30 0
8 ACS-GC 20278150 AGN 09 58 25.65 +02 20 30.0   23.502 23.144     ~ 7 0
9 COSMOS2015 634914 AGN 09 58 27.02 +02 15 49.5 25.79 24.12 23.66 23.87 24.11 ~ 9 0
10 ACS-GC 20075758 AGN 09 58 38.40 +01 58 26.9 24.38 24.22 23.54 23.32 22.75 ~ 14 0
11 ACS-GC 20186666 AGN 09 58 41.37 +02 37 28.3   23.7983 23.9924     ~ 8 0
12 [VV2006] J095842.0+015857 QSO 09 58 42.034 +01 58 57.75   21.62 21.17   21.260 ~ 31 0
13 2XMM J095847.7+022629 QSO 09 58 47.700 +02 26 28.35   21.7907 21.4703   21.35 ~ 30 0
14 SDSS J095849.39+022511.1 Sy1 09 58 49.3956143568 +02 25 11.261530632 21.04 21.2564 20.4401   20.57 ~ 37 0
15 SDSS J095850.70+020842.5 AGN 09 58 50.6967691582 +02 08 42.566577385   21.4497 20.7929   20.34 ~ 19 0
16 ACS-GC 20073208 AGN 09 58 56.62 +02 01 39.5   23.7558 23.0849   22.754 ~ 23 0
17 ACS-GC 20126156 AGN 09 58 57.24 +02 26 02.0   22.5516 22.0809   21.959 ~ 22 0
18 ACS-GC 20128566 Sy1 09 58 57.31 +02 21 58.9     24.044   23.160 ~ 21 0
19 ACS-GC 20071143 AGN 09 59 02.02 +02 03 59.9 24.62 24.18 23.30 22.82 21.872 ~ 20 0
20 [VV2006] J095908.6+025424 QSO 09 59 08.6879780160 +02 54 24.035832900   18.759 18.979 18.2   ~ 46 0
21 ACS-GC 20070206 Sy1 09 59 17.45 +02 05 22.8   22.9029 22.3881   22.309 ~ 30 0
22 ACS-GC 20155524 AGN 09 59 26.47 +02 32 41.2   23.3649 23.0609   22.652 ~ 28 0
23 [VV2006] J095928.3+021950 QSO 09 59 28.3315537464 +02 19 50.493467388 21.22 21.0403 20.8343   20.777 ~ 47 0
24 ACS-GC 20125695 AGN 09 59 30.5 +02 26 39         23.347 ~ 11 0
25 COSMOS2015 670364 rG 09 59 31.58 +02 19 05.5 24.79 24.317 24.061     ~ 30 0
26 COSMOS2015 1036595 AGN 09 59 34.81 +02 52 33.1   23.439 23.160     ~ 10 0
27 ACS-GC 20068595 AGN 09 59 34.823 +02 02 49.87   22.5789 22.3133   22.15 ~ 32 0
28 [VV2006] J095940.0+022306 QSO 09 59 40.0605651792 +02 23 06.676861812   20.5731 20.1035   20.162 ~ 49 0
29 SDSS J095943.41+020707.4 QSO 09 59 43.4136711744 +02 07 07.362946992   19.831 19.650   19.472 ~ 44 0
30 ACS-GC 20153879 rG 09 59 49.347 +02 30 07.28 23.596 23.2825 22.6349 22.33 21.891 ~ 33 0
31 ACS-GC 20154544 AGN 09 59 54.45 +02 29 12.0 23.207 23.01 22.6433 22.63 22.46 ~ 16 0
32 COSMOS 1302712 QSO 09 59 58.868 +02 00 23.87   22.8927 22.2822   21.81 ~ 27 0
33 ACS-GC 20122069 Sy1 10 00 01.01 +02 23 21.0   22.8666 22.7629   22.827 ~ 29 0
34 SDSS J100001.06+021413.5 Sy1 10 00 01.064 +02 14 13.56   22.7446 22.2065   21.70 ~ 41 0
35 [VV2006] J100001.5+024844 QSO 10 00 01.4450832264 +02 48 44.657574840   19.468 19.402 18.9   ~ 53 0
36 ACS-GC 20093355 AGN 10 00 02.52 +02 15 21.3 24.014 23.88 23.41 23.38 22.78 ~ 24 0
37 ACS-GC 20040645 AGN 10 00 06.11 +01 52 39.6   23.0744 22.6541   22.719 ~ 30 0
38 COSMOS2015 372362 AGN 10 00 07.45 +01 51 27.3           ~ 11 0
39 [VV2006] J100010.2+023745 QSO 10 00 10.1929960488 +02 37 44.996406168   21.2191 20.744   20.21 ~ 33 0
40 COSMOS2015 604453 AGN 10 00 10.829 +02 13 04.25 23.547 23.28 22.79 22.67 22.46 ~ 19 0
41 [VV2006] J100012.9+023523 QSO 10 00 12.9097049400 +02 35 22.829192268   19.0 19.24 18.5 18.89 ~ 81 0
42 [VV2006] J100013.6+013739 QSO 10 00 13.5462892248 +01 37 38.922920580   20.554 20.584   20.304 ~ 40 0
43 SDSS J100014.91+022718.1 rG 10 00 14.914 +02 27 18.14 21.894 21.624 21.172 21.284 20.836 ~ 36 0
44 ACS-GC 20255441 AGN 10 00 16.61 +02 13 52.8   24.6969 24.1455   23.943 ~ 27 0
45 CANDELS COSMOS F160W J100023.01+021351.2 AGN 10 00 23.01 +02 13 51.3 24.025 23.82 23.44 23.53 23.19 ~ 18 0
46 [VV2006] J100024.5+020619 QSO 10 00 24.4802452008 +02 06 19.669651812   19.43 19.42   19.89 ~ 64 0
47 [VV2006] J100025.2+015851 QSO 10 00 25.2472241232 +01 58 52.087650276   18.71 18.62   18.81 ~ 82 0
48 ACS-GC 20040374 AGN 10 00 25.89 +01 51 41.5 24.53 24.0693 23.55 23.08 22.56 ~ 16 0
49 ACS-GC 20092397 QSO 10 00 26.09 +02 09 25.4         22.860 ~ 25 0
50 NAME COSMOS Field reg 10 00 28.60 +02 12 21.0           ~ 3639 0
51 ACS-GC 20121134 AGN 10 00 31.93 +02 18 11.8   23.984 24.079   23.587 ~ 36 0
52 [VV2006] J100038.0+020822 QSO 10 00 38.0145823704 +02 08 22.399120716   20.698 20.617   20.45 ~ 66 0
53 COSMOS2015 506105 G 10 00 48.38 +02 04 04.6           ~ 8 0
54 ACS-GC 20063271 rG 10 00 55.37 +01 59 55.4 23.353 23.48 23.20 23.27 23.11 ~ 22 0
55 ACS-GC 20060854 rG 10 00 57.2 +02 03 22 24.21 23.96 23.69 23.34 22.77 ~ 19 0
56 [VV2006] J100058.8+015400 QSO 10 00 58.8426061536 +01 54 00.208903968   20.3763 20.1944   20.008 ~ 70 0
57 SDSS J100100.80+015947.6 Sy1 10 01 00.809 +01 59 47.64   22.3313 21.6764   21.833 ~ 36 0
58 ACS-GC 20193411 AGN 10 01 04.98 +02 49 11.7   23.638 23.029   22.576 ~ 11 0
59 COSMOS2015 195004 AGN 10 01 05.98 +01 34 32.8   22.349 22.372     ~ 11 0
60 ACS-GC 20062965 AGN 10 01 06.954 +01 57 34.59   21.963 21.616   20.83 ~ 21 0
61 ACS-GC 20114996 AGN 10 01 09.58 +02 27 17.5   23.803 23.810   22.989 ~ 18 0
62 [VV2006] J100112.6+020939 QSO 10 01 12.6192429024 +02 09 39.869372160   20.4773 20.18   20.199 ~ 34 0
63 ACS-GC 20036381 AGN 10 01 13.50 +01 52 30.5 24.02 24.0847 23.8213 23.76 23.43 ~ 15 0
64 COSMOS2015 495819 AGN 10 01 13.65 +02 03 13.8 24.15 23.84 23.58 23.48 23.09 ~ 14 0
65 SDSS J100115.96+021448.4 QSO 10 01 15.960 +02 14 48.44   22.1163 21.5547   21.49 ~ 35 0
66 ACS-GC 20143757 Sy2 10 01 17.70 +02 33 09.4   24.0342 23.0174   22.599 ~ 24 0
67 ACS-GC 20114445 AGN 10 01 18.91 +02 22 49.9   25.321 25.246   23.967 ~ 20 0
68 COSMOS2015 456984 AGN 10 01 22.74 +01 59 33.4 24.87 24.86 24.40 24.46 23.85 ~ 14 0
69 ACS-GC 20113854 AGN 10 01 23.448 +02 23 27.59 23.91 23.72 23.0175 22.87 22.127 ~ 28 0
70 ACS-GC 20062119 AGN 10 01 25.88 +02 01 29.7         23.027 ~ 19 0
71 SDSS J100129.82+023238.9 Sy1 10 01 29.808 +02 32 39.15   22.462 21.891   20.877 ~ 31 0
72 SDSS J100130.77+021146.8 Sy1 10 01 30.772 +02 11 46.82   22.9582 22.6969   22.264 ~ 34 0
73 [VV2006] J100132.8+015800 QSO 10 01 32.814 +01 57 59.81 21.416 21.458 21.291 21.202 20.966 ~ 37 0
74 ACS-GC 20011782 Sy2 10 01 32.87 +01 38 47.2   23.256 22.569   20.881 ~ 22 0
75 ACS-GC 20083084 AGN 10 01 37.21 +02 16 12.5   22.299 21.575   20.537 ~ 20 0
76 ACS-GC 20142373 Sy1 10 01 39.83 +02 31 32.8   23.2293 23.186   23.055 ~ 31 0
77 SDSS J100140.95+015643.1 QSO 10 01 40.9565658720 +01 56 43.040195376   19.316 19.162   18.640 ~ 44 0
78 SDSS J100141.33+021031.1 Sy1 10 01 41.340 +02 10 31.32   21.4017 20.726   20.541 ~ 36 0
79 ACS-GC 20058793 QSO 10 01 41.42 +02 00 51.1 22.258 22.35 21.6944 22.12 21.807 ~ 34 0
80 2XMM J100143.4+015606 QSO 10 01 43.443 +01 56 06.85   21.5402 21.1378   20.969 ~ 32 0
81 COSMOS2015 1053990 AGN 10 01 47.40 +02 53 57.1   22.426 22.353     ~ 9 0
82 [VV2006] J100147.9+021446 QSO 10 01 47.9050183272 +02 14 47.087964204   20.7508 20.2766   20.485 ~ 35 0
83 [VV2006] J100148.5+020841 QSO 10 01 48.4611 +02 08 41.257   21.1911 20.7349   20.61 ~ 36 0
84 [VV2006] J100151.1+020032 QSO 10 01 51.1119881760 +02 00 32.429882736   20.36 20.05   20.015 ~ 44 0
85 ACS-GC 20168618 AGN 10 01 54.39 +02 42 36.5   22.820 22.703   21.840 ~ 18 0
86 ACS-GC 20084352 Sy1 10 01 56.25 +02 09 43.3   22.4623 22.4187   22.126 ~ 33 0
87 SDSS J100157.57+015205.0 rG 10 01 57.581 +01 52 05.03   21.759 21.766   21.340 ~ 25 0
88 SDSS J100157.78+024631.6 Sy1 10 01 57.7740875016 +02 46 31.663779744   20.7642 20.2364   19.938 ~ 39 0
89 [VV2006] J100158.9+022445 QSO 10 01 58.9156 +02 24 45.101   21.8918 21.4896   21.60 ~ 43 0
90 [VV2006] J100159.5+023935 QSO 10 01 59.4219270984 +02 39 35.658657576   21.102 20.6617   20.43 ~ 36 0
91 [VV2006] J100201.5+020329 QSO 10 02 01.5108351336 +02 03 29.495333844   18.9 19.30 18.8 18.28 ~ 65 0
92 [VV2006] J100202.8+022434 QSO 10 02 02.7744155544 +02 24 34.595331228   20.4499 19.9723 20.11 20.33 ~ 66 0
93 ACS-GC 20111734 AGN 10 02 04.57 +02 19 15.7   23.1725 23.0734   22.633 ~ 20 0
94 SDSS J100208.67+021623.6 AGN 10 02 08.676 +02 16 23.67   22.512 22.060   21.58 ~ 27 0
95 ACS-GC 20000627 rG 10 02 11.27 +01 37 06.6 24.48 24.146 24.188   22.613 ~ 82 0
96 NVSS J100218+015836 rG 10 02 17.973 +01 58 36.18   22.2182 21.8659   21.444 ~ 30 0
97 ACS-GC 20079962 Sy1 10 02 19.647 +02 17 15.71   22.756 22.273   21.29 ~ 37 0
98 [VV2006] J100229.2+020932 QSO 10 02 29.1492366168 +02 09 31.846840056   20.726 20.770   20.298 ~ 26 0
99 SDSS J100230.17+014555.6 AGN 10 02 30.174 +01 45 55.68   21.750 21.934   21.069 ~ 23 0
100 ACS-GC 20164508 AGN 10 02 39.45 +02 45 24.6   22.978 23.187     ~ 6 0
101 2XMM J100243.6+024708 QSO 10 02 43.6980345480 +02 47 07.866747168   19.952 19.992   19.964 ~ 19 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2020ApJ...889...32S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu