2020MNRAS.492.2683B


Query : 2020MNRAS.492.2683B

2020MNRAS.492.2683B - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 492, 2683-2697 (2020/February-3)

Are exoplanetesimals differentiated?

BONSOR A., CARTER P.J., HOLLANDS M., GANSICKE B.T., LEINHARDT Z. and HARRISON J.H.D.

Abstract (from CDS):

Metals observed in the atmospheres of white dwarfs suggest that many have recently accreted planetary bodies. In some cases, the compositions observed suggest the accretion of material dominantly from the core (or the mantle) of a differentiated planetary body. Collisions between differentiated exoplanetesimalrrs produce such fragments. In this work, we take advantage of the large numbers of white dwarfs where at least one siderophile (core-loving) and one lithophile (rock-loving) species have been detected to assess how commonly exoplanetesimals differentiate. We utilize N-body simulations that track the fate of core and mantle material during the collisional evolution of planetary systems to show that most remnants of differentiated planetesimals retain core fractions similar to their parents, while some are extremely core rich or mantle rich. Comparison with the white dwarf data for calcium and iron indicates that the data are consistent with a model in which 66+4–6 per cent have accreted the remnants of differentiated planetesimals, while 31+5–5 per cent have Ca/Fe abundances altered by the effects of heating (although the former can be as high as 100 per cent, if heating is ignored). These conclusions assume pollution by a single body and that collisional evolution retains similar features across diverse planetary systems. These results imply that both collisions and differentiation are key processes in exoplanetary systems. We highlight the need for a larger sample of polluted white dwarfs with precisely determined metal abundances to better understand the process of differentiation in exoplanetary systems.

Abstract Copyright: © 2020 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Royal Astronomical Society

Journal keyword(s): planets and satellites: general - circumstellar matter - planetary systems - white dwarfs

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/MNRAS/492/2683): tablea1.dat>

Simbad objects: 179

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 179
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SDSS J000215.65+320914.1 WD* 00 02 15.6532184904 +32 09 13.922980704           DZ 10 0
2 SDSS J000614.53+052039.0 WD* 00 06 14.4863999088 +05 20 38.795037072           DZ 8 0
3 GALEX J001052.4-043016 WD* 00 10 52.5248531928 -04 30 14.062233204           DZ 9 0
4 SDSS J001949.26+220926.5 WD* 00 19 49.2454913808 +22 09 26.902984392           DZ 9 0
5 LP 349-35 WD* 00 31 24.9083465616 +22 18 23.531181876   17.4   16.7   DA 19 0
6 LSPM J0044+0418 WD* 00 44 51.7053134328 +04 18 20.567585844   19.2   18.6   DZ 16 0
7 SDSS J004634.22+271737.6 WD* 00 46 34.2161748144 +27 17 37.938292188           DZ 8 0
8 SDSS J004757.07+162836.5 WD* 00 47 57.0761146272 +16 28 36.452817480           DZ 6 0
9 SDSS J010825.79-053755.6 WD* 01 08 25.7890462992 -05 37 55.738277472           DZ 8 0
10 SDSS J011421.17+350547.1 WD* 01 14 21.1460170416 +35 05 47.191525260           DZ 7 0
11 SDSS J011646.10+205001.9 WD* 01 16 46.0798611144 +20 50 02.404208472           DZ 17 0
12 GALEX J011759.8+002137 WD* 01 17 59.8102208376 +00 21 38.064524616   19.27 19.06     DZ 15 1
13 KUV 01223-2245 WD* 01 24 44.7360118560 -22 29 06.883173852   17.0       DZ 19 0
14 SDSS J012620.48+253433.6 WD* 01 26 20.3965862016 +25 34 34.081947516           DZ 10 0
15 SDSS J013504.11+130240.4 WD* 01 35 04.1156361336 +13 02 40.436248704           DAZ: 18 0
16 SDSS J014300.52+011356.8 WD* 01 43 00.5240622768 +01 13 56.986794732           DZ 15 0
17 SDSS J014415.12+192021.4 WD* 01 44 15.1251758664 +19 20 21.632824032           DZ 7 0
18 SDSS J014834.00-011235.9 WD* 01 48 33.9957732744 -01 12 35.746818624           DZ 6 0
19 SDSS J015008.55+135433.9 WD* 01 50 08.5553091072 +13 54 33.985712340   20.14 19.87     DZ 12 1
20 LP 884-58 WD* 01 54 05.3395327763 -30 34 32.271212287     17.08     DAZ 21 0
21 SDSS J015849.02-094225.3 WD* 01 58 48.9880712880 -09 42 25.194651192           DZ 7 0
22 SDSS J020128.66+201521.8 WD* 02 01 28.6287253104 +20 15 21.997977588           DZ 8 0
23 SDSS J025206.06-040130.3 WD* 02 52 06.0130686672 -04 01 30.289139976           DZ 9 0
24 SDSS J025253.20+005439.4 WD* 02 52 53.1990610200 +00 54 39.404919600           DZ 10 0
25 GD 40 WD* 03 02 53.1037481136 -01 08 33.798683976   15.479 15.384     DBZ4 187 0
26 GD 61 WD* 04 38 39.3740627256 +41 09 32.353957332 13.801 14.767 14.879 14.932 14.970 DBAZ3 112 0
27 SDSS J044751.21+112403.8 WD* 04 47 51.2085069264 +11 24 03.930138252           DZ 9 0
28 HE 0446-2531 WD* 04 49 01.4020207176 -25 26 36.268538172   16.9   16.5   DBAZ 26 0
29 HE 0449-2554 WD* 04 51 53.7470033760 -25 49 14.732939496 15.88 16.77 16.71     DBAZ 21 0
30 SDSS J051212.78-050503.4 WD* 05 12 12.7889393496 -05 05 03.356572848         16.89 DZ 15 0
31 SDSS J072144.24+392843.5 WD* 07 21 44.2675869816 +39 28 43.664317068           DZ 7 0
32 SDSS J073635.22+411828.2 WD* 07 36 35.2145514768 +41 18 28.680529536           DZ 19 0
33 GALEX J073842.6+183509 WD* 07 38 42.5662133112 +18 35 09.713206464           DBZ 67 0
34 SDSS J074153.45+314620.4 WD* 07 41 53.4241887864 +31 46 20.339459436           DZ 13 0
35 SDSS J074414.66+464912.5 WD* 07 44 14.6432029608 +46 49 12.641796336           DZ 20 0
36 SDSS J074444.03+440845.6 WD* 07 44 44.0342188848 +44 08 45.017669472           DZ 5 0
37 SDSS J074450.24+270132.6 WD* 07 44 50.2376960208 +27 01 32.683198368           DZ 8 0
38 SDSS J074456.22+164042.2 WD* 07 44 56.2117485168 +16 40 42.733031844           DZ 8 0
39 SDSS J080626.70+305555.7 WD* 08 06 26.6999783880 +30 55 55.806215412           DZ 6 0
40 SDSS J080643.94+405837.7 WD* 08 06 43.9497888648 +40 58 38.238726576           DZ 15 0
41 SDSS J081606.19+233030.2 WD* 08 16 06.1997791200 +23 30 30.243818197           DZ 5 0
42 SDSS J081828.12+124717.2 WD* 08 18 28.1214975864 +12 47 16.961494236           DZ 5 0
43 LP 545-12 WD* 08 23 03.8637313800 +05 46 56.424331596   18.3   16.7   DZ 23 0
44 SDSS J083033.66-031911.0 WD* 08 30 33.6316859736 -03 19 10.897519152           DZ 12 0
45 HD 72223 SB* 08 31 01.8370479672 -19 03 16.419734496   10.405 9.754 9.902   G0III 11 0
46 SDSS J083858.56+232252.9 WD* 08 38 58.5536635536 +23 22 52.980646260           DZ 15 0
47 GALEX J084223.2+140616 WD* 08 42 23.1647001432 +14 06 16.591615848           DZ 15 0
48 SDSS J084239.85+153628.8 WD* 08 42 39.8604698928 +15 36 28.864476756           DZ 7 0
49 SDSS J084300.23+561452.8 WD* 08 43 00.2461341984 +56 14 52.565829684           DZ 8 0
50 Ton 345 WD* 08 45 39.1819378488 +22 57 28.251061956   15.2 16.07     DB 89 0
51 WD 0848+159 WD* 08 51 00.2432511768 +15 43 02.045586576   19.7 19.24 18.5   DZ 20 1
52 SDSS J085217.59+340211.3 WD* 08 52 17.6013020040 +34 02 11.259461868           DZ 8 0
53 SDSS J090146.87+075206.8 WD* 09 01 46.8814385184 +07 52 06.851661888           DZ 9 0
54 SDSS J090244.75+100459.7 WD* 09 02 44.7571275936 +10 04 59.742588540           DZ 4 0
55 SDSS J090652.20+114149.9 WD* 09 06 52.2025442568 +11 41 49.783356276           DZ 5 0
56 SDSS J090803.35+513633.1 WD* 09 08 03.3666222144 +51 36 32.927063688           DZ 12 0
57 SDSS J091322.37+262752.0 WD* 09 13 22.3695214080 +26 27 52.216915284           DZ 9 0
58 LP 369-22 WD* 09 16 21.3076471560 +25 40 29.103778164   18.3   17.6   DZ 26 0
59 SDSS J092450.03+430136.4 WD* 09 24 50.0372220000 +43 01 36.445960956           DZ 6 0
60 SDSS J092523.10+313019.0 WD* 09 25 23.1022854984 +31 30 19.600121808           DZ 15 0
61 SDSS J092932.50+424757.9 WD* 09 29 32.4968476488 +42 47 57.853518180           DZ 9 0
62 SDSS J093719.14+522802.3 WD* 09 37 19.1560872984 +52 28 02.329951548           DZ 18 0
63 SDSS J093916.04+413612.9 WD* 09 39 16.0483824600 +41 36 12.856013280           DZ 10 0
64 SDSS J093944.58+501917.7 WD* 09 39 44.5900282344 +50 19 17.772527856           DZ 11 0
65 SDSS J094813.74+300851.2 WD* 09 48 13.7534170464 +30 08 51.390483612           DZ 9 0
66 GALEX J095645.1+591241 WD* 09 56 45.1467202896 +59 12 40.638553884           DZA 32 0
67 SDSS J100609.16+175221.3 WD* 10 06 09.1617223056 +17 52 21.754905240           DZ 8 0
68 SDSS J101711.54+344710.5 WD* 10 17 11.5644061584 +34 47 10.947176052           DZ 9 0
69 SDSS J101750.24+241911.6 WD* 10 17 50.2400565264 +24 19 11.947224360           DZ 7 0
70 PG 1015+161 WD* 10 18 03.8273436048 +15 51 58.566029940   15.596 15.607 16.000   DA2.5 92 0
71 SDSS J101959.51+204553.4 WD* 10 19 59.4976874544 +20 45 53.500371372           DZ 5 0
72 SDSS J102414.83+453109.9 WD* 10 24 14.8373684880 +45 31 09.856666020           DZ 7 0
73 SDSS J103352.89+180935.2 WD* 10 33 52.8619141080 +18 09 35.740824732           DZ 11 0
74 GALEX J103809.1-003622 WD* 10 38 09.1869876816 -00 36 22.450492872   17.3   16.7   DZ 31 0
75 SDSS J103839.01+043223.8 WD* 10 38 39.0118748544 +04 32 23.918381880           DZ 6 0
76 LP 372-53 WD* 10 40 46.5185417784 +24 08 00.171882924   19.7   18.9   DZ 19 0
77 SDSS J104130.65+343240.7 WD* 10 41 30.6390419064 +34 32 40.902636048           DZ 8 0
78 SDSS J104319.84+351641.6 WD* 10 43 19.8692704656 +35 16 42.087943704           DZ 22 0
79 SDSS J105533.73+372542.7 WD* 10 55 33.7446876816 +37 25 43.192942284           DZ 11 0
80 GALEX J105826.7+314359 WD* 10 58 26.6013802896 +31 43 58.450846620           DZ 14 0
81 SDSS J110234.21+021459.2 WD* 11 02 34.2194472288 +02 14 59.255975508           DZ 13 0
82 SDSS J110304.15+414434.9 WD* 11 03 04.1633710728 +41 44 35.052082260           DZ 12 0
83 SDSS J111215.06+070052.4 ** 11 12 15.0620261592 +07 00 52.585190532           DZ+M: 14 0
84 SDSS J113410.85+154245.9 WD* 11 34 10.85784 +15 42 45.9072           DZ 5 0
85 SDSS J114408.05+372007.8 WD* 11 44 08.0534785848 +37 20 07.864788480           DZ 9 0
86 LSPM J1144+1218 WD* 11 44 41.8898659872 +12 18 29.349168912   18.4   17.9   DZ 15 0
87 SDSS J114944.95+051947.7 WD* 11 49 44.9498668920 +05 19 47.698855140           DZ 9 0
88 SDSS J115015.74+492843.7 WD* 11 50 15.7253809128 +49 28 43.594956696           DZ 10 0
89 SDSS J115809.38+184557.3 WD* 11 58 09.4036945752 +18 45 57.486447360           DZ 10 0
90 SDSS J115809.90+594210.0 WD* 11 58 09.8985587736 +59 42 10.022395860           DZ 8 0
91 SDSS J115818.77+045447.5 WD* 11 58 18.7790931960 +04 54 47.534261796           DZ 5 0
92 SDSS J115822.32+471214.9 WD* 11 58 22.3428535920 +47 12 14.967286416           DZ 8 0
93 GALEX J120548.7+353642 WD* 12 05 49.0065960744 +35 36 42.436664460           DZ 7 0
94 SDSS J121106.43+232623.0 WD* 12 11 06.4642207800 +23 26 22.742617884           DZ 7 0
95 SDSS J121731.31+115715.9 WD* 12 17 31.3163711208 +11 57 16.029243072           DZ 10 0
96 SDSS J121837.12+002304.0 WD* 12 18 37.1197328784 +00 23 03.858756756           DZ 16 1
97 SDSS J122035.76+092948.1 WD* 12 20 35.7678458880 +09 29 48.087818520           DZ 6 0
98 SDSS J122437.06+283853.0 WD* 12 24 37.0392481560 +28 38 53.364121548           DZ 13 0
99 PG 1225-079 WD* 12 27 47.3585913504 -08 14 37.972720428   14.86 14.74 15.15   DZA4 85 0
100 GALEX J122859.9+104032 WD* 12 28 59.9341604496 +10 40 33.045988944           DAZe: 152 0
101 SDSS J122943.93+074311.8 WD* 12 29 43.9219055184 +07 43 11.748815436           DZ 10 0
102 SDSS J123024.04+314339.7 WD* 12 30 24.0424410576 +31 43 39.832084524           DZ 9 0
103 GALEX J123415.3+520808 WD* 12 34 15.2001220800 +52 08 08.304344412           DZ 16 0
104 SDSS J123826.93+214937.7 WD* 12 38 26.9488870224 +21 49 38.014858020           DZ 8 0
105 SBSS 1240+527 WD* 12 42 31.0898339136 +52 26 26.609640108   18.2   18.2   DABZ 38 0
106 SDSS J124547.11+082231.4 WD* 12 45 47.1061751400 +08 22 31.693424700           DZ 6 0
107 SDSS J125454.93+355145.7 WD* 12 54 54.9145409184 +35 51 45.772336368           DZ 9 0
108 SDSS J125720.87-031025.1 WD* 12 57 20.8743904512 -03 10 25.146657552           DZ 6 0
109 SDSS J125922.03+311215.2 WD* 12 59 22.0329433032 +31 12 15.589122912           DZ 12 0
110 EGGR 94 WD* 12 59 46.6567450670 +27 34 04.137867253   15.68   15.0   DAZ5.9 80 0
111 SDSS J130328.07+405545.5 WD* 13 03 28.0793071992 +40 55 45.594214032           DZ 12 0
112 SDSS J130830.03+025844.5 WD* 13 08 30.0342555264 +02 58 44.456815596           DZ 8 0
113 SDSS J131612.87+191806.5 WD* 13 16 12.8590920960 +19 18 06.755240448           DZ 8 0
114 SDSS J131900.19+364149.8 WD* 13 19 00.1769801064 +36 41 49.843772376           DZ 9 0
115 SDSS J132941.79+130131.9 WD* 13 29 41.8062381696 +13 01 31.935654912           DZ 8 0
116 G 165-7 WD* 13 30 59.4185829051 +30 29 53.651822645   16.73 16.04 15.74 15.60 DZ7 84 0
117 SDSS J133624.26+354751.2 WD* 13 36 24.2727178272 +35 47 51.702550044           DZ 18 0
118 SDSS J133905.98+264322.9 WD* 13 39 05.9536154040 +26 43 23.044419768           DZ 13 0
119 SDSS J134050.31+270219.0 WD* 13 40 50.3197025496 +27 02 19.193845812           DZ 8 0
120 SDSS J134520.99+115357.6 WD* 13 45 21.0173343672 +11 53 57.384605400           DZ 12 0
121 SDSS J134711.47+141528.0 WD* 13 47 11.4730599480 +14 15 28.127731392           DZ 8 0
122 SDSS J135054.02+105808.0 WD* 13 50 54.0166373400 +10 58 08.229970488           DZ 9 0
123 SDSS J135123.87+264546.5 WD* 13 51 23.8840225680 +26 45 46.529301348           DZ 12 0
124 HE 1350-1612 WD* 13 53 34.9627545960 -16 27 06.231136968   16.2   16.7   DBAZ 24 0
125 SDSS J135632.63+241606.0 WD* 13 56 32.5998388536 +24 16 06.268600452   19.53 19.20     DZ 16 0
126 SDSS J135654.01+023641.5 WD* 13 56 54.0161690616 +02 36 41.514244812           DZ 9 0
127 SDSS J140137.31+365909.9 WD* 14 01 37.3223828928 +36 59 10.113632304           DZ 15 0
128 LSPM J1404+3620 WD* 14 04 10.7652993744 +36 20 57.117681024   19.1   18.6   DZ 20 0
129 SDSS J140525.20+254212.4 WD* 14 05 25.2000351840 +25 42 12.416831424           DZ 5 0
130 SDSS J140557.10+154940.5 WD* 14 05 57.1326322368 +15 49 40.558656288           DZ 14 0
131 SDSS J141140.27+341039.4 WD* 14 11 40.2778222080 +34 10 39.307085436           DZ 9 0
132 SDSS J142120.11+184351.6 WD* 14 21 20.1262293264 +18 43 51.714943068           DZ 10 0
133 G 200-42 WD* 14 28 33.7357493688 +44 03 46.937099268           DZ 33 0
134 SDSS J143007.15-015129.5 WD* 14 30 07.1600327016 -01 51 29.670636348           DZ 14 0
135 SDSS J144535.03+091340.5 WD* 14 45 35.03472 +09 13 40.5048           DZ 5 0
136 SDSS J144804.49+104709.1 WD* 14 48 04.4772014760 +10 47 09.194407944           DZ 17 0
137 SDSS J150228.71+374452.9 WD* 15 02 28.6917956544 +37 44 53.226776868           DZ 11 0
138 SDSS J151835.63+050627.5 WD* 15 18 35.6285365608 +05 06 27.461344176           DZ 13 0
139 SDSS J152449.58+404938.1 WD* 15 24 49.5779469336 +40 49 38.077809024           DZ 14 0
140 G 137-24 WD* 15 35 05.8098944592 +12 47 45.199307508   15.31   15.7   DZ 55 0
141 SBSS 1536+520 WD* 15 37 25.7250808728 +51 51 26.827045956           DBA 42 0
142 SDSS J154201.76+465020.2 WD* 15 42 01.7756226816 +46 50 20.236966116           DZ 8 0
143 SDSS J154510.31+523618.4 WD* 15 45 10.3164483960 +52 36 18.172863108           DZ 10 0
144 SDSS J154625.33+300946.2 WD* 15 46 25.3451203752 +30 09 46.259533512           DZ 12 0
145 SDSS J154913.46+263301.1 WD* 15 49 13.4519189712 +26 33 01.294989804           DZ 9 0
146 GALEX J155429.0+173547 WD* 15 54 29.0040390648 +17 35 46.536316368           DZ 21 0
147 SDSS J160429.80+183035.4 WD* 16 04 29.8118405112 +18 30 35.583372828           DZ 11 0
148 SDSS J161603.00+330301.2 WD* 16 16 03.0095555280 +33 03 01.126782144           DZ 14 0
149 SDSS J162612.73+330308.2 WD* 16 26 12.7439477256 +33 03 08.190792360           DZ 6 0
150 SDSS J162703.34+464658.3 WD* 16 27 03.3428070264 +46 46 58.239037056           DZ 7 0
151 SDSS J163601.33+161907.1 WD* 16 36 01.3510365792 +16 19 07.508230104           DZ 17 0
152 SDSS J164104.95+185602.1 WD* 16 41 04.9424940168 +18 56 01.980253104           DZ 11 0
153 SDSS J164939.23+223807.2 WD* 16 49 39.2254992336 +22 38 07.213794324           DZ 9 0
154 LP 276-33 WD* 16 54 45.6926039157 +38 29 36.628370427   17.1 15.86 16.5   DZA 63 0
155 SDSS J170638.11+254111.8 WD* 17 06 38.1173600160 +25 41 11.757479208           DZ 7 0
156 GD 362 WD* 17 31 34.3168718112 +37 05 20.711767812   16.3   16.4   DAZB 200 0
157 GALEX J193156.8+011745 WD* 19 31 56.9316163968 +01 17 44.107104876     14.20     DAZ 79 1
158 SDSS J210916.51-003921.6 WD* 21 09 16.5114800136 -00 39 21.547759788   20.35 19.98     DZ 10 1
159 LAWD 83 WD* 21 13 16.8549349741 -81 49 12.878285501 13.28 13.82 13.59 13.6   DA4.8 125 0
160 LAWD 84 WD* 21 19 36.5325585235 -55 50 14.465412588 13.94 14.50 14.27 14.5   DA5.1 96 0
161 SDSS J212312.19+001653.5 WD* 21 23 12.1728124944 +00 16 53.428695312           DZ 11 0
162 SDSS J215752.30+120603.1 WD* 21 57 52.3031229984 +12 06 03.248050824           DZ 11 0
163 WT 853 WD* 22 00 45.3745671960 -57 11 23.274992688 15.72 16.26 15.96 15.73 15.49 DAZ 24 0
164 LAWD 91 WD* 22 19 48.3089909755 -65 29 17.484537097 13.98 14.66 14.53     DZ5 61 0
165 G 241-6 WD* 22 23 33.1053008448 +68 37 24.282156972   15.7 15.65 15.7   DB 52 0
166 SDSS J222503.71+233855.1 WD* 22 25 03.6541438776 +23 38 55.900690908           DZ 11 0
167 LSPM J2231+0906 WD* 22 31 01.0518517560 +09 06 36.793727820   19.4   19.3   DZ 17 0
168 SDSS J223507.65-005607.7 WD* 22 35 07.6585394064 -00 56 07.680470640           DZ 8 0
169 SDSS J223811.11+021352.9 WD* 22 38 11.0867063904 +02 13 53.003953992           DZ 5 0
170 SDSS J223815.97-011336.9 WD* 22 38 15.9829722720 -01 13 36.797056068   20.5   19.7   DZ 8 0
171 HS 2253+8023 WD* 22 54 35.7124764456 +80 39 53.794385208   16.02 16.11     DBAZ3.4 47 0
172 SDSS J230414.49+241554.0 WD* 23 04 14.5069999560 +24 15 54.481364568           DZ 14 0
173 SDSS J231937.39+301848.4 WD* 23 19 37.3547640937 +30 18 48.541159634           DZ 6 0
174 V* ZZ Psc WD* 23 28 47.6365087803 +05 14 54.235051503   13.217   13.106   DA4.1 536 0
175 SDSS J233054.31+280517.4 WD* 23 30 54.2781399096 +28 05 17.567908908           DZ 9 0
176 SDSS J234034.61+012416.5 WD* 23 40 34.5547121208 +01 24 16.130350656           DZ 9 0
177 SDSS J234048.74+081753.3 WD* 23 40 48.6799720344 +08 17 53.199812760           DZ 11 0
178 SDSS J235249.12+334439.1 WD* 23 52 49.1357298456 +33 44 39.187957668           DZ 5 0
179 SDSS J235715.01+234849.0 WD* 23 57 15.0570137736 +23 48 48.723198588           DZ 5 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2020MNRAS.492.2683B and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu