2021A&A...655A.117B


Query : 2021A&A...655A.117B

2021A&A...655A.117B - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 655A117-117 (2021/11-1)

Chemical evolution of the Galactic bulge as traced by microlensed dwarf and subgiant stars. VIII. Carbon and oxygen.

BENSBY T., GOULD A., ASPLUND M., FELTZING S., MELENDEZ J., JOHNSON J.A., LUCATELLO S., UDALSKI A. and YEE J.C.

Abstract (from CDS):


Context. Next to H and He, carbon is, together with oxygen, the most abundant element in the Universe and widely used when modelling the formation and evolution of galaxies and their stellar populations. For the Milky Way bulge, there are currently essentially no measurements of carbon in un-evolved stars, hampering our abilities to properly compare Galactic chemical evolution models to observational data for this still enigmatic stellar population.
Aims. We aim to determine carbon abundances for our sample of 91 microlensed dwarf and subgiant stars in the Galactic bulge. Together with new determinations for oxygen this forms the first statistically significant sample of bulge stars that have C and O abundances measured, and for which the C abundances have not been altered by the nuclear burning processes internal to the stars.
Methods. Our analysis is based on high-resolution spectra for a sample of 91 dwarf and subgiant stars that were obtained during microlensing events when the brightnesses of the stars were highly magnified. Carbon abundances were determined through spectral line synthesis of six CI lines around 9100 Å, and oxygen abundances using the three OI lines at about 7770 Å. One-dimensional (1D) MARCS model stellar atmospheres calculated under the assumption of local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) were used, and non-LTE corrections were applied when calculating the synthetic spectra for both C and O.
Results. Carbon abundances was possible to determine for 70 of the 91 stars in the sample and oxygen abundances for 88 of the 91 stars in the sample. The [C/Fe] ratio evolves essentially in lockstep with [Fe/H], centred around solar values at all [Fe/H]. The [O/Fe]-[Fe/H] trend has an appearance very similar to that observed for other α-elements in the bulge, with the exception of a continued decrease in [O/Fe] at super-solar [Fe/H], where other α-elements tend to level out. When dividing the bulge sample into two sub-groups, one younger than 8 Gyr and one older than 8 Gyr, the stars in the two groups follow exactly the elemental abundance trends defined by the solar neighbourhood thin and thick disks, respectively. Comparisons with recent models of Galactic chemical evolution in the [C/O]-[O/H] plane show that the models that best match the data are the ones that have been calculated with the Galactic thin and thick disks in mind.
Conclusions. We conclude that carbon, oxygen, and the combination of the two support the idea that the majority of the stars in the Galactic bulge have a secular origin; that is, they are formed from disk material. We cannot exclude that a fraction of stars in the bulge could be classified as a classical bulge population, but it would have to be small. More dedicated and advanced models of the inner region of the Milky Way are needed to make more detailed comparisons to the observations.

Abstract Copyright: © ESO 2021

Journal keyword(s): gravitational lensing: micro - Galaxy: bulge - Galaxy: formation - Galaxy: evolution - stars: abundances

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/655/A117): table2.dat>

Simbad objects: 93

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 93
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 OGLE-2012-BLG-0270 * 17 14 42.460 -29 35 50.40           ~ 8 0
2 OGLE BLG613.8 68613 * 17 32 49.61 -29 23 10.6           ~ 8 0
3 OGLE-2012-BLG-0026 * 17 34 18.7004610096 -27 08 33.867112596           ~ 55 1
4 OGLE BLG604.24 29952 * 17 43 38.53 -35 05 12.1           ~ 7 0
5 OGLE BLG603.5 113678 * 17 45 00.65 -34 32 49.5           ~ 10 0
6 OGLE BLG660.5 81711 * 17 45 13.37 -33 29 50.4           ~ 6 0
7 NAME Galactic Center reg 17 45 39.60213 -29 00 22.0000           ~ 16269 0
8 OGLE-2013-BLG-1938 * 17 46 01.8824015551 -34 12 31.383610395           ~ 6 0
9 MOA 2009-BLG-456 * 17 48 56.40 -34 13 29.7           ~ 10 0
10 OGLE-2011-BLG-0462 * 17 51 40.150 -29 53 26.15           ~ 41 0
11 MOA 2010-BLG-78 * 17 52 01.650 -30 24 25.63           ~ 8 0
12 OGLE-2013-BLG-1768 * 17 52 26.580 -31 36 43.80           ~ 5 0
13 OGLE BLG503.10 121377 * 17 52 48.18 -35 00 51.4           ~ 7 0
14 OGLE-2013-BLG-0835 * 17 52 59.390 -29 05 57.10           ~ 5 0
15 OGLE-2013-BLG-1125 * 17 53 27.010 -29 47 34.10           ~ 6 0
16 OGLE BLG535.9 35861 * 17 54 02.42 -32 35 31.6           ~ 7 0
17 OGLE-2013-BLG-1793 * 17 54 04.690 -29 38 04.10           ~ 6 0
18 MOA 2006-BUL-99 * 17 54 10.99 -35 13 38.0           G 16 0
19 NAME OGLE 2011-BLG-012N * 17 54 11.320 -30 05 21.56           ~ 7 0
20 MOA 2008-BLG-310 * 17 54 14.53 -34 46 41.0           GV 51 1
21 MOA 2013-BLG-68 * 17 54 21.860 -31 11 39.95           ~ 6 0
22 MOA 2011-BLG-104 * 17 54 22.480 -29 50 01.67           ~ 13 0
23 OGLE-2013-BLG-1114 * 17 54 24.400 -28 56 32.10           ~ 5 0
24 OGLE BLG507.25 76512 * 17 54 48.34 -31 25 57.8           ~ 8 0
25 OGLE-2012-BLG-0617 * 17 54 53.870 -31 08 19.10           ~ 9 0
26 OGLE-2015-BLG-0078 * 17 55 30.690 -27 57 36.50           ~ 6 0
27 MOA 2013-BLG-551 * 17 55 31.980 -29 15 13.80           ~ 13 0
28 OGLE BLG507.14 156979 * 17 55 42.33 -31 53 34.3           ~ 6 0
29 MOA 2009-BLG-493 * 17 55 46.13 -28 48 25.5           ~ 11 0
30 OGLE BLG507.31 100807 * 17 55 59.48 -31 16 35.8           ~ 6 0
31 OGLE-2014-BLG-1469 * 17 56 07.540 -30 57 13.00           ~ 6 0
32 MOA 2010-BLG-285 * 17 56 48.2172216118 -30 00 39.422801495           ~ 10 0
33 OGLE BLG507.13 70237 * 17 56 52.39 -31 46 54.5           ~ 9 0
34 MOA 2008-BLG-311 * 17 56 53.65 -31 23 49.9           ~ 18 0
35 OGLE-2011-BLG-1072 * 17 56 53.940 -28 50 53.31           ~ 8 0
36 MOA 2010-BLG-523 RS* 17 57 08.870 -29 44 58.40           ~ 14 0
37 MOA 2011-BLG-336 * 17 57 16.6312602936 -32 39 57.021314467           ~ 20 0
38 MOA 2011-BLG-174 * 17 57 20.620 -30 22 47.57           ~ 8 0
39 MOA 2012-BLG-22 * 17 57 40.970 -27 29 56.49           ~ 8 0
40 MOA 2009-BLG-489 * 17 57 46.7236172064 -28 38 57.070782024           ~ 11 0
41 MOA 2009-BLG-259 * 17 57 57.51 -29 11 39.4           ~ 10 0
42 OGLE-2007-BUL-514 * 17 58 03.09 -27 31 05.7           ~ 16 0
43 OGLE-2012-BLG-0816 * 17 58 15.980 -29 57 21.45           ~ 7 0
44 OGLE BLG509.28 42093 * 17 58 16.8493504536 -33 46 18.724805940           ~ 7 0
45 OGLE-2009-BLG-076 * 17 58 31.93 -29 12 17.9           ~ 15 0
46 MOA 2012-BLG-532 * 17 58 41.130 -30 02 11.80           ~ 9 0
47 MOA 2013-BLG-605 * 17 58 42.880 -29 23 53.60           ~ 21 0
48 OGLE BLG507.19 119151 * 17 58 56.67 -31 26 31.1           ~ 9 0
49 MOA 2014-BLG-131 * 17 59 02.500 -31 01 54.70           ~ 5 0
50 OGLE-2012-BLG-1156 * 18 00 35.950 -28 11 15.20           ~ 8 0
51 OGLE-2012-BLG-1534 * 18 00 46.350 -28 01 00.30           ~ 8 0
52 MOA 2009-BLG-174 * 18 02 07.70 -31 25 26.4           FV 12 0
53 MOA 2009-BLG-475 * 18 02 27.46 -27 26 49.4           ~ 10 0
54 OGLE BLG516.30 79355 * 18 02 29.58 -33 06 32.0           ~ 6 0
55 MOA 2012-BLG-291 * 18 02 43.080 -28 23 00.86           ~ 9 0
56 MOA 2013-BLG-402 * 18 03 00.140 -29 54 24.42           ~ 6 0
57 MOA 2011-BLG-445 * 18 04 45.630 -28 35 44.06           ~ 7 0
58 OGLE-2008-BUL-209 * 18 04 49.8347028546 -29 42 33.675924320           ~ 15 0
59 OGLE BUL-SC33 164492 * 18 05 05.28 -28 34 41.7           ~ 38 0
60 MOA 2010-BLG-49 * 18 05 07.020 -26 46 12.79           ~ 9 0
61 MOA 2010-BLG-37 * 18 05 17.930 -27 56 13.21           ~ 9 0
62 MOA 2007-BLG-379 ** 18 05 24.43 -26 25 18.8           ~ 58 1
63 OGLE-2013-BLG-1868 * 18 05 35.560 -30 53 06.50           ~ 6 0
64 OGLE-2012-BLG-0521 * 18 05 36.8004591912 -25 45 47.975039460           ~ 9 0
65 OGLE BLG513.17 85619 * 18 05 55.57 -29 40 56.3           ~ 7 0
66 MOA 2012-BLG-288 * 18 05 57.720 -27 42 43.20           ~ 19 0
67 MOA 2009-BLG-133 * 18 06 32.85 -31 30 11.4           ~ 11 0
68 OGLE-2013-BLG-0446 * 18 06 56.180 -31 39 27.20           ~ 8 0
69 OGLE BLG519.14 123254 * 18 07 04.2329670288 -28 03 58.309956360           ~ 10 0
70 OGLE-2006-BUL-265 * 18 07 18.88 -27 47 42.7           G 18 0
71 OGLE BLG519.22 117841 * 18 07 43.23 -27 48 50.1           ~ 6 0
72 OGLE BLG520.13 53669 * 18 08 02.17 -29 28 11.3           ~ 9 0
73 OGLE BLG518.21 8862 * 18 08 39.19 -26 40 44.8           ~ 7 0
74 MOA 2010-BLG-311 * 18 08 49.980 -25 57 04.27           ~ 15 0
75 OGLE BLG518.3 140178 * 18 08 52.98 -27 16 04.1           ~ 7 0
76 OGLE BLG520.11 172127 * 18 09 00.33 -29 14 12.7           ~ 9 0
77 OGLE BLG573.28 60514 * 18 09 41.13 -31 11 04.7           ~ 8 0
78 OGLE-2012-BLG-1526 * 18 09 43.130 -28 48 45.20           ~ 8 0
79 OGLE-2012-BLG-0211 * 18 10 10.960 -25 01 40.20           ~ 9 0
80 MOA 2011-BLG-34 * 18 10 12.2722102032 -27 32 02.595693696           ~ 10 0
81 OGLE BLG519.26 139638 * 18 10 16.85 -27 37 59.0           ~ 9 0
82 MOA 2012-BLG-410 * 18 10 22.620 -25 10 16.83           ~ 8 0
83 OGLE-2013-BLG-1259 * 18 10 23.340 -27 58 45.60           ~ 6 0
84 MOA 2011-BLG-90 * 18 10 29.850 -26 38 43.03           ~ 13 0
85 OGLE BLG518.17 141255 * 18 10 56.7681163598 -26 33 48.039060843           ~ 8 0
86 OGLE BLG545.16 79421 * 18 10 56.92 -25 01 38.3           ~ 7 0
87 OGLE BLG525.25 58563 * 18 11 27.40 -29 41 02.8           ~ 10 0
88 MOA 2012-BLG-202 * 18 12 34.8686940936 -25 02 59.308913076           ~ 8 0
89 MOA 2013-BLG-517 * 18 13 36.420 -27 43 22.83           ~ 5 0
90 OGLE BLG522.11 4130 * 18 14 47.62 -26 24 38.9           ~ 7 0
91 OGLE BLG523.18 72530 * 18 16 06.6574651761 -27 11 06.007727775           ~ 7 0
92 OGLE BLG529.24 95835 * 18 16 53.61 -25 31 31.0           ~ 7 0
93 NAME Galactic Bulge reg ~ ~           ~ 4794 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2021A&A...655A.117B and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu