2021ApJ...922..155M


Query : 2021ApJ...922..155M

2021ApJ...922..155M - Astrophys. J., 922, 155-155 (2021/December-1)

A sample of massive black holes in dwarf galaxies detected via [Fe x] coronal line emission: active galactic nuclei and/or tidal disruption events.

MOLINA M., REINES A.E., LATIMER C.J., BALDASSARE V. and SALEHIRAD S.

Abstract (from CDS):

The massive black hole (BH) population in dwarf galaxies (MBH <= 105 M☉) can provide strong constraints on the origin of BH seeds. However, traditional optical searches for active galactic nuclei (AGNs) only reliably detect high-accretion, relatively high-mass BHs in dwarf galaxies with low amounts of star formation, leaving a large portion of the overall BH population in dwarf galaxies relatively unexplored. Here, we present a sample of 81 dwarf galaxies (M* <= 3 x 109 M☉) with detectable [Fe X]λ6374 coronal line emission indicative of accretion onto massive BHs, only two of which were previously identified as optical AGNs. We analyze optical spectroscopy from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey and find [Fe X]λ6374 luminosities in the range L_[Fe x]_ ≃ 1036-1039 erg s–1, with a median value of 1.6 x 1038 erg s–1. The [Fe X]λ6374 luminosities are generally much too high to be produced by stellar sources, including luminous Type IIn supernovae (SNe). Moreover, based on known SNe rates, we expect at most eight Type IIn SNe in our sample. That said, the [Fe X]λ6374 luminosities are consistent with accretion onto massive BHs from AGNs or tidal disruption events (TDEs). We find additional indicators of BH accretion in some cases using other emission line diagnostics, optical variability, and X-ray and radio emission (or some combination of these). However, many of the galaxies in our sample only have evidence for a massive BH based on their [Fe X]λ6374 luminosities. This work highlights the power of coronal line emission to find BHs in dwarf galaxies missed by other selection techniques and to probe the BH population in bluer, lower-mass dwarf galaxies.

Abstract Copyright: © 2021. The American Astronomical Society. All rights reserved.

Journal keyword(s): Black holes - Active galaxies - Active galactic nuclei - Low-luminosity active galactic nuclei - Dwarf galaxies - Tidal disruption

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/922/155): table1.dat table2.dat table3.dat>

Nomenclature: Table 6: [MRL2021] NNNNNN-XN N=9.

Simbad objects: 89

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 89
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SHOC 22 H2G 00 32 18.6280200984 +15 00 14.108425020           ~ 20 0
2 LEDA 983014 AG? 00 36 35.84932 -10 03 03.6757   16.14   15.39   ~ 8 0
3 LEDA 969419 AG? 00 51 22.551 -11 08 43.11           ~ 4 0
4 V* V723 Cas No* 01 05 05.3607320352 +54 00 40.238720388   15.817 15.484 15.044   ~ 216 0
5 2SLAQ J011745.30-011032.0 H2G 01 17 45.306 -01 10 32.15           ~ 5 0
6 SDSS J030903.88+003846.7 H2G 03 09 03.87650 +00 38 46.8457           ~ 3 0
7 [VV2003c] J030915.8-005657 Sy1 03 09 15.75499 -00 56 56.4712     19.33     ~ 3 0
8 SDSS J031618.15+010021.9 G 03 16 18.15640 +01 00 21.9299           ~ 3 0
9 SDSS J033027.28-005113.5 G 03 30 27.289 -00 51 13.56           ~ 3 0
10 SDSS J033549.23-003913.1 G 03 35 49.236 -00 39 13.14           ~ 4 0
11 SDSS J033553.12-003946.6 G 03 35 53.12366 -00 39 46.6225           ~ 4 0
12 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 19090 0
13 V* V574 Pup No* 07 41 53.5879413696 -27 06 37.894596372   18.2 17.9     ~ 55 0
14 SDSS J075204.19+424524.2 G 07 52 04.19116 +42 45 24.1674           ~ 3 0
15 SDSS J081329.70+544441.2 G 08 13 29.708 +54 44 41.26           ~ 3 0
16 SDSS J082212.87+580141.9 AG? 08 22 12.87354 +58 01 41.9542           ~ 2 0
17 LEDA 4009125 G 08 24 49.86121 +38 35 14.5649           ~ 2 0
18 LEDA 3448969 AG? 08 30 25.5335306184 +33 03 29.364783660           ~ 5 0
19 SDSS J083908.64+331830.8 G 08 39 08.6835690120 +33 18 30.813918948           ~ 3 0
20 SHOC 222 Sy1 08 45 27.609 +53 08 52.89     18.02     ~ 13 0
21 LEDA 3997145 G 08 54 43.392 +08 56 52.68           ~ 6 0
22 SDSS J090813.65+264203.0 G 09 08 13.6243019208 +26 42 03.253973364           ~ 4 0
23 LEDA 3454857 G 09 09 35.620 +45 57 19.02           ~ 5 0
24 SDSS J091521.04+122615.1 G 09 15 21.04202 +12 26 15.1066           ~ 4 0
25 SDSS J091938.46+193528.2 G 09 19 38.4559296216 +19 35 28.272833844           ~ 5 0
26 SDSS J092025.82+504939.5 G 09 20 25.82838 +50 49 39.5215           ~ 4 0
27 SN 2005ip SN* 09 32 06.42 +08 26 44.4 18.1 18.7 18.5     SNIIn 230 1
28 Z 7-25 Sy1 09 44 01.8742171440 -00 38 31.993352700   15.5       ~ 89 0
29 Mrk 709S G 09 49 18.0547846840 +16 52 44.116102185           ~ 7 0
30 Z 94-75 H2G 10 29 49.27907 +16 10 51.2213   15.2       ~ 26 0
31 LEDA 1687001 G 10 31 49.708 +23 25 02.65           ~ 5 0
32 Z 65-86 GiG 10 42 00.368 +12 20 05.73   15.85       ~ 28 0
33 LEDA 1364508 EmG 10 45 20.4012426816 +09 23 49.052251248           ~ 16 0
34 LEDA 92920 G 10 49 19.292 +37 52 34.46   16.70       ~ 7 0
35 SDSS J104926.81+421451.3 G 10 49 26.82047 +42 14 51.4115           ~ 2 0
36 SDSS J105544.62+462218.3 G 10 55 44.62379 +46 22 18.3366           ~ 3 0
37 [BKD2008] WR 276 PoG 11 05 08.112 +44 44 47.11           ~ 12 0
38 SDSS J110943.10+253800.1 G 11 09 43.10956 +25 38 00.1126           ~ 4 0
39 SDSS J111608.54+302233.0 G 11 16 08.54819 +30 22 32.9767           ~ 4 0
40 SDSS J113449.15-010347.7 G 11 34 49.1611085184 -01 03 47.838358764   18.418   17.663   ~ 6 0
41 [VV2003c] J114306.5+680717 Sy1 11 43 06.5480380176 +68 07 17.770070712     18.13     ~ 7 0
42 SDSS J114430.37+323405.4 G 11 44 30.37230 +32 34 05.3725           ~ 7 0
43 LEDA 3345323 G 11 51 17.617 +67 18 44.32           ~ 4 0
44 LEDA 1721675 G 11 54 16.8534168096 +24 58 21.833847084           ~ 9 0
45 LEDA 4307695 G 12 02 13.383 +06 16 59.20           ~ 5 0
46 LEDA 3476254 G 12 02 52.692 +10 14 34.71           ~ 4 0
47 FIRST J122011.2+302008 rG 12 20 11.2617289800 +30 20 08.250271270           ~ 11 0
48 SDSS J122058.34+562118.6 G 12 20 58.3536403800 +56 21 18.574654752           ~ 4 0
49 SDSS J122311.99+375927.8 AG? 12 23 11.989 +37 59 27.84           ~ 4 0
50 2MASX J12234282+5814459 Sy1 12 23 42.8115876144 +58 14 46.104372420   18.10 17.24     ~ 50 0
51 SDSS J123909.53+080822.2 G 12 39 09.53487 +08 08 22.2902           ~ 3 0
52 IC 3723 H2G 12 44 30.5678834088 +40 44 12.864711048   15.5       ~ 22 0
53 SDSS J124732.81+133705.2 G 12 47 32.8108613328 +13 37 05.305986588           ~ 3 0
54 SDSS J124841.10+383431.9 G 12 48 41.10352 +38 34 31.9852           ~ 3 0
55 MCG+07-27-042 AG? 13 12 06.31848 +39 09 27.8244   16       ~ 7 0
56 LEDA 2275350 G 13 13 07.115 +46 05 54.36           ~ 6 0
57 Ton 151 AGN 13 16 03.915 +29 22 54.05   16.71 16.35     ~ 79 0
58 2dFGRS TGN195Z089 GiP 13 16 47.183 -03 02 57.73   16.971   16.219   ~ 4 1
59 LEDA 1185126 G 13 17 56.49604 +01 07 07.0240           ~ 6 0
60 LEDA 2088323 G 13 26 19.60698 +36 51 45.5520           ~ 5 0
61 SDSS J132753.77+553842.5 G 13 27 53.7878255304 +55 38 42.425427048           ~ 3 0
62 LEDA 1513807 G 13 30 11.69382 +16 39 11.7518           ~ 4 0
63 SDSS J133400.52+364200.1 EmG 13 34 00.52550 +36 42 00.1312   18.00       ~ 3 0
64 LEDA 101497 EmG 13 38 57.08174 +36 35 45.0091   17.8       ~ 8 0
65 LEDA 1545211 G 13 46 15.169 +17 54 58.54           ~ 8 0
66 Z 218-64 H2G 13 51 25.3760186496 +40 12 47.734846344   15.4   13.83   ~ 32 0
67 LEDA 1486281 G 13 54 47.37484 +15 30 04.1975           ~ 4 0
68 [VV2003c] J140655.5+655456 Sy1 14 06 55.4735554440 +65 54 56.643206760     18.14     ~ 5 0
69 LEDA 2080090 G 14 15 26.84174 +36 24 29.7363           ~ 4 0
70 SDSS J141623.30+330724.9 G 14 16 23.2999660224 +33 07 24.965318064           ~ 4 0
71 LEDA 1772644 G 14 24 37.21618 +26 20 39.0847           ~ 4 0
72 LEDA 4416958 G 14 27 01.9636235304 +28 15 34.111108440           ~ 6 0
73 SDSS J145801.77+261330.0 G 14 58 01.77071 +26 13 29.9678           ~ 3 0
74 SHOC 496a HII 15 03 55.6509734568 +00 25 55.592513364           ~ 3 0
75 2SLAQ J150356.82-004200.3 Sy1 15 03 56.8246781112 -00 42 00.366653592     19.39     ~ 5 0
76 LEDA 2390249 AG? 15 18 44.774 +51 12 27.84   16.0       ~ 11 0
77 SDSS J152007.01+375953.5 G 15 20 07.01648 +37 59 53.5942           ~ 3 0
78 LEDA 1539333 G 15 25 51.92066 +17 42 02.0052           ~ 4 0
79 SDSS J153704.18+551550.5 H2G 15 37 04.1703489192 +55 15 50.657550372           ~ 7 0
80 LEDA 4480075 G 15 50 52.733 +15 43 51.60           ~ 7 0
81 SDSS J162152.57+151856.0 EmG 16 21 52.5734987136 +15 18 55.985040684           ~ 10 0
82 LEDA 1505933 AG? 16 26 16.953 +16 19 12.42           ~ 9 0
83 SDSS J165546.84+364047.5 G 16 55 46.8489041232 +36 40 47.465370084           ~ 3 0
84 PNV J17422408-2053088 No* 17 42 24.11 -20 53 08.6           ~ 10 0
85 V* V3890 Sgr No* 18 30 43.2877623168 -24 01 08.944843980     15.944 14.798 12.611 M5III 232 0
86 V* V1974 Cyg No* 20 30 31.6546001712 +52 37 50.837478240           ~ 597 0
87 SDSS J205655.65-002427.2 G 20 56 55.66262 -00 24 27.2842           ~ 1 0
88 SDSS J210709.14-072522.3 G 21 07 09.1454767392 -07 25 22.169217000           ~ 3 0
89 SDSS J225236.35-003317.7 G 22 52 36.350 -00 33 17.78           ~ 6 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2021ApJ...922..155M and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu