2021MNRAS.506.4389G


Query : 2021MNRAS.506.4389G

2021MNRAS.506.4389G - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 506, 4389-4412 (2021/September-3)

A consistent and robust measurement of the thermal state of the IGM at 2 <= z <= 4 from a large sample of Ly α forest spectra: evidence for late and rapid He II reionization.

GAIKWAD P., SRIANAND R., HAEHNELT M.G. and CHOUDHURY T.R.

Abstract (from CDS):

We characterize the thermal state of the intergalactic medium (IGM) in 10 redshift bins in the range 2 <= z <= 4 with a sample of 103 high-resolution, high S/N Ly α forest spectra using four different flux distribution statistics. Our measurements are calibrated with mock spectra from a large suite of hydrodynamical simulations post-processed with our thermal IGM evolution code CITE, finely sampling amplitude, and slope of the expected temperature-density relation. The thermal parameters inferred from our measurements of the flux power spectrum, Doppler parameter distribution, as well as wavelet and curvature statistics agree well within their respective errors and all clearly show the peak in temperature and minimum in slope of the temperature density relation expected from He II reionization. Combining our measurements from the different flux statistics gives T0 = (14 750 ± 1322) K for the peak temperature at mean density and a corresponding minimum slope γ = 1.225 ± 0.120. The peak in the temperature evolution occurs around z ≃ 3, in agreement with previous measurements that had suggested the presence of such a peak, albeit with a large scatter. Using CITE, we also calculate the thermal state of the IGM predicted by five widely used (spatially homogeneous) UV-background models. The rather rapid thermal evolution inferred by our measurements is well reproduced by two of the models, if we assume (physically well motivated) non-equilibrium evolution with photoheating rates that are reduced by a moderate factor of ∼0.7-0.8. The other three models predict He II reionization to be more extended with a higher temperature peak occurring somewhat earlier than our measurements suggest.

Abstract Copyright: © The Author(s) 2021. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): methods: numerical - intergalactic medium - quasars: absorption lines - large-scale structure of Universe

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/MNRAS/506/4389): tableqso.dat tablefps.dat tablews.dat tablecs.dat tableb.dat>

Simbad objects: 104

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 104
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 LBQS 2359-0216B QSO 00 01 49.9509602856 -01 59 39.455306448   18 18.0     ~ 112 0
2 6C 001403+811827 BLL 00 17 08.47489694 +81 35 08.1365094   17.60 16.52 15.95   ~ 405 1
3 LBQS 0018-0220 QSO 00 21 27.3594469824 -02 03 33.553165068   17.48 17.10     ~ 36 0
4 [VV2006] J002830.5-281706 QSO 00 28 30.4642386648 -28 17 05.238885732     18.01     ~ 27 0
5 LBQS 0027+0149 QSO 00 29 52.1116445568 +02 06 06.197335020   17 18.9     ~ 50 0
6 QSO J0035-0918 QSO 00 35 01.8852012984 -09 18 17.640206928   19.32 19.12     ~ 60 0
7 LBQS 0041-2707 QSO 00 43 51.8592434352 -26 51 28.169761500     17.83 17.9   ~ 36 0
8 LBQS 0041-2607 QSO 00 43 58.8119675424 -25 51 15.417967500   17.5 17.40 17.1   ~ 31 0
9 LBQS 0042-2627 QSO 00 44 33.9605081160 -26 11 19.711610520     17.67 18.5   ~ 54 0
10 [VV2000] J004448.3+372114 QSO 00 44 48.3191224200 +37 21 14.678927640   17.6       ~ 11 0
11 QSO B0043-265 QSO 00 45 30.4831607856 -26 17 08.979328536   18.62 17.87 18.3   ~ 22 0
12 PHL 868 QSO 00 52 02.4056270064 +01 01 29.270570160   17.87 17.67     ~ 116 0
13 [VV2006] J005700.2+143738 QSO 00 57 00.1917547800 +14 37 37.787199636   18.28 17.96     ~ 32 0
14 LBQS 0105-2649 QSO 01 07 41.9261254560 -26 33 28.414578528     17.7     ~ 16 0
15 QSO B0130-403 QSO 01 33 01.9294067496 -40 06 27.997379496   17.68 17.02     ~ 89 0
16 QSO J0134+3307 QSO 01 34 21.4863198144 +33 07 56.378382420     18.80     ~ 37 0
17 QSO B0142-100 QSO 01 45 16.5958283760 -09 45 17.265131352   17.23 16.95     ~ 247 1
18 UM 675 BLL 01 52 27.3261958536 -20 01 07.045348584     17.4     ~ 99 0
19 6C 014940+333547 QSO 01 52 34.5766588080 +33 50 33.159720264   18.5 18.5     ~ 134 1
20 QSO J0157-0106 QSO 01 57 41.5697767176 -01 06 29.648080260   19.40 18.71     ~ 49 0
21 QSO B0201+113 Bla 02 03 46.65705710 +11 34 45.4094619   19.5 19.5 19.41   ~ 216 1
22 QSO J0225+0054 QSO 02 25 54.8563961016 +00 54 51.953062608   19.18 18.92     ~ 42 0
23 [VV2006] J023359.7+004938 QSO 02 33 59.7210123312 +00 49 38.473525236   17.98 17.80     ~ 40 0
24 [VV2006] J023924.5-090138 QSO 02 39 24.4848492648 -09 01 38.667280584   18.22 17.99     ~ 29 0
25 QSO B0237-2322 QSO 02 40 08.1743783856 -23 09 15.729012036   16.78 16.63     ~ 516 1
26 QSO B0241-01 QSO 02 44 01.8451874040 -01 34 03.848758680     18.20     ~ 65 0
27 QSO J0248+1802 QSO 02 48 54.2720204400 +18 02 49.274967876     18.4     ~ 49 0
28 QSO B0248+3402 QSO 02 51 27.7403607984 +34 14 41.852477256   17.7       ~ 11 0
29 PB 6929 QSO 02 55 15.2058379392 +01 48 28.684266840   18.23 18.07     ~ 39 0
30 PB 6940 QSO 02 56 44.6911855488 +00 12 46.046020716   18.31 18.10     ~ 68 0
31 LBQS 0256-0000 QSO 02 59 05.6356015320 +00 11 21.964472340   18.50 18.11     ~ 137 0
32 US 3509 QSO 03 00 46.0256922912 +02 22 45.160207716   18.0 17.70     ~ 30 0
33 LBQS 0302-0019 QSO 03 04 49.8593341368 -00 08 13.534398816   18.08 17.80 17.5   ~ 261 0
34 LBQS 0307-0058 QSO 03 10 03.0134952144 -00 46 45.731656632   18.44 18.24     ~ 43 0
35 QSO J0324-3203 QSO 03 24 12.4531164024 -32 02 59.782195860     17.95     ~ 11 0
36 [VV2006] J040241.5-064137 QSO 04 02 41.4340099272 -06 41 37.990576824   18.32 18.12     ~ 26 0
37 QSO J0427-1303 QSO 04 27 07.3053460464 -13 02 53.708724168     17.50     ~ 160 1
38 KODIAQ J043038-133546 QSO 04 30 38.80 -13 35 46.0           ~ 3 0
39 QSO B0449-135 QSO 04 51 42.7191531552 -13 20 46.950207288   18.9 17.0     ~ 57 2
40 QSO B0449-1645 QSO 04 52 14.2529886192 -16 40 16.386415284   18.0 17.0 17.8   ~ 48 1
41 4C -02.19 Bla 05 01 12.80988538 -01 59 14.2564557   19.1 18.06 19.04   ~ 624 1
42 7C 064253.00+445430.00 Bla 06 46 32.02599653 +44 51 16.5901185   19.57 18.49 18.64   ~ 370 1
43 [VV2006] J073149.5+285449 QSO 07 31 49.5082094184 +28 54 48.775769640   20.17 19.21     ~ 35 0
44 QSO J0747+2739 QSO 07 47 11.1466907592 +27 39 03.365989812     17.20     ~ 74 0
45 SDSS J082849.15+085854.8 QSO 08 28 49.1589199440 +08 58 54.865896024   18.88 18.68     ~ 21 0
46 QSO J0831+3358 QSO 08 31 02.5681902336 +33 58 03.088763328   19.20 19.00     ~ 44 0
47 QSO J0831+5245 QSO 08 31 41.7108197808 +52 45 17.616994560   19.2   14.5 13.9 ~ 574 1
48 2MASS J09364349+2927138 QSO 09 36 43.5086372448 +29 27 13.663601172   18.53 18.39     ~ 38 0
49 QSO B0933+733 QSO 09 37 48.8931145824 +73 01 58.080158076     17.3     ~ 60 0
50 QSO J0958+1202 QSO 09 58 52.1994218616 +12 02 45.038331528   18.24 17.91     ~ 129 0
51 QSO B1015-205 QSO 10 17 23.98 -20 46 58.6   17.08 17.08     ~ 71 2
52 QSO J1019+5246 QSO 10 19 39.1675648704 +52 46 27.866425152   18.39 18.14     ~ 39 0
53 4C 10.29 QSO 10 20 09.9945425592 +10 40 02.694508932   18.74 18.35     ~ 108 1
54 QSO B1031+0414 QSO 10 34 56.3122729872 +03 58 59.378287224   18.79 18.25     ~ 43 0
55 QSO J1057+4555 QSO 10 57 56.2610108784 +45 55 53.070401748   20.19 18.80 17.2 16.8 ~ 118 0
56 QSO B1103+6416 QSO 11 06 10.7339248800 +64 00 09.644901192   16.36 16.16     ~ 76 0
57 QSO B1107+4847 QSO 11 10 38.6370859200 +48 31 15.691679076   17.09 16.87     ~ 94 0
58 QSO B1122-168 QSO 11 24 42.8658917592 -17 05 17.389038732   16.5 16.5 16.1   ~ 132 1
59 QSO J1134+5742 QSO 11 34 18.9637439016 +57 42 04.726160208   19.62 18.99     ~ 45 0
60 QSO J1143+3452 QSO 11 43 08.8809241248 +34 52 22.233156204   17.43 17.15     ~ 49 0
61 QSO B1157+3143 QSO 12 00 06.2491993344 +31 26 30.837671952   16.76 16.47     ~ 72 0
62 QSO B1159+123 QSO 12 01 47.9118521640 +12 06 30.253926276   18.85 18.16     ~ 108 0
63 [VV2006] J120416.7+022110 QSO 12 04 16.6906519584 +02 21 10.973201292   19.42 19.23     ~ 43 0
64 LBQS 1210+1731 QSO 12 13 03.0135468360 +17 14 23.237180160   18.21 18.03     ~ 91 0
65 QSO B1217+4957 QSO 12 19 30.7755423144 +49 40 52.196980584   17.50 17.21     ~ 60 0
66 Ton 618 Bla 12 28 24.9659725464 +31 28 37.628987592   16.15 15.87 15.35   ~ 294 1
67 [VV2006] J123749.0+012607 QSO 12 37 48.9947454288 +01 26 06.929768364   19.51 19.18     ~ 42 0
68 QSO B1243+3047 QSO 12 46 10.800 +30 31 17.00     17.00     ~ 44 0
69 PB 3273 QSO 13 04 11.9899066632 +29 53 48.879479652   18 17.85     ~ 21 0
70 QSO J1310+4601 QSO 13 10 11.6048502288 +46 01 24.457661076   17.08 16.91     ~ 53 0
71 QSO B1310+4254A QSO 13 12 15.2351758152 +42 39 00.885750948   18.93 18.73   17.97 ~ 57 0
72 [VV2006] J131855.8+531207 QSO 13 18 55.7506719456 +53 12 07.211049084   18.59 18.31     ~ 36 0
73 QSO B1337+11 QSO 13 40 02.5419344664 +11 06 30.181521168     18.7     ~ 120 0
74 2MASS J13503888-2512167 QSO 13 50 38.8793407584 -25 12 16.854820164           ~ 15 0
75 QSO B1422+2309 BLL 14 24 38.0938 +22 56 00.587   16.77 15.84 14.79   ~ 464 1
76 QSO J1439+2954 QSO 14 39 12.3385727616 +29 54 48.054291876   18.13 17.91     ~ 36 0
77 QSO B1445+101 Bla 14 45 16.46525080 +09 58 36.0727447   18.58 17.78     ~ 408 2
78 QSO J1521+5202 QSO 15 21 56.4821480376 +52 02 38.598049752   16.02 15.70     ~ 64 0
79 QSO J1551+1911 QSO 15 51 52.4688797112 +19 11 04.014875400           ~ 66 0
80 QSO B1554+3749 QSO 15 56 10.6481701008 +37 40 39.614881044   18.20 17.91     ~ 14 0
81 7C 1602+5739 Bla 16 03 55.9315808928 +57 30 54.414349524     18.3 16.94   ~ 100 1
82 QSO J1604+3951 QSO 16 04 13.9798326192 +39 51 21.887640756   19.34 18.67     ~ 50 0
83 2MASS J16084390+0715087 QSO 16 08 43.9038779112 +07 15 08.641060344   17.29 17.01     ~ 36 0
84 QSO B1623+268A QSO 16 25 48.0865431168 +26 44 32.575702092   18.59 18.41     ~ 89 0
85 QSO B1623+269 QSO 16 25 48.7980918960 +26 46 58.784527056   17.77 17.64     ~ 109 0
86 QSO J1626+6426 QSO 16 26 45.6720635616 +64 26 55.026430800     15.8     ~ 34 0
87 QSO J1634+3203 BLL 16 34 12.7898408784 +32 03 35.425991844   17.92 17.71     ~ 67 1
88 QSO J1646+5514 QSO 16 46 56.3884451808 +55 14 46.123613484     18.10     ~ 32 0
89 HS 1700+6416 QSO 17 01 00.6194059368 +64 12 09.118892376   16.39 16.17     ~ 382 0
90 [VV2006] J173352.2+540030 QSO 17 33 52.2311709504 +54 00 30.514515120   18.07 17.60     ~ 61 0
91 QSO B2038-0116 QSO 20 40 51.4819834296 -01 05 38.590047780     19.2     ~ 28 0
92 SDSS J212329.46-005052.9 QSO 21 23 29.4639412848 -00 50 52.916363736   16.91 16.62     ~ 131 0
93 QSO J2129-1602 QSO 21 29 04.9442732328 -16 02 49.160080140       19.2   ~ 7 0
94 QSO B2126-15 Bla 21 29 12.17589329 -15 38 41.0419083   17.61 17.3 17.3   ~ 521 1
95 QSO J2215-2944 BLL 22 15 16.0346800104 -29 44 23.328587400   17.58 17.44 16.9   ~ 81 1
96 QSO J2222-0946 QSO 22 22 56.1132566016 -09 46 36.283906272   18.71 18.34     ~ 81 0
97 LBQS 2230-0015 QSO 22 34 08.9971751592 +00 00 01.703853180   18.09 17.39 17.3   ~ 142 0
98 KODIAQ J223627+135714 QSO 22 36 27.0824133456 +13 57 14.024012004   19.04 18.73     ~ 71 0
99 QSO B2237-0607 QSO 22 39 53.6812264896 -05 52 19.996061772     18.3     ~ 120 0
100 4C 24.61 QSO 22 54 09.34189937 +24 45 23.4229729     17.8     ~ 149 1
101 KODIAQ J230301-093930 QSO 23 03 01.4579957256 -09 39 30.654165780   18.64 18.12     ~ 41 0
102 KODIAQ J231324+003444 QSO 23 13 24.4542611808 +00 34 44.583853800   17.05 16.59     ~ 49 0
103 [VV2006] J233823.2+150445 BLL 23 38 23.1627715704 +15 04 45.278298876   17.92 17.74     ~ 43 0
104 QSO B2344+125 QSO 23 46 32.80 +12 45 40.0     17.0     ~ 88 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2021MNRAS.506.4389G and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu