2022A&A...663L...7S


Query : 2022A&A...663L...7S

2022A&A...663L...7S - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 663L7-7 (2022/7-1)

Quasars as high-redshift standard candles.

SACCHI A., RISALITI G., SIGNORINI M., LUSSO E., NARDINI E., BARGIACCHI G., BISOGNI S., CIVANO F., ELVIS M., FABBIANO G., GILLI R., TREFOLONI B. and VIGNALI C.

Abstract (from CDS):

The non-linear relation between the X-ray and ultraviolet (UV) luminosity in quasars has been used to derive quasar distances and to build a Hubble diagram at redshifts up to z ∼ 7. This cosmological application is based on the assumption of independence of the relation on redshift and luminosity. We want to test the reliability of this hypothesis by studying the spectroscopic properties of high-redshift quasars in the X-ray and UV bands. We performed a one-by-one analysis of a sample of 130 quasars at z > 2.5 with high-quality X-ray and UV spectroscopic observations. We found that not only does the X-ray to UV correlation still hold at these redshifts, but its intrinsic dispersion is as low as 0.12 dex (previous works reached 0.20-0.22 dex). For a sample of quasars at z ∼ 3 with particularly high-quality observations, the dispersion further drops to 0.09 dex, a value entirely accountable for by intrinsic variability and source geometry effects. The composite spectra of these quasars, in both the X-rays and the UV, do not show any difference with respect to the average spectra of quasars at lower redshifts. The absence of any spectral difference between high- and low-z quasars and the tightness of the X-ray to UV relation suggests that no evolutionary effects are present in the relation. Therefore, it can be safely employed to derive quasar distances. Under this assumption, we obtain a measurement for the luminosity distance at z ∼ 3 with 15% uncertainty, and in a 4σ tension with the concordance model.

Abstract Copyright: © A. Sacchi et al. 2022

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: nuclei - quasars: general - cosmology: observations - distance scale - X-rays: galaxies

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/663/L7): sample.dat>

Simbad objects: 127

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 127
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SDSS J000335.49-061112.5 QSO 00 03 35.5027321152 -06 11 12.452709300           ~ 9 0
2 [VV2006] J001205.0+144122 QSO 00 12 05.0300035560 +14 41 22.255654668   19.41 19.19     ~ 26 0
3 SDSS J001913.57-080410.6 QSO 00 19 13.5708725160 -08 04 10.571749860           ~ 10 0
4 SDSS J004505.31-014048.0 QSO 00 45 05.3079629016 -01 40 48.013504716           ~ 10 0
5 SDSS J004936.10+322438.2 QSO 00 49 36.1100881224 +32 24 38.175289776           ~ 7 0
6 SDSS J005518.60-011402.1 QSO 00 55 18.6106009368 -01 14 02.156824860           ~ 10 0
7 SDSS J010920.73+275406.9 QSO 01 09 20.7340183896 +27 54 06.927051564           ~ 9 0
8 SDSS J011533.52+000356.3 QSO 01 15 33.5265331488 +00 03 56.313139860           ~ 21 0
9 SDSS J012711.73+020322.1 QSO 01 27 11.7385440792 +02 03 22.109241852           ~ 9 0
10 SDSS J012826.12+290838.0 QSO 01 28 26.1235849104 +29 08 38.076663588           ~ 10 0
11 QSO J0133+0400 QSO 01 33 40.3265690928 +04 00 59.844453768     18.30     ~ 74 0
12 SDSS J014937.51+130924.2 QSO 01 49 37.5157011528 +13 09 24.201430416           ~ 11 0
13 SDSS J021438.15-052024.5 QSO 02 14 38.1529153368 -05 20 24.565663680           ~ 9 0
14 SDSS J021719.46-052305.3 QSO 02 17 19.4604216696 -05 23 05.403665544   19.81837 19.42802 19.63557   ~ 19 0
15 SDSS J025709.11+000707.7 QSO 02 57 09.1241895936 +00 07 07.765348620   20.16 19.96     ~ 23 0
16 LBQS 0301-0035 QSO 03 03 41.0487601176 -00 23 21.907819248   18.26 17.93 17.6   ~ 121 0
17 LBQS 0302-0019 QSO 03 04 49.8593341368 -00 08 13.534398816   18.08 17.80 17.5   ~ 261 0
18 SDSS J031703.24+411528.8 QSO 03 17 03.2458032744 +41 15 28.867742352           ~ 17 0
19 SDSS J033654.24+004016.0 QSO 03 36 54.2470203216 +00 40 16.041902196   19.67 19.38 19.34   ~ 22 0
20 SDSS J075100.95+173813.3 QSO 07 51 00.951 +17 38 13.32           ~ 3 0
21 [VV2006] J083052.9+380907 QSO 08 30 52.8987076080 +38 09 07.344787536   19.76 19.41     ~ 34 0
22 2MASS J08353569+2122401 QSO 08 35 35.6917373592 +21 22 40.224996840   18.73 18.36     ~ 32 0
23 SDSS J083832.33+200142.1 QSO 08 38 32.3340260040 +20 01 42.115162116   19.83 18.99     ~ 21 0
24 SDSS J083843.99+200523.8 QSO 08 38 43.9986390192 +20 05 23.854233120           ~ 9 0
25 SDSS J084139.83+010235.0 QSO 08 41 39.8330541504 +01 02 35.077645896           ~ 11 0
26 [VV2006] J085609.5+374929 QSO 08 56 09.4739236944 +37 49 28.793168436   18.93 18.78     ~ 34 0
27 SDSS J085631.38+015236.8 QSO 08 56 31.3839663480 +01 52 36.809665788           ~ 13 0
28 [VV2006] J090508.8+305756 QSO 09 05 08.8856022480 +30 57 57.274061004   18.02 17.78     ~ 33 0
29 SDSS J092004.91+010012.5 QSO 09 20 04.9144293864 +01 00 12.681875520           ~ 12 0
30 QSO J0929+2825 QSO 09 29 14.4966601344 +28 25 29.140690656   18.94 18.25     ~ 43 0
31 QSO J0942+0422 QSO 09 42 02.0480819568 +04 22 44.548204368   17.78 17.47     ~ 66 0
32 SDSS J094610.43+231311.8 QSO 09 46 10.4365901328 +23 13 11.805431376           ~ 7 0
33 2MASS J09473420+1421168 QSO 09 47 34.1970129912 +14 21 16.944191676   17.89 17.65     ~ 39 0
34 COSMOS J095753.49+024736.1 QSO 09 57 53.49 +02 47 36.2   23.047 22.244   21.8 ~ 25 0
35 ACS-GC 20078484 AGN 09 57 59.01 +01 58 04.9   23.678 22.763   23.207 ~ 14 0
36 COSMOS2015 961107 AGN 09 58 11.22 +02 45 44.0   22.332 22.324   22.31 ~ 18 0
37 ACS-GC 20245315 AGN 09 58 25.20 +02 03 09.5         23.155 ~ 15 0
38 ACS-GC 20132346 AGN 09 58 34.402 +02 20 54.84         22.42 ~ 23 0
39 ACS-GC 20075517 AGN 09 58 51.746 +02 00 59.48   22.2297 21.9783   22.32 ~ 28 0
40 ACS-GC 20099567 QSO 09 58 56.70 +02 10 47.7   28.017 25.2149   23.885 ~ 31 0
41 COSMOS2015 719700 AGN 09 59 08.07 +02 23 26.1   24.1361 23.7005     ~ 9 0
42 ACS-GC 20071495 Sy1 09 59 10.66 +02 04 23.1   23.9037 23.3998   22.952 ~ 26 0
43 ACS-GC 20097001 AGN 09 59 17.66 +02 13 41.9   22.7111 22.2592   22.208 ~ 27 0
44 SDSS J095923.55+022227.3 QSO 09 59 23.5532763744 +02 22 27.286757760   21.1515 20.7961   20.87 ~ 41 0
45 ACS-GC 20096726 AGN 09 59 24.37 +02 16 35.0   24.2981 22.9219   23.271 ~ 25 0
46 ACS-GC 20097019 QSO 09 59 31.010 +02 13 33.01         22.989 ~ 33 0
47 SDSS J095938.28+020450.0 QSO 09 59 38.2905119568 +02 04 50.066591052   21.2275 20.5315   20.13 ~ 43 0
48 ACS-GC 20069978 AGN 09 59 41.41 +01 58 45.3   22.5527 22.0362   22.459 ~ 29 0
49 ACS-GC 20069702 AGN 09 59 41.52 +02 01 36.8 23.74 23.2463 22.8585 22.84 22.78 ~ 24 0
50 COSMOS2015 486220 QSO 10 00 01.058 +02 02 19.96   23.2001 21.8854   21.78 ~ 37 0
51 COSMOS2015 166147 G 10 00 05.54 +01 32 02.3   24.070 23.403     ~ 5 0
52 ACS-GC 20094946 QSO 10 00 11.041 +02 12 04.05         22.37 ~ 33 0
53 SDSS J100024.88+023956.6 QSO 10 00 24.885 +02 39 56.59   20.994 21.284   21.21 ~ 40 0
54 COSMOS2015 451334 AGN 10 00 43.91 +01 59 00.2           ~ 12 0
55 ACS-GC 20149465 rG 10 00 49.28 +02 30 10.5   24.0642 23.4208   23.425 ~ 24 0
56 SDSS J100050.12+022854.8 QSO 10 00 50.1200098608 +02 28 54.857419212   21.1516 19.9896   20.08 ~ 52 0
57 ACS-GC 20060963 rG 10 01 02.813 +02 06 59.93   21.651 21.3326   21.31 ~ 22 0
58 ACS-GC 20174444 AGN 10 01 11.80 +02 38 00.5 24.43 23.4253 23.20 22.93 23.11 ~ 17 0
59 2XMM J100124.3+024041 QSO 10 01 24.338 +02 40 41.75   21.3884 20.9137   20.96 ~ 26 0
60 ACS-GC 20171537 AGN 10 01 26.843 +02 46 44.86   22.4083 21.9105   22.35 ~ 20 0
61 ACS-GC 20008485 AGN 10 01 35.22 +01 44 08.5   23.4038 22.9466   22.851 ~ 22 0
62 2XMM J100203.4+024837 AGN 10 02 03.48 +02 48 36.8         21.175 ~ 15 0
63 SDSS J100223.93+022353.5 QSO 10 02 23.9285987520 +02 23 53.583354780   21.1543 20.8725   20.714 ~ 24 0
64 ACS-GC 20138435 Sy1 10 02 28.15 +02 28 58.0   23.5056 22.9424   23.234 ~ 16 0
65 [VV2006] J100238.2+013746 QSO 10 02 38.2539442032 +01 37 46.571198844 19.71 19.05 19.15   19.17 ~ 61 0
66 COSMOS2015 812993 AGN 10 02 41.77 +02 31 56.4           ~ 12 0
67 COSMOS 377968 AGN 10 03 04.585 +01 42 35.79   22.305 22.192   22.03 ~ 6 0
68 CSO 38 QSO 10 11 55.5947671920 +29 41 41.595330804   16.28 16.05     ~ 117 0
69 QSO B1011+4315 QSO 10 14 47.1891688176 +43 00 30.167514324   17.39 17.05     ~ 74 0
70 [VV2000] J102714.7+354318 QSO 10 27 14.7800880984 +35 43 17.395124844   16.96 16.69     ~ 50 0
71 SDSS J103458.88+393216.5 QSO 10 34 58.8864577824 +39 32 16.519546284   18       ~ 17 0
72 SDSS J104559.64+590631.5 QSO 10 45 59.6625445512 +59 06 31.154856192   19.54 19.31     ~ 23 0
73 SDSS J105144.87+324637.1 QSO 10 51 44.8723561056 +32 46 37.171198380           ~ 7 0
74 3XMM J105306.0+573424 Sy1 10 53 06.0540527592 +57 34 24.595144572   20.71 20.46     ~ 27 0
75 QSO B1107+4847 QSO 11 10 38.6370859200 +48 31 15.691679076   17.09 16.87     ~ 94 0
76 [VV2006] J111511.3+532039 QSO 11 15 11.2888034736 +53 20 37.770180612   17.70 17.57     ~ 18 0
77 SDSS J111828.31+074300.1 QSO 11 18 28.3217412888 +07 43 00.163037028           ~ 19 0
78 SDSS J112002.55+064334.9 QSO 11 20 02.556 +06 43 34.91           ~ 9 0
79 QSO J1143+3452 QSO 11 43 08.8809241248 +34 52 22.233156204   17.43 17.15     ~ 49 0
80 [VV2006] J120233.4+580501 QSO 12 02 33.3926596176 +58 05 01.893082092   20.13 19.57     ~ 30 0
81 QSO J1203+1522 QSO 12 03 31.2904721952 +15 22 54.705635004   17.14 16.92     ~ 35 0
82 QSO J1225+4831 QSO 12 25 18.66000 +48 31 16.3020   18.69 18.30     ~ 41 0
83 [VV2006] J122740.9+440604 QSO 12 27 40.8542533872 +44 06 04.738773132   21.87 20.92     ~ 29 0
84 LBQS 1228+1808 QSO 12 30 56.9712219696 +17 51 39.484962936   18.45 18.28     ~ 35 0
85 SDSS J123113.25+110506.4 QSO 12 31 13.2523332360 +11 05 06.352176228           ~ 15 0
86 SDSS J123142.12+110308.1 QSO 12 31 42.1304810064 +11 03 08.084508768           ~ 11 0
87 SDSS J124252.82+024731.0 QSO 12 42 52.8202061112 +02 47 30.953320224           ~ 16 0
88 SDSS J124451.49-002815.0 QSO 12 44 51.4990637856 -00 28 15.071064888   20.00 19.76     ~ 11 0
89 2MASS J12463704+2625005 QSO 12 46 37.0609409328 +26 25 00.309738432   18.18 17.83     ~ 24 0
90 LBQS 1244+1129 QSO 12 46 40.3700829816 +11 13 02.901704808     18.4     ~ 64 0
91 SDSS J124825.30+673135.2 QSO 12 48 25.3069887528 +67 31 35.283928584           ~ 8 0
92 SDSS J125629.75+271506.5 QSO 12 56 29.7491266272 +27 15 06.602287104   19.58 19.42     ~ 25 0
93 [VV96] J130812.1+292513 QSO 13 08 11.9201013240 +29 25 12.641278440   19.07 18.79 19.01   ~ 41 0
94 LBQS 1308-0104 QSO 13 11 19.2485497656 -01 20 30.896347056   18.73 18.46 18.06 17.78 ~ 36 0
95 SDSS J131236.26+231630.2 QSO 13 12 36.2618092440 +23 16 30.100811160   20.55 19.77     ~ 24 0
96 [VV2006] J132611.9+074358 QSO 13 26 11.8504307808 +07 43 58.372083372   20.25 18.96     ~ 53 0
97 [VV2000] J133223.2+503432 QSO 13 32 23.2598082984 +50 34 31.355679540   19.97 19.09     ~ 41 0
98 SDSS J133228.53+060518.6 QSO 13 32 28.5377207976 +06 05 18.641342220           ~ 14 0
99 SDSS J134850.23+262504.2 QSO 13 48 50.2366613304 +26 25 04.154632140   20.01 19.68     ~ 35 0
100 QSO B1347.5+2709 QSO 13 49 46.2500886552 +26 54 43.639873200   20.09 19.87     ~ 21 0
101 SDSS J135057.55+600815.9 QSO 13 50 57.5477877552 +60 08 15.919268712           ~ 16 0
102 QSO J1401+0244 QSO 14 01 46.5361320120 +02 44 34.755692604   22.03 20.32     ~ 52 0
103 [VV2006] J140747.2+645420 QSO 14 07 47.2332082608 +64 54 19.916965836   17.73 17.41     ~ 43 0
104 [VV2006] J140904.2+541023 QSO 14 09 04.1570001600 +54 10 23.707473456   19.18 18.94     ~ 35 0
105 QSO J1410+0015 QSO 14 10 51.2457121584 +00 15 46.944584064   19.29 18.42     ~ 20 0
106 SDSS J141550.30+112452.5 QSO 14 15 50.3046173520 +11 24 52.643862936           ~ 15 0
107 SDSS J142228.70+013530.9 QSO 14 22 28.7057342976 +01 35 30.897871980           ~ 11 0
108 QSO B1425+606 QSO 14 26 56.1849081360 +60 25 50.813373324   16.82 16.54     ~ 148 0
109 SDSS J143832.01+033829.9 QSO 14 38 32.0158863432 +03 38 29.952900564           ~ 10 0
110 SDSS J144444.80+015226.9 QSO 14 44 44.8005633048 +01 52 26.845416300           ~ 21 0
111 [VV2006] J144742.9-015919 QSO 14 47 42.9400782384 -01 59 19.691126268   20.27 19.93     ~ 26 0
112 [VV2006] J144841.5+484123 QSO 14 48 41.5029106056 +48 41 23.861461128   19.15 18.93     ~ 30 0
113 SDSS J150151.76+421757.0 QSO 15 01 51.7721908104 +42 17 57.003368208           ~ 5 0
114 SDSS J150616.13+014131.3 QSO 15 06 16.1438533752 +01 41 31.340804100           ~ 16 0
115 SDSS J153744.64+543539.2 QSO 15 37 44.6478885912 +54 35 39.308146476           ~ 10 0
116 SDSS J160144.95+272547.0 QSO 16 01 44.9526978840 +27 25 47.013998736           ~ 11 0
117 QSO B1603+3820 QSO 16 04 55.3999673952 +38 12 01.628642808   16.37 15.99     ~ 60 0
118 HS 1700+6416 QSO 17 01 00.6194059368 +64 12 09.118892376   16.39 16.17     ~ 382 0
119 SDSS J170222.94+340735.2 QSO 17 02 22.9508201712 +34 07 35.321372616           ~ 8 0
120 SDSS J172051.26+410146.3 QSO 17 20 51.2658368016 +41 01 46.338977748           ~ 13 0
121 SDSS J215309.20-011217.4 QSO 21 53 09.2041249848 -01 12 17.355335256           ~ 9 0
122 LBQS 2230-0015 QSO 22 34 08.9971751592 +00 00 01.703853180   18.09 17.39 17.3   ~ 142 0
123 SDSS J225418.79+113432.0 QSO 22 54 18.792 +11 34 32.00           ~ 6 0
124 SDSS J232457.12+282617.3 QSO 23 24 57.1144321728 +28 26 17.316964644           ~ 8 0
125 QSO B2342+089 QSO 23 45 31.0157080176 +09 09 05.553114912           ~ 31 1
126 SDSS J235054.63+200938.6 QSO 23 50 54.6332371896 +20 09 38.619243468           ~ 11 0
127 SDSS J235201.30+200902.4 QSO 23 52 01.3061112288 +20 09 02.469467484           ~ 10 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2022A&A...663L...7S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu