2022ApJ...927..164B


Query : 2022ApJ...927..164B

2022ApJ...927..164B - Astrophys. J., 927, 164-164 (2022/March-2)

Toward a Better Understanding of Cosmic Chronometers: Stellar Population Properties of Passive Galaxies at Intermediate Redshift.

BORGHI N., MORESCO M., CIMATTI A., HUCHET A., QUAI S. and POZZETTI L.

Abstract (from CDS):

We take advantage of the publicly available LEGA-C spectroscopic survey to measure the stellar population properties of 140 individual massive and passive galaxies at z ∼ 0.7. We develop and publicly release PyLick, a flexible Python code to measure UV to near-IR spectral indices. With PyLick we study the H/K ratio as a new diagnostic based on the pseudo-Lick Ca II H and K indices and find that a cut in H/K < 1.1 can be used jointly with other criteria to select (or verify the purity of) samples of passive galaxies. By combining photometric and spectroscopic criteria, we select a reliable sample of passively evolving galaxies. We constrain single-burst stellar ages, metallicities [Z/H], and [α/Fe] with an optimized set of Lick indices, exploring in detail the robustness of our measurement against different combinations. Even without imposing cosmological priors, the derived ages follow a clear trend compatible with the expected cosmological aging of the universe. We observe no significant redshift evolution for the metal abundance with respect to the values derived at z = 0, with median [Z/H] = 0.08 ± 0.18 and [α/Fe] = 0.13 ± 0.11. Finally, we analyze the relations between log age, [Z/H], [α/Fe], and the stellar velocity dispersion, finding slopes of (0.5 ± 0.1), (0.3 ± 0.2), and (0.2 ± 0.1), respectively; the small scatter of <0.2 dex points to rather homogeneous and short star formation histories. Overall, these results confirm and extend low-redshift findings of a mass-downsizing evolution. This work further strengthens the possibility of selecting pure samples of passive galaxies to be exploited reliably as cosmic chronometers to place independent cosmological constraints.

Abstract Copyright: © 2022. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): Galaxy evolution - Galaxy abundances - Galaxy ages - Observational cosmology

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/ApJ/927/164): table4.dat>

Simbad objects: 141

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 141
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 COSMOS2015 573095 G 09 58 59.90 +02 10 07.8 26.47 25.82 24.10 23.23 21.963 ~ 8 0
2 COSMOS2015 531369 G 09 59 01.02 +02 06 17.8 25.99 24.89 23.02 22.25 21.037 ~ 9 0
3 COSMOS2015 837632 G 09 59 01.57 +02 34 03.1 25.91 25.24 23.49 22.73 21.557 ~ 8 0
4 COSMOS2015 595117 G 09 59 02.58 +02 12 04.5 25.79 25.22 23.55 22.71 21.452 ~ 8 0
5 COSMOS2015 671586 G 09 59 04.515 +02 18 56.29         20.482 ~ 11 0
6 COSMOS2015 505673 G 09 59 06.21 +02 03 57.8 25.80 24.96 23.29 22.48 21.312 ~ 9 0
7 COSMOS2015 674209 rG 09 59 07.29 +02 19 05.7 24.77 24.09 22.45 21.634 20.450 ~ 18 0
8 COSMOS2015 620345 G 09 59 07.84 +02 14 20.9 25.41 24.60 22.90 22.10 20.931 ~ 8 0
9 COSMOS2015 635120 G 09 59 09.98 +02 15 44.0 26.29 25.94 23.97 23.15 21.840 ~ 10 0
10 COSMOS2015 784577 G 09 59 10.13 +02 29 20.8 24.66 24.43 23.17 22.46 21.189 ~ 11 0
11 COSMOS2015 606729 G 09 59 12.059 +02 13 03.98 25.60 24.21 22.58 21.713 20.661 ~ 10 0
12 COSMOS2015 855335 G 09 59 16.454 +02 35 34.41 25.21 24.70 23.11 22.38 21.235 ~ 12 0
13 COSMOS2015 650506 G 09 59 24.961 +02 16 58.58 25.86 24.81 23.04 22.25 21.095 ~ 13 0
14 COSMOS2015 878538 G 09 59 25.426 +02 37 47.89 26.50 25.34 23.62 22.95 21.738 ~ 11 0
15 NMBS C18237 rG 09 59 29.227 +02 28 44.75 25.97 24.89 23.08 22.30 20.996 ~ 22 0
16 ACS-GC 20070355 rG 09 59 30.00 +02 03 45.5 25.99 25.37 23.61 22.73 21.471 ~ 16 0
17 COSMOS2015 840191 BiC 09 59 30.70 +02 34 40.9 25.37 24.40 22.53 21.738 20.507 ~ 13 0
18 COSMOS2015 841101 G 09 59 31.674 +02 34 28.15 25.81 24.88 22.98 22.21 21.003 ~ 15 0
19 COSMOS2015 800937 G 09 59 32.99 +02 30 47.3 26.02 25.04 23.13 22.37 21.034 ~ 12 0
20 COSMOS2015 806508 G 09 59 33.56 +02 31 18.6 26.36 25.56 23.67 22.90 21.619 ~ 14 0
21 COSMOS2015 795027 GiC 09 59 33.561 +02 30 20.33 25.87 25.11 23.42 22.76 21.583 ~ 11 0
22 COSMOS2015 963785 G 09 59 34.40 +02 45 56.7 26.58 25.15 23.42 22.63 21.507 ~ 8 0
23 COSMOS2015 689516 G 09 59 34.41 +02 20 38.8 27.08 26.01 24.12 23.40 22.112 ~ 8 0
24 NMBS C13377 G 09 59 34.74 +02 23 11.2 25.43 24.69 22.87 22.11 20.855 ~ 13 0
25 COSMOS2015 869198 G 09 59 35.83 +02 37 02.3 26.81 25.75 24.14 23.38 22.198 ~ 10 0
26 COSMOS2015 973219 G 09 59 36.37 +02 46 51.0 27.45 26.01 24.05 23.31 22.118 ~ 9 0
27 COSMOS 2382635 GiC 09 59 38.359 +02 30 16.65 26.09 25.12 23.21 22.43 21.155 ~ 13 0
28 SDSS J095939.16+023043.8 AGN 09 59 39.170 +02 30 44.10   24.321 22.740   19.867 ~ 19 0
29 COSMOS2015 965871 G 09 59 39.24 +02 46 09.1 26.12 25.37 23.51 22.76 21.628 ~ 9 0
30 DES J095940.81+023033.5 GiC 09 59 40.815 +02 30 33.55 26.92 25.54 23.67 22.90 21.600 ~ 13 0
31 COSMOS2015 493309 G 09 59 41.155 +02 02 50.22 25.13 24.40 22.80 22.021 20.870 ~ 12 0
32 NMBS C11937 G 09 59 41.93 +02 21 40.5 26.08 25.43 23.60 22.82 21.533 ~ 11 0
33 COSMOS2015 859118 G 09 59 42.535 +02 35 57.02 24.94 23.95 22.17 21.411 20.295 ~ 12 0
34 COSMOS2015 814496 BiC 09 59 43.130 +02 31 58.00 23.358 22.88 21.693 21.172 20.124 ~ 12 0
35 COSMOS2015 576527 rG 09 59 46.069 +02 10 23.47 25.55 24.81 23.04 22.22 20.980 ~ 17 0
36 [BMM2014] 795321 G 09 59 46.077 +02 05 54.84 25.72 24.59 22.74 21.903 20.674 ~ 14 0
37 COSMOS2015 880355 G 09 59 46.52 +02 37 57.6 26.10 25.33 23.56 22.78 21.501 ~ 9 0
38 COSMOS2015 817173 rG 09 59 46.759 +02 32 10.87 25.73 24.99 23.11 22.38 21.119 ~ 15 0
39 SDSS J095946.83+022908.6 BiC 09 59 46.854 +02 29 08.54 25.41 24.66 22.76 21.956 20.628 ~ 14 0
40 SDSS J095948.27+022859.2 G 09 59 48.292 +02 28 58.97 25.67 25.06 23.27 22.47 21.161 ~ 14 0
41 COSMOS2015 533797 G 09 59 49.325 +02 06 36.39 24.96 24.07 22.37 21.629 20.525 ~ 14 0
42 COSMOS2015 621027 G 09 59 50.398 +02 14 22.64 25.59 24.47 22.69 21.858 20.631 ~ 13 0
43 COSMOS2015 751525 G 09 59 53.379 +02 26 17.35 26.08 25.20 23.31 22.62 21.372 ~ 15 0
44 COSMOS2015 826407 G 09 59 53.914 +02 33 19.75 24.71 24.26 22.62 21.974 20.723 ~ 15 0
45 COSMOS2015 846981 G 09 59 55.78 +02 34 52.3 26.40 25.13 23.24 22.45 21.159 ~ 12 0
46 COSMOS2015 600444 G 09 59 55.99 +02 12 40.6 26.22 24.93 23.27 22.47 21.404 ~ 10 0
47 COSMOS2015 850661 BiC 09 59 57.36 +02 35 16.0 25.42 24.22 22.46 21.689 20.541 ~ 13 0
48 COSMOS2015 636692 G 09 59 57.836 +02 15 49.11 26.43 25.11 23.40 22.57 21.395 ~ 15 0
49 COSMOS2015 759922 G 09 59 57.87 +02 27 03.3   25.090 23.883   21.580 ~ 10 0
50 COSMOS2015 630733 G 09 59 58.43 +02 15 15.6 27.01 25.44 23.77 22.80 21.588 ~ 13 0
51 COSMOS2015 956170 G 09 59 58.49 +02 45 12.5 26.62 25.83 23.96 23.15 21.875 ~ 8 0
52 COSMOS2015 721109 G 09 59 59.47 +02 23 23.3 26.07 25.19 23.31 22.49 21.187 ~ 9 0
53 COSMOS2015 854291 G 09 59 59.56 +02 35 31.2   24.408 22.971   20.091 ~ 12 0
54 COSMOS2015 503674 G 09 59 59.681 +02 03 48.36 25.03 24.78 23.52 22.75 21.577 ~ 14 0
55 COSMOS2015 830405 G 10 00 00.06 +02 33 20.4     24.026   21.425 ~ 8 0
56 COSMOS2015 932733 G 10 00 02.67 +02 42 50.6 24.40 24.36 23.07 22.40 21.281 ~ 9 0
57 COSMOS2015 765830 G 10 00 02.897 +02 27 32.67 25.76 24.84 22.95 22.19 20.841 ~ 14 0
58 SDSS J100006.69+023307.1 BiC 10 00 06.698 +02 33 07.21 25.23 24.49 22.57 21.864 20.537 ~ 15 0
59 COSMOS2015 814559 G 10 00 07.192 +02 31 59.11 25.45 24.59 22.85 22.13 20.937 ~ 11 0
60 COSMOS2015 860983 G 10 00 10.41 +02 36 10.4 25.22 24.75 23.18 22.44 21.201 ~ 13 0
61 COSMOS2015 982654 G 10 00 10.76 +02 47 39.4 25.42 24.54 22.82 22.08 20.825 ~ 9 0
62 COSMOS2015 954415 G 10 00 11.832 +02 45 00.84 25.48 24.56 22.79 22.08 20.895 ~ 11 0
63 SDSS J100012.47+023449.4 G 10 00 12.466 +02 34 49.61 25.48 24.73 22.74 22.004 20.661 ~ 14 0
64 COSMOS2015 661723 rG 10 00 13.605 +02 18 05.04 25.76 24.90 23.02 22.20 20.892 ~ 25 0
65 SDSS J100014.35+023211.0 rG 10 00 14.363 +02 32 10.83 25.21 24.34 22.56 21.784 20.611 ~ 20 0
66 COSMOS 1654845 G 10 00 14.48 +02 13 33.6 26.39 25.79 23.86 23.01 21.734 ~ 12 0
67 SDSS J100014.78+023850.3 rG 10 00 14.76 +02 38 50.2 25.55 24.53 22.66 21.906 20.667 ~ 15 0
68 COSMOS2015 877703 GiC 10 00 18.529 +02 37 41.73 25.13 24.42 22.98 22.28 21.076 ~ 11 0
69 COSMOS2015 766811 BiC 10 00 21.30 +02 27 38.5   24.287 22.974   20.054 ~ 16 0
70 ZFOURGE COSMOS 1870 BiC 10 00 22.17 +02 11 37.1 25.40 24.60 22.88 22.10 20.932 ~ 15 0
71 CANDELS COSMOS F160W J100022.95+021213.3 G 10 00 22.954 +02 12 13.36 26.17 25.22 23.25 22.40 21.107 ~ 19 0
72 COSMOS2015 872072 G 10 00 23.049 +02 37 16.20 25.41 24.78 23.28 22.56 21.438 ~ 13 0
73 COSMOS 2335409 G 10 00 23.75 +02 32 45.8 25.34 24.75 22.89 22.21 20.976 ~ 11 0
74 COSMOS2015 934636 G 10 00 24.28 +02 43 45.4 25.28 24.47 22.66 21.909 20.668 ~ 12 0
75 SDSS J100024.84+021152.3 G 10 00 24.858 +02 11 52.61 25.41 24.60 23.13 22.38 21.256 ~ 19 0
76 COSMOS2015 503252 rG 10 00 26.144 +02 03 50.29 25.33 24.81 23.25 22.52 21.286 ~ 14 0
77 COSMOS2015 364533 G 10 00 26.24 +01 50 29.9 26.05 25.11 23.36 22.52 21.350 ~ 9 0
78 COSMOS2015 922796 G 10 00 28.414 +02 41 57.31 26.15 25.09 23.22 22.48 21.238 ~ 12 0
79 NAME COSMOS Field reg 10 00 28.60 +02 12 21.0           ~ 3639 0
80 COSMOS2015 422614 G 10 00 29.06 +01 56 06.2 24.77 23.92 22.38 21.531 20.418 ~ 13 0
81 COSMOS2015 842599 G 10 00 29.982 +02 34 34.79 26.87 25.80 23.93 23.19 21.977 ~ 14 0
82 COSMOS2015 485000 G 10 00 30.10 +02 02 18.0 26.05 24.91 23.16 22.37 21.187 ~ 9 0
83 COSMOS2015 415969 G 10 00 31.83 +01 55 24.3 26.28 25.38 23.49 22.75 21.489 ~ 12 0
84 COSMOS2015 792152 G 10 00 33.336 +02 30 02.69 27.23 25.69 24.06 23.30 22.249 ~ 16 0
85 COSMOS2015 508082 G 10 00 34.193 +02 04 09.64 25.22 24.63 23.20 22.51 21.365 ~ 16 0
86 SDSS J100035.54+023104.5 rG 10 00 35.54 +02 31 04.3 25.13 24.06 22.34 21.542 20.407 ~ 21 0
87 COSMOS 1984167 G 10 00 38.763 +02 21 44.90 27.22 26.07 24.36 23.66 22.40 ~ 15 0
88 COSMOS 2339523 rG 10 00 41.49 +02 31 41.1 26.53 25.67 23.90 23.10 21.810 ~ 17 0
89 COSMOS2015 490884 G 10 00 44.517 +02 02 38.64 25.53 24.94 23.23 22.49 21.252 ~ 12 0
90 SDSS J100044.69+023332.7 rG 10 00 44.68 +02 33 32.4 25.82 24.62 22.73 21.919 20.600 ~ 14 0
91 UVISTADR1 J100045.27+022951.7 G 10 00 45.267 +02 29 51.69 26.12 24.95 23.54 22.80 21.694 ~ 14 0
92 COSMOS2015 922955 G 10 00 45.38 +02 41 59.1   24.120 23.098   21.084 ~ 8 0
93 COSMOS2015 569767 G 10 00 47.95 +02 09 44.2 25.32 24.63 23.13 22.28 21.123 ~ 10 0
94 COSMOS 1983811 G 10 00 48.69 +02 21 47.1 24.75 24.11 22.49 21.757 20.616 ~ 18 0
95 COSMOS2015 620347 G 10 00 49.479 +02 14 24.01 25.01 24.68 23.43 22.78 21.588 ~ 14 0
96 COSMOS2015 498357 G 10 00 52.423 +02 03 27.87 25.67 24.95 23.21 22.36 21.079 ~ 12 0
97 COSMOS2015 935776 G 10 00 52.65 +02 43 16.9 24.22 23.77 22.40 21.886 20.764 ~ 9 0
98 COSMOS2015 942663 G 10 00 53.921 +02 44 04.54 25.85 24.37 22.73 21.921 20.853 ~ 11 0
99 COSMOS2015 943230 G 10 00 55.016 +02 43 54.28 26.19 24.75 23.02 22.23 21.121 ~ 14 0
100 COSMOS2015 691561 G 10 00 55.569 +02 20 48.40 26.37 25.66 23.90 23.20 22.031 ~ 14 0
101 COSMOS2015 753296 G 10 00 55.756 +02 26 25.68 26.55 25.52 23.75 22.96 21.787 ~ 12 0
102 COSMOS2015 573841 G 10 00 58.118 +02 10 06.66 25.61 24.42 22.62 21.817 20.621 ~ 13 0
103 COSMOS2015 591968 G 10 01 02.007 +02 11 56.29 26.35 25.39 23.65 22.88 21.757 ~ 12 0
104 COSMOS2015 413336 G 10 01 03.010 +01 55 07.29 25.45 24.71 23.63 23.00 21.980 ~ 9 0
105 COSMOS2015 751787 G 10 01 04.061 +02 26 21.88     22.860   20.373 ~ 12 0
106 [BMM2014] 1440430 G 10 01 04.123 +02 28 11.14 25.46 24.18 22.31 21.563 20.344 ~ 17 0
107 COSMOS2015 846338 G 10 01 04.57 +02 34 50.9 25.57 25.13 23.34 22.47 21.222 ~ 11 0
108 COSMOS2015 880282 G 10 01 05.753 +02 37 54.71 25.84 25.35 23.83 23.04 21.748 ~ 13 0
109 COSMOS 484387 G 10 01 06.760 +01 46 00.89 25.07 24.19 22.58 21.780 20.714 ~ 14 0
110 COSMOS2015 707200 G 10 01 06.96 +02 22 06.4 25.75 24.98 23.23 22.49 21.311 ~ 9 0
111 COSMOS2015 496531 G 10 01 08.89 +02 03 12.1 26.31 24.99 23.29 22.45 21.334 ~ 8 0
112 zCOSMOS 837890 G 10 01 10.72 +02 29 19.5     22.387   19.810 ~ 13 0
113 COSMOS2015 838015 G 10 01 11.38 +02 34 06.6 25.53 24.69 23.13 22.34 21.229 ~ 9 0
114 COSMOS2015 709240 G 10 01 11.726 +02 22 20.59 25.98 25.38 23.71 23.02 21.796 ~ 13 0
115 UVISTADR1 J100121.86+024627.8 G 10 01 21.86 +02 46 27.8 25.30 24.25 22.52 21.709 20.560 ~ 10 0
116 COSMOS2015 972527 G 10 01 22.34 +02 46 49.1 25.81 24.94 23.31 22.60 21.545 ~ 11 0
117 COSMOS2015 638305 G 10 01 26.24 +02 15 57.1 25.62 24.56 22.92 22.19 21.083 ~ 9 0
118 COSMOS 1585124 G 10 01 28.40 +02 10 59.1 25.62 24.42 22.79 21.966 20.859 ~ 13 0
119 COSMOS2015 540311 G 10 01 28.894 +02 07 11.14 25.58 25.04 23.24 22.62 21.360 ~ 14 0
120 COSMOS2015 876811 G 10 01 30.17 +02 37 35.9         21.452 ~ 8 0
121 COSMOS2015 680147 G 10 01 32.31 +02 19 43.1 25.54 24.66 22.90 22.17 20.978 ~ 12 0
122 COSMOS2015 688496 G 10 01 48.66 +02 20 21.1 25.86 25.45 23.66 22.79 21.576 ~ 9 0
123 COSMOS2015 807146 G 10 01 48.68 +02 31 20.7 26.07 25.06 23.32 22.57 21.457 ~ 10 0
124 COSMOS2015 613069 G 10 01 48.76 +02 13 42.2 26.29 25.45 23.67 22.81 21.494 ~ 9 0
125 COSMOS2015 506309 G 10 01 48.79 +02 04 06.7 25.68 25.10 23.21 22.35 21.040 ~ 9 0
126 COSMOS2015 509447 G 10 01 48.98 +02 04 19.7 25.40 25.00 23.31 22.49 21.161 ~ 10 0
127 COSMOS2015 596761 G 10 01 49.57 +02 12 37.9     22.550   20.056 ~ 7 0
128 COSMOS2015 648828 G 10 01 58.649 +02 16 55.79 25.24 24.61 22.89 22.14 20.853 ~ 16 0
129 [BMM2014] 1417470 G 10 01 59.055 +02 28 10.50 24.34 23.64 22.13 21.397 20.314 ~ 13 0
130 COSMOS2015 762935 G 10 01 59.93 +02 27 19.1 25.54 24.84 23.36 22.61 21.514 ~ 9 0
131 COSMOS2015 792354 G 10 02 27.61 +02 30 01.3 25.58 25.20 23.73 22.96 21.746 ~ 9 0
132 COSMOS2015 509766 G 10 02 28.02 +02 04 18.6 25.09 24.29 22.85 22.07 20.996 ~ 9 0
133 COSMOS2015 682683 rG 10 02 32.699 +02 20 00.04 25.45 24.20 22.60 21.768 20.668 ~ 15 0
134 COSMOS2015 483273 G 10 02 33.32 +02 01 55.3 25.40 24.69 22.87 22.18 20.989 ~ 9 0
135 COSMOS2015 688193 G 10 02 34.36 +02 20 29.0 26.16 25.50 24.03 23.25 21.965 ~ 11 0
136 COSMOS2015 656506 G 10 02 35.32 +02 17 37.1 25.78 24.79 23.06 22.37 21.067 ~ 9 0
137 COSMOS2015 593847 G 10 02 37.90 +02 12 02.0 25.79 24.69 22.89 22.10 20.928 ~ 8 0
138 UVISTADR1 J100239.55+022245.4 G 10 02 39.55 +02 22 45.6 25.01 24.02 22.14 21.378 20.201 ~ 11 0
139 COSMOS2015 478550 G 10 02 40.26 +02 01 25.2 25.43 24.62 22.73 22.009 20.747 ~ 10 0
140 COSMOS2015 481744 G 10 02 47.05 +02 01 42.2 25.62 24.74 22.92 22.18 20.984 ~ 10 0
141 COSMOS2015 664634 G 10 02 50.10 +02 18 21.6 26.01 24.69 23.00 22.23 21.127 ~ 9 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2022ApJ...927..164B and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu