2022MNRAS.514.1148Y

Query : 2022MNRAS.514.1148Y

2022MNRAS.514.1148Y - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 514, 1148-1161 (2022/July-3)

The size-luminosity relation of lensed galaxies at z ∼ 6-9 in the Hubble Frontier Fields.

YANG L., LEETHOCHAWALIT N., TREU T., ROBERTS-BORSANI G., BRADAC M., BIRRER S., CASTELLANO M., MERLIN E., FONTANA A., AMORIN R. and TRENTI M.

Abstract (from CDS):

We measure the size-luminosity relation of photometrically selected galaxies within the redshift range z ∼ 6-9, using galaxies lensed by six foreground Hubble Frontier Fields (HFF) clusters. The power afforded by strong gravitational lensing allows us to observe fainter and smaller galaxies than in blank fields. We select our sample of galaxies and obtain their properties, e.g. redshift, magnitude, from the photometrically derived ASTRODEEP catalogues. The intrinsic size is measured with the Lenstruction software, and completeness maps are created as a function of size and luminosity via the GLACiAR2 software. We perform a Bayesian analysis to estimate the intrinsic and incompleteness-corrected size-luminosity distribution, with parametrization re ∝ Lβ. We find slopes of β= 0.50+0.07–0.07 at z ∼ 6 - 7 and β= 0.67+0.14–0.15 at z ∼ 8.5, adopting the Bradac lens model. Our inferred slopes are consistent with other independent determinations of the size-luminosity relation from the HFF data set and steeper than that obtained from the bright galaxies in blank fields. We also investigate the systematic uncertainties associated with the choice of lens models, finding that the slopes of size-luminosity relations derived from different models are mutually consistent, i.e. modelling errors are not a significant source of discrepancy between the size-luminosity relation of blank and lensed fields.

Abstract Copyright: © 2022 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society

Journal keyword(s): gravitational lensing: strong - galaxies: evolution - galaxies: fundamental parameters

Simbad objects: 179

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 179
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA 		ICRS (J2000)
DEC 		Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026 		#notes
1 [LBL2018] A2744 cluster 48 LeG 00 14 16.327 -30 24 03.75     29.2659   29.1011 ~ 4 0
2 [ARK2014] 1265 LeG 00 14 16.817 -30 24 13.40         28.2924 ~ 7 0
3 [ARK2014] 171 LeG 00 14 16.9561 -30 24 52.780         27.8587 ~ 18 0
4 [MAC2016] A2744cl 21690 LeG 00 14 17.292 -30 23 49.89         30.3239 ~ 3 0
5 [HBH2019] A2744-061 LeG 00 14 17.404 -30 24 47.76           ~ 8 0
6 [MAC2016] A2744cl 20214 LeG 00 14 17.467 -30 24 48.70         30.2952 ~ 3 0
7 [ARK2015] 1282 LeG 00 14 18.1161 -30 24 30.910         30.0980 ~ 5 0
8 [MAC2016] A2744cl 548 LeG 00 14 18.432 -30 24 26.79   29.6738       ~ 3 0
9 [ARK2015] 5258 LeG 00 14 18.4534 -30 23 10.763         31.1031 ~ 12 0
10 [LFL2017] A2744 z6 2363 LeG 00 14 19.120 -30 23 55.24           ~ 6 0
11 ACO 2744 ClG 00 14 20.03 -30 23 17.8           ~ 1077 0
12 [ARK2015] 4358 LeG 00 14 20.6999 -30 23 33.749         30.1141 ~ 5 0
13 [MAC2016] A2744cl 22392 LeG 00 14 21.078 -30 23 24.14         29.5272 ~ 3 0
14 [MAC2016] A2744cl 22347 LeG 00 14 21.120 -30 23 26.33     30.2316     ~ 3 0
15 [MAC2016] A2744cl 2007 LeG 00 14 21.274 -30 23 10.48         30.0218 ~ 3 0
16 [MAC2016] A2744cl 21582 LeG 00 14 21.463 -30 23 54.59         30.5853 ~ 3 0
17 [ARK2015] 6245 LeG 00 14 21.7240 -30 22 47.132         29.6260 ~ 6 0
18 [IKO2015] HFF1C-i7 LeG 00 14 21.790 -30 22 45.88         27.5378 ~ 10 0
19 [BIO2017] A2744I-4219124454 LeG 00 14 21.909 -30 24 45.47         30.4062 ~ 5 0
20 [ARK2015] 1060 LeG 00 14 22.1189 -30 24 35.698           ~ 6 0
21 [MAC2016] A2744cl 22064 LeG 00 14 22.276 -30 23 37.31         30.3867 ~ 3 0
22 [ARK2015] 491 LeG 00 14 22.3074 -30 24 47.988     30.5901   29.1091 ~ 13 0
23 [MAC2016] A2744cl 22542 LeG 00 14 22.473 -30 23 17.48         30.2729 ~ 3 0
24 [ARK2014] 93 EmG 00 14 22.5135 -30 24 55.598         29.4057 ~ 15 0
25 [ARK2015] 5202 LeG 00 14 23.0624 -30 23 08.992           ~ 21 0
26 [MAC2016] A2744cl 23153 LeG 00 14 23.481 -30 22 52.05         29.9039 ~ 3 0
27 [ARK2015] 6662 LeG 00 14 23.5450 -30 22 56.600         30.99 ~ 10 0
28 [ARK2014] 1266 EmG 00 14 24.2569 -30 24 14.375         29.0818 ~ 15 0
29 [ARK2014] 561 LeG 00 14 24.7709 -30 24 37.271         29.7124 ~ 17 0
30 [ARK2015] 4877 LeG 00 14 24.8114 -30 22 56.118           ~ 23 0
31 [ARK2015] 4779 LeG 00 14 24.8203 -30 22 59.585         28.5931 ~ 13 0
32 [ARK2015] 4886 LeG 00 14 24.927 -30 22 56.15           ~ 85 0
33 [IKO2015] HFF1C-Y8 LeG 00 14 24.961 -30 22 56.31           ~ 17 0
34 [ARK2014] 2070 LeG 00 14 25.0846 -30 22 49.674   29.7772       ~ 28 0
35 [ARK2015] 1184 LeG 00 14 25.0959 -30 24 33.700         30.0639 ~ 12 0
36 [BIO2017] A2744I-4251243355 LeG 00 14 25.140 -30 24 33.45         28.6888 ~ 6 0
37 [IKO2018] HFF1C-2516-4570 LeG 00 14 25.169 -30 24 57.05         26.9931 ~ 6 0
38 [ARK2015] 6593 LeG 00 14 25.2137 -30 22 53.263           ~ 12 0
39 [BIO2017] A2744I-4252524255 LeG 00 14 25.249 -30 24 25.58         29.7599 ~ 5 0
40 [ARK2014] 2770 LeG 00 14 25.4941 -30 23 11.929         27.4590 ~ 14 0
41 [ARK2014] 841 LeG 00 14 25.5327 -30 24 26.222     30.0476   28.5858 ~ 7 0
42 [ARK2015] 6525 LeG 00 14 25.5503 -30 22 51.582         30.99 ~ 26 0
43 ACO 370 ClG 02 39 50.5 -01 35 08           ~ 825 0
44 NAME CANUCS-A370-z8-LAE LeG 02 39 51.872 -01 35 41.18           ~ 7 0
45 [BHF2019] A370 729 LeG 02 39 52.387 -01 35 50.09           ~ 1 0
46 [BHF2019] A370 3825 LeG 02 39 54.736 -01 33 32.24           ~ 1 0
47 [BHF2019] A370 3822 LeG 02 39 54.765 -01 33 32.33           ~ 1 0
48 [BHF2019] A370 3252 EmG 02 39 55.227 -01 34 00.23         27.236 ~ 5 0
49 [BHF2019] A370 3241 LeG 02 39 55.265 -01 34 00.34           ~ 3 0
50 [BHF2019] A370 3238 LeG 02 39 55.822 -01 33 59.99           ~ 1 0
51 [BHF2019] A370 2026 LeG 02 39 56.421 -01 34 43.62           ~ 1 0
52 [BHF2019] A370 2843 LeG 02 39 56.595 -01 34 16.69           ~ 4 0
53 [BHF2019] A370 2356 LeG 02 39 56.708 -01 34 30.72           ~ 1 0
54 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 2867 LeG 02 39 58.1152 -01 34 15.176           ~ 2 0
55 [MAC2016] M0416cl 21659 LeG 04 16 04.568 -24 04 23.88   29.2305     30.2411 ~ 3 0
56 [MAC2016] M0416cl 1253 LeG 04 16 04.640 -24 04 30.55           ~ 3 0
57 [MAC2016] M0416cl 21216 LeG 04 16 04.880 -24 04 42.55         30.3791 ~ 3 0
58 [MAC2016] M0416cl 20722 LeG 04 16 05.382 -24 05 00.96         30.0738 ~ 3 0
59 [MAC2016] M0416cl 21864 LeG 04 16 05.859 -24 04 15.47           ~ 3 0
60 [HBH2019] MACS0416-032 LeG 04 16 06.581 -24 05 23.92   27.5364 27.2506   29.9415 ~ 4 0
61 [BIO2017] M0416I-6082905229 LeG 04 16 08.295 -24 05 22.93         29.0465 ~ 10 0
62 MCS J0416.1-2403 ClG 04 16 08.380 -24 04 20.80           ~ 425 0
63 [BIO2017] M0416I-6089603288 LeG 04 16 08.967 -24 03 28.79         29.7575 ~ 5 0
64 [BIO2017] M0416I-6089903404 LeG 04 16 08.996 -24 03 40.44         28.8219 ~ 10 0
65 [BCM2019b] 393 LeG 04 16 09.020 -24 05 17.17         30.3809 ~ 15 0
66 [MAC2016] M0416cl 20594 LeG 04 16 09.104 -24 05 07.49         30.4233 ~ 3 0
67 [MAC2016] M0416cl 20914 LeG 04 16 09.113 -24 04 53.22         30.5433 ~ 3 0
68 [BIO2017] M0416I-6091105128 LeG 04 16 09.117 -24 05 12.81         29.9753 ~ 4 0
69 [MAC2016] M0416cl 111 LeG 04 16 09.179 -24 05 33.99   29.8374 28.2875   31.8030 ~ 3 0
70 [IKO2018] HFF2C-0924-5133 LeG 04 16 09.240 -24 05 13.34         30.0221 ~ 7 0
71 [MAC2016] M0416cl 22035 LeG 04 16 09.353 -24 04 10.27     27.4767   28.9617 ~ 3 0
72 [MAC2016] M0416cl 21997 LeG 04 16 09.393 -24 04 09.97     30.1291   34.9319 ~ 3 0
73 ALMA J041609.4-240535 LeG 04 16 09.401 -24 05 35.47         28.96 ~ 67 0
74 [MAC2016] M0416cl 139 LeG 04 16 09.423 -24 05 30.52   28.7527 27.4572     ~ 4 0
75 CLASH MACSJ0416.1-2403 1821 LeG 04 16 09.4889 -24 05 18.742         27.6588 ~ 10 0
76 CLASH MACSJ0416.1-2403 419 LeG 04 16 09.609 -24 03 42.64         28.6181 ~ 12 0
77 [CBZ2015] FFC2-0972-5201 LeG 04 16 09.719 -24 05 20.07           ~ 4 0
78 [MAC2016] M0416cl 20618 LeG 04 16 09.770 -24 05 06.36         30.2997 ~ 3 0
79 [LFL2017] M0416 z8 2943 LeG 04 16 09.937 -24 04 44.13           ~ 4 0
80 [BIO2017] M0416I-6101705454 LeG 04 16 10.177 -24 05 45.45         29.8944 ~ 5 0
81 [BIO2017] M0416I-6102005417 LeG 04 16 10.205 -24 05 41.76         30.0420 ~ 4 0
82 CLASHVLT J041610.31-240325.9 EmG 04 16 10.307 -24 03 25.86         29.3804 ~ 15 0
83 CLASHVLT J041610.46-240332.4 EmG 04 16 10.457 -24 03 32.41         28.6567 ~ 14 0
84 [BIO2017] M0416I-6106703335 LeG 04 16 10.675 -24 03 33.52         29.5797 ~ 6 0
85 [MAC2016] M0416cl 21650 LeG 04 16 11.058 -24 04 24.37         30.6371 ~ 3 0
86 [MAC2016] M0416cl 22746 LeG 04 16 11.162 -24 03 41.87           ~ 4 0
87 [BIO2017] M0416I-6113103400 LeG 04 16 11.316 -24 03 40.08     30.7034   28.9774 ~ 10 0
88 [MAC2016] M0416cl 13 LeG 04 16 11.417 -24 05 49.47   30.0833 26.7630   26.1621 ~ 4 0
89 CLASH MACSJ0416.1-2403 427 EmG 04 16 11.4836 -24 03 43.448         28.2550 ~ 23 0
90 [BCM2019b] 1040 LeG 04 16 11.515 -24 04 53.99           ~ 17 0
91 [BCM2019b] 1065 LeG 04 16 11.534 -24 04 53.14   29.9978       ~ 14 0
92 [MAC2016] M0416cl 20465 LeG 04 16 11.781 -24 05 13.08           ~ 3 0
93 CLASHVLT J041611.83-240415.4 EmG 04 16 11.829 -24 04 15.38         29.9194 ~ 7 0
94 [HBH2019] MACS0416-030 LeG 04 16 11.900 -24 03 52.55           ~ 6 0
95 [BIO2017] M0416I-6120203507 LeG 04 16 12.019 -24 03 50.77         30.0131 ~ 4 0
96 CLASHVLT J041612.21-240359.5 LeG 04 16 12.206 -24 03 59.55         28.1991 ~ 14 0
97 [IKO2018] HFF2C-1225-3594 LeG 04 16 12.259 -24 03 59.46         29.9931 ~ 8 0
98 [MAC2016] M0416cl 735 LeG 04 16 13.054 -24 04 53.98   27.2117 26.7711   25.9828 ~ 3 0
99 [MAC2016] M0717cl 20950 LeG 07 17 28.929 +37 44 20.19           ~ 1 0
100 [MAC2016] M0717cl 332 LeG 07 17 30.377 +37 43 53.33           ~ 1 0
101 [MAC2016] M0717cl 392 LeG 07 17 30.436 +37 43 57.09           ~ 1 0
102 CLASH MACSJ0717.5+3745 370 LeG 07 17 30.4840 +37 44 11.160         29.29 ~ 7 0
103 [MAC2016] M0717cl 374 LeG 07 17 30.529 +37 43 55.86           ~ 1 0
104 [MAC2016] M0717cl 1095 LeG 07 17 30.626 +37 44 30.47           ~ 1 0
105 [MAC2016] M0717cl 356 LeG 07 17 30.762 +37 43 54.85           ~ 1 0
106 [MAC2016] M0717cl 250 LeG 07 17 30.894 +37 43 45.85           ~ 1 0
107 [MAC2016] M0717cl 208 LeG 07 17 30.895 +37 43 41.61           ~ 1 0
108 [MAC2016] M0717cl 246 LeG 07 17 30.917 +37 43 44.91           ~ 1 0
109 [IKO2018] HFF3C-3096-4181 LeG 07 17 30.968 +37 44 18.19         30.09 ~ 5 0
110 [MAC2016] M0717cl 203 LeG 07 17 31.091 +37 43 42.23           ~ 1 0
111 [BIO2017] M0717I-7312944580 LeG 07 17 31.296 +37 44 58.05           ~ 3 0
112 [BIO2017] M0717I-7314543538 LeG 07 17 31.450 +37 43 53.78         28.83 ~ 8 0
113 [MAC2016] M0717cl 136 LeG 07 17 31.551 +37 43 34.91           ~ 1 0
114 [MAC2016] M0717cl 2169 LeG 07 17 32.296 +37 45 10.82           ~ 1 0
115 [MAC2016] M0717cl 23588 LeG 07 17 32.432 +37 45 32.07           ~ 1 0
116 CLASH MACSJ0717.5+3745 1077 LeG 07 17 32.6940 +37 45 06.942         28.98 ~ 8 0
117 [BIO2017] M0717I-7334243294 LeG 07 17 33.4261 +37 43 29.484         29.19 ~ 7 0
118 CLASH MACSJ0717.5+3745 1749 LeG 07 17 33.7752 +37 44 32.014         26.3 ~ 6 0
119 [MAC2016] M0717cl 797 LeG 07 17 34.058 +37 44 16.78           ~ 1 0
120 CLASH MACSJ0717.5+3745 234 LeG 07 17 35.7888 +37 45 53.850         29.16 ~ 7 0
121 [MAC2016] M0717cl 23536 LeG 07 17 36.030 +37 44 48.48           ~ 1 0
122 ClG J0717+3745 ClG 07 17 36.50 +37 45 23.0           ~ 511 0
123 [BIO2017] M0717I-7367945563 LeG 07 17 36.796 +37 45 56.38           ~ 2 0
124 [IKO2018] HFF3C-3810-4541 LeG 07 17 38.107 +37 44 54.16           ~ 5 0
125 CLASH MACSJ0717.5+3745 859 LeG 07 17 38.170 +37 45 16.87         28.39 ~ 14 0
126 [FLB2020] MACS0717.53 EmG 07 17 39.0850 +37 44 01.695         29.70 ~ 7 0
127 [MAC2016] M0717cl 2368 LeG 07 17 39.106 +37 45 20.13           ~ 1 0
128 [IKO2018] HFF3C-3928-4047 LeG 07 17 39.2791 +37 44 04.699         29.61 ~ 5 0
129 [BIO2017] M0717I-7404744196 LeG 07 17 40.4759 +37 44 19.650         29.74 ~ 7 0
130 [MAC2016] M1149cl 23096 LeG 11 49 31.344 +22 24 19.67           ~ 1 0
131 CLASH MACSJ1149.6+2223 1401 LeG 11 49 31.8119 +22 23 43.489         27.5 ~ 8 0
132 [MAC2016] M1149cl 1243 LeG 11 49 32.289 +22 23 33.80           ~ 1 0
133 [BIO2017] M1149I-9323122579 LeG 11 49 32.315 +22 22 57.91           ~ 5 0
134 [BIO2017] M1149I-9328224046 LeG 11 49 32.827 +22 24 04.67           ~ 5 0
135 [BIO2017] M1149I-9330524210 LeG 11 49 33.050 +22 24 21.01           ~ 6 0
136 [MAC2016] M1149cl 22863 LeG 11 49 33.164 +22 24 12.39           ~ 1 0
137 CLASH MACSJ1149.6+2223 2104 LeG 11 49 33.2138 +22 22 56.601         28.5 ~ 7 0
138 [MAC2016] M1149cl 20570 LeG 11 49 34.329 +22 22 52.76           ~ 1 0
139 [MAC2016] M1149cl 354 LeG 11 49 34.329 +22 22 52.77           ~ 1 0
140 [MAC2016] M1149cl 22717 LeG 11 49 34.343 +22 24 07.70           ~ 1 0
141 [BIO2017] M1149I-9353523161 LeG 11 49 35.350 +22 23 16.10           ~ 2 0
142 MCS J1149.5+2223 ClG 11 49 35.8 +22 23 55           ~ 546 0
143 [BIO2017] M1149I-9366524526 LeG 11 49 36.654 +22 24 52.61           ~ 6 0
144 [MAC2016] M1149cl 23485 LeG 11 49 36.724 +22 24 34.20           ~ 1 0
145 [MAC2016] M1149cl 2619 LeG 11 49 36.724 +22 24 34.21           ~ 1 0
146 [MAC2016] M1149cl 2316 LeG 11 49 37.844 +22 24 18.90           ~ 1 0
147 [IKO2018] HFF4C-3791-4415 LeG 11 49 37.916 +22 24 41.54           ~ 5 0
148 [BIO2017] M1149I-9382624295 LeG 11 49 38.261 +22 24 29.53           ~ 2 0
149 [MAC2016] M1149cl 24039 LeG 11 49 38.884 +22 24 56.80           ~ 1 0
150 [MAC2016] M1149cl 3054 LeG 11 49 38.884 +22 24 56.80           ~ 1 0
151 [MAC2016] M1149cl 2966 LeG 11 49 39.104 +22 24 49.11           ~ 1 0
152 [MAC2016] M1149cl 23874 LeG 11 49 39.104 +22 24 49.12           ~ 1 0
153 [IKO2018] HFF4C-3952-5014 LeG 11 49 39.526 +22 25 01.42           ~ 6 0
154 [BIO2017] M1149I-9404224206 LeG 11 49 40.426 +22 24 20.51           ~ 5 0
155 [BIO2017] M1149I-9404742299 LeG 11 49 40.470 +22 24 22.99           ~ 2 0
156 [MAC2016] M1149cl 825 LeG 11 49 42.063 +22 23 10.98           ~ 1 0
157 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 1690 LeG 22 48 39.447 -44 31 48.81           ~ 4 0
158 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 2955 LeG 22 48 39.730 -44 30 52.80           ~ 1 0
159 CLASH RXJ2248-4431 1551 LeG 22 48 40.3165 -44 32 33.024         27.0 ~ 3 0
160 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 2932 LeG 22 48 40.776 -44 30 54.56           ~ 1 0
161 CLASH RXJ2248-4431 401 LeG 22 48 41.110 -44 31 11.41         27.4 ~ 16 0
162 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 2608 LeG 22 48 41.280 -44 31 09.59           ~ 1 0
163 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 438 LeG 22 48 41.538 -44 32 42.90           ~ 1 0
164 CLASH RXJ2248-4431 743 LeG 22 48 41.5986 -44 31 33.361         29.6 ~ 4 0
165 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 3001 LeG 22 48 41.752 -44 30 50.72           ~ 1 0
166 CLASH RXJ2248-4431 1563 LeG 22 48 42.2705 -44 32 33.620         28.2 ~ 5 0
167 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 247 LeG 22 48 42.4924 -44 32 53.976           ~ 2 0
168 CLASH RXJ2248-4431 1722 LeG 22 48 42.6525 -44 32 48.976         28.3 ~ 5 0
169 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 2086 LeG 22 48 43.164 -44 31 32.38           ~ 3 0
170 [BCR2013] L2 LeG 22 48 43.450 -44 32 04.66         26.4 ~ 15 0
171 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 2048 LeG 22 48 43.744 -44 31 33.87           ~ 3 0
172 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 1143 LeG 22 48 44.142 -44 32 07.14           ~ 1 0
173 ACO S 1063 ClG 22 48 45.4 -44 31 42           ~ 395 0
174 CLASH RXJ2248-4431 847 LeG 22 48 45.370 -44 31 48.06         25.2 ~ 16 0
175 CLASH RXJ2248-4431 1291 LeG 22 48 45.810 -44 32 14.86         25.9 ~ 31 0
176 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 617 LeG 22 48 46.506 -44 32 33.80           ~ 1 0
177 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 242 LeG 22 48 46.704 -44 32 54.25           ~ 1 0
178 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 1142 LeG 22 48 47.650 -44 32 07.12           ~ 1 0
179 [BHF2019] RXCJ2248 165 LeG 22 48 48.462 -44 32 59.66           ~ 1 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2022MNRAS.514.1148Y and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu