2022MNRAS.515.3184H


Query : 2022MNRAS.515.3184H

2022MNRAS.515.3184H - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 515, 3184-3198 (2022/September-3)

Integrated mass-loss of evolved stars in M4 using asteroseismology.

HOWELL M., CAMPBELL S.W., STELLO D. and DE SILVA G.M.

Abstract (from CDS):

Mass-loss remains a major uncertainty in stellar modelling. In low-mass stars, mass-loss is most significant on the red giant branch (RGB), and will impact the star's evolutionary path and final stellar remnant. Directly measuring the mass difference of stars in various phases of evolution represents one of the best ways to quantify integrated mass-loss. Globular clusters (GCs) are ideal objects for this. M4 is currently the only GC for which asteroseismic data exist for stars in multiple phases of evolution. Using K2 photometry, we report asteroseismic masses for 75 red giants in M4, the largest seismic sample in a GC to date. We find an integrated RGB mass-loss of $\Delta \overline{M} = 0.17 \pm 0.01 ~\mathrm{M}_{\odot }$, equivalent to a Reimers' mass-loss coefficient of ηR = 0.39. Our results for initial mass, horizontal branch mass, ηR, and integrated RGB mass-loss show remarkable agreement with previous studies, but with higher precision using asteroseismology. We also report the first detections of solar-like oscillations in early asymptotic giant branch (EAGB) stars in GCs. We find an average mass of $\overline{M}_{\text{EAGB}}=0.54 \pm 0.01 ~\mathrm{M}_{\odot }$, significantly lower than predicted by models. This suggests larger-than-expected mass-loss on the horizontal branch. Alternatively, it could indicate unknown systematics in the scaling relations for the EAGB. We discover a tentative mass bimodality in the RGB sample, possibly due to the multiple populations. In our red horizontal branch sample, we find a mass distribution consistent with a single value. We emphasize the importance of seismic studies of GCs since they could potentially resolve major uncertainties in stellar theory.

Abstract Copyright: © The Author(s) 2022. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): asteroseismology - stars: low-mass - stars: mass-loss - stars: oscillations - galaxies: star clusters: individual: NGC 6121 (M4)

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/MNRAS/515/3184): table2.dat>

Simbad objects: 83

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 83
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NGC 2682 OpC 08 51 23.5 +11 48 54           ~ 2528 0
2 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3677 0
3 M 3 GlC 13 42 11.62 +28 22 38.2     6.39     ~ 2593 0
4 2MASS J16230063-2618065 AB* 16 23 00.6361570104 -26 18 06.699454848 14.39 13.63 12.43 12.202 10.87 ~ 10 0
5 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2314 RG* 16 23 02.6724730512 -26 29 28.297399308 15.43 14.41 13.09   11.34 ~ 15 0
6 NGC 6121 314 RG* 16 23 04.3810595256 -26 23 43.069565040 14.75 13.303 11.817   10.100 ~ 41 0
7 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 33584 RG* 16 23 09.9291214416 -26 28 33.625764660 16.14 15.60 14.50   13.026 ~ 10 0
8 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 43 RG* 16 23 11.5355195904 -26 26 40.835287392 15.91 15.12 13.877   12.287 ~ 13 0
9 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 259 RG* 16 23 12.0579925536 -26 29 43.734852096 16.08 15.501 14.327   12.85 ~ 12 0
10 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2205 HB* 16 23 12.3784849944 -26 21 58.488783084   14.55 13.61     ~ 8 0
11 NGC 6121 424 RG* 16 23 16.9017005856 -26 29 47.955475500 15.28 14.389 13.100   11.559 ~ 22 0
12 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 50 RG* 16 23 17.2944771432 -26 24 57.886602480 16.09 15.389 14.160   12.65 ~ 11 0
13 NGC 6121 350 * 16 23 17.6437360368 -26 27 10.283513868   14.35 13.38     ~ 9 0
14 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 256 RG* 16 23 17.9139691056 -26 30 05.960294496 13.3 15.03 13.85     ~ 10 0
15 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 264 * 16 23 18.20 -26 29 07.4   15.98 14.85     ~ 4 0
16 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 270 RG* 16 23 21.4120564944 -26 28 33.576492540 16.17 15.54 14.42     ~ 14 0
17 NGC 6121 352 RG* 16 23 21.6956365512 -26 26 46.944146328 15.61 14.821 13.565   12.031 ~ 21 0
18 NGC 6121 273 RG* 16 23 21.8745001152 -26 17 16.085065956   14.35 12.96     ~ 13 0
19 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 33946 RG* 16 23 21.9541703184 -26 30 32.055462756 15.63 14.878 13.643   12.148 ~ 17 0
20 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 258 RG* 16 23 22.5271470048 -26 29 42.277971840 13.64 15.254 14.046     ~ 7 0
21 NGC 6121 353 RG* 16 23 22.6533747336 -26 26 22.202991384 15.02 14.032 12.651   11.014 ~ 21 0
22 Cl* NGC 6121 S 1753 RG* 16 23 23.0205576120 -26 30 33.673417092 15.48 14.661 13.459   11.906 ~ 11 0
23 NGC 6121 1 * 16 23 23.4162305124 -26 29 09.816025196   14.47 13.43     ~ 5 0
24 NGC 6121 35 RG* 16 23 24.0238740192 -26 30 00.551004264 15.17 14.128 12.776   11.162 ~ 20 0
25 NGC 6121 2 RG* 16 23 24.9961632504 -26 29 25.029889944 15.66 14.937 13.725   12.239 ~ 17 0
26 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 435 RG* 16 23 25.0802402016 -26 29 53.079367560   15.217 14.044   12.523 ~ 14 0
27 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 454 * 16 23 27.8582934144 -26 29 11.556924972   15.423 14.256     ~ 5 0
28 NGC 6121 357 HB* 16 23 28.1465792845 -26 26 08.566699800   14.369 13.252 13.131   ~ 12 0
29 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 290 RG* 16 23 29.3824626264 -26 26 27.709318968 16.22 15.67 14.63   13.01 ~ 9 0
30 NGC 6121 6 RG* 16 23 29.5109139504 -26 29 11.711659776 14.88 13.678 12.246   10.565 ~ 35 0
31 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 54 RG* 16 23 29.8236396144 -26 23 25.343658672 15.46 14.387 13.044   11.448 ~ 14 0
32 2MASS J16233067-2629390 AB* 16 23 30.6776799888 -26 29 39.158959344 14.39 13.724 12.543   11.086 ~ 6 0
33 UCAC4 318-088632 RG* 16 23 31.2974646816 -26 25 15.782592468 16.39 15.8 14.71 14.428 13.22 ~ 4 0
34 NGC 6121 47 RG* 16 23 31.4508993312 -26 30 24.792840288 14.98 13.864 12.471   10.834 ~ 21 0
35 2MASS J16233236-2629222 RG* 16 23 32.3636738232 -26 29 22.281240948 15.66 14.992 13.880   12.368 ~ 18 0
36 NGC 6121 361 RG* 16 23 32.3708260704 -26 26 20.601330540 15.23 14.364 13.061   11.489 ~ 23 0
37 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 57 RG* 16 23 32.5065194187 -26 24 34.117730502   14.82 13.55 13.282   ~ 8 0
38 NGC 6121 365 HB* 16 23 32.9362150272 -26 27 50.209798320   14.41 13.41     ~ 11 0
39 2MASS J16233380-2627497 RG* 16 23 33.8060898888 -26 27 49.766327352 15.61 14.90 13.677   12.128 ~ 14 0
40 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2704 * 16 23 34.1518999416 -26 30 10.441736640   15.386 14.233     ~ 5 0
41 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 2705 * 16 23 34.1842796856 -26 30 14.739956280   15.644 14.505     ~ 5 0
42 [MPB2015] 41526 * 16 23 34.7673617232 -26 30 08.155203624   15.653 14.526     ~ 3 0
43 M 4 GlC 16 23 35.22 -26 31 32.7           ~ 1978 0
44 NGC 6121 57 * 16 23 35.3675377704 -26 30 10.772823168   14.30 13.36     ~ 5 0
45 NGC 6121 368 * 16 23 35.4337127976 -26 26 00.797392572   14.50 13.50     ~ 6 0
46 NGC 6121 369 RR* 16 23 35.9422591968 -26 26 20.627194128   14.52 13.46     ~ 10 0
47 NGC 6121 60 RG* 16 23 36.5811712320 -26 30 20.101500180 14.86 13.74 12.322   10.613 ~ 20 0
48 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 457 RG* 16 23 37.5081377448 -26 28 39.651177504 13.49 15.215 14.052 13.975   ~ 7 0
49 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 3219 RG* 16 23 37.6810890984 -26 20 38.168819520 16.02 15.26 14.09   12.55 ~ 8 0
50 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 36356 RG* 16 23 37.9512411456 -26 28 41.365716744 15.52 14.759 13.521   12.010 ~ 13 0
51 2MASS J16233846-2629235 AB* 16 23 38.4717394368 -26 29 23.586544392 14.47 13.639 12.370   10.840 ~ 8 0
52 NGC 6121 23 RG* 16 23 38.6102366832 -26 29 15.996407460 15.32 14.48 13.223   11.657 ~ 15 0
53 NGC 6121 66 * 16 23 38.75184 -26 30 00.0072   14.32 13.31     ~ 10 0
54 NGC 6121 370 RG* 16 23 38.8582043016 -26 25 42.784867632 15.26 14.362 13.071   11.528 ~ 26 0
55 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 3218 RG* 16 23 38.9433422448 -26 22 09.505604856 15.60 14.78 13.592   12.033 ~ 15 0
56 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 316 * 16 23 39.8413893768 -26 28 28.994974428   15.841 14.727     ~ 5 0
57 NGC 6121 71 RG* 16 23 40.9146947328 -26 30 09.401896656 15.49 14.78 13.570   12.072 ~ 16 0
58 NGC 6121 29 * 16 23 41.3457277874 -26 29 08.841135799   14.33 13.38     ~ 10 0
59 NGC 6121 72 RG* 16 23 41.7586076760 -26 29 46.773230316 15.68 15.02 13.807   12.284 ~ 18 0
60 Cl* NGC 6121 SAW V54 RG* 16 23 42.8012546448 -26 29 27.609257292 17.79 13.98 12.66 11.86 11.06 ~ 23 0
61 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 318 RG* 16 23 43.0923509424 -26 28 07.468793256 15.50 14.75 13.548   12.047 ~ 21 0
62 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 314 Pe* 16 23 43.2168614136 -26 26 41.805002256   15.286 14.139     ~ 7 0
63 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 309 RG* 16 23 43.5194290104 -26 25 37.522720596 15.99 15.340 14.173   12.74 ~ 11 0
64 2MASS J16234405-2630061 RG* 16 23 44.0648699088 -26 30 06.152203764 14.67 13.262 11.771   10.079 ~ 32 0
65 Cl* NGC 6121 MVP 8460 RG* 16 23 47.3275948128 -26 22 30.069873120 16.14 15.47 14.37   12.92 ~ 13 0
66 NGC 6121 78 RG* 16 23 47.8825228152 -26 29 48.285234744 15.50 14.783 13.575   12.106 ~ 26 0
67 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 3508 RG* 16 23 48.992 -26 29 19.17 15.48 14.94 13.798   12.311 ~ 16 0
68 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 329 RG* 16 23 49.7487658512 -26 28 51.793731156 13.27 15.109 13.975     ~ 11 0
69 NGC 6121 431 RG* 16 23 50.2613060976 -26 29 25.894920300 15.33 14.610 13.408   11.957 ~ 14 0
70 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 70 RG* 16 23 52.3168924224 -26 24 35.134626312 16.26 15.8 14.71     ~ 11 0
71 NGC 6121 385 RG* 16 23 53.0053327056 -26 28 06.600361584 15.43 14.744 13.520   12.033 ~ 20 0
72 2MASS J16235440-2625538 RG* 16 23 54.4034989056 -26 25 53.852181636   13.771 12.475   10.938 ~ 11 0
73 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 346 * 16 23 54.6222570696 -26 29 41.830670148   15.228 14.097     ~ 4 0
74 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 75 RG* 16 23 56.5172003592 -26 25 28.468943400   14.09 13.20     ~ 12 0
75 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 109 RG* 16 23 57.3654678504 -26 29 32.121187080   15.55 14.48     ~ 10 0
76 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 73 RG* 16 23 58.7487813816 -26 24 29.031538572 15.49 14.91 13.78 13.591 12.38 ~ 8 0
77 Cl* NGC 6121 ALC 96 RG* 16 24 00.6064769544 -26 28 20.750658276 15.77 15.266 14.173   12.76 ~ 13 0
78 2MASS J16240858-2624552 AB* 16 24 08.5890044928 -26 24 55.234147608   13.099 11.845   10.307 ~ 28 0
79 Cl* NGC 6121 LEE 3204 RG* 16 24 14.7007412904 -26 27 16.787005704 15.21 14.560 13.347   11.883 ~ 15 0
80 NAME Sco-Oph Cloud ? 16 30 00 -21 30.0           ~ 17 0
81 NGC 6397 GlC 17 40 42.09 -53 40 27.6     5.17     ~ 2103 0
82 NGC 6791 OpC 19 20 52.8 +37 46 40   10.52 9.5     ~ 1120 0
83 NGC 6819 OpC 19 41 18.3 +40 11 19   8.21 7.3     ~ 719 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2022MNRAS.515.3184H and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu