2023A&A...677A..86L


Query : 2023A&A...677A..86L

2023A&A...677A..86L - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 677A86 (2023/9-1)

SHOTGLAS II. MUSE spectroscopy of blue horizontal branch stars in the core of ω Centauri and NGC6752.

LATOUR M., HAMMERICH S., DORSCH M., HEBER U., HUSSER T.-O., KAMMAN S., DREIZLER S. and BRINCHMANN J.

Abstract (from CDS):

Aims. We want to study the population of blue horizontal branch (HB) stars in the centres of globular clusters (GC) for the first time by exploiting the unique combination of MUSE spectroscopy and HST photometry. In this work, we characterize their properties in the GCs ω Cen and NGC 6752.
Methods. We use dedicated model atmospheres and grids of synthetic spectra computed using a hybrid LTE/NLTE modeling approach to fit the MUSE spectra of HB stars hotter than 8000 K in both clusters. The spectral fits provide estimates of the effective temperature (Teff), surface gravity (log ɡ), and helium abundance of the stars. The model grids are further used to fit the HST magnitudes of the stars, that is, their spectral energy distributions (SEDs). From the SED fits, we derive the average reddening, radius, luminosity, and mass of the stars in our sample.
Results. The atmospheric and stellar properties that we derive for the stars in our sample are in good agreement with theoretical expectations. In particular, the stars cooler than ∼15 000 K closely follow the theoretical predictions on radius, log ɡ, and luminosity for helium-normal (Y = 0.25) models. In ω Cen, we show that the majority of these cooler HB stars cannot originate from a helium-enriched population with Y > 0.35. The properties of the hotter stars (radii and luminosities) are still in reasonable agreement with theoretical expectations, but the individual measurements show a large scatter. For these hot stars, we find a mismatch between the effective temperatures indicated from the MUSE spectral fits and the photometric fits, with the latter returning Teff lower by ∼3000 K. We use three different diagnostics, namely the position of the G-jump and changes in metallicity and helium abundances, to place the onset of diffusion in the stellar atmospheres at Teff between 11 000 and 11 500 K. Our sample includes two stars known as photometric variables; we confirm one to be a bona fide extreme HB object but the other is a blue straggler star. Finally, unlike what has been reported in the literature, we do not find significant differences between the properties (e.g., log ɡ, radius, and luminosity) of the stars in the two clusters.
Conclusions. We show that our analysis method - combining MUSE spectra and HST photometry of HB stars in GCs - is a powerful tool for characterising their stellar properties. With the availability of MUSE and HST observations of additional GCs, we have a unique opportunity to combine homogeneous spectroscopic and photometric data to study and compare the properties of blue HB stars in different GCs.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2023

Journal keyword(s): stars: fundamental parameters - stars: horizontal-branch - globular clusters: individual: NGC 5139 - globular clusters: individual: NGC 6752

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/677/A86): tableb1.dat-tableb6.dat>

Errata: erratum vol. 685, art. C2 (2024)

Status at CDS : All or part of tables of objects will be ingested in SIMBAD with priority 1.

Simbad objects: 152

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 152
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NGC 1851 GlC 05 14 06.76 -40 02 47.6           ~ 1529 0
2 NGC 2808 GlC 09 12 03.10 -64 51 48.6           ~ 1540 0
3 NAME Virgo Cluster ClG 12 30 47.8 +12 23 07           ~ 7107 0
4 Cl* NGC 5139 UIT 1 * 13 26 45.1 -47 27 11           ~ 5 0
5 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3677 0
6 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7     5.95     ~ 2095 0
7 NGC 5986 GlC 15 46 03.00 -37 47 11.1     6.92     ~ 408 0
8 M 80 GlC 16 17 02.41 -22 58 33.9           ~ 780 0
9 M 13 GlC 16 41 41.634 +36 27 40.75     5.8     ~ 2291 0
10 M 14 GlC 17 37 36.15 -03 14 45.3   9.55 5.73     ~ 420 0
11 NGC 6397 162 HS* 17 40 38.4613882368 -53 38 31.347142908   13.06 13.23     sdOp 47 1
12 NGC 6397 GlC 17 40 42.09 -53 40 27.6     5.17     ~ 2103 0
13 M 22 GlC 18 36 23.94 -23 54 17.1           ~ 1459 0
14 M 54 GlC 18 55 03.33 -30 28 47.5           ~ 1164 0
15 NAME SDG G 18 55 19.0 -30 32 43   4.5 3.6     ~ 2438 2
16 2MASS J19103751-5959361 HB* 19 10 37.51584 -59 59 36.1608     15.09     ~ 3 0
17 GES J19103817-5959553 HB* 19 10 38.1893877312 -59 59 55.330080936     14.68     ~ 3 0
18 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 23807 HB* 19 10 39.486 -59 59 21.33           ~ 1 0
19 2MASS J19103987-5958561 HB* 19 10 39.87960 -59 58 56.1432           ~ 2 0
20 GES J19104031-5959047 HB* 19 10 40.3188080858 -59 59 04.792673106 13.937 13.858 13.800     ~ 4 0
21 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 23188 HB* 19 10 41.371 -59 59 19.32           ~ 1 0
22 GES J19104138-5959130 HB* 19 10 41.382 -59 59 13.02     14.35     ~ 2 0
23 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 23093 HB* 19 10 41.606 -59 59 50.21           ~ 1 0
24 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 23081 HB* 19 10 41.734 -59 59 09.97           ~ 1 0
25 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 22586 HB* 19 10 42.9654591030 -59 59 30.037240327           ~ 2 0
26 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 39125 HB* 19 10 45.833 -59 58 52.06           ~ 1 0
27 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 21185 HB* 19 10 46.104 -59 59 16.47           ~ 1 0
28 [BH2018] J287.692417-59.974722 HB* 19 10 46.180 -59 58 29.00           ~ 2 0
29 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 20877 HB* 19 10 46.459 -59 59 40.32           ~ 1 0
30 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 38786 HB* 19 10 46.474 -59 58 31.50           ~ 1 0
31 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 38725 HB* 19 10 46.564 -59 58 57.78           ~ 1 0
32 GES J19104675-5959424 HB* 19 10 46.7376463769 -59 59 42.513000123           ~ 2 0
33 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 38598 HB* 19 10 46.839 -59 58 29.49           ~ 1 0
34 [BH2018] J287.695292-59.964472 HB* 19 10 46.870 -59 57 52.10           ~ 2 0
35 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 49278 HB* 19 10 46.876 -59 58 02.06           ~ 1 0
36 2MASS J19104728-5958549 HB* 19 10 47.28096 -59 58 54.9192           ~ 2 0
37 GES J19104732-5958279 HB* 19 10 47.329 -59 58 27.92     14.84     ~ 3 0
38 [BH2018] J287.697333-59.954028 HB* 19 10 47.360 -59 57 14.50           ~ 2 0
39 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 38141 HB* 19 10 47.449 -59 58 54.04           ~ 1 0
40 [BH2018] J287.698875-59.987389 HB* 19 10 47.730 -59 59 14.60           ~ 2 0
41 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 48948 HB* 19 10 47.774 -59 57 57.93           ~ 1 0
42 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 37973 HB* 19 10 47.799 -59 58 35.47           ~ 1 0
43 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 20102 HB* 19 10 47.822 -59 59 07.38           ~ 1 0
44 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 37802 HB* 19 10 47.951 -59 59 06.17           ~ 1 0
45 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 37882 HB* 19 10 47.967 -59 58 29.57           ~ 1 0
46 GES J19104801-5958336 HB* 19 10 48.018 -59 58 33.61     14.63     ~ 2 0
47 GES J19104806-5958459 HB* 19 10 48.06 -59 58 45.9           ~ 2 0
48 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 19848 HB* 19 10 48.167 -59 59 15.25           ~ 1 0
49 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 37550 HB* 19 10 48.449 -59 58 33.79           ~ 1 0
50 [BH2018] J287.702792-59.991056 HB* 19 10 48.670 -59 59 27.80           ~ 2 0
51 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 19331 HB* 19 10 48.827 -59 59 54.92           ~ 1 0
52 [BH2018] J287.703542-59.986528 HB* 19 10 48.850 -59 59 11.50           ~ 2 0
53 [BH2018] J287.704458-59.959389 HB* 19 10 49.070 -59 57 33.80           ~ 2 0
54 GES J19104924-5959396 HB* 19 10 49.2411685457 -59 59 39.646041903           ~ 3 0
55 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 37003 HB* 19 10 49.386 -59 58 19.75           ~ 1 0
56 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 36991 HB* 19 10 49.425 -59 58 25.25           ~ 1 0
57 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 18893 HB* 19 10 49.468 -59 59 38.17           ~ 1 0
58 [BH2018] J287.706542-59.992417 HB* 19 10 49.570 -59 59 32.70           ~ 2 0
59 [BH2018] J287.706583-59.983167 HB* 19 10 49.580 -59 58 59.40           ~ 2 0
60 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 36680 HB* 19 10 49.749 -59 58 55.86           ~ 1 0
61 [BH2018] J287.707833-59.997556 HB* 19 10 49.880 -59 59 51.20           ~ 2 0
62 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 18703 HB* 19 10 49.916 -59 59 13.06           ~ 1 0
63 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 36271 HB* 19 10 50.183 -59 59 03.49           ~ 1 0
64 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 36281 HB* 19 10 50.213 -59 59 01.07           ~ 1 0
65 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 18416 HB* 19 10 50.262 -59 59 23.96           ~ 1 0
66 GES J19105043-5959179 HB* 19 10 50.4341737320 -59 59 17.975294426           ~ 2 0
67 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 35974 HB* 19 10 50.552 -59 58 58.13           ~ 1 0
68 [BH2018] J287.710792-59.957639 HB* 19 10 50.590 -59 57 27.50           ~ 2 0
69 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 47659 HB* 19 10 50.712 -59 58 11.54           ~ 1 0
70 GES J19105085-5959029 HB* 19 10 50.8587800659 -59 59 02.906194390           ~ 2 0
71 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 35326 HB* 19 10 51.159 -59 59 06.37           ~ 1 0
72 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 35475 HB* 19 10 51.190 -59 58 22.00           ~ 1 0
73 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 35473 HB* 19 10 51.218 -59 58 23.16           ~ 1 0
74 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 17657 HB* 19 10 51.223 -59 59 07.61           ~ 1 0
75 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 35472 HB* 19 10 51.229 -59 58 22.80           ~ 1 0
76 GES J19105125-5958272 HB* 19 10 51.2547720935 -59 58 27.251655503           ~ 2 0
77 Cl* NGC 6752 DSZ 3 HB* 19 10 51.357 -59 58 56.35 16.800 17.09 16.67     ~ 2 0
78 GES J19105138-5958435 HB* 19 10 51.3909748182 -59 58 43.547516674           ~ 2 0
79 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 35208 HB* 19 10 51.393 -59 58 59.34           ~ 1 0
80 Cl* NGC 6752 DSZ 18 BS* 19 10 51.3961259760 -59 58 42.297088836 15.860 15.86 15.75     ~ 4 0
81 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 47365 HB* 19 10 51.406 -59 58 12.39           ~ 1 0
82 Cl* NGC 6752 DSZ 2 HB* 19 10 51.627 -59 58 55.41 14.610 15.67 15.82     ~ 2 0
83 2MASS J19105167-6000349 HB* 19 10 51.67440 -60 00 34.9632           ~ 2 0
84 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 34864 HB* 19 10 51.705 -59 58 55.91           ~ 1 0
85 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 17069 HB* 19 10 51.806 -59 59 07.54           ~ 1 0
86 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 17058 HB* 19 10 51.831 -59 59 08.39           ~ 1 0
87 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 16962 HB* 19 10 51.845 -59 59 37.23           ~ 1 0
88 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 34548 HB* 19 10 51.960 -59 58 28.40           ~ 1 0
89 [LMD2013] BSS2 BS* 19 10 52.0475 -59 59 04.647     15.62   15.48 ~ 2 0
90 NGC 6752 GlC 19 10 52.11 -59 59 04.4           ~ 2121 0
91 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 16746 HB* 19 10 52.176 -59 59 09.57           ~ 1 0
92 Cl* NGC 6752 DSZ 8 HB* 19 10 52.263 -59 59 07.85 16.870 17.10 16.71     ~ 2 0
93 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 16415 HB* 19 10 52.450 -59 59 11.18           ~ 1 0
94 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 16331 HB* 19 10 52.489 -59 59 38.46           ~ 1 0
95 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 33926 HB* 19 10 52.497 -59 58 48.42           ~ 1 0
96 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 46925 HB* 19 10 52.582 -59 57 36.43           ~ 1 0
97 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 33761 HB* 19 10 52.653 -59 58 45.34           ~ 1 0
98 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 33452 HB* 19 10 52.992 -59 58 47.16           ~ 1 0
99 GES J19105307-5959565 HB* 19 10 53.079 -59 59 56.53     15.49     ~ 2 0
100 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 1081 HB* 19 10 53.081 -60 00 54.24           ~ 1 0
101 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 33332 HB* 19 10 53.111 -59 58 39.49           ~ 1 0
102 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 15807 HB* 19 10 53.160 -59 59 10.24           ~ 1 0
103 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 33174 HB* 19 10 53.309 -59 58 38.17           ~ 1 0
104 GES J19105338-5958446 HB* 19 10 53.3848409925 -59 58 44.574859715           ~ 3 0
105 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 33085 HB* 19 10 53.400 -59 59 06.15           ~ 1 0
106 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 15474 HB* 19 10 53.507 -59 59 25.84           ~ 1 0
107 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 4679 HB* 19 10 53.582 -60 00 06.79           ~ 1 0
108 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 33067 HB* 19 10 53.589 -59 58 23.39           ~ 1 0
109 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 32816 HB* 19 10 53.627 -59 58 59.49           ~ 1 0
110 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 32820 HB* 19 10 53.725 -59 58 55.86           ~ 1 0
111 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 32717 HB* 19 10 53.856 -59 58 45.42           ~ 1 0
112 GES J19105385-5959380 HB* 19 10 53.8604738693 -59 59 38.049832619 13.736 13.661 13.584     ~ 3 0
113 GES J19105390-5959237 HB* 19 10 53.9034675247 -59 59 23.749375584           ~ 2 0
114 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 4464 HB* 19 10 53.943 -60 00 21.08           ~ 1 0
115 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 15070 HB* 19 10 54.030 -59 59 47.16           ~ 1 0
116 GES J19105424-5959481 HB* 19 10 54.2530570005 -59 59 48.120718964     14.40     ~ 3 0
117 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 860 HB* 19 10 54.530 -60 01 01.86           ~ 1 0
118 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 14687 HB* 19 10 54.651 -59 59 12.20           ~ 1 0
119 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 14698 HB* 19 10 54.670 -59 59 08.29           ~ 1 0
120 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 14557 HB* 19 10 54.789 -59 59 17.11           ~ 1 0
121 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 31911 HB* 19 10 54.803 -59 58 37.49           ~ 1 0
122 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 4059 HB* 19 10 54.942 -60 00 41.49           ~ 1 0
123 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 31779 HB* 19 10 54.989 -59 58 43.76           ~ 1 0
124 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 14385 HB* 19 10 55.054 -59 59 52.57           ~ 1 0
125 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 3990 HB* 19 10 55.115 -60 00 37.10           ~ 1 0
126 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 738 HB* 19 10 55.431 -60 01 01.07           ~ 1 0
127 GES J19105562-5959412 HB* 19 10 55.620 -59 59 41.23     14.94     ~ 2 0
128 2MASS J19105565-6001000 HB* 19 10 55.6465321657 -60 00 59.902260275           ~ 3 0
129 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 14045 HB* 19 10 55.717 -59 59 23.49           ~ 1 0
130 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 13884 HB* 19 10 55.854 -59 59 48.97           ~ 1 0
131 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 31030 HB* 19 10 55.999 -59 58 41.84           ~ 1 0
132 [BH2018] J287.733375-59.985778 HB* 19 10 56.010 -59 59 08.80           ~ 2 0
133 GES J19105600-5958270 HB* 19 10 56.0102780952 -59 58 27.084896364     14.74     ~ 5 0
134 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 3569 HB* 19 10 56.430 -60 00 20.57           ~ 1 0
135 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 13294 HB* 19 10 56.889 -59 59 31.69           ~ 1 0
136 GES J19105712-5959229 HB* 19 10 57.12 -59 59 22.9 13.984 13.927 13.903     ~ 3 0
137 GES J19105740-5959077 HB* 19 10 57.3987605635 -59 59 07.649748457           ~ 2 0
138 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 3188 HB* 19 10 57.440 -60 00 31.96           ~ 1 0
139 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 12828 HB* 19 10 57.612 -59 59 20.10           ~ 1 0
140 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 29979 HB* 19 10 57.692 -59 58 23.03           ~ 1 0
141 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 12813 HB* 19 10 57.732 -59 59 27.51           ~ 1 0
142 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 12705 HB* 19 10 57.914 -59 59 40.61           ~ 1 0
143 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 29643 HB* 19 10 58.226 -59 58 58.91           ~ 1 0
144 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 44211 HB* 19 10 58.987 -59 58 16.37           ~ 1 0
145 GES J19105904-5958592 HB* 19 10 59.0441383575 -59 58 59.305158446           ~ 2 0
146 2MASS J19110119-5958128 HB* 19 11 01.19400 -59 58 12.8820           ~ 2 0
147 [BH2018] J287.760792-59.972417 HB* 19 11 02.590 -59 58 20.70           ~ 2 0
148 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 27298 HB* 19 11 03.534 -59 58 53.09           ~ 1 0
149 [LMD2013] BSS10 BS* 19 11 04.0540582947 -59 59 07.466184506 15.410 15.381 15.27   15.19 ~ 6 0
150 [SBC2007] NGC 6752 9785 HB* 19 11 05.3234374783 -59 59 15.651648526           ~ 2 0
151 Cl* NGC 6752 SAW V16 HB* 19 11 06.4301778381 -59 58 48.271558967 15.598 16.367 16.53     ~ 5 0
152 M 15 GlC 21 29 58.33 +12 10 01.2           ~ 3274 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2023A&A...677A..86L and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu