2023ApJ...942....4X


Query : 2023ApJ...942....4X

2023ApJ...942....4X - Astrophys. J., 942, 4 (2023/January-1)

Measuring the Dust Masses of Protoplanetary Disks in Lupus with ALMA: Evidence That Disks Can Be Optically Thick at 3 mm.

XIN Z., ESPAILLAT C.C., RILINGER A.M., RIBAS A. and MACIAS E.

Abstract (from CDS):

Accurate disk mass measurements are necessary to constrain disk evolution and the timescale of planet formation, but such measurements are difficult to make and are very dependent on assumptions. Here, we look at the assumption that the disk is optically thin at radio wavelengths and the effect of this assumption on measurements of disk dust mass. We model the optical to radio spectral energy distributions of 41 protoplanetary disks located in the young (∼1-3 Myr old) Lupus star-forming region, including 0.89 1.33 and 3 mm flux densities when available. We measure disk dust masses that are ∼1.5-6 times higher than when using the commonly adopted disk dust mass equation under the assumption of optically thin emission in the (sub)millimeter range. The cause of this discrepancy is that most disks are optically thick at millimeter wavelengths, even up to 3 mm, demonstrating that observations at longer wavelengths are needed to trace the fully optically thin emission of disks.

Abstract Copyright: © 2022. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): Protoplanetary disks - T Tauri stars - Neural networks

Errata: erratum vol. 947, art. 91 (2023)

Simbad objects: 74

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 74
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NAME Tau-Aur Complex SFR 04 30 +25.0           ~ 1453 0
2 V* TW Hya TT* 11 01 51.9053285064 -34 42 17.033218380   11.94 10.50 10.626 9.18 K6Ve 2144 1
3 Sz 65 Or* 15 39 27.7716659160 -34 46 17.211087984   13.11 12.13 11.33 10.76 K7 118 0
4 Sz 66 TT* 15 39 28.2828956688 -34 46 18.082914564   14.9   14.51 12.56 M2 75 0
5 Lupus 1 Cld 15 43 02.1 -34 09 06           ~ 320 0
6 2MASS J15450634-3417378 Y*? 15 45 06.34296 -34 17 37.8312           ~ 27 0
7 2MASS J15450887-3417333 Or* 15 45 08.8742780880 -34 17 33.454839372       18.73   M5.5 54 0
8 CD-33 10685 Or* 15 45 12.8678037432 -34 17 30.644403036 12.47 11.56 10.224 9.60 8.685 K3Ve 306 1
9 V* HW Lup Or* 15 45 17.4118414392 -34 18 28.286447220   17.41 16.25     M1 87 0
10 V* GW Lup Or* 15 46 44.7290527536 -34 30 35.677420056   13.8       M1.5e 201 0
11 V* HM Lup Or* 15 47 50.6288371920 -35 28 35.404076028   15.941 14.748 14.337   M3e 103 0
12 THA 15-5 TT* 15 47 56.9427182064 -35 14 34.796420412   14.5 16.2     K7e 95 0
13 V* HN Lup Or* 15 48 05.2154956876 -35 15 53.295162846   16.083 14.377 13.726   M3.5e 69 0
14 V* GQ Lup Or* 15 49 12.1053805848 -35 39 05.058139788 12.19 12.76 11.66 11.15   K7Ve 334 1
15 NAME THA 15-10A Or* 15 55 50.2814014152 -38 01 33.699111168           M4.5 18 0
16 WRAY 15-1384 TT* 15 56 02.0994258408 -36 55 28.274506140 14.91 14.342 13.470 13.311 11.86 M1 56 0
17 THA 15-12 Or* 15 56 09.2066646912 -37 56 06.126118692   13.12 11.93 11.45   M0e 554 0
18 V* RU Lup TT* 15 56 42.3108692112 -37 49 15.473946900 9.27 10.07 9.60     K7/M0e 528 0
19 Lupus 2 MoC 15 57 08 -37 47.1           ~ 119 1
20 Sz 84 TT* 15 58 02.5198436808 -37 36 02.729938536   14.3       M5.0e 85 0
21 WRAY 15-1400 TT* 15 59 16.4717314824 -41 57 10.300018176   13.5 12.0     K7IVe 125 0
22 2MASS J15592523-4235066 Or* 15 59 25.2340111704 -42 35 06.571838868   17.42 16.82     M5 28 0
23 V* RY Lup Or* 15 59 28.3864710696 -40 21 51.249496176   12.62 9.90     G8/K1IV-V 251 0
24 UCAC3 96-205744 Or* 16 00 00.6018563304 -42 21 56.821951152   17.29 15.85 15.25 13.43 M4.5 47 0
25 UCAC3 96-205752 Or* 16 00 02.3583827328 -42 22 14.600258148   16.86 15.46 14.98 13.59 M4 54 0
26 2MASS J16002612-4153553 Or* 16 00 26.1203153232 -41 53 55.371567156   16.57 16.45 15.70 13.80 M5.25 42 0
27 Sz 130 TT* 16 00 31.0374709944 -41 43 36.988516560   15.82 14.71 13.56 12.46 M1.5 73 0
28 V* MY Lup TT* 16 00 44.5202267160 -41 55 30.935126748   12.64 12.17 11.06   K0 144 0
29 Sz 131 Or* 16 00 49.4333360352 -41 30 03.916812096   17.51 16.13 14.60 12.92 M2 55 0
30 2MASS J16011549-4152351 Y*O 16 01 15.49224 -41 52 35.1912           ~ 36 0
31 NAME Lupus Complex SFR 16 03 -38.1           ~ 851 0
32 HD 325367 Or* 16 03 05.4915085848 -40 18 25.426727676   11.40 8.50     M0 406 0
33 Lupus 4 MoC 16 03 12.4 -42 07 43           ~ 163 0
34 Sz 133 Or* 16 03 29.3848659360 -41 40 01.765426548   17.77 16.60 15.78 15.04 K2 50 0
35 V* HO Lup Or* 16 07 00.603672 -39 02 19.49316   13.94 13.17 13.03   M1e 70 0
36 2MASS J16070384-3911113 Or* 16 07 03.84336 -39 11 11.3208       18.79 16.80 M4.5 47 0
37 2MASS J16070854-3914075 LM* 16 07 08.5530917712 -39 14 07.494035352   17.85   18.67 17.86 M1.75 44 0
38 THA 15-21 TT* 16 07 10.0694468880 -39 11 03.260683896   15.28 13.70 13.70 12.49 K7-M0 84 0
39 2MASS J16073773-3921388 Or* 16 07 37.7327699304 -39 21 38.745260928   18.38 17.4 17.12 15.68 M5.5e 48 0
40 Sz 95 TT* 16 07 52.3109740056 -38 58 06.091698756   16.714 15.189 14.934 12.53 ~ 66 0
41 2MASS J16075475-3915446 Y*O 16 07 54.75096 -39 15 44.6328       21.91 19.92 ~ 25 0
42 2MASS J16080017-3902595 Or* 16 08 00.1718615064 -39 02 59.504573976   16.94 17.01 16.72 14.31 M5.5e 53 0
43 Sz 96 TT* 16 08 12.6308620920 -39 08 33.470354256   14.80 13.43 13.69 11.84 ~ 87 0
44 2MASS J16081497-3857145 Or* 16 08 14.9753942112 -38 57 14.409165492       18.93 17.42 4.75 48 0
45 THA 15-24 Or* 16 08 21.8037909864 -39 04 21.491863824   16.18 14.61 14.67 12.92 M3 70 0
46 V* V1279 Sco Or* 16 08 22.4935277520 -39 04 46.427612052   14.99 13.66 11.70 11.21 M0.4 154 1
47 THA 15-26 Or* 16 08 25.7633674272 -39 06 01.247043888   16.62 15.43 14.97 13.12 M5 79 0
48 WRAY 16-203 Or* 16 08 29.7275063376 -39 03 11.024360496   16.26 15.91 15.38 15.69 K0: 180 1
49 THA 15-29 Or* 16 08 30.2687378568 -39 06 11.176056000   14.8 11.14 15.18 13.15 M4 76 0
50 IRAS 16051-3820 Or* 16 08 30.6994064064 -38 28 26.846324004   11.89 11.15 10.67   K2 89 0
51 THA 15-30 TT* 16 08 30.8142130416 -39 05 48.837746436   15.2 15.25 13.96 13.57 M5 73 0
52 V* V856 Sco Ae* 16 08 34.2870044544 -39 06 18.325711332 7.66 7.41 7.05 6.92   A9V_sh 405 0
53 Sz 106 Or* 16 08 39.7597402848 -39 06 25.321212288   15.1   15.00 14.66 M2.5 55 0
54 NAME Sz 108B Or* 16 08 42.8838783888 -39 06 14.692839804       17.71 14.39 M6Ve 44 0
55 IRAS 16054-3857 Or* 16 08 49.3987083072 -39 05 39.447341844   16.76 17.71 15.89 14.24 M4.5 61 0
56 V* V1192 Sco Or* 16 08 51.4348063536 -39 05 30.460358652     21.9 18.97 18.18 M5 78 0
57 V* V1193 Sco Or* 16 08 51.5693655096 -39 03 17.707587264   15.27 14.58 13.72 12.28 M4.5 82 0
58 UCAC3 102-194910 Or* 16 08 53.2420957464 -39 14 40.160339952   17.53 16.35 15.35 13.52 M3 62 1
59 2MASS J16085373-3914367 Or* 16 08 53.7357629040 -39 14 36.799256184       21.73 18.76 M5.5 41 0
60 THA 15-33 TT* 16 08 54.6849382512 -39 37 43.145069664   15.34 13.98 13.29   M1IVe 109 0
61 2MASS J16085529-3848481 Or* 16 08 55.2899613672 -38 48 48.174613416   17.36   17.24 15.24 M6.5 43 1
62 Sz 112 Or* 16 08 55.5289090032 -39 02 33.941081832   16.62 15.39 14.78 12.93 M6 76 0
63 THA 15-34 Or* 16 08 57.8026653048 -39 02 22.853868252   17.46 16.50 16.64 14.65 M6 67 0
64 2MASS J16090141-3925119 Or* 16 09 01.4148377304 -39 25 11.923332420   16.92 15.31 15.04 13.48 M4 58 0
65 THA 15-35 Or* 16 09 01.8486544824 -39 05 12.414717240   15.33 14.12 14.35 12.54 M5.5 142 0
66 2MASS J16092697-3836269 Or* 16 09 26.9795990952 -38 36 26.933727420   17.55   16.31 14.74 M4.5 43 0
67 THA 15-37 Or* 16 09 44.3607357216 -39 13 30.167581764   15.84 14.59 14.20 12.38 M2 70 0
68 Sz 118 Or* 16 09 48.6562295568 -39 11 16.847425032   18.32 16.90 16.61 15.00 K6 76 0
69 2MASS J16095628-3859518 Or* 16 09 56.2954845696 -38 59 51.581549796   17.37 18.0 16.49 15.28 M6.0e 53 0
70 2MASS J16102741-3902299 Y*O 16 10 27.41736 -39 02 29.9760       21.73 19.26 ~ 17 0
71 2MASS J16102955-3922144 Or* 16 10 29.5517478000 -39 22 14.451017844   17.51 16.31 15.79 13.90 M4.5 60 0
72 THA 15-42 Or* 16 10 51.5849835192 -38 53 13.767885384   15.89 14.48 14.44 12.95 M1e 84 0
73 UCAC3 104-204438 Or* 16 12 43.7499349656 -38 15 03.075603264   15.00 13.44 13.39 11.61 M1 62 0
74 2MASS J16134410-3736462 Or* 16 13 44.1007544088 -37 36 46.261518840   17.97   16.37 14.66 M5 36 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2023ApJ...942....4X and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu