2023ApJ...954...41T


Query : 2023ApJ...954...41T

2023ApJ...954...41T - Astrophys. J., 954, 41 (2023/September-1)

How Large Is a Disk-What Do Protoplanetary Disk Gas Sizes Really Mean?

TRAPMAN L., ROSOTTI G., ZHANG K. and TABONE B.

Abstract (from CDS):

It remains unclear what mechanism is driving the evolution of protoplanetary disks. Direct detection of the main candidates, either turbulence driven by magnetorotational instabilities or magnetohydrodynamical disk winds, has proven difficult, leaving the time evolution of the disk size as one of the most promising observables able to differentiate between these two mechanisms. But to do so successfully, we need to understand what the observed gas disk size actually traces. We studied the relation between RCO,90%, the radius that encloses 90% of the 12CO flux, and Rc, the radius that encodes the physical disk size, in order to provide simple prescriptions for conversions between these two sizes. For an extensive grid of thermochemical models, we calculate RCO,90% from synthetic observations and relate properties measured at this radius, such as the gas column density, to bulk disk properties, such as Rc and the disk mass Mdisk. We found an empirical correlation between the gas column density at RCO,90% and disk mass: ${N}_{\mathrm{gas}}{({R}_{\mathrm{CO},90 \% })\approx 3.73\,\times \,{10}^{21}({M}_{\mathrm{disk}}/{M}_{\odot })}^{0.34}\ {\mathrm{cm}}^{-2}$. Using this correlation we derive an analytical prescription of RCO,90% that only depends on Rc and Mdisk. We derive Rc for disks in Lupus, Upper Sco, Taurus, and the DSHARP sample, finding that disks in the older Upper Sco region are significantly smaller (〈Rc〉 = 4.8 au) than disks in the younger Lupus and Taurus regions (〈Rc〉 = 19.8 and 20.9 au, respectively). This temporal decrease in Rc goes against predictions of both viscous and wind-driven evolution, but could be a sign of significant external photoevaporation truncating disks in Upper Sco.

Abstract Copyright: © 2023. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): Protoplanetary disks - Astrochemistry

Simbad objects: 68

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 68
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 [BCG93] 1 TT* 04 14 17.6095515480 +28 06 09.654704388 18.04         M4.5 126 0
2 V* FP Tau Or* 04 14 47.3033083488 +26 46 26.414391720 17.21 16.14 15.02     M4Ve 189 0
3 V* CX Tau Or* 04 14 47.8615248984 +26 48 11.014877916 16.48 15.93 14.50     M1.5Ve 217 0
4 2MASS J04155799+2746175 TT* 04 15 57.9994267200 +27 46 17.332228344           M5.2 50 0
5 2MASS J04202555+2700355 Or* 04 20 25.5570424392 +27 00 35.548485552           M5e 51 0
6 2MASS J04322210+1827426 TT* 04 32 22.1098625760 +18 27 42.649845048           M5.0 78 0
7 V* UZ Tau Or* 04 32 43.02172 +25 52 30.9038           M4Ve+M1/3Ve 323 0
8 V* DL Tau Or* 04 33 39.0767679288 +25 20 38.101382952 14.04 14.59 13.40 11.85 10.89 K7Ve 372 0
9 2MASS J04334465+2615005 TT* 04 33 44.6585167008 +26 15 00.436234680           M5.2 53 0
10 V* DM Tau Or* 04 33 48.7336763736 +18 10 09.973460280 14.30 14.82 14.00     M2Ve 731 0
11 NAME Taurus Complex SFR 04 41.0 +25 52           ~ 4971 0
12 2MASS J04422101+2520343 LM* 04 42 21.0216126792 +25 20 34.305993708 18.67         M5.1 79 0
13 V* GO Tau Or* 04 43 03.0761840904 +25 20 18.706850340   16.2 14.40     M2.3 229 0
14 V* GM Aur Or* 04 55 10.9815576936 +30 21 59.373771876 14.59 13.351 12.242 11.798   K3Ve 797 0
15 V* TW Hya TT* 11 01 51.9053285064 -34 42 17.033218380   11.94 10.50 10.626 9.18 K6Ve 2144 1
16 Sz 65 Or* 15 39 27.7716659160 -34 46 17.211087984   13.11 12.13 11.33 10.76 K7 118 0
17 Sz 66 TT* 15 39 28.2828956688 -34 46 18.082914564   14.9   14.51 12.56 M2 75 0
18 V* HW Lup Or* 15 45 17.4118414392 -34 18 28.286447220   17.41 16.25     M1 87 0
19 2MASS J15451851-3421246 Or* 15 45 18.5160315960 -34 21 24.553939896   17.95   17.35   M6.5 27 0
20 V* GW Lup Or* 15 46 44.7290527536 -34 30 35.677420056   13.8       M1.5e 201 0
21 V* HM Lup Or* 15 47 50.6288371920 -35 28 35.404076028   15.941 14.748 14.337   M3e 103 0
22 THA 15-5 TT* 15 47 56.9427182064 -35 14 34.796420412   14.5 16.2     K7e 95 0
23 V* GQ Lup Or* 15 49 12.1053805848 -35 39 05.058139788 12.19 12.76 11.66 11.15   K7Ve 334 1
24 Sz 76 TT* 15 49 30.7355449512 -35 49 51.413284020   16.611 15.095 14.710   M3.2 58 0
25 Sz 77 TT* 15 51 46.9580885472 -35 56 44.112678504   12.0       K5.5 86 0
26 WRAY 15-1384 TT* 15 56 02.0994258408 -36 55 28.274506140 14.91 14.342 13.470 13.311 11.86 M1 56 0
27 THA 15-12 Or* 15 56 09.2066646912 -37 56 06.126118692   13.12 11.93 11.45   M0e 554 0
28 HD 142666 TT* 15 56 40.0221861696 -22 01 40.005872148 9.41 9.37 8.82 8.31 8.01 F0V_sh 306 0
29 V* RU Lup TT* 15 56 42.3108692112 -37 49 15.473946900 9.27 10.07 9.60     K7/M0e 528 0
30 Sz 84 TT* 15 58 02.5198436808 -37 36 02.729938536   14.3       M5.0e 85 0
31 HD 143006 Or* 15 58 36.9126279888 -22 57 15.220559196   10.92 10.14   8.70 G5IVe 338 0
32 WRAY 15-1400 TT* 15 59 16.4717314824 -41 57 10.300018176   13.5 12.0     K7IVe 125 0
33 V* RY Lup Or* 15 59 28.3864710696 -40 21 51.249496176   12.62 9.90     G8/K1IV-V 251 0
34 UCAC3 96-205752 Or* 16 00 02.3583827328 -42 22 14.600258148   16.86 15.46 14.98 13.59 M4 54 0
35 Sz 130 TT* 16 00 31.0374709944 -41 43 36.988516560   15.82 14.71 13.56 12.46 M1.5 73 0
36 V* MY Lup TT* 16 00 44.5202267160 -41 55 30.935126748   12.64 12.17 11.06   K0 144 0
37 Sz 131 Or* 16 00 49.4333360352 -41 30 03.916812096   17.51 16.13 14.60 12.92 M2 55 0
38 NAME Lupus Complex SFR 16 03 -38.1           ~ 851 0
39 HD 325367 Or* 16 03 05.4915085848 -40 18 25.426727676   11.40 8.50     M0 406 0
40 Sz 133 Or* 16 03 29.3848659360 -41 40 01.765426548   17.77 16.60 15.78 15.04 K2 50 0
41 2MASS J16070384-3911113 Or* 16 07 03.84336 -39 11 11.3208       18.79 16.80 M4.5 47 0
42 2MASS J16070854-3914075 LM* 16 07 08.5530917712 -39 14 07.494035352   17.85   18.67 17.86 M1.75 44 0
43 THA 15-21 TT* 16 07 10.0694468880 -39 11 03.260683896   15.28 13.70 13.70 12.49 K7-M0 84 0
44 THA 15-20 TT* 16 07 11.5873449384 -39 03 47.492129340   16.25 14.58 14.11 12.92 M0.5 122 0
45 Sz 96 TT* 16 08 12.6308620920 -39 08 33.470354256   14.80 13.43 13.69 11.84 ~ 87 0
46 2MASS J16081497-3857145 Or* 16 08 14.9753942112 -38 57 14.409165492       18.93 17.42 4.75 48 0
47 THA 15-26 Or* 16 08 25.7633674272 -39 06 01.247043888   16.62 15.43 14.97 13.12 M5 79 0
48 WRAY 16-203 Or* 16 08 29.7275063376 -39 03 11.024360496   16.26 15.91 15.38 15.69 K0: 180 1
49 IRAS 16051-3820 Or* 16 08 30.6994064064 -38 28 26.846324004   11.89 11.15 10.67   K2 89 0
50 V* V1094 Sco TT* 16 08 36.1772010696 -39 23 02.464980972 16.01 15.00 13.48 12.47 11.45 ~ 101 1
51 2MASS J16083733-3923109 Or* 16 08 37.3331402112 -39 23 10.926378348   20.1 19.1 20.70 18.44 M7.5e 28 0
52 V* V1192 Sco Or* 16 08 51.4348063536 -39 05 30.460358652     21.9 18.97 18.18 M5 78 0
53 THA 15-33 TT* 16 08 54.6849382512 -39 37 43.145069664   15.34 13.98 13.29   M1IVe 109 0
54 2MASS J16085953-3856275 Or* 16 08 59.5395612120 -38 56 27.592929708       19.25 16.91 M8.5e 38 0
55 2MASS J16090141-3925119 Or* 16 09 01.4148377304 -39 25 11.923332420   16.92 15.31 15.04 13.48 M4 58 0
56 THA 15-35 Or* 16 09 01.8486544824 -39 05 12.414717240   15.33 14.12 14.35 12.54 M5.5 142 0
57 2MASS J16092697-3836269 Or* 16 09 26.9795990952 -38 36 26.933727420   17.55   16.31 14.74 M4.5 43 0
58 Sz 118 Or* 16 09 48.6562295568 -39 11 16.847425032   18.32 16.90 16.61 15.00 K6 76 0
59 2MASS J16102955-3922144 Or* 16 10 29.5517478000 -39 22 14.451017844   17.51 16.31 15.79 13.90 M4.5 60 0
60 NAME Upper Sco Association As* 16 12 -23.4           ~ 1586 1
61 UCAC3 104-204438 Or* 16 12 43.7499349656 -38 15 03.075603264   15.00 13.44 13.39 11.61 M1 62 0
62 NAME Upper Sco-Cen As* 16 15 -24.2           ~ 1497 1
63 EM* SR 4 Or* 16 25 56.1659023848 -24 20 48.240627072     12.80 11.7 10.7 K0:Ve 216 1
64 DoAr 25 TT* 16 26 23.6911292736 -24 43 13.888543800       12.65   K5 201 0
65 DoAr 33 TT* 16 27 39.0123517344 -23 58 18.709495500   15.7   13.24 12.02 K4 100 0
66 Hen 3-1258 Or* 16 48 45.6326070624 -14 16 35.849828856   14.94 13.34 12.84   K6 144 0
67 EM* AS 209 TT* 16 49 15.3034917000 -14 22 08.643317664   12.62 11.28     K4Ve 494 0
68 HD 163296 Ae* 17 56 21.2881851168 -21 57 21.871819008 7.00 6.93 6.85 6.86 6.67 A3VaekA1mA1 1301 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2023ApJ...954...41T and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu