2023MNRAS.524.2124P


Query : 2023MNRAS.524.2124P

2023MNRAS.524.2124P - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 524, 2124-2147 (2023/September-2)

The oblateness of the Milky Way dark matter halo from the stellar streams of NGC 3201, M68, and Palomar 5.

PALAU C.G. and MIRALDA-ESCUDE J.

Abstract (from CDS):

We explore constraints on the Milky Way dark matter halo oblateness using three stellar streams from globular clusters NGC3201, M68, and Palomar 5. Previous constraints on the gravitational potential from dynamical equilibrium of stellar populations and distant Milky Way satellites are included. We model the dark halo as axisymmetric with axis ratio $q_\rho ^{\rm h}$ and four additional free parameters of a two power-law density profile. The halo axis ratio, while barely constrained by the NGC3201 stream alone, is required to be close to spherical by the streams of Palomar 5 ($q_\rho ^{\rm h}=1.01\pm 0.09$) and M68 ($q_\rho ^{\rm h}=1.14^{+0.21}_{-0.14}$), the latter allowing a more prolate shape. The three streams together are well fitted with a halo axis ratio $q_\rho ^{\rm h}=1.06 \pm 0.06$ and core radius ∼20 kpc. Our estimate of the halo shape agrees with previous studies using other observational data and is in tension with cosmological simulations, predicting that most spiral galaxies have oblate dark matter haloes with the short axis perpendicular to the disc. We discuss why the impact of the Magellanic Clouds tide is too small to change our conclusion on the halo axis ratio. We note that dynamical equilibrium of a spherical halo in the oblate disc potential implies an anisotropic dark matter velocity dispersion, larger along the vertical direction than the horizontal ones, which should relate to the assembly history of the Milky Way.

Abstract Copyright: © 2023 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society

Journal keyword(s): Galaxy: halo - Galaxy: kinematics and dynamics - Galaxy: structure

Status at CDS : Large table(s) will be appraised for possible ingestion in VizieR.

Simbad objects: 146

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 146
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NGC 37 EmG 00 11 22.9432447128 -56 57 26.339243652   14.70   13.27   ~ 23 0
2 NAME Sagittarius Stream St* 02 22 +00.0           ~ 1001 0
3 NAME Magellanic Clouds GrG 03 00 -71.0           ~ 7988 0
4 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 19090 0
5 NGC 3201 GlC 10 17 36.82 -46 24 44.9           ~ 1001 0
6 M 68 GlC 12 39 27.98 -26 44 38.6     7.96     ~ 1069 0
7 NAME NGP reg 12 51 26.275 +27 07 41.70           ~ 1274 0
8 NGC 5139 GlC 13 26 47.28 -47 28 46.1           ~ 3677 0
9 NGC 5466 GlC 14 05 27.29 +28 32 04.0     9.70     ~ 887 0
10 Gaia DR3 6327240546525053824 * 14 50 03.7892990121 -08 07 59.916787487           ~ 1 0
11 Gaia DR2 6327454916932476800 * 14 50 47.0801245098 -07 55 09.016150760           ~ 1 0
12 Gaia DR2 6333632175119962368 * 14 53 31.1659489437 -06 51 48.637457259           ~ 1 0
13 Gaia DR2 6333638840909351808 * 14 54 52.9634785378 -06 42 09.106250117           ~ 1 0
14 Gaia DR3 6334133694157081856 * 14 55 20.0080342000 -05 50 46.542557068           ~ 1 0
15 Gaia DR3 6337139376694381440 * 14 55 39.7190515156 -05 40 49.806031551           ~ 1 0
16 Gaia DR2 6334151110248964224 * 14 57 42.2386959505 -05 40 01.852203654           ~ 1 0
17 Gaia DR2 6334300162794237184 * 14 58 53.5841736918 -05 05 55.137194700           ~ 1 0
18 Gaia DR2 6338851453738047488 * 14 59 53.2828441107 -04 12 52.117431383           ~ 1 0
19 Gaia DR2 6334298169929419392 * 14 59 55.7528299152 -05 05 12.965837665           ~ 1 0
20 Gaia DR2 6338874990158885376 * 15 00 15.0038055962 -04 10 27.779096892           ~ 1 0
21 Gaia DR2 6338879564298848640 * 15 01 12.2697848688 -04 05 46.465184198           ~ 1 0
22 Gaia DR2 6338859562636251904 * 15 01 18.1857974207 -04 15 12.203042817           ~ 1 0
23 Gaia DR2 6338880487717174528 * 15 01 49.7503165545 -04 03 29.868102470           ~ 1 0
24 Gaia DR2 6338869149003524224 * 15 02 09.0479828141 -04 02 52.358363874           ~ 1 0
25 Gaia DR2 6339016002525065472 * 15 03 00.8543544934 -03 33 22.552618523           ~ 1 0
26 Gaia DR2 6338987758819995776 * 15 03 06.6677786899 -03 41 47.004166124           ~ 1 0
27 Gaia DR2 6339017823591238400 * 15 03 24.5873233726 -03 30 52.844369674           ~ 1 0
28 Gaia DR2 6339403580374320896 * 15 04 33.3115611247 -03 12 58.280094042           ~ 1 0
29 Gaia DR2 6339405195282047232 * 15 04 40.8427724500 -03 11 23.525365450           ~ 1 0
30 Gaia DR2 6339486112465206528 * 15 05 29.8315214148 -02 56 05.762884188           ~ 1 0
31 Gaia DR2 6339492091059869696 * 15 05 37.5921008619 -02 45 45.176944522           ~ 1 0
32 SDSS J150558.13-024255.7 RR* 15 05 58.1406422976 -02 42 55.714327740     17.28     ~ 8 0
33 Gaia DR2 6339607745939180928 * 15 07 53.9349345455 -02 16 41.040821118           ~ 1 0
34 Gaia DR2 6339642724153085056 * 15 08 58.5338288432 -01 58 59.652841397           ~ 1 0
35 Gaia DR3 6339639666136263040 * 15 09 02.7101744027 -02 05 23.198552002           ~ 1 0
36 Gaia DR2 4418107238191732352 * 15 09 22.6027920341 -01 56 56.811197221           ~ 1 0
37 [ILT2017] J151051.488-013139.10 * 15 10 51.4689774936 -01 31 39.023425452           ~ 3 0
38 V* OW Lib RR* 15 11 01.1341178856 -01 37 54.831542880     17.45     A0 13 0
39 Gaia DR2 4418143968756451968 * 15 11 28.0219209263 -01 35 13.854408402           ~ 1 0
40 Gaia DR3 4418261930029664256 * 15 11 50.7700669953 -01 13 52.862819975           ~ 1 0
41 Cl* Palomar 5 OGK 20018 Pe* 15 11 52.5638881632 -01 12 02.450362752         16.6 ~ 5 0
42 Gaia DR2 4418300339922183040 * 15 13 05.5204191908 -00 54 19.990570224           ~ 1 0
43 Cl* Palomar 5 OGK 30439 * 15 13 23.6477509560 -00 56 44.683716660         17.8 ~ 2 0
44 2MASS J15135441-0049083 * 15 13 54.4052866056 -00 49 08.545095228           ~ 5 0
45 Gaia DR2 4418876999410407808 * 15 13 59.1530883060 -00 30 55.574602819           ~ 1 0
46 Gaia DR2 4418292299742718336 * 15 14 13.1305293436 -00 52 44.616459920           ~ 1 0
47 2MASS J15141716-0033085 * 15 14 17.1800102736 -00 33 08.405357040           ~ 5 0
48 Gaia DR2 4418306490314700416 * 15 14 18.9107295090 -00 46 18.955841456           ~ 1 0
49 Gaia DR2 4418306387235478784 * 15 14 20.1983695601 -00 47 19.668645141           ~ 1 0
50 Cl* Palomar 5 OGK 20016 Pe* 15 14 20.7108812856 -00 46 22.006725276         17.1 ~ 6 0
51 Gaia DR2 4418307899063987584 * 15 14 29.4966132446 -00 43 00.467480243           ~ 1 0
52 Gaia DR3 4418687161856244096 * 15 14 33.8346491854 -00 37 14.535902075           ~ 1 0
53 Gaia DR2 4418889815592901248 * 15 14 35.3666487130 -00 17 48.998201083           ~ 1 0
54 Gaia DR2 4418683485364220160 * 15 14 39.0184266519 -00 39 40.266263851           ~ 1 0
55 Gaia DR2 4418696404625960448 * 15 15 17.7723959128 -00 24 53.412105329           ~ 1 0
56 Gaia DR2 4418692040939128832 * 15 15 19.5646899080 -00 32 53.765256947           ~ 1 0
57 Gaia DR2 4418698397490799232 * 15 15 38.1621150221 -00 22 23.377949821           ~ 1 0
58 Gaia DR2 4418679396555391616 * 15 15 49.9609973465 -00 34 53.595937263           ~ 1 0
59 2MASS J15155042-0015452 Pe* 15 15 50.4316062696 -00 15 45.348648264           ~ 3 0
60 Gaia DR2 4418723583179058944 * 15 15 51.8658455040 -00 15 27.661440292           ~ 1 0
61 Gaia DR2 4418693724566344192 * 15 16 01.5117635967 -00 28 01.888232328           ~ 1 0
62 NAME Palomar 5 Stream St* 15 16 05 -00 06.7           ~ 132 0
63 Cl Pal 5 GlC 15 16 05.30 -00 06 41.0   15.1       ~ 797 1
64 Gaia DR2 4418926855391616000 * 15 16 16.7994518678 +00 03 18.930838739           ~ 1 0
65 [ILT2017] J151623.531-001249.90 * 15 16 23.5385132712 -00 12 49.836247236           ~ 3 0
66 ZTF J151634.71-000424.9 RR* 15 16 34.7129946072 -00 04 24.985170336           A0 11 0
67 Gaia DR2 4418727225312005504 * 15 16 41.0621829566 -00 15 15.372398111           ~ 1 0
68 Gaia DR3 4418726404973230080 * 15 16 48.6753834913 -00 16 10.217325029           ~ 1 0
69 Gaia DR2 4419023234457620352 * 15 16 57.7731361355 +00 12 15.346217434           ~ 1 0
70 Gaia DR2 4419073575769649664 * 15 17 13.4835438030 +00 31 26.085476480           ~ 1 0
71 Gaia DR2 4419026842229420800 * 15 17 33.1968813443 +00 13 47.011886922           ~ 1 0
72 Gaia DR2 4419052405874782592 * 15 18 23.2330082194 +00 21 49.766674665           ~ 1 0
73 Gaia DR2 4419078145614843776 * 15 18 26.0678888170 +00 38 06.237523220           ~ 1 0
74 M 5 GlC 15 18 33.22 +02 04 51.7     5.95     ~ 2095 0
75 Gaia DR2 4419068108275272448 * 15 18 50.5094589267 +00 39 32.756812040           ~ 1 0
76 Gaia DR2 4418864767344458112 * 15 18 58.8675929751 +00 19 22.218332828           ~ 1 0
77 Gaia DR2 4420584403529433728 * 15 19 21.6388532714 +00 51 03.137221007           ~ 1 0
78 Gaia DR2 4420577943898627968 * 15 20 08.4452474355 +00 52 12.545923642           ~ 1 0
79 Gaia DR2 4420385323205469568 * 15 20 35.9735490100 +00 43 58.508476411           ~ 1 0
80 [ILT2017] J152049.559+010758.10 * 15 20 49.5556593576 +01 07 58.086841224           ~ 4 0
81 Gaia DR2 4420603301385612928 * 15 21 14.3475329899 +01 02 56.020847977           ~ 1 0
82 Gaia DR2 4420616289367861760 * 15 21 36.1099034196 +01 15 34.767797644           ~ 1 0
83 Gaia DR2 4420608562721387776 * 15 21 45.1277592106 +01 03 30.681534763           ~ 1 0
84 Gaia DR2 4420616048849698304 * 15 21 57.7211457708 +01 16 53.190993856           ~ 1 0
85 Gaia DR2 4420708888861661440 * 15 22 31.4498997808 +01 20 52.473285696           ~ 1 0
86 [ILT2017] J152336.145+012927.40 * 15 23 36.1368987648 +01 29 27.266612820           ~ 3 0
87 Gaia DR2 4420528568955338112 * 15 23 36.4284252257 +01 24 56.735230480           ~ 1 0
88 [ILT2017] J152415.906+013345.20 * 15 24 15.9131858784 +01 33 45.350388000           ~ 3 0
89 Gaia DR2 4420744283688076672 * 15 24 17.3938254328 +01 38 59.832820639           ~ 1 0
90 Gaia DR2 4420749364634207104 * 15 24 41.8416584204 +01 40 09.914121028           ~ 1 0
91 Gaia DR2 4421127944526566272 * 15 25 15.5296454762 +01 51 08.363095398           ~ 1 0
92 [ILT2017] J152527.602+015103.90 * 15 25 27.5983225728 +01 51 03.797804556           ~ 3 0
93 Gaia DR2 4420939958103532416 * 15 25 28.9412599118 +01 48 47.577121301           ~ 1 0
94 [ILT2017] J152605.840+015511.60 * 15 26 05.8394015088 +01 55 11.469499068           ~ 3 0
95 Gaia DR2 4420974111684168320 * 15 27 17.0327997683 +02 04 17.806675216           ~ 1 0
96 [ILT2017] J152730.164+020116.30 * 15 27 30.1712513304 +02 01 16.211166996           ~ 4 0
97 Gaia DR2 4420973256984758912 * 15 27 40.2075314546 +02 06 41.149211970           ~ 1 0
98 Gaia DR2 4420985003720258688 * 15 28 06.1957346026 +02 17 40.659795548           ~ 1 0
99 Gaia DR2 4420985553476080768 * 15 28 17.7577272072 +02 19 58.308998037           ~ 1 0
100 Gaia DR3 4421270739303308032 * 15 28 21.3630405974 +02 29 38.586341201           ~ 1 0
101 Gaia DR2 4421075889522936832 * 15 28 36.9999908791 +02 18 09.331586963           ~ 1 0
102 Gaia DR2 4420980914911383552 * 15 28 42.9624397187 +02 14 59.043167457           ~ 1 0
103 Gaia DR2 4421074820076313088 * 15 28 55.4273411388 +02 15 45.714410094           ~ 1 0
104 [ILT2017] J152858.680+021912.90 * 15 28 58.6786216896 +02 19 12.758336652           ~ 3 0
105 Gaia DR2 4420967892569667200 * 15 28 58.7286269520 +02 10 29.430680608           ~ 1 0
106 Gaia DR2 4421063034685042048 * 15 29 04.0176207923 +02 15 28.677509114           ~ 1 0
107 Gaia DR2 4421279741554833664 * 15 29 21.7144270741 +02 39 55.543053290           ~ 1 0
108 Gaia DR2 4421086261868313216 * 15 30 05.0092044905 +02 31 15.069934030           ~ 1 0
109 Gaia DR2 4421118388224664448 * 15 30 09.8115978688 +02 47 15.041856045           ~ 1 0
110 Gaia DR2 4421120896484661504 * 15 31 20.6389946805 +02 46 40.014591262           ~ 1 0
111 Gaia DR2 4421122648831334784 * 15 31 22.0631958483 +02 51 25.932841064           ~ 1 0
112 Gaia DR2 4421121102643098880 * 15 31 22.0781843391 +02 48 46.163669868           ~ 1 0
113 Gaia DR2 4427109146047429120 * 15 32 13.4780606172 +02 43 33.609741450           ~ 1 0
114 Gaia DR2 4421056922947507584 * 15 32 15.0982061759 +02 39 22.706735982           ~ 1 0
115 Gaia DR2 4427115605678338048 * 15 32 22.5836012206 +02 52 46.062001602           ~ 1 0
116 Gaia DR2 4427116365888010496 * 15 32 32.1263692638 +02 55 31.759239118           ~ 1 0
117 [ILT2017] J153236.500+025428.00 * 15 32 36.4929612600 +02 54 28.031527296           ~ 3 0
118 [ILT2017] J153300.508+025619.90 * 15 33 00.4962417192 +02 56 19.873513824           ~ 3 0
119 Gaia DR2 4427149587458915328 * 15 33 13.1854656358 +03 07 57.133043965           ~ 1 0
120 Gaia DR2 4427072385423018112 * 15 33 56.1021398593 +02 55 01.607244782           ~ 1 0
121 Cl* Palomar 5 OGK 30556 * 15 34 12.8372878392 +03 20 05.585255592         17.6 ~ 2 0
122 Gaia DR2 4427267342578834816 * 15 34 28.4929863066 +03 28 22.779657116           ~ 1 0
123 Gaia DR2 4427108080895293440 * 15 34 53.1981619911 +03 13 11.023094537           ~ 1 0
124 Gaia DR2 4427252391796247936 * 15 35 41.3587471728 +03 25 39.023220184           ~ 1 0
125 Gaia DR3 4427286068636375552 * 15 36 27.6885557043 +03 40 10.776363649           ~ 1 0
126 Gaia DR2 4427242118235062400 * 15 37 43.2708245580 +03 38 55.460582505           ~ 1 0
127 Gaia DR2 4427620281515156608 * 15 38 33.6719971140 +03 48 32.255847982           ~ 1 0
128 Gaia DR2 4427616364504699264 * 15 39 48.9963060393 +03 54 13.259895398           ~ 1 0
129 Gaia DR2 4427617051699467264 * 15 39 59.0097888203 +03 54 18.681298636           ~ 1 0
130 Gaia DR2 4427641206595577728 * 15 40 29.5995161946 +04 00 17.602318698           ~ 1 0
131 Gaia DR2 4427638079859372288 * 15 40 35.1227481483 +03 58 07.437781853           ~ 1 0
132 Gaia DR2 4427657149514263680 * 15 40 40.7259397958 +04 11 29.938238504           ~ 1 0
133 Gaia DR2 4427749061814709504 * 15 42 03.3584731346 +04 21 34.057271969           ~ 1 0
134 Gaia DR2 4427746076813323520 * 15 42 32.7217651367 +04 21 56.374785961           ~ 1 0
135 Gaia DR3 4424743718578674688 * 15 43 44.9090922574 +04 16 54.428903069           ~ 1 0
136 Gaia DR2 4424779727584949120 * 15 45 05.3977958764 +04 36 36.195371303           ~ 1 0
137 Gaia DR2 4426303478901609344 * 15 48 06.0322180757 +04 56 55.250224453           ~ 1 0
138 Gaia DR2 4426315848407518336 * 15 48 32.9534240526 +05 09 32.717168136           ~ 1 0
139 NAME Galactic Center reg 17 45 39.60213 -29 00 22.0000           ~ 16269 0
140 NAME Sgr A* X 17 45 40.03599 -29 00 28.1699           ~ 4970 3
141 NAME SDG G 18 55 19.0 -30 32 43   4.5 3.6     ~ 2438 2
142 NAME Orphan Stream St* 19 09 -23.           ~ 281 0
143 V* RR Lyr RR* 19 25 27.9129605304 +42 47 03.693258204   7.36   7.6   kA3hF0 951 0
144 NAME GD-1 Stream St* 22 40 +31.           ~ 319 0
145 GCl 124 GlC 23 06 44.48 +12 46 19.2   15.6       ~ 307 1
146 NAME NGC 3201 Stream St* ~ ~           ~ 7 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2023MNRAS.524.2124P and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu