2023MNRAS.524.2741B


Query : 2023MNRAS.524.2741B

2023MNRAS.524.2741B - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 524, 2741-2769 (2023/September-2)

Star formation and molecular gas properties of post-starburst galaxies.

BARON D., NETZER H., FRENCH K.D., LUTZ D., DAVIES R.I. and PROCHASKA J.X.

Abstract (from CDS):

Post-starburst galaxies are believed to be in a rapid transition between major merger starbursts and quiescent ellipticals. Their optical spectrum is dominated by A-type stars, suggesting a starburst that was quenched recently. While optical observations suggest little ongoing star formation, some have been shown to host significant molecular gas reservoirs. This led to the suggestion that gas depletion is not required to end the starburst, and that star formation is suppressed by other processes. We present NOEMA CO(1-0) observations of 15 post-starburst galaxies with emission lines consistent with active galactic nucleus (AGN) photoionization. We collect post-starburst candidates with molecular gas measurements from the literature, with some classified as classical E + A, while others with line ratios consistent with AGN and/or shock ionization. Using far-infrared observations, we show that systems that were reported to host exceptionally large molecular gas reservoirs host in fact obscured star formation, with some systems showing star formation rates comparable to ULIRGs. Among E + A galaxies with molecular gas measurements, 7 out of 26 (26 per cent) host obscured starbursts. Using far-infrared observations, post-starburst candidates show similar SFR-$M_{\mathrm{H_2}}$ and Kennicutt-Schmidt relations to those observed in star-forming and starburst galaxies. In particular, there is no need to hypothesize star formation quenching by processes other than the consumption of molecular gas by star formation. The combination of optical, far-infrared, and CO observations indicates that some regions within these galaxies have been recently quenched, while others are still forming stars in highly obscured regions. All this calls into question the traditional interpretation of such galaxies.

Abstract Copyright: © 2023 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: active - galaxies: evolution - galaxies: general - galaxies: interactions - galaxies: supermassive black holes - galaxies: star formation

Simbad objects: 134

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 134
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 LEDA 1176136 Sy2 00 03 18.20568 +00 48 44.3808   20.16 19.48     ~ 15 0
2 2MASX J00114518-0054303 Sy2 00 11 45.2234465520 -00 54 30.672854028   19.19 18.50     ~ 14 0
3 SDSS J002928.97+143342.8 Sy2 00 29 28.9744979016 +14 33 42.745659444   20.23 19.44     ~ 9 0
4 SDSS J003443.68+251020.9 AGN 00 34 43.68504 +25 10 20.9604           ~ 4 0
5 SDSS J003707.82+002436.5 Sy2 00 37 07.8234323592 +00 24 36.506520000   18.58 17.95     ~ 11 0
6 2MASX J00445922-0853228 LIN 00 44 59.2386710424 -08 53 22.973523540   15.09 14.34 13.99   ~ 33 1
7 [VV2006c] J011956.7+133431 Sy2 01 19 56.7480639792 +13 34 31.602639792   19.12 18.54     ~ 8 0
8 Z 390-42 Sy2 03 16 54.9175323408 -00 02 31.266170592   15.4       ~ 47 0
9 LEDA 3378386 Sy2 07 45 49.5050926440 +31 22 42.134094444           ~ 10 0
10 2MASX J07511426+3425051 LIN 07 51 14.3008142208 +34 25 05.529815688           ~ 9 0
11 Z 236-8 Sy2 07 51 51.8880700320 +49 48 51.493468716   17.57 16.75     ~ 50 0
12 2MASS J07592750+5337482 Sy2 07 59 27.5013259368 +53 37 48.251021484           ~ 6 0
13 SDSS J080359.62+253051.5 LIN 08 03 59.6149032096 +25 30 51.704457228           ~ 7 0
14 2MASS J08042784+1329309 Sy2 08 04 27.8427452856 +13 29 30.760117548           ~ 7 0
15 2MASX J08072440+2006079 LIN 08 07 24.4546929648 +20 06 08.459010828           ~ 7 0
16 SDSS J081603.15+193643.3 Sy2 08 16 03.1595287512 +19 36 43.394041260           ~ 7 0
17 2MASX J08240366+5154156 Sy2 08 24 03.6777268104 +51 54 15.639711588   18.37 17.69     ~ 18 0
18 Z 119-101 SyG 08 27 01.3920061152 +21 42 24.410127024   14.8       ~ 51 0
19 LEDA 1530579 G 08 34 33.7079920656 +17 20 46.347777996           ~ 19 0
20 SDSS J084545.38+200610.3 G 08 45 45.3865790568 +20 06 10.302183504           ~ 5 0
21 SDSS J085356.81+031033.5 G 08 53 56.8128579936 +03 10 33.506955516           ~ 10 0
22 Z 5-43 Sy2 08 58 28.5922639728 +00 01 24.531135960   17.15 16.60     ~ 43 1
23 2MASX J08594261+1006439 LIN 08 59 42.6267298200 +10 06 43.615626264           ~ 8 0
24 LEDA 2265450 Sy2 09 11 29.9705066928 +45 28 05.758200120           ~ 90 0
25 NVSS J091407+375308 rG 09 14 07.2303948768 +37 53 09.904035372           ~ 11 0
26 2MASX J09175988+5000079 LIN 09 17 59.8535389152 +50 00 07.796533716           ~ 11 0
27 LEDA 2190813 G 09 18 49.9790671704 +42 00 43.507702260           ~ 12 0
28 LEDA 1299872 LIN 09 25 18.3165545184 +06 23 34.057943952           ~ 9 0
29 SDSS J092619.29+184040.9 G 09 26 19.2958024152 +18 40 40.980118224           ~ 9 0
30 LEDA 2200663 G 09 26 57.6898287744 +42 31 36.529738392           ~ 12 0
31 SDSS J092819.54+074158.4 LIN 09 28 19.5322264848 +07 41 58.454643768           ~ 6 0
32 2MASX J09381989+1819529 G 09 38 19.8543330936 +18 19 52.644266544           ~ 10 0
33 Z 122-46 Sy2 09 40 44.5072404432 +21 14 03.368948028   15.41 14.53     ~ 58 0
34 LEDA 3092152 LIN 09 44 26.9652200520 +04 29 56.781210768           ~ 24 0
35 SDSS J094818.68+023004.2 LIN 09 48 18.6774069192 +02 30 04.277223576           ~ 16 0
36 2MASX J09574953-0012390 Sy1 09 57 49.537 -00 12 39.08   17.67 17.21 15.818   ~ 26 0
37 2MASS J10033426+2850315 Sy1 10 03 34.2839493552 +28 50 31.463353104           ~ 4 0
38 LEDA 3533608 G 10 08 16.2294928560 +09 36 16.422351048           ~ 6 0
39 2MASX J10082875+1916195 Sy2 10 08 28.729 +19 16 20.06           ~ 6 0
40 SDSS J100847.69+512352.7 LIN 10 08 47.6855220768 +51 23 52.657510416           ~ 6 0
41 FIRST J101823.9+153631 rG 10 18 23.9686661976 +15 36 30.839335992           ~ 14 0
42 LEDA 1664728 G 10 22 00.7860881376 +22 09 47.486937060           ~ 11 0
43 SDSS J102653.34+434008.4 G 10 26 53.3375778840 +43 40 08.430201840           ~ 7 0
44 LEDA 3756119 Sy2 10 28 25.8105261744 +57 36 08.899819308           ~ 9 0
45 2MASX J10283733+5023510 Sy2 10 28 37.3895392344 +50 23 50.921748708           ~ 11 0
46 SDSS J103134.83+054057.5 G 10 31 34.8304450272 +05 40 57.526040280           ~ 6 0
47 SDSS J103342.71+210740.7 G 10 33 42.7057424376 +21 07 40.715016636           ~ 9 0
48 2MASX J10375735+4614402 LIN 10 37 57.3841460304 +46 14 40.616779776           ~ 18 0
49 NVSS J104636+280434 rG 10 46 36.5280668716 +28 04 34.726931100           ~ 3 0
50 2MASX J10504149+3119560 Sy2 10 50 41.5072210704 +31 19 56.462119104           ~ 9 0
51 SDSS J105220.44+054941.5 G 10 52 20.4493881120 +05 49 41.592572796           ~ 14 0
52 2MASX J10575109+0554478 LIN 10 57 51.0754824144 +05 54 46.950958296           ~ 12 0
53 LEDA 3470153 G 11 05 40.7031223752 +05 59 54.242916504           ~ 13 0
54 Z 67-28 rG 11 11 17.9602630608 +11 33 15.824932272   15.3       ~ 22 0
55 Z 291-52 G 11 19 07.6343046096 +58 03 14.334705000   15.1       ~ 29 0
56 SDSS J111943.84+105037.1 Sy2 11 19 43.8410544648 +10 50 37.168710324           ~ 5 0
57 LEDA 3769383 Sy2 11 20 23.915 +15 43 54.63           ~ 6 0
58 2MASX J11234700+3526318 Sy2 11 23 47.0200088016 +35 26 32.339288544           ~ 20 0
59 NVSS J112620+191324 rG 11 26 19.402 +19 13 28.74           ~ 14 0
60 SDSS J112703.65+125655.3 Sy2 11 27 03.6538767696 +12 56 55.362063444           ~ 6 0
61 2MASX J11281987+2737196 Sy2 11 28 19.9174862592 +27 37 19.572078396           ~ 15 0
62 Mrk 176 Sy2 11 32 40.2448971432 +52 57 01.289256768   15.50 14.61 13.52   ~ 244 1
63 SDSS J113339.08+524028.4 Sy2 11 33 39.0928169808 +52 40 28.465011624           ~ 19 0
64 FIRST J113655.1+245325 rG 11 36 55.1862706152 +24 53 25.281282732           ~ 15 0
65 IRAS F11370+4647 LIN 11 39 39.3357438360 +46 31 32.026536228           ~ 13 0
66 [VV2006c] J115259.3+130719 Sy1 11 52 59.3133981192 +13 07 18.783332436   17.92 17.46     ~ 7 0
67 2MASX J11530653+6417567 Sy2 11 53 06.4565710176 +64 17 56.548398804           ~ 11 0
68 LEDA 2816787 G 11 53 41.3429234208 +09 30 25.271264592           ~ 9 0
69 2MASX J11542941+4258490 Sy2 11 54 29.4174812160 +42 58 48.817922268           ~ 20 0
70 2MASS J11560682+5925295 Sy2 11 56 06.8294057040 +59 25 29.695246572           ~ 10 0
71 2MASX J12020465+3519173 Sy2 12 02 04.6153685808 +35 19 17.927494320           ~ 9 0
72 LEDA 2500941 Sy2 12 08 04.6665438864 +55 24 27.548068824   17.08 16.47     ~ 14 0
73 SDSS J121138.23+293616.5 LIN 12 11 38.2348073160 +29 36 16.575727176           ~ 8 0
74 NVSS J121622+190442 rG 12 16 22.2753569184 +19 04 42.488368356           ~ 10 0
75 2MASX J12162273+1417534 Sy2 12 16 22.7363874336 +14 17 53.102681412           ~ 11 0
76 SDSS J121702.42+390437.3 G 12 17 02.4632827080 +39 04 37.453827720           ~ 10 0
77 IRAS 12266+3240 QSO 12 29 06.9051013824 +32 24 17.818537545           ~ 13 0
78 2MASS J12380416+4820421 Sy2 12 38 04.1661040248 +48 20 42.288473904           ~ 12 0
79 Mrk 779 G 12 39 36.0437604432 +12 26 20.021340408   16.5       ~ 35 0
80 2MASS J12414806+4742320 Sy2 12 41 48.0715977840 +47 42 31.982028048           ~ 9 0
81 2dFGRS TGN253Z244 LIN 12 44 51.6954840984 -01 45 35.744531508   17.855   16.700   ~ 10 0
82 Z 270-20 LIN 12 46 26.8490585376 +50 47 31.340853888   15.5       ~ 25 0
83 2MASX J12482222+5514520 G 12 48 22.1702318640 +55 14 52.187419104           ~ 6 0
84 Z 271-4 Sy2 13 05 25.8215702280 +53 35 30.261477696   15.3       ~ 44 0
85 Z 16-24 Sy2 13 13 52.3987020408 +02 07 57.335104416   16.65 16.09     ~ 27 0
86 2MASX J13144755+2106266 LIN 13 14 47.556 +21 06 26.70           ~ 10 0
87 2MASX J13145978+5116213 LIN 13 14 59.8317891672 +51 16 21.286345764           ~ 14 0
88 IC 860 LIN 13 15 03.51 +24 37 07.8   14.8       ~ 236 0
89 SDSS J132111.30+145452.1 LIN 13 21 11.3011610208 +14 54 52.144302564           ~ 3 0
90 Z 218-7 Sy2 13 23 48.4513699680 +43 18 04.312035900   15.7       ~ 55 0
91 2MASX J13240163+4546208 Sy2 13 24 01.6358542296 +45 46 20.741246292   18.63 18.17     ~ 13 0
92 2MASX J13264815+1922459 Sy2 13 26 48.1164659400 +19 22 45.715561896           ~ 6 0
93 2MFGC 10927 LIN 13 34 14.8203020256 +34 11 38.957471196           ~ 21 0
94 LEDA 1891826 G 13 36 04.1239761552 +30 08 27.756319776   16.584       ~ 14 0
95 LEDA 3556466 LIN 13 39 53.1676344888 +44 22 36.791809680           ~ 6 0
96 LEDA 1831093 G 13 56 43.4615610408 +28 16 21.297878220           ~ 7 0
97 Mrk 1370 Sy2 14 08 04.0024196544 +07 19 39.457831404   16.0       ~ 34 0
98 LEDA 2816901 G 14 09 52.5388320864 +10 16 46.867737828           ~ 10 0
99 2MASX J14463960+3321292 Sy2 14 46 39.6218706144 +33 21 29.300812812           ~ 4 0
100 2MASX J14481604+1733055 LIN 14 48 16.048 +17 33 05.93           ~ 22 0
101 Z 134-43 Sy2 14 50 37.8500235408 +22 44 03.576974676   15.7       ~ 87 0
102 SDSS J145505.44+131651.6 LIN 14 55 05.4465695736 +13 16 51.611153160           ~ 8 0
103 Z 105-93 rG 15 01 36.31029 +16 43 46.9362   15.4       ~ 31 0
104 2MASX J15054154+5847190 Sy2 15 05 41.5918719816 +58 47 19.003453764   19.89 19.17     ~ 10 0
105 2MASS J15061915+0806429 LIN 15 06 19.1654787288 +08 06 42.772748616           ~ 16 0
106 87GB 150658.6+374440 LIN 15 08 55.0937319288 +37 33 29.846803248           ~ 15 0
107 Z 106-23 rG 15 15 48.331 +20 01 20.81   15.6       ~ 31 0
108 SDSS J152908.37+060119.5 G 15 29 08.3632508256 +06 01 19.539449760           ~ 3 0
109 SDSS J152926.64+091325.2 G 15 29 26.6364158064 +09 13 25.166324712           ~ 5 0
110 2MASS J15304857+5519438 LIN 15 30 48.5798189544 +55 19 43.701692304           ~ 11 0
111 Z 297-14 H2G 15 32 31.69920 +57 52 58.8650   15.5       ~ 36 0
112 2MASX J15474417+4124089 Sy2 15 47 44.1429925680 +41 24 08.336969640   16.0       ~ 31 0
113 LEDA 3854831 Sy2 15 51 12.7317677040 +14 41 46.980040164           ~ 16 0
114 SDSS J155524.94+295550.7 G 15 55 24.94495 +29 55 50.8121           ~ 6 0
115 LEDA 2416280 G 15 58 16.4389092216 +52 29 21.374490012           ~ 16 0
116 MCG+07-33-028 Sy2 16 02 37.9390299600 +41 17 36.377220156   17       ~ 37 0
117 Z 223-47 LIN 16 10 20.4760832928 +41 51 17.589854484   15.2       ~ 43 0
118 SDSS J161119.39+084032.7 G 16 11 19.3976338320 +08 40 32.722553820           ~ 4 0
119 2MASXI J1613301+510335 GiP 16 13 30.1885672344 +51 03 35.600325300           ~ 24 2
120 IRAS 16152+1410 rG 16 17 35.40167 +14 03 08.1470           ~ 20 0
121 Z 224-21 AGN 16 25 49.25712 +40 20 42.8204   15.3       ~ 75 0
122 2MASX J16270254+4328340 Sy2 16 27 02.5557944232 +43 28 33.950210916           ~ 47 0
123 2MASX J16273803+4453420 Sy2 16 27 38.0753956824 +44 53 42.091713960   18.47 17.86     ~ 6 0
124 FIRST J162842.9+222349 rG 16 28 42.96344 +22 23 49.8173           ~ 18 0
125 LEDA 97536 Sy2 16 30 32.6560544664 +39 23 03.103312344     15.3     ~ 96 0
126 IRAS 16342+2922 LIN 16 36 14.095 +29 16 13.41           ~ 16 0
127 LEDA 1442522 G 16 37 58.8706784184 +13 51 33.880555584           ~ 11 0
128 SDSS J164503.79+304802.0 G 16 45 03.8000169216 +30 48 02.017059732           ~ 6 0
129 Z 225-4 GiC 16 51 41.6923910040 +41 40 06.111711552   15.5       ~ 19 0
130 LEDA 1045221 EmG 21 05 08.6774969064 -05 23 59.412514992   16.48   15.13   ~ 17 0
131 Z 375-16 G 21 14 00.5329240920 +00 32 06.387317988   14.9       ~ 29 0
132 2MASX J22453277+1232360 Sy2 22 45 32.7424769328 +12 32 36.303291240           ~ 6 0
133 LEDA 1180817 G 22 55 06.7998478104 +00 58 39.974957616           ~ 20 0
134 6dFGS gJ232637.2-011435 Sy1 23 26 37.221 -01 14 35.27   18.93   17.65   ~ 8 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2023MNRAS.524.2741B and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu