2023MNRAS.525.3201K


Query : 2023MNRAS.525.3201K

2023MNRAS.525.3201K - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 525, 3201-3215 (2023/November-1)

Hunting for the candidates of misclassified sources in LSP BL Lacs using machine learning.

KANG S.-J., ZHENG Y.-G. and WU Q.

Abstract (from CDS):

An equivalent-width-based classification may cause the erroneous judgement to the flat spectrum radio quasars (FSRQs) and BL Lacerate objects (BL Lac) due to the diluting the line features by dramatic variations in the jet continuum flux. To help address the issue, this work explores the possible intrinsic classification on the basis of a random forest supervised machine learning algorithm. In order to do so, we compile a sample of 1680 Fermi blazars that have both gamma-rays and radio-frequencies data available from the 4LAC-DR2 catalogue, which includes 1352 training and validation samples and 328 forecast samples. By studying the results for all of the different combinations of 23 characteristic parameters, we found that there are 178 optimal parameter combinations (OPCs) with the highest accuracy (≃98.89 per cent). Using the combined classification results from the nine combinations of these OPCs to the 328 forecast samples, we predict that there are 113 true BL Lacs (TBLs) and 157 false BL Lacs (FBLs) that are possible intrinsically FSRQs misclassified as BL Lacs. The FBLs show a clear separation from TBLs and FSRQs in the gamma-ray photon spectral index, Γph, and X-band radio flux, logFR, plot. Phenomenally, existence a BL Lac to FSRQ (B-to-F) transition zone is suggested, where the FBLs are in the stage of transition from BL Lacs to FSRQs. Comparing the LSP changing-look blazars (CLBs) reported in the literatures, the majority of LSP CLBs are located at the B-to-F zone. We argue that the FBLs located at B-to-F transition zone are the most likely candidates of CLBs.

Abstract Copyright: © 2023 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society

Journal keyword(s): galaxies: active - BL Lacertae objects: general - quasars: general

Status at CDS : Large table(s) will be appraised for possible ingestion in VizieR.

Simbad objects: 134

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 134
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 ATO J000.3251-07.7741 BLL 00 01 18.0249466512 -07 46 26.920186536 18.18 17.88 17.90 16.3   ~ 61 1
2 4FGL J0003.2+2207 Bz? 00 03 13.4 +22 07 49           ~ 17 0
3 ICRF J000404.9-114858 BLL 00 04 04.91500103 -11 48 58.3862126       19.09   ~ 64 1
4 4FGL J0006.3-0620 Bz? 00 06 23.8 -06 20 57           ~ 27 0
5 2MASS J00075997+4712078 BLL 00 07 59.9724805320 +47 12 07.769093004   18.3   18.2   ~ 71 1
6 QSO J0009+0628 BLL 00 09 03.9322109352 +06 28 21.242543304 19.24 18.51 18.14 19.1   ~ 85 1
7 ICRF J001259.9-395426 BLL 00 12 59.9097885288 -39 54 26.056833444   18.33   18.05   ~ 84 1
8 ICRF J001356.3+191041 BLL 00 13 56.3761095216 +19 10 41.919814056       18.17   ~ 87 1
9 QSO J0019+2021 BLL 00 19 37.85449305 +20 21 45.6446105     20.6 19.70   ~ 90 1
10 ATO J005.5386-18.8930 BLL 00 22 09.2686975344 -18 53 34.868121432 17.48 17.20 16.97     ~ 52 1
11 QSO B0019+058 BLL 00 22 32.44121084 +06 08 04.2689202   19.2   19.07   ~ 152 1
12 4FGL J0023.9+1603 Bz? 00 23 55.7 +16 03 50           ~ 14 0
13 NAME SMC B0026-7101 Bla 00 28 41.5636966584 -70 45 15.927580080       16.62   ~ 51 1
14 2dFGRS TGS283Z129 BLL 00 32 33.0970812456 -28 49 20.390589480   18.723 18.80 17.242   ~ 52 1
15 4FGL J0035.8-0837 Bz? 00 35 49.8 -08 37 57           ~ 6 0
16 SDSS J003808.50+001336.6 BLL 00 38 08.5092177984 +00 13 36.492891960   20.09 19.49 19.3   ~ 45 1
17 RX J0040.2+4049 BLL 00 40 13.8112928443 +40 50 04.756997684     19.30 19.9   ~ 80 1
18 QSO J0049+0237 BLL 00 49 43.23593957 +02 37 03.7785936 19.56 19.23 19.14 19.07   ~ 104 1
19 4FGL J0056.8+1626 Bz? 00 56 48.5 +16 26 10           ~ 13 0
20 ICRF J005802.2-323420 BLL 00 58 02.2303103256 -32 34 20.750614536 18.26 17.61 17.60 20.00   ~ 69 1
21 7C 0059+5808 Bla 01 02 45.76237340 +58 24 11.1366164   20.09 19.22 18.57 17.90 ~ 262 1
22 87GB 010219.8+391221 Bla 01 05 09.1962613704 +39 28 15.320001180     19.69 18.2   ~ 58 1
23 4FGL J0107.4+0334 Bz? 01 07 24.2 +03 34 09           ~ 10 0
24 QSO B0109+224 BLL 01 12 05.8247044608 +22 44 38.785880796   16.00 15.66 15.47   ~ 373 2
25 4FGL J0113.7+0225 Bz? 01 13 42.7 +02 25 11           ~ 16 0
26 PSO J021.2103-06.4169 BLL 01 24 50.4851504351 -06 25 00.943106646       18.4   ~ 46 1
27 9Y-MST J0125-2549 Bla 01 25 23.4 -25 48 27           ~ 22 0
28 9Y-MST J0127-0821 Bla 01 27 13.8 -08 19 50           ~ 25 0
29 1RXS J014126.8-092857 BLL 01 41 25.83216015 -09 28 43.6742470   16.94 16.55 17.21   ~ 302 1
30 4FGL J0142.7-0543 Bz? 01 42 42.1 -05 44 00           ~ 12 0
31 ICRF J014433.5+270503 BLL 01 44 33.55384903 +27 05 03.1179726       18.6   ~ 104 1
32 2FGL J0148.6+0127 BLL 01 48 33.7946130240 +01 29 01.442301648           ~ 42 1
33 3FGL J0202.5+4206 Bla 02 02 44.7 +42 04 17           ~ 22 0
34 6C 015907+721900 BLL 02 03 33.38495695 +72 32 53.6673482     19.2 15.90   ~ 102 1
35 NVSS J020345+304129 rG 02 03 45.35524711 +30 41 29.1068408           ~ 64 1
36 QSO B0206-688 BLL 02 07 50.9311178880 -68 37 55.162059384           ~ 47 1
37 4FGL J0208.5-0046 Bz? 02 08 32.4 -00 46 36           ~ 14 0
38 4FGL J0209.9+7229 Bz? 02 09 59.5 +72 29 16           ~ 22 0
39 ICRF J021717.1+083703 BLL 02 17 17.1248727600 +08 37 03.897374052     17.90 14.68   ~ 118 1
40 QSO J0217+0144 Bla 02 17 48.95475095 +01 44 49.6990271   16.74 16.09 18.51 13.29 ~ 455 1
41 4FGL J0219.5+0724 Bz? 02 19 33.9 +07 24 23           ~ 15 0
42 9Y-MST J0223-7941 BLL 02 24 01.3 -79 41 36           ~ 25 0
43 ESO 115-15 Bla 02 31 09.2739335616 -57 55 06.051101592   14.41 15.5 12.63   ~ 49 1
44 QSO B0235+1624 BLL 02 38 38.93010450 +16 36 59.2745528   16.46 15.50 15.92   ~ 1614 2
45 4FGL J0241.0-0505 Bz? 02 41 00.2 -05 05 39           ~ 12 0
46 ICRF J024330.8+712017 BLL 02 43 30.8913278232 +71 20 17.905675416     19.4 18.4   ~ 80 1
47 4FGL J0245.1-0257 Bz? 02 45 09.9 -02 57 18           ~ 15 0
48 BWE 0253+0522 BLL 02 55 49.5140473680 +05 33 55.054257336           ~ 29 1
49 87GB 025515.9+201804 BLL 02 58 07.3086122544 +20 30 01.589316804       18.4   ~ 50 1
50 ICRF J030116.6-165245 BLL 03 01 16.6225967472 -16 52 45.101632764           ~ 46 1
51 ZW V 326 BLL 03 12 50.2876842864 +36 15 19.539047556     17.60     ~ 50 1
52 9Y-MST J0314-5102 BLL 03 14 25.70348 -51 04 31.5614 18.57 18.33 18.00 18.4   ~ 47 1
53 RX J0316.1+0904 BLL 03 16 12.7326021672 +09 04 43.281750684       17.2   ~ 73 1
54 QSO B0332-403 BLL 03 34 13.65448823 -40 08 25.3979928 18.54 18.35 17.87 17.5   ~ 349 1
55 ICRF J033415.4-372543 BLL 03 34 15.4249837080 -37 25 43.063647672 16.95 16.71 16.56     ~ 80 1
56 QSO B0335-122 Bla 03 37 55.4513467728 -12 04 04.551994488   21.018 20.110 20.199   ~ 88 1
57 QSO B0338-214 BLL 03 40 35.60785848 -21 19 31.1721373   16.04 17.1 17.07   ~ 182 1
58 4FGL J0347.0+4844 AG? 03 47 00.6 +48 44 15           ~ 16 0
59 9Y-MST J0348-1610 Bla 03 48 36.8 -16 09 55           ~ 22 0
60 8C 0346+800 Bla 03 54 46.12599356 +80 09 28.8472674       19.5   ~ 81 1
61 [VV98] J035933.7-261531 BLL 03 59 33.68186047 -26 15 31.3313649   21.8   20.6   ~ 62 1
62 2MASS J04020076-2615395 BLL 04 02 00.7850211204 -26 15 39.414974683 19.60 19.06 18.68 18.8   ~ 47 1
63 NVSS J040341-244408 Bla 04 03 41.73605888 -24 44 08.4586620       19.58   ~ 47 1
64 [VV2006] J040729.1+074208 BLL 04 07 29.08668900 +07 42 07.4714246     17.59 17.28   ~ 100 1
65 1RXS J042218.2+195047 BLL 04 22 18.3397702069 +19 50 54.920278805           ~ 90 0
66 QSO B0422+004 BLL 04 24 46.8421990080 +00 36 06.329375028 16.15 15.94 16.98     ~ 378 1
67 2MASS J04250426-5331581 BLL 04 25 04.2730028208 -53 31 58.259236728           ~ 51 1
68 WISEA J042840.41-375619.3 BLL 04 28 40.4241894720 -37 56 19.580735832   18.96 19.0 17.21   ~ 343 1
69 RX J0433.6+2906 BLL 04 33 37.82985981 +29 05 55.4770576   19.0 17.80 17.06   ~ 181 1
70 QSO B0437-454 BLL 04 39 00.85466368 -45 22 22.5631875   20.44 20.6 19.48   ~ 121 1
71 QSO B0446+113 BLL 04 49 07.67110194 +11 21 28.5963618     20.00 18.58   ~ 305 1
72 ICRF J050927.4+101144 Bla 05 09 27.45706676 +10 11 44.6001432   19.5       ~ 101 1
73 QSO B0507+179 Bla 05 10 02.36912937 +18 00 41.5815635   20.0 19.0 19.09   ~ 470 1
74 QSO B0516-621 BLL 05 16 44.92617055 -62 07 05.3894029 18.50 18.09 17.85 17.46   ~ 139 1
75 ICRF J052123.5-173730 BLL 05 21 23.5579026408 -17 37 30.185353524       17.77   ~ 64 1
76 QSO B0537-441 BLL 05 38 50.36155950 -44 05 08.9390233   15.77 16.48 16   ~ 924 2
77 NVSS J053942+143345 Bla 05 39 42.36599322 +14 33 45.5616887           ~ 104 1
78 QSO B0537-286 Bla 05 39 54.28147904 -28 39 55.9481236   19.70 20.0 18.789   ~ 314 1
79 ICRF J060111.2-703608 Bla 06 01 11.2488493488 -70 36 08.802829692           ~ 117 2
80 ICRF J062923.7-195919 BLL 06 29 23.76186296 -19 59 19.7236825   20.43 18.6 20.68   ~ 141 1
81 4FGL J0654.7+4246 Bz? 06 54 44.5 +42 46 45           ~ 20 0
82 4C 47.23 BLL 07 10 46.10488160 +47 32 11.1426490   18.2 18.2 13.9   ~ 165 1
83 7C 071604.59+331243.00 BLL 07 19 19.41966120 +33 07 09.7087082   17.66 17.05     ~ 130 1
84 QSO J0738+1742 BLL 07 38 07.39375312 +17 42 18.9981506   16.76 16.22 15.78   ~ 1045 1
85 QSO B0808+019 BLL 08 11 26.70731711 +01 46 52.2201568   17.58 17.2 17.96   ~ 281 1
86 7C 081451.89+423206.00 BLL 08 18 15.99961476 +42 22 45.4148987   18.88 18.18 17.81   ~ 429 1
87 QSO B0829+047 BLL 08 31 48.8770033992 +04 29 39.086842884   17.10 16.4 14.55   ~ 511 2
88 9Y-MST J0832+4914 Bla 08 32 25.9 +49 12 46           ~ 30 0
89 6C 083032+423415 Bla 08 33 53.8854255168 +42 24 01.847106900   17.69 17.23 16.47   ~ 139 1
90 9C J1001+2911 BLL 10 01 10.2057148656 +29 11 37.537140264   19.00 18.34 16.39   ~ 123 1
91 CRATES J100851-313914 BLL 10 08 50.55040 -31 39 05.4661           ~ 33 1
92 6C 103234+442524 Bz? 10 35 32.1240148560 +44 09 31.432885164           ~ 20 1
93 QSO B1034-293 Bla 10 37 16.07974265 -29 34 02.8134977   16.46 16.46 17.54   ~ 358 1
94 ICRF J104309.0+240835 BLL 10 43 09.03578135 +24 08 35.4094642   17.98 17.32 16.40   ~ 171 1
95 4FGL J1058.0+4305 Bz? 10 58 04.3 +43 05 38           ~ 14 0
96 4C 01.28 BLL 10 58 29.60520810 +01 33 58.8237454   18.74 18.28 16.68   ~ 828 2
97 QSO B1057-797 BLL 10 58 43.30979475 -80 03 54.1598058   19.08   17.31   ~ 211 1
98 ICRF J112402.7+233645 BLL 11 24 02.70590242 +23 36 45.8701768 19.50 19.32 19.26 19.75   ~ 104 1
99 4FGL J1135.1+3014 Bz? 11 35 09.2 +30 14 04           ~ 10 0
100 QSO B1144-3755 BLL 11 47 01.37071212 -38 12 11.0235229   19.03 16.2 16.72   ~ 320 1
101 7C 122223.5+213929 Bla 12 24 54.4583146056 +21 22 46.385507388   17.56 17.50 18.2   ~ 770 2
102 9Y-MST J1250+0216 Bla 12 50 36.3 +02 17 15           ~ 29 0
103 7C 130046.50+580438.00 Bla 13 02 52.46528286 +57 48 37.6093029   20.47 19.76 20.63   ~ 124 1
104 NVSS J132210+084231 BLL 13 22 10.16928 +08 42 33.0660           ~ 40 1
105 3FGL J1331.1-1328 BLL 13 31 20.3588348256 -13 26 05.590756896           ~ 31 1
106 ICRF J133307.4+272518 Bla 13 33 07.49072970 +27 25 18.3826301       19.58   ~ 88 1
107 6C 142016+323628 Bla 14 22 30.3788624376 +32 23 10.440862980   19.33 19.16 19.11   ~ 196 1
108 [VV2006] J150348.0+475931 BLL 15 03 47.9973 +47 59 31.024   20.49 20.04 19.2   ~ 65 1
109 7C 164616.60+495503.00 BLL 16 47 34.9117576933 +49 50 00.584303604     17 12.47   ~ 119 1
110 4C 48.41 BLL 16 57 46.87895361 +48 08 33.0407928       19.70   ~ 92 1
111 NVSS J170409+123421 BLL 17 04 09.5806742568 +12 34 21.510015888           ~ 45 1
112 4C 09.57 BLL 17 51 32.81857326 +09 39 00.7284066   17.46 16.78 15.57   ~ 1007 1
113 1RXS J180043.6+782806 BLL 18 00 45.6838528560 +78 28 04.018028016   16.4 15.90 16.134   ~ 793 1
114 Z 340-35 BLL 18 06 50.6802916920 +69 49 28.109609256   14.77 14.22 11.39   ~ 909 1
115 PMN J1816-4943 rG 18 16 55.99425 -49 43 44.6729           ~ 43 1
116 QSO B1933-400 Bla 19 37 16.21735889 -39 58 01.5531167   18.15 19 17.43   ~ 209 2
117 9Y-MST J1943-3512 Bla 19 43 37.38 -35 31 27.0           ~ 31 1
118 ICRF J195441.1-112322 BLL 19 54 41.15572923 -11 23 22.6421728       19.02   ~ 108 1
119 QSO J2015+371 BLL 20 15 28.72978661 +37 10 59.5147372     21.82 21.4   ~ 324 2
120 ICRF J202553.6-284548 QSO 20 25 53.61284023 -28 45 48.6983395       17.70   ~ 60 1
121 ICRF J212100.6+190128 Bla 21 21 00.60664506 +19 01 28.2791111       20.3   ~ 89 1
122 4C -02.81 BLL 21 34 10.30958988 -01 53 17.2389056   18.6 19.00 18.87   ~ 431 1
123 QSO B2150+173 BLL 21 52 24.81939266 +17 34 37.7950210     17.9 17.98   ~ 186 2
124 QSO B2155-152 Bla 21 58 06.28188411 -15 01 09.3284729   18.63 18.30 17.79   ~ 355 1
125 NAME BL Lac BLL 22 02 43.2913536816 +42 16 39.979416792   15.66 14.72     ~ 2397 1
126 QSO B2209+236 Bla 22 12 05.96631459 +23 55 40.5438259   19 20.66 19.69   ~ 257 1
127 ICRF J221700.8+242145 BLL 22 17 00.82117644 +24 21 45.9580153       19.21   ~ 104 1
128 3C 446 BLL 22 25 47.25929101 -04 57 01.3907626   18.83 18.39 16.3   ~ 863 1
129 QSO B2232+282 BLL 22 36 22.47084387 +28 28 57.4132050   19.1 19.0 17.60   ~ 306 2
130 3FHL J2241.2+4120 Bla 22 41 14.1 +41 20 23           ~ 22 0
131 ICRF J231544.3-501839 BLL 23 15 44.33035057 -50 18 39.7046902 19.21 18.79 18.95 18.53   ~ 94 1
132 QSO J2345-1555 BLL 23 45 12.4622049264 -15 55 07.836801888   19.21   18.48   ~ 202 1
133 4FGL J2349.4+0534 AG? 23 49 25.4 +05 34 44           ~ 19 0
134 ICRF J235725.1-015215 BLL 23 57 25.13793285 -01 52 15.5090369     21.2 19.92   ~ 81 1

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2023MNRAS.525.3201K and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu