2024A&A...691A.226C


Query : 2024A&A...691A.226C

2024A&A...691A.226C - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 691A226 (2024/11-1)

A comparative high-resolution spectroscopic analysis of in situ and accreted globular clusters.

CECCARELLI E., MUCCIARELLI A., MASSARI D., BELLAZZINI M. and MATSUNO T.

Abstract (from CDS):

Globular clusters (GCs) are extremely intriguing systems that help in reconstructing the assembly of the Milky Way via the characterisation of their chemo-chrono-dynamical properties. In this study, we use high-resolution spectroscopic archival data from UVES and UVES-FLAMES at the VLT to compare the chemistry of GCs dynamically tagged as either Galactic (NGC 6218, NGC 6522, and NGC 6626) or accreted from distinct merger events (NGC 362 and NGC 1261 from Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus, and Ruprecht 106 from the Helmi Streams) in the metallicity regime where abundance patterns of field stars with different origin effectively separate (-1.3 ≤ [Fe/H] ≤ -1.0 dex). We find remarkable similarities in the abundances of the two Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus GCs across all chemical elements. They both display depletion in the α-elements (Mg, Si and Ca) and statistically significant differences in Zn and Eu compared to in situ GCs. Additionally, we confirm that Ruprecht 106 exhibits a completely different chemical makeup from the other target clusters, being underabundant in all chemical elements. This demonstrates that when high precision is achieved, the abundances of certain chemical elements can not only efficiently separate in situ from accreted GCs, but can also distinguish among GCs born in different progenitor galaxies. In the end, we investigate the possible origin of the chemical peculiarity of Ruprecht 106. Given that its abundances do not match the chemical patterns of the field stars associated with its most likely parent galaxy (i.e. the Helmi Streams), being depleted in the abundances of α-elements in particular, we believe Ruprecht 106 to originate from a less massive galaxy compared to the progenitor of the Helmi Streams.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2024

Journal keyword(s): stars: abundances - Galaxy: formation - globular clusters: general

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/691/A226): table1.dat table2.dat table3.dat table4.dat>

Simbad objects: 85

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 85
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NGC 121 GlC 00 26 49.0 -71 32 10   11.2 11.24     ~ 330 0
2 NAME SMC G 00 52 38.0 -72 48 01   2.79 2.2     ~ 12317 1
3 NGC 288 GlC 00 52 45.24 -26 34 57.4   10 8.13     ~ 1130 0
4 NAME Sculptor Dwarf Galaxy G 01 00 09.4 -33 42 32   9.79 8.6 8.81   ~ 1498 4
5 NGC 362 4084 RG* 01 02 37.6352653416 -70 50 37.066360920   14.335 12.950     ~ 30 0
6 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 2205 SB* 01 02 38.0593130784 -70 51 21.645800892   14.561 13.345   12.13 ~ 14 0
7 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 39 RG* 01 02 40.2459742200 -70 47 47.446181448   14.818 13.674     ~ 13 0
8 2MASS J01024512-7052105 RG* 01 02 45.1287312000 -70 52 10.590947112   14.601 13.441     ~ 27 0
9 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1159 RG* 01 02 53.1634752912 -70 50 30.884368848   14.331 12.68     ~ 19 0
10 NGC 362 4061 RG* 01 02 55.9640571216 -70 50 17.664781560   14.336 13.017     ~ 10 0
11 NGC 362 1044 RG* 01 02 58.5941862120 -70 51 53.351670564   14.492 13.253     ~ 23 0
12 Cl* NGC 362 FWM dj RG* 01 03 03.9157961904 -70 51 32.182739820   14.315 12.992     ~ 8 0
13 Cl* NGC 362 TUC 216 s?r 01 03 08.4898183488 -70 45 28.100168172   14.83 13.59     ~ 13 0
14 NGC 362 GlC 01 03 14.26 -70 50 55.6     6.58     ~ 1167 0
15 2MASS J01032882-7049527 RG* 01 03 28.8201038616 -70 49 52.837039632   14.844 13.52     ~ 12 0
16 NGC 362 3037 RG* 01 03 30.6397961448 -70 50 10.562883396   14.453 13.204     ~ 14 0
17 NGC 362 3044 RG* 01 03 34.9196877312 -70 48 07.968919104   14.261 12.804     ~ 30 0
18 Cl* NGC 362 HAR 1415 RG* 01 03 37.2476218080 -70 50 05.915808312   14.694 13.541     ~ 14 0
19 Cl* NGC 362 ALC 199 RG* 01 04 02.4058789320 -70 49 10.916148000   14.821 13.646     ~ 17 0
20 MCG-06-07-001 G 02 39 59.3 -34 26 57   9.02 7.4     ~ 1894 1
21 NAME Magellanic Clouds GrG 03 00 -71.0           ~ 7988 0
22 GES J03120777-5512129 * 03 12 07.7803626419 -55 12 12.962523930           ~ 4 0
23 [MMR2021] NGC 1261 52 RG* 03 12 09.7818239195 -55 12 49.892368702           ~ 3 0
24 [MMR2021] NGC 1261 6 RG* 03 12 12.8762114416 -55 13 52.123353394           ~ 2 0
25 2MASS J03121313-5513570 * 03 12 13.1435377806 -55 13 57.069393757           ~ 9 0
26 GES J03121542-5512213 RG* 03 12 15.4370407903 -55 12 21.274866642           ~ 4 0
27 NGC 1261 GlC 03 12 16.21 -55 12 58.4     8.63     ~ 579 0
28 GES J03121651-5513592 * 03 12 16.5198907345 -55 13 59.217154139           ~ 5 0
29 GES J03121658-5512063 * 03 12 16.5903878020 -55 12 06.352134654           ~ 3 0
30 2MASS J03121822-5513310 RG* 03 12 18.2525673492 -55 13 31.028501061           ~ 8 0
31 GES J03121959-5513426 RG* 03 12 19.6050166658 -55 13 42.572754104           ~ 4 0
32 GES J03122139-5512245 RG* 03 12 21.4056529800 -55 12 24.482419918           ~ 5 0
33 GES J03122958-5511302 * 03 12 29.6023369293 -55 11 30.161043054     14.597   13.341 ~ 6 0
34 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 19090 0
35 NGC 2005 Cl* 05 30 08.500 -69 45 14.42   12.30 11.57     ~ 103 0
36 ESO 206-20A G 06 41 36.7 -50 57 58   22.14 11.0 19.47   ~ 1190 0
37 NAME Sextans dSph LSB 10 13 02.9 -01 36 53   12 10.4     ~ 921 0
38 Cl* Ruprecht 106 BBF 1-1863 * 12 38 34.7532841094 -51 08 01.916129082   17.53 16.42     ~ 3 0
39 Cl* Ruprecht 106 BBF 1-1951 * 12 38 35.4754518951 -51 07 52.572695498   16.81 15.49     ~ 6 0
40 Cl* Ruprecht 106 BBF 1-801 * 12 38 36.0010403106 -51 09 37.524687987   17.81 16.71     ~ 2 0
41 2MASS J12383655-5108256 LP* 12 38 36.5536887351 -51 08 25.718845912   16.40 14.73     ~ 4 0
42 Cl* Ruprecht 106 BBF 1-1445 * 12 38 39.2148690032 -51 08 39.656540415           ~ 1 0
43 Cl Ruprecht 106 GlC 12 38 40.20 -51 09 01.0           ~ 413 0
44 Cl* Ruprecht 106 BBF 1-2004 * 12 38 40.9610648319 -51 07 46.417193837   16.35 14.82     ~ 3 0
45 Gaia DR3 6078980647868868608 RG* 12 38 42.5793994072 -51 09 23.078679517     15.494   14.054 ~ 2 0
46 Cl* Ruprecht 106 BBF 1-676 * 12 38 43.8315479997 -51 09 50.939358107   17.45 16.30     ~ 3 0
47 Cl* Ruprecht 106 BBF 1-2032 * 12 38 48.9300698760 -51 07 43.276689211   17.56 16.46     ~ 2 0
48 Z 318-18 G 15 09 08.0 +67 13 21   13.60 10.6     ~ 1459 0
49 NGC 6218 4263 RG* 16 46 52.9676623944 -01 56 33.116729064   14.549 13.422     ~ 14 0
50 2MASS J16470329-0155466 RG* 16 47 03.2982145512 -01 55 46.606242144   13.886 12.533     ~ 8 0
51 NGC 6218 1265 RG* 16 47 03.9791924520 -02 01 32.251929780   14.236 12.995     ~ 19 0
52 Cl* NGC 6218 KUST 76 RG* 16 47 04.4613982584 -01 57 48.713460588   14.324 13.086     ~ 13 0
53 2MASS J16470709-0156030 RG* 16 47 07.1003386152 -01 56 03.032244240   14.753 13.648     ~ 6 0
54 NGC 6218 1148 RG* 16 47 08.7205055280 -01 59 09.634895340   14.694 13.567     ~ 11 0
55 Cl* NGC 6218 KUST 174 RG* 16 47 11.8552335000 -01 59 57.373258560   14.727 13.614     ~ 15 0
56 M 12 GlC 16 47 14.18 -01 56 54.7     6.07     ~ 736 0
57 NGC 6218 3163 RG* 16 47 17.7044416344 -01 59 09.793785840   14.307 13.117     ~ 14 0
58 NGC 6218 2107 RG* 16 47 21.6051199584 -01 56 59.270374500   13.944 12.589 12.335   ~ 15 0
59 NGC 6218 2116 RG* 16 47 26.5580746896 -01 57 19.165388796   14.152 12.857     ~ 13 0
60 NGC 6218 2247 RG* 16 47 27.4153039512 -02 00 24.667284060   13.923 12.577     ~ 20 0
61 OGLE BWC I 341 * 18 03 31.5912418440 -30 00 51.372743076     15.86   14.241 ~ 5 0
62 2MASS J18033354-3002254 * 18 03 33.54888 -30 02 25.4868     16.306   14.672 ~ 2 0
63 NGC 6522 GlC 18 03 34.08 -30 02 02.3           ~ 569 0
64 Cl* NGC 6522 ARP 2187 * 18 03 42.2569293912 -30 03 40.442064048   17.39 16.014 15.70 14.36 ~ 16 0
65 2MASS J18034235-3002088 * 18 03 42.3562398759 -30 02 08.890315841     16.226   14.554 ~ 3 0
66 NGC 6626 1236 * 18 24 27.3119622990 -24 52 34.960086394           ~ 1 0
67 2MASS J18242792-2451160 RG* 18 24 27.9264931392 -24 51 16.040466504   16.07 14.64     ~ 5 0
68 2MASS J18242914-2452024 RG* 18 24 29.1432374904 -24 52 02.357056416           ~ 2 0
69 2MASS J18243130-2452471 RG* 18 24 31.2992347056 -24 52 47.165203740           ~ 4 0
70 2MASS J18243140-2451136 RG* 18 24 31.4020658664 -24 51 13.654680984           ~ 4 0
71 2MASS J18243191-2453293 RG* 18 24 31.9133207496 -24 53 29.345118252   15.03 13.39     ~ 4 0
72 2MASS J18243208-2452567 RG* 18 24 32.0784115800 -24 52 56.809516332           ~ 2 0
73 M 28 GlC 18 24 32.89 -24 52 11.4           ~ 821 0
74 2MASS J18243318-2451079 RG* 18 24 33.1834429752 -24 51 07.916016132           ~ 2 0
75 2MASS J18243398-2451227 RG* 18 24 33.9777184104 -24 51 22.653135648           ~ 2 0
76 2MASS J18243399-2450583 RG* 18 24 33.9892601976 -24 50 58.333972488           ~ 2 0
77 2MASS J18243460-2452406 RG* 18 24 34.6012771488 -24 52 40.653625656           ~ 2 0
78 NGC 6626 1364 * 18 24 35.9043331654 -24 52 09.056182635           ~ 1 0
79 2MASS J18243627-2452221 RG* 18 24 36.2761471416 -24 52 22.222922556           ~ 2 0
80 2MASS J18243700-2451179 RG* 18 24 37.0006032456 -24 51 17.985519576   15.29 13.67     ~ 3 0
81 2MASS J18243713-2452257 RG* 18 24 37.1296873680 -24 52 25.808759040           ~ 2 0
82 2MASS J18243900-2451077 RG* 18 24 39.0003651360 -24 51 07.832647656   16.58 14.10     ~ 5 0
83 NAME Gaia Enceladus-Sausage St* ~ ~           ~ 860 0
84 NAME Galactic Bulge reg ~ ~           ~ 4794 0
85 NAME Local Group GrG ~ ~           ~ 9325 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2024A&A...691A.226C and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu