2024A&A...692A.109D


Query : 2024A&A...692A.109D

2024A&A...692A.109D - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 692A109 (2024/12-1)

Investigating 39 Galactic Wolf-Rayet stars with VLTI/GRAVITY Uncovering a long-period binary desert.

DESHMUKH K., SANA H., MERAND A., BORDIER E., LANGER N., BODENSTEINER J., DSILVA K., FROST A.J., GOSSET E., LE BOUQUIN J.-B., LEFEVER R.R., MAHY L., PATRICK L.R., REGGIANI M., SANDER A.A.C., SHENAR T., TRAMPER F., VILLASENOR J.I. and WAISBERG I.

Abstract (from CDS):

Context. Wolf-Rayet stars (WRs) represent one of the final evolutionary stages of massive stars and are thought to be the immediate progenitors of stellar-mass black holes. Their multiplicity characteristics form an important anchor point in single and binary population models for predicting gravitational-wave progenitors. Recent spectroscopic campaigns have suggested incompatible multiplicity fractions and period distributions for N- and C-rich Galactic WRs (WNs and WCs) at both short and long orbital periods, in contradiction with evolutionary model predictions.
Aims. In this work, we employed long-baseline infrared interferometry to investigate the multiplicity of WRs at long periods and explored the nature of their companions. We present a magnitude-limited (K < 9; V < 14) survey of 39 Galactic WRs, including 11 WN, 15 WC, and 13 H-rich WN (WNh) stars.
Methods. We used the K-band instrument GRAVITY at the Very Large Telescope Interferometer (VLTI) in Chile. The sensitivity of GRAVITY at spatial scales of ∼1 to 200 milliarcseconds and flux contrast of 1% allowed an exploration of periods in the range 102 - 105 d and companions down to ∼5 M⊙. We carried out a companion search for all our targets, with the aim of either finding wide companions or calculating detection limits. We also explored the rich GRAVITY dataset beyond a multiplicity search to look for other interesting properties of the WR sample.
Results. We detected wide companions with VLTI/GRAVITY for only four stars in our sample: WR 48, WR 89, WR 93, and WR 115. Combining our results with spectroscopic studies, we arrived at observed multiplicity fractions of $ f^{\mathrm{WN}}_{\mathrm{obs}} = 0.55\,{\pm}\,0.15 $, $ f^{\mathrm{WC}}_{\mathrm{obs}} = 0.40\,{\pm}\,0.13, $ and $ f^{\mathrm{WNh}}_{\mathrm{obs}} = 0.23\,{\pm}\,0.12 $. The multiplicity fractions and period distributions of WNs and WCs are consistent in our sample. For single WRs, we placed upper limits on the mass of potential companions down to ∼5 M⊙ for WNs and WCs, and ∼7 M⊙ for WNh stars. In addition, we also found other features in the GRAVITY dataset, such as (i) a diffuse extended component contributing significantly to the K-band flux in over half the WR sample; (ii) five known spectroscopic binaries resolved in differential phase data, which constitutes an alternative detection method for close binaries; and (iii) spatially resolved winds in four stars: WR 16, WR 31a, WR 78, and WR 110.
Conclusions. Our survey reveals a lack of intermediate- (a few hundred days) and long- (a few years to decades) period WR systems. The 200d peak in the period distributions of WR+OB and BH+OB binaries predicted by Case B mass-transfer binary evolution models is not seen in our data. The rich companionship of their O-type progenitors in this separation range suggests that the WR progenitor stars expand and interact with their companions, most likely through unstable mass transfer, resulting in either a short-period system or a merger.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2024

Journal keyword(s): techniques: interferometric - binaries: general - stars: massive - stars: Wolf-Rayet

Simbad objects: 84

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 84
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 NAME SMC G 00 52 38.0 -72 48 01   2.79 2.2     ~ 12317 1
2 HD 5980 WR* 00 59 26.5838833944 -72 09 53.927337312   11.13 11.31   11.029 WN4+O7I: 419 1
3 M 33 GiG 01 33 50.8965749232 +30 39 36.630403128 6.17 6.27 5.72     ~ 6226 1
4 NAME Romano Star WR* 01 35 09.7011882336 +30 41 57.160957560     18.04     Ofpe/WN9 59 1
5 NAME LMC G 05 23 34.6 -69 45 22     0.4     ~ 19090 0
6 HD 61103 * 07 36 17.3026252416 -33 44 28.918252392   10.04 8.87     K0III 6 0
7 HD 62910 WR* 07 44 58.2217347768 -31 54 29.554957188 10.08 10.44 10.10 10.17   WN6/WC4 134 0
8 HD 63099 WR* 07 45 50.3991805440 -34 19 48.500286780 11.47 11.43 10.50 10.37   WC4+O7 119 0
9 HD 64545 * 07 53 13.6487599320 -30 51 43.882311960   10.08 8.98     K0III 6 0
10 CD-45 4482 WR* 08 44 47.2901340000 -45 58 55.417387548 10.95 11.29 10.74 10.58   WN8h+? 108 0
11 HD 75027 * 08 45 44.0986790376 -46 51 30.893784624   9.90 8.75     K0III 7 0
12 HD 76536 WR* 08 54 59.1670918944 -47 35 32.662167792 9.04 9.13 8.80 9.52   WC 129 0
13 HD 79573 WR* 09 13 11.7689184720 -50 06 25.523968608 12.30 11.80 10.69 10.52   WC6 87 0
14 HD 80347 * 09 17 27.2303013720 -50 34 35.445049032   8.30 7.34     K0III 10 0
15 HD 85779 * 09 52 18.6567063072 -56 39 00.346227408   10.45 9.07     K2/3III 6 0
16 HD 86161 WR* 09 54 52.9033957968 -57 43 38.274644604 7.94 8.65 8.36 8.93   WN8h 230 0
17 HD 88687 * 10 12 03.7919897400 -56 30 28.249577352   10.09 8.97     K1III 9 0
18 HD 89358 WR* 10 17 02.2743231360 -57 54 46.875258324 11.1 11.19 10.83 10.59   WN4-s 181 1
19 HD 90274 PM* 10 23 42.4355119464 -59 12 21.879502596   8.26 7.07     K1III 7 0
20 HD 90657 WR* 10 26 31.4087563344 -58 38 26.182481568 9.53 10.07 9.65 9.84   WN5+O4-6 169 0
21 HD 91652 * 10 33 26.2000348008 -61 08 15.868752792   10.09 8.66     K0/1II/III 7 0
22 HD 92740 WR* 10 41 17.5158425712 -59 40 36.895992960 5.68 6.50 6.42 7.38   WN7h+O9III-V 426 0
23 HD 92809 WR* 10 41 38.3243333544 -58 46 18.723223308 8.95 9.28 9.03 9.60   WC6 163 0
24 HD 93131 WR* 10 43 52.2579213120 -60 07 04.019676456 5.52 6.43 6.48 7.46   WN6ha-w 309 0
25 NGC 3357 rG 10 44 20.7384422256 +14 05 04.088114412   14.3       ~ 33 2
26 HD 93808 * 10 48 38.5767315072 -57 59 17.752994304   10.62 9.38     K0/1(III) 8 0
27 HD 94546 WR* 10 53 44.8179035891 -59 30 46.684250766 10.38 10.94 10.51 10.48   WN4+O8V 129 0
28 WRAY 15-682 WR* 10 53 59.5777329720 -60 26 44.361095316   11.64 10.85 10.56   WN11h 155 3
29 HD 95096 * 10 57 30.0532130232 -62 29 56.556682620   10.01 8.65     K1III 16 0
30 HD 96010 * 11 03 35.3802407808 -53 35 21.043443696   11.08 10.23     K1III: 5 0
31 HD 96568 * 11 06 24.2536530672 -64 50 23.899090308   6.490 6.381 7.59 8.43 A3V 43 0
32 HD 97152 WR* 11 10 04.0797150120 -60 58 44.963276664 7.47 8.03 8.07 8.91   WC7+O7V 190 0
33 HD 98677 * 11 20 34.2990985560 -58 35 22.671655080   9.77 8.54     K2/3III 5 0
34 HD 107837 * 12 23 45.8758597752 -62 30 18.424092024   10.09 9.02     K0(III) 7 0
35 HD 311884 WR* 12 43 50.9991209208 -63 05 14.812489320 11.45 11.64 10.81 10.59   WN6+O5V 175 0
36 * tet Mus WR* 13 08 07.1531705448 -65 18 21.679426548 4.71 5.50 5.53 5.44 5.40 WC5+B0III 336 0
37 HD 115473 WR* 13 18 27.9941240160 -58 08 13.603221168 9.09 9.68 9.00 9.72   WC5 119 0
38 HD 116140 * 13 21 49.9538419200 -07 44 47.555310228   10.66 9.38     K2III 6 0
39 HD 116007 PM* 13 22 34.9086374424 -67 58 14.100717000   10.53 9.53     K0/2(III) 6 0
40 HD 116471 * 13 25 08.8461233016 -60 11 16.590774372   10.77 9.68     K0II/III 6 0
41 HD 116703 SB* 13 27 08.5933457400 -67 01 20.618703192   8.66 7.40     K1III 14 0
42 HD 117688 WR* 13 33 30.1197052368 -62 19 01.214335740 8.69 10.81 10.90 10.44   WN7 134 0
43 HD 119078 WR* 13 43 16.3587374232 -67 24 04.973391360 9.11 9.737 9.40 10.08   WC7/8 110 0
44 HD 134877 WR* 15 14 57.7186057272 -59 50 30.215432688 12.13 12.19 11.34 11.08   WN8(h) 112 0
45 HD 135378 * 15 17 24.0188929176 -58 26 43.030611492   10.81 9.67     K3III 6 0
46 HD 147155 * 16 22 41.7032361000 -52 21 17.104411188   10.49 9.40     K1(III) 7 0
47 HD 147419 WR* 16 24 26.2279587024 -51 32 06.061114140   11.46 10.50 10.74   WN6-s 114 0
48 HD 151790 * 16 51 16.6401676008 -39 50 09.125009196   9.74 8.51     K0III 9 0
49 HD 151932 WR* 16 52 19.2477039480 -41 51 16.270066224 6.06 6.79 6.51 7.64   WN7h 326 0
50 HD 152270 WR* 16 54 19.6991292072 -41 49 11.531710092 6.26 6.80 6.597 6.72 6.39 WC7+O5-8 315 0
51 HD 152408 WR* 16 54 58.5051071856 -41 09 03.093075612 5.17 5.92 5.77 7.00   O8Iape 388 0
52 HD 152370 * 16 55 01.1089423656 -44 33 31.886821332   10.24 8.88     K0III 6 0
53 HD 152386 WR* 16 55 06.4499424072 -44 59 21.364771956 8.15 8.64 8.13 8.84   O6:Iafpe 88 0
54 MR 66 WR* 17 02 40.3826152512 -45 59 15.453237084   13.62 12.07 11.77   WC9 67 0
55 HD 153951 * 17 04 40.9927708944 -45 30 40.620294216   10.22 8.94     K0/1(III) 8 0
56 LS 3982 WR* 17 14 27.1191622584 -39 45 47.051105904 10.63 10.95 10.41     WN6h-w 73 0
57 HD 155808 * 17 15 32.4985788216 -38 05 10.010298012   10.25 8.87     K2III 7 0
58 HD 156291 PM* 17 18 39.7579326864 -40 46 22.818434664   10.60 9.67 9.11 9.109 K1/2(III) 27 0
59 WRAY 15-1666 WR* 17 18 52.8750705984 -38 50 03.606746928 13.93 13.27 11.83 11.43   WN7 79 0
60 CD-38 11746 WR* 17 19 00.5232022104 -38 48 51.247595664 13.01 12.48 11.02 10.55   WN8h 106 0
61 HD 156641 * 17 20 38.1419834232 -40 34 01.868287404   9.64 8.48 7.78 8.052 K1III 20 0
62 HD 157504 WR* 17 25 08.8532916336 -34 11 12.498318168 12.80 12.10 10.68 10.39 11.546 WC7+O7-9 121 0
63 HD 157451 WR* 17 25 23.2779945960 -43 29 31.469964540 10 10.59 10.20 10.46   WC9 96 0
64 HD 158021 * 17 28 15.1377385056 -34 36 39.552382332   10.40 9.02     K1(III) 18 0
65 HD 159488 * 17 36 28.5185125320 -34 36 13.912223724   9.79 8.73     K0III 5 0
66 HD 320102 WR* 17 36 53.6232746376 -34 02 36.778424604 11.51 11.60 10.72 10.65   WN4+O5/7V 100 0
67 HD 318016 WR* 17 37 13.7436747168 -33 27 56.013254280 13.71 13.16 11.81 11.42   WN8/WC7 83 0
68 WR 98a WR* 17 41 13.0411858104 -30 32 30.409373688   18.40   15.20 13.82 WC8/9 112 1
69 HD 160263 * 17 41 16.2430825872 -46 55 18.611215428 5.72 5.78 5.79     A0V 68 0
70 MR 80 WR* 18 02 04.1244400656 -23 37 42.168277056   15.002 13.155 12.056   WC9 241 1
71 HD 313846 WR* 18 05 25.7344895280 -23 00 20.334949992 10.48 10.69 9.89 9.89   WN9h+OB 143 0
72 HD 165688 WR* 18 07 56.9609461704 -19 23 56.863324824 10.46 10.31 9.87 9.85   WN5-6b 162 0
73 HD 165763 WR* 18 08 28.4692108104 -21 15 11.183076540 7.16 7.54 7.82 8.55   WC6 286 0
74 HD 166031 * 18 09 41.2361577168 -20 49 52.680347976   10.536 9.426     K0III 10 0
75 HD 166240 * 18 10 34.8467962848 -18 42 00.844899372   9.981 9.150     K0III 10 0
76 WR 112 WR* 18 16 33.4909366272 -18 58 42.341845368   20.7 17.7     WC8+O6/7III/V 143 0
77 HD 167811 * 18 17 29.0868261024 -14 03 21.552008220   11.27 9.86     K0/1(III) 6 0
78 HD 168206 WR* 18 19 07.3629298440 -11 37 59.164994424 9.65 9.88 9.10     WC8+O8/9III/V 308 1
79 HD 169010 WR* 18 23 16.3427231112 -13 43 26.102574732 13.53 12.99 12.02 11.95   WC 82 0
80 MR 87 WR* 18 25 30.0135261024 -14 38 40.967308176 13.38 13.09 11.86 11.33   WN6-w 84 0
81 HD 169783 * 18 26 57.1419410496 -13 51 16.907071464   9.33 8.17     K0III 5 0
82 HD 192641 WR* 20 14 31.7666855880 +36 39 39.598210224 7.80 8.20 7.91     WC7pd+O9V 347 0
83 HD 193077 WR* 20 17 00.0260987184 +37 25 23.785483116 7.82 8.32 8.01 8.71   WN5o+B? 297 0
84 HD 193793 WR* 20 20 27.9757908696 +43 51 16.286840244 6.90 7.25 6.85 4.58   WC7pd+O5.5fc 754 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2024A&A...692A.109D and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu