2024AJ....167..271V


Query : 2024AJ....167..271V

2024AJ....167..271V - Astron. J., 167, 271 (2024/June-0)

Differences between Stable and Unstable Architectures of Compact Planetary Systems.

VOLK K. and MALHOTRA R.

Abstract (from CDS):

We present a stability analysis of a large set of simulated planetary systems of three or more planets based on architectures of multiplanet systems discovered by Kepler and K2. We propagated 21,400 simulated planetary systems up to 5 billion orbits of the innermost planet; approximately 13% of these simulations ended in a planet-planet collision within that time span. We examined trends in dynamical stability based on dynamical spacings, orbital period ratios, and mass ratios of nearest-neighbor planets as well as the system-wide planet mass distribution and the spectral fraction describing the system's short-term evolution. We find that instability is more likely in planetary systems with adjacent planet pairs that have period ratios less than 2 and in systems of greater variance of planet masses. Systems with planet pairs at very small dynamical spacings (less than ∼10-12 mutual Hill radii) are also prone to instabilities, but instabilities also occur at much larger planetary separations. We find that a large spectral fraction (calculated from short integrations) is a reasonable predictor of longer-term dynamical instability; systems that have a large number of Fourier components in their eccentricity vectors are prone to secular chaos and subsequent eccentricity growth and instabilities.

Abstract Copyright: © 2024. The Author(s). Published by the American Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): Exoplanets - Exoplanet dynamics - Exoplanet systems - Orbital evolution

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/AJ/167/271): table2.dat>

Simbad objects: 165

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 165
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 K2-219 * 00 51 22.8636621264 +08 52 03.502996140   12.84 12.09     G3 16 0
2 2MASS J00580427-0011353 * 00 58 04.2759465960 -00 11 35.361645648           K7V 14 0
3 K2-384 PM* 01 21 59.8550930760 +00 45 04.411982556       16.02   ~ 13 0
4 K2-80 Em* 03 56 08.9999038224 +13 33 33.442027668   13.61 12.63 12.49   G8 21 0
5 LP 415-17 PM* 04 21 52.4852745864 +21 21 12.937879152   14.07   12.46   K6V 45 0
6 K2-136 PM* 04 29 38.9939167752 +22 52 57.793533924   12.48 11.20 10.90   K5.5V 92 0
7 LP 358-499 PM* 04 40 35.6391087000 +25 00 36.048117816   15.63   13.4   M2V 29 0
8 K2-183 * 08 20 01.7183469384 +14 01 10.070401116   13.63 12.85 12.74   G7 32 0
9 K2-187 * 08 50 05.6681799264 +23 11 33.369793728           K0 23 0
10 K2-268 * 08 54 50.2862040432 +11 50 53.774484972   14.78 13.85 13.62   K1 27 0
11 K2-266 PM* 10 31 44.5056089208 +00 56 15.269139996           K5V 39 0
12 K2-3 PM* 11 29 20.3917077216 -01 27 17.281697868   13.52 12.17 11.88   M1V 99 0
13 K2-19 * 11 39 50.4803341248 +00 36 12.875047920   13.80 13.00 12.88   G7 75 0
14 K2-165 * 12 19 36.0868643352 +00 58 06.201209244   12.45 11.33     K0V 13 0
15 BD-19 4086 * 15 21 55.1983073496 -20 13 53.990924232   11.81 10.88     K3 38 0
16 K2-37 * 16 13 48.2446204272 -24 47 13.428497616           ~ 36 0
17 K2-32 PM* 16 49 42.2601799152 -19 32 34.151379684   13.28 12.31 12.11   ~ 66 0
18 Kepler-431 Er* 18 44 26.9622053520 +43 13 40.040381892   12.674 12.021 11.949   F6IV 61 0
19 Kepler-94 Er* 18 44 46.7440377288 +47 29 49.749482616   14.438 13.184 12.825   M0V 83 0
20 Kepler-102 PM* 18 45 55.8559851072 +47 12 28.845259020   12.58 12.07 11.510   K3V 137 0
21 Kepler-83 Er* 18 48 55.8020067360 +43 39 56.249582760       15.914   M0V 67 1
22 Kepler-446 * 18 49 00.0433305672 +44 55 15.977921880           M4V 45 0
23 Kepler-338 Er* 18 51 54.9519387600 +40 47 03.675669144   12.88 12.19 12.142   G0 84 0
24 Kepler-271 Er* 18 52 00.7169260536 +44 17 03.188714244   14.370 13.583 13.501   F9 75 0
25 Kepler-298 Ro* 18 52 09.5526737544 +48 49 31.316827260           ~ 44 0
26 Kepler-363 Er* 18 52 46.1054164776 +41 18 19.315610676   14.380 13.473 13.334   G5V 64 0
27 Kepler-299 Ro* 18 52 49.6707822504 +48 34 49.794434544           ~ 65 0
28 Kepler-62 Er* 18 52 51.0518497680 +45 20 59.399622996   14.702 13.982 13.807   G5 158 1
29 Kepler-1388 Ro* 18 53 20.6548120296 +47 10 28.257812616           M0V 49 0
30 Kepler-172 Er* 18 53 28.4170433352 +41 49 18.551185212   15.627 14.702 14.517   G8 75 0
31 Kepler-301 Ro* 18 55 55.8992978160 +49 13 58.711633932           F9 61 0
32 BD+44 3020 Em* 18 56 14.3076037320 +44 31 05.389610412   10.45 9.77     G8V 158 1
33 Kepler-90 EB* 18 57 44.0383126392 +49 18 18.496454184   14.604 13.896 13.713   G2 155 0
34 Kepler-282 Ro* 18 58 42.5471457528 +44 47 51.598416912           ~ 69 0
35 Kepler-26 Er* 18 59 45.8408222304 +46 33 59.437703052   17.203 15.982 15.568   M0V 104 1
36 Kepler-55 Er* 19 00 40.4013750408 +44 01 35.369032296       15.929   K5 92 1
37 Kepler-1254 Ro* 19 00 41.5973276352 +48 46 12.060671844           K3 34 0
38 Kepler-127 Er* 19 00 45.5887144320 +46 01 40.693626120   12.231 11.627 11.415   G0 95 0
39 Kepler-30 Er* 19 01 08.0746104528 +38 56 50.218268856   16.50   15.767 14.55 ~ 180 1
40 Kepler-295 Ro* 19 01 23.0049838008 +45 22 03.986652576           ~ 58 0
41 Kepler-350 Er* 19 01 40.7037733680 +39 42 22.016147364   14.669 13.884 13.903   F5 57 0
42 Kepler-9 Er* 19 02 17.7544327200 +38 24 03.176851896     13.9 13.791   G2 223 1
43 Kepler-1542 Ro* 19 02 54.8381343672 +42 39 16.310499048           G5V 66 0
44 Kepler-354 Ro* 19 03 00.3548814720 +41 20 08.296950264           K5 37 0
45 Kepler-169 Er* 19 03 59.9740327176 +40 55 09.611690772   15.451 14.410 14.283   ~ 77 0
46 Kepler-235 Er* 19 04 18.9842922480 +39 16 41.945483928       16.051   M0V 83 0
47 Kepler-351 Er* 19 05 48.6587767968 +42 39 28.319770584   16.798 16.206 16.283   ~ 36 0
48 Kepler-324 EB* 19 05 53.1508522392 +49 38 56.390047152           ~ 64 0
49 Kepler-770 Ro* 19 05 57.7023851784 +38 22 29.693161488           ~ 49 0
50 Kepler-296 ** 19 06 09.6025302984 +49 26 14.396852760           M2V 99 0
51 Kepler-25 Er* 19 06 33.2141354736 +39 29 16.358725104   11.337 10.623 10.622   F6 192 1
52 Kepler-332 Ro* 19 06 39.1083005856 +47 24 49.388410404           ~ 61 0
53 Kepler-52 Er* 19 06 57.1300334784 +49 58 32.637931608   17.108 15.716 15.217   M0V 77 1
54 Kepler-124 Er* 19 07 00.6695622552 +49 03 53.578044756   15.257 14.329 14.191   ~ 57 0
55 Kepler-178 Er* 19 08 24.2565925224 +46 53 47.360614236   15.493 14.788 14.550   ~ 64 0
56 Kepler-334 Er* 19 08 33.7575590712 +47 06 54.721322640   13.393 12.839 12.748   G0 74 0
57 Kepler-244 Er* 19 08 58.2403386624 +42 18 04.900346640       15.146   ~ 56 0
58 Kepler-174 Er* 19 09 45.4027017600 +43 49 55.499376144   15.539 14.601 14.276   K5 71 0
59 Kepler-104 EB* 19 10 25.1128815288 +42 10 00.255205236   13.12 12.73 12.61   G0V 101 0
60 Kepler-411 Er* 19 10 25.3469947368 +49 31 23.712634632   13.70 12.55 12.26   K3V 129 0
61 Kepler-20 Er* 19 10 47.5233433920 +42 20 19.301370684   13.278 12.630 12.478 11.64 G5V 201 1
62 Kepler-164 Ro* 19 11 07.3972813536 +47 37 47.634405528           ~ 71 0
63 Kepler-238 Er* 19 11 35.3058296736 +40 38 16.143812448       15.189   ~ 77 0
64 Kepler-192 Er* 19 11 40.2999391728 +45 35 34.425445272   15.237 14.223 14.041   G7 72 0
65 Kepler-254 Er* 19 12 39.5241024600 +45 48 59.394712176   16.896 15.958 15.953   ~ 71 0
66 Kepler-150 Er* 19 12 56.1835322352 +40 31 15.208382352   16.046 15.228 15.081   ~ 80 0
67 Kepler-402 Er* 19 13 28.8534589176 +43 21 16.582563936   13.884 13.317 13.177   F2 75 0
68 Kepler-130 Er* 19 13 48.1593590088 +40 14 43.162049328   12.687 12.007 11.868   G1V 90 0
69 Kepler-306 Er* 19 14 09.2870355888 +40 36 58.113106632       15.570   ~ 60 0
70 BD+40 3638 Er* 19 14 45.2915908224 +41 09 04.210237980   11.643 11.115 11.009   F6IV 159 1
71 Kepler-219 Er* 19 14 57.3495104640 +46 45 45.290906784   14.594 13.899 13.701   G2V 79 0
72 Kepler-319 Er* 19 15 14.8707783264 +39 46 14.405364444   14.860 14.008 13.829   G4V 62 0
73 Kepler-310 Er* 19 15 21.4377198432 +46 59 12.293095272       14.287   ~ 68 0
74 Kepler-288 Ro* 19 15 39.9366319272 +39 35 41.088472836           G1V 50 0
75 Kepler-60 Er* 19 15 50.6983640712 +42 15 54.050260968   14.477 14.083 13.934   G2 132 1
76 Kepler-33 Er* 19 16 18.6099987120 +46 00 18.813656376   14.823 14.146 14.022 13.23 F2 117 1
77 Kepler-92 Er* 19 16 20.6546892216 +41 33 46.654315236   12.460 11.849 11.777   G0IV 101 0
78 Kepler-126 Er* 19 17 23.3505657144 +44 12 30.709225008   11.182 10.566 10.515   F7IV 108 0
79 Kepler-250 Ro* 19 18 22.7423825568 +44 08 30.962454756           ~ 48 0
80 BD+41 3306 PM* 19 19 00.5489000285 +41 38 04.582441681 10.01 9.67 8.86 8.18 7.66 K0V 331 0
81 Kepler-154 Er* 19 19 07.3336120632 +49 53 47.550728148   15.11 14.57 14.66   G6 82 0
82 Kepler-325 Er* 19 19 20.5054876128 +49 49 32.163328344   15.956 15.262 15.212   G5 55 0
83 Kepler-341 Er* 19 19 26.7755204304 +43 28 21.988135488   15.490 14.765 14.600   G3 59 0
84 Kepler-403 Ro* 19 19 41.1509829792 +46 44 40.488916560           F9 61 0
85 Kepler-207 Ro* 19 20 07.3247573880 +42 09 57.757238064           G3 66 0
86 Kepler-401 Ro* 19 20 19.8617895696 +50 51 48.538719216           ~ 43 0
87 Kepler-336 Er* 19 20 57.0311647224 +41 19 53.055383772   14.355 13.688 13.554   G3 53 0
88 Kepler-138 Er* 19 21 31.5679755816 +43 17 34.680970608   14.621 13.168 12.680   M1V 145 0
89 Kepler-24 Er* 19 21 39.1857355848 +38 20 37.450192200   15.860 15.126 14.787   ~ 95 1
90 Kepler-19 Er* 19 21 40.9995019176 +37 51 06.437281140   12.88 12.04 11.888   F9 112 1
91 Kepler-53 Er* 19 21 50.8278108312 +40 33 44.887115556   16.283 15.352 15.367   ~ 75 1
92 Kepler-265 Ro* 19 22 02.5195713768 +41 14 41.294159952           G3 65 0
93 Kepler-198 Ro* 19 22 41.5540510848 +38 41 27.586105764           F9 73 0
94 Kepler-286 Er* 19 22 42.2833952040 +48 17 39.218963784       15.600   ~ 62 0
95 Kepler-224 Er* 19 23 44.2255728048 +47 21 27.303516396   16.639 15.940 15.596   ~ 67 0
96 Kepler-85 Er* 19 23 53.6255300424 +45 17 25.088907084   15.782 14.932 14.785   ~ 79 1
97 Kepler-157 Ro* 19 24 23.3283015432 +38 52 32.142415692           G3 65 0
98 Kepler-122 Er* 19 24 26.8513235976 +39 56 56.599044504   14.979 14.378 14.337   ~ 81 0
99 Kepler-191 Ro* 19 24 44.0051264352 +45 19 23.397872412           G9 56 0
100 Kepler-357 Ro* 19 24 58.3358734152 +44 00 31.348146708           ~ 47 0
101 Kepler-372 Ro* 19 25 01.4896532904 +49 15 32.293087884           ~ 47 0
102 Kepler-100 Er* 19 25 32.6432787456 +41 59 24.945100548   12.009 11.278 11.128   G8IV 142 0
103 Kepler-398 Ro* 19 25 52.4829537816 +40 20 37.817930724           ~ 47 0
104 Kepler-220 Er* 19 26 01.4891656008 +46 53 44.783155752   14.322 13.201 12.828   K3V 74 0
105 Kepler-245 Er* 19 26 33.3541730304 +42 26 10.779132804   16.911 16.104 15.529   ~ 81 0
106 Kepler-331 BY* 19 27 20.2411748808 +39 18 26.485483752       15.868   ~ 60 0
107 Kepler-253 Er* 19 27 22.0764853560 +44 51 29.245497804   16.653 15.779 15.736   ~ 50 0
108 Kepler-184 Er* 19 27 48.4549205376 +43 04 28.973525592   15.168 14.460 14.317   F2 65 0
109 Kepler-194 Ro* 19 27 53.1541559712 +47 51 50.953209372           G3 55 0
110 Kepler-42 PM* 19 28 52.5688740811 +44 37 08.989819665   17.8   16.06   M4V 131 1
111 Kepler-49 Er* 19 29 10.6951719216 +40 35 30.458944212   17.110 15.883 15.539   M1V 80 1
112 Kepler-226 Er* 19 29 30.2722726368 +47 52 51.580008300       15.263   ~ 64 0
113 Kepler-275 Er* 19 29 55.1288580480 +38 30 53.670776796   16.109 15.382 15.344   ~ 58 0
114 Kepler-256 Er* 19 30 19.3010309184 +46 05 50.533193976       14.946   ~ 67 0
115 Kepler-327 Er* 19 30 34.1672429376 +44 05 15.563767632   17.246 15.756 15.113   M1V 65 0
116 Kepler-167 Er* 19 30 38.0261896920 +38 20 43.437246900   15.255 14.284 13.989   K3 98 0
117 Kepler-342 Er* 19 30 42.7395837984 +46 43 36.159004776       13.125   F6IV 77 0
118 Kepler-82 Er* 19 31 29.6083527360 +42 57 58.067640720   15.940 15.318 14.676   ~ 83 1
119 Kepler-217 Ro* 19 32 09.0586262088 +46 16 39.067579920           F3V 65 0
120 Kepler-758 EB* 19 32 20.3082335280 +41 08 07.560720276       14.357   ~ 62 0
121 Kepler-166 Er* 19 32 38.4339503856 +48 52 52.388815332   15.678 14.930 14.685   K1 55 0
122 Kepler-339 Er* 19 33 24.4114554120 +48 26 40.647612696   15.555 14.778 14.664   G7 60 0
123 Kepler-276 Er* 19 34 16.3567060728 +39 02 10.707604404       15.399   G7 63 0
124 Kepler-81 Er* 19 34 32.8684643808 +42 49 29.761950396   16.636 15.536 14.858   M0V 83 1
125 Kepler-208 Er* 19 35 33.6470003208 +42 31 40.724818032   14.109 13.683 13.465   G0 82 0
126 Kepler-114 PM* 19 36 29.1357624552 +48 20 58.291722816   14.972 13.803 13.746   M0V 86 0
127 Kepler-374 Er* 19 36 33.1030734096 +42 22 13.721835576   15.459 14.873 14.638   G3 60 0
128 Kepler-23 Er* 19 36 52.5355328952 +49 28 45.252600204   14.190 13.547 13.71   G2V 98 1
129 Kepler-326 Er* 19 37 18.1337949432 +46 00 08.063097696   14.811 13.863 13.584   K1V 79 0
130 Kepler-304 Er* 19 37 46.0342587552 +40 33 27.199163844       14.885   ~ 70 0
131 Kepler-176 Er* 19 38 40.3180039344 +43 51 11.758931640       14.633   ~ 74 0
132 Kepler-54 Er* 19 39 05.7418156224 +43 03 22.599784476       15.497   M1V 75 1
133 Kepler-215 Er* 19 39 53.6402937048 +45 12 49.220709192   14.273 13.736 13.636   G3 85 0
134 Kepler-142 Er* 19 40 28.5407018232 +48 28 52.654331856   14.101 13.318 13.177   ~ 73 0
135 Kepler-197 PM* 19 40 54.3398888544 +50 33 32.423445180   12.42 11.78 11.800   F5 106 0
136 Kepler-218 Er* 19 41 39.0786751032 +46 15 59.364727092   14.981 14.076 13.943   G8IV 75 0
137 Kepler-450 Er* 19 41 56.7727769064 +51 00 48.582305136   11.99 11.692 11.685   ~ 86 0
138 Kepler-292 Er* 19 43 03.8774957880 +42 25 27.449661468       16.191   ~ 66 0
139 Kepler-255 Ro* 19 44 15.4216915944 +45 58 36.604526628           ~ 50 0
140 Kepler-80 Er* 19 44 27.0200680656 +39 58 43.594100688   16.303 15.201 14.866   M0V 177 1
141 Kepler-58 Ro* 19 45 26.0755073736 +39 06 54.729120168           ~ 71 1
142 Kepler-251 Er* 19 46 15.8967097200 +44 06 21.118869360   16.244 15.274 15.233   ~ 62 0
143 Kepler-221 Er* 19 46 37.1434561728 +46 50 06.841651128   14.853 14.017 13.778   G5 97 0
144 Kepler-171 Er* 19 47 05.2538906928 +41 45 19.990096812   16.030 15.066 15.079   ~ 68 0
145 Kepler-249 Er* 19 47 56.4240903816 +43 39 30.701898792   17.879 16.399 15.763   M2V 72 0
146 Kepler-107 Er* 19 48 06.7734610824 +48 12 30.964175676   13.330 12.639 12.448   ~ 116 0
147 Kepler-203 Er* 19 48 21.5923608240 +41 23 16.986023880   14.884 14.107 13.965   G1 78 0
148 Kepler-11 Er* 19 48 27.6226218768 +41 54 32.903163504   14.635 13.838 13.742   G2V 377 1
149 Kepler-289 Er* 19 49 51.6736237968 +42 52 58.268872164   14.724 14.175 14.019   G2 94 0
150 Kepler-32 Er* 19 51 22.1744302704 +46 34 27.390583380       15.563   M1V 119 1
151 Kepler-84 Er* 19 53 00.4851863233 +40 29 45.947737759       14.804   ~ 76 1
152 Kepler-223 Er* 19 53 16.4202435936 +47 16 46.308434088   16.209 15.570 15.78   ~ 192 1
153 Kepler-186 Er* 19 54 36.6535147488 +43 57 18.025920324   16.731 15.290 14.833   M1V 151 0
154 Kepler-445 PM* 19 54 56.6592332856 +46 29 54.793640508   19.2   17.1   M4V 50 0
155 Kepler-272 Ro* 19 56 30.6090734448 +47 35 37.816201464           G6 56 0
156 Kepler-48 Er* 19 56 33.4161659688 +40 56 56.496876216   14.253 13.331 13.054   K0V 123 1
157 Kepler-305 Er* 19 56 53.8365433512 +40 20 35.445181812       15.715   ~ 75 0
158 Kepler-399 Ro* 19 58 00.4156023312 +40 40 14.889229896           ~ 56 0
159 Kepler-267 Er* 19 59 19.2924878040 +47 09 26.896687236           M1V 58 0
160 Kepler-79 Er* 20 02 04.1057010912 +44 22 53.646047436   14.55 13.98 14.00   F5 136 1
161 Kepler-106 Er* 20 03 27.3499329384 +44 20 15.191981988   13.592 12.963 12.817   G1 94 0
162 K2-58 * 22 15 17.2365014064 -14 02 59.313030216           ~ 27 0
163 LP 759-72 LM* 22 18 29.2548547872 -09 36 44.381088036     15.04     M2V 42 0
164 K2-138 * 23 15 47.7686067840 -10 50 58.895461284   13.01 12.21 12.12 11.40 ~ 75 0
165 K2-285 * 23 17 32.2274265744 +01 18 01.074749508   12.87 11.75 11.88   G9 20 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2024AJ....167..271V and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu