2024MNRAS.527.9061H


Query : 2024MNRAS.527.9061H

2024MNRAS.527.9061H - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 527, 9061-9117 (2024/January-3)

Measuring the initial-final mass relation using wide double white dwarf binaries from Gaia DR3.

HOLLANDS M.A., LITTLEFAIR S.P. and PARSONS S.G.

Abstract (from CDS):

The initial-final mass relation (IFMR) maps the masses of main-sequence stars to their white dwarf descendants. The most common approach to measure the IFMR has been to use white dwarfs in clusters. However, it has been shown that wide double white dwarfs can also be used to measure the IFMR using a Bayesian approach. We have observed a large sample of 90 Gaia double white dwarfs using FORS2 on the VLT. Considering 52 DA + DA, DA + DC, and DC + DC pairs, we applied our extended Bayesian framework to probe the IFMR in exquisite detail. Our monotonic IFMR is well constrained by our observations for initial masses of 1-5 M⊙, with the range of 1-4 M⊙ mostly constrained to a precision of 0.03 M⊙ or better. We add an important extension to the framework, using a Bayesian mixture-model to determine the IFMR robustly in the presence of systems departing from single star evolution. We find a large but uncertain outlier fraction of 59 ± 21 per cent, with outlier systems requiring an additional $0.70_{-0.22}^{+0.40}$ Gyr uncertainty in their cooling age differences. However, we find that this fraction is dominated by a few systems with massive components near 0.9 M⊙, where we are most sensitive to outliers, but are also able to establish four systems as merger candidates.

Abstract Copyright: © 2023 The Author(s) Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): (stars:) white dwarfs - (stars:) binaries: visual

Simbad objects: 179

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 179
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SDSS J000215.33+073359.1 WD* 00 02 15.3818662584 +07 33 59.558395284   17.4   17.7   DA 15 0
2 SDSS J000216.13+073349.9 WD* 00 02 16.1829759792 +07 33 50.295355200   17.6   18.0   DAH 16 0
3 ** KPP 2678B WD* 00 07 34.1916232952 -16 05 13.104450407           DA 12 1
4 EGGR 509 ** 00 07 34.8220306056 -16 05 31.611970536   16.0   16.0 16.050 DA+L3 39 1
5 GALEX J002229.4-723208 WD* 00 22 29.3172000120 -72 32 09.630690900           DA 11 0
6 Gaia DR3 4689543506237079936 WD* 00 22 32.6654779632 -72 32 33.627111180           DA 9 0
7 SDSS J002335.57+064325.5 WD* 00 23 35.5298308632 +06 43 25.886643492           DA 15 0
8 PB 5921 WD* 00 23 36.2093552592 +06 43 20.898272352   17.2   17.5   DA 13 0
9 PHL 873 WD* 00 52 12.2589114768 +13 53 02.030650620   18.1 18.2     DA 12 0
10 SDSS J005212.73+135301.1 WD* 00 52 12.7211831592 +13 53 01.132936836           DA 10 0
11 PHL 925 WD* 00 59 09.3561887112 -24 17 33.255127284   16.4   15.9   DB 10 1
12 PHL 3190 WD* 00 59 09.6118558512 -24 17 28.365847584   18.4       DA 9 0
13 PHL 7041 WD* 01 01 31.0645045392 -16 29 08.136558348   18.4       DA 9 0
14 PHL 7040 WD* 01 01 31.4803996104 -16 29 09.111606504   18.4   18.3   DA 10 0
15 EGGR 462 WD* 01 04 56.4721762379 +21 19 58.868935539   18.6   17.8   DC9 41 0
16 EGGR 463 WD* 01 04 57.9558211711 +21 20 17.545876869   18.9   17.8   DC12 42 0
17 LP 707-8 WD* 01 09 03.4164087144 -10 42 14.150746404   16.6   16.4   DA 23 0
18 LP 707-9 WD* 01 09 04.2209294352 -10 42 15.390619596   19.3 18.95 19.0   DC 20 0
19 GD 953 WD* 01 20 58.8109647120 -16 22 46.567577424   15.91 15.76 16.05   DA3.6 21 0
20 Gaia DR3 2454507598448711296 WD* 01 20 59.3375320224 -16 22 48.180670608           D 11 0
21 Gaia DR3 80926701504179584 WD* 02 15 23.7127101360 +18 21 15.464239236           DA 7 0
22 SDSS J021524.07+182128.9 WD* 02 15 24.0581867904 +18 21 28.928045304           DA 10 0
23 GALEX J022031.0-153247 WD* 02 20 31.0108212024 -15 32 48.083090244           D 11 0
24 Gaia DR3 5146493662498666624 WD* 02 20 31.4241051408 -15 32 48.982379280           DA 11 0
25 Gaia DR3 4940155500795290624 WD* 02 24 40.2749312904 -46 11 33.909595980           DA: 9 0
26 Gaia DR3 4940155500795290880 WD* 02 24 40.6467725544 -46 11 40.645405608           DA 9 0
27 SDSS J022556.26-175608.3 WD* 02 25 56.2644579864 -17 56 08.217318444           DA 11 0
28 GALEX J022556.4-175614 WD* 02 25 56.4496194600 -17 56 14.782127964           DC 12 0
29 GALEX J024051.6-324837 WD* 02 40 51.5915662296 -32 48 37.301125860           DA 12 0
30 GALEX J024051.9-324813 WD* 02 40 51.9349216776 -32 48 14.085091296           DA 12 0
31 Gaia DR3 4721828191286828672 WD* 02 53 39.3647629128 -61 52 51.965388732           DA 7 0
32 GALEX J025341.8-615216 WD* 02 53 41.8155815808 -61 52 15.396679848           DA 9 0
33 Gaia DR3 31047184711544832 WD* 03 09 53.8928183760 +15 05 11.528879100           DA 12 0
34 PG 0307+149 WD* 03 09 53.9529363288 +15 05 21.831742176   14.72   15.2   DA2.3 33 0
35 GALEX J034410.8+151022 WD* 03 44 10.9007106696 +15 10 22.337082372   16.71 16.52     DC 15 0
36 GALEX J034411.5+150945 WD* 03 44 11.4803510016 +15 09 45.812641140   16.9   16.8   DA 17 0
37 EC 04081-1649a WD* 04 10 24.9332837712 -16 41 50.425804572 14.48 15.37 15.46     DA 12 0
38 EC 04081-1649b WD* 04 10 26.4968948640 -16 41 42.571189248 15.84 16.45 16.43     DA 11 0
39 HS 0507+0434B WD* 05 10 13.5215260416 +04 38 55.135549140   15.52 15.31 15.63   DA2.3 77 0
40 HS 0507+0434A WD* 05 10 13.9441357968 +04 38 38.436217584   14.14 14.22 14.46   DA4.1 41 0
41 Ruiz 496-512 WD* 08 55 50.7059652456 -26 37 45.129733068   17.16 16.83 16.86   DA 16 0
42 Ruiz 496-513 WD* 08 55 51.0340292160 -26 37 50.205558936   15.1 16.97 15.4   DA 16 0
43 GALEX J090230.9-354036 WD* 09 02 30.8744488008 -35 40 38.530820748           DA 8 0
44 GALEX J090232.0-354043 WD* 09 02 32.0985103488 -35 40 43.391189640           DA 9 0
45 Gaia DR3 5427657619159602944 WD* 09 20 16.0366688280 -41 27 02.009311776           DA 12 0
46 Gaia DR3 5427657584803951232 WD* 09 20 16.1037937824 -41 27 09.506032380           DA 12 0
47 HS 1003+0726 WD* 10 06 23.0749934496 +07 12 12.698070336   16.0   15.8   DA 30 0
48 SDSS J100623.18+071154.2 WD* 10 06 23.1745157472 +07 11 54.300001200           DC 11 0
49 LSPM J1013+0305 WD* 10 13 59.8447757880 +03 05 53.907147348   19.1   18.0   DA 15 0
50 LSPM J1014+0305 WD* 10 14 01.5978984384 +03 05 50.415312192   19.2   18.1   DA 12 0
51 LP 549-32 WD* 10 15 01.7485819049 +08 06 11.252634489   17.9   17.0   DC 27 0
52 G 43-38 WD* 10 15 02.6095463036 +08 06 35.702726437   16.57   15.7   DA7.5 55 0
53 GALEX J101954.6+121717 WD* 10 19 54.6149065152 +12 17 18.032596224   17.4   16.8   DA 11 0
54 PG 1017+125 WD* 10 19 55.9112404968 +12 16 31.526935176   15.81   15.7   DA2.2 43 0
55 Gaia DR3 3562650151984291840 WD* 11 00 21.7692449904 -16 00 14.952141576           DA 10 0
56 GALEX J110022.8-160012 WD* 11 00 22.7599874664 -16 00 11.786671800           DA 12 0
57 GALEX J112405.5-123443 WD* 11 24 05.4197110800 -12 34 42.456578556           DA 12 0
58 Gaia DR3 3562301611094074240 WD* 11 24 07.2195083856 -12 34 40.251359784           DA 11 0
59 Gaia DR3 5377861317357370240 WD* 11 59 42.6718549900 -46 30 35.767757624           DC 11 0
60 Ruiz 267-110 WD* 11 59 57.7902380759 -46 29 04.835672442   17.80 17.55 17.2   DQ 19 0
61 Gaia DR3 6143377428989586304 WD* 12 11 03.7571335416 -45 51 51.093088992           DA 7 0
62 Gaia DR3 6143377806949386752 WD* 12 11 04.9022580072 -45 51 45.995625972           DA 8 0
63 GALEX J121509.7+094847 WD* 12 15 09.6796065528 +09 48 47.143464552           DA 20 0
64 GALEX J121510.1+094836 WD* 12 15 10.1048676504 +09 48 36.375294312           DA 12 0
65 HE 1252-0202 WD* 12 54 58.0777971864 -02 18 37.746606132   16.8 16.3 17.3   DA3.0 30 0
66 GALEX J125458.6-021809 WD* 12 54 58.5437763408 -02 18 07.702151220           DC: 8 0
67 Gaia DR3 6141313538289167104 WD* 13 10 46.1882602584 -39 30 41.540899896           DA 9 0
68 GALEX J131046.4-393041 WD* 13 10 46.6940751504 -39 30 42.217690680           DC: 8 0
69 SDSS J131332.12+203039.8 WD* 13 13 32.1530261640 +20 30 39.400380000           DA 19 0
70 GALEX J131332.3+203039 WD* 13 13 32.5742500104 +20 30 39.190039920           DA 14 0
71 SDSS J131426.37+173228.1 WD* 13 14 26.3913543144 +17 32 28.398418872   18.5   18.1   DAH 22 0
72 GALEX J131426.8+173210 WD* 13 14 26.8409746920 +17 32 09.499719228   16.1   16.3   DA 21 0
73 Gaia DR3 6080685917382766592 WD* 13 21 52.7156179632 -50 44 07.053165924           DA 6 0
74 Gaia DR3 6080685917382773504 WD* 13 21 53.9172064248 -50 43 54.577699032           DA 6 0
75 Gaia DR3 3603920492731480960 WD* 13 36 51.7556726640 -16 20 20.100840324           DA 9 0
76 Gaia DR3 3603920595812980864 WD* 13 36 52.2121127016 -16 20 10.937257908           DA 9 0
77 Gaia DR3 3714517790389197696 WD* 13 38 21.3261589896 +04 39 33.521023332           DA 8 0
78 Gaia DR3 3714517794684754432 WD* 13 38 23.1170889192 +04 39 26.494184484           DA 8 0
79 Gaia DR3 6065382021191694848 WD* 13 39 18.8936055528 -54 49 37.010447652           DA 9 0
80 Gaia DR3 6065382021191695104 WD* 13 39 20.0362841856 -54 49 36.323401332           DA 10 0
81 Gaia DR3 6107113950664587008 WD* 13 46 44.2573824048 -46 30 56.909954088           DA 10 0
82 Gaia DR3 6107114058041088512 WD* 13 46 48.0165333264 -46 30 41.047195032           DA 11 0
83 Gaia DR3 6093462315507278208 WD* 13 50 06.0353959296 -50 25 40.061688852           DA 12 0
84 Gaia DR3 6093462311215003776 WD* 13 50 06.2428353168 -50 25 34.216422888           D 12 0
85 Gaia DR3 1246691979392466048 WD* 13 56 57.4051056792 +19 20 46.531945428           DA 7 0
86 SDSS J135704.68+192133.3 WD* 13 57 04.6765637112 +19 21 33.339410676           DA 10 0
87 2MASS J14452810+2921250 WD* 14 45 28.1158350024 +29 21 24.287149836           DA 13 0
88 Ton 213 WD* 14 45 28.4732292408 +29 21 32.074698816   14.5       DA3.8 28 0
89 Gaia DR3 6310166397960730112 WD? 14 55 18.1991400840 -14 59 37.461778296           ~ 6 0
90 Gaia DR3 6310166397960730240 WD* 14 55 18.4383871104 -14 59 33.124608708           DA 8 0
91 LP 384-21 WD* 15 35 54.0674174232 +21 25 06.580443216   17.4   16.6   DA 18 0
92 UCAC4 558-056003 WD* 15 35 56.4671078808 +21 25 22.857025224           DA 12 0
93 Gaia DR3 5998049513967312512 WD* 15 57 55.2333650832 -38 32 42.747723816           DC: 9 0
94 Gaia DR3 5998049513957889536 WD* 15 57 55.8731670192 -38 32 43.601521344           DC: 10 0
95 SDSS J163647.33+092708.5 WD? 16 36 47.3197583880 +09 27 08.598812976   19.6   18.9   ~ 7 0
96 SDSS J163647.81+092715.7 WD* 16 36 47.7972247056 +09 27 15.853800096   17.8   17.7   DA 10 0
97 LP 332-27 WD* 17 29 29.2620304152 +29 16 09.727556088   16.9   16.8   DA 17 0
98 LP 332-28 WD* 17 29 29.6419405632 +29 15 54.768702312   18.0   17.9   DA 16 0
99 Gaia DR3 6437150438963510912 WD* 18 04 52.0902892008 -66 17 05.996994288           DA 8 0
100 Gaia DR3 6437150438963510784 WD* 18 04 52.8687468120 -66 17 09.453728976           DA 8 0
101 Gaia DR3 4471739010213094272 WD* 18 13 30.4736821104 +06 04 12.510197184           DA 12 0
102 GALEX J181332.1+060411 WD* 18 13 32.2023266784 +06 04 12.612723528           D 12 0
103 Gaia DR3 6414762870395214080 WD* 18 18 43.9287601536 -74 41 06.666404460           DA 12 0
104 Gaia DR3 6414762874686188672 WD* 18 18 45.1852474512 -74 41 09.972173472           DA 11 0
105 Ross 137 WD* 18 27 13.0871903322 +04 03 46.788559039 13.383 13.981 13.889 13.928 13.958 DA3.5 86 0
106 Ross 137B WD* 18 27 16.3437342174 +04 03 11.266951503   20.1   18.7   DA 9 0
107 Gaia DR3 6436604226499058432 WD? 18 31 00.8319029232 -66 08 36.169053936           ~ 4 0
108 Gaia DR3 6436604157779581056 WD* 18 31 02.4735983856 -66 09 02.068071624           DA 5 0
109 Gaia DR3 6631472385979671296 WD? 18 34 33.9276884160 -61 08 14.015147136           ~ 5 0
110 GALEX J183434.3-610804 WD* 18 34 34.4458535712 -61 08 04.169128992           DC 7 0
111 Gaia DR3 6655420161551244416 WD* 18 36 36.0761587848 -51 14 40.747992396           DA 6 0
112 GALEX J183636.0-511455 WD* 18 36 36.0899882568 -51 14 56.047908300           DB 6 0
113 GALEX J185623.6+291721 WD* 18 56 23.5502971680 +29 17 22.474327380           DA 7 0
114 GALEX J185624.0+291648 WD* 18 56 24.0304161432 +29 16 49.117953792           DA 7 0
115 WT 612A WD* 18 59 33.2766655906 -55 29 09.158187911           DA 10 0
116 Gaia DR3 4085489994240885632 WD* 19 04 18.5884746744 -19 46 38.096912856           DA 11 0
117 Gaia DR3 4085489994240873728 WD* 19 04 18.7928165808 -19 46 43.250831508           DA 11 0
118 Gaia DR3 4267611073087674752 WD* 19 07 37.5617107800 +01 36 42.107334624           DA 11 0
119 Gaia DR3 4267612546219850880 WD* 19 07 39.2619542736 +01 36 47.488757076           D 11 0
120 Gaia DR3 6645357023108224256 WD* 19 29 11.2544963184 -53 13 25.974912698           DC 9 0
121 Gaia DR3 6645357018814684288 WD* 19 29 12.6923536574 -53 13 52.296662160           DA: 9 0
122 Gaia DR3 6758402482190569728 WD* 19 29 22.1946763920 -30 00 55.812921480           DA 5 0
123 Gaia DR3 6758402482191376512 WD* 19 29 23.6477096472 -30 00 50.717506572           DA 6 0
124 Gaia DR3 6645121585887374976 WD? 19 33 12.4835727528 -53 27 51.431715036           ~ 4 0
125 Gaia DR3 6645121590181460736 WD? 19 33 13.7106251568 -53 27 25.444731780           ~ 4 0
126 GALEX J195333.1-101953 WD* 19 53 33.1249440816 -10 19 54.847624836           DA 11 0
127 GALEX J195336.0-101929 ** 19 53 36.022872 -10 19 30.36504   15.575 15.400 14.925   ~ 4 0
128 Gaia DR3 6697056948905594496 WD* 20 07 49.8173280984 -37 01 16.376409732           DA 8 0
129 Gaia DR3 6697056953199978112 WD* 20 07 49.9614973440 -37 01 23.029985784           DC 7 0
130 Gaia DR3 1829120747684239104 WD* 20 18 36.7188044016 +21 29 31.057603620           D 13 0
131 Gaia DR3 1829120747684237312 WD* 20 18 36.7937940096 +21 29 24.444375144           DA 11 0
132 Gaia DR3 6876026174545050752 WD* 20 23 35.3109715272 -14 46 22.944745560           DA 7 0
133 Gaia DR3 6876026174545050368 WD* 20 23 36.0608054256 -14 46 25.281971832           DA: 9 0
134 GALEX J202628.5-502009 WD* 20 26 28.5338132184 -50 20 09.525977628           DA 11 0
135 EC 20228-5030 WD* 20 26 30.5293620240 -50 20 41.797658904 16.97 17.39 17.13     DA 14 0
136 Gaia DR3 6348333951253469184 WD* 20 47 36.2567067312 -82 05 53.205415800           DA: 9 0
137 GALEX J204737.6-820602 WD* 20 47 38.2730121048 -82 06 02.801802528           D 11 0
138 Gaia DR3 1756725152590009344 WD* 20 58 19.5431294808 +10 37 26.643959652           DA 8 0
139 Gaia DR3 1756725152590009216 WD* 20 58 19.6087461888 +10 37 33.727947600           DA 8 0
140 Gaia DR3 6455914296380436352 WD* 21 00 23.8697197824 -60 11 24.325447200           DA 8 0
141 Gaia DR3 6455914296380435712 WD* 21 00 25.5049134624 -60 11 29.305932396           DA 8 0
142 GALEX J211507.3-074151 WD* 21 15 07.3966404144 -07 41 51.477296280   17.5   16.8   DA5 29 0
143 GALEX J211507.3-074134 WD* 21 15 07.4218140528 -07 41 34.458354600   17.0   16.2   DA 17 0
144 Gaia DR3 1840810854079992832 WD* 21 15 31.3778768424 +25 34 52.739321988           DA 11 0
145 GALEX J211531.4+253457 WD* 21 15 31.5802815192 +25 34 57.515855340           D 11 0
146 LSPM J2122+3005 WD* 21 22 55.8815154576 +30 05 40.235886528   19.3   18.8   DA 12 0
147 LSPM J2123+3005 WD* 21 23 07.1886100992 +30 05 33.722050740   18.1   17.0   DA 12 0
148 Gaia DR3 6590545195937635456 WD* 21 31 36.4399235544 -34 59 05.012876544           DA 9 0
149 Gaia DR3 6590545195937636992 WD* 21 31 36.4659751296 -34 58 58.343612088           DA 9 0
150 LP 758-17 WD* 21 39 08.1635036448 -10 03 43.098063552     17.30     DA 12 0
151 Gaia DR3 6893432749282629248 WD* 21 39 09.5316024528 -10 03 29.425878180           DA: 8 0
152 LP 518-35 WD* 21 42 08.0708422295 +13 29 06.437394155   18.1   17.6   DC: 16 0
153 G 126-25 WD* 21 42 08.5322947898 +13 28 44.235252231   16.87   16.2   DA6.6 34 0
154 GALEX J215033.0-621840 WD* 21 50 32.9520656856 -62 18 40.055627916           DA 8 0
155 GALEX J215035.5-621808 WD* 21 50 35.5090859928 -62 18 08.623791612           DA 8 0
156 HS 2220+2146A WD* 22 23 01.6030049304 +22 01 31.690804764   14.7   15.95   DA 26 0
157 HS 2220+2146B WD* 22 23 01.7051526288 +22 01 25.282334820   15.24 15.22 16.25   DA 26 0
158 SSSPM J2231-7515 WD* 22 30 33.5339081384 -75 15 24.304628824       16.17 15.51 DC12 34 1
159 SSSPM J2231-7514 WD* 22 30 39.9813622429 -75 13 55.234553688       15.924 15.33 DC9 36 1
160 HS 2240+1234B WD* 22 42 30.3361463472 +12 50 02.413102452   15.64 16.85 16.65 16.66 DA3.6 24 0
161 HS 2240+1234A WD* 22 42 31.1464949328 +12 50 04.993693332   16.6       DA3.1 31 0
162 Gaia DR3 6503784558750861952 WD* 22 48 27.9484574376 -58 30 31.004037468           DC: 9 0
163 LEHPM 5157 WD* 22 48 29.4956829840 -58 30 36.387779616           DA: 10 0
164 PG 2257+138 WD* 22 59 32.2089121272 +14 04 39.283410180   16.5 16.65     DA1.8 29 0
165 SDSS J225932.74+140444.2 WD* 22 59 32.7357136296 +14 04 44.243798520   18.8   18.7   DAH 14 0
166 PB 7497 WD* 23 03 27.9055249872 -07 55 04.808522028   18.2   18.4   DA 10 0
167 PB 7496 WD* 23 03 28.1419312320 -07 54 57.979024524   18.4   18.3   DA 10 0
168 LP 701-69 WD* 23 04 18.9344445272 -07 01 24.506114617   17.0   17.0   DC7 21 0
169 LP 701-70 WD* 23 04 19.4950587908 -07 01 49.828058364   21.0   19.9 18.45 DC17 18 0
170 SDSS J231650.15+064123.4 WD* 23 16 50.1269988624 +06 41 23.479737828           DA 10 0
171 PG 2314+064 WD* 23 16 50.2406942712 +06 41 28.413420324   16.01   16.0   DA2.7 28 0
172 GALEX J231943.0-212118 WD* 23 19 43.0329372456 -21 21 18.208601460           DA 8 0
173 Gaia DR3 2385725694362729088 WD? 23 19 44.6559465288 -21 22 11.514443124           ~ 5 0
174 GALEX J235057.6-155911 WD* 23 50 57.6288809712 -15 59 12.414267492           DA 8 0
175 GALEX J235104.1-160120 WD* 23 51 04.1646482712 -16 01 21.310669884           DA 8 0
176 LEHPM 6408 WD* 23 53 43.0510855704 -36 20 50.728070076           D 14 0
177 LEHPM 6410 WD* 23 53 44.0259472272 -36 20 42.508297608           DA 13 0
178 SDSS J235515.29+170806.6 WD* 23 55 15.2653897512 +17 08 06.733989852   18.3   17.9   DA 10 0
179 GALEX J235515.4+170829 WD* 23 55 15.4423025256 +17 08 30.990266088   16.5   16.4   DB 12 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2024MNRAS.527.9061H and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu