2024MNRAS.529.3806K


Query : 2024MNRAS.529.3806K

2024MNRAS.529.3806K - Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 529, 3806-3814 (2024/April-3)

Tracing back the birth environments of Type Ia supernova progenitor stars: a pilot study based on 44 early-type host galaxies.

KIM Y.-L., GALBANY L., HOOK I. and KANG Y.

Abstract (from CDS):

The environmental dependence of Type Ia supernova (SN Ia) luminosities is well established, and efforts are being made to find its origin. Previous studies typically use the currently observed status of the host galaxy. However, given the delay time between the birth of the progenitor star and the SN Ia explosion, the currently observed status may differ from the birth environment of the SN Ia progenitor star. In this paper, employing the chemical evolution and accurately determined stellar population properties of 44 early-type host galaxies, we, for the first time, estimate the SN Ia progenitor star birth environment, specifically [Fe/H]Birth and [α/Fe]Birth. We show that [α/Fe]Birth has a $30.4^{\text{+10.6}}_{-10.1}{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ wider range than the currently observed [α/Fe]Current, while the range of [Fe/H]Birth is not statistically different ($17.9^{\text{+26.0}}_{-27.1}{{\ \rm per\ cent}}$) to that of [Fe/H]Current. The birth and current environments of [Fe/H] and [α/Fe] are sampled from different populations (p-values of the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test <0.01). We find that light-curve fit parameters are insensitive to [Fe/H]Birth (<0.9σ for the non-zero slope), while a linear trend is observed with Hubble residuals (HRs) at the 2.4σ significance level. With [α/Fe]Birth, no linear trends (<1.1σ) are observed. Interestingly, we find that [α/Fe]Birth clearly splits the SN Ia sample into two groups: SN Ia exploded in [α/Fe]Birth-rich or [α/Fe]Birth-poor environments. SNe Ia exploded in different [α/Fe]Birth groups have different weighted-means of light-curve shape parameters: 0.81 ± 0.33 (2.5σ). They are thought to be drawn from different populations (p-value = 0.01). Regarding SN Ia colour and HRs, there is no difference (<1.0σ) in the weighted-means and distribution (p-value > 0.27) of each [α/Fe]Birth group.

Abstract Copyright: © 2024 The Author(s). Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Royal Astronomical Society.

Journal keyword(s): supernovae: general - galaxies: fundamental parameters - methods: data analysis

Simbad objects: 88

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 88
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 SN 2006ej SN* 00 38 59.77 -09 00 56.6   16.0 16.4     SNIa 78 1
2 NGC 191A GiP 00 39 00.2351185176 -09 00 52.381414332   15       ~ 36 0
3 SN 2003ic SN* 00 41 50.335 -09 18 19.12     17.6     SNIa 52 1
4 MCG-02-02-086 rG 00 41 50.45002 -09 18 11.4633   14 13.52 12.94   ~ 154 1
5 SN 2007nq SN* 00 57 33.60 -01 23 19.5     17.6     SNIa 50 1
6 Z 384-48 rG 00 57 34.90446247 -01 23 27.5469897   14.07 15.10     ~ 269 1
7 SN 2000dk SN* 01 07 23.52 +32 24 23.2   15.63 15.2     SNIa 109 1
8 NGC 382 GiP 01 07 23.87 +32 24 13.9   14.2       ~ 110 1
9 Z 411-25 GiG 01 20 53.4789486480 +04 48 05.119986636   15.4       ~ 39 0
10 SN 2008gl SN* 01 20 54.82 +04 48 19.1           SNIa 53 1
11 SN 1992bo SN* 01 21 58.44 -34 12 43.5   15.85 15.76     SNIa 119 1
12 MCG-06-04-014 GiG 01 22 02.3946806136 -34 11 48.186807036   14.63   13.39   ~ 47 1
13 NGC 495 GiG 01 22 55.9580753040 +33 28 17.045070636   14.0       ~ 98 0
14 SN 1999ej SN* 01 22 57.38 +33 27 58.0   15.65       SNIa 77 1
15 NGC 809 LIN 02 04 18.9745020216 -08 44 07.055506788   14   13.39   ~ 56 1
16 SN 2006ef SN* 02 04 19.529 -08 43 42.49     15.6     SNIa 65 1
17 ESO 544-31 G 02 15 04.5868321152 -20 46 03.743095620   15.32   13.85   ~ 30 0
18 SN 2006ot SN* 02 15 04.84 -20 45 58.2     17.4     SNIap 48 1
19 SN 2003iv SN* 02 50 07.244 +12 50 45.28     17.2     SNIa 45 1
20 Z 440-18 GiG 02 50 08.8512565344 +12 50 37.000140864   15.4       ~ 25 0
21 SN 2008R SN* 03 03 53.70 -11 59 39.4     15.5     SNIa 44 1
22 NGC 1200 EmG 03 03 54.481 -11 59 30.67   13   11.42   ~ 59 0
23 SN 2008L SN* 03 17 16.596 +41 22 56.24       18.7   SNIa 44 1
24 NGC 1259 GiG 03 17 17.2707022200 +41 23 07.513025028   14.2       ~ 49 0
25 SN 2007jh SN* 03 36 01.536 +01 06 12.11           SNIa 39 1
26 Z 391-14 G 03 36 01.5900205011 +01 06 17.135294122   15.4     14.800 ~ 31 0
27 SN 2006kf SN* 03 41 50.48 +08 09 25.0     17.4     SNIa 78 1
28 Z 417-4 AG? 03 41 50.8600448976 +08 09 35.357640624   15.0       ~ 41 0
29 NGC 1725 GiG 04 59 22.8951102336 -11 07 56.503905888   13   12.58   ~ 36 0
30 SN 2009F SN* 04 59 23.56 -11 07 50.1           SNIap 41 1
31 NGC 1819 GiC 05 11 46.150 +05 12 02.21   13.7       ~ 114 1
32 SN 2005el SN* 05 11 48.76 +05 11 39.0     18.7     SNIa 118 1
33 NGC 1875 IG 05 21 45.7696350552 +06 41 19.680233280   14.89   12.23   ~ 43 0
34 SN 2004gc SN* 05 21 49.949 +06 40 33.71     17.4     SNIa 32 1
35 SN 1993ac SN* 05 46 23.58 +63 22 07.1   18.36 17.71     SNIa 63 1
36 Z 307-23 rG 05 46 24.6164052000 +63 21 32.616771588   15.7       ~ 34 0
37 Z 308-9 GiG 06 08 30.3739788504 +64 43 25.144033404   14.7       ~ 29 0
38 SN 2006N SN* 06 08 31.24 +64 43 25.1     15.0     SNIa 66 1
39 SN 1997E SN* 06 47 38.10 +74 29 51.0   15.59       SNIa 64 1
40 NGC 2258 AGN 06 47 46.2009489480 +74 28 54.536253852   13.2       ~ 66 0
41 SN 2008C SN* 06 57 11.53 +20 26 13.7     14.9     SNIa 60 1
42 Z 85-18 GiG 06 57 11.7249963264 +20 26 14.193949236   15.1       ~ 44 0
43 Z 234-97 rG 07 11 42.00 +49 51 42.8   14.2       ~ 29 0
44 SN 2007au SN* 07 11 46.11 +49 51 13.4     17.0     SNIa 43 1
45 Z 119-103 LIN 08 27 05.9618029776 +21 38 43.030642200   15.0       ~ 60 0
46 SN 2005mc SN* 08 27 06.36 +21 38 45.6     17     SNIa 58 1
47 SN 2004gs SN* 08 38 23.179 +17 37 39.79     17.1     SNIa 77 1
48 Z 89-58 LIN 08 38 23.8480757184 +17 37 52.791340476   14.9       ~ 46 0
49 SN 2008ia SN* 08 50 35.15 -61 16 40.6           SNIa 52 1
50 ESO 125-6 Sy2 08 50 35.8297703976 -61 16 40.350291420   15.30   13.47   ~ 32 0
51 SN 2008hv SN* 09 07 34.06 +03 23 32.1           SNIa-norm 96 1
52 NGC 2765 GiG 09 07 36.6392523384 +03 23 34.469642868   13.30       ~ 95 0
53 SN 1993ag SN* 10 03 35.00 -35 27 47.6   18.30 17.78     SNIa 71 1
54 2MASX J10033546-3527410 G 10 03 35.4396402456 -35 27 41.044198860   17.05   15.69   ~ 15 1
55 SN 2001ie SN* 10 16 50.70 +60 16 44.5     16.5     SNIa 27 1
56 Z 290-25 LIN 10 16 53.0504157072 +60 17 05.543812428   14.9       ~ 37 0
57 NGC 3392 Sy1 10 51 03.0013512384 +65 46 53.585661468   16.83 16.11     ~ 51 0
58 SN 2010Y SN* 10 51 03.90 +65 46 47.0           SNIa-norm 41 1
59 Z 127-15 GiG 11 38 29.4636799752 +20 31 39.704385756   14.9       ~ 41 0
60 SN 2006bd SN* 11 38 29.59 +20 31 38.2     18.2     SNIap 40 1
61 SN 2007ci SN* 11 45 45.85 +19 46 13.9     17.5     SNIa 61 1
62 NGC 3873 GiP 11 45 46.1153243784 +19 46 25.563061236   14.2       ~ 89 0
63 NGC 4070 LIN 12 04 11.2984701048 +20 24 35.375326776   14.3       ~ 89 0
64 SN 2005bl SN* 12 04 12.24 +20 24 24.6           SNIap 109 1
65 NGC 4493 G 12 31 08.3696052552 +00 36 49.347407340   14.851   13.405   ~ 74 0
66 SN 1994M SN* 12 31 08.61 +00 36 19.6   16.31 16.24     SNIa 102 1
67 SN 2006cs SN* 13 45 33.89 +35 36 36.6     17.8     SNIa 29 1
68 Z 190-50 GiG 13 45 34.969 +35 36 40.19   15.0       ~ 31 0
69 SN 2005al SN* 13 50 00.329 -30 34 34.21           SNIa 50 1
70 NGC 5304 EmG 13 50 01.5032553624 -30 34 42.256367472   13.59 13.56 12.02 12.55 ~ 76 0
71 NGC 5490 GiG 14 09 57.330 +17 32 43.53   13.4 15.5     ~ 178 1
72 SN 1997cn SN* 14 09 57.76 +17 32 32.3   17.2 16.7     SNIapec 91 1
73 IRAS 14542+0931 G 14 56 43.2213720470 +09 19 36.381424399           ~ 17 1
74 SN 2005ag SN* 14 56 43.649 +09 19 42.49           SNIa 52 1
75 Z 105-88 rG 14 59 27.6351444840 +16 38 42.329730372   14.5       ~ 47 0
76 SN 2008af SN* 14 59 28.50 +16 39 12.3     17.1     SNIa 48 1
77 SN 2007ap SN* 15 56 23.035 +16 30 57.92     15.5     SNIa 41 1
78 Z 108-12 GiC 15 56 23.5926793272 +16 31 24.188876328   14.7       ~ 39 0
79 SN 1998bp SN* 17 54 50.74 +18 19 50.5   15.73       SNIa 77 1
80 NGC 6495 GiG 17 54 50.7755269728 +18 19 36.669498852   13.8       ~ 60 0
81 NGC 6685 GiG 18 39 58.6266324336 +39 58 54.482715624   14.7       ~ 29 0
82 SN 2006bq SN* 18 39 58.68 +39 58 50.8     15.8     SNIa 48 1
83 MCG+07-41-001 GiG 19 56 12.8563708176 +40 26 02.379371280   16       ~ 30 0
84 SN 2002do SN* 19 56 12.88 +40 26 10.8     16.3     SNIa 34 1
85 SN 1990af SN* 21 34 58.12 -62 44 07.4   17.91 17.75     SNIa 84 1
86 LEDA 340526 G 21 34 59.3411484504 -62 44 14.405919684   16.58   15.39   ~ 16 1
87 SN 2007hj SN* 23 01 47.89 +15 35 11.4     15.9     SNIa 59 1
88 NGC 7461 AG? 23 01 48.3342056808 +15 34 57.265786776   14.5       ~ 49 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2024MNRAS.529.3806K and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu