2025A&A...693A.286S


Query : 2025A&A...693A.286S

2025A&A...693A.286S - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 693A286 (2025/1-1)

Intermediate mass T Tauri disk masses and a comparison to their Herbig disk descendants.

STAPPER L.M., HOGERHEIJDE M.R., VAN DISHOECK E.F., VIOQUE M., WILLIAMS J.P. and GINSKI C.

Abstract (from CDS):

Context. Herbig disks are prime sites for the formation of massive exoplanets and looking into the precursors of these disks can offer clues for determining planet formation timescales. The precursors of Herbig stars, called intermediate-mass T Tauri (IMTT) stars, have spectral types later than F, but stellar masses between 1.5 and 5 M⊙. These stars will eventually become Herbig stars of spectral types A and B.
Aims. The aim of this work is to obtain the dust and gas masses and radii of all IMTT disks with ALMA archival data. The obtained disk masses are then compared to Herbig disks and T Tauri disks and the obtained disks sizes to those of Herbig disks.
Methods. ALMA Band 6 and 7 archival data were obtained for 34 IMTT disks with continuum observations, 32 of which have at least 12CO, 13CO, or C18O observations, but with most of them at quite shallow integrations. The disk integrated flux together with a stellar luminosity-scaled disk temperature were used to obtain a total disk dust mass by assuming optically thin emission. Using thermochemical Dust And LInes (DALI) models drawn from previous works, we also obtained gas masses of 10 out of 35 of the IMTT disks based on the CO isotopologues. From the disk masses and sizes, we obtained the cumulative distributions.
Results. The IMTT disks in this study have the same dust mass and radius distributions as Herbig disks. The dust mass of the IMTT disks is higher compared to that of the T Tauri disks, as also found for the Herbig disks. No differences in dust mass were found for group I versus group II disks, in contrast to Herbig disks. The disks for which a gas mass could be determined display a similarly high-mass as to the Herbig disks. Comparing the disk dust and gas mass distributions to the mass distribution of exoplanets shows that there also is not enough dust mass in disks around intermediate-mass stars to form massive exoplanets. On the other hand, there is more than enough gas to form the atmospheres of exoplanets.
Conclusions. We conclude that the sampled IMTT disk population is almost indistinguishable compared to Herbig disks, as their disk masses are the same, even though the former objects are younger. Based on this study, we conclude that planet formation is already well underway in these objects and, thus, planet formation is expected to start early on in the lifetime of Herbig disks. Combined with our findings on group I and group II disks, we conclude that most disks around intermediate-mass pre-main sequence stars converge quickly to small disks, unless they are prevented from doing so by a nearby massive exoplanet.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): surveys - protoplanetary disks - stars: early-type - stars: pre-main sequence - stars: variables: T Tauri, Herbig Ae/Be - submillimeter: planetary systems

Simbad objects: 49

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 49
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 EM* LkHA 330 TT* 03 45 48.2805122064 +32 24 11.850978276   12.30 10.97     F7 160 0
2 V* XY Per Ae* 03 49 36.3365862552 +38 58 55.548299928 12.12 10.14 9.58 9.54 8.40 A2II+B6 158 0
3 V* RY Tau TT* 04 21 57.4092550080 +28 26 35.555316612 10.82 10.34 9.30 9.67 8.87 K1IV/Ve 744 1
4 V* UX Tau Or* 04 30 03.99626 +18 13 49.4355 11.23 11.84 10.80 9.83 9.05 K2Ve+M1Ve 380 0
5 V* HQ Tau Or* 04 35 47.3357318616 +22 50 21.686966484 15.01 14.15 12.02 11.18   K0 129 0
6 * 51 Eri PM* 04 37 36.1326090888 -02 28 24.775726260   5.486 5.209     F0IV 285 0
7 V* SU Aur Or* 04 55 59.3866872552 +30 34 01.499608092   10.33 9.30 9.17   G2IIIne 628 0
8 HD 31648 Ae* 04 58 46.2655706952 +29 50 36.987625680 7.84 7.78 7.62 7.76 7.43 A5Vep 612 0
9 HD 34700 Or* 05 19 41.4089390784 +05 38 42.778590864 9.75 9.778 9.659 9.205 8.47 G0IVe 125 0
10 V* CO Ori Or* 05 27 38.3386648 +11 25 38.974625 12.96 12.33 10.30 10.33 9.63 F7Ve 180 0
11 HD 35929 Ae* 05 27 42.7906489200 -08 19 38.446702140   8.55 8.11     F2IV/V 125 0
12 V* GW Ori TT* 05 29 08.3928710640 +11 52 12.666457092   10.83 10.10 9.52   G5/8Ve 382 0
13 V* RY Ori Or* 05 32 09.9419233368 -02 49 46.770599784 12.62 12.76 10.80 10.82 10.34 F7 78 0
14 BD-05 1299 Or* 05 34 14.1619196472 -05 36 54.187822224 11.081 10.697 10.219   9.425 F8 84 0
15 V* SW Ori Or* 05 34 15.7488580272 -06 36 04.674208860   15.21 13.10 13.37   G5/K0e 86 0
16 Brun 656 Or* 05 35 21.3152972328 -05 12 12.609578520 13.057 12.043 11.225   9.538 G2III 69 0
17 V* PR Ori Or* 05 36 24.9926892648 -06 17 32.551271232   12.59 11.40 10.89   K1.0 57 0
18 HD 294260 Or* 05 36 51.270 -04 25 39.97           G1IV 47 0
19 V* BE Ori Or* 05 37 00.1082085840 -06 33 27.323739324   15.80 14.24 12.45   G3.0 68 0
20 HBC 502 TT* 05 46 07.8799942272 -00 11 56.887013256     14.5     K3 56 0
21 EM* LkHA 310 TT* 05 47 10.9810095480 +00 19 14.765040480   18.0 15.6     G6 28 0
22 * bet Pic PM* 05 47 17.0876901 -51 03 59.441135 4.13 4.03 3.86 3.74 3.58 A6V 2087 1
23 HD 288313A Or* 05 54 02.9845319872 +01 40 21.939047703   11.72 10.65     ~ 9 0
24 HD 288313 Or* 05 54 02.9907527336 +01 40 21.814523504   10.98 9.95 9.72 9.55 K2V 35 1
25 CD-38 4381 TT* 08 23 11.8586968392 -39 07 01.621267032   10.380 9.929     F3Ve 26 1
26 Hen 3-545 Or* 10 59 06.9715593000 -77 01 40.309233240   12.91 11.136   9.596 K4Ve 237 0
27 Ass Cha T 2-21 TT* 11 06 15.3471261840 -77 21 56.720362608   12.58 11.01   9.35 G5Ve 144 0
28 V* DI Cha Or* 11 07 20.7276076008 -77 38 07.308086352   12.02 10.74 10.72   G2Ve 190 0
29 V* CV Cha Or* 11 12 27.7055693328 -76 44 22.302807396   12.02 10.98 10.51 9.76 G9Ve 216 1
30 Ass Cha T 2-54 TT* 11 12 42.6709132056 -77 22 22.943489160     11.103   9.653 G8+K7 102 2
31 HD 100546 Be* 11 33 25.4408872296 -70 11 41.241297948   6.71 6.30   6.64 A0VaekB8_lB 894 1
32 HD 135344B Or* 15 15 48.4460065200 -37 09 16.024369824   9.21 8.708     F8V 548 0
33 CD-33 10685 Or* 15 45 12.8678037432 -34 17 30.644403036 12.47 11.56 10.224 9.60 8.685 K3Ve 306 1
34 HD 142526 * 15 56 17.0237664360 -33 27 24.085867176   10.60 10.10     F0V 7 0
35 HD 142666 TT* 15 56 40.0221861696 -22 01 40.005872148 9.41 9.37 8.82 8.31 8.01 F0V_sh 306 0
36 HD 142527 Ae* 15 56 41.8882637904 -42 19 23.248281828   9.04 8.34     F6III 741 1
37 NAME Lupus Complex SFR 16 03 -38.1           ~ 851 0
38 HD 144432 Ae* 16 06 57.9533126832 -27 43 09.760564056 8.47 8.53 8.19 7.82 7.53 A9IVe 266 0
39 NAME Upper Sco Association As* 16 12 -23.4           ~ 1586 1
40 Haro 1-6 Or* 16 26 03.0276684144 -24 23 36.188140848   14.15 14.01 12.38 10.80 K0 229 2
41 EM* SR 21A TT* 16 27 10.2778380120 -24 19 12.622467720   16.08 14.10     G1 293 1
42 V* AK Sco Ae* 16 54 44.8491575376 -36 53 18.566586456 9.80 9.63 9.00     F5V 304 1
43 HD 163296 Ae* 17 56 21.2881851168 -21 57 21.871819008 7.00 6.93 6.85 6.86 6.67 A3VaekA1mA1 1301 0
44 [M81] I-671 TT* 18 27 26.0721349320 -04 34 47.457169032   12.40 11.43     G5III 16 0
45 HD 200775 Ae* 21 01 36.9205762896 +68 09 47.789578836 7.34 7.754 7.427 8.13   B2Ve 582 0
46 V* BH Cep Ae* 22 01 42.8723960712 +69 44 36.426918696 12.18 11.54 11.01 10.62 10.32 F5IIIe 71 0
47 V* BO Cep Ae* 22 16 54.0583196880 +70 03 44.988517332 11.86 11.98 11.55 11.16 10.84 F5Ve 79 0
48 V* SV Cep Ae* 22 21 33.2166238512 +73 40 27.097678812 11.40 11.25 10.35 10.28 10.08 A2IVe 141 0
49 HD 218396 El* 23 07 28.7157209544 +21 08 03.310767492   6.21 5.953     F0+VkA5mA5 1285 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...693A.286S and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu