2025A&A...695A..27M


Query : 2025A&A...695A..27M

2025A&A...695A..27M - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 695A27 (2025/3-1)

Intermediate-mass stars and the origin of the gas-giant planet-metallicity correlation.

MALDONADO J., MIROUH G.M., MENDIGUTIA I., MONTESINOS B., GRAGERA-MAS J.L. and VILLAVER E.

Abstract (from CDS):

Context. Currently, the number of known planets around intermediate-mass stars (1.5 M⊙ < M⋆ < 3.5 M⊙) is rather low. As a consequence, models of planet formation derive their strongest observational evidence from the chemical signature of mostly low-mass (FGK) main-sequence (MS) stars with planets.
Aims. We aim to test whether the well-known correlation between the metallicity of the star and the presence of gas-giant planets found for MS low-mass stars still holds for intermediate-mass stars. In particular, we aim to understand whether or not the planet-metallicity relation changes as stars evolve from the pre-MS to the red giant branch.
Methods. We compiled the basic stellar parameters (metallicity, mass, and age) of a sample of intermediate-mass stars at different evolutionary phases with and without evidence suggesting that they host gas-giant planets. The metallicities of the different susbsamples were compared and set in the context of current models of planet formation and stellar evolution.
Results. Our results confirm that pre-MS stars with transitional discs with gaps show lower metallicities than pre-MS ones with flat discs. We show a tendency of intermediate-mass stars in the MS to follow the gas-giant planet-metallicity correlation, although the differences in metal content between planet and non-planet hosts are rather modest and the strength of the correlation is significantly lower than for the less massive FGK MS stars. For stars in the red giant branch, we find a strong planet-metallicity correlation, compatible with that found for FGK MS stars. We discuss how the evolution of the mass in the convective zone of the star's interior might affect the measured metallicity of the star. In particular, if the planet-metallicity correlation were of a primordial origin, one would expect it to be stronger for less massive stars, as they are longer convective during the stellar evolution. However, within our sample, we find the opposite.
Conclusions. The lack of a well-established planet-metallicity correlation in pre-MS and MS intermediate-mass stars can be explained by a scenario in which planet formation leads to an accretion of metal-poor material on the surface of the star. As intermediate-mass stars are mainly radiative, the metallicity of the star does not reflect its bulk composition but the composition of the accreted material. When the star leaves the MS and develops a sizeable convective envelope, a strong-planet metallicity correlation is recovered. Thus, our results are in line with core-accretion models of planet formation and the idea that the planet-metallicity correlation reflects a bulk property of the star.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): techniques: spectroscopic - planets and satellites: formation - stars: abundances - stars: early-type

VizieR on-line data: <Available at CDS (J/A+A/695/A27): tablea1.dat tablea2.dat tablea3.dat>

Simbad objects: 132

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 132
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 HD 360 HB* 00 08 17.5324307736 -08 49 26.801843988   7.014 5.980     K1II 57 0
2 * 87 Peg PM* 00 09 02.4247431528 +18 12 43.074790956   6.607 5.555     G9III 70 0
3 HD 645 RG* 00 10 42.8341071816 -12 34 47.633650356   6.861 5.849     K0III 68 0
4 * eta Cet HB* 01 08 35.3913324413 -10 10 56.151936084 5.80 4.61 3.45 2.61 2.03 K2-IIIb 239 0
5 * 49 And * 01 30 06.1015103472 +47 00 26.181123984   6.261 5.261     K0III 87 0
6 * eta Psc ** 01 31 29.0081880156 +15 20 44.994632991 5.320 4.600 3.620 2.90 2.40 G7IIIa 255 0
7 * 49 Cet PM* 01 34 37.7786780856 -15 40 34.898673000   5.667 5.607   5.54 A1V 348 0
8 * ups Per PM* 01 37 59.5580239328 +48 37 41.563066970 6.29 4.85 3.57 2.61 1.96 K3-IIICN0.5 244 0
9 * chi And SB* 01 39 20.9885732088 +44 23 10.229915472   5.886 5.008     G8III 91 0
10 * eta02 Hyi PM* 01 54 56.1314447592 -67 38 50.291415024   5.623 4.685     G8IIIb 129 1
11 * 3 Per * 01 58 33.5059620456 +49 12 15.670560312   6.706 5.702     K0IV 63 0
12 HD 15082 EB* 02 26 51.0582618096 +37 33 01.736482032   8.41 8.14     kA5hA8mF4 229 1
13 * 75 Cet HB* 02 32 09.4224095904 -01 02 05.616571164   6.366 5.358 10.0   K1III 95 1
14 * 81 Cet PM* 02 37 41.8020809760 -03 23 46.225928328   6.674 5.647     K0III 97 1
15 * tau Per SB* 02 54 15.4777208304 +52 45 44.882735292 5.17 4.71 3.96 3.33 2.89 G8III+A7V 175 0
16 HD 23281 * 03 43 33.8338762320 -10 29 08.365157736 5.88 5.80 5.61 5.40 5.30 A5III-IV 95 0
17 * 37 Tau PM* 04 04 41.7128811713 +22 04 54.946823724 6.41 5.44 4.37 3.58 3.05 K0III-IIIb 194 0
18 * eps Tau ** 04 28 37.0002551195 +19 10 49.563140930 5.42 4.54 3.53     G9.5IIICN0.5 628 1
19 V* AB Aur Ae* 04 55 45.8458932216 +30 33 04.292077032 7.20 7.16 7.05 6.96 6.70 A0Ve 1176 2
20 HD 287325 * 04 58 12.5627969184 +09 59 52.804564656   9.62 9.47     A2 21 0
21 HD 31648 Ae* 04 58 46.2655706952 +29 50 36.987625680 7.84 7.78 7.62 7.76 7.43 A5Vep 612 0
22 V* UX Ori Ae* 05 04 29.9878898040 -03 47 14.286732072 10.25 10.93 8.70 9.62 9.43 A4IVe 379 1
23 HD 290380 Or* 05 23 31.0101754824 -01 04 23.701574136   10.97 10.41 10.25 9.79 keF6IVeb 53 0
24 HD 287823 Or* 05 24 08.0485208544 +02 27 46.884084984   9.91 9.74     A0 64 0
25 HD 287841 Y*O 05 24 42.8032369656 +01 43 48.249234516 10.55 10.45 10.17 9.99 9.80 A8V 123 0
26 V* CO Ori Or* 05 27 38.3386648 +11 25 38.974625 12.96 12.33 10.30 10.33 9.63 F7Ve 180 0
27 HD 290500 Or* 05 29 48.0515601936 -00 23 43.508069160   11.35 11.04     A2 44 0
28 HD 244314 Or* 05 30 19.0247390376 +11 20 20.002720452   10.33 10.18     A1V 39 0
29 HD 244604 Or* 05 31 57.2511172320 +11 17 41.368840404   9.61 9.43     A0Vesh 92 0
30 V* RY Ori Or* 05 32 09.9419233368 -02 49 46.770599784 12.62 12.76 10.80 10.82 10.34 F7 78 0
31 HD 245185 Ae* 05 35 09.6034684104 +10 01 51.465413208 10.05 10.07 9.93     A0Vae 145 0
32 V* NV Ori Ae* 05 35 31.3686116448 -05 33 08.872027056 10.36 10.21 8.70 9.48 9.22 F6IIIe 117 0
33 HD 37258 Ae* 05 36 59.2496063912 -06 09 16.331028249   9.72 9.61 9.56   A3V_sh 153 0
34 HD 290770 Or* 05 37 02.4474064872 -01 37 21.363674700   9.29 9.30     B9 55 0
35 V* BF Ori Ae* 05 37 13.2623828280 -06 35 00.568242528 10.37 10.00 9.69 10.06 9.31 A7III 311 0
36 HD 37357 Ae* 05 37 47.0794735560 -06 42 30.209473224   8.96 8.85     A3VankA1 120 0
37 V* V1247 Ori dS* 05 38 05.2519466880 -01 15 21.698856468   10.18 9.82     F0V 136 0
38 V* V599 Ori Or* 05 38 58.6396084320 -07 16 45.626538792   15.39 13.70 12.61   A8.9 71 0
39 V* V350 Ori Or* 05 40 11.7638894112 -09 42 11.086012692 12.74 12.08 11.42 11.38 10.96 A7V 88 0
40 * del Dor * 05 44 46.3699967519 -65 44 07.793159129 4.69 4.57 4.36 4.10 3.93 A7V 138 0
41 * bet Pic PM* 05 47 17.0876901 -51 03 59.441135 4.13 4.03 3.86 3.74 3.58 A6V 2087 1
42 2MASS J06065848-0555066 TT* 06 06 58.4991960744 -05 55 06.700428156   12.97 12.44     A0 24 0
43 EM* LkHA 339 Ae* 06 10 57.8449670232 -06 14 39.659250840   14.44 13.60 13.44 12.50 A1e 44 0
44 V* V435 Car dS* 06 21 50.0593461744 -51 14 15.751606740   6.95 6.73     A5V 44 0
45 HD 47366 PM* 06 37 40.7934964800 -12 59 06.422813988   7.096 6.106     K1(III) 73 0
46 NGC 2264 84 TT* 06 40 42.1820308368 +09 33 37.422060732 12.575 12.57 12.01 11.74 11.33 G0 87 0
47 HD 50445 PM* 06 51 42.4207334784 -36 13 48.979898580   6.120 5.940     A3V 41 0
48 * lam Gem PM* 07 18 05.5789195368 +16 32 25.389581244   3.674 3.559     A4IV 269 0
49 BD+07 1721 Pe* 07 26 02.2901761080 +07 36 56.815027668   10.21 9.86     A8V+G9V/K1V 35 0
50 HD 59686 PM* 07 31 48.4045109592 +17 05 09.764723724   6.574 5.442     K2III 130 1
51 * bet Gem PM* 07 45 18.94987 +28 01 34.3160 3.00 2.14 1.14 0.39 -0.11 K0IIIb 1150 2
52 HD 68695 Or* 08 11 44.5714665288 -44 05 08.777141772   9.93 9.87     A3VbekA0mA0_lB 55 0
53 BD+14 1881 Pe* 08 22 28.2046820904 +13 44 07.143774288   9.53 9.23   8.948 kA1hA5mA9Si 43 0
54 HD 73764 * 08 40 13.3364351808 +06 33 56.284684776   7.50 6.59     K0 26 0
55 1SWASP J084201.35+034238.0 Pe* 08 42 01.3562355288 +03 42 38.021676300   10.05 9.77     A7V(Sr) 27 0
56 IRAS F08432-5945 Or* 08 44 23.6523525384 -59 56 57.876645408   10.96 10.91     A5V 20 0
57 IRAS 08469-4037 Or* 08 48 45.6634197192 -40 48 21.082180356   12.63 12.34     A0 19 0
58 HD 85628 * 09 50 19.2009107592 -66 06 49.897904652   8.40 8.19     A3V 32 0
59 * q Vel PM* 10 14 44.1556880397 -42 07 18.988830783 3.98 3.90 3.85 3.83 3.81 A2Va 146 0
60 HD 95086 * 10 57 03.0215719872 -68 40 02.449216128   7.60 7.36     A8III 208 1
61 HD 97048 Ae* 11 08 03.3109731720 -77 39 17.490777444 9.03 8.76 9.00   8.64 A0Vep 590 0
62 HD 100453 Ae* 11 33 05.5766482920 -54 19 28.547100696   8.09 7.79     F1Vn 335 1
63 HD 101615 PM* 11 41 19.7910777168 -43 05 44.397442968   5.57 5.53     A0V 62 0
64 HD 102956 * 11 51 22.5108967056 +57 38 26.642076396   8.825 7.851 8.21   K0III 71 1
65 * 3 Crv PM* 12 11 03.8390016096 -23 36 08.715836340   5.52 5.47     A1V 65 0
66 HD 106314 PM* 12 13 55.7727012600 +02 15 36.789208488   7.82 6.91     G8/K0IV 38 0
67 * 7 Com * 12 16 20.5383338546 +23 56 43.466192439   5.81 4.86     G8III-IIIb 137 0
68 HD 106760 SB* 12 16 30.1337441112 +33 03 41.428822680   6.08 4.94     K0.5III-IIIb 130 0
69 * chi Vir ** 12 39 14.7669620640 -07 59 44.033845848   5.886 4.643 6.45   K2+IIICN0.5 167 1
70 CD-34 8618 * 13 04 10.5339280776 -35 32 58.322148612   10.93 10.52     ~ 31 0
71 HD 115820 * 13 20 26.8121687568 -49 13 25.207170420   8.19 7.95     A7/8V 46 0
72 * 15 Boo PM* 14 14 50.8487473560 +10 06 02.196736560   6.37 5.32 6.59   K1III 115 0
73 HD 125490 PM* 14 19 53.1993312624 -06 44 46.174154496   7.36 6.44     K0III 26 0
74 * m Hya ** 14 46 00.07998 -25 26 35.4355           F0VSr+G1V 76 0
75 HD 133112 PM* 15 02 44.8678907928 -03 01 52.986571896   6.788 6.618     A4/5IV/V 86 0
76 HD 132947 Or* 15 04 56.0564413224 -63 07 52.644571500   9.00 8.94     B9V 46 0
77 HD 135344B Or* 15 15 48.4460065200 -37 09 16.024369824   9.21 8.708     F8V 548 0
78 * 11 UMi * 15 17 05.8894632720 +71 49 26.047336872   6.384 5.015     K4III 138 1
79 HD 139357 * 15 35 16.1985929736 +53 55 19.709392008   7.160 5.964     K4III: 78 1
80 HD 139614 Or* 15 40 46.3820275416 -42 29 53.538761832   8.47 8.24     A9VekA5mA5(_lB) 243 0
81 HD 141569 Or* 15 49 57.7482550392 -03 55 16.341617064 7.22 7.20 7.12 7.00 7.04 A2VekB9mB9(_lB) 578 0
82 HD 142666 TT* 15 56 40.0221861696 -22 01 40.005872148 9.41 9.37 8.82 8.31 8.01 F0V_sh 306 0
83 HD 142527 Ae* 15 56 41.8882637904 -42 19 23.248281828   9.04 8.34     F6III 741 1
84 HD 144432 Ae* 16 06 57.9533126832 -27 43 09.760564056 8.47 8.53 8.19 7.82 7.53 A9IVe 266 0
85 HD 145718 Ae* 16 13 11.5918435992 -22 29 06.621987516   9.29 8.86     A5Ve 130 0
86 * d Sco PM* 16 18 17.8991603537 -28 36 50.471996469   4.804 4.782     A1Va 172 0
87 * bet Her SB* 16 30 13.2003216885 +21 29 22.598684027 4.39 3.70 2.77 2.13 1.65 G7IIIaFe-0.5 331 0
88 HD 149914 Or* 16 38 28.6527873384 -18 13 13.713126384   6.967 6.746     B9.5IV 82 0
89 HD 150193 Ae* 16 40 17.9243127240 -23 53 45.193372692 9.69 9.32 8.79 8.41   A3Va(e) 336 0
90 HD 153053 PM* 17 00 06.2792932296 -54 35 49.837300800   5.816 5.633     A5IV/V 47 0
91 * pi. Ara PM* 17 38 05.5153908936 -54 30 01.562028048   5.431 5.242     A5IV/V 104 0
92 HD 163296 Ae* 17 56 21.2881851168 -21 57 21.871819008 7.00 6.93 6.85 6.86 6.67 A3VaekA1mA1 1301 0
93 * 71 Oph * 18 07 18.3593981592 +08 44 01.922061912   5.592 4.640     G8III 182 0
94 HD 166229 PM* 18 08 02.2385481072 +36 24 04.556318652   6.65   4.8   K2III 89 0
95 HD 167042 PM* 18 10 31.6398993768 +54 17 11.592196980   6.89   5.4   K1III 174 1
96 * kap Lyr V* 18 19 51.7091048595 +36 03 52.370938421 6.70 5.51 4.34 3.48 2.93 K2-IIIabCN0.5 150 0
97 * 74 Oph * 18 20 52.0636719528 +03 22 37.790695740   5.764 4.856     G8III 117 0
98 HD 169142 Ae* 18 24 29.7799891464 -29 46 49.327400568   8.42 8.16     F1VekA3mA3_lB? 535 0
99 * alf Lyr dS* 18 36 56.33635 +38 47 01.2802 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.07 0.10 A0V 2787 1
100 HD 173416 PM* 18 43 36.1092769368 +36 33 23.782819428   7.093 6.037     G8 57 1
101 HD 179218 Ae* 19 11 11.2538919456 +15 47 15.636008472 7.55 7.476 7.39 7.25 7.21 A0Ve 273 0
102 HD 181342 RG* 19 21 04.2304823448 -23 37 10.450151292   8.566 7.55   8.62 K0III 65 1
103 V* PX Vul Or* 19 26 40.2532914312 +23 53 50.782579116 12.56 12.57 11.83 10.90 10.30 F3Ve 64 0
104 HD 183492 RG* 19 29 22.1540342928 +14 35 45.669109020   6.618 5.564     K0III 68 0
105 HD 184010 * 19 31 21.6214301712 +26 37 01.817079708   6.811 5.893     K0III-IV 64 0
106 HD 185603 * 19 38 38.7352230144 +31 13 09.217127532   7.67 7.58     A0 80 0
107 * eps Pav PM* 20 00 35.5515303087 -72 54 37.812955563   3.927 3.940     A0Va 142 0
108 * eta Sge PM* 20 05 09.4929426624 +19 59 27.862887444   6.139 5.093     K2III 101 0
109 HD 192787 PM* 20 15 23.7687076080 +33 43 44.709183120   6.632 5.698     G8III 55 0
110 * 18 Sge * 20 16 19.7881699488 +21 35 55.328401464   7.169 6.110     K1III 53 0
111 HD 194013 * 20 23 10.6933936608 +05 20 34.733986584   6.279 5.301     G8III-IV 99 0
112 HD 195689 SB* 20 31 26.3534153736 +39 56 19.773037500   7.59 7.56     A0 151 0
113 * 1 Aqr SB* 20 39 24.8927058552 +00 29 11.155000416   6.204 5.153     K0III 99 0
114 * gam02 Del PM* 20 46 39.4998239664 +16 07 27.458234724   5.26 4.25 4.1   K1IV 192 0
115 * 31 Vul SB* 20 52 07.6902075264 +27 05 48.999114816   5.399 4.568     G7IIIFe-1 154 0
116 HD 199870 SB* 20 58 19.4663810952 +44 28 18.140900268   6.528 5.547     K0III:Fe-0.5 109 0
117 * 18 Del PM* 20 58 25.9335294984 +10 50 21.430869504   6.432 5.506     G6III 107 1
118 V* DV Aqr SB* 20 58 41.8398627000 -14 28 59.250192924   6.192 5.963   6.010 A9V 96 0
119 HD 200964 PM* 21 06 39.8422794792 +03 48 11.226709188   7.379 6.487     G8IV 101 1
120 HD 201585 * 21 10 12.3723073896 +10 44 19.949472816   8.51 8.27     A8 53 0
121 * 34 Vul PM* 21 21 04.3938814104 +23 51 21.486740544   6.62   4.9   K0III 131 0
122 * g Cyg PM* 21 29 26.9497663992 +46 32 26.107970964   6.188 5.217     K0-III 112 0
123 HD 206610 * 21 43 24.9001051368 -07 24 29.710256004   9.38 8.35   8.76 K0III 51 1
124 HD 208897 PM* 21 58 59.6916479016 +19 01 13.091250972 8.420 7.520 6.510     K0 49 0
125 HD 210702 * 22 11 51.3309460896 +16 02 25.997965476   6.896 5.930     K0III 111 1
126 * 11 Lac PM* 22 40 30.8584750462 +44 16 34.706857320 7.15 5.79 4.46 3.54 2.86 K2.5III 148 0
127 * eta Peg SB* 22 43 00.1288449480 +30 13 16.372969392 4.38 3.81 2.95 2.31 1.83 G8II+F0V 208 0
128 * 13 Lac * 22 44 05.4787170600 +41 49 09.245333172 6.82 6.04 5.08     G8III 101 0
129 * alf PsA PM* 22 57 39.04625 -29 37 20.0533 1.31 1.25 1.16 1.11 1.09 A4V 1303 3
130 * tet Psc PM* 23 27 58.0946643849 +06 22 44.372303191 6.41 5.38 4.30 3.50 2.97 K0.5III 185 0
131 * 70 Peg SB* 23 29 09.2992398120 +12 45 37.979571348 6.24 5.50 4.56 3.82 3.37 G8IIIa 159 0
132 * 20 Psc PM* 23 47 56.5419212784 -02 45 41.752306188   6.433 5.490     K0III 99 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...695A..27M and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu