2025A&A...695A.131R


Query : 2025A&A...695A.131R

2025A&A...695A.131R - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 695A131 (2025/3-1)

Testing the mass-radius relation of white dwarfs in common proper-motion pairs I. Hydrogen-dominated atmospheres.

RADDI R., REBASSA-MANSERGAS A., TORRES S., CAMISASSA M.E., NAPIWOTZKI R., KOESTER D., TREMBLAY P.-E., HEBER U. and ALTHAUS L.

Abstract (from CDS):

Context. White dwarf masses are among the most important properties used to constrain their past and future evolution. Direct estimates of white dwarf masses are crucial for assessing the validity of theoretical evolutionary models and methods of analysis.
Aims. The main goal of this work was to measure the masses and radii of white dwarfs that belong to widely separated, common proper-motion binaries with non-degenerate companions. These can be assessed, independently from theoretical mass-radius relations, through measurements of gravitational redshifts and photometric radii.
Methods. We studied 50 white dwarfs with hydrogen-dominated atmospheres, performing a detailed analysis of high-resolution (R ≈ 18 500) spectra via state-of-the-art grids of synthetic models and specialized software. We measured accurate radial velocities from the Hα and Hβ line cores to obtain the white dwarf gravitational redshifts. Jointly with a photometric analysis, formalized by a Bayesian inference method, we measured precise radii for the white dwarfs in our sample, which allowed us to directly measure the white dwarf masses from their gravitational redshifts.
Results. The distributions of measured masses and radii agree within 6% (at the 1-σ level) from the theoretical mass-radius relation, thus delivering a much smaller scatter in comparison with previous analyses that used gravitational redshift measurements from low-resolution spectra. Our comparison against model-dependent spectroscopic estimates produces a larger scatter of 15% on the mass determinations. We find an agreement within ≈10% from previous model-based, photometric mass estimates from the literature.
Conclusions. Combining gravitational redshift measurements and photometric analysis of white dwarfs delivers precise and accurate empirical estimates of their masses and radii. This work confirms the reliability of the theoretical mass-radius relation from the lightest to the heaviest white dwarfs in our sample (≈0.38-1.3 M⊙).

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): techniques: radial velocities - binaries: visual - white dwarfs

Simbad objects: 160

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 160
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 LAWD 1 WD* 00 02 40.0947866937 -34 13 39.592411637   15.36 14.94     DC 75 0
2 Gaia DR3 2772926200211837056 PM* 00 03 32.9838668412 +17 13 37.176331256           ~ 3 0
3 GALEX J000333.8+171336 WD* 00 03 33.8665046328 +17 13 36.277657068           DA 8 0
4 Gaia DR3 4906307172772653056 * 00 30 23.0319219076 -58 56 52.157421129           ~ 2 0
5 GALEX J003026.6-585638 WD* 00 30 26.8393811256 -58 56 38.612282712           D 9 0
6 GD 623 WD* 00 35 25.2988927992 -17 30 40.938867576   16.8 15.7 16.3   DA2.9 22 0
7 UCAC4 363-000789 PM* 00 35 25.7256500538 -17 30 36.134507082   16.328 16.000     ~ 3 0
8 Gaia DR3 4907169670925418752 WD* 00 42 43.7482014360 -58 20 36.418591392           DA 11 0
9 UCAC3 64-1590 PM* 00 42 44.1430296408 -58 20 45.716227512   14.15 12.74 12.31 10.96 ~ 9 0
10 GD 683 WD* 01 08 20.7692886528 -35 34 41.697626232   14.53 14.72 15.8   DA1.6 58 0
11 Gaia DR3 5014008975278023040 PM* 01 08 21.5911982802 -35 36 32.305529017           ~ 4 0
12 2MASS J01155570+1534483 Em* 01 15 55.7178244862 +15 34 48.367604101           K4 5 0
13 Gaia DR3 2591573203298626432 WD* 01 15 56.1476165616 +15 34 50.098834452           DA 7 0
14 Gaia DR3 4637598659932556928 WD* 01 25 32.3863254552 -76 19 50.090098512           DA 8 0
15 CD-76 53 * 01 25 32.8498201704 -76 19 59.737651176   10.981 10.473     G0 10 0
16 TYC 35-972-1 PM* 01 41 44.7518296248 +07 11 52.081564236   12.64 11.12     ~ 4 0
17 GALEX J014147.1+071131 WD* 01 41 47.1954310728 +07 11 31.378133148           DB 16 0
18 HS 0145+1737 WD* 01 48 21.5792705760 +17 52 13.681691544       15.95   DA 18 0
19 Gaia DR3 91690164426524288 PM* 01 48 22.0155340300 +17 52 20.776687986           ~ 4 0
20 2MASS J01565713-4722451 WD* 01 56 57.1371306264 -47 22 45.068873952   16.7       DA 11 0
21 UCAC2 11456803 * 01 57 08.6605066440 -47 24 54.894791412   12.95 11.90 11.53 10.62 ~ 6 0
22 2MASS J02064751-3807034 PM* 02 06 47.5084511568 -38 07 03.395841420           ~ 5 0
23 HE 0204-3821 WD* 02 06 47.7505392024 -38 07 03.899605512           DA 18 0
24 LP 885-22 WD* 02 07 02.2964165568 -30 23 32.577786420     16.18     DA 26 0
25 LP 885-23 PM* 02 07 06.3478114272 -30 24 23.170008744   15.74 14.13 13.81 11.47 M0 20 0
26 GALEX J020731.9+035504 WD* 02 07 31.9431446064 +03 55 03.842465052           DA 8 0
27 Gaia DR3 2517771234063151360 * 02 07 35.1133585733 +03 54 41.682684767           ~ 2 0
28 GALEX J020933.3-014004 WD* 02 09 33.4257283704 -01 40 04.335038328           DA 12 0
29 BD-02 372 PM* 02 09 34.7202395640 -01 40 11.032033404   10.80 9.94     K0 10 0
30 HD 14784 PM* 02 23 34.2002081520 +22 27 28.800678348   8.79   7.9   G0 17 0
31 EGGR 18 WD* 02 23 36.0793120872 +22 27 29.051674848   15.90 15.83 15.46   DA3.1 49 0
32 2MASS J02305302-4755303 PM* 02 30 53.0399798064 -47 55 30.265109724         14.958 ~ 4 0
33 LB 1628 WD* 02 30 53.3106368280 -47 55 26.103805932   14.25 14.52 14.0   DA.8 47 0
34 TYC 9158-463-1 PM* 03 19 29.0678282136 -72 54 05.203515420   11.76 10.81     ~ 7 0
35 GALEX J031929.5-725412 WD* 03 19 29.6114486088 -72 54 14.380627248           DA 10 0
36 UCAC2 11459336 PM* 03 32 01.9982731152 -47 26 01.508991900   14.14 12.78 12.38 11.08 ~ 9 0
37 HE 0330-4736 WD* 03 32 03.9347318976 -47 25 56.533648584   16.2   15.8   DA 18 0
38 UCAC4 192-004042 PM* 04 11 09.7474982339 -51 46 45.684844094   16.046 15.908     ~ 3 0
39 HE 0409-5154 WD* 04 11 10.3228636440 -51 46 51.045394296 15.03 15.99 16.04 17.2   DA 20 0
40 Cl Melotte 25 OpC 04 30 27.4 +16 46 43           ~ 3309 0
41 HD 29635 PM* 04 39 53.0075730072 -04 06 07.986902724   9.74 8.97     G6V 9 0
42 SDSS J043955.27-040552.1 WD* 04 39 55.2740992632 -04 05 52.074395052           DA 13 0
43 2MASS J05190426-1801275 * 05 19 04.2698749104 -18 01 27.536541204         15.145 ~ 4 0
44 HE 0516-1804 WD* 05 19 04.2822546456 -18 01 29.841403260           DA 14 0
45 Gaia DR3 3315373564607614208 WD* 06 08 18.7496411904 +02 04 56.983802124           D 10 0
46 PM J06083+0205 Em* 06 08 19.5363295056 +02 05 06.315502092     12.328 11.827   M0 9 0
47 UPM J0608-5301A PM* 06 08 41.7664555488 -53 01 23.483742096   14.3   12.2 10.9 ~ 9 0
48 LEHPM 2-2008 WD* 06 08 43.8018447720 -53 01 34.273941816     15.99 15.92 15.78 DA5.5 15 0
49 SDSS J060851.45-005950.3 WD* 06 08 51.4492252440 -00 59 50.241654348           DA 12 0
50 2MASS J06085209-0059076 * 06 08 52.0939243819 -00 59 07.780520253           ~ 2 0
51 WG 8 WD* 06 16 14.2567729529 -59 12 27.405103079   14.00 14.09     DB3+ 68 0
52 HD 44120 PM* 06 16 18.7856158311 -59 12 48.609682671   7.02 6.43     F9.5V 120 0
53 Gaia DR3 5499525444356625408 WD* 06 21 00.4216761936 -54 56 01.445201844           DA 11 0
54 HD 44878 PM* 06 21 01.9290733224 -54 56 04.645963104   9.01 8.40     G0V 28 0
55 G 106-51B WD* 06 30 38.5997399928 -02 05 50.485413624     15.32 15.43   DA7.3 40 0
56 G 106-51 PM* 06 30 38.8042685496 -02 05 53.936865204   15.62 14.69   12.41 M3/4: 18 0
57 LAWD 23 WD* 06 47 37.9897150309 +37 30 57.066665144   11.97 12.07 12.26   DA2.3 182 0
58 Gaia DR3 3126316040609035008 WD* 06 53 27.9341816832 +02 39 43.770357468           DA 11 0
59 2MASS J06533591+0238309 PM* 06 53 35.9155590976 +02 38 31.005261212           ~ 4 0
60 HD 56280 * 07 15 32.8938123312 -23 42 26.417430684   8.90 8.35     G0V 8 0
61 Gaia DR3 5617978855684923136 WD* 07 15 34.7361512952 -23 42 25.671035448           DA 8 0
62 * alf CMi B WD* 07 39 17.8800 +05 13 26.800   10.7 10.92     DQZ 174 0
63 Gaia DR3 3043761413359412992 * 07 46 40.6795272039 -06 42 59.777662583           ~ 3 0
64 Gaia DR3 3043761409059739776 WD* 07 46 42.0288098496 -06 42 54.686924964           DA 8 0
65 BD+00 2186 PM* 08 06 22.4929372392 -00 06 47.960416044   10.83 9.92     ~ 17 0
66 Gaia DR3 3083590225639363712 WD* 08 06 22.5711501816 -00 06 54.576768708           DA 6 0
67 HD 67556 PM* 08 07 08.7557407704 -36 22 53.082522624   7.83 7.30     F8V 43 0
68 Gaia DR3 5544588928434374016 WD* 08 07 10.4591020632 -36 22 51.687996420           DA 11 0
69 TYC 803-374-1 * 08 18 05.1980501400 +12 12 56.892081168   10.92 10.52     ~ 4 0
70 GALEX J081806.8+121155 WD* 08 18 06.8889707256 +12 11 55.427741628           DA 17 0
71 NGC 2632 OpC 08 39 58.4 +19 36 33           ~ 1733 0
72 LAWD 29 WD* 08 47 29.4298183296 -18 59 49.751256732 14.607 15.564 15.682 15.782 15.901 DB3 64 0
73 NLTT 20261 PM* 08 47 31.2411072096 -18 59 33.541549044   12.60 11.23 11.25 10.411 K4V 17 1
74 HS 0949+0935 WD* 09 51 48.8922918216 +09 21 12.650524920   16.7   17.2   DA 15 0
75 2MASS J09515008+0921417 PM* 09 51 50.0880755276 +09 21 41.869527970           ~ 3 0
76 TYC 251-632-1 * 10 11 52.5865010136 +05 36 39.980907432   12.06 11.09     ~ 5 0
77 GALEX J101153.8+053639 WD* 10 11 53.7755667456 +05 36 39.320009424           DA 7 0
78 2MASS J10172624-2153305 * 10 17 26.2485093081 -21 53 30.561557821           ~ 3 0
79 EC 10150-2138 WD* 10 17 26.6429256600 -21 53 42.762321456   15.46 15.66 16.062   DA1.6 20 0
80 HD 90211B WD* 10 24 48.8474585736 -00 23 12.319810260           DAZ: 19 0
81 HD 90211 * 10 24 51.1400267880 -00 24 06.665667948   8.55 8.06     A0/1 36 0
82 GALEX J102918.2-374829 WD* 10 29 18.3664414992 -37 48 29.975732244           DA 11 0
83 UCAC4 261-052939 PM* 10 29 18.6152904504 -37 48 37.570110804   13.994 12.648 12.252   ~ 9 0
84 Gaia DR3 5390094110062904704 WD* 10 54 38.9014740384 -41 23 38.806758348           DA 8 0
85 UCAC4 244-048118 * 10 54 39.4705257114 -41 23 32.603777797   15.068 13.760 13.320   ~ 5 0
86 EGGR 76 WD* 11 07 59.9504280373 -05 09 26.034289695 12.397 13.093 13.057 13.141 13.215 DA3 172 0
87 L 970-27 PM* 11 08 06.5391855920 -05 13 47.135439598 15.253 14.058 12.559 11.479 10.125 M3V 65 0
88 TYC 9411-1581-1 PM* 11 26 24.1652713560 -76 31 11.056191348   12.69 11.49     ~ 3 0
89 GALEX J112625.3-763108 WD* 11 26 25.5856039944 -76 31 08.315741244           DA 8 0
90 2MASS J11291106-2233513 PM* 11 29 11.0409659033 -22 33 51.472127200         14.879 ~ 4 0
91 EC 11266-2217 WD* 11 29 11.5200550656 -22 33 43.809938136   16.541 16.352 16.1 16.313 DA4.1 27 0
92 GD 140 WD* 11 37 05.1041466528 +29 47 58.288741080 11.47 12.42 12.45 12.73 12.714 DA2.2 257 0
93 CD-31 9159 * 11 39 59.5445092368 -31 42 21.351933324   10.927 10.19     K0 8 0
94 GALEX J114000.4-314226 WD* 11 40 00.4893008424 -31 42 25.845560496           DA 5 0
95 G 121-21 PM* 11 50 17.5887658493 +25 18 21.454504713   16.96   14.3   M2Ve 20 0
96 LAWD 38 WD* 11 50 20.1723452944 +25 18 32.765299925   15.78   15.4   DA5 66 0
97 TIC 461203226 WD* 12 06 50.8944985728 -38 05 49.227395856           DA 14 0
98 HD 105227 PM* 12 06 54.6992200944 -38 06 23.218871976   10.14 9.32     G8/K0V 30 0
99 Gaia DR3 3597718564252561408 * 12 07 44.2897103638 -04 11 51.707586381           ~ 3 0
100 GALEX J120745.1-041203 WD* 12 07 45.1971639576 -04 12 04.224942432           DA 9 0
101 HD 109409 PM* 12 34 42.3935608056 -44 40 22.867472928   6.44 5.76     G3IV 89 0
102 UCAC4 227-063983 WD* 12 34 45.3675135072 -44 40 01.751102580       16.28   DC 14 0
103 G 59-39 PM* 12 47 13.4303536179 +14 42 14.040866558   14.95   12.3   M0 19 0
104 EGGR 92 WD* 12 47 14.7133704150 +14 42 30.875986658   16.08   15.9   DA4.6 66 0
105 GD 267 WD* 12 59 50.3511623976 +04 31 26.415222672   14.96 15.05     DA2.2 50 0
106 GD 267B PM* 12 59 50.8507825726 +04 31 31.838688295           ~ 4 0
107 Gaia DR3 6112283308883211264 WD* 13 44 25.6328526576 -41 54 21.448290204           DB 8 0
108 UCAC4 241-065221 * 13 44 25.7072029244 -41 54 11.915492081   15.056 13.619 13.246   ~ 5 0
109 SDSS J135024.27+052252.3 WD* 13 50 24.2751594240 +05 22 52.362421536   16.6   17.2   DA 10 0
110 LAMOST J135030.12+051931.2 Em* 13 50 30.1290637738 +05 19 31.289871996           G9 4 0
111 LAWD 53 WD* 13 51 22.6873041720 -27 33 57.820912668   15.05 15.00 15.37 15.13 DA5.0 44 0
112 L 619-49 PM* 13 51 23.2289986344 -27 33 52.440716808   13.30 12.531 12.077 10.12 M3V 23 0
113 Gaia DR3 5892401599200616064 WD* 14 26 57.3676327656 -57 16 38.828963676           DA 11 0
114 HD 126375 PM* 14 27 00.2815920456 -57 17 18.725956764   8.35 7.86     F6V 32 0
115 UCAC4 286-075268 PM* 14 34 28.1975214986 -32 56 27.432470542   15.010 13.731 13.337   ~ 5 0
116 GALEX J143428.4-325621 WD* 14 34 28.4307831144 -32 56 22.543474128           DA 8 0
117 LAWD 57 WD* 15 23 16.5213076087 -34 12 07.397871157   15.62 15.43   15.13 DC 16 0
118 GALEX J152420.9-231833 WD* 15 24 20.8544524560 -23 18 32.862980448           DA 8 0
119 UCAC2 22485328 PM* 15 24 21.3131850648 -23 18 34.347057732   12.44 11.66 11.55 10.95 ~ 8 0
120 HD 140901 PM* 15 47 29.1010163043 -37 54 58.722921986   6.73 6.01     G7IV 223 0
121 HD 140901B WD* 15 47 30.0209908033 -37 55 08.460010675   13.10 12.80 13.53 12.34 DA4.8 108 0
122 TYC 1499-1002-1 * 15 59 19.2217405752 +19 04 20.144078184   12.67 11.87     ~ 3 0
123 KUV 15571+1913 WD* 15 59 21.0799205424 +19 04 08.303421468   15.5 15.4     DB 28 0
124 Gaia DR3 4398887092042907904 WD* 16 01 39.7632603696 -03 45 40.012345548           D 13 0
125 HD 143615 PM* 16 01 41.1830350896 -03 45 48.369540636   7.25 6.86     F3V 32 0
126 PG 1619+123 WD* 16 22 03.8614974768 +12 13 33.547640376   14.95   15.0   DA2.9 42 0
127 HD 147528 PM* 16 22 07.0666901160 +12 12 52.408636596   8.72 8.19     G0 38 0
128 CD-38 10980 WD* 16 23 33.8380498896 -39 13 46.161043572 9.916 10.885 11.029 10.936 10.841 DA2 526 0
129 HD 147513 PM* 16 24 01.2911377368 -39 11 34.729913940 6.17 6.02 5.376     G5V 389 1
130 TYC 9443-3498-1 * 16 40 03.5280942072 -75 24 20.748429504   12.78 11.92     ~ 2 0
131 LSPM J1743+1434N PM* 17 43 22.5046221053 +14 34 59.693728151   14.9   13.460   dM3.5 11 0
132 LSPM J1743+1434S WD* 17 43 22.9811021813 +14 34 52.254097752   14.9   14.2   DC 17 0
133 2MASS J18051187-0818184 PM* 18 05 11.8765914041 -08 18 18.539661569           ~ 4 0
134 Gaia DR3 4170899954423211776 WD* 18 05 51.4087589736 -08 13 03.193001904           D 12 0
135 TYC 8372-1717-1 PM* 18 40 58.5724741512 -50 55 28.591193784   12.19 11.29     ~ 3 0
136 GALEX J184106.1-505613 WD* 18 41 06.1723518936 -50 56 13.046259408           DA 8 0
137 G 142-B2B WD* 19 13 38.6751658464 +13 36 27.362642868 13.52     14.47   DA3.6 59 0
138 G 142-B2A PM* 19 13 39.2394553080 +13 36 11.613419496       12.391   M2V 20 0
139 LAWD 75 WD* 19 35 41.9402542560 -13 30 07.020286092   16.00 15.95 16.1   DA2.9 36 0
140 L 852-36 PM* 19 35 42.9472700616 -13 29 42.364469472   15.05 13.63 13.24   M1V 7 0
141 MCT 2020-4234 WD* 20 23 59.5069330104 -42 24 25.846993944 13.73 14.70 14.89     DA1.6 59 0
142 2MASS J20244543-4223354 * 20 24 45.4288057920 -42 23 35.606050339         15.717 ~ 2 0
143 TYC 6929-1394-1 PM* 20 41 12.1683459384 -26 28 04.850449968   11.96 10.98     ~ 9 0
144 GALEX J204112.5-262811 WD* 20 41 12.6630827016 -26 28 12.304333308           D 12 0
145 LP 984-110 PM* 22 27 20.7356932944 -34 11 22.308573480   13.89 12.78 12.63 10.92 M2V 12 0
146 LAWD 92 WD* 22 27 20.9516950200 -34 11 14.067803616   14.5   14.81 14.50 DB3 43 0
147 UCAC4 525-147219 WD* 22 34 18.8327546232 +14 56 54.415320252           DA 17 0
148 UCAC4 525-147220 PM* 22 34 19.8765664872 +14 57 57.937512420       12.62   ~ 8 0
149 BD-10 5983 PM* 22 45 25.4166822576 -10 02 36.445481988   11.23 10.30     ~ 11 0
150 PB 7181 WD* 22 45 29.4832546584 -10 02 44.293743096   17.5       DA 25 0
151 PG 2244+031 WD* 22 47 22.2458635560 +03 21 46.927863072   16.1   16.2   DA.8 20 0
152 PG 2244+031B * 22 47 22.3947587880 +03 21 48.211038720           ~ 2 0
153 LP 581-35 WD* 22 55 55.7113298194 +05 45 22.592241568   16.0   16.06   DA8.1 50 0
154 G 28-24 PM* 22 55 56.8193753640 +05 45 18.346071785 13.796 12.661 11.212 10.267 9.216 M1V 58 0
155 HD 218572 PM* 23 10 20.5693703412 -68 50 20.026272139   9.80 8.78     K3+Vk: 66 0
156 HD 218572B WD* 23 10 22.8543738235 -68 50 23.958448995           DB 16 0
157 LP 522-34 WD* 23 20 31.3017695952 +12 58 14.589261228   15.9   16.1   DA3.6 35 0
158 LP 522-35 PM* 23 20 33.1677298176 +12 58 37.125827148   17.2   15.7   ~ 11 0
159 PG 2353+027 WD* 23 56 27.6927573888 +02 57 05.600554632   15.83 15.830 16.1   DA.8 30 0
160 2MASS J23565049+0256321 PM* 23 56 50.4948569367 +02 56 32.185558341           ~ 2 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...695A.131R and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu