2025A&A...695A.253D


Query : 2025A&A...695A.253D

2025A&A...695A.253D - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 695A253 (2025/3-1)

No robust statistical evidence for a population of water worlds in a 2025 sample of planets orbiting M stars.

DAINESE S. and ALBRECHT S.H.

Abstract (from CDS):

The study of exoplanets has led to many surprises, one of which is the discovery of planets larger than Earth yet smaller than Neptune, super Earths, and gas dwarfs. No such planet is a member of the Solar System, yet they appear to be abundant in the local neighbourhood. Their internal structure is not well understood. Super Earths presumably are rocky planets with a thin secondary atmosphere, whereas gas dwarfs have a substantial (by volume) primary H/He atmosphere. However, conflicting evidence exists regarding the presence of a third class of planets, so-called water worlds, which are hypothesised to contain a significant mass fraction of water in condensed or steam form. This study examines the evidence for water worlds and presents a sample of 60 precisely measured small exoplanets (less than 4 Earth radii) orbiting M dwarf stars. We combined observational data and unsupervised machine-learning techniques to classify these planets based on their mass, radius, and density. We individually modelled the interior of each planet using the ExoMDN code and classify them into populations based on these models. Our findings indicate that the sample divides into two distinct planet populations, with no clear evidence supporting the existence of water worlds in the current dataset.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): planets and satellites: composition - planets and satellites: fundamental parameters - planets and satellites: interiors - planets and satellites: terrestrial planets

Simbad objects: 60

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 60
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 TOI-1470b Pl 00 40 21.2900714938 +61 12 49.056302600           ~ 7 0
2 NAME G 267-158b Pl 00 42 16.9405469664 -36 43 05.414977812           ~ 12 0
3 NAME G 268-38c Pl 00 44 59.3309137511 -15 16 17.542839990           ~ 95 0
4 NAME G 268-38b Pl 00 44 59.3309137511 -15 16 17.542839990           ~ 237 0
5 NAME LSPM J0106+1913c Pl 01 06 36.9754315896 +19 13 33.163383396           ~ 16 0
6 LSPM J0106+1913b Pl 01 06 36.9754315896 +19 13 33.163383396           ~ 21 0
7 GJ 3090 b Pl 01 21 45.3901703856 -46 42 51.764974020           ~ 24 0
8 NAME PM J01276+7217b Pl 01 27 40.9728637224 +72 17 47.186355408           ~ 15 0
9 NAME PM J02489-1432Wb Pl 02 48 59.2728446101 -14 32 14.942011299           ~ 22 0
10 NAME G 245-61b Pl 02 57 18.2595506687 +76 33 11.253543067           ~ 41 0
11 BD-17 588 ** 03 01 51.3895517 -16 35 36.110284           M3.5+M3.0 73 0
12 NAME LP 994-91b Pl 03 17 02.9761531523 -42 14 32.537542994           ~ 9 0
13 NAME PM J03455+3706b Pl 03 45 33.6408895592 +37 06 43.999247912           ~ 34 0
14 K2-25b Pl 04 13 05.6131374072 +15 14 52.018080576           ~ 108 0
15 NAME L 231-32d Pl 04 33 39.7200127728 -51 57 22.435373160           ~ 128 0
16 NAME L 231-32c Pl 04 33 39.7200127728 -51 57 22.435373160           ~ 45 0
17 NAME L 231-32b Pl 04 33 39.7200127728 -51 57 22.435373160           ~ 49 0
18 NAME PM J04343+4302b Pl 04 34 22.4953034088 +43 02 14.692100424           ~ 45 0
19 TOI-269b Pl 05 03 23.0610114456 -54 10 37.924879404           ~ 25 0
20 HD 260655c Pl? 06 37 10.7988015297 +17 33 53.333221083           ~ 21 0
21 HD 260655b Pl 06 37 10.7988015297 +17 33 53.333221083           ~ 23 0
22 NAME G 50-16b Pl 08 02 22.8829177661 +03 20 19.691170937           ~ 30 0
23 NAME L 98-59 d Pl 08 18 07.6214406393 -68 18 46.805365587           ~ 98 0
24 NAME L 98-59 c Pl 08 18 07.6214406393 -68 18 46.805365587           ~ 86 0
25 K2-146b Pl 08 40 06.4242250368 +19 05 34.430759088           ~ 29 0
26 K2-146c Pl 08 40 06.4242250368 +19 05 34.430759088           ~ 22 0
27 NAME G 9-40b Pl 08 58 52.3297250887 +21 04 34.200161052           ~ 15 0
28 NAME L 678-39b Pl 09 36 01.6372169407 -21 39 38.877606712           ~ 86 0
29 CD-45 5378b Pl 09 44 29.8367689785 -45 46 35.427639685           ~ 86 0
30 TOI-5747.01 Pl? 09 53 30.9082873440 +35 34 16.718737548           ~ 7 0
31 LSPM J1008+6916b Pl 10 08 51.8069885952 +69 16 35.560317504           ~ 44 0
32 NAME L 320-124b Pl 10 14 51.7786855411 -47 09 24.192778106           ~ 223 0
33 G 162-44 PM* 10 18 35.1372361341 -11 43 00.243355403   14.68 13.14 12.84   M4.0 98 0
34 NAME L 248-27b Pl 10 26 59.4940030876 -52 28 09.944352049           ~ 26 0
35 NAME WT 1825b Pl 10 40 15.9529520592 -08 30 38.608979508           ~ 3 0
36 LP 791-18 PM* 11 02 45.9546199392 -16 24 22.288196376           M6V 50 0
37 K2-3b Pl 11 29 20.3917077216 -01 27 17.281697868           ~ 57 0
38 K2-18b Pl 11 30 14.5177445592 +07 35 18.255348492           ~ 303 0
39 NAME LP 961-53b Pl 11 54 18.3921193416 -37 33 09.837719244           ~ 47 0
40 HD 106100b Pl 12 12 28.5093521712 -49 00 27.504441432           ~ 4 0
41 Wolf 437b Pl 12 47 56.6245693190 +09 45 05.035666747           ~ 95 0
42 NAME PM J13119+6550b Pl 13 11 59.5600372848 +65 50 01.703045580           ~ 16 0
43 NAME G 139-21b Pl 17 15 18.9339850845 +04 57 50.066612336           ~ 845 1
44 G 182-34b Pl 18 01 16.1002287008 +35 35 50.495366783           ~ 6 0
45 LSPM J1907+5905b Pl 19 07 24.8342713584 +59 05 09.358958868           ~ 5 0
46 Kepler-138c Pl 19 21 31.5679755816 +43 17 34.680970608           ~ 80 0
47 Kepler-54c Pl 19 39 05.7418156224 +43 03 22.599784476           ~ 37 1
48 Kepler-54b Pl 19 39 05.7418156224 +43 03 22.599784476           ~ 42 1
49 NAME L 210-70b Pl 20 27 42.0813992356 -56 27 25.151894071           ~ 68 0
50 TOI-1075b Pl 20 39 53.3385084312 -65 26 57.987806640           ~ 17 0
51 BD+44 3567b Pl 20 45 04.0992448490 +44 29 56.645139366           ~ 17 0
52 NAME G 189-1b Pl 22 06 00.6662280633 +39 18 02.897475330           ~ 8 0
53 TRAPPIST-1b Pl 23 06 29.3684948589 -05 02 29.037301866           ~ 380 0
54 TRAPPIST-1c Pl 23 06 29.3684948589 -05 02 29.037301866           ~ 282 0
55 TRAPPIST-1e Pl 23 06 29.3684948589 -05 02 29.037301866           ~ 384 0
56 TRAPPIST-1g Pl 23 06 29.3684948589 -05 02 29.037301866           ~ 237 0
57 TRAPPIST-1h Pl 23 06 29.3684948589 -05 02 29.037301866           ~ 162 0
58 TRAPPIST-1d Pl 23 06 29.3684948589 -05 02 29.037301866           ~ 263 0
59 TRAPPIST-1f Pl 23 06 29.3684948589 -05 02 29.037301866           ~ 281 0
60 CD-60 8051 PM* 23 20 07.5245143451 -60 03 54.644648069   12.45 11.02 10.584   M2V 69 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...695A.253D and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu