2025A&A...699A.134T


Query : 2025A&A...699A.134T

2025A&A...699A.134T - Astronomy and Astrophysics, volume 699A134 (2025/7-1)

MINDS: Water reservoirs of compact planet-forming dust discs A diversity of H2O distributions.

TEMMINK M., SELLEK A.D., GASMAN D., VAN DISHOECK E.F., VLASBLOM M., PRANGER A., GUDEL M., HENNING T., LAGAGE P.-O., CARATTI O GARATTI A., KAMP I., OLOFSSON G., ARABHAVI A.M., GRANT S.L., KAEUFER T., KURTOVIC N.T., PEROTTI G., SAMLAND M., SCHWARZ K. and TABONE B.

Abstract (from CDS):

Context. Millimetre-compact dust discs are thought to have efficient radial drift of icy dust pebbles. It has been hypothesised that this drift could produce an enhanced cold (T < 400 K) H2O reservoir in their inner discs. Mid-infrared spectral surveys, now including the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), pave the way to explore this hypothesis. In this work, we test this theory for eight compact discs (Rdust < 60 au) with JWST-MIRI/MRS observations.
Aims. To explore the H2O distribution in the inner discs and consider whether these discs are enhanced in cold H2O emission, we analyse the different reservoirs that can be probed with the pure rotational lines (>10 µm) by JWST: hot (T > 800 K), intermediate (400 < T < 800 K), and cold (T < 400 K).
Methods. We probed the H2O reservoirs with JWST-MIRI observations for a sample of eight compact discs through parametric column density profiles (power laws, jump abundances, and parabolas), multiple-component (two or three) slab models, and line flux ratios.
Results. We find that not all compact discs show strong enhancements of the cold H2O reservoir; instead, we propose three different classes of inner disc H2O distributions. Four of our discs (BP Tau, CY Tau, DR Tau, and RNO 90; i.e. type N or 'normal' discs) appear to have similar H2O distributions to many of the large and structured discs, as indicated by the slab model fitting and the line flux ratios. These discs have a small cold reservoir, suggesting the inward drift of dust, but it is not as efficient as hypothesised before. Only two discs (FT Tau and XX Cha; type E or cold H2O enhanced discs) do show a strong enhancement of the cold H2O emission, in agreement with the original hypothesis. The two remaining discs (CX Tau and DN Tau; type P or H2O-poor discs) are found to be very H2O-poor, yet they show emission from either the hot or immediate reservoirs (depending on the fit) in addition to emission from the cold one. For the three types, we find that different parametrisation schemes are able to provide a good description of the observed H2O spectra. Overall, a jump abundance at a free temperature is amongst the preferred profiles for all three types, suggesting that this profile can provide a good description of the observed reservoirs for most discs. The multiple-component analysis yields similar results to those of the parametric models. However, in some cases, a power law can give an entirely different distribution compared to the other parametric models. Finally, we also report the detection of other molecules in these discs, including a tentative detection of CH4 in CY Tau.
Conclusions. Not all compact discs follow the hypothesis that their cold H2O reservoir is enhanced following efficient radial drift. Therefore, we introduced a classification based on the observed H2O reservoirs, which should hold for all (isolated) discs: type N, type E, and type P. Type N discs are considered to behave as many other (large and structured) discs, with all three reservoirs present; yet the cold emission is not enhanced. The type E discs show strong enhancements of the cold H2O emission, while the type P discs are generally H2O-poor.

Abstract Copyright: © The Authors 2025

Journal keyword(s): astrochemistry - protoplanetary disks - stars: variables: T Tauri, Herbig Ae/Be - infrared: general

Status at CDS : Large table(s) will be appraised for possible ingestion in VizieR.

Simbad objects: 27

goto Full paper

goto View the references in ADS

Number of rows : 27
N Identifier Otype ICRS (J2000)
RA
ICRS (J2000)
DEC
Mag U Mag B Mag V Mag R Mag I Sp type #ref
1850 - 2026
#notes
1 V* CX Tau Or* 04 14 47.8615248984 +26 48 11.014877916 16.48 15.93 14.50     M1.5Ve 217 0
2 V* CY Tau Or* 04 17 33.7284990744 +28 20 46.812121656 14.52 14.68 13.40 12.59   M1.5 297 0
3 V* BP Tau Or* 04 19 15.8339827632 +29 06 26.926959492   13.13 12.12 11.89   K5/7Ve 721 0
4 V* FT Tau Or* 04 23 39.1888788312 +24 56 14.250818940   16.15 14.93 14.70   M2.8 169 0
5 V* IQ Tau Or* 04 29 51.5569574040 +26 06 44.859710736 15.43   13.80 12.28 11.11 M0.5 281 0
6 V* FZ Tau Or* 04 32 31.7627107344 +24 20 03.056011548 16.15     15.04   M0 176 0
7 V* GK Tau Or* 04 33 34.5630097872 +24 21 05.855136732 15.50   13.00 12.02 10.62 K7:Ve 338 0
8 V* DL Tau Or* 04 33 39.0767679288 +25 20 38.101382952 14.04 14.59 13.40 11.85 10.89 K7Ve 372 0
9 V* CI Tau Or* 04 33 52.0143963264 +22 50 30.094090908 14.97 15.09 13.80     K4IVe 422 1
10 V* DN Tau Or* 04 35 27.3776226144 +24 14 58.910343720 13.56 12.88 11.50 11.79   M1:Ve 448 0
11 NAME Taurus Complex SFR 04 41.0 +25 52           ~ 4971 0
12 Haro 6-33 TT* 04 41 38.8257958224 +25 56 26.741499648     18.40     M0.5 140 2
13 V* DR Tau Or* 04 47 06.2151561264 +16 58 42.813872580 12.03 11.86 10.50 12.19   K5Ve 585 0
14 V* GQ Tau EB* 05 41 34.9488618120 +25 59 52.989632088   11.84 11.39     B9 23 0
15 V* SY Cha Or* 10 56 30.3883129248 -77 11 39.401977596         11.29 K5Ve 194 0
16 V* XX Cha Or* 11 11 39.6728641032 -76 20 15.032221548   16.67 15.28   12.56 M3Ve 137 1
17 V* GW Lup Or* 15 46 44.7290527536 -34 30 35.677420056   13.8       M1.5e 201 0
18 V* GQ Lup Or* 15 49 12.1053805848 -35 39 05.058139788 12.19 12.76 11.66 11.15   K7Ve 334 1
19 V* RY Lup Or* 15 59 28.3864710696 -40 21 51.249496176   12.62 9.90     G8/K1IV-V 251 0
20 V* MY Lup TT* 16 00 44.5202267160 -41 55 30.935126748   12.64 12.17 11.06   K0 144 0
21 HD 325367 Or* 16 03 05.4915085848 -40 18 25.426727676   11.40 8.50     M0 406 0
22 V* V1279 Sco Or* 16 08 22.4935277520 -39 04 46.427612052   14.99 13.66 11.70 11.21 M0.4 154 1
23 V* V1094 Sco TT* 16 08 36.1772010696 -39 23 02.464980972 16.01 15.00 13.48 12.47 11.45 ~ 101 1
24 DoAr 33 TT* 16 27 39.0123517344 -23 58 18.709495500   15.7   13.24 12.02 K4 100 0
25 NAME Ophiuchus Molecular Cloud SFR 16 28 06 -24 32.5           ~ 3969 1
26 V* V1003 Oph TT* 16 34 09.1696133088 -15 48 16.776092124     13.44     G5 105 0
27 EM* AS 209 TT* 16 49 15.3034917000 -14 22 08.643317664   12.62 11.28     K4Ve 494 0

To bookmark this query, right click on this link: simbad:objects in 2025A&A...699A.134T and select 'bookmark this link' or equivalent in the popup menu